There are a few ethical considerations here:
1. Prioritizing this patient's facial fractures ahead of others could be seen as unfair if his injuries are not more severe or life-threatening. Triage should be based on medical need and severity of condition, not other factors.
2. On the other hand, expediting his facial surgery could help avoid long-term psychological impacts from visible disfigurement, which is also an important consideration.
3. More information would be needed to fully evaluate - details on the types and severity of other patients' injuries currently waiting would provide context.
Overall, a balanced decision that considers both medical need/severity and potential psychological impacts seems most ethical. If his injuries are among the
1. P R E P A R E D B Y
O F O R I - A D D O
MVC CASE STUDY
2. MEDICAL HISTORY AND DIAGNOSIS
On March 15, 2015, A 36yo male was admitted to
SAMMC after ejecting out of vehicle following a
collision.
Upon admission to SAMMC, Pt. was found to be
Hypotensive
Tachycardic,
Acidotic (pH 6.9)
Lactate of 8,
Base deficit of 16,
Pt. was tested positive to a FAST exam.
3. MEDICAL HISTORY AND DIAGNOSIS
He was intubated in the Emergency Department and
transported to the Operating Room where he
underwent
an exploratory laparotomy including splenectomy
repair of a small left hemidiaphragm injury
bilateral tube thoracostomies
placement of intraabdominal drains for a moderate
hemoperitoneum
abdominal wound vac placement
4. MEDICAL HISTORY AND DIAGNOSIS
Patient postoperatively was febrile with thick
tracheal secretions
Cultures demonstrated E. facaelis bacteremia, however the
Patient on March 21, 2015, underwent bronchoscopy
and was subsequently successfully extubated.
Pt continued to have intermittent fevers through 26
March though cultures had been negative since the
initial bacteremia was identified.
5. MEDICAL HISTORY AND DIAGNOSIS
Patient noted to have the following complications
MVC with ejection:
Nasal Fracture
Left distal clavicle fracture
Left scapula fracture
Left Pneumotorax and hemothorax
Left 2-8 rib fractures with flail chest
Left diaphragm injury
Left Adrenal and Renal Laceration
Grade II liver injury - Superficial left of falciform
Small pancreatic tail leak
Oblique fracture of the distal shaft of the radius
Spinous and transverse process fractures of C6-T1, T6, T8, and T10
19. Levalbuterol
Brand Name – Xopenex
Drug Class: Selective Beta 2 adrenergic agonist
Treats or prevents bronchospasm in patients with asthma
or other reversible lung diseases.
Given concomitantly to prevent bronchospasms from…
20. Acetylcysteine
Brand Name – Mucomyst
Drug Class – Mucolytic/Antidote for acetaminophen
Treatment of abnormal, sticky, or thick mucus secretions in
various lung problems (chronic emphysema, bronchitis,
asthmatic bronchitis, pneumonia, during anesthesia,
following surgery or various lung tests).
Given because Pt had flail chest and a laparotomy which
severely decreased his ability to clear secretions.
21. Ipratropium Bromide
Brand Name – Atrovent
Drug Class – Anti-cholinergic
Ipratropium is used to control and prevent wheezing and
shortness of breath caused by chronic lung disease. It works
by relaxing the muscles around the airways so that they
open up and you can breathe easier.
Given to reduce the amount of secretions by blocking the
muscarinic acetylcholine receptors & for its long lasting
bronchodilating effects.
22. Labetalol
Brand Name – Trandate
Drug Class – Beta blocker
Treats high blood pressure. Labetalol is an adrenergic
receptor blocker. It works by blocking both alpha and beta
receptors in the body, which lowers blood pressure.
High point of 207/65 on 29March2359 given prn for bouts
of high BP
23. Promethazine
Brand Name – Phenergan
Drug Class – Anti-emetic
Prevents and controls motion sickness, nausea, vomiting,
and dizziness. Also used to relieve or prevent allergic
reactions, helps people go to sleep, and control their pain or
anxiety before or after surgery or other procedures.
Given to relieve the stress on the abdomen by preventing
vomiting after surgery and as a sleep aid from delirium.
24. Propranolol
Brand Name – Inderal
Drug Class – Beta Blockers
Treats high blood pressure, angina, irregular heartbeat,
migraine headaches, tremors, and lowers the risk of
repeated heart attacks.
Given for daily control of elevated BP.
25. Meperedine
Brand Name – Demerol
Drug Class – Opioid
Short-term treatment of moderate to severe pain. It may
also be used before or during surgery to support anesthesia.
Meperidine is a narcotic analgesic, it works in the brain and
nervous system to decrease pain.
Given to Pt to reduce post operative non-thermoregulatory
shivering.
Depresses the Respiratory system!
26. Hydromorphone
Brand Name - Dilaudid
Drug Class – Opioid
Hydromorphone is used to treat moderate to severe pain
(6-10 on the PACU scale). The extended-release form of
this medicine is for around-the-clock treatment of
moderate to severe pain.
Depresses Respiratory drive!
27. Quetiapine
Brand Name – Seroquel
Drug Class – Atypical Anti-psychotic
Treating schizophrenia or bipolar disorder. Exactly how it
works is not known except that it interrupts
communication among the nerves of the brain.
Given because Pt showed signs of schizophrenia and
delirium from extended ICU stay. States he is “At Sears in
the mall and someone is playing with my feet.”
29. Pt. Fever/Infection
Enterococcus Faecalis is a non-motile, gram-positive, spherical
bacterium. It can be observed singly, in pairs, or in short chains, and is
most often found in the large intestine of humans. It is a facultative
anaerobe with a fermentative metabolism. It can often be confused with
S. pneumonia, but E. Faecalis contains many identification features
that can be verified with testing.
E. Faecalis is listed as the first to the third leading cause of nosocomial
infections. Most of these infections occur after surgery of the abdomen
or a puncturing trauma
E. Faecalis is among the most antibiotic resistant bacteria known. It is
also considered to be a carrier of Vancomycin resistance for other
genera of bacteria. With E. Faecalis occurring frequently in hospital
secondary infections, these multiple drug resistant strains create a
scary concept.
Due to its extremely wide resistance to antibiotic treatments, new
treatments are being developed that allow the bacteria to attack the
“Host Treatment” that eventually leads to its destruction.
31. Patient Care Is Ongoing
• Patient is current eating soft solid foods on his own.
• Patient is not longer on ventilator support.
• Patient was seen at the SAMMC Oral and Facial Surgery Clinic
for a fractured left medial orbital wall and a non displaced distal
nasal bone fracture.
33. Glasgow Comma Scale
(GCS)
I. Motor Response
6 – Obeys commands fully
5 – Localizes to noxious stimuli
4 – Withdraws from noxious stimuli
3 – Abnormal flexion
2 – Extensor response
1 – No response
II. Verbal Response
5 – Alert and Oriented
4 – Confused, yet coherent speech
3 – Inappropriate words and jumbled phrases
consisting of jumbled words.
2 – Incomprehensible sounds
1 – No sounds
III. Eye Opening
4 – Spontaneous eye opening
3 – Eyes open to speech
2 – Eyes open to pain
1 – No eye opening
Mild (13-15)
Moderate (9-12):
■ Loss of consciousness greater than 30 minutes
■ Physical or cognitive impairments which may or
may not resolve
Severe (3-8):
■ Coma: unconscious state. No meaningful
response, no voluntary activity.
Vegetative State (Less Than 3):
■ Sleep wake cycles
■ Arousal, but no interaction with environment
■ No localized response to pain
Persistent Vegetative State:
■ Vegetative state lasting longer than one month
Brain Death:
■ No brain function
■ Specific criteria needed for making this diagnosis
http://www.traumaticbraininjury.com/symptoms-of-tbi/glasgow-coma-scale/
34. Pts Mental Progress Over Course of Treatment
When Patient was brought to SAMC he was rated 3-6 on the Glasgow
Comma Scale. He also had a blood alcohol level of .25.
Through the 16-20 of March Patient’s GCS was between a 6-9 due to being
sedated for the following behaviors.
1. Schizophrenic
2. Agitated
3. Combative
Starting on the 21 March to the present Patient’s GCS has been between 14-
15.
Patient has not suffered any serious injury affecting his brain. To better
confirm any long term affects Patient should be further evaluated by CT or
MIR Neruo scan.
35. Emotional
Patient was involved in a motor vehicle accident.
Individuals who suffer this type of trauma are at higher
risk for:
1. Post Traumatic Stress Disorder
2. Long term anxiety
3. Phobias and fears about vehicles
36. Emotional
The feelings of stress can compile and affect the
Patient's life by interfering with their work and
relationships which can eventually lead to
depression, anxiety, and sleep problems
If symptoms persist from more than 3 months after
the accident it is highly recommend to seek help
from a provider specializing in Post Traumatic Stress
Disorder treatment.
37. Emotional Treatment
Treatment may include:
1. Anxiety management
2. Breathing and relaxation exercises
3. Medications to relieve anxiety and/or help
sleep.
39. ETHICAL QUESTION
Is it ethical for this patient to be sent as a priority to
the facial plastic surgeon (Maxilofacialary surgery)
ahead of the other SAMMC military patients for
facial reconstruction when he was intoxicated and
without insurance?
Note that, Pt. had a .25 on his blood/alcohol level!!!
And his family denied drug/alcohol abuse.