SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  9
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Mandibular arch form: The relationship
between dental and basal anatomy
Valerie Ronay,a
R. Matthew Miner,b
Leslie A. Will,c
and Kazuhito Araid
Vienna, Austria, Boston, Mass, and Tokyo, Japan
Introduction: We investigated mandibular dental arch form at the levels of both the clinically relevant
application points of the orthodontic bracket and the underlying anatomic structure of the apical base. The
correlation of both forms was evaluated and examined to determine whether the basal arch could be used
to derive a standardized clinical arch form. Methods: Thirty-five mandibular dental casts (skeletal and dental
Class I) were laser scanned, and a 3-dimensional virtual model was created. Two reference points (FA, the
most prominent part of the central lobe on each crown’s facial surface, and WALA, a point at the height of
the mucogingival junction) were selected for each tooth from the right to the left first molars. The FA and
WALA arch forms were compared, and the distances between corresponding points and intercanine and
intermolar widths were analyzed. Results: Both arch forms were highly individual and the tooth values
scattered. Nevertheless, a highly significant relationship between the FA and WALA curves was found,
especially in the canine (0.75) and molar (0.87) areas. Conclusions: Both FA and WALA point-derived arch
forms were individual and therefore could not be defined by a generalized shape. WALA points proved to be
a useful representation of the apical base and helpful in the predetermination of an individualized dental arch
form. (Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop 2008;134:430-8)
T
he size and shape of the dental arches have
considerable implications for orthodontic diagno-
sis and treatment planning. These factors have an
effect on space available, stability of the dentition, and
dental esthetics. Furthermore, the definition of arch form
would improve the understanding of malocclusion and
assist clinicians in producing orthodontic results that are
consistent with the natural laws of biologic variation.
Although most arch form studies have looked at similar
patient samples—subjects with orthodontically untreated
ideal occlusions—few come even close to agreement
about the natural shape of the dental arch. It is commonly
believed that the dental arch form is initially shaped by the
configuration of its supporting bone.1
Nevertheless, 2
opposing theories about modifying the dental arch form
have coexisted for 100 years.2,3
The bone-growing theory is that the supporting
bone grows in response to normal stimulation, such as
mastication, if the teeth are aligned in the ideal position.
Angle4
reported stable orthodontic treatment results of
his expanded crowding patients and first advocated the
bone-growing theory. In the latter part of the 19th
century a basic biologic principle was introduced called
Wolff’s law in which the bone structure changes in
response to external force. According to this theory,
tooth size is controlled by heredity, but size and shape
of the supporting bones depend largely on environmen-
tal stimuli including eruption of the teeth, pressure from
tongue and cheek, and mastication. For example, a
small mandible can result from the lack of healthy jaw
function and indicates degeneration.5
This approach
resulted in fewer extractions and is often called the
nonextraction theory.
According to the “apical base” theory, the size and
shape of the supporting bone are largely under genetic
control, and there is a limit to expansion of a dental arch.
In 1925, Lundström6
proposed a new term—apical
base—to describe the limits of expansion of the dental
arch and wrote extensively on this topic. He stated that the
apical base (1) is not changed after loss of teeth, (2) is not
influenced by orthodontic tooth movement or masticatory
function, and (3) limits the size of dental arch. If the teeth
are orthodontically moved beyond this limit, labial or
buccal tipping of the teeth,6
periodontal problems,7
or an
unstable treatment result8
could be expected.2
One of
Angle’s students, Tweed,9
also observed unstable results
after nonextraction treatment with Angle’s mechanics
a
Student, Clinic of Dentistry, Vienna University, Vienna, Austria.
b
Assistant clinical professor, Department of Developmental Biology, Harvard
School of Dental Medicine, Boston, Mass.
c
Professor and graduate program director, Department of Orthodontics, Tufts
University School of Dental Medicine, Boston, Mass.
d
Assistant professor, Department of Orthodontics, Nippon Dental University,
Tokyo, Japan; visiting professor, Department of Developmental Biology,
Harvard School of Dental Medicine, Boston, Mass.
Reprint requests to: R. Matthew Miner, One Lyons St, Dedham, MA 02026;
e-mail, r_miner@hsdm.harvard.edu.
Submitted, April 2006; revised and accepted, October 2006.
0889-5406/$34.00
Copyright © 2008 by the American Association of Orthodontists.
doi:10.1016/j.ajodo.2006.10.040
430
during the 1930s. He established his diagnostic analysis in
favor of extraction and refined the mechanics for extrac-
tion treatment. Simultaneously, another Angle student,
Begg,10
also changed to the extraction technique and
sought anthropologic evidence for extraction treatment
because of less mastication required in modern diets.
Since then, this theory was confirmed by case reports, and
most orthodontists are now convinced of the validity of
this theory.11,12
However, an objective limit for buccal or
labial tooth movement in any patient, especially those
with mild crowding, is still not available today.2
As the frequency of extraction orthodontic treatment
has decreased over the last 30 years, a new bone-growing
theory has emerged. Esthetic preference for fuller profiles,
temporomandibular disorder problems,2
and the emer-
gence of functional appliance therapy13
were contributing
factors, but, most significantly, it was found that extrac-
tion did not insure stability.14
With stability not guaran-
teed, extraction treatment lost much of its perceived
advantage. Recently, the clinical results of a new orth-
odontic appliance were reported.15
Its developer claimed
that buccal tooth movements without tipping could be
achieved with his biocompatible appliance with extremely
light forces. Computed tomography images of expanded
teeth from severely crowded dental arches were shown,
and apparently healthy alveolar bone was demonstrated as
evidence for this bone-growing theory. Most clinicians,
however, still explain to their patients that there might be
a limit for expansion of the dental arch with any appliance.
Furthermore, we still do not know exactly the limit for
each patient.
The purpose of this study was to investigate the
relationship between the dental arch form and the
supporting bone. We hypothesized that there is a
quantifiable relationship between basal and dental arch
forms, and that basal-bone landmarks can be used as
reliable references for determining biologic arch form
in clinical orthodontics.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
The mandibular dental casts of 35 patients (13
male, 22 female) were randomly selected from a
sample of 750. The mandible was studied because
therapeutic possibilities are more limited than in the
maxilla, and the maxillary arch form is strongly asso-
ciated with the mandibular form.2,16
The subjects’
pretreatment casts were identified as skeletal Class I
(ANB angle, 0°-4°) and dental Class I (canine and
molar relationship according to Angle classification)
with fully developed permanent dentitions from first
molar to first molar. The second molars were excluded
from analysis because the age of most patients pre-
cluded ascertainment of complete eruption of this tooth.
The patients had only minimal restorations with no
prosthetic crowns and were excluded if they had
occlusal wear or gingival defects, or if the mucogingi-
val junction was not identifiable on the model. Mild
crowding or spacing (Ͻ2 mm) was acceptable, but no
subjects requiring extractions for arch-length defi-
ciency were included in the sample. The average age of
these patients was 17 years 11 months.
The dental casts were laser scanned with a computer-
assisted noncontact high-definition 3-dimensional (3D)
scanning system. This system consisted of a laser-
scanning unit (Dental Plaster Model Shape Scanning
System,17
Surflacer model VMS-100F, UNISN, Osaka,
Japan), a computer-aided-design software program
(Dent-Merge, version 5.0; UNISN), and dental cast
analyzing software (Surfacer, version 9.0, Imageware,
Ann Arbor, Mich). This setup was used for image
production and refinement, and landmark identification.
A detailed description of the performance characteris-
tics, including measurement accuracy of this data-
recording system, was reported elsewhere.18
The mea-
suring device of the laser-scanning unit consisted of a
slit-ray laser projector and 2 sets of charged-coupled
device video cameras to capture the reflected images.
X, y, and z coordinate data and data to measure the
circumference of the object was produced as a result.
The scanner was connected to the computer for image
processing. The dental casts were projected and
scanned by a revolving polygon mirror with a slit-ray
laser beam of 670 nm wavelength at 3 mW output.
Triangulation was used to determine the location of
each point with a measurement error of less than 0.05
mm.The generation of 3D graphics of each dental cast
took approximately 80 minutes. About 90,000 sets of
coordinates (x, y, z) per model were stored in the
computer.
Each mandibular dental cast was scanned at 3
angles in the frontal and sagittal planes (Fig 1, a). The
image processor converted the raster coordinates and
brightness data of the analog video signals’ input from
the video cameras into digital data. The computer
imported the digital data and converted the picture
coordinates to 3D spatial coordinates. The data was
synthesized, manually corrected for scanning errors, and
merged into a single data set for each model with the
Dent-Merge software. With cast analyzing software, a 3D
model of the entire mandibular dentition and its adjacent
structures was constructed (Fig 1, b and c).
By using the cast analyzing software, 2 reference
points (1 on the crown, and 1 at the mucogingival
junction) were selected for each tooth from the right to the
left first molar for a total of 24 points for each model.
The FA point is defined as the midpoint of the facial
American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics
Volume 134, Number 3
Ronay et al 431
axis of the clinical crown, which is the most prominent
part of the central lobe on each crown’s facial surface
except for the molars.19
For the first molars, the facial
axis of the clinical crown is represented by the mesio-
buccal groove that separates the 2 large facial cusps.
The WALA ridge is defined as the most prominent
point on the soft-tissue ridge immediately occlusal to the
mucogingival junction. It is located at or nearly at the
same vertical level as the horizontal center of rotation of
each tooth.20
WALA was measured directly below FA of
each tooth perpendicular to the occlusal plane. This point
varied in its occlusogingival position from tooth to tooth.
Both points were digitized as coordinates (x, y, z)
and exported in an ASCII format from the Surfacer
software into Excel 2002 software (Microsoft, Red-
mond, Wash). A standard graph format was created to
enable comparisons of the patients. The data was first
translated, shifting the midpoint between the WALA
and FA points of the central incisors to the origin of the
graph (x-y intersection). Then it was rotated, relocating
the midpoint of the first molars to the y-axis. The
positions of the rotated reference points and the curve
were confirmed on the graphic display of the software
program. This method was applied to the data of each
set of FA and WALA points, and average FA and
WALA curves were created (Fig 2).
Statistical analysis
Descriptive statistics including the average and
standard deviation of the relative distances between FA
and WALA points of corresponding teeth were com-
puted and shown graphically. The average values and
Fig 1. a, Original model scanning; b, polygon wire-frame image; c, Gouraud-shaded image.
Fig 2. Sample FA and WALA curves superimposed.
American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics
September 2008
432 Ronay et al
standard deviations of the intercanine and intermolar
widths at FA and WALA including their ratios were
calculated. The Pearson correlation coefficients be-
tween the width at the bilateral FA points and the
WALA points at the canine and molar levels were
calculated and statistically analyzed at the 0.01 and
0.05 levels of significance. Furthermore, the Pearson
correlation coefficients between the ratios at the FA and
WALA point widths were calculated and also statisti-
cally analyzed at the 0.01 and 0.05 levels. These
evaluations were made to investigate the relationship
between points representing the dental arch and those
constituting the basal arch.
RESULTS
A data table was created for each patient (Fig 3).
All 3 coordinates (x, y, z) of the FA and the WALA
points were described for each tooth, starting at the
right first molar and ending with the left first molar. The
third dimension (z, vertical) was omitted in further
analysis to facilitate comparison in arch width and
length. To compare patients, the data was standardized
as described above. The patient tables also show the
absolute distance between FA and WALA of the
corresponding teeth in millimeters. The FA and WALA
curves were superimposed to evaluate their relationship
Fig 3. Digitized FA and WALA points were imported into Excel 2002 (Microsoft, Redmond, Wash).
First, the distances between the 12 pairs were digitally calculated to create the “original” data. Then
the data was “translated” with the midline at the origin of the x-y axis. Finally, the data was “rotated”
to relocate the first molars as bilateral reference points for standardized y-axis positioning that
would permit comparison between subjects. Canine and molar widths and depths, and canine to
molar ratios, were determined. This method was applied to each FA-WALA data set. FDI
tooth-numbering system; R, right; L, left.
American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics
Volume 134, Number 3
Ronay et al 433
(Fig 2). Male and female data were combined because
initial analysis showed them to be indistinguishable.
The distribution of FA and WALA points on the
mandibular cast is shown in Figures 4 and 5, respec-
tively, with the FA and WALA curves produced
through connection of their single values by linear
interpolation. Those curves are individual and the
values describing the same teeth are scattered, espe-
cially in the premolar and molar areas.
The average relative distances between correspond-
ing FA and WALA points were created by summing the
values of the right and left sides. This data (Table I) is
shown in Figure 6, illustrating which FA points are
located more lingually (positive values) and which are
located more labially (negative values) in relation to
corresponding WALA points.
Table II gives the intercanine and intermolar widths
for the FA and WALA points in millimeters and the FA
Fig 4. FA curves created through linear interpolation of the individual FA values.
Fig 5. WALA curves created through linear interpolation of the individual WALA values.
American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics
September 2008
434 Ronay et al
and WALA ratios of the canines and molars to each
other, including averages and standard deviations. In
the canine area, increasing distances between FA points
were accompanied by increasing distances between
WALA points. However, the corresponding increase in
distances between FA points was always larger. With a
canine correlation coefficient of 0.75, this data was
highly statistically significant (Table III). Similarly, in
the molar region where the proportional increase in
distances between the WALA points was even larger,
the correlation was also highly significant (0.87). A
comparison of the x- and y-coordinates shows that in
the canine area there was greater variation in FA than in
WALA distances. To a lesser degree, this tendency was
also observed in the molar region.
DISCUSSION
Retention is still a major issue in orthodontics.
Theories have been proposed to minimize posttreat-
ment relapse, such as creating a proper occlusion4
and
muscular balance,21
uprighting mandibular incisors,22
and maintaining the pretreatment apical base6
and
intercanine and intermolar widths.14
The purpose of our
analysis was to estimate arch dimensions that permit
stable treatment goals.2
Orthodontists generally accept
the importance of respecting basal bone when planning
treatment. Treatment decisions regarding arch form in
particular should be related to the patient’s underlying
basal anatomy.
The definition of apical base is not completely clear
in the literature. These words—apical base, basal bone,
basal arch, and supporting bone—are not anatomic
terminology and are used only in orthodontics. Defini-
tions of the vertical position of the basal area of the
alveolar process vary. For example, in 1925, Lund-
ström6
defined it as follows: “in normal cases the apical
base will in the horizontal plane coincide with the
region in which the apices of the roots are located.”
Howes23
stated that the basal arch refers to the apical
third of the alveolus and the bone that supports the
alveolar processes below the mandibular teeth. He also
explained that it is the most constricted area of the
alveolus and is generally about 8 mm below the
gingival margin.
Clinicians generally assess basal anatomy by either
subjective palpation or analyzing lateral cephalograms.
The latter uses Points A and B to define the anterior
limit of the apical bases, but it obviously does not take
into account actual width and overall size. With dental
casts, the method of recording the most concave con-
tour of the sulci in relation to the apices of the teeth has
been reported.24
Various studies have looked at the position of the
teeth in the basal bone, and several methods for
determining this relationship have been used. In 1945,
Tweed25
described a method of sectioning dental casts
in the midline to determine the relationship of the
incisors to the alveolar and basal bone. Sergl et al24
measured the maxillary and mandibular apical base
area using a gnathograph specially designed for this
purpose. Oda et al26
presented a technique to record and
evaluate mandibular apical base form and tooth posi-
tion with computed tomography scans.
The use of 3D scanning devices has been reported
recently.27
The area of interest is most likely between
the bottom of a periodontal pocket and the apex of a
tooth. A reason for this variation in definition is the
difficulty in estimating the height of the root apex of
tooth without x-ray evaluation. However, there is not
enough data about the limit of buccal or labial tooth
movements, and it is not clear how much the bones can
be changed. In 2000, Andrews and Andrews20
pro-
posed a new term, WALA ridge, to indicate a surface
structure at the same level as basal bone. The WALA
ridge is the ridge of tissue at the mucogingival junction,
and they suggested that the horizontal arch shape of this
ridge of an initial mandibular basal arch in an orthodon-
tic patient is similar to the archwire form of the dental
arch. The WALA ridge is easy to identify and might be
more clinically reliable than estimation of the root
apex. However, that hypothesis has not been widely
discussed and confirmed. This is the first report that
examines the usefulness of WALA points to represent
the basal arch and their relevance in determining dental
arch form, but further research is required.
The use of different points in different reports could
have caused confusion regarding arch form. Some
studies used the arch form based on points where the
orthodontic bracket is placed, and others used the arch
form connecting the incisal edges and cusp tips of the
teeth. Different results are obtained with these measure-
ment methods on the same dental cast.28
This is the first
study to investigate the mandibular dental arch form
while considering both the clinically relevant working
point of the orthodontic bracket and wire and the
underlying anatomic-biologic structure of the basal
bone to correlate these structures. Most other arch-form
Table I. Average distances (mm) of WALA points
relative to corresponding FA points and their standard
deviations (n ϭ 70) (FDI tooth-numbering system)
Tooth 1 2 3 4 5 6
Average Ϫ1.21 Ϫ0.88 Ϫ0.32 0.59 1.78 2.77
SD 1.24 1.07 1.63 1.28 1.10 0.89
American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics
Volume 134, Number 3
Ronay et al 435
studies attempted to fit generalized mathematic or
geometric functions to the dentition but did not look for
an anatomic reference for deriving an “ideal” form for
each patient.
Arch form has been analyzed on plaster reproduc-
tions of the dentition for years. By using digital models
(3D virtual images), point identification takes on new
meaning, particularly for basal arch form. Each identi-
fied point has 3 known Cartesian coordinates that
permit precise analysis of its position. Relationships
between some points can be determined on digital
models regardless of interfering structures. Virtual
points within the model can also be created and
comparisons made between internal and external or
surface landmarks.
Relatively large individual variations of dental arch
form were found with both FA and WALA points as
shown in Figures 4 and 5, in spite of excluding dental
casts with significant crowding or irregularities. This
can be seen as a naturally occurring variation of tooth
position and bone anatomy in Class I occlusion. These
wide variations in dental and basal arches can be
explained by genetic background and environmental
factors influencing the patient’s growth and develop-
ment. These observations suggest that the quantified
arch forms are highly individual and should not be
viewed as variations of a general arch form as had been
done in the past.
On the other hand, a statistically significant positive
correlation was found between the dental and basal
arches in untreated patients. Comparisons of canine and
molar values in Tables II and III show a constant
relationship between dental and basal arch forms. A
statistically significant positive correlation of canine
and molar widths to corresponding FA and WALA
points was found. This suggests that the dental arch
form is affiliated with the basal arch form (defined by
the WALA points) in each patient, supporting the
above-mentioned apical base theory. If the dental arch
form is altered without considering the basal arch form,
it might result in unhealthy periodontal conditions or
unstable treatment results. Additionally, by determin-
ing WALA values, one can estimate their correspond-
ing FA values and then determine clinical arch form,
which can produce an archwire form. A statistically
significant positive correlation also was found for the
WALA and FA canine-to-molar width ratio. This rela-
tionship was observed for both dental arch size and
shape.
These findings have considerable relevance for
treatment outcomes. An implant study in the 1980s
reported significant lateral expansion of the maxillary
basal bone by a functional appliance.13
A recent article
reported thinned or dehisced buccal plates after maxil-
lary palatal expansion therapy with computed tomog-
raphy.29
Ultimately, the new bone-growing theory is
still at odds the apical base theory.15
The new bone-
growing theorists claim that crowded posterior teeth
can be moved laterally, and buccal bones can be
developed without tipping and bone loss with ex-
tremely light forces. However, most orthodontists be-
lieve that the dental arch cannot usually be expanded in
a short time without a heavier force, such as with
palatal expansion. Thus, a classic controversy in orth-
Fig 6. Average distances (mm) of WALA points relative to corresponding FA points and their
standard deviations (n ϭ 70).
American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics
September 2008
436 Ronay et al
odontics has been reignited. Research on the morphol-
ogy of the supporting bone after conventional and
newly developed orthodontic mechanics and stability
of the treatment results is therefore critical, and the
WALA and FA points used in this study might be
useful references for this purpose.
Our results demonstrate the ability to look at the
apical base and predict a patient’s dental arch form. It
will be of future interest to study whether other ana-
tomic landmarks could serve as an even more accurate
representations of basal bone. Additionally, it should be
determined whether the buccolingual relationships be-
tween the FA and WALA points are related to archwire
torque. Further research should also include the third
dimension when assessing patient data to give clini-
cians more information about the curve of Spee. How-
ever, the vertical distribution of WALA points might
depend on not only tooth inclination but also periodon-
tal conditions, such as the attachment level or the root
length of the patient. We expect that the WALA-FA
relationships will be different in patients with Class II
and Class III dental and skeletal relationships, as well
as in adults relative to growing patients. These are the
subjects of continuing investigations.
This study shows that distal to the mandibular
canines, the average distance between FA and WALA
points describing the same tooth changes buccolin-
gually. In this posterior area, the FA points are more
lingually located than the WALA points. This fact
might be linked to the clinically observed gradient of
crown torque along the dental arch but also to the
differences in basal vs dental arch shape. Andrews and
Andrews20
obtained different results. They reported
only positive values between FA and WALA points and
projected that the points at the mucogingival junction
were always more buccally positioned than the most
prominent part of the tooth crown. The difference in
results can be explained by their method or sample
selection. Nonetheless, our findings support their hy-
pothesis that WALA points can be used to describe the
basal arch and to draw conclusions regarding the
dimensions of the dental arch form. Additionally,
individual variations of the distance between the
WALA and FA points for each tooth were observed.
This might reflect the buccolingual inclination of the
teeth.
As a result of our research, we cannot confirm past
research postulating the existence of an ideal arch form
template. On the contrary, this study suggests that all
basal and dental arches should be individually derived.
Furthermore, the basal arch, represented by WALA
points, can be used as a clinical guide in fabricating
Table III. Correlation coefficients between FA and
WALA points at 3-3 width, 6-6 width, and (3-3/6-6)
ratio
3-3
width
6-6
width
(3-3/6-6)
ratio (%)
Correlation coefficient 0.750 0.869 0.750
t value (degree of freedom n-2 ϭ 33) 6.520 10.105 6.516
5% significance level 1.69 1.69 1.69
1% significance level 2.45 2.45 2.45
3-3, Canine to canine; 6-6, first molar to first molar.
Table II. FA and WALA point distances between ca-
nines and molars and their ratios
Patient
Distances (mm)
Ratios (%)
FA points WALA points
FA
ratio
(3-3/6-6)
WALA
ratio
(3-3/6-6)
3-3
width
6-6
width
3-3
width
6-6
width
1 28.00 54.50 29.27 60.27 51.37 48.57
2 27.05 50.26 26.50 54.54 53.81 48.59
3 29.80 52.50 28.50 57.76 56.77 49.33
4 28.29 55.28 30.85 59.25 51.17 52.07
5 26.81 48.34 29.37 56.10 55.45 52.34
6 28.26 53.35 30.82 58.15 52.97 53.00
7 30.01 48.77 31.50 54.75 61.53 57.53
8 27.07 52.29 28.01 55.78 51.77 50.23
9 26.00 50.29 28.26 56.33 51.70 50.17
10 26.50 50.75 28.00 53.78 52.21 52.05
11 28.95 56.48 29.42 57.58 51.25 51.10
12 27.02 53.11 27.01 59.26 50.86 45.57
13 26.05 50.10 28.29 56.78 52.00 49.82
14 26.36 48.93 26.53 53.41 53.87 49.67
15 26.05 53.14 24.34 57.35 49.02 42.45
16 28.53 51.59 30.76 59.55 55.31 51.65
17 28.00 48.75 30.75 53.25 57.43 57.76
18 29.54 51.05 30.04 54.06 57.87 55.58
19 24.27 45.50 23.75 49.75 53.35 47.73
20 30.25 59.30 29.75 66.51 51.02 44.73
21 26.50 49.00 27.75 53.75 54.08 51.62
22 29.50 50.74 31.75 57.00 58.12 55.71
23 25.76 47.83 27.81 52.80 53.87 52.68
24 23.52 51.00 24.50 55.50 46.11 44.14
25 27.54 50.01 27.00 52.76 55.06 51.17
26 27.01 49.77 30.00 55.01 54.26 54.53
27 25.67 46.34 27.25 53.05 55.40 51.37
28 28.75 50.50 31.01 58.50 56.92 53.01
29 29.95 54.35 30.29 60.59 55.11 49.99
30 27.00 50.99 30.50 54.75 52.94 55.71
31 27.50 53.00 29.75 58.75 51.88 50.63
32 27.25 54.00 29.99 59.77 50.46 50.18
33 27.07 46.40 29.55 52.81 58.35 55.96
34 29.26 49.31 29.51 55.79 59.34 52.90
35 27.77 50.33 30.04 56.30 55.17 53.36
Average 27.51 51.08 28.81 56.32 53.94 51.22
SD 1.60 2.92 2.02 3.14 0.03 0.04
3-3, Canine to canine; 6-6, first molar to first molar.
American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics
Volume 134, Number 3
Ronay et al 437
individualized archwire templates. Consideration of the
anatomy of each mandibular base also ensures that
optimal function of the occlusion, periodontal health,
desired esthetic appearance, and, of course, stability of
the dental arch form can be achieved. With increasing
access to 3D patient data, this important information
will be available to practitioners and must be consid-
ered in orthodontic treatment planning and archwire
design.
CONCLUSIONS
1. Arch forms derived from both FA and WALA are
individual and cannot be defined by 1 generalized
shape. These results show that form, degree of
curvature, and other parameters of the alveolar
ridge and dental arch are subject to much variation.
2. WALA points can be useful in the predetermination
of a dental arch form. The highly significant corre-
lation of WALA and FA point width in the canine
and molar areas proves that assessments of WALA
points enable prediction of corresponding FA val-
ues and the clinical arch form.
We thank Mutsuji Muramoto, UNISN, Osaka, Ja-
pan, for generously providing the VMS Dental Plaster
Model Shape Scanning System for this study.
REFERENCES
1. Brash JC. The etiology of irregularity and malocclusion of the
teeth. 2nd ed. London: Dental Board of the United Kingdom;
1956.
2. Proffit WR, Fields HW. Contemporary orthodontics. 3rd ed. St
Louis: Mosby Yearbook; 2000. p. 240-93.
3. Peck S. The state of our specialty. Angle Orthod 2004;74:iv.
4. Angle EH. Bone-growing. Dent Cosmos 1910;52:261-7.
5. Corruccini RS. How anthropology informs the orthodontic diag-
nosis of malocclusion’s causes. Mellen studies in anthropology.
Vol. 1. Lewiston, NY: Edward Mellen Press; 1999.
6. Lundström AF. Malocclusion of the teeth regarded as a problem
in connection with the apical base. Int J Orthod Oral Surg
Radiogr 1925;9:591-602, 724-31, 793-812, 933-40, 1022-42,
1109-33.
7. Betts NJ, Vanarsdall RL, Barber HD, Higgins-Barber K, Fonseca
RJ. Diagnosis and treatment of transverse maxillary deficiency.
Int J Adult Orthod Orthognath Surg 1995;10:75-96.
8. Strang RHW. The fallacy of denture expansion as a treatment
procedure. Angle Orthod 1949;19:12-22.
9. Tweed CH. Clinical orthodontics. Vol. 1. St Louis: Mosby; 1966.
10. Begg PR. Begg orthodontic theory and technique. Philadelphia:
Saunders; 1965.
11. Buchner HJ. An answer to some criticisms of treatment follow-
ing bicuspid extractions. Angle Orthod 1949;19:23-47.
12. Rees DJ. A method for assessing the proportional relation of
apical bases and contact diameters of the teeth. Am J Orthod
1953;39:695-707.
13. Brieden CM, Pangrazio-Kulbersh V, Kulbersh P. Maxillary
skeletal and dental changes with Fränkel appliance therapy—an
implant study. Angle Orthod 1984;54:226-32.
14. Little RM. Stability and relapse of dental arch alignment. Br J
Orthod 1990;17:235-41.
15. Damon DH. Treatment of the face with biocompatible orthodon-
tics. 4th ed. In: Graber TM, Vanarsdall RL, Vig KW, editors.
Orthodontics: current principles and techniques. St Louis:
Elsevier-Mosby; 2005. p. 753-832.
16. Ricketts RM. Design of arch form and details for bracket
placement. Denver: Rocky Mountain Orthodontics; 1979.
17. Arai K, Ishikawa H. Application of non-contact three-dimen-
sional shape measuring system to dental cast. Reduction of blind
region. Orthod Waves 1999;58:148-53.
18. Hayama K, Arai K, Ishikawa H. Correlation between upper and
lower dental arch forms by fitting of fourth-order polynomials.
Orthod Waves 2000;59:303-11.
19. Andrews LF. Composites. I: straight-wire, the concept and
appliance. San Diego: L. A. Wells; 1989. p. 13-33.
20. Andrews LF, Andrews WA. The six elements of orofacial
harmony. Andrews J 2000;1:13-22.
21. Proffit WR. Muscle pressure and tooth position: North American
white and Australian aborigines. Angle Orthod 1975;45:1-11.
22. Tweed DH. Frankfort-mandibular plane angle in orthodontic
diagnosis, classification, treatment planning and prognosis. Am J
Orthod Oral Surg 1946;32:175-230.
23. Howes JH. A polygon portrayal of coronal and basal arch
dimensions in the horizontal plane. Am J Orthod 1954;40:
811-31.
24. Sergl HG, Kerr WJS, McColl JH. A method of measuring the
apical base. Eur J Orthod 1996;18:479-83.
25. Tweed CH. A philosophy of orthodontic treatment. Am J Orthod
Oral Surg 1945;31:74-103.
26. Oda Y, Takada K, Sakuda M. Description of mandibular apical
base form and tooth arrangement by means of spline functions.
Nippon Kyosei Shika Gakkai Zasshi 1987;46:751-8.
27. Fujita K, Takada K, QianRong G, Shibata T. Patterning of
human dental arch wire blanks using a vector quantization
algorithm. Angle Orthod 2002;72:285-94.
28. Bennett JC, McLaughlin RP. Arch form considerations for
stability and esthetics. Rev Esp Ortod 1999;29:46-63.
29. Garib DG, Henriques JFC, Janson G, de Freitas MR, Fernades
AY. Periodontal effects of rapid maxillary expansion with
tooth-tissue-borne and tooth-borne expanders: a computed to-
mography evaluation. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop 2006;
129:749-58.
American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics
September 2008
438 Ronay et al

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Downs analysis
Downs analysisDowns analysis
Downs analysis
Faizan Ali
 
Debonding procedures in orthodontics
Debonding procedures in orthodonticsDebonding procedures in orthodontics
Debonding procedures in orthodontics
Fasahat Butt
 
Space analysis and tooth size analysis for orthodontists by Almuzian
Space analysis and tooth size analysis for orthodontists by AlmuzianSpace analysis and tooth size analysis for orthodontists by Almuzian
Space analysis and tooth size analysis for orthodontists by Almuzian
University of Sydney and Edinbugh
 

Tendances (20)

recent advances in orthodontics
recent advances in orthodonticsrecent advances in orthodontics
recent advances in orthodontics
 
Downs analysis
Downs analysisDowns analysis
Downs analysis
 
Occlusograms
OcclusogramsOcclusograms
Occlusograms
 
Indics /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental academy
Indics /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental academy Indics /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental academy
Indics /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental academy
 
Space analysis /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental academy
Space analysis /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental academy Space analysis /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental academy
Space analysis /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental academy
 
Principle and theories of craniofacial growth
Principle and theories of craniofacial growthPrinciple and theories of craniofacial growth
Principle and theories of craniofacial growth
 
Molar distalisation
Molar distalisationMolar distalisation
Molar distalisation
 
Pitchfork Analysis
Pitchfork AnalysisPitchfork Analysis
Pitchfork Analysis
 
Natural head position /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental a...
Natural head position /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental a...Natural head position /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental a...
Natural head position /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental a...
 
Modelanalysis /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental academy
Modelanalysis /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental academy Modelanalysis /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental academy
Modelanalysis /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental academy
 
An overview of class 2 & class 3 treatment plan
An overview of class 2 & class 3 treatment planAn overview of class 2 & class 3 treatment plan
An overview of class 2 & class 3 treatment plan
 
Debonding procedures in orthodontics
Debonding procedures in orthodonticsDebonding procedures in orthodontics
Debonding procedures in orthodontics
 
Orthodontic vertical discrepancies 1- LONG FACE
Orthodontic vertical discrepancies 1- LONG FACE Orthodontic vertical discrepancies 1- LONG FACE
Orthodontic vertical discrepancies 1- LONG FACE
 
Canine retraction
Canine retractionCanine retraction
Canine retraction
 
Rakosi’s analysis
Rakosi’s analysisRakosi’s analysis
Rakosi’s analysis
 
Space analysis and tooth size analysis for orthodontists by Almuzian
Space analysis and tooth size analysis for orthodontists by AlmuzianSpace analysis and tooth size analysis for orthodontists by Almuzian
Space analysis and tooth size analysis for orthodontists by Almuzian
 
skeletal maturity indicators in orthodontics /certified fixed orthodontic cou...
skeletal maturity indicators in orthodontics /certified fixed orthodontic cou...skeletal maturity indicators in orthodontics /certified fixed orthodontic cou...
skeletal maturity indicators in orthodontics /certified fixed orthodontic cou...
 
Template analysis /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental acad...
Template analysis  /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental acad...Template analysis  /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental acad...
Template analysis /certified fixed orthodontic courses by Indian dental acad...
 
Orthodontic triage
Orthodontic triageOrthodontic triage
Orthodontic triage
 
Orthodontic Correction of Rotated Teeth
Orthodontic Correction of Rotated TeethOrthodontic Correction of Rotated Teeth
Orthodontic Correction of Rotated Teeth
 

En vedette

Malposition of unerupted mandibular second premolar in children with palatall...
Malposition of unerupted mandibular second premolar in children with palatall...Malposition of unerupted mandibular second premolar in children with palatall...
Malposition of unerupted mandibular second premolar in children with palatall...
EdwardHAngle
 
Role of polycystin 1 in bone remodeling- orthodontic tooth movement study in ...
Role of polycystin 1 in bone remodeling- orthodontic tooth movement study in ...Role of polycystin 1 in bone remodeling- orthodontic tooth movement study in ...
Role of polycystin 1 in bone remodeling- orthodontic tooth movement study in ...
EdwardHAngle
 
Surgically assisted rapid palatal expansion a comparison of technique, respo...
Surgically assisted rapid palatal expansion  a comparison of technique, respo...Surgically assisted rapid palatal expansion  a comparison of technique, respo...
Surgically assisted rapid palatal expansion a comparison of technique, respo...
EdwardHAngle
 
Malposition of unerupted mandibular second premolar in children with cleft li...
Malposition of unerupted mandibular second premolar in children with cleft li...Malposition of unerupted mandibular second premolar in children with cleft li...
Malposition of unerupted mandibular second premolar in children with cleft li...
EdwardHAngle
 
Orthodontic movement using pulsating force induced peizoelctricity
Orthodontic movement using pulsating force induced peizoelctricityOrthodontic movement using pulsating force induced peizoelctricity
Orthodontic movement using pulsating force induced peizoelctricity
EdwardHAngle
 
Increased occurrence of dental anomalies associated with infraocclusion of de...
Increased occurrence of dental anomalies associated with infraocclusion of de...Increased occurrence of dental anomalies associated with infraocclusion of de...
Increased occurrence of dental anomalies associated with infraocclusion of de...
EdwardHAngle
 
Short term and long-term stability of surgically assisted rapid palatal expan...
Short term and long-term stability of surgically assisted rapid palatal expan...Short term and long-term stability of surgically assisted rapid palatal expan...
Short term and long-term stability of surgically assisted rapid palatal expan...
Dr Sylvain Chamberland
 
Long term clinical and bacterial effetcx of xylitol on paitnets with fixed or...
Long term clinical and bacterial effetcx of xylitol on paitnets with fixed or...Long term clinical and bacterial effetcx of xylitol on paitnets with fixed or...
Long term clinical and bacterial effetcx of xylitol on paitnets with fixed or...
EdwardHAngle
 
Influence of common fixed retainers on the diagnostic quality of cranial magn...
Influence of common fixed retainers on the diagnostic quality of cranial magn...Influence of common fixed retainers on the diagnostic quality of cranial magn...
Influence of common fixed retainers on the diagnostic quality of cranial magn...
EdwardHAngle
 
The effect of vibration on the rate of leveling and alignment
The effect of vibration on the rate of leveling and alignmentThe effect of vibration on the rate of leveling and alignment
The effect of vibration on the rate of leveling and alignment
EdwardHAngle
 

En vedette (20)

Malposition of unerupted mandibular second premolar in children with palatall...
Malposition of unerupted mandibular second premolar in children with palatall...Malposition of unerupted mandibular second premolar in children with palatall...
Malposition of unerupted mandibular second premolar in children with palatall...
 
Role of polycystin 1 in bone remodeling- orthodontic tooth movement study in ...
Role of polycystin 1 in bone remodeling- orthodontic tooth movement study in ...Role of polycystin 1 in bone remodeling- orthodontic tooth movement study in ...
Role of polycystin 1 in bone remodeling- orthodontic tooth movement study in ...
 
Closer look at sarpe chamberland-proffit joms sept08
Closer look at sarpe chamberland-proffit joms sept08Closer look at sarpe chamberland-proffit joms sept08
Closer look at sarpe chamberland-proffit joms sept08
 
Surgically assisted rapid palatal expansion a comparison of technique, respo...
Surgically assisted rapid palatal expansion  a comparison of technique, respo...Surgically assisted rapid palatal expansion  a comparison of technique, respo...
Surgically assisted rapid palatal expansion a comparison of technique, respo...
 
Angular changes and their rates in concurrence to developmental stages of the...
Angular changes and their rates in concurrence to developmental stages of the...Angular changes and their rates in concurrence to developmental stages of the...
Angular changes and their rates in concurrence to developmental stages of the...
 
Malposition of unerupted mandibular second premolar in children with cleft li...
Malposition of unerupted mandibular second premolar in children with cleft li...Malposition of unerupted mandibular second premolar in children with cleft li...
Malposition of unerupted mandibular second premolar in children with cleft li...
 
Orthodontic movement using pulsating force induced peizoelctricity
Orthodontic movement using pulsating force induced peizoelctricityOrthodontic movement using pulsating force induced peizoelctricity
Orthodontic movement using pulsating force induced peizoelctricity
 
Transverse growth of the maxilla and mandible in untreated girls with low, av...
Transverse growth of the maxilla and mandible in untreated girls with low, av...Transverse growth of the maxilla and mandible in untreated girls with low, av...
Transverse growth of the maxilla and mandible in untreated girls with low, av...
 
Increased occurrence of dental anomalies associated with infraocclusion of de...
Increased occurrence of dental anomalies associated with infraocclusion of de...Increased occurrence of dental anomalies associated with infraocclusion of de...
Increased occurrence of dental anomalies associated with infraocclusion of de...
 
Skeletal and dental changes in the sagittal, vertical, and transverse dimensi...
Skeletal and dental changes in the sagittal, vertical, and transverse dimensi...Skeletal and dental changes in the sagittal, vertical, and transverse dimensi...
Skeletal and dental changes in the sagittal, vertical, and transverse dimensi...
 
Craniofacial growth in untreated skeletal class i subjects with low, average,...
Craniofacial growth in untreated skeletal class i subjects with low, average,...Craniofacial growth in untreated skeletal class i subjects with low, average,...
Craniofacial growth in untreated skeletal class i subjects with low, average,...
 
Three dimensional changes of the naso-maxillary complex following rapid maxil...
Three dimensional changes of the naso-maxillary complex following rapid maxil...Three dimensional changes of the naso-maxillary complex following rapid maxil...
Three dimensional changes of the naso-maxillary complex following rapid maxil...
 
Short term and long-term stability of surgically assisted rapid palatal expan...
Short term and long-term stability of surgically assisted rapid palatal expan...Short term and long-term stability of surgically assisted rapid palatal expan...
Short term and long-term stability of surgically assisted rapid palatal expan...
 
Preprosthetic management/ orthodontic seminars
Preprosthetic management/ orthodontic seminarsPreprosthetic management/ orthodontic seminars
Preprosthetic management/ orthodontic seminars
 
Effects of bonded rapid palatal expansion on the transverse dimensions of the...
Effects of bonded rapid palatal expansion on the transverse dimensions of the...Effects of bonded rapid palatal expansion on the transverse dimensions of the...
Effects of bonded rapid palatal expansion on the transverse dimensions of the...
 
Long term clinical and bacterial effetcx of xylitol on paitnets with fixed or...
Long term clinical and bacterial effetcx of xylitol on paitnets with fixed or...Long term clinical and bacterial effetcx of xylitol on paitnets with fixed or...
Long term clinical and bacterial effetcx of xylitol on paitnets with fixed or...
 
Influence of common fixed retainers on the diagnostic quality of cranial magn...
Influence of common fixed retainers on the diagnostic quality of cranial magn...Influence of common fixed retainers on the diagnostic quality of cranial magn...
Influence of common fixed retainers on the diagnostic quality of cranial magn...
 
The effect of vibration on the rate of leveling and alignment
The effect of vibration on the rate of leveling and alignmentThe effect of vibration on the rate of leveling and alignment
The effect of vibration on the rate of leveling and alignment
 
Effects of rapid palatal expansion on the sagittal and vertical dimensions of...
Effects of rapid palatal expansion on the sagittal and vertical dimensions of...Effects of rapid palatal expansion on the sagittal and vertical dimensions of...
Effects of rapid palatal expansion on the sagittal and vertical dimensions of...
 
Subjective classification and objective analysis of the mandibular dental arc...
Subjective classification and objective analysis of the mandibular dental arc...Subjective classification and objective analysis of the mandibular dental arc...
Subjective classification and objective analysis of the mandibular dental arc...
 

Similaire à Mandibular arch form the relationship between dental and basal anatomy

Central incisor implant
Central incisor implantCentral incisor implant
Central incisor implant
Nader Elbokle
 
A new method to mesure mesiodistal angulation and faciolingual with cbct
A new method to mesure mesiodistal angulation and faciolingual with cbctA new method to mesure mesiodistal angulation and faciolingual with cbct
A new method to mesure mesiodistal angulation and faciolingual with cbct
Nielsen Pereira
 
A cone-beam computed tomography evaluation of buccal bone thickness following...
A cone-beam computed tomography evaluation of buccal bone thickness following...A cone-beam computed tomography evaluation of buccal bone thickness following...
A cone-beam computed tomography evaluation of buccal bone thickness following...
AlyOsman4
 
Mixed dentition analysis
Mixed dentition analysisMixed dentition analysis
Mixed dentition analysis
Rajesh Bariker
 
The curve of dental arch in normal occlusion
The curve of dental arch in normal occlusionThe curve of dental arch in normal occlusion
The curve of dental arch in normal occlusion
Abu-Hussein Muhamad
 
A New Concept of Dental Arch of Children in Normal Occlusion
A New Concept of Dental Arch of Children in Normal OcclusionA New Concept of Dental Arch of Children in Normal Occlusion
A New Concept of Dental Arch of Children in Normal Occlusion
Abu-Hussein Muhamad
 

Similaire à Mandibular arch form the relationship between dental and basal anatomy (20)

Central incisor implant
Central incisor implantCentral incisor implant
Central incisor implant
 
A new method to mesure mesiodistal angulation and faciolingual with cbct
A new method to mesure mesiodistal angulation and faciolingual with cbctA new method to mesure mesiodistal angulation and faciolingual with cbct
A new method to mesure mesiodistal angulation and faciolingual with cbct
 
Magne width lengthratio
Magne width lengthratioMagne width lengthratio
Magne width lengthratio
 
Articulo
ArticuloArticulo
Articulo
 
retiner hawleys
 retiner hawleys retiner hawleys
retiner hawleys
 
Commercially available archwire forms compared with normal dental arch forms ...
Commercially available archwire forms compared with normal dental arch forms ...Commercially available archwire forms compared with normal dental arch forms ...
Commercially available archwire forms compared with normal dental arch forms ...
 
A cone-beam computed tomography evaluation of buccal bone thickness following...
A cone-beam computed tomography evaluation of buccal bone thickness following...A cone-beam computed tomography evaluation of buccal bone thickness following...
A cone-beam computed tomography evaluation of buccal bone thickness following...
 
Yang2015
Yang2015Yang2015
Yang2015
 
Mixed dentition space analysis.pptx
Mixed dentition space analysis.pptxMixed dentition space analysis.pptx
Mixed dentition space analysis.pptx
 
orthodontic dental casts the case against
orthodontic dental casts the case againstorthodontic dental casts the case against
orthodontic dental casts the case against
 
Mixed dentition analysis
Mixed dentition analysisMixed dentition analysis
Mixed dentition analysis
 
Two Treatment Approaches for Missing Maxillary Lateral Incisors: A Case
Two Treatment Approaches for Missing Maxillary Lateral Incisors: A CaseTwo Treatment Approaches for Missing Maxillary Lateral Incisors: A Case
Two Treatment Approaches for Missing Maxillary Lateral Incisors: A Case
 
The uses of orthodontic study models in DIAGNOSIS AND TREATMENT PLANNING
The uses of orthodontic study models in DIAGNOSIS AND TREATMENT PLANNINGThe uses of orthodontic study models in DIAGNOSIS AND TREATMENT PLANNING
The uses of orthodontic study models in DIAGNOSIS AND TREATMENT PLANNING
 
Model analysis in orthodontics
Model analysis in orthodonticsModel analysis in orthodontics
Model analysis in orthodontics
 
Journal Club Presentation on Overlay Removable Partial Denture
Journal  Club Presentation on Overlay Removable Partial DentureJournal  Club Presentation on Overlay Removable Partial Denture
Journal Club Presentation on Overlay Removable Partial Denture
 
The curve of dental arch in normal occlusion
The curve of dental arch in normal occlusionThe curve of dental arch in normal occlusion
The curve of dental arch in normal occlusion
 
A New Concept of Dental Arch of Children in Normal Occlusion
A New Concept of Dental Arch of Children in Normal OcclusionA New Concept of Dental Arch of Children in Normal Occlusion
A New Concept of Dental Arch of Children in Normal Occlusion
 
mixed dentition analysis
mixed dentition analysismixed dentition analysis
mixed dentition analysis
 
9th publication - IJOHMR - 4th Name.pdf
9th publication - IJOHMR - 4th Name.pdf9th publication - IJOHMR - 4th Name.pdf
9th publication - IJOHMR - 4th Name.pdf
 
seminar deleted slides.pptx
seminar deleted slides.pptxseminar deleted slides.pptx
seminar deleted slides.pptx
 

Dernier

Dernier (20)

Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Ludhiana Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ludhiana Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Tirupati Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Tirupati Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Tirupati Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Tirupati Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
The Most Attractive Hyderabad Call Girls Kothapet 𖠋 9332606886 𖠋 Will You Mis...
The Most Attractive Hyderabad Call Girls Kothapet 𖠋 9332606886 𖠋 Will You Mis...The Most Attractive Hyderabad Call Girls Kothapet 𖠋 9332606886 𖠋 Will You Mis...
The Most Attractive Hyderabad Call Girls Kothapet 𖠋 9332606886 𖠋 Will You Mis...
 
Call Girls Coimbatore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Coimbatore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Coimbatore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Coimbatore Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls in Delhi Triveni Complex Escort Service(🔝))/WhatsApp 97111⇛47426
Call Girls in Delhi Triveni Complex Escort Service(🔝))/WhatsApp 97111⇛47426Call Girls in Delhi Triveni Complex Escort Service(🔝))/WhatsApp 97111⇛47426
Call Girls in Delhi Triveni Complex Escort Service(🔝))/WhatsApp 97111⇛47426
 
Best Rate (Patna ) Call Girls Patna ⟟ 8617370543 ⟟ High Class Call Girl In 5 ...
Best Rate (Patna ) Call Girls Patna ⟟ 8617370543 ⟟ High Class Call Girl In 5 ...Best Rate (Patna ) Call Girls Patna ⟟ 8617370543 ⟟ High Class Call Girl In 5 ...
Best Rate (Patna ) Call Girls Patna ⟟ 8617370543 ⟟ High Class Call Girl In 5 ...
 
(Low Rate RASHMI ) Rate Of Call Girls Jaipur ❣ 8445551418 ❣ Elite Models & Ce...
(Low Rate RASHMI ) Rate Of Call Girls Jaipur ❣ 8445551418 ❣ Elite Models & Ce...(Low Rate RASHMI ) Rate Of Call Girls Jaipur ❣ 8445551418 ❣ Elite Models & Ce...
(Low Rate RASHMI ) Rate Of Call Girls Jaipur ❣ 8445551418 ❣ Elite Models & Ce...
 
Book Paid Powai Call Girls Mumbai 𖠋 9930245274 𖠋Low Budget Full Independent H...
Book Paid Powai Call Girls Mumbai 𖠋 9930245274 𖠋Low Budget Full Independent H...Book Paid Powai Call Girls Mumbai 𖠋 9930245274 𖠋Low Budget Full Independent H...
Book Paid Powai Call Girls Mumbai 𖠋 9930245274 𖠋Low Budget Full Independent H...
 
Call Girls Siliguri Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Siliguri Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Siliguri Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Siliguri Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Visakhapatnam Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...
Call Girls Visakhapatnam Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...Call Girls Visakhapatnam Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...
Call Girls Visakhapatnam Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Ava...
 
Call Girls Ooty Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ooty Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Ooty Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Ooty Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...
 
Premium Call Girls In Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️VVIP SEEMA Call Girl in Jaipur Ra...
Premium Call Girls In Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️VVIP SEEMA Call Girl in Jaipur Ra...Premium Call Girls In Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️VVIP SEEMA Call Girl in Jaipur Ra...
Premium Call Girls In Jaipur {8445551418} ❤️VVIP SEEMA Call Girl in Jaipur Ra...
 
Top Quality Call Girl Service Kalyanpur 6378878445 Available Call Girls Any Time
Top Quality Call Girl Service Kalyanpur 6378878445 Available Call Girls Any TimeTop Quality Call Girl Service Kalyanpur 6378878445 Available Call Girls Any Time
Top Quality Call Girl Service Kalyanpur 6378878445 Available Call Girls Any Time
 
Premium Bangalore Call Girls Jigani Dail 6378878445 Escort Service For Hot Ma...
Premium Bangalore Call Girls Jigani Dail 6378878445 Escort Service For Hot Ma...Premium Bangalore Call Girls Jigani Dail 6378878445 Escort Service For Hot Ma...
Premium Bangalore Call Girls Jigani Dail 6378878445 Escort Service For Hot Ma...
 
Pondicherry Call Girls Book Now 9630942363 Top Class Pondicherry Escort Servi...
Pondicherry Call Girls Book Now 9630942363 Top Class Pondicherry Escort Servi...Pondicherry Call Girls Book Now 9630942363 Top Class Pondicherry Escort Servi...
Pondicherry Call Girls Book Now 9630942363 Top Class Pondicherry Escort Servi...
 
Call Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Nagpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Varanasi Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Varanasi Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Varanasi Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Varanasi Just Call 8250077686 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Night 7k to 12k Chennai City Center Call Girls 👉👉 7427069034⭐⭐ 100% Genuine E...
Night 7k to 12k Chennai City Center Call Girls 👉👉 7427069034⭐⭐ 100% Genuine E...Night 7k to 12k Chennai City Center Call Girls 👉👉 7427069034⭐⭐ 100% Genuine E...
Night 7k to 12k Chennai City Center Call Girls 👉👉 7427069034⭐⭐ 100% Genuine E...
 

Mandibular arch form the relationship between dental and basal anatomy

  • 1. ORIGINAL ARTICLE Mandibular arch form: The relationship between dental and basal anatomy Valerie Ronay,a R. Matthew Miner,b Leslie A. Will,c and Kazuhito Araid Vienna, Austria, Boston, Mass, and Tokyo, Japan Introduction: We investigated mandibular dental arch form at the levels of both the clinically relevant application points of the orthodontic bracket and the underlying anatomic structure of the apical base. The correlation of both forms was evaluated and examined to determine whether the basal arch could be used to derive a standardized clinical arch form. Methods: Thirty-five mandibular dental casts (skeletal and dental Class I) were laser scanned, and a 3-dimensional virtual model was created. Two reference points (FA, the most prominent part of the central lobe on each crown’s facial surface, and WALA, a point at the height of the mucogingival junction) were selected for each tooth from the right to the left first molars. The FA and WALA arch forms were compared, and the distances between corresponding points and intercanine and intermolar widths were analyzed. Results: Both arch forms were highly individual and the tooth values scattered. Nevertheless, a highly significant relationship between the FA and WALA curves was found, especially in the canine (0.75) and molar (0.87) areas. Conclusions: Both FA and WALA point-derived arch forms were individual and therefore could not be defined by a generalized shape. WALA points proved to be a useful representation of the apical base and helpful in the predetermination of an individualized dental arch form. (Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop 2008;134:430-8) T he size and shape of the dental arches have considerable implications for orthodontic diagno- sis and treatment planning. These factors have an effect on space available, stability of the dentition, and dental esthetics. Furthermore, the definition of arch form would improve the understanding of malocclusion and assist clinicians in producing orthodontic results that are consistent with the natural laws of biologic variation. Although most arch form studies have looked at similar patient samples—subjects with orthodontically untreated ideal occlusions—few come even close to agreement about the natural shape of the dental arch. It is commonly believed that the dental arch form is initially shaped by the configuration of its supporting bone.1 Nevertheless, 2 opposing theories about modifying the dental arch form have coexisted for 100 years.2,3 The bone-growing theory is that the supporting bone grows in response to normal stimulation, such as mastication, if the teeth are aligned in the ideal position. Angle4 reported stable orthodontic treatment results of his expanded crowding patients and first advocated the bone-growing theory. In the latter part of the 19th century a basic biologic principle was introduced called Wolff’s law in which the bone structure changes in response to external force. According to this theory, tooth size is controlled by heredity, but size and shape of the supporting bones depend largely on environmen- tal stimuli including eruption of the teeth, pressure from tongue and cheek, and mastication. For example, a small mandible can result from the lack of healthy jaw function and indicates degeneration.5 This approach resulted in fewer extractions and is often called the nonextraction theory. According to the “apical base” theory, the size and shape of the supporting bone are largely under genetic control, and there is a limit to expansion of a dental arch. In 1925, Lundström6 proposed a new term—apical base—to describe the limits of expansion of the dental arch and wrote extensively on this topic. He stated that the apical base (1) is not changed after loss of teeth, (2) is not influenced by orthodontic tooth movement or masticatory function, and (3) limits the size of dental arch. If the teeth are orthodontically moved beyond this limit, labial or buccal tipping of the teeth,6 periodontal problems,7 or an unstable treatment result8 could be expected.2 One of Angle’s students, Tweed,9 also observed unstable results after nonextraction treatment with Angle’s mechanics a Student, Clinic of Dentistry, Vienna University, Vienna, Austria. b Assistant clinical professor, Department of Developmental Biology, Harvard School of Dental Medicine, Boston, Mass. c Professor and graduate program director, Department of Orthodontics, Tufts University School of Dental Medicine, Boston, Mass. d Assistant professor, Department of Orthodontics, Nippon Dental University, Tokyo, Japan; visiting professor, Department of Developmental Biology, Harvard School of Dental Medicine, Boston, Mass. Reprint requests to: R. Matthew Miner, One Lyons St, Dedham, MA 02026; e-mail, r_miner@hsdm.harvard.edu. Submitted, April 2006; revised and accepted, October 2006. 0889-5406/$34.00 Copyright © 2008 by the American Association of Orthodontists. doi:10.1016/j.ajodo.2006.10.040 430
  • 2. during the 1930s. He established his diagnostic analysis in favor of extraction and refined the mechanics for extrac- tion treatment. Simultaneously, another Angle student, Begg,10 also changed to the extraction technique and sought anthropologic evidence for extraction treatment because of less mastication required in modern diets. Since then, this theory was confirmed by case reports, and most orthodontists are now convinced of the validity of this theory.11,12 However, an objective limit for buccal or labial tooth movement in any patient, especially those with mild crowding, is still not available today.2 As the frequency of extraction orthodontic treatment has decreased over the last 30 years, a new bone-growing theory has emerged. Esthetic preference for fuller profiles, temporomandibular disorder problems,2 and the emer- gence of functional appliance therapy13 were contributing factors, but, most significantly, it was found that extrac- tion did not insure stability.14 With stability not guaran- teed, extraction treatment lost much of its perceived advantage. Recently, the clinical results of a new orth- odontic appliance were reported.15 Its developer claimed that buccal tooth movements without tipping could be achieved with his biocompatible appliance with extremely light forces. Computed tomography images of expanded teeth from severely crowded dental arches were shown, and apparently healthy alveolar bone was demonstrated as evidence for this bone-growing theory. Most clinicians, however, still explain to their patients that there might be a limit for expansion of the dental arch with any appliance. Furthermore, we still do not know exactly the limit for each patient. The purpose of this study was to investigate the relationship between the dental arch form and the supporting bone. We hypothesized that there is a quantifiable relationship between basal and dental arch forms, and that basal-bone landmarks can be used as reliable references for determining biologic arch form in clinical orthodontics. MATERIAL AND METHODS The mandibular dental casts of 35 patients (13 male, 22 female) were randomly selected from a sample of 750. The mandible was studied because therapeutic possibilities are more limited than in the maxilla, and the maxillary arch form is strongly asso- ciated with the mandibular form.2,16 The subjects’ pretreatment casts were identified as skeletal Class I (ANB angle, 0°-4°) and dental Class I (canine and molar relationship according to Angle classification) with fully developed permanent dentitions from first molar to first molar. The second molars were excluded from analysis because the age of most patients pre- cluded ascertainment of complete eruption of this tooth. The patients had only minimal restorations with no prosthetic crowns and were excluded if they had occlusal wear or gingival defects, or if the mucogingi- val junction was not identifiable on the model. Mild crowding or spacing (Ͻ2 mm) was acceptable, but no subjects requiring extractions for arch-length defi- ciency were included in the sample. The average age of these patients was 17 years 11 months. The dental casts were laser scanned with a computer- assisted noncontact high-definition 3-dimensional (3D) scanning system. This system consisted of a laser- scanning unit (Dental Plaster Model Shape Scanning System,17 Surflacer model VMS-100F, UNISN, Osaka, Japan), a computer-aided-design software program (Dent-Merge, version 5.0; UNISN), and dental cast analyzing software (Surfacer, version 9.0, Imageware, Ann Arbor, Mich). This setup was used for image production and refinement, and landmark identification. A detailed description of the performance characteris- tics, including measurement accuracy of this data- recording system, was reported elsewhere.18 The mea- suring device of the laser-scanning unit consisted of a slit-ray laser projector and 2 sets of charged-coupled device video cameras to capture the reflected images. X, y, and z coordinate data and data to measure the circumference of the object was produced as a result. The scanner was connected to the computer for image processing. The dental casts were projected and scanned by a revolving polygon mirror with a slit-ray laser beam of 670 nm wavelength at 3 mW output. Triangulation was used to determine the location of each point with a measurement error of less than 0.05 mm.The generation of 3D graphics of each dental cast took approximately 80 minutes. About 90,000 sets of coordinates (x, y, z) per model were stored in the computer. Each mandibular dental cast was scanned at 3 angles in the frontal and sagittal planes (Fig 1, a). The image processor converted the raster coordinates and brightness data of the analog video signals’ input from the video cameras into digital data. The computer imported the digital data and converted the picture coordinates to 3D spatial coordinates. The data was synthesized, manually corrected for scanning errors, and merged into a single data set for each model with the Dent-Merge software. With cast analyzing software, a 3D model of the entire mandibular dentition and its adjacent structures was constructed (Fig 1, b and c). By using the cast analyzing software, 2 reference points (1 on the crown, and 1 at the mucogingival junction) were selected for each tooth from the right to the left first molar for a total of 24 points for each model. The FA point is defined as the midpoint of the facial American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics Volume 134, Number 3 Ronay et al 431
  • 3. axis of the clinical crown, which is the most prominent part of the central lobe on each crown’s facial surface except for the molars.19 For the first molars, the facial axis of the clinical crown is represented by the mesio- buccal groove that separates the 2 large facial cusps. The WALA ridge is defined as the most prominent point on the soft-tissue ridge immediately occlusal to the mucogingival junction. It is located at or nearly at the same vertical level as the horizontal center of rotation of each tooth.20 WALA was measured directly below FA of each tooth perpendicular to the occlusal plane. This point varied in its occlusogingival position from tooth to tooth. Both points were digitized as coordinates (x, y, z) and exported in an ASCII format from the Surfacer software into Excel 2002 software (Microsoft, Red- mond, Wash). A standard graph format was created to enable comparisons of the patients. The data was first translated, shifting the midpoint between the WALA and FA points of the central incisors to the origin of the graph (x-y intersection). Then it was rotated, relocating the midpoint of the first molars to the y-axis. The positions of the rotated reference points and the curve were confirmed on the graphic display of the software program. This method was applied to the data of each set of FA and WALA points, and average FA and WALA curves were created (Fig 2). Statistical analysis Descriptive statistics including the average and standard deviation of the relative distances between FA and WALA points of corresponding teeth were com- puted and shown graphically. The average values and Fig 1. a, Original model scanning; b, polygon wire-frame image; c, Gouraud-shaded image. Fig 2. Sample FA and WALA curves superimposed. American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics September 2008 432 Ronay et al
  • 4. standard deviations of the intercanine and intermolar widths at FA and WALA including their ratios were calculated. The Pearson correlation coefficients be- tween the width at the bilateral FA points and the WALA points at the canine and molar levels were calculated and statistically analyzed at the 0.01 and 0.05 levels of significance. Furthermore, the Pearson correlation coefficients between the ratios at the FA and WALA point widths were calculated and also statisti- cally analyzed at the 0.01 and 0.05 levels. These evaluations were made to investigate the relationship between points representing the dental arch and those constituting the basal arch. RESULTS A data table was created for each patient (Fig 3). All 3 coordinates (x, y, z) of the FA and the WALA points were described for each tooth, starting at the right first molar and ending with the left first molar. The third dimension (z, vertical) was omitted in further analysis to facilitate comparison in arch width and length. To compare patients, the data was standardized as described above. The patient tables also show the absolute distance between FA and WALA of the corresponding teeth in millimeters. The FA and WALA curves were superimposed to evaluate their relationship Fig 3. Digitized FA and WALA points were imported into Excel 2002 (Microsoft, Redmond, Wash). First, the distances between the 12 pairs were digitally calculated to create the “original” data. Then the data was “translated” with the midline at the origin of the x-y axis. Finally, the data was “rotated” to relocate the first molars as bilateral reference points for standardized y-axis positioning that would permit comparison between subjects. Canine and molar widths and depths, and canine to molar ratios, were determined. This method was applied to each FA-WALA data set. FDI tooth-numbering system; R, right; L, left. American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics Volume 134, Number 3 Ronay et al 433
  • 5. (Fig 2). Male and female data were combined because initial analysis showed them to be indistinguishable. The distribution of FA and WALA points on the mandibular cast is shown in Figures 4 and 5, respec- tively, with the FA and WALA curves produced through connection of their single values by linear interpolation. Those curves are individual and the values describing the same teeth are scattered, espe- cially in the premolar and molar areas. The average relative distances between correspond- ing FA and WALA points were created by summing the values of the right and left sides. This data (Table I) is shown in Figure 6, illustrating which FA points are located more lingually (positive values) and which are located more labially (negative values) in relation to corresponding WALA points. Table II gives the intercanine and intermolar widths for the FA and WALA points in millimeters and the FA Fig 4. FA curves created through linear interpolation of the individual FA values. Fig 5. WALA curves created through linear interpolation of the individual WALA values. American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics September 2008 434 Ronay et al
  • 6. and WALA ratios of the canines and molars to each other, including averages and standard deviations. In the canine area, increasing distances between FA points were accompanied by increasing distances between WALA points. However, the corresponding increase in distances between FA points was always larger. With a canine correlation coefficient of 0.75, this data was highly statistically significant (Table III). Similarly, in the molar region where the proportional increase in distances between the WALA points was even larger, the correlation was also highly significant (0.87). A comparison of the x- and y-coordinates shows that in the canine area there was greater variation in FA than in WALA distances. To a lesser degree, this tendency was also observed in the molar region. DISCUSSION Retention is still a major issue in orthodontics. Theories have been proposed to minimize posttreat- ment relapse, such as creating a proper occlusion4 and muscular balance,21 uprighting mandibular incisors,22 and maintaining the pretreatment apical base6 and intercanine and intermolar widths.14 The purpose of our analysis was to estimate arch dimensions that permit stable treatment goals.2 Orthodontists generally accept the importance of respecting basal bone when planning treatment. Treatment decisions regarding arch form in particular should be related to the patient’s underlying basal anatomy. The definition of apical base is not completely clear in the literature. These words—apical base, basal bone, basal arch, and supporting bone—are not anatomic terminology and are used only in orthodontics. Defini- tions of the vertical position of the basal area of the alveolar process vary. For example, in 1925, Lund- ström6 defined it as follows: “in normal cases the apical base will in the horizontal plane coincide with the region in which the apices of the roots are located.” Howes23 stated that the basal arch refers to the apical third of the alveolus and the bone that supports the alveolar processes below the mandibular teeth. He also explained that it is the most constricted area of the alveolus and is generally about 8 mm below the gingival margin. Clinicians generally assess basal anatomy by either subjective palpation or analyzing lateral cephalograms. The latter uses Points A and B to define the anterior limit of the apical bases, but it obviously does not take into account actual width and overall size. With dental casts, the method of recording the most concave con- tour of the sulci in relation to the apices of the teeth has been reported.24 Various studies have looked at the position of the teeth in the basal bone, and several methods for determining this relationship have been used. In 1945, Tweed25 described a method of sectioning dental casts in the midline to determine the relationship of the incisors to the alveolar and basal bone. Sergl et al24 measured the maxillary and mandibular apical base area using a gnathograph specially designed for this purpose. Oda et al26 presented a technique to record and evaluate mandibular apical base form and tooth posi- tion with computed tomography scans. The use of 3D scanning devices has been reported recently.27 The area of interest is most likely between the bottom of a periodontal pocket and the apex of a tooth. A reason for this variation in definition is the difficulty in estimating the height of the root apex of tooth without x-ray evaluation. However, there is not enough data about the limit of buccal or labial tooth movements, and it is not clear how much the bones can be changed. In 2000, Andrews and Andrews20 pro- posed a new term, WALA ridge, to indicate a surface structure at the same level as basal bone. The WALA ridge is the ridge of tissue at the mucogingival junction, and they suggested that the horizontal arch shape of this ridge of an initial mandibular basal arch in an orthodon- tic patient is similar to the archwire form of the dental arch. The WALA ridge is easy to identify and might be more clinically reliable than estimation of the root apex. However, that hypothesis has not been widely discussed and confirmed. This is the first report that examines the usefulness of WALA points to represent the basal arch and their relevance in determining dental arch form, but further research is required. The use of different points in different reports could have caused confusion regarding arch form. Some studies used the arch form based on points where the orthodontic bracket is placed, and others used the arch form connecting the incisal edges and cusp tips of the teeth. Different results are obtained with these measure- ment methods on the same dental cast.28 This is the first study to investigate the mandibular dental arch form while considering both the clinically relevant working point of the orthodontic bracket and wire and the underlying anatomic-biologic structure of the basal bone to correlate these structures. Most other arch-form Table I. Average distances (mm) of WALA points relative to corresponding FA points and their standard deviations (n ϭ 70) (FDI tooth-numbering system) Tooth 1 2 3 4 5 6 Average Ϫ1.21 Ϫ0.88 Ϫ0.32 0.59 1.78 2.77 SD 1.24 1.07 1.63 1.28 1.10 0.89 American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics Volume 134, Number 3 Ronay et al 435
  • 7. studies attempted to fit generalized mathematic or geometric functions to the dentition but did not look for an anatomic reference for deriving an “ideal” form for each patient. Arch form has been analyzed on plaster reproduc- tions of the dentition for years. By using digital models (3D virtual images), point identification takes on new meaning, particularly for basal arch form. Each identi- fied point has 3 known Cartesian coordinates that permit precise analysis of its position. Relationships between some points can be determined on digital models regardless of interfering structures. Virtual points within the model can also be created and comparisons made between internal and external or surface landmarks. Relatively large individual variations of dental arch form were found with both FA and WALA points as shown in Figures 4 and 5, in spite of excluding dental casts with significant crowding or irregularities. This can be seen as a naturally occurring variation of tooth position and bone anatomy in Class I occlusion. These wide variations in dental and basal arches can be explained by genetic background and environmental factors influencing the patient’s growth and develop- ment. These observations suggest that the quantified arch forms are highly individual and should not be viewed as variations of a general arch form as had been done in the past. On the other hand, a statistically significant positive correlation was found between the dental and basal arches in untreated patients. Comparisons of canine and molar values in Tables II and III show a constant relationship between dental and basal arch forms. A statistically significant positive correlation of canine and molar widths to corresponding FA and WALA points was found. This suggests that the dental arch form is affiliated with the basal arch form (defined by the WALA points) in each patient, supporting the above-mentioned apical base theory. If the dental arch form is altered without considering the basal arch form, it might result in unhealthy periodontal conditions or unstable treatment results. Additionally, by determin- ing WALA values, one can estimate their correspond- ing FA values and then determine clinical arch form, which can produce an archwire form. A statistically significant positive correlation also was found for the WALA and FA canine-to-molar width ratio. This rela- tionship was observed for both dental arch size and shape. These findings have considerable relevance for treatment outcomes. An implant study in the 1980s reported significant lateral expansion of the maxillary basal bone by a functional appliance.13 A recent article reported thinned or dehisced buccal plates after maxil- lary palatal expansion therapy with computed tomog- raphy.29 Ultimately, the new bone-growing theory is still at odds the apical base theory.15 The new bone- growing theorists claim that crowded posterior teeth can be moved laterally, and buccal bones can be developed without tipping and bone loss with ex- tremely light forces. However, most orthodontists be- lieve that the dental arch cannot usually be expanded in a short time without a heavier force, such as with palatal expansion. Thus, a classic controversy in orth- Fig 6. Average distances (mm) of WALA points relative to corresponding FA points and their standard deviations (n ϭ 70). American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics September 2008 436 Ronay et al
  • 8. odontics has been reignited. Research on the morphol- ogy of the supporting bone after conventional and newly developed orthodontic mechanics and stability of the treatment results is therefore critical, and the WALA and FA points used in this study might be useful references for this purpose. Our results demonstrate the ability to look at the apical base and predict a patient’s dental arch form. It will be of future interest to study whether other ana- tomic landmarks could serve as an even more accurate representations of basal bone. Additionally, it should be determined whether the buccolingual relationships be- tween the FA and WALA points are related to archwire torque. Further research should also include the third dimension when assessing patient data to give clini- cians more information about the curve of Spee. How- ever, the vertical distribution of WALA points might depend on not only tooth inclination but also periodon- tal conditions, such as the attachment level or the root length of the patient. We expect that the WALA-FA relationships will be different in patients with Class II and Class III dental and skeletal relationships, as well as in adults relative to growing patients. These are the subjects of continuing investigations. This study shows that distal to the mandibular canines, the average distance between FA and WALA points describing the same tooth changes buccolin- gually. In this posterior area, the FA points are more lingually located than the WALA points. This fact might be linked to the clinically observed gradient of crown torque along the dental arch but also to the differences in basal vs dental arch shape. Andrews and Andrews20 obtained different results. They reported only positive values between FA and WALA points and projected that the points at the mucogingival junction were always more buccally positioned than the most prominent part of the tooth crown. The difference in results can be explained by their method or sample selection. Nonetheless, our findings support their hy- pothesis that WALA points can be used to describe the basal arch and to draw conclusions regarding the dimensions of the dental arch form. Additionally, individual variations of the distance between the WALA and FA points for each tooth were observed. This might reflect the buccolingual inclination of the teeth. As a result of our research, we cannot confirm past research postulating the existence of an ideal arch form template. On the contrary, this study suggests that all basal and dental arches should be individually derived. Furthermore, the basal arch, represented by WALA points, can be used as a clinical guide in fabricating Table III. Correlation coefficients between FA and WALA points at 3-3 width, 6-6 width, and (3-3/6-6) ratio 3-3 width 6-6 width (3-3/6-6) ratio (%) Correlation coefficient 0.750 0.869 0.750 t value (degree of freedom n-2 ϭ 33) 6.520 10.105 6.516 5% significance level 1.69 1.69 1.69 1% significance level 2.45 2.45 2.45 3-3, Canine to canine; 6-6, first molar to first molar. Table II. FA and WALA point distances between ca- nines and molars and their ratios Patient Distances (mm) Ratios (%) FA points WALA points FA ratio (3-3/6-6) WALA ratio (3-3/6-6) 3-3 width 6-6 width 3-3 width 6-6 width 1 28.00 54.50 29.27 60.27 51.37 48.57 2 27.05 50.26 26.50 54.54 53.81 48.59 3 29.80 52.50 28.50 57.76 56.77 49.33 4 28.29 55.28 30.85 59.25 51.17 52.07 5 26.81 48.34 29.37 56.10 55.45 52.34 6 28.26 53.35 30.82 58.15 52.97 53.00 7 30.01 48.77 31.50 54.75 61.53 57.53 8 27.07 52.29 28.01 55.78 51.77 50.23 9 26.00 50.29 28.26 56.33 51.70 50.17 10 26.50 50.75 28.00 53.78 52.21 52.05 11 28.95 56.48 29.42 57.58 51.25 51.10 12 27.02 53.11 27.01 59.26 50.86 45.57 13 26.05 50.10 28.29 56.78 52.00 49.82 14 26.36 48.93 26.53 53.41 53.87 49.67 15 26.05 53.14 24.34 57.35 49.02 42.45 16 28.53 51.59 30.76 59.55 55.31 51.65 17 28.00 48.75 30.75 53.25 57.43 57.76 18 29.54 51.05 30.04 54.06 57.87 55.58 19 24.27 45.50 23.75 49.75 53.35 47.73 20 30.25 59.30 29.75 66.51 51.02 44.73 21 26.50 49.00 27.75 53.75 54.08 51.62 22 29.50 50.74 31.75 57.00 58.12 55.71 23 25.76 47.83 27.81 52.80 53.87 52.68 24 23.52 51.00 24.50 55.50 46.11 44.14 25 27.54 50.01 27.00 52.76 55.06 51.17 26 27.01 49.77 30.00 55.01 54.26 54.53 27 25.67 46.34 27.25 53.05 55.40 51.37 28 28.75 50.50 31.01 58.50 56.92 53.01 29 29.95 54.35 30.29 60.59 55.11 49.99 30 27.00 50.99 30.50 54.75 52.94 55.71 31 27.50 53.00 29.75 58.75 51.88 50.63 32 27.25 54.00 29.99 59.77 50.46 50.18 33 27.07 46.40 29.55 52.81 58.35 55.96 34 29.26 49.31 29.51 55.79 59.34 52.90 35 27.77 50.33 30.04 56.30 55.17 53.36 Average 27.51 51.08 28.81 56.32 53.94 51.22 SD 1.60 2.92 2.02 3.14 0.03 0.04 3-3, Canine to canine; 6-6, first molar to first molar. American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics Volume 134, Number 3 Ronay et al 437
  • 9. individualized archwire templates. Consideration of the anatomy of each mandibular base also ensures that optimal function of the occlusion, periodontal health, desired esthetic appearance, and, of course, stability of the dental arch form can be achieved. With increasing access to 3D patient data, this important information will be available to practitioners and must be consid- ered in orthodontic treatment planning and archwire design. CONCLUSIONS 1. Arch forms derived from both FA and WALA are individual and cannot be defined by 1 generalized shape. These results show that form, degree of curvature, and other parameters of the alveolar ridge and dental arch are subject to much variation. 2. WALA points can be useful in the predetermination of a dental arch form. The highly significant corre- lation of WALA and FA point width in the canine and molar areas proves that assessments of WALA points enable prediction of corresponding FA val- ues and the clinical arch form. We thank Mutsuji Muramoto, UNISN, Osaka, Ja- pan, for generously providing the VMS Dental Plaster Model Shape Scanning System for this study. REFERENCES 1. Brash JC. The etiology of irregularity and malocclusion of the teeth. 2nd ed. London: Dental Board of the United Kingdom; 1956. 2. Proffit WR, Fields HW. Contemporary orthodontics. 3rd ed. St Louis: Mosby Yearbook; 2000. p. 240-93. 3. Peck S. The state of our specialty. Angle Orthod 2004;74:iv. 4. Angle EH. Bone-growing. Dent Cosmos 1910;52:261-7. 5. Corruccini RS. How anthropology informs the orthodontic diag- nosis of malocclusion’s causes. Mellen studies in anthropology. Vol. 1. Lewiston, NY: Edward Mellen Press; 1999. 6. Lundström AF. Malocclusion of the teeth regarded as a problem in connection with the apical base. Int J Orthod Oral Surg Radiogr 1925;9:591-602, 724-31, 793-812, 933-40, 1022-42, 1109-33. 7. Betts NJ, Vanarsdall RL, Barber HD, Higgins-Barber K, Fonseca RJ. Diagnosis and treatment of transverse maxillary deficiency. Int J Adult Orthod Orthognath Surg 1995;10:75-96. 8. Strang RHW. The fallacy of denture expansion as a treatment procedure. Angle Orthod 1949;19:12-22. 9. Tweed CH. Clinical orthodontics. Vol. 1. St Louis: Mosby; 1966. 10. Begg PR. Begg orthodontic theory and technique. Philadelphia: Saunders; 1965. 11. Buchner HJ. An answer to some criticisms of treatment follow- ing bicuspid extractions. Angle Orthod 1949;19:23-47. 12. Rees DJ. A method for assessing the proportional relation of apical bases and contact diameters of the teeth. Am J Orthod 1953;39:695-707. 13. Brieden CM, Pangrazio-Kulbersh V, Kulbersh P. Maxillary skeletal and dental changes with Fränkel appliance therapy—an implant study. Angle Orthod 1984;54:226-32. 14. Little RM. Stability and relapse of dental arch alignment. Br J Orthod 1990;17:235-41. 15. Damon DH. Treatment of the face with biocompatible orthodon- tics. 4th ed. In: Graber TM, Vanarsdall RL, Vig KW, editors. Orthodontics: current principles and techniques. St Louis: Elsevier-Mosby; 2005. p. 753-832. 16. Ricketts RM. Design of arch form and details for bracket placement. Denver: Rocky Mountain Orthodontics; 1979. 17. Arai K, Ishikawa H. Application of non-contact three-dimen- sional shape measuring system to dental cast. Reduction of blind region. Orthod Waves 1999;58:148-53. 18. Hayama K, Arai K, Ishikawa H. Correlation between upper and lower dental arch forms by fitting of fourth-order polynomials. Orthod Waves 2000;59:303-11. 19. Andrews LF. Composites. I: straight-wire, the concept and appliance. San Diego: L. A. Wells; 1989. p. 13-33. 20. Andrews LF, Andrews WA. The six elements of orofacial harmony. Andrews J 2000;1:13-22. 21. Proffit WR. Muscle pressure and tooth position: North American white and Australian aborigines. Angle Orthod 1975;45:1-11. 22. Tweed DH. Frankfort-mandibular plane angle in orthodontic diagnosis, classification, treatment planning and prognosis. Am J Orthod Oral Surg 1946;32:175-230. 23. Howes JH. A polygon portrayal of coronal and basal arch dimensions in the horizontal plane. Am J Orthod 1954;40: 811-31. 24. Sergl HG, Kerr WJS, McColl JH. A method of measuring the apical base. Eur J Orthod 1996;18:479-83. 25. Tweed CH. A philosophy of orthodontic treatment. Am J Orthod Oral Surg 1945;31:74-103. 26. Oda Y, Takada K, Sakuda M. Description of mandibular apical base form and tooth arrangement by means of spline functions. Nippon Kyosei Shika Gakkai Zasshi 1987;46:751-8. 27. Fujita K, Takada K, QianRong G, Shibata T. Patterning of human dental arch wire blanks using a vector quantization algorithm. Angle Orthod 2002;72:285-94. 28. Bennett JC, McLaughlin RP. Arch form considerations for stability and esthetics. Rev Esp Ortod 1999;29:46-63. 29. Garib DG, Henriques JFC, Janson G, de Freitas MR, Fernades AY. Periodontal effects of rapid maxillary expansion with tooth-tissue-borne and tooth-borne expanders: a computed to- mography evaluation. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop 2006; 129:749-58. American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics September 2008 438 Ronay et al