SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  3
EESC Conference
Elizabeth Collett – presentation notes

Immigration as an opportunity- the transatlantic experience

Thank you for the opportunity to speak here today.

MPI Europe is a Brussels-based independent thinktank that that aims to provide a better
understanding of migration in Europe and thus promote effective policymaking. To do so, MPI
Europe builds on the resources of MPI, headquartered in Washington DC, and one of the flagship
projects of MPI is the Transatlantic Council on Migration. As such, my remarks today will focus
upon the transatlantic experiences of, and attitudes toward, immigration, and the kinds of
‘wealths’ that immigration has delivered.

In Europe, a great deal of energy has been expended upon quantifying the economic ‘costs and
benefits’ of immigration across the continent. Such studies can, on the whole, determine the
outcomes through their methodology. In the UK alone one can find studies highlighting greater
benefits as well as those highlighting greater costs.

The implication of these studies is that immigration is only a public good, and an opportunity, if it
conveys significant economic benefits, as this is the only way it can balance out a widespread
assumptive belief that immigration is socially costly for Europeans.

For the smaller cabal of immigration experts, the concept of opportunity is far broader than the
purely economic, and extends towards the contribution to the labour market and Europe’s skills
pool, the possibility of ameliorating demographic decline, and the cultural contributions that a
diverse society can bring.

However, this does not necessarily reverberate with European publics, and majorities of nationals
across Europe express scepticism towards the benefits of immigration and believe it presents more
of a problem than an opportunity.

In this regard, it is interesting to assess the experience across the Atlantic, and correlate it with the
current political debates in Europe. The remainder of my remarks will draw heavily from two
papers commissioned by MPI for a meeting of the Transatlantic Council on Migration that focused
the interplay between immigration, identity formation and society:
 - Irene Bloemraad – Understanding Canadian Exceptionalism
 - Michael Jones-Correa – Contested Ground
 For those of you interested, these papers can be found on MPI’s website, along with a set of
 corresponding papers for the UK, Germany, Spain, France.

First, the US:
The United States has historically always perceived itself as a country of immigration – the
proverbial ‘melting pot’. However, this does not mean that immigration has been seen as a
positive development, as successive prejudices towards waves of immigrants to the US – whether
Italian, Polish, or Mexican – may attest.

Despite high numbers of immigrants in the US (40m of 309m immigrant in 2010), and the
dominance of immigrant background within the US population as a whole, the overall attitude to
immigration is ambivalent, coloured by anxiety over levels of unauthorised migration from Central
America (and particularly Mexico). Such ambivalence tends to be conceptual in practice: individual
immigrants who arrive and work hard are celebrated; it is the whole of ‘immigration’ that causes
anxiety.

However, the perception from this side of the Atlantic is that, regardless of national attitudes of US
citizens towards immigration, the US as a whole is realising the value (the opportunity) of
immigration in a way that Europe is not.

This is perhaps because, economically at least, this is the case:
- Immigrants benefit native incomes: An MPI study on the impact of immigration on overall
     wages levels found that between 1990 and 2006, there was a 2.9% increase in real wages for
     the average US worker.
- Immigrants create businesses: immigrants are 30% more likely to be entrepreneurs, and 18%
     of all US businesses are immigrant owned.
- Immigrants create jobs: immigrant businesses employed 4.7 people in 2007;

This suggests that the idea of immigration as an opportunity is taken as a given for the US. It is
understood as a positive thing, and the current debate in the US on Comprehensive Immigration
Reform reflects this: that regularisation of unauthorised workers would be economically and
socially positive is implicit within the debate and the central question is whether they should also
be allowed access to permanent residence and citizenship, and on what basis.

Turning to Canada, the experience is very different:
Canadian citizens have overwhelmingly positive attitudes towards immigration, at levels that have
remained stable since the 1970s. This is despite the fact that the immigrant population in Canada is
far higher than that in most European countries – around 20% compared to around 12% in other
major countries of immigration in Europe.

Why is this? Some posit that it is Canada’s points system – which rigorously selects new
immigrants, and perceived control of the system, supported by the fact that Canada is remotely
located, and far from major countries of origin, unlike the US and the EU.
But Bloemraad highlights that Canada’s points system and geography are insufficient to explain
this positive opinion, which holds even for groups typically sceptical of immigration, such as the
unemployed. (80% of the country thinks immigration is positive for the economy, including 68% of
the unemployed).

Rather, for Canadians, their exceptionalism is found in the fact that immigration is seen as a part of
nation-building, and integral to national identity. Research in Canada found that the more patriotic
a citizen, the more likely they were to support immigration and multiculturalism. For Canadian’s
the idea that immigration is an opportunity for the nation is hardwired – or mainstreamed – into
public opinion.

There are questions about whether this positive approach will be sustainable in an era of more
diverse immigration, and emerging inequalities for those with immigrant or minority background.

What can Europe learn from this?
- First, that you do not need to regard immigration as an opportunity to realise its benefits….
   But it helps. While a lot can be learned from the Canadian experience, the idea of replanting
   the ideas comprised within the long-term nation-building process
- Second, that the opportunities presented by immigration are substantially reduced in a
   context of persistent inequality, or whether social mobility is stymied by discrimination.
-   Third, the opportunities can be squandered by poor policy-making, and failure to capitalise on
    the value presented by immigrants in terms of recognising skills, and encouraging social and
    political participation.

For Europeans, there is a significant risk that viewing immigration as a risk rather than an
opportunity will become a self-fulfilling prophecy. Policies currently assume the spirit of minimising
risk, rather than maximising opportunity – from short-term work permits, integration conditions
for immigrants, and limiting access to citizenship – which can limit the potential that is presented
by immigrants and their families.

Contenu connexe

Tendances

globalization and Pakistan
globalization and Pakistanglobalization and Pakistan
globalization and PakistanTahreem Mehmood
 
What is DE- Globalization & its examples
What is DE- Globalization & its examplesWhat is DE- Globalization & its examples
What is DE- Globalization & its examplesDEEPAK KUMAR
 
Anti Globalization goes Global
Anti Globalization goes GlobalAnti Globalization goes Global
Anti Globalization goes GlobalDinesh Kumar
 
Globalization and Justice Essay Sample
Globalization and Justice Essay SampleGlobalization and Justice Essay Sample
Globalization and Justice Essay Sampleessayprime
 
Presentation on Globalization
Presentation on GlobalizationPresentation on Globalization
Presentation on GlobalizationESSAYSHARK.com
 
Introduction To Globalization
Introduction To GlobalizationIntroduction To Globalization
Introduction To Globalizationbobjohan
 
Globalization and Youth
Globalization and Youth Globalization and Youth
Globalization and Youth stepbystep
 
The Contemporary World - Topics 1-4
The Contemporary World - Topics 1-4The Contemporary World - Topics 1-4
The Contemporary World - Topics 1-4Jojean de la Cruz
 
Globallization Vs Anti Globalization
Globallization Vs Anti GlobalizationGloballization Vs Anti Globalization
Globallization Vs Anti GlobalizationSurya Srivastava
 
Communication and globalization
Communication and globalizationCommunication and globalization
Communication and globalizationEliasTaragua
 
Migration And Push Pull Factors
Migration And Push Pull FactorsMigration And Push Pull Factors
Migration And Push Pull Factorstudorgeog
 
Managing the risks of international trade
Managing the risks of international tradeManaging the risks of international trade
Managing the risks of international tradeadnanessa
 
The impact of globalization,chukwuma ike 1and udochukwu ogbaji 2
The impact of globalization,chukwuma ike 1and udochukwu ogbaji 2The impact of globalization,chukwuma ike 1and udochukwu ogbaji 2
The impact of globalization,chukwuma ike 1and udochukwu ogbaji 2ogbaji udochukwu
 
Bejasa rico cw_globalization1
Bejasa rico cw_globalization1Bejasa rico cw_globalization1
Bejasa rico cw_globalization1Rico Allan Bejasa
 

Tendances (20)

globalization and Pakistan
globalization and Pakistanglobalization and Pakistan
globalization and Pakistan
 
What is DE- Globalization & its examples
What is DE- Globalization & its examplesWhat is DE- Globalization & its examples
What is DE- Globalization & its examples
 
Globalization
GlobalizationGlobalization
Globalization
 
Anti Globalization goes Global
Anti Globalization goes GlobalAnti Globalization goes Global
Anti Globalization goes Global
 
Globalization and Justice Essay Sample
Globalization and Justice Essay SampleGlobalization and Justice Essay Sample
Globalization and Justice Essay Sample
 
Presentation on Globalization
Presentation on GlobalizationPresentation on Globalization
Presentation on Globalization
 
Introduction to globalization and developing countries
Introduction to globalization and developing countriesIntroduction to globalization and developing countries
Introduction to globalization and developing countries
 
Globalization
GlobalizationGlobalization
Globalization
 
Introduction To Globalization
Introduction To GlobalizationIntroduction To Globalization
Introduction To Globalization
 
Globalization and its Impact on Organizational Change
Globalization and its Impact on Organizational ChangeGlobalization and its Impact on Organizational Change
Globalization and its Impact on Organizational Change
 
Globalization and Youth
Globalization and Youth Globalization and Youth
Globalization and Youth
 
The Contemporary World - Topics 1-4
The Contemporary World - Topics 1-4The Contemporary World - Topics 1-4
The Contemporary World - Topics 1-4
 
Globalisation
GlobalisationGlobalisation
Globalisation
 
Globalization
GlobalizationGlobalization
Globalization
 
Globallization Vs Anti Globalization
Globallization Vs Anti GlobalizationGloballization Vs Anti Globalization
Globallization Vs Anti Globalization
 
Communication and globalization
Communication and globalizationCommunication and globalization
Communication and globalization
 
Migration And Push Pull Factors
Migration And Push Pull FactorsMigration And Push Pull Factors
Migration And Push Pull Factors
 
Managing the risks of international trade
Managing the risks of international tradeManaging the risks of international trade
Managing the risks of international trade
 
The impact of globalization,chukwuma ike 1and udochukwu ogbaji 2
The impact of globalization,chukwuma ike 1and udochukwu ogbaji 2The impact of globalization,chukwuma ike 1and udochukwu ogbaji 2
The impact of globalization,chukwuma ike 1and udochukwu ogbaji 2
 
Bejasa rico cw_globalization1
Bejasa rico cw_globalization1Bejasa rico cw_globalization1
Bejasa rico cw_globalization1
 

En vedette

Tutorial pixlr tool_box
Tutorial pixlr tool_boxTutorial pixlr tool_box
Tutorial pixlr tool_boxSirui Wang
 
Sabrina iab local search - sis
Sabrina iab   local search - sisSabrina iab   local search - sis
Sabrina iab local search - sisSabrinaIAB
 
UX-Pshycology-by-HT Final
UX-Pshycology-by-HT FinalUX-Pshycology-by-HT Final
UX-Pshycology-by-HT FinalHirosh Tharaka
 
Thailand Automotive Sales Statistics by PPV Segment February 2016
Thailand Automotive Sales Statistics by PPV Segment February 2016Thailand Automotive Sales Statistics by PPV Segment February 2016
Thailand Automotive Sales Statistics by PPV Segment February 2016Uli Kaiser
 
Higiene industrial
Higiene industrialHigiene industrial
Higiene industrialandreasotoa
 
Clarity go - New Upgrade: UAKARI
Clarity go - New Upgrade: UAKARIClarity go - New Upgrade: UAKARI
Clarity go - New Upgrade: UAKARIClarity Software
 
3º ano caráter acidobásico de substâncias orgânicas e reações de substituição
3º ano   caráter acidobásico de substâncias orgânicas e reações de substituição3º ano   caráter acidobásico de substâncias orgânicas e reações de substituição
3º ano caráter acidobásico de substâncias orgânicas e reações de substituiçãoAnalynne Almeida
 
O impacto da rotatividade na Gestão do Conhecimento Organizacional. A rotativ...
O impacto da rotatividade na Gestão do Conhecimento Organizacional. A rotativ...O impacto da rotatividade na Gestão do Conhecimento Organizacional. A rotativ...
O impacto da rotatividade na Gestão do Conhecimento Organizacional. A rotativ...Luis Borges Gouveia
 
ANUPAM MAHAL CURRICULUM VITAE
ANUPAM MAHAL CURRICULUM VITAEANUPAM MAHAL CURRICULUM VITAE
ANUPAM MAHAL CURRICULUM VITAEAnupam Mahal
 
הטרדה מינית במקום העבודה
הטרדה מינית במקום העבודההטרדה מינית במקום העבודה
הטרדה מינית במקום העבודהIdan Almog
 
IBISBA_an infrastructrue for IB
IBISBA_an infrastructrue for IBIBISBA_an infrastructrue for IB
IBISBA_an infrastructrue for IBMichael O'Donohue
 
Cocos2d-x(JS) ハンズオン #02 「画像表示とアクション」
Cocos2d-x(JS) ハンズオン #02 「画像表示とアクション」Cocos2d-x(JS) ハンズオン #02 「画像表示とアクション」
Cocos2d-x(JS) ハンズオン #02 「画像表示とアクション」Tomoaki Shimizu
 
Nature of communication
Nature of communicationNature of communication
Nature of communicationShadman Ameen
 
Shampoo preparations and basic review
Shampoo preparations and basic review Shampoo preparations and basic review
Shampoo preparations and basic review ajith kakaraparthi
 
TestLink introduction
TestLink introductionTestLink introduction
TestLink introductionDavid Ionut
 

En vedette (20)

Tutorial pixlr tool_box
Tutorial pixlr tool_boxTutorial pixlr tool_box
Tutorial pixlr tool_box
 
Sabrina iab local search - sis
Sabrina iab   local search - sisSabrina iab   local search - sis
Sabrina iab local search - sis
 
untitled
untitleduntitled
untitled
 
Client recommendation 2
Client recommendation 2Client recommendation 2
Client recommendation 2
 
UX-Pshycology-by-HT Final
UX-Pshycology-by-HT FinalUX-Pshycology-by-HT Final
UX-Pshycology-by-HT Final
 
Thailand Automotive Sales Statistics by PPV Segment February 2016
Thailand Automotive Sales Statistics by PPV Segment February 2016Thailand Automotive Sales Statistics by PPV Segment February 2016
Thailand Automotive Sales Statistics by PPV Segment February 2016
 
Higiene industrial
Higiene industrialHigiene industrial
Higiene industrial
 
Maquillaje
MaquillajeMaquillaje
Maquillaje
 
Clarity go - New Upgrade: UAKARI
Clarity go - New Upgrade: UAKARIClarity go - New Upgrade: UAKARI
Clarity go - New Upgrade: UAKARI
 
isomeria
isomeriaisomeria
isomeria
 
3º ano caráter acidobásico de substâncias orgânicas e reações de substituição
3º ano   caráter acidobásico de substâncias orgânicas e reações de substituição3º ano   caráter acidobásico de substâncias orgânicas e reações de substituição
3º ano caráter acidobásico de substâncias orgânicas e reações de substituição
 
O impacto da rotatividade na Gestão do Conhecimento Organizacional. A rotativ...
O impacto da rotatividade na Gestão do Conhecimento Organizacional. A rotativ...O impacto da rotatividade na Gestão do Conhecimento Organizacional. A rotativ...
O impacto da rotatividade na Gestão do Conhecimento Organizacional. A rotativ...
 
ANUPAM MAHAL CURRICULUM VITAE
ANUPAM MAHAL CURRICULUM VITAEANUPAM MAHAL CURRICULUM VITAE
ANUPAM MAHAL CURRICULUM VITAE
 
הטרדה מינית במקום העבודה
הטרדה מינית במקום העבודההטרדה מינית במקום העבודה
הטרדה מינית במקום העבודה
 
IBISBA_an infrastructrue for IB
IBISBA_an infrastructrue for IBIBISBA_an infrastructrue for IB
IBISBA_an infrastructrue for IB
 
Cocos2d-x(JS) ハンズオン #02 「画像表示とアクション」
Cocos2d-x(JS) ハンズオン #02 「画像表示とアクション」Cocos2d-x(JS) ハンズオン #02 「画像表示とアクション」
Cocos2d-x(JS) ハンズオン #02 「画像表示とアクション」
 
Nature of communication
Nature of communicationNature of communication
Nature of communication
 
Diapositivas 4 r
Diapositivas 4 rDiapositivas 4 r
Diapositivas 4 r
 
Shampoo preparations and basic review
Shampoo preparations and basic review Shampoo preparations and basic review
Shampoo preparations and basic review
 
TestLink introduction
TestLink introductionTestLink introduction
TestLink introduction
 

Similaire à Immigration as an opportunity- the transatlantic experience

How to Talk About Immigration (Briefly)
How to Talk About Immigration (Briefly)How to Talk About Immigration (Briefly)
How to Talk About Immigration (Briefly)Miqui Mel
 
Immigration And Mexican Immigration
Immigration And Mexican ImmigrationImmigration And Mexican Immigration
Immigration And Mexican ImmigrationMegan Moore
 
LaBe project "How to overcome stereotypes about migrants?"
LaBe project "How to overcome stereotypes about migrants?"LaBe project "How to overcome stereotypes about migrants?"
LaBe project "How to overcome stereotypes about migrants?"LampedusaBerlinProject
 
Immigration Policy Summary
Immigration Policy SummaryImmigration Policy Summary
Immigration Policy SummaryAmanda Barber
 
Transnational Communities - Not Your Grandfather's Diaspora
Transnational Communities - Not Your Grandfather's DiasporaTransnational Communities - Not Your Grandfather's Diaspora
Transnational Communities - Not Your Grandfather's DiasporaInstituto Diáspora Brasil (IDB)
 
IMMIGRATION RESEARCH PAPER (FINAL)
IMMIGRATION RESEARCH PAPER (FINAL)IMMIGRATION RESEARCH PAPER (FINAL)
IMMIGRATION RESEARCH PAPER (FINAL)Conrad Brooks
 
European identity and citizenship: Integration process final
European identity and citizenship: Integration process finalEuropean identity and citizenship: Integration process final
European identity and citizenship: Integration process finalsenior.udc
 
Integration Of Immigrants Vs. Australia
Integration Of Immigrants Vs. AustraliaIntegration Of Immigrants Vs. Australia
Integration Of Immigrants Vs. AustraliaSara Harris
 
Syrian Refugee Crisis Sociological Analysis
Syrian Refugee Crisis Sociological AnalysisSyrian Refugee Crisis Sociological Analysis
Syrian Refugee Crisis Sociological AnalysisAshley Koetter
 
Improving The Immigration Policy
Improving The Immigration PolicyImproving The Immigration Policy
Improving The Immigration PolicyAmy Williams
 
U.S. Immigration Policy: What should we do?
U.S. Immigration Policy: What should we do?U.S. Immigration Policy: What should we do?
U.S. Immigration Policy: What should we do?Everyday Democracy
 
International Capital Mobility Essay Examples
International Capital Mobility Essay ExamplesInternational Capital Mobility Essay Examples
International Capital Mobility Essay ExamplesStacey Wilson
 

Similaire à Immigration as an opportunity- the transatlantic experience (20)

Integration in Spain
Integration in SpainIntegration in Spain
Integration in Spain
 
Causes And Effects Of Immigration
Causes And Effects Of ImmigrationCauses And Effects Of Immigration
Causes And Effects Of Immigration
 
How to Talk About Immigration (Briefly)
How to Talk About Immigration (Briefly)How to Talk About Immigration (Briefly)
How to Talk About Immigration (Briefly)
 
MIGRATION08_FINAL
MIGRATION08_FINALMIGRATION08_FINAL
MIGRATION08_FINAL
 
Immigration And Mexican Immigration
Immigration And Mexican ImmigrationImmigration And Mexican Immigration
Immigration And Mexican Immigration
 
LaBe project "How to overcome stereotypes about migrants?"
LaBe project "How to overcome stereotypes about migrants?"LaBe project "How to overcome stereotypes about migrants?"
LaBe project "How to overcome stereotypes about migrants?"
 
Respect for immigrants' fundamental rights: a duty
Respect for immigrants' fundamental rights: a dutyRespect for immigrants' fundamental rights: a duty
Respect for immigrants' fundamental rights: a duty
 
Undocumented Immigration Outline
Undocumented Immigration OutlineUndocumented Immigration Outline
Undocumented Immigration Outline
 
Immigration Policy Summary
Immigration Policy SummaryImmigration Policy Summary
Immigration Policy Summary
 
Transnational Communities - Not Your Grandfather's Diaspora
Transnational Communities - Not Your Grandfather's DiasporaTransnational Communities - Not Your Grandfather's Diaspora
Transnational Communities - Not Your Grandfather's Diaspora
 
IMMIGRATION RESEARCH PAPER (FINAL)
IMMIGRATION RESEARCH PAPER (FINAL)IMMIGRATION RESEARCH PAPER (FINAL)
IMMIGRATION RESEARCH PAPER (FINAL)
 
Immigration In Canada
Immigration In CanadaImmigration In Canada
Immigration In Canada
 
European identity and citizenship: Integration process final
European identity and citizenship: Integration process finalEuropean identity and citizenship: Integration process final
European identity and citizenship: Integration process final
 
Integration Of Immigrants Vs. Australia
Integration Of Immigrants Vs. AustraliaIntegration Of Immigrants Vs. Australia
Integration Of Immigrants Vs. Australia
 
Syrian Refugee Crisis Sociological Analysis
Syrian Refugee Crisis Sociological AnalysisSyrian Refugee Crisis Sociological Analysis
Syrian Refugee Crisis Sociological Analysis
 
Improving The Immigration Policy
Improving The Immigration PolicyImproving The Immigration Policy
Improving The Immigration Policy
 
Essay On Immigration Paperwork
Essay On Immigration PaperworkEssay On Immigration Paperwork
Essay On Immigration Paperwork
 
U.S. Immigration Policy: What should we do?
U.S. Immigration Policy: What should we do?U.S. Immigration Policy: What should we do?
U.S. Immigration Policy: What should we do?
 
International Capital Mobility Essay Examples
International Capital Mobility Essay ExamplesInternational Capital Mobility Essay Examples
International Capital Mobility Essay Examples
 
Essay On Family Immigration
Essay On Family ImmigrationEssay On Family Immigration
Essay On Family Immigration
 

Plus de European Economic and Social Committee - SOC Section

Plus de European Economic and Social Committee - SOC Section (20)

Interactive ESCO job matching game
Interactive ESCO job matching gameInteractive ESCO job matching game
Interactive ESCO job matching game
 
EU Skills Panorama
EU Skills PanoramaEU Skills Panorama
EU Skills Panorama
 
Sector Skills Alliances
Sector Skills AlliancesSector Skills Alliances
Sector Skills Alliances
 
Eures Targeted Mobility Schemes
Eures Targeted Mobility SchemesEures Targeted Mobility Schemes
Eures Targeted Mobility Schemes
 
Housing & Encampment Areas - A summary of the main conclusions of four CAHROM...
Housing & Encampment Areas - A summary of the main conclusions of four CAHROM...Housing & Encampment Areas - A summary of the main conclusions of four CAHROM...
Housing & Encampment Areas - A summary of the main conclusions of four CAHROM...
 
Roma and travellers' education: a summary of the standards, case-law, project...
Roma and travellers' education: a summary of the standards, case-law, project...Roma and travellers' education: a summary of the standards, case-law, project...
Roma and travellers' education: a summary of the standards, case-law, project...
 
CAHROM
CAHROMCAHROM
CAHROM
 
Roma education fund
Roma education fundRoma education fund
Roma education fund
 
Roma and education
Roma and educationRoma and education
Roma and education
 
The Roma and Employment - state of play, evaluation of measures adopted, main...
The Roma and Employment - state of play, evaluation of measures adopted, main...The Roma and Employment - state of play, evaluation of measures adopted, main...
The Roma and Employment - state of play, evaluation of measures adopted, main...
 
ERDF support for Roma inclusion in the 2014-2020 programming period - Housing...
ERDF support for Roma inclusion in the 2014-2020 programming period - Housing...ERDF support for Roma inclusion in the 2014-2020 programming period - Housing...
ERDF support for Roma inclusion in the 2014-2020 programming period - Housing...
 
A rural alliance - Cooperation Esbeek
A rural alliance - Cooperation EsbeekA rural alliance - Cooperation Esbeek
A rural alliance - Cooperation Esbeek
 
Social investment in Wales
Social investment in WalesSocial investment in Wales
Social investment in Wales
 
How Social Economy and Social Enterprises are concretely contributing to soci...
How Social Economy and Social Enterprises are concretely contributing to soci...How Social Economy and Social Enterprises are concretely contributing to soci...
How Social Economy and Social Enterprises are concretely contributing to soci...
 
Rethinking Development - The role of Social and Solidarity Economy
Rethinking Development - The role of Social and Solidarity EconomyRethinking Development - The role of Social and Solidarity Economy
Rethinking Development - The role of Social and Solidarity Economy
 
Learning from outside the EU - What are other international organisations doi...
Learning from outside the EU - What are other international organisations doi...Learning from outside the EU - What are other international organisations doi...
Learning from outside the EU - What are other international organisations doi...
 
Social Innovation - What the Commission does about it
Social Innovation - What the Commission does about itSocial Innovation - What the Commission does about it
Social Innovation - What the Commission does about it
 
Social Economy Entreprises - Cooperatives, Mutuals, Foundations, Associations...
Social Economy Entreprises - Cooperatives, Mutuals, Foundations, Associations...Social Economy Entreprises - Cooperatives, Mutuals, Foundations, Associations...
Social Economy Entreprises - Cooperatives, Mutuals, Foundations, Associations...
 
Is the EU putting its money where its mouth is? The use of Structural Funds ...
 Is the EU putting its money where its mouth is? The use of Structural Funds ... Is the EU putting its money where its mouth is? The use of Structural Funds ...
Is the EU putting its money where its mouth is? The use of Structural Funds ...
 
Disability in the Mid-term review of Europe 2020
Disability in the Mid-term review of Europe 2020Disability in the Mid-term review of Europe 2020
Disability in the Mid-term review of Europe 2020
 

Dernier

Green Aesthetic Ripped Paper Thesis Defense Presentation_20240311_111012_0000...
Green Aesthetic Ripped Paper Thesis Defense Presentation_20240311_111012_0000...Green Aesthetic Ripped Paper Thesis Defense Presentation_20240311_111012_0000...
Green Aesthetic Ripped Paper Thesis Defense Presentation_20240311_111012_0000...virgfern3011
 
Another Day, Another Default Judgment Against Gabe Whitley
Another Day, Another Default Judgment Against Gabe WhitleyAnother Day, Another Default Judgment Against Gabe Whitley
Another Day, Another Default Judgment Against Gabe WhitleyAbdul-Hakim Shabazz
 
Anantkumar Hegde
Anantkumar Hegde  Anantkumar Hegde
Anantkumar Hegde NewsFeed1
 
Por estos dos motivos, defensa de JOH solicita repetir juicio
Por estos dos motivos, defensa de JOH solicita repetir juicioPor estos dos motivos, defensa de JOH solicita repetir juicio
Por estos dos motivos, defensa de JOH solicita repetir juicioAlexisTorres963861
 
Européennes 2024 : projection du Parlement européen à trois mois du scrutin
Européennes 2024 : projection du Parlement européen à trois mois du scrutinEuropéennes 2024 : projection du Parlement européen à trois mois du scrutin
Européennes 2024 : projection du Parlement européen à trois mois du scrutinIpsos France
 
Light Rail in Canberra: Too much, too little, too late: Is the price worth th...
Light Rail in Canberra: Too much, too little, too late: Is the price worth th...Light Rail in Canberra: Too much, too little, too late: Is the price worth th...
Light Rail in Canberra: Too much, too little, too late: Is the price worth th...University of Canberra
 
One India vs United India by Dream Tamilnadu
One India vs United India by Dream TamilnaduOne India vs United India by Dream Tamilnadu
One India vs United India by Dream TamilnaduDreamTamilnadu
 
19032024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
19032024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf19032024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
19032024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdfFIRST INDIA
 
Ministry of Justice Extradition Eswatini 3.pdf
Ministry of Justice Extradition Eswatini 3.pdfMinistry of Justice Extradition Eswatini 3.pdf
Ministry of Justice Extradition Eswatini 3.pdfSABC News
 

Dernier (9)

Green Aesthetic Ripped Paper Thesis Defense Presentation_20240311_111012_0000...
Green Aesthetic Ripped Paper Thesis Defense Presentation_20240311_111012_0000...Green Aesthetic Ripped Paper Thesis Defense Presentation_20240311_111012_0000...
Green Aesthetic Ripped Paper Thesis Defense Presentation_20240311_111012_0000...
 
Another Day, Another Default Judgment Against Gabe Whitley
Another Day, Another Default Judgment Against Gabe WhitleyAnother Day, Another Default Judgment Against Gabe Whitley
Another Day, Another Default Judgment Against Gabe Whitley
 
Anantkumar Hegde
Anantkumar Hegde  Anantkumar Hegde
Anantkumar Hegde
 
Por estos dos motivos, defensa de JOH solicita repetir juicio
Por estos dos motivos, defensa de JOH solicita repetir juicioPor estos dos motivos, defensa de JOH solicita repetir juicio
Por estos dos motivos, defensa de JOH solicita repetir juicio
 
Européennes 2024 : projection du Parlement européen à trois mois du scrutin
Européennes 2024 : projection du Parlement européen à trois mois du scrutinEuropéennes 2024 : projection du Parlement européen à trois mois du scrutin
Européennes 2024 : projection du Parlement européen à trois mois du scrutin
 
Light Rail in Canberra: Too much, too little, too late: Is the price worth th...
Light Rail in Canberra: Too much, too little, too late: Is the price worth th...Light Rail in Canberra: Too much, too little, too late: Is the price worth th...
Light Rail in Canberra: Too much, too little, too late: Is the price worth th...
 
One India vs United India by Dream Tamilnadu
One India vs United India by Dream TamilnaduOne India vs United India by Dream Tamilnadu
One India vs United India by Dream Tamilnadu
 
19032024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
19032024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf19032024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
19032024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
 
Ministry of Justice Extradition Eswatini 3.pdf
Ministry of Justice Extradition Eswatini 3.pdfMinistry of Justice Extradition Eswatini 3.pdf
Ministry of Justice Extradition Eswatini 3.pdf
 

Immigration as an opportunity- the transatlantic experience

  • 1. EESC Conference Elizabeth Collett – presentation notes Immigration as an opportunity- the transatlantic experience Thank you for the opportunity to speak here today. MPI Europe is a Brussels-based independent thinktank that that aims to provide a better understanding of migration in Europe and thus promote effective policymaking. To do so, MPI Europe builds on the resources of MPI, headquartered in Washington DC, and one of the flagship projects of MPI is the Transatlantic Council on Migration. As such, my remarks today will focus upon the transatlantic experiences of, and attitudes toward, immigration, and the kinds of ‘wealths’ that immigration has delivered. In Europe, a great deal of energy has been expended upon quantifying the economic ‘costs and benefits’ of immigration across the continent. Such studies can, on the whole, determine the outcomes through their methodology. In the UK alone one can find studies highlighting greater benefits as well as those highlighting greater costs. The implication of these studies is that immigration is only a public good, and an opportunity, if it conveys significant economic benefits, as this is the only way it can balance out a widespread assumptive belief that immigration is socially costly for Europeans. For the smaller cabal of immigration experts, the concept of opportunity is far broader than the purely economic, and extends towards the contribution to the labour market and Europe’s skills pool, the possibility of ameliorating demographic decline, and the cultural contributions that a diverse society can bring. However, this does not necessarily reverberate with European publics, and majorities of nationals across Europe express scepticism towards the benefits of immigration and believe it presents more of a problem than an opportunity. In this regard, it is interesting to assess the experience across the Atlantic, and correlate it with the current political debates in Europe. The remainder of my remarks will draw heavily from two papers commissioned by MPI for a meeting of the Transatlantic Council on Migration that focused the interplay between immigration, identity formation and society: - Irene Bloemraad – Understanding Canadian Exceptionalism - Michael Jones-Correa – Contested Ground For those of you interested, these papers can be found on MPI’s website, along with a set of corresponding papers for the UK, Germany, Spain, France. First, the US: The United States has historically always perceived itself as a country of immigration – the proverbial ‘melting pot’. However, this does not mean that immigration has been seen as a positive development, as successive prejudices towards waves of immigrants to the US – whether Italian, Polish, or Mexican – may attest. Despite high numbers of immigrants in the US (40m of 309m immigrant in 2010), and the dominance of immigrant background within the US population as a whole, the overall attitude to immigration is ambivalent, coloured by anxiety over levels of unauthorised migration from Central America (and particularly Mexico). Such ambivalence tends to be conceptual in practice: individual
  • 2. immigrants who arrive and work hard are celebrated; it is the whole of ‘immigration’ that causes anxiety. However, the perception from this side of the Atlantic is that, regardless of national attitudes of US citizens towards immigration, the US as a whole is realising the value (the opportunity) of immigration in a way that Europe is not. This is perhaps because, economically at least, this is the case: - Immigrants benefit native incomes: An MPI study on the impact of immigration on overall wages levels found that between 1990 and 2006, there was a 2.9% increase in real wages for the average US worker. - Immigrants create businesses: immigrants are 30% more likely to be entrepreneurs, and 18% of all US businesses are immigrant owned. - Immigrants create jobs: immigrant businesses employed 4.7 people in 2007; This suggests that the idea of immigration as an opportunity is taken as a given for the US. It is understood as a positive thing, and the current debate in the US on Comprehensive Immigration Reform reflects this: that regularisation of unauthorised workers would be economically and socially positive is implicit within the debate and the central question is whether they should also be allowed access to permanent residence and citizenship, and on what basis. Turning to Canada, the experience is very different: Canadian citizens have overwhelmingly positive attitudes towards immigration, at levels that have remained stable since the 1970s. This is despite the fact that the immigrant population in Canada is far higher than that in most European countries – around 20% compared to around 12% in other major countries of immigration in Europe. Why is this? Some posit that it is Canada’s points system – which rigorously selects new immigrants, and perceived control of the system, supported by the fact that Canada is remotely located, and far from major countries of origin, unlike the US and the EU. But Bloemraad highlights that Canada’s points system and geography are insufficient to explain this positive opinion, which holds even for groups typically sceptical of immigration, such as the unemployed. (80% of the country thinks immigration is positive for the economy, including 68% of the unemployed). Rather, for Canadians, their exceptionalism is found in the fact that immigration is seen as a part of nation-building, and integral to national identity. Research in Canada found that the more patriotic a citizen, the more likely they were to support immigration and multiculturalism. For Canadian’s the idea that immigration is an opportunity for the nation is hardwired – or mainstreamed – into public opinion. There are questions about whether this positive approach will be sustainable in an era of more diverse immigration, and emerging inequalities for those with immigrant or minority background. What can Europe learn from this? - First, that you do not need to regard immigration as an opportunity to realise its benefits…. But it helps. While a lot can be learned from the Canadian experience, the idea of replanting the ideas comprised within the long-term nation-building process - Second, that the opportunities presented by immigration are substantially reduced in a context of persistent inequality, or whether social mobility is stymied by discrimination.
  • 3. - Third, the opportunities can be squandered by poor policy-making, and failure to capitalise on the value presented by immigrants in terms of recognising skills, and encouraging social and political participation. For Europeans, there is a significant risk that viewing immigration as a risk rather than an opportunity will become a self-fulfilling prophecy. Policies currently assume the spirit of minimising risk, rather than maximising opportunity – from short-term work permits, integration conditions for immigrants, and limiting access to citizenship – which can limit the potential that is presented by immigrants and their families.