Transportation Networks

Wednesday, November 4, 2009

Welcome to Portland, Oregon-The Most Well
Connected City in the United States and the
Home of the Ugliest Building in the World*

* I work in this building

Tuesday, November 3, 2009

For purposes of discussion we will compare two pairs of
neighborhoods using their relative accessibility and connectivity to
illustrate the difﬁculty of building connected networks in the
modern urban setting.

The neighborhoods are:
Downtown
Gateway

NE 60th Ave LRT station area
NE 148th Ave. LRT station area


Downtown Portland
East/West-4th Ave. to Broadway N
North/South-SW Pine St. to SW Columbia St.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Broadway

13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
6th Ave.

25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 5th Ave.
Text
37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 4th Ave.
SW Columbia St.

SW Jefferson St.

SW Morrison St.
SW Madison St.

SW Main St.

SW Yamhill St.
SW Salmon St.

SW Taylor St.

SW Washington St.
SW Alder St.

SW Stark St.

SW Pine St.
48-Intersections
.08 sq. mile

Siena, IT-Medieval Connectivity & Intersection Density


Gateway Regional Center
NE Wiedler/Halsey to NE Washington/Stark
NE 99th to NE 102nd N

1 2 3 4 4 8
5 6 7

11 10 9

12 13
17 18
14 15 16 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26

26 Intersections
.29 sq. Miles

Gateway Concept Plan by Peter Calthorpe N

Approx. Capital Investment For New
Streets and Row-$70 million

THOMPSON ST THOMPSON ST
THOMPSON ST
105TH AV

THOMPSON ST
106TH AVE
92ND AVE

THOMPSON ST
95TH PL

EUGENE ST
117TH AVE
112TH AVE

$
&
%
205 EUGENE ST
104TH AVE

116TH AVE

TILLAMOOK ST
$
&
%
N

E

84 SAN RAFAEL ST
HANCOCK DR SAN RAFAEL ST
113TH AVE

HANCOCK ST
HANCOCK ST
114TH PL

SCHUYLER ST
108TH AVE
101ST AVE
R
BELL D

118TH AVE

119TH AVE

SCHUYLER ST
104TH AVE

BROADWAY
111TH AVE
106TH AVE

116TH PL

BROADWAY
102ND AVE

103RD PL
100TH AVE

WEIDLER ST
HALSEY ST
114TH AVE
108TH AVE
Revised Gateway Street Plan-Adopted by Council Oct. 22, 09

CLACKAMAS ST
117TH AVE

WASCO ST
$
&
%
118TH AVE

84
MULTNOMAH ST MULTNOMAH ST
112TH AVE
109TH AVE
GATEW

107TH PL

HASSALO ST
108TH AVE
AY

113TH AVE

HOLLADAY ST
TC

PACIFIC ST HOLLADAY ST
110TH AVE
AVE

OREGON ST PACIFIC ST
107TH AVE

PACIFIC ST
"
# "
#
111TH AVE
92ND AVE

93RD AVE

"
#
97TH

117TH AVE

118TH AVE
OREGON ST OREGON ST
106TH PL

113TH AVE
107TH PL

109TH CT

IRVING ST
108TH AVE

TH CT
HOYT ST
101ST AVE

"
#

116TH PL 116
GLISAN ST
"
# 113TH AVE
103RD AVE

104TH AVE

FLANDERS ST
105TH AVE

108TH PL
106TH AVE
92ND PL

97TH AVE

100TH AVE

EVERETT CT
EVERETT ST
99TH AVE

EVERETT ST EVERETT ST EVERETT ST
109TH AVE

110TH AVE
!!!!!

116TH AVE
DAVIS ST
DAVIS ST
"
#
94TH AVE

COUCH CT

118TH AVE
113TH PL
BURNSIDE ST

Cost Unknown at this time
"
#
103RD AVE

ANKENY ST
ANKENY ST
93RD AVE

ANKENY ST
97TH AVE

ASH ST 108TH AVE
ASH ST
!!!!

109TH AVE

PINE CT
105TH AVE

106TH AVE
ASH ST

CT
PINE ST

119TH AVE
ASH
PINE CT PINE ST
OAK ST
"
# OAK ST
OAK ST
STARK ST
103RD DR

WASHINGTON ST
WASHINGTON ST
ALDER ST
ALDER ST

111TH AVE
MORRISON ST

117TH AVE
114TH
112TH AVE
102ND AVE
MORRISON ST
YAMHILL ST
94TH AVE

YAMHILL ST

PL
TAYLOR ST C HE
RR

L
TAYLOR ST

P
$
Y
&
% BL

TH
SALMON ST
205 OS
SALMON ST

114
S OM
MAIN ST DR
SALMON CT MAIN
ST MAIN ST
MAIN ST

CL

114TH AVE
115TH AVE
AY
MADISON ST MA
DI MADISON ST

100TH AVE

109TH AVE
S
96TH AVE S

107TH AVE
ON

T
DR
94TH AVE

CLA HAWTHORNE BLVD
Y ST
CLAY ST
MARKET ST
MA

114TH PL
R KE

106TH AVE

112TH AVE

113TH AVE
T

100TH AVE
DR MILL CT
MILL CT
MILL ST MILL ST MILL CT
104TH CT STEPHENS ST
STEPHENS ST
STEPHENS ST

Proposed Amendment
!
Existing Street !!!! Proposed Street Vacation
Proposed New Street Central Gateway Amendment Area Portland Master Street Plan
Pedestrian Connection Gateway Regional Center Map 11.11.3
0 500 1,000 Gateway District
"
# Public Bike and Pedestrian Accessways will be required on these blocks such Updated October 22, 2009
Feet that spacing of public connections shall be no more than 330 feet where full
street connections are more than 530 feet.
Analysis by C. Hainey; Analysis Date: 04-29-09; Plot Date: 10-14-09; File Name: PortlandMasterStreetPlan_Gateway.mxd

Intersection Density Comparison
Downtown vs. Gateway Regional Center
Downtown
48 Intersections/.08 sq. miles
600 stations/sq. mile
Gateway Regional Center
26 intersections/.29 sq. miles

1 2 3 4 5 6

7 8 9

10
60th Ave Station/Blue Line
13 14 15 16 17 18

Intersection Density
11

45 Intersection
12

.19 sq. miles
19 23 24
22
21
20

1

30
25 28
27
29 31
26 32

37
33 34 35 36 38

40 41 42 43
39 44 45


60th Ave. Station/Blue Line

Approx. $7 million in local street improvements

8

5
4
6

3
1 2 7 9
11

10
NE 148th Ave LRT Station Area
11 Intersections-.19 sq. miles


Intersection Density Comparison
NE 60th LRT Station Area vs. NE 148th LRT
Station Area
NE 60th Ave. LRT Station Area
45 Intersections/.19 sq. miles
NE 148th Ave. LRT Sation Area
26 intersections/.29 sq. miles

Approx. $21.2 million in local street
improvements

#1 Obstacle To Improving Transportation Networks

Sheer Enormity of the Problem
Increase in Intersection Density of Approximately six fold


Direct Outgrowth of Obstacle #1
Enormous Cost of Creating New Transportation Networks
To Create or Improve Transportation Networks in Three Areas
1. NE 60th Ave. LRT Station Area: $7 million
2. Gateway Regional Center: $70 million
3. NE 148th Ave. LRT Station Area: $21.2 million
$98.2 million



Political and Social realities!!
Believe it or Not Large Numbers of People Prefer the Status Quo
Legal Barriers Involved in Condemning Private Land for Public Uses


Transportation Networks

Recommandé

Recommandé

Contenu connexe

Plus de Congress for the New Urbanism

Plus de Congress for the New Urbanism (14)

Dernier

Dernier (20)

Transportation Networks