SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 16
Does public and private sector procurement education merit a separate syllabus?  Dr Gordon Murray
You can have the right professional qualification but does that mean you know the right things?
Acceptance of difference ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
The debate is not about difference  I don’t want a different public sector procurement qualification,  I  want all  the private sector procurement knowledge plus   public sector dimensions
Defining procurement and all that stuff Strategic needs  assessment Decide priorities  and outcomes Plan and  design services Optional  appraisal Sourcing Delivery Monitor  and review The  commissioning  cycle Determine the need Supplier selection Contracting Ordering Expediting Follow-up/ evaluation The  purchasing  cycle procurement
To define the local government procurement ‘professional’ follow the money Dir Social Services (ADSS) Asset mgrs (RICS ) Waste managers (IWM ) Highways eng. (CHIT) Architects (RIBA) ICT (SOCITM) Marketing (CIM) Procurement (CIPS) GPs Spend University  provision  of  procurement  education
How are sector differences in requirements handled in procurement education at university level in UK? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
The  ideal  would be a  comprehensive  procurement education for  motivated  students without a time constraint   but “…  the time is short ”
If you have to ration/prioritise, where do you start? Segmentation and targeting
‘Need to know’ content ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Priorities for some… but not for all ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Stakeholder mapping? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Education within change management ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Educators as Knights or Knaves? ,[object Object],[object Object]
The answer is in the word ‘merit’ Justice to  students  & sponsors Breadth &  depth of the  body of  knowledge Merit common  core  content, targeted  at  range of  levels &  ‘ sector  specific’  essential  content  but  not  always  separate  delivery   Given time  constraint + + =
The answer is in the word ‘merit’ Justice to  students  & sponsors Breadth &  depth of the  body of  knowledge Merit common  core  content, targeted  at  range of  levels &  ‘ sector  specific’  essential  content  but  not  always  separate  delivery   Given time  constraint + + =

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

110809 observations of local govt improvement & challenges
110809 observations of local govt improvement  & challenges110809 observations of local govt improvement  & challenges
110809 observations of local govt improvement & challengesDr Gordon Murray
 
What's the Efficiency Exchange?
What's the Efficiency Exchange?What's the Efficiency Exchange?
What's the Efficiency Exchange?Dr Gordon Murray
 
NPM in the UK: a local government perspective
NPM in the UK: a local government perspectiveNPM in the UK: a local government perspective
NPM in the UK: a local government perspectiveDr Gordon Murray
 
Aesynt - Thursday - 3:30 PM
Aesynt - Thursday - 3:30 PMAesynt - Thursday - 3:30 PM
Aesynt - Thursday - 3:30 PMApttus
 
Contract Lifecycle Management
Contract Lifecycle Management Contract Lifecycle Management
Contract Lifecycle Management InnocenzoLippa
 
Apttus Quote-to-Cash Impact Study
Apttus Quote-to-Cash Impact StudyApttus Quote-to-Cash Impact Study
Apttus Quote-to-Cash Impact StudyApttus
 
S2 p strategic opportunity-s2p-implementation-0113-1
S2 p strategic opportunity-s2p-implementation-0113-1S2 p strategic opportunity-s2p-implementation-0113-1
S2 p strategic opportunity-s2p-implementation-0113-1Dr Gordon Murray
 
Digital procurement strategy
Digital procurement strategyDigital procurement strategy
Digital procurement strategyDr Gordon Murray
 
An approach to strategic sourcing /category management
An approach to strategic sourcing /category managementAn approach to strategic sourcing /category management
An approach to strategic sourcing /category managementDr Gordon Murray
 
Configure Price Quote as an Agent for Change
Configure Price Quote as an Agent for ChangeConfigure Price Quote as an Agent for Change
Configure Price Quote as an Agent for ChangeApttus
 
Basic procurement training
Basic procurement trainingBasic procurement training
Basic procurement trainingDr Gordon Murray
 
Guide to Contract Management
Guide to Contract ManagementGuide to Contract Management
Guide to Contract ManagementBerkman Solutions
 
10 Contract Management Implementation Pitfalls | Selectica
10 Contract Management Implementation Pitfalls | Selectica10 Contract Management Implementation Pitfalls | Selectica
10 Contract Management Implementation Pitfalls | SelecticaDetermine
 

Viewers also liked (17)

110809 observations of local govt improvement & challenges
110809 observations of local govt improvement  & challenges110809 observations of local govt improvement  & challenges
110809 observations of local govt improvement & challenges
 
Procurement fraud-0614-1
Procurement fraud-0614-1Procurement fraud-0614-1
Procurement fraud-0614-1
 
What's the Efficiency Exchange?
What's the Efficiency Exchange?What's the Efficiency Exchange?
What's the Efficiency Exchange?
 
NPM in the UK: a local government perspective
NPM in the UK: a local government perspectiveNPM in the UK: a local government perspective
NPM in the UK: a local government perspective
 
Aesynt - Thursday - 3:30 PM
Aesynt - Thursday - 3:30 PMAesynt - Thursday - 3:30 PM
Aesynt - Thursday - 3:30 PM
 
E procurement strategy
E procurement strategyE procurement strategy
E procurement strategy
 
Procurement change 101116
Procurement change 101116Procurement change 101116
Procurement change 101116
 
Contract Lifecycle Management
Contract Lifecycle Management Contract Lifecycle Management
Contract Lifecycle Management
 
Apttus Quote-to-Cash Impact Study
Apttus Quote-to-Cash Impact StudyApttus Quote-to-Cash Impact Study
Apttus Quote-to-Cash Impact Study
 
S2 p strategic opportunity-s2p-implementation-0113-1
S2 p strategic opportunity-s2p-implementation-0113-1S2 p strategic opportunity-s2p-implementation-0113-1
S2 p strategic opportunity-s2p-implementation-0113-1
 
Digital procurement strategy
Digital procurement strategyDigital procurement strategy
Digital procurement strategy
 
An approach to strategic sourcing /category management
An approach to strategic sourcing /category managementAn approach to strategic sourcing /category management
An approach to strategic sourcing /category management
 
Configure Price Quote as an Agent for Change
Configure Price Quote as an Agent for ChangeConfigure Price Quote as an Agent for Change
Configure Price Quote as an Agent for Change
 
Basic procurement training
Basic procurement trainingBasic procurement training
Basic procurement training
 
Contract management general
Contract management generalContract management general
Contract management general
 
Guide to Contract Management
Guide to Contract ManagementGuide to Contract Management
Guide to Contract Management
 
10 Contract Management Implementation Pitfalls | Selectica
10 Contract Management Implementation Pitfalls | Selectica10 Contract Management Implementation Pitfalls | Selectica
10 Contract Management Implementation Pitfalls | Selectica
 

Similar to IPSERA Debate The Case For Differentiated Procurement Education

Certified international commercial contracts manager
Certified  international  commercial  contracts managerCertified  international  commercial  contracts manager
Certified international commercial contracts managerITI Institute
 
Third sector commissioning & Procurement
Third sector commissioning & ProcurementThird sector commissioning & Procurement
Third sector commissioning & ProcurementDr Gordon Murray
 
Procurement Landscape In Public Sector 2010
Procurement Landscape In Public Sector 2010Procurement Landscape In Public Sector 2010
Procurement Landscape In Public Sector 2010Dr Gordon Murray
 
100326 Procurement Landscape In Public Sector 2010
100326 Procurement Landscape In Public Sector 2010100326 Procurement Landscape In Public Sector 2010
100326 Procurement Landscape In Public Sector 2010Dr Gordon Murray
 
Whats Different About PM in the Public Sector
Whats Different About PM in the Public SectorWhats Different About PM in the Public Sector
Whats Different About PM in the Public Sectoralleyj
 
Routes to mcips
Routes to mcipsRoutes to mcips
Routes to mcipsCip Qat
 
091126 UUJ MSc Bus Imp.ppt
091126  UUJ MSc Bus Imp.ppt091126  UUJ MSc Bus Imp.ppt
091126 UUJ MSc Bus Imp.pptDr Gordon Murray
 
Public sector tendering - your route to success
Public sector tendering - your route to successPublic sector tendering - your route to success
Public sector tendering - your route to successwalescva
 
Acca commissioning, procurement, purchasing and third sector commissioning
Acca commissioning, procurement, purchasing and third sector commissioningAcca commissioning, procurement, purchasing and third sector commissioning
Acca commissioning, procurement, purchasing and third sector commissioningDr Gordon Murray
 
Introduction to Presales Consulting and Proposal Authoring
Introduction to Presales Consulting and Proposal AuthoringIntroduction to Presales Consulting and Proposal Authoring
Introduction to Presales Consulting and Proposal AuthoringSowmak Bardhan
 
Organisational Learning - Why are we still talking about training AB - Feb 2016
Organisational Learning - Why are we still talking about training AB - Feb 2016Organisational Learning - Why are we still talking about training AB - Feb 2016
Organisational Learning - Why are we still talking about training AB - Feb 2016Dr. Ann Bicknell
 
World class procurement and your business
World class procurement and your business World class procurement and your business
World class procurement and your business Procurement For Housing
 

Similar to IPSERA Debate The Case For Differentiated Procurement Education (20)

Certified international commercial contracts manager
Certified  international  commercial  contracts managerCertified  international  commercial  contracts manager
Certified international commercial contracts manager
 
Third sector commissioning & Procurement
Third sector commissioning & ProcurementThird sector commissioning & Procurement
Third sector commissioning & Procurement
 
Procurement Landscape In Public Sector 2010
Procurement Landscape In Public Sector 2010Procurement Landscape In Public Sector 2010
Procurement Landscape In Public Sector 2010
 
081209 Mo J
081209 Mo J081209 Mo J
081209 Mo J
 
Management consultancy primer
Management consultancy primerManagement consultancy primer
Management consultancy primer
 
100326 Procurement Landscape In Public Sector 2010
100326 Procurement Landscape In Public Sector 2010100326 Procurement Landscape In Public Sector 2010
100326 Procurement Landscape In Public Sector 2010
 
Whats Different About PM in the Public Sector
Whats Different About PM in the Public SectorWhats Different About PM in the Public Sector
Whats Different About PM in the Public Sector
 
Routes to mcips
Routes to mcipsRoutes to mcips
Routes to mcips
 
CPP.pdf
CPP.pdfCPP.pdf
CPP.pdf
 
CPP.pdf
CPP.pdfCPP.pdf
CPP.pdf
 
CPP.pdf
CPP.pdfCPP.pdf
CPP.pdf
 
091126 UUJ MSc Bus Imp.ppt
091126  UUJ MSc Bus Imp.ppt091126  UUJ MSc Bus Imp.ppt
091126 UUJ MSc Bus Imp.ppt
 
Public sector tendering - your route to success
Public sector tendering - your route to successPublic sector tendering - your route to success
Public sector tendering - your route to success
 
070921 Sopo 2007
070921 Sopo 2007070921 Sopo 2007
070921 Sopo 2007
 
Acca commissioning, procurement, purchasing and third sector commissioning
Acca commissioning, procurement, purchasing and third sector commissioningAcca commissioning, procurement, purchasing and third sector commissioning
Acca commissioning, procurement, purchasing and third sector commissioning
 
Lecture 03 DMC and Strategy
Lecture 03 DMC and StrategyLecture 03 DMC and Strategy
Lecture 03 DMC and Strategy
 
Introduction to Presales Consulting and Proposal Authoring
Introduction to Presales Consulting and Proposal AuthoringIntroduction to Presales Consulting and Proposal Authoring
Introduction to Presales Consulting and Proposal Authoring
 
Organisational Learning - Why are we still talking about training AB - Feb 2016
Organisational Learning - Why are we still talking about training AB - Feb 2016Organisational Learning - Why are we still talking about training AB - Feb 2016
Organisational Learning - Why are we still talking about training AB - Feb 2016
 
Commercial masterclasses
Commercial masterclassesCommercial masterclasses
Commercial masterclasses
 
World class procurement and your business
World class procurement and your business World class procurement and your business
World class procurement and your business
 

More from Dr Gordon Murray

Penny wise procurement strategies-long-term-effectiveness-short-term-wins 1012-1
Penny wise procurement strategies-long-term-effectiveness-short-term-wins 1012-1Penny wise procurement strategies-long-term-effectiveness-short-term-wins 1012-1
Penny wise procurement strategies-long-term-effectiveness-short-term-wins 1012-1Dr Gordon Murray
 
Effective supplier-engagement-strategy-0316-1
Effective supplier-engagement-strategy-0316-1Effective supplier-engagement-strategy-0316-1
Effective supplier-engagement-strategy-0316-1Dr Gordon Murray
 
Digital procurement strategy-0513-1
Digital procurement strategy-0513-1Digital procurement strategy-0513-1
Digital procurement strategy-0513-1Dr Gordon Murray
 
Procurement fraud: Are you vulnerable?
Procurement fraud: Are you vulnerable?Procurement fraud: Are you vulnerable?
Procurement fraud: Are you vulnerable?Dr Gordon Murray
 
A view of procurement best practice
A view of procurement best practiceA view of procurement best practice
A view of procurement best practiceDr Gordon Murray
 
A General View Of The Modernisation Process
A General View Of The Modernisation ProcessA General View Of The Modernisation Process
A General View Of The Modernisation ProcessDr Gordon Murray
 
Effective Specification Writing
Effective Specification WritingEffective Specification Writing
Effective Specification WritingDr Gordon Murray
 
Effective Contract Management
Effective Contract ManagementEffective Contract Management
Effective Contract ManagementDr Gordon Murray
 
101018 czech parimentary committee re commissionisioning
101018 czech parimentary committee re commissionisioning101018 czech parimentary committee re commissionisioning
101018 czech parimentary committee re commissionisioningDr Gordon Murray
 
Strategic procurement for councillors
Strategic procurement for councillorsStrategic procurement for councillors
Strategic procurement for councillorsDr Gordon Murray
 
031114 PhD thesis final copy
031114 PhD thesis final copy031114 PhD thesis final copy
031114 PhD thesis final copyDr Gordon Murray
 
Getting research knowledge into the practitioner community
Getting research knowledge into the practitioner communityGetting research knowledge into the practitioner community
Getting research knowledge into the practitioner communityDr Gordon Murray
 

More from Dr Gordon Murray (15)

Procurement challenges
Procurement challengesProcurement challenges
Procurement challenges
 
Penny wise procurement strategies-long-term-effectiveness-short-term-wins 1012-1
Penny wise procurement strategies-long-term-effectiveness-short-term-wins 1012-1Penny wise procurement strategies-long-term-effectiveness-short-term-wins 1012-1
Penny wise procurement strategies-long-term-effectiveness-short-term-wins 1012-1
 
Effective supplier-engagement-strategy-0316-1
Effective supplier-engagement-strategy-0316-1Effective supplier-engagement-strategy-0316-1
Effective supplier-engagement-strategy-0316-1
 
Digital procurement strategy-0513-1
Digital procurement strategy-0513-1Digital procurement strategy-0513-1
Digital procurement strategy-0513-1
 
Addressing tail spend
Addressing tail spendAddressing tail spend
Addressing tail spend
 
Procurement fraud: Are you vulnerable?
Procurement fraud: Are you vulnerable?Procurement fraud: Are you vulnerable?
Procurement fraud: Are you vulnerable?
 
A view of procurement best practice
A view of procurement best practiceA view of procurement best practice
A view of procurement best practice
 
A General View Of The Modernisation Process
A General View Of The Modernisation ProcessA General View Of The Modernisation Process
A General View Of The Modernisation Process
 
Effective Specification Writing
Effective Specification WritingEffective Specification Writing
Effective Specification Writing
 
Effective Contract Management
Effective Contract ManagementEffective Contract Management
Effective Contract Management
 
101018 czech parimentary committee re commissionisioning
101018 czech parimentary committee re commissionisioning101018 czech parimentary committee re commissionisioning
101018 czech parimentary committee re commissionisioning
 
Strategic procurement for councillors
Strategic procurement for councillorsStrategic procurement for councillors
Strategic procurement for councillors
 
031114 PhD thesis final copy
031114 PhD thesis final copy031114 PhD thesis final copy
031114 PhD thesis final copy
 
Getting research knowledge into the practitioner community
Getting research knowledge into the practitioner communityGetting research knowledge into the practitioner community
Getting research knowledge into the practitioner community
 
Efficiency Exchange
Efficiency ExchangeEfficiency Exchange
Efficiency Exchange
 

IPSERA Debate The Case For Differentiated Procurement Education

  • 1. Does public and private sector procurement education merit a separate syllabus? Dr Gordon Murray
  • 2. You can have the right professional qualification but does that mean you know the right things?
  • 3.
  • 4. The debate is not about difference I don’t want a different public sector procurement qualification, I want all the private sector procurement knowledge plus public sector dimensions
  • 5. Defining procurement and all that stuff Strategic needs assessment Decide priorities and outcomes Plan and design services Optional appraisal Sourcing Delivery Monitor and review The commissioning cycle Determine the need Supplier selection Contracting Ordering Expediting Follow-up/ evaluation The purchasing cycle procurement
  • 6. To define the local government procurement ‘professional’ follow the money Dir Social Services (ADSS) Asset mgrs (RICS ) Waste managers (IWM ) Highways eng. (CHIT) Architects (RIBA) ICT (SOCITM) Marketing (CIM) Procurement (CIPS) GPs Spend University provision of procurement education
  • 7.
  • 8. The ideal would be a comprehensive procurement education for motivated students without a time constraint but “… the time is short ”
  • 9. If you have to ration/prioritise, where do you start? Segmentation and targeting
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15. The answer is in the word ‘merit’ Justice to students & sponsors Breadth & depth of the body of knowledge Merit common core content, targeted at range of levels & ‘ sector specific’ essential content but not always separate delivery Given time constraint + + =
  • 16. The answer is in the word ‘merit’ Justice to students & sponsors Breadth & depth of the body of knowledge Merit common core content, targeted at range of levels & ‘ sector specific’ essential content but not always separate delivery Given time constraint + + =

Editor's Notes

  1. Unfortunately, I'm not confident all these are covered anyway! - You decide from your perspective?