SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  21
Private equity value investing in public markets
Introduction



     Avenir Capital specialises in fundamental, value –based and special-situation investments in global
      equity and debt markets

     We search for materially mispriced securities which we can buy well below intrinsic value (that is,
      with a large margin of safety) and that offer the potential for superior returns with limited risk of
      permanent loss of capital

     Our investment program applies key elements of private equity investing to public markets with 3
      underlying pillars:
           Focus on the downside first – fixate on avoiding permanent loss of capital
           Fundamental, bottom up approach to investment selection
           Focus on absolute long term returns not relative short term returns

     Avenir has an attractive fee structure aligning the interests of investors and the fund manager and
      providing some protection for investors in periods of lower returns

     Avenir is managed by an experienced and successful investor and manager of third party money




1
The Model

    Avenir Capital applies the best elements of private equity and public market investing to identify and invest in
    significantly mispriced assets

                      Private Equity                                        Public Market
                                                                  Greater opportunity set
             Focus on low risk investing
                                                                 Deep discounts to intrinsic value
                Longer term investment horizon
                     Focus on fundamentals                       Focus on investment analysis not
                                                                   ‘deal process’
                          In depth due diligence                 Lower transaction costs
                               Conviction investing
                                                                      Liquidity
                                   Concentrated portfolio


                                               Current Market Sentiment
                                             Active investment selection

                                             Transparency

                                             Lower leverage

                                             Liquidity




2
                                              Avenir Capital
3 Underlying Pillars




         Think About               Focus on Absolute                 Bottom Up not
        Downside First                 Returns                         Top Down


    •   Focus on minimising        •   Longer term absolute      •   Fundamental analysis
        risk of permanent loss         return focus not short
        of capital                     term relative returns     •   Company specific
                                                                     investment decisions
    •   What is probability of     •   Avoid closet indexing
        loss; how much can                                       •   Don’t try to guess
                                   •   Avoid asset gathering         short term market
        we lose?
                                       behaviour                     direction
    •   Don’t view volatility as
                                   •   Patient investing to      •   Look for materially
        risk
                                       benefit from ‘time            mispriced assets
    •   Worry more about               arbitrage’
        what we can lose than
                                   •   Not afraid to invest in
        what we might make
                                       ‘unloved’ companies
    •   Margin of safety –
        Always!



3
Consistent with Private Equity Heritage

    Much of the investment approach and risk management of Avenir Capital is consistent with the Principal’s private
    equity investing heritage


                        • Concentrated portfolio investing in only the best opportunities
        Investment      • Intense focus on downside risk minimisation
        Framework/
            Risk        • Simple businesses: Avoid single product, technology or resource risk
        Management      • Medium/long term investment horizon
                        • Patience, patience, patience



                        • Extensive investigative due diligence and financial analysis experience
                        • Deep experience in assessing competitive position, industry structure and
                          management team
       Due Diligence    • Operational experience in assessing strategy viability, timeframes and
                          operational capability
                        • Extensive experience in assessing capital structure, financial viability and bank
                          pressure points

                                  Key Elements Added
                                        Margin of Safety
                                        Low Risk, High Uncertainty Investing
                                        Event Driven/Special Situation Opportunities
4
Principal’s Background

    The Principal is an experienced professional investor and manager of third party money



                                • 17 years in third party investment management
                                • Managing Director/part owner of $1B Australian PE firm
          Investment
                                • Managing Director of leading pan-Asian PE firm
         Management
                                • US and Australian investment management
                                • Large cap and small/mid cap public market investments


                                • Extensive operational and board level experience
                                • First hand insight into management and company capability
       Business Insight         • Extensive debt and capital market experience
                                • Deep and varied due diligence and financial analysis




                                • Excellent and consistent investment track record
         Track Record
                                • 3.7x money return on investments




5
Principal: Private Equity Returns

                                                                                                          Return Measurement(2)

                  Transaction                            Investment(1)       Exit Value                  IRR              Money Multiple
    ($m)
    Waters                                                     40                 309                   225%                      7.7x

    Pacific Brands                                            236              1,216                    129%                      5.2x

    Tech Pacific                                              138                 506                   122%                      3.7x

    Mettler Toledo                                            224                 805                     91%                     3.6x

    Vertex                                                     15                  51                   100%                      3.4x

    Affinity Health                                           247                 782                   124%                      3.2x

    Frucor                                                     50                 155                     57%                     3.1x

    Manchester Tank                                            28                  86                     55%                     3.1x

    Valley Longwall                                            88                    8                     n/a                    0.1x
    Total                                                   1,066              3,918                       n/a                    3.7x

    NOTE: Mr Warner does not claim to have been responsible for any portion of the above track record or whether this would be representative of
          Mr Warner’s investment performance. The results above are the work of teams of professionals and no single individual was responsible
          for any investment.
    (1)     Includes co-investments
6   (2)     Before expenses, fees and carried interest
Performance: Avenir Value Fund


    Avenir Value Fund Performance (Net of Fees and Expenses)
                                   110.0
                                                                                             104.5 104.6
                                   105.0                                             102.1                                                          102.4
        Index = 100 at Inception



                                                                101.2 101.1                                101.1
                                           100.0 101.0
                                                                                                                   97.5                      98.5
                                   100.0                                      96.5
                                                         96.0
                                                                                                                           93.7
                                    95.0                                                                                            92.5

                                    90.0

                                    85.0

                                    80.0




                                                                  All Ords Accumulation           Avenir Value Fund


    Monthly Performance (Net of Fees/Expenses since Inception 1 August 2011)*
      Year       Jan     Feb     Mar     Apr      May      Jun     Jul      Aug                     Sep      Oct     Nov      Dec           YTD     All Ords^
      2012        5.8%    2.4%    0.1% -3.3% -3.6% -3.9% -1.3%               6.5%                    4.0%                                  6.1%      11.3%
      2011                                                                   1.0%                   -5.0%     5.4%    -0.1%   -4.5%        -3.5%      -7.9%
    * Results are unaudited.
    ^ All Ordinaries Accumulation Index


7
Investment Framework

         “The market is normally efficient but it is not always efficient.
      The difference between those two propositions is like night and day”
                                                      Warren Buffett


                                Margin of
                                Safety –
                                Always!



      Simple                                                   Special
    Businesses                                               Situations
                       The Search for
                       Mispriced assets



           Low Risk, High                   Focus on our Best
            Uncertainty                           Ideas

8
Investment Framework


    Margin of Safety
     Search for safe and remarkably cheap investment opportunities
     Buy at <60% of intrinsic value (Margin of Safety); Sell when price returns to near intrinsic value
     When we buy an asset for substantially less than it is worth we reduce downside risk and increase the
      prospect for higher return
     All discounts to intrinsic value eventually close


         “The function of the margin of safety is, in essence, that of
           rendering unnecessary an accurate estimate of the future”
                                                    Benjamin Graham



    Simple Business/Durable Moats
      Avenir invests in simple businesses with a durable competitive advantage (the Moat)
      Our investments are generally in industries with slow rates of change
      We only invest in companies and industries we understand
      The businesses we invest in don’t have to be great businesses but they have to be bought at great prices


9
Investment Framework

     Special Situations
       Demergers, spin-offs, restructurings, recapitalisations, rights offerings, asset sales, liquidations, etc
       Value can often be found in complex situations, poorly followed/’unloved’ companies, ‘hidden’ assets
       Often the most mispriced assets are to be found in stressed or distressed opportunities

     Low Risk, High Uncertainty
       Most investors measure risk as volatility or deviation from a benchmark
             Avenir fixates solely on minimising the risk of permanent loss of capital
       Avenir also differentiates between an uncertain outcome (i.e. a range of possible outcomes) and the risk of loss
        of capital
       Low risk, high uncertainty is a great combination for finding investment value as it can lead to severely
        depressed prices for businesses – the market hates uncertainty
       We seek to invest only in “Heads I win; tails, I don’t lose much” investment propositions



     Focus on Our Best Ideas
       Our approach is to bet heavily when the odds are overwhelmingly in our favour; at other times, we don’t bet!
       We fixate on minimising permanent loss of capital so we only invest in assymetric opportunities when
        downside risk is very low
       The non-market risk of owning one stock is reduced by ~80% with 8 stocks and over 90% with 16 stocks
10
Portfolio Construction

     Avenir Capital’s portfolio construction is derived from a fundamental belief that low risk, high return investments
     are rare and that risk is adequately managed with a moderately diversified portfolio

      Portfolio Construction                                              ‘Representative’ Portfolio
                                                                          Holding              Investment           Return $   Return %
      Total portfolio approximately 15-25 positions                      Holding 1                $50                $10        -80%
                                                                          Holding 2                $50                $20        -60%
            Focus only on the best investment opportunities when
                                                                          Holding 3                $50                $40        -20%
             the odds are overwhelmingly in our favour                    Holding 4                $50                $50          0%
            High conviction/concentrated portfolio (consistent with      Holding 5                $50                $50          0%
             private equity heritage)                                     Holding 6                $50                $60         20%
                                                                          Holding 7                $50                $60         20%
      Portfolio structure: 3%, 5%, 10% framework                         Holding 8                $50                $70         40%
                                                                          Holding 9                $50                $70         40%
            No position in excess of 15% of net fund assets              Holding 10               $50                $75         50%
                                                                          Holding 11               $50                $75         50%
      Top 10-15 holdings roughly 60-70% of net fund assets               Holding 12               $50                $80         60%
                                                                          Holding 13               $50                $90         80%
      Cash position is a function of opportunities rather than policy    Holding 14               $50                $90         80%
           Cash will grow in times of few compelling opportunities       Holding 15               $50                $100      100%
                                                                          Holding 16               $50                $100      100%
             and decline when opportunities are plentiful
                                                                          Holding 17               $50                $100      100%
                                                                          Holding 18               $50                $120      140%
                                                                          Holding 19               $50                $150      200%
                                                                          Holding 20               $50                $150      200%
                                                                          Total                  $1,000              $1,560       56%

                                                                          Portfolio Internal Rate of Return (IRR)
                                                                          1 year                       56.0%
                                                                          2 years                      24.9%
11
                                                                          3 years                      16.0%
Benefits of Allocation to Avenir Capital

     Avenir Capital provides exposure to alternative investment opportunities and an alternative risk management
     philosophy


          • Access ‘unloved’ part of market                         • Avenir targets above market rates of return
          • Ex ‘mainstream’ stocks                                  • Focus on absolute returns not benchmark relative
                                                                      returns
          • Increase exposure to special situations
                                                                                • Patient disciplined investing in only low
          • Focused international exposure                                        risk, high return opportunities
                                                        Broaden      Above
                                                      Investment    Market
                                                       Exposure     Returns


          • Experienced high conviction                            Avoid cost of      • Avoid opportunity cost of market
            investment manager                       Risk                               moving ‘sideways’ for prolonged
                                                                    ‘Sideways’
                                                          test
                                                  Management                            period
          • Provides exposure to different risk                       Market
            management philosophy                                                • Benefit from active stock selection
          • Minimise risk of permanent capital loss                              • Reduced market correlation
            rather than risk of deviation from
            benchmark or annual volatility
          • Margin of safety investing


12
Risk Management

     Risk management flows through every element of the Avenir operating model



                                                            Margin of safety - Always!
                                                            Buy at well below intrinsic value
                                                            Fixate on minimising permanent loss of capital
                                                            Private equity heritage
                    Philosophy


                                                            No single investment over 15% of net fund assets
                                                            Leverage not used to drive returns
                                                            Sufficient diversification in portfolio

                  Fund Structure

                                                            Investment discipline – patience, patience, patience
                                                            Invest in simple companies and simple industries
                                                            Low Risk, High Uncertainty opportunities
                                                            Manage correlations within portfolio
             Investment Framework
13
Key Fund Terms

     Avenir Capital’s fund terms are designed to maximise alignment of interest between investors and the fund manager.
     There is no management fee so the Fund Manager only earns income based on return performance above a
     threshold


         Management Fee:          0% management fee (other than to cover administrative costs of fund including
                                   accounting, audit, rent, etc)

         Performance Fee:         25% of annual increase in fund profit
                                     - Only paid if returns above 6% (catch up in place above 6%)
                                     - High watermark
                                                                                Gross Return
                                  Return to Investors             6%       8%     10%     12%         15%     20%
                                  Index fund (0.5%)             5.5%     7.5%    9.5% 11.5%         14.5%    19.5%
                                  Mutual Fund (1.5%)            4.5%     6.5%    8.5% 10.5%         13.5%    18.5%
                                  Hedge Fund (2%/20%)           3.2%     4.8%    6.4%    8.0%       10.4%    14.4%
                                  Avenir Capital (0%/25%)       6.0%     6.0%    7.5%    9.0%       11.3%    15.0%
                                  (no performance fee <6%)


         Redemption:              Monthly

         Reporting:               Quarterly update; annual meeting; high level of access for investors


14
Summary



      Avenir Capital specialises in fundamental, value –based and special-situation investments in global
       equity and debt markets

      We invest in materially mispriced securities which we can buy well below intrinsic value (a large
       margin of safety) and that offer the potential for superior returns with limited risk of permanent
       loss of capital

      Our investment program applies private equity style disciplines to the public market with the 3
       underlying pillars being:
           Focus on the downside first – fixate on avoiding permanent loss of capital
           Fundamental, bottom up approach to investment selection
           Focus on absolute long term returns not relative short term returns

      Avenir has an attractive fee structure aligning the interests of investors and the fund manager and
       providing some protection for investors in periods of lower returns

      Avenir is managed by an experienced and successful investor and manager of third party
       money




15
Appendix:

     Investment Sourcing and Examples




16
Investment Idea Sourcing


        The key insight to sourcing investment ideas is the ongoing search for irrational or misguided sellers


     Read widely with antenna tuned to        Investigate situations/ opportunities           Stay close to sources of value
           market overreaction                             others avoid                               investing ideas


 Newspapers                                 Poorly covered or unloved stocks           52 week low lists
         WSJ, FT, AFR, SMH, etc             Spin offs                                  Company screens
 Magazines                                  Restructurings / Reorganisations               Low P/E
     Barrons, Forbes, Fortune               Companies or industries out of favour          Low price to book value
                                             Overleveraged situations                       High equity free cash flow yield
 Websites
     Value Investor Insight                 Post bankruptcy equities                   Value investor forums
     Tickerspy                              Focus on Margin of safety and                   Value Investors Club
     Motley Fools                            minimising downside risk                        SumZero
     Marketwatch                                                                             Gurufocus
     Seekingalpha                                                                            Valueforum
     Bloomberg                                                                          Value investing conferences
     CNBC, etc                                                                               Value investors congress
                                                                                         Hedge fund SEC filings and investor
                                                                                          newsletters


17
Investment Example: International Coal (US)


 Investment Thesis                                                        International Coal (ICO US)
 ICO provided the opportunity to buy into an underfollowed coal          A$

  business with sizeable natural resources and backed by renowned
  value investor Wilbur Ross
 ICO had a messy and confusing beginning:                                                                                                 Buy
      formed by the bringing together of 3 previously bankrupt
                                                                                                                                                             Sell
         companies
      underwent a major debt to equity recapitalisation
      Issued new equity to further paydown debt
      Confusing financials due to complex formation and short life
 The underfollowed and unloved company, however, had several
  attributes
       highly contracted medium term sales                                    Source: Bloomberg
       a low cost position
       increasingly shifting output to higher margin metallurgical                 Estimated 2011 EBITDA ($m)                    285
                                                                                    Estimated 2011 EBITA ($m)                     185
          coal in an environment of rising prices
       >1bn tons of coal reserves backed by a well formed and                      Pro Forma Plus Tygart No. 1 mine
          financed development capital plan                                         Increased volume                              3.5 m tonnes
                                                                                    Avg margin($/t)                                15 *
       significant recent capital expenditure and excess plant
                                                                                    Increased margin ($m)                        52.5
          capacity                                                                                                                      Multiple
                                                                                    PF 2011 EBITDA ($m)                           338    3.3     x PF for Tygart mine no. 1
 We bought at an average price of $4.55 per share which was just
                                                                                    PF 2011 EBITA ($m)                            238    4.6     x PF for Tygart mine no. 1
  over TBV and, we estimated, at approx. 50% of intrinsic value
 As is often the case when we buy cheaply, ‘good things happen’                    Target EBITA multiple                        8.0 x Assumed
                                                                                    Target Enterprise Value ($m)                1900
 Outcome                                                                            Target Market cap ($m)                      1729
                                                                                    Target share price ($)                      8.48
 Arch Coal Inc. made an offer at $14.50 per share                                  Current share price ($)                     4.55
                                                                                    Discount to 'intrinsic' value               46%
 We sold post announcement at ~$14.43 (IRR 365%)
                                                                                    * Cons erva tive a s ma na gement s tated $40/t ma rgi n
18
Investment Example: Village Roadshow


 Investment Thesis                                                        Village Roadshow (VRL AU)
 VRL provided a prime opportunity to buy high quality, cash              A$
                                                                                                                                              $1.00
  generative assets at 50-60 cents on the dollar when management                                               20c div                       Special
  making clear efforts to simplify the business                                                                                                div

 VRL has historically had a very complicated corporate and capital
  structure leading to market aversion
 Austereo stake confused market as to underlying value and
  provided value creation opportunity                                                                                                         Current
 Key insiders increasing their economic control highlighted the                                                  Buy                          value

  material undervaluation (as did share buybacks below intrinsic
  value)
       Proposed take private in 2009; 26% share buyback in Nov
          2009; 21% proposed share buyback Sep/Oct 2010                        Source: Bloomberg
                                                                                                                               Pre-      Post-
 Company was poorly covered and materially undervalued with                          (A$m)                                   Buyback   Buyback
  continued share buybacks or full privatisation attempts likely                      FY10 EBITDA (incl 100% Austereo)              255       255
                                                                                      Austereo EBITDA                                89        89
 At our entry price of $2.45, we estimated VRL was trading at a 40-                  Net FY10 EBITDA (excl Austereo)               166       166

  50% discount to intrinsic value                                                     Assumed EBITDA Multiple                      6.0        6.0
 LTM P/E = 6.3x (current shares outstanding); pro forma for                          Enterprise value (excl Austereo)            996        996

  announced buyback = 5.1x                                                            Net Debt (pre- and post- buyback)            827       914
                                                                                      Less: Austereo debt                          209       209
 LTM price to FCF (post tax) = 1.6x (current shares outstanding); 0.4x               Net debt (excl Austereo)                     618       705
  (pro forma for announced share buyback)
                                                                                      Equity value (excl Austereo)                 378       291
 Outcome                                                                              Plus: value of 52% stake in Austereo         298       298
                                                                                      Total VRL equity value                       676       589
 Austereo business sold; $1 special dividend paid and market better                  # shares (m) (Pre- and post- buyback)        166       131
  realised underlying value
                                                                                      Equity value per share                      4.06       4.48
 Current value ~$3.20 plus $1.20 dividend (IRR 91%)                                  Average share price                         2.45       2.45
                                                                                      % discount to intrinsic value               40%        45%
19
Investment Example: Oaks Hotels and Resorts


 Investment Thesis                                                            Oaks Hotels and Resorts (OAK AU)
 The company found itself amidst great noise and confusion as the            A$
  Founder/CEO’s personal 35% stake was placed into receivership
  and he was removed from board
                                                                                                                                          Sell
 The ex-CEO subsequently sought to overturn the board and
  instate his own nominees
 A mysterious Chinese investor appeared as a material holder on                                                                Buy
  the register and gained a board seat
 Amidst the chaotic activity and negative press, the market lost
  sight of the fact that the business owned stable, long term and
  separable assets and was generating record revenue/earnings
 We acquired shares at an average of $0.26 per share (less than
  60% of NAV and 4x FCF) with our estimated intrinsic value being                  Source: Bloomberg
  $0.60-0.70 per share                                                    NET ASSET VALUE                      CASH FLOW MULTIPLE 2010            2011 (1)
                                                                          30 June 10 Net asset value    70.8   'Core' EBITDA               25.8      30.0
 Outcome                                                                  Plus: October placement        6.5   Capex/Depreciation           5.2        5.2
 An overseas listed leisure and hospitality operator launched an         30 Oct 10 Adj NAV             77.3   'Core' EBITA                20.6      24.8
  initial $0.32 per share hostile bid during the confusion                                                     Less
                                                                          # shares                     173.8   Cash finance costs           8.8        8.8
 We expressed our view of value to the board and ultimately sold         NAV per share                 0.44   Tax                          4.0        4.0
  into the revised offer of $.52 per share (IRR 462%)                     Average entry share price     0.26   Free cash flow               7.8      12.0
 While our view of intrinsic value was significantly higher than         Discount to NAV               42%
  $.52 per share we did not have the financial firepower to join the                                           Current share price         0.26      0.26
                                                                                                               # shares                  173.8      173.8
  battle so grudgingly accepted the revised offer
                                                                                                               Equity value                45.2      45.2
                                                                                                               Equity / FCF                 5.8        3.8
                                                                                                               FCF yield (%)               17%        27%
                                                                                                               (1) Ba s ed on mgmt gui da nce of $30-32m.
20

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Hybrid Portfolio Theory, 6.17.09
Hybrid Portfolio Theory, 6.17.09Hybrid Portfolio Theory, 6.17.09
Hybrid Portfolio Theory, 6.17.09Prescient Partners
 
The importance of investment methodology
The importance of investment methodologyThe importance of investment methodology
The importance of investment methodologyA.W. Berry
 
10 Year Anniversary Tocqueville Value Europe
10 Year Anniversary Tocqueville Value Europe10 Year Anniversary Tocqueville Value Europe
10 Year Anniversary Tocqueville Value Europefitzgeralddon
 
Investment Strategy
Investment StrategyInvestment Strategy
Investment Strategydrsues02
 
Investment Planning & Policy Development
Investment Planning & Policy DevelopmentInvestment Planning & Policy Development
Investment Planning & Policy DevelopmentExplore Atlanta
 
MFA RAUM Calculation
MFA RAUM CalculationMFA RAUM Calculation
MFA RAUM CalculationManagedFunds
 
Sa investec opportunity_fund_brochure
Sa investec opportunity_fund_brochureSa investec opportunity_fund_brochure
Sa investec opportunity_fund_brochureCobus Minnaar
 
Investment Portfolio Management PowerPoint Presentation Slides
Investment Portfolio Management PowerPoint Presentation Slides Investment Portfolio Management PowerPoint Presentation Slides
Investment Portfolio Management PowerPoint Presentation Slides SlideTeam
 
1. introduction basics of investments.ppt
1. introduction   basics of investments.ppt1. introduction   basics of investments.ppt
1. introduction basics of investments.pptNavneet Jingar
 
Speculation vs investment
Speculation vs investmentSpeculation vs investment
Speculation vs investmentAnjiyaa
 
Investment options for Indians
Investment options for IndiansInvestment options for Indians
Investment options for IndiansSudhir Kumar
 
Basics of Investment
Basics of InvestmentBasics of Investment
Basics of InvestmentManu Antony
 
Introduction portfolio management
Introduction portfolio managementIntroduction portfolio management
Introduction portfolio managementNoorulhadi Qureshi
 
Pb601 introduction to investment
Pb601 introduction to investmentPb601 introduction to investment
Pb601 introduction to investmentAkihisa Akimoto
 
Investment Management Process
Investment Management ProcessInvestment Management Process
Investment Management ProcessSharon Almond
 
Closed-End Funds: Opportunities and Challenges in a Unique Market - Dec. 2011
Closed-End Funds: Opportunities and Challenges in a Unique Market - Dec. 2011Closed-End Funds: Opportunities and Challenges in a Unique Market - Dec. 2011
Closed-End Funds: Opportunities and Challenges in a Unique Market - Dec. 2011RobertWBaird
 
Investment management
Investment managementInvestment management
Investment managementhadi Hedayati
 
Investment Planning
Investment PlanningInvestment Planning
Investment PlanningJohn Daniel
 

Tendances (19)

Hybrid Portfolio Theory, 6.17.09
Hybrid Portfolio Theory, 6.17.09Hybrid Portfolio Theory, 6.17.09
Hybrid Portfolio Theory, 6.17.09
 
The importance of investment methodology
The importance of investment methodologyThe importance of investment methodology
The importance of investment methodology
 
10 Year Anniversary Tocqueville Value Europe
10 Year Anniversary Tocqueville Value Europe10 Year Anniversary Tocqueville Value Europe
10 Year Anniversary Tocqueville Value Europe
 
Investment Strategy
Investment StrategyInvestment Strategy
Investment Strategy
 
Investment Planning & Policy Development
Investment Planning & Policy DevelopmentInvestment Planning & Policy Development
Investment Planning & Policy Development
 
MFA RAUM Calculation
MFA RAUM CalculationMFA RAUM Calculation
MFA RAUM Calculation
 
Sa investec opportunity_fund_brochure
Sa investec opportunity_fund_brochureSa investec opportunity_fund_brochure
Sa investec opportunity_fund_brochure
 
Investment Portfolio Management PowerPoint Presentation Slides
Investment Portfolio Management PowerPoint Presentation Slides Investment Portfolio Management PowerPoint Presentation Slides
Investment Portfolio Management PowerPoint Presentation Slides
 
1. introduction basics of investments.ppt
1. introduction   basics of investments.ppt1. introduction   basics of investments.ppt
1. introduction basics of investments.ppt
 
Speculation vs investment
Speculation vs investmentSpeculation vs investment
Speculation vs investment
 
Investment options for Indians
Investment options for IndiansInvestment options for Indians
Investment options for Indians
 
Basics of Investment
Basics of InvestmentBasics of Investment
Basics of Investment
 
Introduction portfolio management
Introduction portfolio managementIntroduction portfolio management
Introduction portfolio management
 
Investment management
Investment managementInvestment management
Investment management
 
Pb601 introduction to investment
Pb601 introduction to investmentPb601 introduction to investment
Pb601 introduction to investment
 
Investment Management Process
Investment Management ProcessInvestment Management Process
Investment Management Process
 
Closed-End Funds: Opportunities and Challenges in a Unique Market - Dec. 2011
Closed-End Funds: Opportunities and Challenges in a Unique Market - Dec. 2011Closed-End Funds: Opportunities and Challenges in a Unique Market - Dec. 2011
Closed-End Funds: Opportunities and Challenges in a Unique Market - Dec. 2011
 
Investment management
Investment managementInvestment management
Investment management
 
Investment Planning
Investment PlanningInvestment Planning
Investment Planning
 

Similaire à Private equity value investing techniques applied to public markets

Navigating Your Wealth Management Options
Navigating Your Wealth Management OptionsNavigating Your Wealth Management Options
Navigating Your Wealth Management OptionsRobert Champion
 
Explaining 30,000 Mutual Funds to a Billion People
Explaining 30,000 Mutual Funds to a Billion PeopleExplaining 30,000 Mutual Funds to a Billion People
Explaining 30,000 Mutual Funds to a Billion PeopleBentleyDUC
 
John Hancock PowerPoint Presentation
John Hancock PowerPoint PresentationJohn Hancock PowerPoint Presentation
John Hancock PowerPoint PresentationPulse Design Studio
 
aon intro_invest
aon intro_investaon intro_invest
aon intro_investfinance27
 
High div presentation geneva - long
High div presentation   geneva - longHigh div presentation   geneva - long
High div presentation geneva - longTimo Rossi
 
Paradigm Shift Investing In Illiquid Assets Nov 2008
Paradigm Shift   Investing In Illiquid Assets Nov 2008Paradigm Shift   Investing In Illiquid Assets Nov 2008
Paradigm Shift Investing In Illiquid Assets Nov 2008Xavier_Timmermans
 
Model Wealth Portfolios - Deep Dive
Model Wealth Portfolios - Deep DiveModel Wealth Portfolios - Deep Dive
Model Wealth Portfolios - Deep DiveMike Davis
 
EAS Separate Account Presentation
EAS Separate Account PresentationEAS Separate Account Presentation
EAS Separate Account Presentationjackfgonzalez
 
Jeopardy -investments (week 5)
Jeopardy -investments (week 5)Jeopardy -investments (week 5)
Jeopardy -investments (week 5)Donna Kesot
 
Where is "Value" In Value Investing
Where is "Value" In Value InvestingWhere is "Value" In Value Investing
Where is "Value" In Value InvestingDD D
 
Presentation on private equity by ca. sudha g. bhushan
Presentation on private equity by ca. sudha g. bhushanPresentation on private equity by ca. sudha g. bhushan
Presentation on private equity by ca. sudha g. bhushanTAXPERT PROFESSIONALS
 
Fulton Financial Advisors
Fulton Financial AdvisorsFulton Financial Advisors
Fulton Financial AdvisorsDonald Marano
 
Si Brochure 3 10 8 5x11
Si Brochure 3 10 8 5x11Si Brochure 3 10 8 5x11
Si Brochure 3 10 8 5x11Balbitz
 

Similaire à Private equity value investing techniques applied to public markets (20)

Navigating Your Wealth Management Options
Navigating Your Wealth Management OptionsNavigating Your Wealth Management Options
Navigating Your Wealth Management Options
 
Raising venture capital
Raising venture capitalRaising venture capital
Raising venture capital
 
Explaining 30,000 Mutual Funds to a Billion People
Explaining 30,000 Mutual Funds to a Billion PeopleExplaining 30,000 Mutual Funds to a Billion People
Explaining 30,000 Mutual Funds to a Billion People
 
John Hancock PowerPoint Presentation
John Hancock PowerPoint PresentationJohn Hancock PowerPoint Presentation
John Hancock PowerPoint Presentation
 
aon intro_invest
aon intro_investaon intro_invest
aon intro_invest
 
The Mosaic Portfolio
The Mosaic PortfolioThe Mosaic Portfolio
The Mosaic Portfolio
 
Equity Solutions
Equity SolutionsEquity Solutions
Equity Solutions
 
investment
investmentinvestment
investment
 
High div presentation geneva - long
High div presentation   geneva - longHigh div presentation   geneva - long
High div presentation geneva - long
 
Paradigm Shift Investing In Illiquid Assets Nov 2008
Paradigm Shift   Investing In Illiquid Assets Nov 2008Paradigm Shift   Investing In Illiquid Assets Nov 2008
Paradigm Shift Investing In Illiquid Assets Nov 2008
 
Model Wealth Portfolios - Deep Dive
Model Wealth Portfolios - Deep DiveModel Wealth Portfolios - Deep Dive
Model Wealth Portfolios - Deep Dive
 
EAS Separate Account Presentation
EAS Separate Account PresentationEAS Separate Account Presentation
EAS Separate Account Presentation
 
Howard mark memos
Howard mark memosHoward mark memos
Howard mark memos
 
Jeopardy -investments (week 5)
Jeopardy -investments (week 5)Jeopardy -investments (week 5)
Jeopardy -investments (week 5)
 
Where is "Value" In Value Investing
Where is "Value" In Value InvestingWhere is "Value" In Value Investing
Where is "Value" In Value Investing
 
Presentation on private equity by ca. sudha g. bhushan
Presentation on private equity by ca. sudha g. bhushanPresentation on private equity by ca. sudha g. bhushan
Presentation on private equity by ca. sudha g. bhushan
 
Sapm mod !
Sapm mod !Sapm mod !
Sapm mod !
 
Fulton Financial Advisors
Fulton Financial AdvisorsFulton Financial Advisors
Fulton Financial Advisors
 
Si Brochure 3 10 8 5x11
Si Brochure 3 10 8 5x11Si Brochure 3 10 8 5x11
Si Brochure 3 10 8 5x11
 
Investment
InvestmentInvestment
Investment
 

Private equity value investing techniques applied to public markets

  • 1. Private equity value investing in public markets
  • 2. Introduction  Avenir Capital specialises in fundamental, value –based and special-situation investments in global equity and debt markets  We search for materially mispriced securities which we can buy well below intrinsic value (that is, with a large margin of safety) and that offer the potential for superior returns with limited risk of permanent loss of capital  Our investment program applies key elements of private equity investing to public markets with 3 underlying pillars:  Focus on the downside first – fixate on avoiding permanent loss of capital  Fundamental, bottom up approach to investment selection  Focus on absolute long term returns not relative short term returns  Avenir has an attractive fee structure aligning the interests of investors and the fund manager and providing some protection for investors in periods of lower returns  Avenir is managed by an experienced and successful investor and manager of third party money 1
  • 3. The Model Avenir Capital applies the best elements of private equity and public market investing to identify and invest in significantly mispriced assets Private Equity Public Market  Greater opportunity set  Focus on low risk investing  Deep discounts to intrinsic value  Longer term investment horizon  Focus on fundamentals  Focus on investment analysis not ‘deal process’  In depth due diligence  Lower transaction costs  Conviction investing  Liquidity  Concentrated portfolio Current Market Sentiment  Active investment selection  Transparency  Lower leverage  Liquidity 2 Avenir Capital
  • 4. 3 Underlying Pillars Think About Focus on Absolute Bottom Up not Downside First Returns Top Down • Focus on minimising • Longer term absolute • Fundamental analysis risk of permanent loss return focus not short of capital term relative returns • Company specific investment decisions • What is probability of • Avoid closet indexing loss; how much can • Don’t try to guess • Avoid asset gathering short term market we lose? behaviour direction • Don’t view volatility as • Patient investing to • Look for materially risk benefit from ‘time mispriced assets • Worry more about arbitrage’ what we can lose than • Not afraid to invest in what we might make ‘unloved’ companies • Margin of safety – Always! 3
  • 5. Consistent with Private Equity Heritage Much of the investment approach and risk management of Avenir Capital is consistent with the Principal’s private equity investing heritage • Concentrated portfolio investing in only the best opportunities Investment • Intense focus on downside risk minimisation Framework/ Risk • Simple businesses: Avoid single product, technology or resource risk Management • Medium/long term investment horizon • Patience, patience, patience • Extensive investigative due diligence and financial analysis experience • Deep experience in assessing competitive position, industry structure and management team Due Diligence • Operational experience in assessing strategy viability, timeframes and operational capability • Extensive experience in assessing capital structure, financial viability and bank pressure points Key Elements Added  Margin of Safety  Low Risk, High Uncertainty Investing  Event Driven/Special Situation Opportunities 4
  • 6. Principal’s Background The Principal is an experienced professional investor and manager of third party money • 17 years in third party investment management • Managing Director/part owner of $1B Australian PE firm Investment • Managing Director of leading pan-Asian PE firm Management • US and Australian investment management • Large cap and small/mid cap public market investments • Extensive operational and board level experience • First hand insight into management and company capability Business Insight • Extensive debt and capital market experience • Deep and varied due diligence and financial analysis • Excellent and consistent investment track record Track Record • 3.7x money return on investments 5
  • 7. Principal: Private Equity Returns Return Measurement(2) Transaction Investment(1) Exit Value IRR Money Multiple ($m) Waters 40 309 225% 7.7x Pacific Brands 236 1,216 129% 5.2x Tech Pacific 138 506 122% 3.7x Mettler Toledo 224 805 91% 3.6x Vertex 15 51 100% 3.4x Affinity Health 247 782 124% 3.2x Frucor 50 155 57% 3.1x Manchester Tank 28 86 55% 3.1x Valley Longwall 88 8 n/a 0.1x Total 1,066 3,918 n/a 3.7x NOTE: Mr Warner does not claim to have been responsible for any portion of the above track record or whether this would be representative of Mr Warner’s investment performance. The results above are the work of teams of professionals and no single individual was responsible for any investment. (1) Includes co-investments 6 (2) Before expenses, fees and carried interest
  • 8. Performance: Avenir Value Fund Avenir Value Fund Performance (Net of Fees and Expenses) 110.0 104.5 104.6 105.0 102.1 102.4 Index = 100 at Inception 101.2 101.1 101.1 100.0 101.0 97.5 98.5 100.0 96.5 96.0 93.7 95.0 92.5 90.0 85.0 80.0 All Ords Accumulation Avenir Value Fund Monthly Performance (Net of Fees/Expenses since Inception 1 August 2011)* Year Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec YTD All Ords^ 2012 5.8% 2.4% 0.1% -3.3% -3.6% -3.9% -1.3% 6.5% 4.0% 6.1% 11.3% 2011 1.0% -5.0% 5.4% -0.1% -4.5% -3.5% -7.9% * Results are unaudited. ^ All Ordinaries Accumulation Index 7
  • 9. Investment Framework “The market is normally efficient but it is not always efficient. The difference between those two propositions is like night and day” Warren Buffett Margin of Safety – Always! Simple Special Businesses Situations The Search for Mispriced assets Low Risk, High Focus on our Best Uncertainty Ideas 8
  • 10. Investment Framework Margin of Safety  Search for safe and remarkably cheap investment opportunities  Buy at <60% of intrinsic value (Margin of Safety); Sell when price returns to near intrinsic value  When we buy an asset for substantially less than it is worth we reduce downside risk and increase the prospect for higher return  All discounts to intrinsic value eventually close “The function of the margin of safety is, in essence, that of rendering unnecessary an accurate estimate of the future” Benjamin Graham Simple Business/Durable Moats  Avenir invests in simple businesses with a durable competitive advantage (the Moat)  Our investments are generally in industries with slow rates of change  We only invest in companies and industries we understand  The businesses we invest in don’t have to be great businesses but they have to be bought at great prices 9
  • 11. Investment Framework Special Situations  Demergers, spin-offs, restructurings, recapitalisations, rights offerings, asset sales, liquidations, etc  Value can often be found in complex situations, poorly followed/’unloved’ companies, ‘hidden’ assets  Often the most mispriced assets are to be found in stressed or distressed opportunities Low Risk, High Uncertainty  Most investors measure risk as volatility or deviation from a benchmark  Avenir fixates solely on minimising the risk of permanent loss of capital  Avenir also differentiates between an uncertain outcome (i.e. a range of possible outcomes) and the risk of loss of capital  Low risk, high uncertainty is a great combination for finding investment value as it can lead to severely depressed prices for businesses – the market hates uncertainty  We seek to invest only in “Heads I win; tails, I don’t lose much” investment propositions Focus on Our Best Ideas  Our approach is to bet heavily when the odds are overwhelmingly in our favour; at other times, we don’t bet!  We fixate on minimising permanent loss of capital so we only invest in assymetric opportunities when downside risk is very low  The non-market risk of owning one stock is reduced by ~80% with 8 stocks and over 90% with 16 stocks 10
  • 12. Portfolio Construction Avenir Capital’s portfolio construction is derived from a fundamental belief that low risk, high return investments are rare and that risk is adequately managed with a moderately diversified portfolio Portfolio Construction ‘Representative’ Portfolio Holding Investment Return $ Return %  Total portfolio approximately 15-25 positions Holding 1 $50 $10 -80% Holding 2 $50 $20 -60%  Focus only on the best investment opportunities when Holding 3 $50 $40 -20% the odds are overwhelmingly in our favour Holding 4 $50 $50 0%  High conviction/concentrated portfolio (consistent with Holding 5 $50 $50 0% private equity heritage) Holding 6 $50 $60 20% Holding 7 $50 $60 20%  Portfolio structure: 3%, 5%, 10% framework Holding 8 $50 $70 40% Holding 9 $50 $70 40%  No position in excess of 15% of net fund assets Holding 10 $50 $75 50% Holding 11 $50 $75 50%  Top 10-15 holdings roughly 60-70% of net fund assets Holding 12 $50 $80 60% Holding 13 $50 $90 80%  Cash position is a function of opportunities rather than policy Holding 14 $50 $90 80%  Cash will grow in times of few compelling opportunities Holding 15 $50 $100 100% Holding 16 $50 $100 100% and decline when opportunities are plentiful Holding 17 $50 $100 100% Holding 18 $50 $120 140% Holding 19 $50 $150 200% Holding 20 $50 $150 200% Total $1,000 $1,560 56% Portfolio Internal Rate of Return (IRR) 1 year 56.0% 2 years 24.9% 11 3 years 16.0%
  • 13. Benefits of Allocation to Avenir Capital Avenir Capital provides exposure to alternative investment opportunities and an alternative risk management philosophy • Access ‘unloved’ part of market • Avenir targets above market rates of return • Ex ‘mainstream’ stocks • Focus on absolute returns not benchmark relative returns • Increase exposure to special situations • Patient disciplined investing in only low • Focused international exposure risk, high return opportunities Broaden Above Investment Market Exposure Returns • Experienced high conviction Avoid cost of • Avoid opportunity cost of market investment manager Risk moving ‘sideways’ for prolonged ‘Sideways’ test Management period • Provides exposure to different risk Market management philosophy • Benefit from active stock selection • Minimise risk of permanent capital loss • Reduced market correlation rather than risk of deviation from benchmark or annual volatility • Margin of safety investing 12
  • 14. Risk Management Risk management flows through every element of the Avenir operating model  Margin of safety - Always!  Buy at well below intrinsic value  Fixate on minimising permanent loss of capital  Private equity heritage Philosophy  No single investment over 15% of net fund assets  Leverage not used to drive returns  Sufficient diversification in portfolio Fund Structure  Investment discipline – patience, patience, patience  Invest in simple companies and simple industries  Low Risk, High Uncertainty opportunities  Manage correlations within portfolio Investment Framework 13
  • 15. Key Fund Terms Avenir Capital’s fund terms are designed to maximise alignment of interest between investors and the fund manager. There is no management fee so the Fund Manager only earns income based on return performance above a threshold Management Fee:  0% management fee (other than to cover administrative costs of fund including accounting, audit, rent, etc) Performance Fee:  25% of annual increase in fund profit - Only paid if returns above 6% (catch up in place above 6%) - High watermark Gross Return Return to Investors 6% 8% 10% 12% 15% 20% Index fund (0.5%) 5.5% 7.5% 9.5% 11.5% 14.5% 19.5% Mutual Fund (1.5%) 4.5% 6.5% 8.5% 10.5% 13.5% 18.5% Hedge Fund (2%/20%) 3.2% 4.8% 6.4% 8.0% 10.4% 14.4% Avenir Capital (0%/25%) 6.0% 6.0% 7.5% 9.0% 11.3% 15.0% (no performance fee <6%) Redemption:  Monthly Reporting:  Quarterly update; annual meeting; high level of access for investors 14
  • 16. Summary  Avenir Capital specialises in fundamental, value –based and special-situation investments in global equity and debt markets  We invest in materially mispriced securities which we can buy well below intrinsic value (a large margin of safety) and that offer the potential for superior returns with limited risk of permanent loss of capital  Our investment program applies private equity style disciplines to the public market with the 3 underlying pillars being:  Focus on the downside first – fixate on avoiding permanent loss of capital  Fundamental, bottom up approach to investment selection  Focus on absolute long term returns not relative short term returns  Avenir has an attractive fee structure aligning the interests of investors and the fund manager and providing some protection for investors in periods of lower returns  Avenir is managed by an experienced and successful investor and manager of third party money 15
  • 17. Appendix: Investment Sourcing and Examples 16
  • 18. Investment Idea Sourcing The key insight to sourcing investment ideas is the ongoing search for irrational or misguided sellers Read widely with antenna tuned to Investigate situations/ opportunities Stay close to sources of value market overreaction others avoid investing ideas  Newspapers  Poorly covered or unloved stocks  52 week low lists  WSJ, FT, AFR, SMH, etc  Spin offs  Company screens  Magazines  Restructurings / Reorganisations  Low P/E  Barrons, Forbes, Fortune  Companies or industries out of favour  Low price to book value  Overleveraged situations  High equity free cash flow yield  Websites  Value Investor Insight  Post bankruptcy equities  Value investor forums  Tickerspy  Focus on Margin of safety and  Value Investors Club  Motley Fools minimising downside risk  SumZero  Marketwatch  Gurufocus  Seekingalpha  Valueforum  Bloomberg  Value investing conferences  CNBC, etc  Value investors congress  Hedge fund SEC filings and investor newsletters 17
  • 19. Investment Example: International Coal (US) Investment Thesis International Coal (ICO US)  ICO provided the opportunity to buy into an underfollowed coal A$ business with sizeable natural resources and backed by renowned value investor Wilbur Ross  ICO had a messy and confusing beginning: Buy  formed by the bringing together of 3 previously bankrupt Sell companies  underwent a major debt to equity recapitalisation  Issued new equity to further paydown debt  Confusing financials due to complex formation and short life  The underfollowed and unloved company, however, had several attributes  highly contracted medium term sales Source: Bloomberg  a low cost position  increasingly shifting output to higher margin metallurgical Estimated 2011 EBITDA ($m) 285 Estimated 2011 EBITA ($m) 185 coal in an environment of rising prices  >1bn tons of coal reserves backed by a well formed and Pro Forma Plus Tygart No. 1 mine financed development capital plan Increased volume 3.5 m tonnes Avg margin($/t) 15 *  significant recent capital expenditure and excess plant Increased margin ($m) 52.5 capacity Multiple PF 2011 EBITDA ($m) 338 3.3 x PF for Tygart mine no. 1  We bought at an average price of $4.55 per share which was just PF 2011 EBITA ($m) 238 4.6 x PF for Tygart mine no. 1 over TBV and, we estimated, at approx. 50% of intrinsic value  As is often the case when we buy cheaply, ‘good things happen’ Target EBITA multiple 8.0 x Assumed Target Enterprise Value ($m) 1900 Outcome Target Market cap ($m) 1729 Target share price ($) 8.48  Arch Coal Inc. made an offer at $14.50 per share Current share price ($) 4.55 Discount to 'intrinsic' value 46%  We sold post announcement at ~$14.43 (IRR 365%) * Cons erva tive a s ma na gement s tated $40/t ma rgi n 18
  • 20. Investment Example: Village Roadshow Investment Thesis Village Roadshow (VRL AU)  VRL provided a prime opportunity to buy high quality, cash A$ $1.00 generative assets at 50-60 cents on the dollar when management 20c div Special making clear efforts to simplify the business div  VRL has historically had a very complicated corporate and capital structure leading to market aversion  Austereo stake confused market as to underlying value and provided value creation opportunity Current  Key insiders increasing their economic control highlighted the Buy value material undervaluation (as did share buybacks below intrinsic value)  Proposed take private in 2009; 26% share buyback in Nov 2009; 21% proposed share buyback Sep/Oct 2010 Source: Bloomberg Pre- Post-  Company was poorly covered and materially undervalued with (A$m) Buyback Buyback continued share buybacks or full privatisation attempts likely FY10 EBITDA (incl 100% Austereo) 255 255 Austereo EBITDA 89 89  At our entry price of $2.45, we estimated VRL was trading at a 40- Net FY10 EBITDA (excl Austereo) 166 166 50% discount to intrinsic value Assumed EBITDA Multiple 6.0 6.0  LTM P/E = 6.3x (current shares outstanding); pro forma for Enterprise value (excl Austereo) 996 996 announced buyback = 5.1x Net Debt (pre- and post- buyback) 827 914 Less: Austereo debt 209 209  LTM price to FCF (post tax) = 1.6x (current shares outstanding); 0.4x Net debt (excl Austereo) 618 705 (pro forma for announced share buyback) Equity value (excl Austereo) 378 291 Outcome Plus: value of 52% stake in Austereo 298 298 Total VRL equity value 676 589  Austereo business sold; $1 special dividend paid and market better # shares (m) (Pre- and post- buyback) 166 131 realised underlying value Equity value per share 4.06 4.48  Current value ~$3.20 plus $1.20 dividend (IRR 91%) Average share price 2.45 2.45 % discount to intrinsic value 40% 45% 19
  • 21. Investment Example: Oaks Hotels and Resorts Investment Thesis Oaks Hotels and Resorts (OAK AU)  The company found itself amidst great noise and confusion as the A$ Founder/CEO’s personal 35% stake was placed into receivership and he was removed from board Sell  The ex-CEO subsequently sought to overturn the board and instate his own nominees  A mysterious Chinese investor appeared as a material holder on Buy the register and gained a board seat  Amidst the chaotic activity and negative press, the market lost sight of the fact that the business owned stable, long term and separable assets and was generating record revenue/earnings  We acquired shares at an average of $0.26 per share (less than 60% of NAV and 4x FCF) with our estimated intrinsic value being Source: Bloomberg $0.60-0.70 per share NET ASSET VALUE CASH FLOW MULTIPLE 2010 2011 (1) 30 June 10 Net asset value 70.8 'Core' EBITDA 25.8 30.0 Outcome Plus: October placement 6.5 Capex/Depreciation 5.2 5.2  An overseas listed leisure and hospitality operator launched an 30 Oct 10 Adj NAV 77.3 'Core' EBITA 20.6 24.8 initial $0.32 per share hostile bid during the confusion Less # shares 173.8 Cash finance costs 8.8 8.8  We expressed our view of value to the board and ultimately sold NAV per share 0.44 Tax 4.0 4.0 into the revised offer of $.52 per share (IRR 462%) Average entry share price 0.26 Free cash flow 7.8 12.0  While our view of intrinsic value was significantly higher than Discount to NAV 42% $.52 per share we did not have the financial firepower to join the Current share price 0.26 0.26 # shares 173.8 173.8 battle so grudgingly accepted the revised offer Equity value 45.2 45.2 Equity / FCF 5.8 3.8 FCF yield (%) 17% 27% (1) Ba s ed on mgmt gui da nce of $30-32m. 20