SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  38
Social calm -small views in a big world- Cstaubo Behavior Design Stanford 3june2011
What if you died tomorrow?
What will you notice that you have never noticed before?
Maybe you’ll notice the kids playing?
Maybe you would touch  your way around?
Maybe you listen to the wind in the trees?
How would these things make you feel? Calm? Happy? Aware?
Everyday for 10 days I got 30 participants to view their world in this way
Everyday for 10 days I got 30 participants to view their world in this way,  as it was their last day living.
This is their world:
This makes them
Happy
This is what they see
Of White Noise
This is what they touch
Of rough surfaces
They tasted…
They saw red..
They saw an emotion..
They shared it here:
But……
The tasks created awareness, but not calm. “one more thing bombarding me with information which adds stress”- Tom
because to create more calm, keep one personal goal over a couple of days “…if you want to create more calm you could add a routine you believe is destressing that people can follow when they wake up, go to bed, or just feel stressed in general.” -Jonas
That led to a 3 day awareness short-cut
Why                  ? awareness
Aware is the first step to calm
Aware is the first step to self-compassion and happiness
Recipe for the last day:
 -a pinch of Choice mixed with personal goal
-use personal relationship to drive participation
-facebook is too competitive and stressful for calming behavior
 people like to browse but don’t participate
 -repeat the steps above
then mix them all together and bake ….
..start living your day as it was your last day
Next step: Tap into existing fun behaviour

Contenu connexe

En vedette

Frommers barcelona, 2009, 3 ed
Frommers barcelona, 2009, 3 edFrommers barcelona, 2009, 3 ed
Frommers barcelona, 2009, 3 edHumberto Maia
 
1 suraltsagchid tavigdah_shaardlaga
1 suraltsagchid tavigdah_shaardlaga1 suraltsagchid tavigdah_shaardlaga
1 suraltsagchid tavigdah_shaardlagadolgorsurenj
 
3stress reducing services
3stress reducing services3stress reducing services
3stress reducing servicesChristin Staubo
 
Technological ability is more important than calming ability and motivation
Technological ability is more important than  calming ability and motivationTechnological ability is more important than  calming ability and motivation
Technological ability is more important than calming ability and motivationChristin Staubo
 
Design for Calm-Awareness
Design for Calm-Awareness Design for Calm-Awareness
Design for Calm-Awareness Christin Staubo
 
Radiography of eye
Radiography of eyeRadiography of eye
Radiography of eyeravijaichand
 
Press Release Jalan Tol Kertosono – Mojokerto Oktober 2010
Press Release Jalan Tol Kertosono – Mojokerto Oktober 2010Press Release Jalan Tol Kertosono – Mojokerto Oktober 2010
Press Release Jalan Tol Kertosono – Mojokerto Oktober 2010mhitollroad
 
Feedback smile project 1
Feedback smile project 1Feedback smile project 1
Feedback smile project 1Christin Staubo
 

En vedette (10)

Frommers barcelona, 2009, 3 ed
Frommers barcelona, 2009, 3 edFrommers barcelona, 2009, 3 ed
Frommers barcelona, 2009, 3 ed
 
Persona
PersonaPersona
Persona
 
1 suraltsagchid tavigdah_shaardlaga
1 suraltsagchid tavigdah_shaardlaga1 suraltsagchid tavigdah_shaardlaga
1 suraltsagchid tavigdah_shaardlaga
 
Sociala medier - vi reder ut begreppen
Sociala medier - vi reder ut begreppenSociala medier - vi reder ut begreppen
Sociala medier - vi reder ut begreppen
 
3stress reducing services
3stress reducing services3stress reducing services
3stress reducing services
 
Technological ability is more important than calming ability and motivation
Technological ability is more important than  calming ability and motivationTechnological ability is more important than  calming ability and motivation
Technological ability is more important than calming ability and motivation
 
Design for Calm-Awareness
Design for Calm-Awareness Design for Calm-Awareness
Design for Calm-Awareness
 
Radiography of eye
Radiography of eyeRadiography of eye
Radiography of eye
 
Press Release Jalan Tol Kertosono – Mojokerto Oktober 2010
Press Release Jalan Tol Kertosono – Mojokerto Oktober 2010Press Release Jalan Tol Kertosono – Mojokerto Oktober 2010
Press Release Jalan Tol Kertosono – Mojokerto Oktober 2010
 
Feedback smile project 1
Feedback smile project 1Feedback smile project 1
Feedback smile project 1
 

Similaire à Presentatiion social calm cstaubo

Mental health and activities by nurse nerissa
Mental health and activities by nurse nerissaMental health and activities by nurse nerissa
Mental health and activities by nurse nerissaMariaNerissaDiego2
 
Double duty 25 tips to take care of your mental and physical health
Double duty  25 tips to take care of your mental and physical healthDouble duty  25 tips to take care of your mental and physical health
Double duty 25 tips to take care of your mental and physical healthHermain Shaikh
 
Intentional Living is Dependent On Inner Stillness
Intentional Living is Dependent On Inner StillnessIntentional Living is Dependent On Inner Stillness
Intentional Living is Dependent On Inner Stillnessitsemonamin
 
How Successful People Stay Calm in 9 Steps
How Successful People Stay Calm in 9 StepsHow Successful People Stay Calm in 9 Steps
How Successful People Stay Calm in 9 StepsMarius Pranskunas
 
7 Day Mind & Soul Cleanse
7 Day Mind & Soul Cleanse7 Day Mind & Soul Cleanse
7 Day Mind & Soul CleanseMayur Gupta
 
10 ways to have a better day today
10 ways to have a better day today10 ways to have a better day today
10 ways to have a better day todayNam Talae
 
Text2calm home2sanctuary
Text2calm home2sanctuaryText2calm home2sanctuary
Text2calm home2sanctuaryemarr
 
Human responses to nature slide show
Human responses to nature slide showHuman responses to nature slide show
Human responses to nature slide showadenwyers
 
How to improve memory
How to improve memoryHow to improve memory
How to improve memoryZain Zafar
 
Meditation wrkshp wk 4..sharing positive thoughts with others for healing..
Meditation wrkshp wk 4..sharing positive thoughts with others for healing..Meditation wrkshp wk 4..sharing positive thoughts with others for healing..
Meditation wrkshp wk 4..sharing positive thoughts with others for healing..Jdmarlow
 
How to find time for you when you don't have time!
How to find time for you when you don't have time! How to find time for you when you don't have time!
How to find time for you when you don't have time! Jen Mackinnon
 
Air Guitar World Championships Finland  AugustTalca Chile, Slee.docx
Air Guitar World Championships Finland  AugustTalca Chile, Slee.docxAir Guitar World Championships Finland  AugustTalca Chile, Slee.docx
Air Guitar World Championships Finland  AugustTalca Chile, Slee.docxADDY50
 
De escalation skills training
De escalation skills trainingDe escalation skills training
De escalation skills trainingHouse of New Hope
 

Similaire à Presentatiion social calm cstaubo (20)

2nd Version Eben Pagan Wake Up Productive my notetakingnerd ver 2.0 m
2nd Version Eben Pagan Wake Up Productive my notetakingnerd ver 2.0 m2nd Version Eben Pagan Wake Up Productive my notetakingnerd ver 2.0 m
2nd Version Eben Pagan Wake Up Productive my notetakingnerd ver 2.0 m
 
Mental health and activities by nurse nerissa
Mental health and activities by nurse nerissaMental health and activities by nurse nerissa
Mental health and activities by nurse nerissa
 
21 picstomakeyoufeelawesome
21 picstomakeyoufeelawesome21 picstomakeyoufeelawesome
21 picstomakeyoufeelawesome
 
Double duty 25 tips to take care of your mental and physical health
Double duty  25 tips to take care of your mental and physical healthDouble duty  25 tips to take care of your mental and physical health
Double duty 25 tips to take care of your mental and physical health
 
Intentional Living is Dependent On Inner Stillness
Intentional Living is Dependent On Inner StillnessIntentional Living is Dependent On Inner Stillness
Intentional Living is Dependent On Inner Stillness
 
Inscriptions 27 october2019
Inscriptions 27 october2019Inscriptions 27 october2019
Inscriptions 27 october2019
 
How Successful People Stay Calm in 9 Steps
How Successful People Stay Calm in 9 StepsHow Successful People Stay Calm in 9 Steps
How Successful People Stay Calm in 9 Steps
 
Life work balance
Life work balanceLife work balance
Life work balance
 
Hypno Study
Hypno StudyHypno Study
Hypno Study
 
7 Day Mind & Soul Cleanse
7 Day Mind & Soul Cleanse7 Day Mind & Soul Cleanse
7 Day Mind & Soul Cleanse
 
10 ways to have a better day today
10 ways to have a better day today10 ways to have a better day today
10 ways to have a better day today
 
Text2calm home2sanctuary
Text2calm home2sanctuaryText2calm home2sanctuary
Text2calm home2sanctuary
 
Listening
ListeningListening
Listening
 
Human responses to nature slide show
Human responses to nature slide showHuman responses to nature slide show
Human responses to nature slide show
 
How to improve memory
How to improve memoryHow to improve memory
How to improve memory
 
Wfh tom wish
Wfh   tom wishWfh   tom wish
Wfh tom wish
 
Meditation wrkshp wk 4..sharing positive thoughts with others for healing..
Meditation wrkshp wk 4..sharing positive thoughts with others for healing..Meditation wrkshp wk 4..sharing positive thoughts with others for healing..
Meditation wrkshp wk 4..sharing positive thoughts with others for healing..
 
How to find time for you when you don't have time!
How to find time for you when you don't have time! How to find time for you when you don't have time!
How to find time for you when you don't have time!
 
Air Guitar World Championships Finland  AugustTalca Chile, Slee.docx
Air Guitar World Championships Finland  AugustTalca Chile, Slee.docxAir Guitar World Championships Finland  AugustTalca Chile, Slee.docx
Air Guitar World Championships Finland  AugustTalca Chile, Slee.docx
 
De escalation skills training
De escalation skills trainingDe escalation skills training
De escalation skills training
 

Plus de Christin Staubo

Plus de Christin Staubo (6)

technological awarenss vs motivation and ability
technological awarenss vs motivation and abilitytechnological awarenss vs motivation and ability
technological awarenss vs motivation and ability
 
Smallviewsbigworld
SmallviewsbigworldSmallviewsbigworld
Smallviewsbigworld
 
2 deep breaths for calm
2 deep breaths for calm2 deep breaths for calm
2 deep breaths for calm
 
Final
FinalFinal
Final
 
Persona2
Persona2Persona2
Persona2
 
Personas
PersonasPersonas
Personas
 

Dernier

It’s Time to Fight Back Against the Media Narrative Regarding Real Estate Com...
It’s Time to Fight Back Against the Media Narrative Regarding Real Estate Com...It’s Time to Fight Back Against the Media Narrative Regarding Real Estate Com...
It’s Time to Fight Back Against the Media Narrative Regarding Real Estate Com...Tom Blefko
 
Listing Turkey - Resim Modern Catalog Istanbul
Listing Turkey - Resim Modern Catalog IstanbulListing Turkey - Resim Modern Catalog Istanbul
Listing Turkey - Resim Modern Catalog IstanbulListing Turkey
 
Anandtara Iris Residences Mundhwa Pune Brochure.pdf
Anandtara Iris Residences Mundhwa Pune Brochure.pdfAnandtara Iris Residences Mundhwa Pune Brochure.pdf
Anandtara Iris Residences Mundhwa Pune Brochure.pdfabbu831446
 
Saheel ITREND Futura At Baner Annexe Pune - PDF.pdf
Saheel ITREND Futura At Baner Annexe Pune - PDF.pdfSaheel ITREND Futura At Baner Annexe Pune - PDF.pdf
Saheel ITREND Futura At Baner Annexe Pune - PDF.pdfmonikasharma630
 
What-are-the-latest-modular-wardrobe-designs.pdf
What-are-the-latest-modular-wardrobe-designs.pdfWhat-are-the-latest-modular-wardrobe-designs.pdf
What-are-the-latest-modular-wardrobe-designs.pdfKams Designer Zone
 
What is Affordable Housing? Bristol Civic Society April 2024
What is Affordable Housing? Bristol Civic Society April 2024What is Affordable Housing? Bristol Civic Society April 2024
What is Affordable Housing? Bristol Civic Society April 2024Paul Smith
 
Shapoorji Pallonji Vanaha GolfLand 2 | A Space For You To Find Your Space
Shapoorji Pallonji Vanaha GolfLand 2 | A Space For You To Find Your SpaceShapoorji Pallonji Vanaha GolfLand 2 | A Space For You To Find Your Space
Shapoorji Pallonji Vanaha GolfLand 2 | A Space For You To Find Your Spaceaidasheikh47
 
Kohinoor Hinjewadi Phase 2 In Pune - PDF.pdf
Kohinoor Hinjewadi Phase 2 In Pune - PDF.pdfKohinoor Hinjewadi Phase 2 In Pune - PDF.pdf
Kohinoor Hinjewadi Phase 2 In Pune - PDF.pdfmonikasharma630
 
Kolte Patil Mirabilis at Horamavu Road, Bangalore E brochure.pdf
Kolte Patil Mirabilis at Horamavu Road, Bangalore E brochure.pdfKolte Patil Mirabilis at Horamavu Road, Bangalore E brochure.pdf
Kolte Patil Mirabilis at Horamavu Road, Bangalore E brochure.pdfAhanundefined
 
LCAR Unit 20 - Appraising Real Estate - 14th Edition Revised
LCAR Unit 20 - Appraising Real Estate - 14th Edition RevisedLCAR Unit 20 - Appraising Real Estate - 14th Edition Revised
LCAR Unit 20 - Appraising Real Estate - 14th Edition RevisedTom Blefko
 
Experion Elements Sector 45 Noida_Brochure.pdf.pdf
Experion Elements Sector 45 Noida_Brochure.pdf.pdfExperion Elements Sector 45 Noida_Brochure.pdf.pdf
Experion Elements Sector 45 Noida_Brochure.pdf.pdfkratirudram
 
Prestige Sanctuary Nandi Hills Bangalore.pdf
Prestige Sanctuary Nandi Hills Bangalore.pdfPrestige Sanctuary Nandi Hills Bangalore.pdf
Prestige Sanctuary Nandi Hills Bangalore.pdfashiyadav24
 
The Role of Mortgage Brokers in Retirement Housing: Key Considerations
The Role of Mortgage Brokers in Retirement Housing: Key ConsiderationsThe Role of Mortgage Brokers in Retirement Housing: Key Considerations
The Role of Mortgage Brokers in Retirement Housing: Key Considerationssunlite Mortgage
 
SVN Live 4.15.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 4.15.24 Weekly Property BroadcastSVN Live 4.15.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 4.15.24 Weekly Property BroadcastSVN International Corp.
 
Vilas Javdekar Yashwin Enchante Pune E-Brochure .pdf
Vilas Javdekar Yashwin Enchante Pune  E-Brochure .pdfVilas Javdekar Yashwin Enchante Pune  E-Brochure .pdf
Vilas Javdekar Yashwin Enchante Pune E-Brochure .pdfManishSaxena95
 
Honer Richmont Hyderabad E brochure - A Life With A View
Honer Richmont Hyderabad E brochure - A Life With A ViewHoner Richmont Hyderabad E brochure - A Life With A View
Honer Richmont Hyderabad E brochure - A Life With A ViewAhanundefined
 
LCAR RE Practice - The Pearson Vue State Exam
LCAR RE Practice - The Pearson Vue State ExamLCAR RE Practice - The Pearson Vue State Exam
LCAR RE Practice - The Pearson Vue State ExamTom Blefko
 
Pride Wonderland Dhanori Pune Brochure.pdf
Pride Wonderland Dhanori Pune Brochure.pdfPride Wonderland Dhanori Pune Brochure.pdf
Pride Wonderland Dhanori Pune Brochure.pdfabbu831446
 
Prestige Orchards Plots in Shamshabad, Mamidipalli, Hyderabad pdf.pdf
Prestige Orchards Plots in Shamshabad, Mamidipalli, Hyderabad pdf.pdfPrestige Orchards Plots in Shamshabad, Mamidipalli, Hyderabad pdf.pdf
Prestige Orchards Plots in Shamshabad, Mamidipalli, Hyderabad pdf.pdfAhanundefined
 
Ganga Fusion 85 Gurugram - PDF Download.pdf
Ganga Fusion 85 Gurugram - PDF Download.pdfGanga Fusion 85 Gurugram - PDF Download.pdf
Ganga Fusion 85 Gurugram - PDF Download.pdfanjalisaini334541
 

Dernier (20)

It’s Time to Fight Back Against the Media Narrative Regarding Real Estate Com...
It’s Time to Fight Back Against the Media Narrative Regarding Real Estate Com...It’s Time to Fight Back Against the Media Narrative Regarding Real Estate Com...
It’s Time to Fight Back Against the Media Narrative Regarding Real Estate Com...
 
Listing Turkey - Resim Modern Catalog Istanbul
Listing Turkey - Resim Modern Catalog IstanbulListing Turkey - Resim Modern Catalog Istanbul
Listing Turkey - Resim Modern Catalog Istanbul
 
Anandtara Iris Residences Mundhwa Pune Brochure.pdf
Anandtara Iris Residences Mundhwa Pune Brochure.pdfAnandtara Iris Residences Mundhwa Pune Brochure.pdf
Anandtara Iris Residences Mundhwa Pune Brochure.pdf
 
Saheel ITREND Futura At Baner Annexe Pune - PDF.pdf
Saheel ITREND Futura At Baner Annexe Pune - PDF.pdfSaheel ITREND Futura At Baner Annexe Pune - PDF.pdf
Saheel ITREND Futura At Baner Annexe Pune - PDF.pdf
 
What-are-the-latest-modular-wardrobe-designs.pdf
What-are-the-latest-modular-wardrobe-designs.pdfWhat-are-the-latest-modular-wardrobe-designs.pdf
What-are-the-latest-modular-wardrobe-designs.pdf
 
What is Affordable Housing? Bristol Civic Society April 2024
What is Affordable Housing? Bristol Civic Society April 2024What is Affordable Housing? Bristol Civic Society April 2024
What is Affordable Housing? Bristol Civic Society April 2024
 
Shapoorji Pallonji Vanaha GolfLand 2 | A Space For You To Find Your Space
Shapoorji Pallonji Vanaha GolfLand 2 | A Space For You To Find Your SpaceShapoorji Pallonji Vanaha GolfLand 2 | A Space For You To Find Your Space
Shapoorji Pallonji Vanaha GolfLand 2 | A Space For You To Find Your Space
 
Kohinoor Hinjewadi Phase 2 In Pune - PDF.pdf
Kohinoor Hinjewadi Phase 2 In Pune - PDF.pdfKohinoor Hinjewadi Phase 2 In Pune - PDF.pdf
Kohinoor Hinjewadi Phase 2 In Pune - PDF.pdf
 
Kolte Patil Mirabilis at Horamavu Road, Bangalore E brochure.pdf
Kolte Patil Mirabilis at Horamavu Road, Bangalore E brochure.pdfKolte Patil Mirabilis at Horamavu Road, Bangalore E brochure.pdf
Kolte Patil Mirabilis at Horamavu Road, Bangalore E brochure.pdf
 
LCAR Unit 20 - Appraising Real Estate - 14th Edition Revised
LCAR Unit 20 - Appraising Real Estate - 14th Edition RevisedLCAR Unit 20 - Appraising Real Estate - 14th Edition Revised
LCAR Unit 20 - Appraising Real Estate - 14th Edition Revised
 
Experion Elements Sector 45 Noida_Brochure.pdf.pdf
Experion Elements Sector 45 Noida_Brochure.pdf.pdfExperion Elements Sector 45 Noida_Brochure.pdf.pdf
Experion Elements Sector 45 Noida_Brochure.pdf.pdf
 
Prestige Sanctuary Nandi Hills Bangalore.pdf
Prestige Sanctuary Nandi Hills Bangalore.pdfPrestige Sanctuary Nandi Hills Bangalore.pdf
Prestige Sanctuary Nandi Hills Bangalore.pdf
 
The Role of Mortgage Brokers in Retirement Housing: Key Considerations
The Role of Mortgage Brokers in Retirement Housing: Key ConsiderationsThe Role of Mortgage Brokers in Retirement Housing: Key Considerations
The Role of Mortgage Brokers in Retirement Housing: Key Considerations
 
SVN Live 4.15.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 4.15.24 Weekly Property BroadcastSVN Live 4.15.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
SVN Live 4.15.24 Weekly Property Broadcast
 
Vilas Javdekar Yashwin Enchante Pune E-Brochure .pdf
Vilas Javdekar Yashwin Enchante Pune  E-Brochure .pdfVilas Javdekar Yashwin Enchante Pune  E-Brochure .pdf
Vilas Javdekar Yashwin Enchante Pune E-Brochure .pdf
 
Honer Richmont Hyderabad E brochure - A Life With A View
Honer Richmont Hyderabad E brochure - A Life With A ViewHoner Richmont Hyderabad E brochure - A Life With A View
Honer Richmont Hyderabad E brochure - A Life With A View
 
LCAR RE Practice - The Pearson Vue State Exam
LCAR RE Practice - The Pearson Vue State ExamLCAR RE Practice - The Pearson Vue State Exam
LCAR RE Practice - The Pearson Vue State Exam
 
Pride Wonderland Dhanori Pune Brochure.pdf
Pride Wonderland Dhanori Pune Brochure.pdfPride Wonderland Dhanori Pune Brochure.pdf
Pride Wonderland Dhanori Pune Brochure.pdf
 
Prestige Orchards Plots in Shamshabad, Mamidipalli, Hyderabad pdf.pdf
Prestige Orchards Plots in Shamshabad, Mamidipalli, Hyderabad pdf.pdfPrestige Orchards Plots in Shamshabad, Mamidipalli, Hyderabad pdf.pdf
Prestige Orchards Plots in Shamshabad, Mamidipalli, Hyderabad pdf.pdf
 
Ganga Fusion 85 Gurugram - PDF Download.pdf
Ganga Fusion 85 Gurugram - PDF Download.pdfGanga Fusion 85 Gurugram - PDF Download.pdf
Ganga Fusion 85 Gurugram - PDF Download.pdf
 

Presentatiion social calm cstaubo

Notes de l'éditeur

  1. I think these emails add a moderate bit of stress for me. I think having one more task coming at me by email sends my heart rate up a bit. Finding a way to enable calm without feeling like it's one more thing bombarding me with information which adds stress. –TomWith exception for the white noise (day5), I don't think I became much calmer, but the tasks definitely helped me to appreciate the little things in life more. I also enjoyed checking the blog and watching what others had posted, which gave new perspectives and added a group feeling to the exercise.-jonasJeg likte det veldig godt, og så frem til hver nye oppgave. Det var så spennende og gøy å ha en oppgave du skulle gjennomføre hverdag. Jeg ble er oppmerksom på omgivelsene og mine følelser.- marinaI'm not sure about more calm, but it did make me more self-aware of my stress and tension level. That's probably a good first step towards becoming more calm.- luhua
  2. I think if you want to create more calm (the awareness was already successful in my opinion), you could add a routine you believe is destressing that people can follow when they wake up, go to bed, or just feel stressed in general.I think new tasks every day are good for awareness, but to create more calm a repetitive task should me more effective.- jonasI think for me, being given tasks, means that there's just one more thing to do. And that's something that's going to take away from the things that I want to do for myself. For me, getting permission to take some time to do the things that are important to me, and relaxing to me, would be great. Not sure how you do that, but I think that would help create some calm- tom
  3. Design principles-personal goalOr choiceRepetition is good- technology affect your audiences participation- text works bestPeople are browsers not participators online- social accountability is good, works best in small groups where people know eachother-people need triggers, motivation and ability is not enough-
  4. Design principles-personal goalOr choiceRepetition is good- technology affect your audiences participation- text works bestPeople are browsers not participators online- social accountability is good, works best in small groups where people know eachother-people need triggers, motivation and ability is not enough-
  5. - social accountability is good, works best in small groups where people know eachother- this is the driving force for participation-
  6. Moving from one platform to another I lost a lot of user-Technology can be a solution, but an overfocus on technology from the beginning is wrong, the problem needs to be in focus not the toolsFacebook is a place for people to compare themselves to others , competetive placeCalm and competition does not work together- aka calm and facebook does not work
  7. People are browsers not participators online- people are freeriders- -show off /competition is a huge part of the online identity people have, this is not a behaviour that creates calm-
  8. Repetition is goodTo many new things makes people stressed, train them to be good at one thing in one specific setting and then trasnfer that skill to other behaviours-
  9. Design principles-personal goalOr choiceRepetition is good- technology affect your audiences participation- text works bestPeople are browsers not participators online- social accountability is good, works best in small groups where people know eachother-people need triggers, motivation and ability is not enough-