The document discusses plagiarism at universities. It defines plagiarism as copying and pasting work without citing sources. Some examples of plagiarism given include paraphrasing without citations, translating without citing the original work, and copying extracts without mentioning the author. The document also discusses plagiarism among researchers, teachers and students. It notes that universities have policies against plagiarism including student honor codes and potential sanctions ranging from failing grades to expulsion. The document also examines tools that can be used to detect plagiarism such as Ephorus and Compilatio which are paid services and Plagium which offers a free version.
Integration and use of a Plagiarism Detector Tool in Chamilo LMS 1.9.x
1. Chamilo Days
A glimpse on plagiarism at the university
Jérémie Grépilloux – october 2013 - @jereerej (twitter)
2. Plagiarism, Kesako ?
« Here
it
is !!!
You've just done
what people call :
copy/paste !!
'Cause
you've
copied and you've
pasted the post-it »..
Les bidochons, « Les Bidochons internautes », Binet, 2008.
Jérémie Grépilloux – october 2013 - @jereerej (twitter)
3. Some famous (french) cases...
Jérémie Grépilloux – october 2013 - @jereerej (twitter)
4. But, it is also...
Some cases concerning more
the universities :
- to paraphrase some text without
giving any references.
- to translate a document written in
a foreign langage (and without any
references to it).
- to paste an extract of a text
without mentioning the author and
quotes.
Source image
« We found out that your philosphy work is plagiarism. » « Not quite true, the orthographical mistakes are mine. Not Spinoza's»
Jérémie Grépilloux – october 2013 - @jereerej (twitter)
5. It is also..
Researchers, Teachers, Students :
Same struggle !
Plagiarism in Research : How to react ?
Jérémie Grépilloux – october 2013 - @jereerej (twitter)
Source image
7. What commitment?
The user must observe, without this list being exhaustive, the following regulations:
- The private life of any person and compliance,
- The copyright and intellectual and industrial property
- The automated processing of personal data
- Compliance with the rules of public order
- Secrecy of correspondence and the prohibition of interception of communications
transmitted by means of networks.
Jérémie Grépilloux – october 2013 - @jereerej (twitter)
8. What commitment ?
Specific charters dedicated to the
prevention and the fight against
plagiarism, signed by students.
Eg: Each year, students of the
Institute of Political Studies of
Grenoble, have an example of the
charter "plagiarism" of their institution
in their registration form.
Jérémie Grépilloux – october 2013 - @jereerej (twitter)
9. What sanctions ?
Here is an example of the University of Laval in Quebec on the different
sanctions that may be taken in the event of fraud
"Being convicted expose you to important consequences:
- Award of a failure for the course concerned;
- Suspension of registration at the university;
- Dismissal for three sessions;
- Final Expulsion from the University;
- Reminder diploma. "
source
Jérémie Grépilloux – october 2013 - @jereerej (twitter)
10. What sanctions ?
Another example: in 2009-2010 at the University of Versailles SaintQuentin-en-Yvelines, 24 fraudsters revealed (about 18,000 students)
- 2 warnings;
- 2 blames;
- 10 exclusions suspended;
- 3 farms exclusions (3 months to 1 year);
- 7 exclusions of any public institution of higher education (from 6 months
to 1 year).
(More details here (french) :
http://www.letudiant.fr/bac/triche-au-bac-et-aux-examens-quels-risques-12268/triche-a-luniversite-beaucoup-de-relaxes-17682.html )
Jérémie Grépilloux – october 2013 - @jereerej (twitter)
11. What tools ?
There are different solutions to assess the degree of plagiarism of a
document.
At the University of Grenoble, which are paid solutions, with extensive
analysis results that have been selected by the institutions: Ephorus and
Compilatio.
But even if all UFR are not equipped, there are still tools, less developed,
more limited but free, that allow a teacher to verify the origin of any
content. (Plagium in its « light version » for example)
Jérémie Grépilloux – october 2013 - @jereerej (twitter)
12. What tools ?
But teachers are not the only ones who are allowed to check content.
Students also have options such as Studium (Compilatio product) which,
through the purchase of credits, check the originality of a work, highlight
the sources not listed, etc.
Although Compilatio denies it, this tool has the somewhat controversial
"teacher" side.
Jérémie Grépilloux – october 2013 - @jereerej (twitter)
13. References
Sites web :
A file by Liege University : http://www.ulg.ac.be/cms/c_146131/le-plagiat
A « oldstyle » site but of references : http://www.leplagiat.net/Page001.html
Michelle Bergadaà 's site :
http://responsable.unige.ch/index.php
Jérémie Grépilloux – october 2013 - @jereerej (twitter)