SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 73
The 2010 Gross National
Happiness Index : Part II




    The Centre for Bhutan Studies
                2011
                                    .
Part II:
Understanding Happiness
1.   National happiness
2.   Happiness by Dzongkhag
3.   Happiness by region
4.   Happiness by gender
5.   Happiness by age group
6.   Happiness by marital status
7.   Happiness by educational level
8.   Happiness by occupational group
9.   People’s Stories
Part II:
Understanding Happiness
1.   National happiness
2.   Happiness by Dzongkhag
3.   Happiness by region
4.   Happiness by gender
5.   Happiness by age group
6.   Happiness by marital status
7.   Happiness by educational level
8.   Happiness by occupational group
9.   People’s Stories
A person who has achieved
sufficiency in at least 6 of the 9
domains of GNH is classified as
“HAPPY”
How is happiness measured?

     33 indicators:
     Sufficiency thresholds


       Nine domains:
       Happiness threshold


          GNH Index: 0.743
40.8% of Bhutanese
   are classified happy after
applying sufficiency and happy
           threshold.

The value for GNH Index 2010
           is 0.743

                                 .
Proportion of people non-deprived/happy

                 77%                                     Domains: Psychological
                                          74%            wellbeing, Health, Time
80%                                                use, Culture, Ecology, Community
                                                     vitality, Good Governance and
70%                                                          Living standards

60%
                                                                41%
50%                                  Domains:
              Indicator:
                                    Health, Edu
             Consumption
40%           per capita            cation and
                                       Living
30%                                  Standards
20%

10%

0%
      National Poverty line   Multidimensional       Gross National
              2007            Poverty Index 2010   Happiness Index 2010

                                                                                      .
In which domainscontribution to GNH index enjoy sufficiency?
    Domain percentage
                      do happy people
                                                               Health

                  9%
                               14%                             Ecological diversity and
                                                               resilience
      9%
                                                               Psychological wellbeing


                                           12%                 Community vitality

10%
                                                               Living standards


                                                               Time use
                                          12%
           10%                                                 Cultural diversity and
                                                               resilience
                                                               Good Governance
                 11%          12%

                                                               Education
In which domainscontribution to GNH index enjoy sufficiency?
    Domain percentage
                      do happy people
                                                               Health

                  9%                                     Observation 1:
                               14%                             Ecological diversity and
                                                               resilience
      9%                                                     All nine
                                                             Psychological wellbeing
                                                           dimensions
                                           12%            contributevitality
                                                             Community to

10%
                                                              GNH.
                                                               Living standards

                                                         Happy people
                                                            Time use
                                          12%           live relatively
           10%
                                                        balanced diversity and
                                                            Cultural lives.
                                                               resilience

                 11%          12%                        No dimension
                                                            Good Governance
                                                        is unimportant
                                                               Education
Domain percentage contribution to GNH index
  Biggest contributions
                                                          Health

                      9%
                                        14%               Ecological diversity and
  Observation 2:
                                                          resilience
         9%
Good Health (14%)                                         Psychological wellbeing


Community (12%)                                     12%   Community vitality

  10%
Ecology (12%), and                                        Living standards


Psychological well-                                       Time use
                                                    12%
   being (12%)
              10%                                         Cultural diversity and
                                                          resilience
 Contribute the
 most to GNH in                                           Good Governance
           11%                        12%
     2010.
                                                          Education
Biggest contributionsHealth
    Domain percentage
       contribution to GNH index                         Percentage of people enjoying sufficiency
                              Ecological                          in indicators of Health
                              diversity and
    Observation 2:
 9%         9% 14%
                              resilience
                              Psychological                   89%            86%
     Good Health
        (14%)                 wellbeing            90%                                      76%            74%
      Community               Community            80%
        (12%)           12%   vitality             70%
        Ecology               Living standards     60%
      (12%), and        12%                        50%
    10%
   Psychological              Time use
                                                   40%
10%
  well-being (12%)12%                              30%
   Contribute the                                  20%
                              Cultural diversity
       11%
   most to GNH in
                              and resilience       10%
       2010.
                                                    0%
                              Good Governance
                                                           Disability   Mental health   Healthy days   Self reported
                                                                                                       health status

                                                    • 89% of Bhutanese either do not suffer from long term
                                                    disability or those who are disable ones are not
                                                    restricted from doing their daily activities
                                                    • 86% of Bhutanese have normal mental wellbeing
                                                    • 76% of Bhutanese have sufficient number of
                                                    healthy days
                                                    • 74% of Bhutanese have rated their health as either
                                                    “good” or “very good”
Percentage of people enjoying
           sufficiency in Health                           Percentage of people enjoying sufficiency and
                                                                 are happy in indicators of Health
           89%     86%
100%                        76%      74%
 80%                                                            39%            39%
 60%                                                 40%
 40%
 20%
  0%                                                 38%
        Disability Mental Healthy
                   health
                                   Self
                           days reported
                                                                                              36%
                                  health             36%                                                      35%
                                  status
  • 89% of Bhutanese either do not suffer from       34%
  long term disability or those who are disable
  ones are not restricted from doing their daily     32%
  activities
  • 86% of Bhutanese have normal mental                      Disability   Mental health   Healthy days   Self reported
  wellbeing                                                                                              health status
  • 76% of Bhutanese have sufficient number of
  health days
  • 74% of Bhutanese have rated their health as
                                                   • Of the Bhutanese who achieved sufficiency levels in
  either “good” or “very good”                     disability, 39% are happy (fulfill the happiness
                                                   threshold)
                                                   • Of the Bhutanese who have normal mental wellbeing
                                                   (86), 39% are happy
                                                   • Of the Bhutanese who have achieved sufficient levels
                                                   of healthy days, 36% are happy
                                                   • Of the Bhutanese who have sufficiency in self
                                                   reported health status , 35% are happy
Biggest percentage Health
    Domain
contributions to GNH
    contribution                                            Percentage of people having sufficiency in
       index                    Ecological
                                diversity and
                                                                 indicators of Community vitality
                                resilience
 9%
  Observation 2:
          9%                    Psychological
     Good Health
                    14%         wellbeing
                                                                                              93%      96%
        (14%)
                                Community            100%
     Community            12%   vitality              90%
       (12%)

                      12%
                                Living standards      80%                         63%
       Ecology
                                                      70%
                                                                  46%
     (12%), and
    10%                         Time use              60%
10%Psychological
      well-being                                      50%
        (12%)                   Cultural diversity
         11%         12%        and resilience
                                                      40%
   Contribute the                                     30%
   most to GNH in               Good
       2010.                    Governance            20%
                                                      10%
                                                       0%
                                                            Donations (time   Community      Family   Safety
                                                              & money)        relationship


                                                     • 96% of Bhutanese have never been victims of crime
                                                     • 93% of Bhutanese report good family relationship
                                                     • 76% of Bhutanese report good community
                                                     relationship
                                                     • 46% of Bhutanese have sufficiency in donations
                                                     (time & money)
Biggest percentage Health
    Domain
contributions to GNH
    contribution                                    Percentage of people who are happy & have
       index
         9%
                               Ecological
                               diversity and
                                                   sufficiency in indicators of Community vitality
                               resilience
9%Observation 2:
                               Psychological
    Good Health
                   14%         wellbeing                                            39%      40%
       (14%)
                               Community         40%
      Community      12%       vitality                                 27%
        (12%)
                               Living            30%      21%
        Ecology                standards
      (12%), and
      10%                      Time use          20%
   Psychological
10%  well-being
      11%
       (12%)       12%         Cultural          10%
                               diversity and
  Contribute the               resilience
  most to GNH in         12%   Good               0%
      2010.                    Governance
                                                       Donations   Community      Family   Safety
                                                        (time &    relationship
                                                        money)

                                               • 39% of Bhutanese who report good family
                                               relationship are happy
                                               • 27% of Bhutanese who have good community
                                               relationship are happy
                                               • 21% of Bhutanese who have sufficiency in donations
                                               (time & money) are also classified happy
Biggest percentage Health
    Domain
                                                             Percentage of people who have sufficiency in
contributions to GNH
    contribution
       index                    Ecological                        Psychological wellbeing indicators
                                diversity and
                                resilience
 9%
  Observation 2:
          9%                    Psychological
     Good Health
                    14%         wellbeing                                                            83%
        (14%)
                                Community
                                                     90%
     Community            12%   vitality             80%                                 65%
       (12%)
                                Living standards     70%                     59%
       Ecology        12%                                      53%
     (12%), and                                      60%
    10%                         Time use
10%Psychological                                     50%
      well-being
        (12%)                   Cultural diversity   40%
         11%         12%        and resilience
   Contribute the                                    30%
   most to GNH in               Good
       2010.                    Governance           20%
                                                     10%
                                                      0%
                                                           Spirituality    Positive   Negative       Life
                                                                          emotions    emotions   satisfaction
                                                      • 83% of Bhutanese have sufficiency in life satisfaction
                                                      • 65% of Bhutanese report low negative emotions
                                                      •59% of Bhutanese report high positive emotions
                                                      • Only 53% of Bhutanese have sufficiency in
                                                      spirituality
Percentage of people who have sufficiency in
                                                       How spiritual do you consider yourself to be?
         Psychological wellbeing indicators


                                  83%
    100%
     50%
             53%    59%    65%

                                                                      Not at all   Somewhat
      0%

                                                                        1%            7%


• 83% of Bhutanese have sufficiency in life
satisfaction
• 65% of Bhutanese report low negative
emotions
•59% of Bhutanese report high positive                       Very                         Moderately
emotions                                                     52%                            40%
•53% of Bhutanese
have sufficiency in
spirituality
                                                   Do you consider Karma in the course of your daily life?
                                                                      Not at all
                                                                        2% Rarely
                                                                                 7%



                                                        Regularly
                                                                                        Occasionally
                                                          57%
                                                                                           34%
Percentage of people who have sufficiency in
                                                       How often do you recite prayers?
          Psychological wellbeing indicators
                                                                         Not at all
    100%
     50%
              53%    59%    65%    83%
                                                                           6%
      0%
                                                                                      Rarely
                                                                                       11%
• 83% of Bhutanese have sufficiency in life
satisfaction
• 65% of Bhutanese report low negative                       Regularly
emotions
•59% of Bhutanese report high positive
                                                               49%
emotions

•   53% of Bhutanese
have sufficiency in                                                                    Occasionally
spirituality                                                                              34%

                                                    How often do you practice meditation?
                                                                                Regularly
                                                          Occasionally             5%
                                                               6%
                                                        Rarely
                                                         7%




                                                                                          Not at all
                                                                                            82%
Domain percentage contribution to GNH index
Lowest contributions
                                                  Health

                    9%          Observation 3:
                                      14%         Ecological diversity and
                                                  resilience
       9%                          Happy
                                                  Psychological wellbeing
                                Bhutanese did
                               not necessarily
                                         12%      Community vitality

10%
                                  have high
                               education (9%).    Living standards


                                                  Time use
                                 Nor did they
                                          12%
            10%
                                 score equally    Cultural diversity and
                                 high in Good     resilience

                  11%             Governance
                                  12%
                                                  Good Governance
                                      (9%).
                                                  Education
0%
                                                                          120%




                                        20%
                                               40%
                                                      60%
                                                             80%
                                                                   100%
                             Value
                            Safety
          Speak native language
                           Family
                         Disability
                   Mental health
             Urbanization issues
         Responsibility towards…
                  Life satisfaction
      Government performance
                     Healthy days
                            Assets
      Self reported health status
                                  health, etc.

                 Ecological issues
                                  sufficiency in




                              Sleep
              Negative emotions
       Community relationship
                                  value, safety, native




             Fundamental rights
                    Artisan skills
                                                                             Percentage of people enjoying sufficiency




                Driglam Namzha
                                  language, family, mental
                                  Bhutanese enjoy highest




                Positive emotions
        Wildlife damage (Rural)
           Political participation
    Household per capita income
                       Spirituality
                           Literacy
                          Housing
      Donations (time & money)
                              Work
                          Services
                        Schooling
           Cultural participation
.




                       Knowledge
0%
               10%
               15%
               25%
               30%
               35%
                                       40%
                                               45%




                 n


                 of
                                         The



               20% in
                         Value
                        Safety
                       Family
                     Disability




                 government
               Mental health
              Life satisfaction




                 politically, and
      Speak native language
     Responsibility towards…




                 of Driglam Namzha.
                 Healthy days
         Urbanization issues

                5% schooling, enjoying

                 services, participating
                 lack sufficiency were



                 ving more than 6 years
                 festivals, donations, ha
                 knowledge, participatio



  Self reported health status
                 happy people still often
                      indicators in which




                 believing in the practice
                         Assets
  Government performance
          Negative emotions
    Wildlife damage (Rural)
                          Sleep
Household per capita income
            Positive emotions
             Ecological issues
                Artisan skills
                       Literacy
         Fundamental rights
   Community relationship
                   Spirituality
                      Housing
                          Work
            Driglam Namzha
                                                     Percentage of people who are happy & have sufficiency




       Political participation
                      Services
                    Schooling
  Donations (time & money)
       Cultural participation
                   Knowledge
Part II:
Understanding Happiness
1.   National happiness
2.   Happiness by Dzongkhag
3.   Happiness by region
4.   Happiness by gender
5.   Happiness by age group
6.   Happiness by marital status
7.   Happiness by educational level
8.   Happiness by occupational group
9.   People’s Stories
GNH Index by dzongkhag (district)
 1

0.9
      0.807 0.795
                  0.783 0.775 0.773 0.771 0.770 0.770
0.8                                                   0.753 0.752 0.737 0.736
                                                                              0.734 0.732
                                                                                            0.712 0.708 0.698 0.698
                                                                                                                    0.684
0.7                                                                                                                         0.655

0.6

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.2

0.1

 0
Confidence intervals of district level GNH indices
 0.9

0.85                                                        Lower boundary
                                                            GNH Index
 0.8
                                                            Upper boundary
0.75

 0.7

0.65

 0.6

0.55

 0.5
Confidence intervals of district level GNH indices
 0.9
                                                         Lower boundary
0.85
                                                         GNH Index
 0.8                                                     Upper boundary
0.75
 0.7
0.65
 0.6
0.55
       The GNH Index is relatively equal. There are not many significant
           differences. A larger sample would give higher definition.
 0.5
Confidence intervals of district level GNH indices
 0.9
                                                       Lower boundary
0.85
                                                       GNH Index
 0.8                                                   Upper boundary
0.75
 0.7
0.65
 0.6      But we might divide
       Dzongkhags into roughly 3
0.55
                groups.
 0.5
GNH Index by Dzongkhags
                                            Samdrup
 0.9
                                       LowerJongkhar
                                            boundary
0.85                                    probably has the
                                       GNH Index
 0.8
                                        lowest GNH Index
                                       Upper boundary
0.75
 0.7
0.65
 0.6
0.55          Higher GNH         Lower GNH
 0.5
GNH index map by district
        GNH Index by district
        GNH Index by district




Low GNH Index
Higher GNH Index                High GNH Index
                                Lower GNH Index
Percentage of happy people by district




Lower GNH Index
Higherpercentage of happy people   Higher percentage
                                   Lower GNH Index of happy people
GNH ranks districts differently than per capita income
                     GNH Index        Per capita Income (BLSSR 2007)
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
 0
GNH ranks districts differently than per capita income
                     GNH Index        Per capita Income (BLSSR 2007)
0.9
  Thimphu is not
0.8
0.7 ranked most
  highly in GNH.
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
 0
GNH ranks districts differently than per capita income
                     GNH Index        Per capita Income (BLSSR 2007)
0.9
                                                Dagana and
  Thimphu is not
0.8
                                               Zhemgang do
0.7 ranked most                                much better in
  highly in GNH.
0.6                                              GNH than
0.5                                               income.
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
 0
Where do the            Trongsa       Pema Gatshel                 Gasa
happy people                            Lhuntse                    Trongsa
live?                       Gasa          Haa                      Pema Gatshel
                                                   Tashi Yangste
                                                  Bumthang         Lhuntse
Thimphu
and Chukha                                        Zhemgang         Haa
                  Thimphu
are home to                                          Punakha       Tashi Yangste
the highest                                                        Bumthang
number of                                              Dagana      Zhemgang
happy                                                              Punakha
people….    Chukha                           Tsirang
                                                                   Dagana
And unhappy                                             Samdrup
people!                                                 Jongkhar   Tsirang
                                                                   Samdrup Jongkhar
               Samtse                                 Wangdue
They are big                                          Phodrang     Wangdue Phodrang
dzongkhags.                                                        Mongar
                    Sarpang                       Mongar
                                                                   Tashigang
                               Paro
Next: Samtse                                                       Paro
                                            Tashigang
& Sarpang
Domain contribution to happiness by Dzongkhag

      Paro
                                                                             Psychological
  Sarpang                                                                    wellbeing
  Dagana
       Haa                                                                   Health
 Thimphu
      Gasa                                                                   Time use
   Tsirang
 Punakha                                                                     Education
Zhemgang
  Chukha
                                                                             Cultural diversity and
 Wangdue…                                                                    resilience
   Samtse
Bumthang                                                                     Good Governance
  Mongar
     Pema…                                                                   Community vitality
Tashigang
  Lhuntse                                                                    Ecological diversity
     Tashi…                                                                  and resilience
  Trongsa
                                                                             Living standards
 Samdrup…

         0%     10%   20%   30%   40%   50%   60%   70%   80%   90%   100%

         The composition of happiness changes a little across
         Dzongkhags. Thimphu is better in education & living
             standards, but worse in community vitality
0.1
                                                     0.2
                                                           0.3
                                                                 0.4
                                                                       0.5
                                                                             0.6
                                                                                   0.7
                                                                                         0.8
                                                                                               0.9




                                           0
                                                                                                     1
                  Life satisfaction
                       Spirituality




                 wellbeing
                Positive emotions




                 Psychological
              Negative emotions
                   Mental health




                  Health
                         Disability
      Self reported health status
                     Healthy days
                              Sleep




             use
             Time
                                                                                                     Paro




                              Work
                             Value
                           Literacy




                   Education
                        Schooling
                       Knowledge
          Speak native language




 and
                Driglam Namzha




 Cultural
 diversity

 resilience
                    Artisan skills
                                                                                                                        Percentage of people having sufficiency




           Cultural participation
                                                                                                     Samdrup Jongkhar




      Government performance




Good
             Fundamental rights




Governance
           Political participation
                          Services
     vitality               Safety
                           Family
     Community




       Community relationship
      Donations (time & money)
             Urbanization issues
      and




                 Ecological issues
      diversity

      resilience
      Ecological




         Responsibility towards…
        Wildlife damage (Rural)
                                                                                                                     and wildlife damage .




                            Assets
                                                                                                                   work time, fundamental




           Household per capita…
                                                                                                               rights, services, income, housing




                          Housing
                                                                                                               Paro and Samdrup differ most in




                               Living
                               standards
Part II:
Understanding Happiness
1.   National happiness
2.   Happiness by Dzongkhag
3.   Happiness by region
4.   Happiness by gender
5.   Happiness by age group
6.   Happiness by marital status
7.   Happiness by educational level
8.   Happiness by occupational group
9.   People’s Stories
GNH Index by region

0.9

0.85
          0.790
 0.8
                          0.737
0.75
                                            0.726
 0.7

 0.65

  0.6

 0.55

  0.5

        Urban
                      National
                                        Rural

                                                    .
Percentage of happy people

                            50% of urban
                         dwellers are happy as
60%       50%              per GNH criteria
50%
                               41%
40%
                                                    37%
30%

20%

 10%

  0%

       Urban
                        National
                                                 Rural



                                                          .
Contribution of domains to happiness by region
   Percentage contribution of domains to GNH Index
                                       Psychological
                                         wellbeing                          In rural areas, Community
                                       15%                                  vitality, Cultural diversity
                                                                              and Good Governance
               Living                                                           contribute more to
                                                              Health
             standards                                                                happiness
                                        10%


 Ecological                              5%
diversity and                                                            Time use              Rural
  resilience                                                                                   Urban
                                         0%
                                                                                               National



    Community
                                                                       Education
      vitality


                                                          Cultural
                       Good                                                         Living
                                                       diversity and
                     Governance                                            standards, Education and
                                                         resilience
                                                                           Health contribute more to
                                                                           happiness in urban areas
                                                                                                           .
0
                             1




                           0.1
                           0.2
                           0.3
                           0.4
                           0.5
                           0.6
                           0.7
                           0.8
                           0.9
           Life satisfaction
        Negative emotions

                                 wellbeing
          Positive emotions      Psychological
                 Spirituality
                  Disability
             Mental health
                                Health




               Healthy days
Self reported health status
                        Sleep
                                 use
                                Time




                        Work
                       Value
                     Literacy
                  Schooling
                                  Education




                Knowledge
    Speak native language
                                and




              Artisan skills
                                Cultural
                                diversity

                                resilience




          Driglam Namzha
     Cultural participation
Government performance
                    Services
                                         Good




       Fundamental rights
                                         Governance




     Political participation
                      Safety
                     Family
                                    vitality
                                                      Percentage of Bhutanese having sufficiency by region




 Community relationship
                                    Community




Donations (time & money)
  Wildlife damage (Rural)
                                and




   Responsibility towards…
                                                           Rural

                                diversity

                                resilience
                                Ecological




           Ecological issues
       Urbanization issues
     Household per capita…
                                                           Urban




                    Housing
                                   Living
                                   standards




                      Assets
0
                                  1




                                0.1
                                0.2
                                0.3
                                0.4
                                0.5
                                0.6
                                0.7
                                0.8
                                0.9
           Life satisfaction
        Negative emotions

                                      wellbeing
          Positive emotions           Psychological
                 Spirituality
                  Disability
             Mental health
                                  Health




               Healthy days
Self reported health status
                        Sleep
                                   use
                                  Time




                        Work
                       Value
                     Literacy
                  Schooling
                                       Education




                Knowledge
    Speak native language
                                  and




              Artisan skills
                                  Cultural
                                  diversity

                                  resilience




          Driglam Namzha
     Cultural participation
Government performance
                    Services
                                              Good




       Fundamental rights
                                              Governance




     Political participation
                      Safety
                     Family
                                         vitality
                                                           Percentage of Bhutanese having sufficiency by region




         Living standards.
         Urban areas have




 Community relationship
        higher sufficiency in
                                         Community




Donations (time & money)
       Health, Education, and




  Wildlife damage (Rural)
                                  and




   Responsibility towards…
                                                                Rural

                                  diversity

                                  resilience
                                  Ecological




           Ecological issues
       Urbanization issues
     Household per capita…
                                                                Urban




                    Housing
                                        Living
                                        standards




                      Assets
0
                             1




                           0.1
                           0.2
                           0.3
                           0.4
                           0.5
                           0.6
                           0.7
                           0.8
                           0.9
           Life satisfaction
        Negative emotions

                                wellbeing
          Positive emotions     Psychological
                 Spirituality
                  Disability
             Mental health
                                                Health




               Healthy days
Self reported health status
                        Sleep
                                                         use
                                                        Time




                        Work
                                              sufficiency in




                       Value
                                        much of Governance.




                     Literacy
                                     Community, Culture, &
                                          Percentage of Bhutanese




                  Schooling
                                                             Education




                Knowledge
    Speak native language
                                                                       and




              Artisan skills
                                                                       Cultural
                                                                       diversity

                                                                       resilience




          Driglam Namzha
     Cultural participation
Government performance
                    Services
                                                                                  Good




       Fundamental rights
                                                                                  Governance




     Political participation
                      Safety
                     Family
                                                                                             vitality
                                     Rural areas have higher having sufficiency by region




 Community relationship
                                                                                             Community




Donations (time & money)
  Wildlife damage (Rural)
                                        and




   Responsibility towards…
                                                                                    Rural

                                        diversity

                                        resilience
                                        Ecological




           Ecological issues
       Urbanization issues
     Household per capita…
                                                                                    Urban




                    Housing
                                                 Living
                                                 standards




                      Assets
Part II:
Understanding Happiness
1.   National happiness
2.   Happiness by Dzongkhag
3.   Happiness by region
4.   Happiness by gender
5.   Happiness by age group
6.   Happiness by marital status
7.   Happiness by educational level
8.   Happiness by occupational group
9.   People’s Stories
GNH Index by gender

0.8

          Men are happier                    0.783
0.78
           than women.
0.76
                            0.737
0.74

0.72        0.704

  0.7

 0.68

 0.66

        Female
                         National
                                          Male
Percentage of happy people

                                               49%
50%
                           41%
45%

40%      33%
35%

30%

25%

20%

15%

10%

5%

0%
      Female           National             Male
Psychological                    Women seem to do
                                    wellbeing                      better in living
                                  16%                              standards and ecology.
                                  14%
          Living standards                               Health
                                  12%
                                  10%
                                   8%
                                   6%
Ecological diversity               4%
                                                                  Time use
  and resilience                   2%                                                    Male
                                   0%
                                                                                         Female


                                                                             Men and women
  Community vitality                                          Education       are about the
                                                                                  same in
                                                                               health, time
                                                  Cultural diversity         use, governance,
                Good Governance
                                                   and resilience              and culture.
0%
                                                        100%




                                                         10%
                                                         20%
                                                         30%
                                                         40%
                                                         60%
                                                         70%
                                                         80%
                                                         90%


                                                         50%
                                    Life satisfaction




             wellbeing
                                  Positive emotions




             Psychological
                                 Negative emotions
                                         Spirituality
                        Self reported health status
                                       Healthy days




              Health
                                           Disability
                                     Mental health
                                               Work
                                                Sleep
                                          Schooling
                                            Literacy




               Education
                                               Value
                                         Knowledge
                                      Artisan skills




and
                             Speak native language




Cultural
diversity

resilience
                              Cultural participation
                                  Driglam Namzha
                        Government performance


       Good
                                Fundamental rights
                                            Services
       Governance            Political participation
                                                                 Percentage Bhutanese having sufficiency by sex




                        Donations (time & money)
                          Community relationship
       vitality




                                             Family
       Community




                                              Safety
                                   Ecological issues
and
                                                               Male




               Responsibility towards environment
diversity

resilience




                           Wildlife damage (Rural)
Ecological




                                Urbanization issues
                                              Assets
                                                               Female




                     Household per capita income
 Living




                                            Housing
 standards
Part II:
Understanding Happiness
1.   National happiness
2.   Happiness by Dzongkhag
3.   Happiness by region
4.   Happiness by gender
5.   Happiness by age group
6.   Happiness by marital status
7.   Happiness by educational level
8.   Happiness by occupational group
9.   People’s Stories
Psychic Happiness level by age group
6.8

6.6                        On a scale of zero to 10, I
                           consider myself: 0 (Not a
                           very happy person)------10
6.4
                           (Very happy person)

6.2

 6

5.8

5.6

5.4

5.2
Age group analysis of GNH Index and Psychic Happiness variable
 0.8

                                        GNH Index          Psychic Happiness
                                                          Happiness level
0.75


 0.7


0.65


 0.6


0.55


 0.5
Part II:
Understanding Happiness
1.   National happiness
2.   Happiness by Dzongkhag
3.   Happiness by region
4.   Happiness by gender
5.   Happiness by age group
6.   Happiness by marital status
7.   Happiness by educational level
8.   Happiness by occupational group
9.   People’s Stories
GNH Index by marital status

             0.791
0.800                     0.747
                                       0.721

0.700                                               0.661
                                                               0.625

0.600

0.500

0.400

0.300

0.200

0.100

0.000
        Never married   Married     Divorced     Separated   Widowed
Percentage of happy people

           50%
50%

45%                     42%
40%                                  36%
35%

30%                                                   27%

25%
                                                               19%
20%

15%

10%

5%

0%
      Never married   Married     Divorced     Separated    Widowed
Contribution to happiness by marital status   Health
100%

90%                                                     Ecological diversity and
                                                        resilience
80%
                                                        Living standards
70%               11%        10%      11%      8%
        12%
60%                                                     Time use
50%
                                                        Psychological wellbeing
40%                          8%
                   9%                 8%       6%
30%     11%
                             13%      11%      12%      Education
                  12%
20%     11%
                  10%        11%      11%      12%
10%      8%                                             Community vitality

 0%
                                                        Cultural diversity and
       Never     Married   Divorced Separated Widowed
                                                        resilience
       married
                                                        Good Governance
Part II:
Understanding Happiness
1.   National happiness
2.   Happiness by Dzongkhag
3.   Happiness by region
4.   Happiness by gender
5.   Happiness by age group
6.   Happiness by marital status
7.   Happiness by educational level
8.   Happiness by occupational group
9.   People’s Stories
GNH Index and percentage of happy people by educational
                              level
                     Percentage of happy people   GNH Index
  1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
  0
Contribution of domains to happiness
100%
 90%                                          Living standards
 80%
 70%                                          Ecological diversity and
                                              resilience
 60%
 50%                                          Community vitality
 40%
 30%                                          Good Governance
 20%
 10%                                          Cultural diversity and
  0%                                          resilience
                                              Education

                                              Time use

                                              Health

                                              Psychological wellbeing
As education increases, contribution of
                                          living standards & education to
  Contribution of domains to happiness happiness increases; governance and
100%                                              culture decrease
90%                                                       Living standards
80%
70%                                                       Ecological diversity and
                                                          resilience
60%
50%                                                       Community vitality
40%
30%                                                       Good Governance
20%
10%                                                       Cultural diversity and
 0%                                                       resilience
                                                          Education

                                                          Time use

                                                          Health

                                                          Psychological wellbeing
Part II:
Understanding Happiness
1.   National happiness
2.   Happiness by Dzongkhag
3.   Happiness by region
4.   Happiness by gender
5.   Happiness by age group
6.   Happiness by marital status
7.   Happiness by educational level
8.   Happiness by occupational group
9.   People’s Stories
GNH Index and percentage of happy people by occupational status

                         Percentage of happy people   GNH Index
  1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
  0
Contribution of domains to happiness
100%                                          Living standards
 90%
 80%
                                              Ecological diversity
 70%
                                              and resilience
 60%
                                              Community vitality
 50%
 40%
                                              Good Governance
 30%
 20%
 10%                                          Cultural diversity
  0%                                          and resilience
                                              Education

                                              Time use

                                              Health

                                              Psychological
                                              wellbeing
Part II:
Understanding Happiness
1.   National happiness
2.   Happiness by Dzongkhag
3.   Happiness by region
4.   Happiness by gender
5.   Happiness by age group
6.   Happiness by marital status
7.   Happiness by educational level
8.   Happiness by occupational group
9.   People’s Stories
Who is Happy?
     Some real people

(minor details have been changed)
One happy person in
                     the GNH survey was a
                     married woman aged 35
                     living in rural Haa. She is
a housewife who has completed primary
school. Again, she achieved sufficiency in
over 90% of the domains. She said she still
suffered from selfishness and jealousy, and did
not donate very much time/money. She was
concerned about littering and the absence of
good waste disposal, as well as floods, and did
not know any zorig chosum skill.
When asked what contributed most
to her happiness she said:

           •   Having sufficient income
           •   Being in good relation with
               the husband
           •   When everyone is in good
               health.
Another happy person
in             the GNH survey was a
               young man aged 22
               who lived in rural
               Sarpang and was
never married. He is a farmer who
finished primary school. His only
deprivations were that wildlife
damaged his crops, and that he did
not know about his political rights.
When asked what contributed most
to happiness he said:

              •   A peaceful environment
              •   Enough money
              •   No suffering
              •   Good health
              •   Good relations with my
                  friends.
Another happy person in
                       the GNH survey was a
                       widowed gomchen aged
70 living in rural Thimphu. He had no formal
education, and was deprived in
education, housing, sleep and did not
participate politically.

He observed that getting good agricultural
products from the land contributes to
happiness.
Another happy person in
                      the GNH survey was a
                      married woman farmer
aged 44 living in rural Tongsa. She was
illiterate, and was deprived from wildlife
damage to her crops, and thought she never
felt forgiveness among the positive emotions –
yet was happy.

She mused that she felt happy when she was
able to do her household work, when she was
harvesting potatoes, and as she wove.
Another happy person in
                      the GNH survey was a
                      married shopkeeper aged
                      37 living in urban
Bumthang. He has finished 10th class, and
meditates and prays regularly. He enjoys
sufficiency in nearly every indicator. But he
did mention that at the moment he only rarely
experiences calmness and contentment. He
also lacked some knowledge and did not think
Driglam Namzha was terribly important.
Another happy person in
                the GNH survey was
                a married corporate
employee aged 35 living in urban
Chukha. He has completed 10th
class, and has achieved sufficiency in
nearly all indicators. He was a bit sleep
deprived, and did not feel a deep sense
of belonging to his community, but was
overall very satisfied with his life.
When asked what contributed most
to happiness he said:

           • To be healthy
           • To meet basic needs
           • To have peace in the
             family
           • To be religious
Our final happy person in
                the GNH survey is
                an unmarried young
                woman aged 26 living in
urban Tashigang. She completed a
bachelor’s degree and is a civil servant
living alone. She scores highly across
domains, although she misses a sense of
belonging. When asked what contributes
to her happiness she replied:
Love, Family, Friends, Education, and
Enough money.
The 2010 Gross National
Happiness Index : Part II




    The Centre for Bhutan Studies
                2011
                                    .

More Related Content

Viewers also liked (16)

Par1
Par1Par1
Par1
 
Sj1
Sj1Sj1
Sj1
 
Lhu1
Lhu1Lhu1
Lhu1
 
Bum1
Bum1Bum1
Bum1
 
Chu1
Chu1Chu1
Chu1
 
Haa1
Haa1Haa1
Haa1
 
Tro1
Tro1Tro1
Tro1
 
Part 3 2
Part 3 2Part 3 2
Part 3 2
 
Ty1
Ty1Ty1
Ty1
 
Sam1
Sam1Sam1
Sam1
 
Mon1
Mon1Mon1
Mon1
 
Pem1
Pem1Pem1
Pem1
 
Gas1
Gas1Gas1
Gas1
 
Pun1
Pun1Pun1
Pun1
 
Zhe1
Zhe1Zhe1
Zhe1
 
Tpu1
Tpu1Tpu1
Tpu1
 

Similar to Bhutan 2010 gnh_index_2

Official List2008 M D Gindicators
Official List2008 M D GindicatorsOfficial List2008 M D Gindicators
Official List2008 M D GindicatorsBirendra Raturi
 
National programme for elderly final
National programme for elderly finalNational programme for elderly final
National programme for elderly finalMadhuri Bind
 
2012 ific food and health survey report of findings (for website)
2012 ific food and health survey report of findings (for website)2012 ific food and health survey report of findings (for website)
2012 ific food and health survey report of findings (for website)watsonphindy
 
Burden disease among elder person
  Burden disease among elder person  Burden disease among elder person
Burden disease among elder personDR HARDEV SINGH
 
Public health frame and approach to the prevention of child maltreatment
Public health frame and approach to the prevention of child maltreatmentPublic health frame and approach to the prevention of child maltreatment
Public health frame and approach to the prevention of child maltreatmentCasey Family Programs
 
Residential characteristic on the association between oral hygiene and body m...
Residential characteristic on the association between oral hygiene and body m...Residential characteristic on the association between oral hygiene and body m...
Residential characteristic on the association between oral hygiene and body m...UniversitasGadjahMada
 

Similar to Bhutan 2010 gnh_index_2 (10)

Bhutan 2010 gnh_index_3
Bhutan 2010 gnh_index_3Bhutan 2010 gnh_index_3
Bhutan 2010 gnh_index_3
 
Bhutan 2010 GNH_Index_3
Bhutan 2010 GNH_Index_3Bhutan 2010 GNH_Index_3
Bhutan 2010 GNH_Index_3
 
Millenium Development Goals
Millenium Development GoalsMillenium Development Goals
Millenium Development Goals
 
Family medicine in the arab world2 1
Family medicine in the arab world2 1Family medicine in the arab world2 1
Family medicine in the arab world2 1
 
Official List2008 M D Gindicators
Official List2008 M D GindicatorsOfficial List2008 M D Gindicators
Official List2008 M D Gindicators
 
National programme for elderly final
National programme for elderly finalNational programme for elderly final
National programme for elderly final
 
2012 ific food and health survey report of findings (for website)
2012 ific food and health survey report of findings (for website)2012 ific food and health survey report of findings (for website)
2012 ific food and health survey report of findings (for website)
 
Burden disease among elder person
  Burden disease among elder person  Burden disease among elder person
Burden disease among elder person
 
Public health frame and approach to the prevention of child maltreatment
Public health frame and approach to the prevention of child maltreatmentPublic health frame and approach to the prevention of child maltreatment
Public health frame and approach to the prevention of child maltreatment
 
Residential characteristic on the association between oral hygiene and body m...
Residential characteristic on the association between oral hygiene and body m...Residential characteristic on the association between oral hygiene and body m...
Residential characteristic on the association between oral hygiene and body m...
 

More from Centre for Bhutan Studies (6)

Wan1
Wan1Wan1
Wan1
 
Haa1
Haa1Haa1
Haa1
 
Pol&pro scr tools
Pol&pro scr toolsPol&pro scr tools
Pol&pro scr tools
 
Trashiyangtse GNH 2011 Results
Trashiyangtse GNH 2011 ResultsTrashiyangtse GNH 2011 Results
Trashiyangtse GNH 2011 Results
 
Tsirang 2011 GNH Results
Tsirang 2011 GNH ResultsTsirang 2011 GNH Results
Tsirang 2011 GNH Results
 
Trongsa GNH 2011 Results
Trongsa GNH 2011 ResultsTrongsa GNH 2011 Results
Trongsa GNH 2011 Results
 

Recently uploaded

BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptx
BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptxBERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptx
BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptxseri bangash
 
💕📲09602870969💓Girl Escort Services Udaipur Call Girls in Chittorgarh Haldighati
💕📲09602870969💓Girl Escort Services Udaipur Call Girls in Chittorgarh Haldighati💕📲09602870969💓Girl Escort Services Udaipur Call Girls in Chittorgarh Haldighati
💕📲09602870969💓Girl Escort Services Udaipur Call Girls in Chittorgarh HaldighatiApsara Of India
 
Genesis 1:6 || Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
Genesis 1:6  ||  Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verseGenesis 1:6  ||  Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
Genesis 1:6 || Meditate the Scripture daily verse by versemaricelcanoynuay
 
DARK TRAVEL AGENCY presented by Khuda Bux
DARK TRAVEL AGENCY presented by Khuda BuxDARK TRAVEL AGENCY presented by Khuda Bux
DARK TRAVEL AGENCY presented by Khuda BuxBeEducate
 
Study Consultants in Lahore || 📞03094429236
Study Consultants in Lahore || 📞03094429236Study Consultants in Lahore || 📞03094429236
Study Consultants in Lahore || 📞03094429236Sherazi Tours
 
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyHire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyNitya salvi
 
How to Get Unpublished Flight Deals and Discounts?
How to Get Unpublished Flight Deals and Discounts?How to Get Unpublished Flight Deals and Discounts?
How to Get Unpublished Flight Deals and Discounts?FlyFairTravels
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking MenDelhi Call girls
 
visa consultant | 📞📞 03094429236 || Best Study Visa Consultant
visa consultant | 📞📞 03094429236 || Best Study Visa Consultantvisa consultant | 📞📞 03094429236 || Best Study Visa Consultant
visa consultant | 📞📞 03094429236 || Best Study Visa ConsultantSherazi Tours
 
🔥HOT🔥📲9602870969🔥Prostitute Service in Udaipur Call Girls in City Palace Lake...
🔥HOT🔥📲9602870969🔥Prostitute Service in Udaipur Call Girls in City Palace Lake...🔥HOT🔥📲9602870969🔥Prostitute Service in Udaipur Call Girls in City Palace Lake...
🔥HOT🔥📲9602870969🔥Prostitute Service in Udaipur Call Girls in City Palace Lake...Apsara Of India
 
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdf
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdfbest weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdf
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdftour guide
 
Visa Consultant in Lahore || 📞03094429236
Visa Consultant in Lahore || 📞03094429236Visa Consultant in Lahore || 📞03094429236
Visa Consultant in Lahore || 📞03094429236Sherazi Tours
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Bhikaji Cama Palace Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Bhikaji Cama Palace Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Bhikaji Cama Palace Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Bhikaji Cama Palace Women Seeking MenDelhi Call girls
 
9 Days Kenya Ultimate Safari Odyssey with Kibera Holiday Safaris
9 Days Kenya Ultimate Safari Odyssey with Kibera Holiday Safaris9 Days Kenya Ultimate Safari Odyssey with Kibera Holiday Safaris
9 Days Kenya Ultimate Safari Odyssey with Kibera Holiday SafarisKibera Holiday Safaris Safaris
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Delhi Call girls
 
char Dham yatra, Uttarakhand tourism.pptx
char Dham yatra, Uttarakhand tourism.pptxchar Dham yatra, Uttarakhand tourism.pptx
char Dham yatra, Uttarakhand tourism.pptxpalakdigital7
 

Recently uploaded (20)

BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptx
BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptxBERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptx
BERMUDA Triangle the mystery of life.pptx
 
💕📲09602870969💓Girl Escort Services Udaipur Call Girls in Chittorgarh Haldighati
💕📲09602870969💓Girl Escort Services Udaipur Call Girls in Chittorgarh Haldighati💕📲09602870969💓Girl Escort Services Udaipur Call Girls in Chittorgarh Haldighati
💕📲09602870969💓Girl Escort Services Udaipur Call Girls in Chittorgarh Haldighati
 
Genesis 1:6 || Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
Genesis 1:6  ||  Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verseGenesis 1:6  ||  Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
Genesis 1:6 || Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
 
DARK TRAVEL AGENCY presented by Khuda Bux
DARK TRAVEL AGENCY presented by Khuda BuxDARK TRAVEL AGENCY presented by Khuda Bux
DARK TRAVEL AGENCY presented by Khuda Bux
 
Study Consultants in Lahore || 📞03094429236
Study Consultants in Lahore || 📞03094429236Study Consultants in Lahore || 📞03094429236
Study Consultants in Lahore || 📞03094429236
 
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls AgencyHire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
Hire 💕 8617697112 Champawat Call Girls Service Call Girls Agency
 
Call Girls Service !! Indirapuram!! @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance VVVIP 🍎 S...
Call Girls Service !! Indirapuram!! @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance  VVVIP 🍎 S...Call Girls Service !! Indirapuram!! @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance  VVVIP 🍎 S...
Call Girls Service !! Indirapuram!! @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance VVVIP 🍎 S...
 
How to Get Unpublished Flight Deals and Discounts?
How to Get Unpublished Flight Deals and Discounts?How to Get Unpublished Flight Deals and Discounts?
How to Get Unpublished Flight Deals and Discounts?
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Chhattarpur Women Seeking Men
 
visa consultant | 📞📞 03094429236 || Best Study Visa Consultant
visa consultant | 📞📞 03094429236 || Best Study Visa Consultantvisa consultant | 📞📞 03094429236 || Best Study Visa Consultant
visa consultant | 📞📞 03094429236 || Best Study Visa Consultant
 
🔥HOT🔥📲9602870969🔥Prostitute Service in Udaipur Call Girls in City Palace Lake...
🔥HOT🔥📲9602870969🔥Prostitute Service in Udaipur Call Girls in City Palace Lake...🔥HOT🔥📲9602870969🔥Prostitute Service in Udaipur Call Girls in City Palace Lake...
🔥HOT🔥📲9602870969🔥Prostitute Service in Udaipur Call Girls in City Palace Lake...
 
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdf
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdfbest weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdf
best weekend places near delhi where you should visit.pdf
 
Visa Consultant in Lahore || 📞03094429236
Visa Consultant in Lahore || 📞03094429236Visa Consultant in Lahore || 📞03094429236
Visa Consultant in Lahore || 📞03094429236
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Bhikaji Cama Palace Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Bhikaji Cama Palace Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Bhikaji Cama Palace Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Bhikaji Cama Palace Women Seeking Men
 
Call Girls Service !! New Friends Colony!! @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance VV...
Call Girls Service !! New Friends Colony!! @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance  VV...Call Girls Service !! New Friends Colony!! @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance  VV...
Call Girls Service !! New Friends Colony!! @9999965857 Delhi 🫦 No Advance VV...
 
9 Days Kenya Ultimate Safari Odyssey with Kibera Holiday Safaris
9 Days Kenya Ultimate Safari Odyssey with Kibera Holiday Safaris9 Days Kenya Ultimate Safari Odyssey with Kibera Holiday Safaris
9 Days Kenya Ultimate Safari Odyssey with Kibera Holiday Safaris
 
Call Girls 🫤 Connaught Place ➡️ 9999965857 ➡️ Delhi 🫦 Russian Escorts FULL ...
Call Girls 🫤 Connaught Place ➡️ 9999965857  ➡️ Delhi 🫦  Russian Escorts FULL ...Call Girls 🫤 Connaught Place ➡️ 9999965857  ➡️ Delhi 🫦  Russian Escorts FULL ...
Call Girls 🫤 Connaught Place ➡️ 9999965857 ➡️ Delhi 🫦 Russian Escorts FULL ...
 
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
Night 7k Call Girls Noida Sector 93 Escorts Call Me: 8448380779
 
Rohini Sector 18 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
Rohini Sector 18 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No AdvanceRohini Sector 18 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
Rohini Sector 18 Call Girls Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Saikh No Advance
 
char Dham yatra, Uttarakhand tourism.pptx
char Dham yatra, Uttarakhand tourism.pptxchar Dham yatra, Uttarakhand tourism.pptx
char Dham yatra, Uttarakhand tourism.pptx
 

Bhutan 2010 gnh_index_2

  • 1. The 2010 Gross National Happiness Index : Part II The Centre for Bhutan Studies 2011 .
  • 2. Part II: Understanding Happiness 1. National happiness 2. Happiness by Dzongkhag 3. Happiness by region 4. Happiness by gender 5. Happiness by age group 6. Happiness by marital status 7. Happiness by educational level 8. Happiness by occupational group 9. People’s Stories
  • 3. Part II: Understanding Happiness 1. National happiness 2. Happiness by Dzongkhag 3. Happiness by region 4. Happiness by gender 5. Happiness by age group 6. Happiness by marital status 7. Happiness by educational level 8. Happiness by occupational group 9. People’s Stories
  • 4. A person who has achieved sufficiency in at least 6 of the 9 domains of GNH is classified as “HAPPY”
  • 5. How is happiness measured? 33 indicators: Sufficiency thresholds Nine domains: Happiness threshold GNH Index: 0.743
  • 6. 40.8% of Bhutanese are classified happy after applying sufficiency and happy threshold. The value for GNH Index 2010 is 0.743 .
  • 7. Proportion of people non-deprived/happy 77% Domains: Psychological 74% wellbeing, Health, Time 80% use, Culture, Ecology, Community vitality, Good Governance and 70% Living standards 60% 41% 50% Domains: Indicator: Health, Edu Consumption 40% per capita cation and Living 30% Standards 20% 10% 0% National Poverty line Multidimensional Gross National 2007 Poverty Index 2010 Happiness Index 2010 .
  • 8. In which domainscontribution to GNH index enjoy sufficiency? Domain percentage do happy people Health 9% 14% Ecological diversity and resilience 9% Psychological wellbeing 12% Community vitality 10% Living standards Time use 12% 10% Cultural diversity and resilience Good Governance 11% 12% Education
  • 9. In which domainscontribution to GNH index enjoy sufficiency? Domain percentage do happy people Health 9% Observation 1: 14% Ecological diversity and resilience 9% All nine Psychological wellbeing dimensions 12% contributevitality Community to 10% GNH. Living standards Happy people Time use 12% live relatively 10% balanced diversity and Cultural lives. resilience 11% 12% No dimension Good Governance is unimportant Education
  • 10. Domain percentage contribution to GNH index Biggest contributions Health 9% 14% Ecological diversity and Observation 2: resilience 9% Good Health (14%) Psychological wellbeing Community (12%) 12% Community vitality 10% Ecology (12%), and Living standards Psychological well- Time use 12% being (12%) 10% Cultural diversity and resilience Contribute the most to GNH in Good Governance 11% 12% 2010. Education
  • 11. Biggest contributionsHealth Domain percentage contribution to GNH index Percentage of people enjoying sufficiency Ecological in indicators of Health diversity and Observation 2: 9% 9% 14% resilience Psychological 89% 86% Good Health (14%) wellbeing 90% 76% 74% Community Community 80% (12%) 12% vitality 70% Ecology Living standards 60% (12%), and 12% 50% 10% Psychological Time use 40% 10% well-being (12%)12% 30% Contribute the 20% Cultural diversity 11% most to GNH in and resilience 10% 2010. 0% Good Governance Disability Mental health Healthy days Self reported health status • 89% of Bhutanese either do not suffer from long term disability or those who are disable ones are not restricted from doing their daily activities • 86% of Bhutanese have normal mental wellbeing • 76% of Bhutanese have sufficient number of healthy days • 74% of Bhutanese have rated their health as either “good” or “very good”
  • 12. Percentage of people enjoying sufficiency in Health Percentage of people enjoying sufficiency and are happy in indicators of Health 89% 86% 100% 76% 74% 80% 39% 39% 60% 40% 40% 20% 0% 38% Disability Mental Healthy health Self days reported 36% health 36% 35% status • 89% of Bhutanese either do not suffer from 34% long term disability or those who are disable ones are not restricted from doing their daily 32% activities • 86% of Bhutanese have normal mental Disability Mental health Healthy days Self reported wellbeing health status • 76% of Bhutanese have sufficient number of health days • 74% of Bhutanese have rated their health as • Of the Bhutanese who achieved sufficiency levels in either “good” or “very good” disability, 39% are happy (fulfill the happiness threshold) • Of the Bhutanese who have normal mental wellbeing (86), 39% are happy • Of the Bhutanese who have achieved sufficient levels of healthy days, 36% are happy • Of the Bhutanese who have sufficiency in self reported health status , 35% are happy
  • 13. Biggest percentage Health Domain contributions to GNH contribution Percentage of people having sufficiency in index Ecological diversity and indicators of Community vitality resilience 9% Observation 2: 9% Psychological Good Health 14% wellbeing 93% 96% (14%) Community 100% Community 12% vitality 90% (12%) 12% Living standards 80% 63% Ecology 70% 46% (12%), and 10% Time use 60% 10%Psychological well-being 50% (12%) Cultural diversity 11% 12% and resilience 40% Contribute the 30% most to GNH in Good 2010. Governance 20% 10% 0% Donations (time Community Family Safety & money) relationship • 96% of Bhutanese have never been victims of crime • 93% of Bhutanese report good family relationship • 76% of Bhutanese report good community relationship • 46% of Bhutanese have sufficiency in donations (time & money)
  • 14. Biggest percentage Health Domain contributions to GNH contribution Percentage of people who are happy & have index 9% Ecological diversity and sufficiency in indicators of Community vitality resilience 9%Observation 2: Psychological Good Health 14% wellbeing 39% 40% (14%) Community 40% Community 12% vitality 27% (12%) Living 30% 21% Ecology standards (12%), and 10% Time use 20% Psychological 10% well-being 11% (12%) 12% Cultural 10% diversity and Contribute the resilience most to GNH in 12% Good 0% 2010. Governance Donations Community Family Safety (time & relationship money) • 39% of Bhutanese who report good family relationship are happy • 27% of Bhutanese who have good community relationship are happy • 21% of Bhutanese who have sufficiency in donations (time & money) are also classified happy
  • 15. Biggest percentage Health Domain Percentage of people who have sufficiency in contributions to GNH contribution index Ecological Psychological wellbeing indicators diversity and resilience 9% Observation 2: 9% Psychological Good Health 14% wellbeing 83% (14%) Community 90% Community 12% vitality 80% 65% (12%) Living standards 70% 59% Ecology 12% 53% (12%), and 60% 10% Time use 10%Psychological 50% well-being (12%) Cultural diversity 40% 11% 12% and resilience Contribute the 30% most to GNH in Good 2010. Governance 20% 10% 0% Spirituality Positive Negative Life emotions emotions satisfaction • 83% of Bhutanese have sufficiency in life satisfaction • 65% of Bhutanese report low negative emotions •59% of Bhutanese report high positive emotions • Only 53% of Bhutanese have sufficiency in spirituality
  • 16. Percentage of people who have sufficiency in How spiritual do you consider yourself to be? Psychological wellbeing indicators 83% 100% 50% 53% 59% 65% Not at all Somewhat 0% 1% 7% • 83% of Bhutanese have sufficiency in life satisfaction • 65% of Bhutanese report low negative emotions •59% of Bhutanese report high positive Very Moderately emotions 52% 40% •53% of Bhutanese have sufficiency in spirituality Do you consider Karma in the course of your daily life? Not at all 2% Rarely 7% Regularly Occasionally 57% 34%
  • 17. Percentage of people who have sufficiency in How often do you recite prayers? Psychological wellbeing indicators Not at all 100% 50% 53% 59% 65% 83% 6% 0% Rarely 11% • 83% of Bhutanese have sufficiency in life satisfaction • 65% of Bhutanese report low negative Regularly emotions •59% of Bhutanese report high positive 49% emotions • 53% of Bhutanese have sufficiency in Occasionally spirituality 34% How often do you practice meditation? Regularly Occasionally 5% 6% Rarely 7% Not at all 82%
  • 18. Domain percentage contribution to GNH index Lowest contributions Health 9% Observation 3: 14% Ecological diversity and resilience 9% Happy Psychological wellbeing Bhutanese did not necessarily 12% Community vitality 10% have high education (9%). Living standards Time use Nor did they 12% 10% score equally Cultural diversity and high in Good resilience 11% Governance 12% Good Governance (9%). Education
  • 19. 0% 120% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Value Safety Speak native language Family Disability Mental health Urbanization issues Responsibility towards… Life satisfaction Government performance Healthy days Assets Self reported health status health, etc. Ecological issues sufficiency in Sleep Negative emotions Community relationship value, safety, native Fundamental rights Artisan skills Percentage of people enjoying sufficiency Driglam Namzha language, family, mental Bhutanese enjoy highest Positive emotions Wildlife damage (Rural) Political participation Household per capita income Spirituality Literacy Housing Donations (time & money) Work Services Schooling Cultural participation . Knowledge
  • 20. 0% 10% 15% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% n of The 20% in Value Safety Family Disability government Mental health Life satisfaction politically, and Speak native language Responsibility towards… of Driglam Namzha. Healthy days Urbanization issues 5% schooling, enjoying services, participating lack sufficiency were ving more than 6 years festivals, donations, ha knowledge, participatio Self reported health status happy people still often indicators in which believing in the practice Assets Government performance Negative emotions Wildlife damage (Rural) Sleep Household per capita income Positive emotions Ecological issues Artisan skills Literacy Fundamental rights Community relationship Spirituality Housing Work Driglam Namzha Percentage of people who are happy & have sufficiency Political participation Services Schooling Donations (time & money) Cultural participation Knowledge
  • 21. Part II: Understanding Happiness 1. National happiness 2. Happiness by Dzongkhag 3. Happiness by region 4. Happiness by gender 5. Happiness by age group 6. Happiness by marital status 7. Happiness by educational level 8. Happiness by occupational group 9. People’s Stories
  • 22. GNH Index by dzongkhag (district) 1 0.9 0.807 0.795 0.783 0.775 0.773 0.771 0.770 0.770 0.8 0.753 0.752 0.737 0.736 0.734 0.732 0.712 0.708 0.698 0.698 0.684 0.7 0.655 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0
  • 23. Confidence intervals of district level GNH indices 0.9 0.85 Lower boundary GNH Index 0.8 Upper boundary 0.75 0.7 0.65 0.6 0.55 0.5
  • 24. Confidence intervals of district level GNH indices 0.9 Lower boundary 0.85 GNH Index 0.8 Upper boundary 0.75 0.7 0.65 0.6 0.55 The GNH Index is relatively equal. There are not many significant differences. A larger sample would give higher definition. 0.5
  • 25. Confidence intervals of district level GNH indices 0.9 Lower boundary 0.85 GNH Index 0.8 Upper boundary 0.75 0.7 0.65 0.6 But we might divide Dzongkhags into roughly 3 0.55 groups. 0.5
  • 26. GNH Index by Dzongkhags Samdrup 0.9 LowerJongkhar boundary 0.85 probably has the GNH Index 0.8 lowest GNH Index Upper boundary 0.75 0.7 0.65 0.6 0.55 Higher GNH Lower GNH 0.5
  • 27. GNH index map by district GNH Index by district GNH Index by district Low GNH Index Higher GNH Index High GNH Index Lower GNH Index
  • 28. Percentage of happy people by district Lower GNH Index Higherpercentage of happy people Higher percentage Lower GNH Index of happy people
  • 29. GNH ranks districts differently than per capita income GNH Index Per capita Income (BLSSR 2007) 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0
  • 30. GNH ranks districts differently than per capita income GNH Index Per capita Income (BLSSR 2007) 0.9 Thimphu is not 0.8 0.7 ranked most highly in GNH. 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0
  • 31. GNH ranks districts differently than per capita income GNH Index Per capita Income (BLSSR 2007) 0.9 Dagana and Thimphu is not 0.8 Zhemgang do 0.7 ranked most much better in highly in GNH. 0.6 GNH than 0.5 income. 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0
  • 32. Where do the Trongsa Pema Gatshel Gasa happy people Lhuntse Trongsa live? Gasa Haa Pema Gatshel Tashi Yangste Bumthang Lhuntse Thimphu and Chukha Zhemgang Haa Thimphu are home to Punakha Tashi Yangste the highest Bumthang number of Dagana Zhemgang happy Punakha people…. Chukha Tsirang Dagana And unhappy Samdrup people! Jongkhar Tsirang Samdrup Jongkhar Samtse Wangdue They are big Phodrang Wangdue Phodrang dzongkhags. Mongar Sarpang Mongar Tashigang Paro Next: Samtse Paro Tashigang & Sarpang
  • 33. Domain contribution to happiness by Dzongkhag Paro Psychological Sarpang wellbeing Dagana Haa Health Thimphu Gasa Time use Tsirang Punakha Education Zhemgang Chukha Cultural diversity and Wangdue… resilience Samtse Bumthang Good Governance Mongar Pema… Community vitality Tashigang Lhuntse Ecological diversity Tashi… and resilience Trongsa Living standards Samdrup… 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% The composition of happiness changes a little across Dzongkhags. Thimphu is better in education & living standards, but worse in community vitality
  • 34. 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 0 1 Life satisfaction Spirituality wellbeing Positive emotions Psychological Negative emotions Mental health Health Disability Self reported health status Healthy days Sleep use Time Paro Work Value Literacy Education Schooling Knowledge Speak native language and Driglam Namzha Cultural diversity resilience Artisan skills Percentage of people having sufficiency Cultural participation Samdrup Jongkhar Government performance Good Fundamental rights Governance Political participation Services vitality Safety Family Community Community relationship Donations (time & money) Urbanization issues and Ecological issues diversity resilience Ecological Responsibility towards… Wildlife damage (Rural) and wildlife damage . Assets work time, fundamental Household per capita… rights, services, income, housing Housing Paro and Samdrup differ most in Living standards
  • 35. Part II: Understanding Happiness 1. National happiness 2. Happiness by Dzongkhag 3. Happiness by region 4. Happiness by gender 5. Happiness by age group 6. Happiness by marital status 7. Happiness by educational level 8. Happiness by occupational group 9. People’s Stories
  • 36. GNH Index by region 0.9 0.85 0.790 0.8 0.737 0.75 0.726 0.7 0.65 0.6 0.55 0.5 Urban National Rural .
  • 37. Percentage of happy people 50% of urban dwellers are happy as 60% 50% per GNH criteria 50% 41% 40% 37% 30% 20% 10% 0% Urban National Rural .
  • 38. Contribution of domains to happiness by region Percentage contribution of domains to GNH Index Psychological wellbeing In rural areas, Community 15% vitality, Cultural diversity and Good Governance Living contribute more to Health standards happiness 10% Ecological 5% diversity and Time use Rural resilience Urban 0% National Community Education vitality Cultural Good Living diversity and Governance standards, Education and resilience Health contribute more to happiness in urban areas .
  • 39. 0 1 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 Life satisfaction Negative emotions wellbeing Positive emotions Psychological Spirituality Disability Mental health Health Healthy days Self reported health status Sleep use Time Work Value Literacy Schooling Education Knowledge Speak native language and Artisan skills Cultural diversity resilience Driglam Namzha Cultural participation Government performance Services Good Fundamental rights Governance Political participation Safety Family vitality Percentage of Bhutanese having sufficiency by region Community relationship Community Donations (time & money) Wildlife damage (Rural) and Responsibility towards… Rural diversity resilience Ecological Ecological issues Urbanization issues Household per capita… Urban Housing Living standards Assets
  • 40. 0 1 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 Life satisfaction Negative emotions wellbeing Positive emotions Psychological Spirituality Disability Mental health Health Healthy days Self reported health status Sleep use Time Work Value Literacy Schooling Education Knowledge Speak native language and Artisan skills Cultural diversity resilience Driglam Namzha Cultural participation Government performance Services Good Fundamental rights Governance Political participation Safety Family vitality Percentage of Bhutanese having sufficiency by region Living standards. Urban areas have Community relationship higher sufficiency in Community Donations (time & money) Health, Education, and Wildlife damage (Rural) and Responsibility towards… Rural diversity resilience Ecological Ecological issues Urbanization issues Household per capita… Urban Housing Living standards Assets
  • 41. 0 1 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 Life satisfaction Negative emotions wellbeing Positive emotions Psychological Spirituality Disability Mental health Health Healthy days Self reported health status Sleep use Time Work sufficiency in Value much of Governance. Literacy Community, Culture, & Percentage of Bhutanese Schooling Education Knowledge Speak native language and Artisan skills Cultural diversity resilience Driglam Namzha Cultural participation Government performance Services Good Fundamental rights Governance Political participation Safety Family vitality Rural areas have higher having sufficiency by region Community relationship Community Donations (time & money) Wildlife damage (Rural) and Responsibility towards… Rural diversity resilience Ecological Ecological issues Urbanization issues Household per capita… Urban Housing Living standards Assets
  • 42. Part II: Understanding Happiness 1. National happiness 2. Happiness by Dzongkhag 3. Happiness by region 4. Happiness by gender 5. Happiness by age group 6. Happiness by marital status 7. Happiness by educational level 8. Happiness by occupational group 9. People’s Stories
  • 43. GNH Index by gender 0.8 Men are happier 0.783 0.78 than women. 0.76 0.737 0.74 0.72 0.704 0.7 0.68 0.66 Female National Male
  • 44. Percentage of happy people 49% 50% 41% 45% 40% 33% 35% 30% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% Female National Male
  • 45. Psychological Women seem to do wellbeing better in living 16% standards and ecology. 14% Living standards Health 12% 10% 8% 6% Ecological diversity 4% Time use and resilience 2% Male 0% Female Men and women Community vitality Education are about the same in health, time Cultural diversity use, governance, Good Governance and resilience and culture.
  • 46. 0% 100% 10% 20% 30% 40% 60% 70% 80% 90% 50% Life satisfaction wellbeing Positive emotions Psychological Negative emotions Spirituality Self reported health status Healthy days Health Disability Mental health Work Sleep Schooling Literacy Education Value Knowledge Artisan skills and Speak native language Cultural diversity resilience Cultural participation Driglam Namzha Government performance Good Fundamental rights Services Governance Political participation Percentage Bhutanese having sufficiency by sex Donations (time & money) Community relationship vitality Family Community Safety Ecological issues and Male Responsibility towards environment diversity resilience Wildlife damage (Rural) Ecological Urbanization issues Assets Female Household per capita income Living Housing standards
  • 47. Part II: Understanding Happiness 1. National happiness 2. Happiness by Dzongkhag 3. Happiness by region 4. Happiness by gender 5. Happiness by age group 6. Happiness by marital status 7. Happiness by educational level 8. Happiness by occupational group 9. People’s Stories
  • 48. Psychic Happiness level by age group 6.8 6.6 On a scale of zero to 10, I consider myself: 0 (Not a very happy person)------10 6.4 (Very happy person) 6.2 6 5.8 5.6 5.4 5.2
  • 49. Age group analysis of GNH Index and Psychic Happiness variable 0.8 GNH Index Psychic Happiness Happiness level 0.75 0.7 0.65 0.6 0.55 0.5
  • 50. Part II: Understanding Happiness 1. National happiness 2. Happiness by Dzongkhag 3. Happiness by region 4. Happiness by gender 5. Happiness by age group 6. Happiness by marital status 7. Happiness by educational level 8. Happiness by occupational group 9. People’s Stories
  • 51. GNH Index by marital status 0.791 0.800 0.747 0.721 0.700 0.661 0.625 0.600 0.500 0.400 0.300 0.200 0.100 0.000 Never married Married Divorced Separated Widowed
  • 52. Percentage of happy people 50% 50% 45% 42% 40% 36% 35% 30% 27% 25% 19% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% Never married Married Divorced Separated Widowed
  • 53. Contribution to happiness by marital status Health 100% 90% Ecological diversity and resilience 80% Living standards 70% 11% 10% 11% 8% 12% 60% Time use 50% Psychological wellbeing 40% 8% 9% 8% 6% 30% 11% 13% 11% 12% Education 12% 20% 11% 10% 11% 11% 12% 10% 8% Community vitality 0% Cultural diversity and Never Married Divorced Separated Widowed resilience married Good Governance
  • 54. Part II: Understanding Happiness 1. National happiness 2. Happiness by Dzongkhag 3. Happiness by region 4. Happiness by gender 5. Happiness by age group 6. Happiness by marital status 7. Happiness by educational level 8. Happiness by occupational group 9. People’s Stories
  • 55. GNH Index and percentage of happy people by educational level Percentage of happy people GNH Index 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0
  • 56. Contribution of domains to happiness 100% 90% Living standards 80% 70% Ecological diversity and resilience 60% 50% Community vitality 40% 30% Good Governance 20% 10% Cultural diversity and 0% resilience Education Time use Health Psychological wellbeing
  • 57. As education increases, contribution of living standards & education to Contribution of domains to happiness happiness increases; governance and 100% culture decrease 90% Living standards 80% 70% Ecological diversity and resilience 60% 50% Community vitality 40% 30% Good Governance 20% 10% Cultural diversity and 0% resilience Education Time use Health Psychological wellbeing
  • 58. Part II: Understanding Happiness 1. National happiness 2. Happiness by Dzongkhag 3. Happiness by region 4. Happiness by gender 5. Happiness by age group 6. Happiness by marital status 7. Happiness by educational level 8. Happiness by occupational group 9. People’s Stories
  • 59. GNH Index and percentage of happy people by occupational status Percentage of happy people GNH Index 1 0.9 0.8 0.7 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0
  • 60. Contribution of domains to happiness 100% Living standards 90% 80% Ecological diversity 70% and resilience 60% Community vitality 50% 40% Good Governance 30% 20% 10% Cultural diversity 0% and resilience Education Time use Health Psychological wellbeing
  • 61. Part II: Understanding Happiness 1. National happiness 2. Happiness by Dzongkhag 3. Happiness by region 4. Happiness by gender 5. Happiness by age group 6. Happiness by marital status 7. Happiness by educational level 8. Happiness by occupational group 9. People’s Stories
  • 62. Who is Happy? Some real people (minor details have been changed)
  • 63. One happy person in the GNH survey was a married woman aged 35 living in rural Haa. She is a housewife who has completed primary school. Again, she achieved sufficiency in over 90% of the domains. She said she still suffered from selfishness and jealousy, and did not donate very much time/money. She was concerned about littering and the absence of good waste disposal, as well as floods, and did not know any zorig chosum skill.
  • 64. When asked what contributed most to her happiness she said: • Having sufficient income • Being in good relation with the husband • When everyone is in good health.
  • 65. Another happy person in the GNH survey was a young man aged 22 who lived in rural Sarpang and was never married. He is a farmer who finished primary school. His only deprivations were that wildlife damaged his crops, and that he did not know about his political rights.
  • 66. When asked what contributed most to happiness he said: • A peaceful environment • Enough money • No suffering • Good health • Good relations with my friends.
  • 67. Another happy person in the GNH survey was a widowed gomchen aged 70 living in rural Thimphu. He had no formal education, and was deprived in education, housing, sleep and did not participate politically. He observed that getting good agricultural products from the land contributes to happiness.
  • 68. Another happy person in the GNH survey was a married woman farmer aged 44 living in rural Tongsa. She was illiterate, and was deprived from wildlife damage to her crops, and thought she never felt forgiveness among the positive emotions – yet was happy. She mused that she felt happy when she was able to do her household work, when she was harvesting potatoes, and as she wove.
  • 69. Another happy person in the GNH survey was a married shopkeeper aged 37 living in urban Bumthang. He has finished 10th class, and meditates and prays regularly. He enjoys sufficiency in nearly every indicator. But he did mention that at the moment he only rarely experiences calmness and contentment. He also lacked some knowledge and did not think Driglam Namzha was terribly important.
  • 70. Another happy person in the GNH survey was a married corporate employee aged 35 living in urban Chukha. He has completed 10th class, and has achieved sufficiency in nearly all indicators. He was a bit sleep deprived, and did not feel a deep sense of belonging to his community, but was overall very satisfied with his life.
  • 71. When asked what contributed most to happiness he said: • To be healthy • To meet basic needs • To have peace in the family • To be religious
  • 72. Our final happy person in the GNH survey is an unmarried young woman aged 26 living in urban Tashigang. She completed a bachelor’s degree and is a civil servant living alone. She scores highly across domains, although she misses a sense of belonging. When asked what contributes to her happiness she replied: Love, Family, Friends, Education, and Enough money.
  • 73. The 2010 Gross National Happiness Index : Part II The Centre for Bhutan Studies 2011 .