Successful communication can be the factor that “makes or breaks” the interdisciplinary team in the SNF, and is the difference between a workplace you WANT to be in and a workplace you HAVE to be in! The presentation details how effective communication skills, both within your own department and with other departments, can positively affect clinical outcomes and customer satisfaction in the SNF. Learn valuable techniques that will engage staff from all departments and disciplines with the vision of the organization, pulling the team together to work toward a common goal—excellence and the highest level of customer satisfaction. The presentation discusses workplace bullying and demonstrate techniques to eliminate this stressful and team-crushing problem. Key strategies for using the employee annual evaluation as an evidence-based tool for discussion of accomplishments and areas with opportunity for improvement is highlighted. Learn strategies for successfully managing difficult employees and learn how good communication can be the ultimate team-building exercise.
Communication and Coaching: A Nurses Guide to Creating a Harmonious Atmosphere
1. Communication & Coaching: A
Nurse’s Guide to Creating a
Harmonious Atmosphere
HARMONY UNIVERSITY
The Provider Unit of
Harmony Healthcare International, Inc. (HHI)
Presented by:
Beckie Dow, RN, RAC-MT
Director of MDS/Nursing Program Development
I believe that this quote speaks to the positive outcome of good communication so eloquently. When a person leaves an interaction with you they may not remember the particular details of the conversation. What they will take away is the memory of how you made them feel during the interaction. People often judge you based on how you make them feel.
Sound familiar?
Have you ever worked here?
These are statements that frustrated and unhappy employees may make. During todays presentation we will explore some strategies to communicate with your staff more effectively. This will increase their satisfaction, and that satisfaction will trickle down to your customers.
How does it affect customers? (transition to next slide)
If our employees are frustrated and angry our customers will notice. Your front line staff spends more time with your customers than anyone else.
It is a worthwhile time investment to communicate effectively with your staff. It will make your customers experience better. Employee retention and employee loyalty will increase. Your organization will develop a good reputation as a nice place to work and a nice place to live.
Effective communication has numerous benefits (transition to next slide)
Connect with others—when others learn that they can trust what you say (ie, what you see is what you get) and that you can guide them toward doing a better job and therefore having their own personal success.
Express what you really mean—you will be able to tell your employees honestly what you need from them in order to have success for the whole team. This may not necessarily jive with their own personal interests, so you will need skills to persuade them to give up their personal gains in order to contribute to the gains of the collective. This takes a lot of skill!
Navigate challenging situations—you need to practice these skills in smaller-stakes situations so your skills are honed when the larger challenges come along.
Build better relationships—when a staff member realizes you are willing to bear with them feeling angry at you in order to tell the truth (and thereby benefit the organization) you will earn their respect that you are willing to sacrifice your own personal interests in favor of the organization. This builds respect. Talk about my family members who will tell me the truth even if they know I am going to get mad at them for what they said. This shows a true respect for a person—being willing to risk them being mad at you so you can help them to succeed as an employee.
Earn respect and loyalty of your team—see above point.
Connect with others—when others learn that they can trust what you say (ie, what you see is what you get) and that you can guide them toward doing a better job and therefore having their own personal success.
Express what you really mean—you will be able to tell your employees honestly what you need from them in order to have success for the whole team. This may not necessarily jive with their own personal interests, so you will need skills to persuade them to give up their personal gains in order to contribute to the gains of the collective. This takes a lot of skill!
Navigate challenging situations—you need to practice these skills in smaller-stakes situations so your skills are honed when the larger challenges come along.
Build better relationships—when a staff member realizes you are willing to bear with them feeling angry at you in order to tell the truth (and thereby benefit the organization) you will earn their respect that you are willing to sacrifice your own personal interests in favor of the organization. This builds respect. Talk about my family members who will tell me the truth even if they know I am going to get mad at them for what they said. This shows a true respect for a person—being willing to risk them being mad at you so you can help them to succeed as an employee.
Earn respect and loyalty of your team—see above point.
Your staff are always watching you and your behavior can be a big influence on their behavior. As you communicate with them, be conscious that you are modeling the communication behavior you would like them to have with each other and your customers.
Last bullet—this is not to say that staff will always feel good after they interact with you. Maybe it is a heavy-duty discipline session where behaviors need to be addressed. But many staff will base their judgement on how they see you day-to-day, and if you address their concerns adequately and follow up with them.
Non-verbal communication can’t be faked. You can learn to modify it in yourself and read it in others, but there will always remain some aspect your own that you are unaware of or is involuntary. Think of an excellent poker player—they know how to read others and how to school their own reactions, but somebody always comes along who can figure out their “tell”.
You may be familiar with advice on how to sit a certain way, steeple your fingers, or shake hands just so in order to appear confident or assert dominance. But the truth is that such tricks aren’t likely to work (unless you truly feel confident and in charge). That’s because you can’t control all of the signals you’re constantly sending off about what you’re really thinking and feeling. And the harder you try, the more unnatural your signals are likely to come across. And that just makes both parties feel really awkward!
This is why it is so important to manage and lead others well. So your communication will be sincere, both verbal and non-verbal. Please don’t misinterpret my use of the word “sincere”. What I mean is, when your staff is well managed and has the vision of the organization they will be less likely to want to pay attention to the small stuff that kills an organization like gossip and backbiting. You as a manager are key to setting that tone and by doing so you will be less frustrated with your staff and less likely to send negative non-verbal communication to them that they may respond negatively to.
Talk about playing with your cell or checking email while someone is talking to you. When did this officially become socially acceptable and not incredibly rude? If you set clear parameters with staff about how to approach you with their questions and concerns and are not afraid to be honest with them when they are over the top you will not feel as though you have to “dodge” that staff member who always has a complaint.
Pretend that at the end of the conversation you are going to get a quiz on what was said. This may keep your mind from wandering off to the next meeting you need to attend or the next deadline that must be reached.
Talk about Ronald Reagan, known as the Great Communicator. His speech about “The Evil Empire” is famous—those behind the iron curtain who heard him speak knew that the leader of the free world saw their plight
His summary of strategy for the cold war: “We win, they lose”.
“Mr. Gorbechev, tear down this wall” was deleted from his speech numerous times, and he kept putting it back in.
As Reagan himself used to say, he wasn't successful because he was a great communicator. He was a strong leader because he communicated great things.
Many behavior problems stem from an inability of the patient to express themselves—leading to frustration—leading to bad behaviors.
“What we have here is failure to communicate.”
There is a reason why solitary confinement is punishment.
Non-verbal communication and tone of voice is more important than the words spoken (“nice shirt”) We will talk more about non-verbal communication later in this presentation.
Patient at Aug Conv who was a Catholic School Dorm Mistress—swore like nobody I have ever seen.
Comfort and reassurance—but do not be condescending.
Use the quick exit when needed…when you come back they may not even remember your last interaction…fresh start!
“My family hates me and has left me here and will never come and get me ever again!”
Dealing with the facts may not be effective—how do you prove that the family does not hate them? What if they do hate them? Maybe they will be in a car crash and really never come back.
Deal with the emotions…”I can see you are upset. It must be frightening to be staying in a place you have never been before. I am ______and I have been here a while. Let me show you how things go here/where your room is/where we eat/etc.”
Customer service is one of those phrases that gets thrown around a lot. Because we use it so much it almost makes the meaning of it innocuous. We all like to talk about it and then it becomes one of those catch phrases that everyone says, but nobody can really “nail down” if we are doing it. Customer service can’t be defined by what you may think it is in one particular moment, it has to be defined by the entire organization and then everyone follow the model. It is not a relative term up for individual interpretation.
If you were to google customer service you would come up with 100 definitions—all different and all the same. This is a paraphrase of many of the definitions that I found in my research and I think it sums it up nicely.
Trust and loyalty—the patient and their significant others come to trust you when you do what you say you will do and don’t try to do what you cant. Meaning, if they have a problem with something that is not your responsibility or authority you refer them to the person who can help them the best. Show you are interested in their issue and then help them to the person who can best address that issue if it is not you. Loyalty to you coworkers means not throwing others under the bus when there is a complaint but instead work with the patient to get the best and quickest resolution to the problem. This will inspire loyalty for the facility from the customer.
Sacrifice and serving—We cant forget that our jobs are service. We are providing a service that the customer is paying for. We need to provide that service.
Do what you say you will do—People will sometimes “overpromise” to attend to something that is not in their scope of duty, and then they can’t provide the service. The best way to avoid this is to know what you are responsible for and know when you are not qualified or authorized to do something…and if that is the case help the customer to the person who is the most qualified to take care of that particular issue.
Customer needs first—again, we are here for service.
Dignity is extremely important. The definition of dignity is “Dignity—the state or quality of being worthy of honor.” Everybody, from the highest ranking dignitary to the person with the lowest social standing all want to be treated with dignity. And when we know we are not being treated with dignity we react in a negative manner toward the person who is not giving us that respect. If you take nothing else home from this presentation
If you asked any organization (healthcare, business, food industry…anything) they would agree that these are some of the goals of good customer service. The elusive issue becomes---how do we practically apply these noble principles into our daily operations? When we are working short? When the power is out? When a visitor is causing a scene at the nursing station?
These scenarios are precisely why a “quick fix” learning seminar is not the final answer, because…
We have seen how important the family member’s input is on the QCLIs. What you should take away from this is that you are always being watched and observed by the residents and visitors in your facility.
What kind of impression are you making?
We have seen how important the family member’s input is on the QCLIs. What you should take away from this is that you are always being watched and observed by the residents and visitors in your facility.
What kind of impression are you making?
Facial expression—smile, smile, smile. Someone with a serious or angry facial expression is harder to approach and people may approach that person with more of a negative tone, simply based on your facial expression.
Your appearance and attire—be certain you are following dress code and your appearance is neat and clean. Family members judge how we will care for their loved ones based on how we care for ourselves. Hairdo, jewelry and fingernails should be appropriate for a nursing home environment.
Your posture—slouching, leaning up on the wall, standing with hands on hips all give the impression of a negative attitude or not wanting to be at work. I am the worst offender at the hands on the hips thing because I spend a lot of time with my head bent over medical records so I stand like that to stretch my neck and shoulders out. I have to be careful of my posture because I don’t want to come off condescending or domineering.
Your speech and inflection—as I demonstrated earlier, your tone of speech and how you say something is much more important than the words that you use. However, careful choice of kind words, when paired with the proper tone, is the best combination.
Your overall attitude—If you really hate your job you are not fooling anyone. Everyone who works with you knows it and all your patients know it. If you are a negative and miserable person you spread that like perfume (or the opposite of perfume) everywhere you go. Is that what you want to smell like?
Telling someone you can’t help them will only frustrate them more. But, you are not expected to do everything for everyone. If what they are asking for is out of your role you need to direct them to the person who will be able to assist them with their problem or complaint.
Nobody is expected to do everything. But if you can’t do something direct the customer to the person who can help them. Don’t just leave them hanging with a “that’s not my job” kind of attitude.
If someone approaches you angrily for no reason…take a moment to consider it. You may not deserve to have been approached with an angry tone. You may have nothing to do with why the person is angry. It could be totally not your fault.
BUT, if you approach them back with an angry, defensive, or condescending tone you are setting the tempo for the rest of the conversation. They are only going to respond back to you more angry, and then you respond to that, and on and on.
For example: It is change of shift and you have just taken responsibility for the floor. Mrs. Jones approaches you and says: “My mother got no breakfast today and she is starving. I told them that she needs two pairs of socks because her feet get cold and I just walked in to find her barefoot. On top of that her favorite pajamas are missing and I told you all that I would do her laundry. I bet someone stole them. This is the worst place I have ever seen. Nobody here does anything, you all just sit around.”
That is a load of negativity to take when you have just walked in! If you respond back to her in an angry and defensive tone, pointing out that she has no idea if breakfast was eaten because she wasn’t there, that the patient takes off her own socks every day, and that the pj’s are in laundry due to her mom’s incontinence…You will have answered the issues but inflamed the situation.
Better script: “I can see that you care very much for your mother and want her to be comfortable. Those are all important issues. One of my responsibilities is to see that she is clothed properly, so I will make sure she has socks on right now. Then let me take you to my supervisor ________ so she can help you with these other important issues.”
To be successful in these difficult situations it is imparative that you have knowledge of the chain of command (A system whereby authority passes down from the top through a series of executive positions or military ranks in which each is accountable to the one directly superior).
Sub-standard level of care has been a hot topic in the news lately. Medicare is increasing their audits and facilities must respond with higher quality documentation to show what they are doing for the patient.
Employee dissatisfaction affects the residents. If employees are dissatisfied this will get passed on to our residents. Im not talking about abuse here, I just mean a low-level feeling of anger or angst that is communicated through body language or off-handed comments that the residents are exposed to.
Comment that “quality care” is not an easily quantifiable term, because most people have a differing opinions. Segue into next slide…
As a result of the Affordable Care Act, CMS released a 5 part action plan (which will be outlined on the next slide) to improve nursing home safety and quality. This program has a 3 part aim, which is outlined in this graphic.
The CMS Nursing Home Action Plan is based on CMS’ Three-Part Aim for improving U.S. healthcare.
The Three-Part Aim comprises three objectives:
1. Improving the individual experience of care;
2. Improving the health of populations; and
3. Reducing the per capita cost of care for populations.
CMS describes its Action Plan as having themes outlined in the action plan that will guide our efforts to continue progress in improving nursing home safety and quality.
CMS’ strategy consists of five interrelated and coordinated approaches, each of which addresses one or more of the Three-Part Aim objectives – those five approaches are listed on this slide:
Enhance consumer engagement
Strengthen survey processes, standards, and enforcement
Promote quality improvement
Create strategic approaches through partnerships
Advance quality through innovation and demonstration
The Action Plan also addresses 5-star program, Culture Change, Care Transitions, The Inappropriate use of Antipsychotics in Nursing Homes, Advancing Excellence in America’s Nursing Homes campaign, to name a few.
These programs put emphasis on quality care and demonstrable communication between the disciplines in a nursing home, as well as upward towards administration and regional consultants, and even higher to owners and stakeholders.
One could make the correlation that good communication can have the outcome of higher quality care.
This is an example of regulatory mandate regarding communication in a LTC facility. Communication is not just important to ensure that we have good relationships with co-workers, it is also part of our every day lives in a regulated field. Although LTC is currently more regulated than an ALF, we can see that patients in an ALF are remaining in their homes for treatment while sicker and sicker, and returning home after a SNF stay even sooner than before.
Talk about Dawn in an ALF as a med technician and giving morphine for the first time.
One of my biggest frustrations as a CNA was that I knew these patients, and somebody else was making facility rules. Now please keep in mind I was 18, and like many 18-year-olds I knew everything.
So that motivated me to become a nurse, where I would have influence on all these decisions being made. Again, my own interpretation of my nurse power was far greater than actual application. I still felt like decisions were being halfhazardly made all around me, and I did not have sufficient enough influence on the overall picture. My own inflated sense of self-worth continued, but I had made some bad mistakes by this time and had learned how to speak to people without getting written up.
So finally, there I was, in management. Now…I would have the influence I desired. Now…I would be making these mighty decisions that seemed so random to me before. And boy, was I ever going to improve things! Lo and behold, I discovered that there was a reason for all those “crazy management decisions”. Hmm. Who would have figured.
Thankfully, time and experience has taught me a valuable lesson of humility.
But it has also taught me that it is important, to the extent possible, to include all levels of the nursing home in decision making or care planning. Once of my biggest frustrations as a care planner was the feeling that I was writing them in a little box, and that my plans were not being used (again, with the humility here). What I have learned is I was doing it wrong. You need to get input about how it is actually done before you can write a care plan that says how you do it. After all, is it a plan of care for you, or a plan of care for the resident?
Assertiveness is a positive aspect in a manager. Don’t confuse it with jerkiness—this definition does not mean running over everyone or bashing them in with the rules. It means a calm and confident air that can be trusted to be working for the good of the organization.
Many managers lack assertiveness, and therefore the tail wags the dog in their department.
An assertive manager is able to communicate in such a way that they can lead people to do things they may not want to do, and like the fact that they are doing it.
Ultimately, you can’t control your employees will. If they do not want to go in the direction established by your organization you cannot force them to go. But, you can clearly set expectations that apply to all that wish to stay in your organization, and hold the employee to them. They can then choose for themselves if they wish to continue with the organization or move on to another that better meets their needs as an employee. Either way is a win—the employee embraces the vision of your organization or they find another organization that has a vision they can be comfortable in.
The only thing that is not an option is staying in your organization and not complying with the expectations set forth for all employees.
One technique we use with patients who behave in ways we do not like is setting clear expectations, have a meeting with the patient to express those expectations, and then quickly and consistently follow up if the expectation is not met. This methood is still appropriate for our employees.
Setting a clear expectation of what is acceptable and what is not acceptable behavior is the best way to get the behavior that is desired. Often times these employees have good skills on the floor, it is their interaction with coworkers that needs to be addressed. The clearer you are with your expectation, and the better you follow up on incidences, the more you can decrease the incidences of this behavior.
Assertiveness is not workplace bullying—we will talk about that topic shortly.
Managers must make clear what expectations they have, especially regarding work performance and comportment. You don’t have to be a general barking orders at the team, but you do have to make your expectations clear. Your staff cannot read your mind, and when left to figure things out for themselves you may not like how they get things done.
Its important that it is clear what will not be tolerated for behavior. Big things are easy—things that should be common sense like coming to work on time and compliance with company drug policy. Some things are not as easy, such as staff-to-staff behavior. It is important as a manager that you clearly communicate what the organizations stance is on issues and hold staff accountable for that standard.
Many mangers really struggle with the confrontation of speaking to an employee about their behavior—and cope with that by avoiding the conversation.
I know that this was an area that I really struggled with as a new manager. I was very young when given my first management opportunities and lacked the maturity that comes with the life experiences of becoming more comfortable with your own self and not needing to define my self by what others thought of me. I would avoid and avoid and avoid these types of situations until they rose to a ridiculous level, then I would respond with all the frustration that had been growing as the situation mounted. The results of those conversations were not positive!
One of the best things I learned from my mentor is that conflict and confrontation can be healthy. Speaking to someone immediately when they are not meeting expectations—rather than letting that resentment or anger build (or even just a mild annoyance)—is an extremely healthy and effective way to deal with others.
BTW, this works in your personal life, too!
As a manager it is also your responsibility to protect other employees. If one employee is consistently able to get away with bad behavior that often interferes with other employees rights or ability to work their job in peace in the most successful way possible. Sure, the person who is creating the problem may leave eventually. But, it is more likely that others will be forced to work around this person, which causes a morale drain for others.
Worst case scenario: the good employees get fed up an leave. Nursing aides who see co-workers providing poor care to residents they may become disaffected, frustrated, and angry.
Your staff will respect you more if there is a standard that everyone is held accountable to. Letting some get away with behaviors while others cannot is unfair. Your staff will trust you more, and be more effective and happy employees, when the same standard is held for all.
In our business, happy and content employees will take care of our customers better and will give a better overall impression of our organization. This will attract more quality employees and will attract more customers.
Remember--You are the role model. Your staff will be watching your behavior. When you see staff in your organization engaging in behavior that is inconsistent with the values or vision of the organization, it is important to address that behavior. It is important for others to watch facility leadership in regards to this.
Tell the story of Nichole, the worst DON in the universe. Ever. Period.
Satisfying the desire for compensation doesn't have to mean paying astronomical salaries. The salaries at Zappos.com, the online shoe store, are well below market rates (only about $23,000 annually for the average hourly employee), yet the company still manages to inspire almost cult-like loyalty from its employees with its free-spirited corporate culture and dedication to molding its entry-level hires into managers [source: Inc.].
Compensation doesn't have to be monetary. It can come in many forms: stock options, extra time off or even a drink out with the boss.
You can satisfy the need to bond by creating a corporate culture that's based on mutual respect and support. Instead of making employees compete against one another -- which creates a cutthroat environment in which people willingly step on their co-workers to get ahead -- reward employees as a team to encourage camaraderie.
To satisfy the third need, you must have transparency. The company's goals and the employee's responsibilities should be obvious from the moment a new person is hired. Everyone's job should be very clearly delineated, and each employee should understand how his or her individual piece fits into the bigger picture.
Finally, employees should be recognized for every contribution they make to your organization. Whether that reward comes in the form of a promotion, salary increase or just a round of applause at a company event, it's still recognition.
Different companies call performance objectives different things:
Responsibilities
Duties
Results
Outputs
Targets
Results Requirements is a concrete description of a result that you expect from any employee who holds the job. For example for a salesman to make $10,000 per quarter.
Behavior Requirements is a description of how you want employees to behave while getting their job done. Behavior requirements often reflect the values of the company. These will relate back to customer service expectations.
Developmental goals are based on:
Weak spots in the employee’s overall performance that the employee should improve on
Strengths that the employee should nurture and develop
Skills that will help job performance
Also do not try to change the employee through their goals. If they truly hate and are not good at public speaking (for example) don’t make them have a developmental goal to speak in front of 1000 people.
Be realistic. Don’t place so much on the employee that they cannot succeed. This can lead to failure, burnout, and low morale.
Be measureable in your goal. Use a fair method of measurement.
A performance log can be very informal. Include:
Concrete details
Be accurate and don’t exaggerate
Don’t use slurs or inappropriate comments. This log may be aired in the courtroom.
Don’t use language that could be misconstrued as discriminatory
Avoid personal attacks. Concentrate on the behavior, performance, conduct, and productivity
Make each entry complete so anyone reading it could understand what happened
Stick to job-related incidents.
Include any kudos the employee earns.
Prior to the evaluation meeting gather up the information and fill out the forms. Then spend some time using critical thinking skills to determine how the information represents the employee, overall. You can’t trust your gut here—you have to gather and review all the documents first, then make your determination.
Blame: don’t blame the employee if things are going badly or take credit for yourself if things are going well. If the employee is not performing well look critically at the circumstances. If the fault lies with you, take responsibility. Your employee will respect you for that.
First impressions: good or bad, may color your impression. Good employees with a bad first impression may feel discouraged that they cannot seem to get past it! Conversely, those you like well should be evaluated with the same standards
The old saying about nurses eating their young.
Because it can occur in a variety of contexts and forms, it is also useful to define workplace bullying by the key features that these behaviours possess. Bullying is characterized by (Einarsen, 1999; Keashly & Harvey 2004; Lutgen-Sandvik, 2006):
Repetition (occurs regularly)
Duration (is enduring)
Escalation (increasing aggression)
Power disparity (the target lacks the power to successfully defend themself).
Attributed intent
With some variations, the following typology of workplace bullying behaviors has been adopted by a number of academic researchers. The typology uses five different categories.[11] [12]
Threat to professional status – including belittling opinions, public professional humiliation, accusations regarding lack of effort, intimidating use of discipline or competence procedures
Threat to personal standing – including undermining personal integrity, destructive innuendo and sarcasm, making inappropriate jokes about target, persistent teasing, name calling, insults, intimidation
Isolation – including preventing access to opportunities, physical or social isolation, withholding necessary information, keeping the target out of the loop, ignoring or excluding
Overwork – including undue pressure, impossible deadlines, unnecessary disruptions.
Destabilisation – including failure to acknowledge good work, allocation of meaningless tasks, removal of responsibility, repeated reminders of blunders, setting target up to fail, shifting goal posts without telling the target.