SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  36
Publishing Roundtable: Publishing results of program evaluations Peter Winch, Houkje Ross, Jim Ricca CORE Fall Membership Meeting 2008
Some recent history ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
“ Emergent” topic for  today’s roundtable ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Challenges to publishing  results of final evaluations ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Challenges to publishing evaluations 1. Estimation of effort required ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Don’t Underestimate  Level Of Effort ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Challenges to publishing evaluations 2. Identification of key messages ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Challenges to publishing evaluations 2. Identification of key messages ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Abstract example #1 ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Abstract example #2 ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Challenges to publishing evaluations 3. Selection of journal ,[object Object],[object Object]
Challenges to publishing evaluations 3. Selection of journal ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Challenges to publishing evaluations 4. Presentation of quantitative data ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
What is your level of evidence? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Level of evidence Higher  Lower Causal attribution of change to prg.  Yes  (or a qualified yes) No  - doesn’t control for other changes Statements in your paper about the links between the observed changes and the intervention or program “ The intervention was effective in increasing X” “ The intervention had a significant impact” “ The program produced a large drop in mortality” “ A triumph for humanity” “ Two thumbs up” “ We observed higher coverage in the intervention area” “ The intervention was associated with increases in X and Y” “ We recorded fewer deaths in the intervention area, which may be due to X, Y or Z…..”
Challenges to publishing evaluations 5. Presentation of qualitative data ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Finding your focus
[object Object],[object Object]
YOUR PAPER NEEDS A  FOCUS
Consider Your Purpose & Audience ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Some Things to Focus On… ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Too many good ideas?   Finding A Topic ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Try Clustering  Changing Cultural Norms Behavior Change Methods Grandmother Solidarity Circles Training and Supervision of Volunteers M & E Revitalized Health Huts DOTS Bamako Initiative 1987 TB Services at  Community Level? Cultural Views of disease  What are its components? Senegal Health System
Where are the Information Gaps? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
What do You Mean? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Examples for discussion ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
CSHGP Lives Saved Article Case Study Submitted to The Lancet March 2008 Publishing Roundtable CORE Fall Meeting October 2, 2008
CSHGP Lives Saved article: Background ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
CSHGP Lives Saved article: Key Issues ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
CSHGP Lives Saved article: Abstract  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
CSHGP Lives Saved article: Discussion ,[object Object],[object Object]
Selected Reviewer Comments ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Reviewer #4 :  I have some problems with Figure 3. The figure as it stands ONLY applies to these specific programmes and the specific areas and populations they covered. It is incorrect to interpret this as showing which interventions save the most lives, since not all interventions were included in all the programmes.
Discussion Points ,[object Object],[object Object]

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Monitoring and Evaluation Workshops: An approach to improve malaria informati...
Monitoring and Evaluation Workshops: An approach to improve malaria informati...Monitoring and Evaluation Workshops: An approach to improve malaria informati...
Monitoring and Evaluation Workshops: An approach to improve malaria informati...MEASURE Evaluation
 
Analisis Jurnal (Using PICO Model)
Analisis Jurnal (Using PICO Model)Analisis Jurnal (Using PICO Model)
Analisis Jurnal (Using PICO Model)Argitya Righo
 
Demystifying Disaggregated Data: Factors that Affect Collection and Use of Se...
Demystifying Disaggregated Data: Factors that Affect Collection and Use of Se...Demystifying Disaggregated Data: Factors that Affect Collection and Use of Se...
Demystifying Disaggregated Data: Factors that Affect Collection and Use of Se...MEASURE Evaluation
 
Developing Gender-Sensitive M&E Systems
Developing Gender-Sensitive M&E SystemsDeveloping Gender-Sensitive M&E Systems
Developing Gender-Sensitive M&E SystemsMEASURE Evaluation
 
Evaluation of the TB-HIV Integration Strategy on Treatment Outcomes
Evaluation of the TB-HIV Integration Strategy on Treatment OutcomesEvaluation of the TB-HIV Integration Strategy on Treatment Outcomes
Evaluation of the TB-HIV Integration Strategy on Treatment OutcomesMEASURE Evaluation
 
Pathways to scaling up health services Peters and Paina
Pathways to scaling up health services Peters and PainaPathways to scaling up health services Peters and Paina
Pathways to scaling up health services Peters and PainaIDS
 
Diabetes, PHRs,at teams - Hopkins Capstone
Diabetes, PHRs,at teams - Hopkins CapstoneDiabetes, PHRs,at teams - Hopkins Capstone
Diabetes, PHRs,at teams - Hopkins CapstoneWade Schuette
 
Using Routine Data to Improve ART Retention: Examples and Lessons Learned fro...
Using Routine Data to Improve ART Retention: Examples and Lessons Learned fro...Using Routine Data to Improve ART Retention: Examples and Lessons Learned fro...
Using Routine Data to Improve ART Retention: Examples and Lessons Learned fro...MEASURE Evaluation
 
Evaluation of the Impact of a Social Support Strategy on Treatment Outcomes
Evaluation of the Impact of a Social Support Strategy on Treatment OutcomesEvaluation of the Impact of a Social Support Strategy on Treatment Outcomes
Evaluation of the Impact of a Social Support Strategy on Treatment OutcomesMEASURE Evaluation
 
Spatial heterogeneity and intervention effects
Spatial heterogeneity and intervention effectsSpatial heterogeneity and intervention effects
Spatial heterogeneity and intervention effectsvaléry ridde
 
Analysis of cross-country changes in health services
Analysis of cross-country changes in health services Analysis of cross-country changes in health services
Analysis of cross-country changes in health services IDS
 
David Haggstrom Regenstrief Conference Slides
David Haggstrom Regenstrief Conference SlidesDavid Haggstrom Regenstrief Conference Slides
David Haggstrom Regenstrief Conference SlidesShawnHoke
 
Developing a Framework for In-country Impact Evaluations of Malaria Control E...
Developing a Framework for In-country Impact Evaluations of Malaria Control E...Developing a Framework for In-country Impact Evaluations of Malaria Control E...
Developing a Framework for In-country Impact Evaluations of Malaria Control E...MEASURE Evaluation
 
Bringing an ethics lens to the evaluation of a project on user fee exemptions...
Bringing an ethics lens to the evaluation of a project on user fee exemptions...Bringing an ethics lens to the evaluation of a project on user fee exemptions...
Bringing an ethics lens to the evaluation of a project on user fee exemptions...valéry ridde
 
 Emma logsdon· 4· 5 the six challenges for resigning health c
 Emma logsdon· 4· 5 the six challenges for resigning health c Emma logsdon· 4· 5 the six challenges for resigning health c
 Emma logsdon· 4· 5 the six challenges for resigning health cssuser774ad41
 
Submission ide 41d14985 d484-4305-976f-c8858ad6647630 si
Submission ide 41d14985 d484-4305-976f-c8858ad6647630 siSubmission ide 41d14985 d484-4305-976f-c8858ad6647630 si
Submission ide 41d14985 d484-4305-976f-c8858ad6647630 sirock73
 
COUNTDOWN on WHO 2020 Targets: A Focus on helminthiasis
COUNTDOWN on WHO 2020 Targets: A Focus on helminthiasisCOUNTDOWN on WHO 2020 Targets: A Focus on helminthiasis
COUNTDOWN on WHO 2020 Targets: A Focus on helminthiasisCOUNTDOWN on NTDs
 
Getting Knowledge into Action for Best Quality Healthcare
Getting Knowledge into Action for Best Quality HealthcareGetting Knowledge into Action for Best Quality Healthcare
Getting Knowledge into Action for Best Quality HealthcareNHSScotlandEvent
 

Tendances (20)

Monitoring and Evaluation Workshops: An approach to improve malaria informati...
Monitoring and Evaluation Workshops: An approach to improve malaria informati...Monitoring and Evaluation Workshops: An approach to improve malaria informati...
Monitoring and Evaluation Workshops: An approach to improve malaria informati...
 
Analisis Jurnal (Using PICO Model)
Analisis Jurnal (Using PICO Model)Analisis Jurnal (Using PICO Model)
Analisis Jurnal (Using PICO Model)
 
Demystifying Disaggregated Data: Factors that Affect Collection and Use of Se...
Demystifying Disaggregated Data: Factors that Affect Collection and Use of Se...Demystifying Disaggregated Data: Factors that Affect Collection and Use of Se...
Demystifying Disaggregated Data: Factors that Affect Collection and Use of Se...
 
Developing Gender-Sensitive M&E Systems
Developing Gender-Sensitive M&E SystemsDeveloping Gender-Sensitive M&E Systems
Developing Gender-Sensitive M&E Systems
 
Evaluation of the TB-HIV Integration Strategy on Treatment Outcomes
Evaluation of the TB-HIV Integration Strategy on Treatment OutcomesEvaluation of the TB-HIV Integration Strategy on Treatment Outcomes
Evaluation of the TB-HIV Integration Strategy on Treatment Outcomes
 
Pathways to scaling up health services Peters and Paina
Pathways to scaling up health services Peters and PainaPathways to scaling up health services Peters and Paina
Pathways to scaling up health services Peters and Paina
 
Diabetes, PHRs,at teams - Hopkins Capstone
Diabetes, PHRs,at teams - Hopkins CapstoneDiabetes, PHRs,at teams - Hopkins Capstone
Diabetes, PHRs,at teams - Hopkins Capstone
 
Using Routine Data to Improve ART Retention: Examples and Lessons Learned fro...
Using Routine Data to Improve ART Retention: Examples and Lessons Learned fro...Using Routine Data to Improve ART Retention: Examples and Lessons Learned fro...
Using Routine Data to Improve ART Retention: Examples and Lessons Learned fro...
 
Evaluation of the Impact of a Social Support Strategy on Treatment Outcomes
Evaluation of the Impact of a Social Support Strategy on Treatment OutcomesEvaluation of the Impact of a Social Support Strategy on Treatment Outcomes
Evaluation of the Impact of a Social Support Strategy on Treatment Outcomes
 
Spatial heterogeneity and intervention effects
Spatial heterogeneity and intervention effectsSpatial heterogeneity and intervention effects
Spatial heterogeneity and intervention effects
 
Analysis of cross-country changes in health services
Analysis of cross-country changes in health services Analysis of cross-country changes in health services
Analysis of cross-country changes in health services
 
David Haggstrom Regenstrief Conference Slides
David Haggstrom Regenstrief Conference SlidesDavid Haggstrom Regenstrief Conference Slides
David Haggstrom Regenstrief Conference Slides
 
Developing a Framework for In-country Impact Evaluations of Malaria Control E...
Developing a Framework for In-country Impact Evaluations of Malaria Control E...Developing a Framework for In-country Impact Evaluations of Malaria Control E...
Developing a Framework for In-country Impact Evaluations of Malaria Control E...
 
Bringing an ethics lens to the evaluation of a project on user fee exemptions...
Bringing an ethics lens to the evaluation of a project on user fee exemptions...Bringing an ethics lens to the evaluation of a project on user fee exemptions...
Bringing an ethics lens to the evaluation of a project on user fee exemptions...
 
The Learning Health System: Democratizing Health Together
The Learning Health System: Democratizing Health TogetherThe Learning Health System: Democratizing Health Together
The Learning Health System: Democratizing Health Together
 
The Learning Health System in 5 Chapters - Guest speaker, William A. Yasnoff
The Learning Health System in 5 Chapters - Guest speaker, William A. YasnoffThe Learning Health System in 5 Chapters - Guest speaker, William A. Yasnoff
The Learning Health System in 5 Chapters - Guest speaker, William A. Yasnoff
 
 Emma logsdon· 4· 5 the six challenges for resigning health c
 Emma logsdon· 4· 5 the six challenges for resigning health c Emma logsdon· 4· 5 the six challenges for resigning health c
 Emma logsdon· 4· 5 the six challenges for resigning health c
 
Submission ide 41d14985 d484-4305-976f-c8858ad6647630 si
Submission ide 41d14985 d484-4305-976f-c8858ad6647630 siSubmission ide 41d14985 d484-4305-976f-c8858ad6647630 si
Submission ide 41d14985 d484-4305-976f-c8858ad6647630 si
 
COUNTDOWN on WHO 2020 Targets: A Focus on helminthiasis
COUNTDOWN on WHO 2020 Targets: A Focus on helminthiasisCOUNTDOWN on WHO 2020 Targets: A Focus on helminthiasis
COUNTDOWN on WHO 2020 Targets: A Focus on helminthiasis
 
Getting Knowledge into Action for Best Quality Healthcare
Getting Knowledge into Action for Best Quality HealthcareGetting Knowledge into Action for Best Quality Healthcare
Getting Knowledge into Action for Best Quality Healthcare
 

En vedette

Scientific literature & format of journal article
Scientific literature & format of journal articleScientific literature & format of journal article
Scientific literature & format of journal articleBenjamin Barba III
 
Article Presentation
Article  PresentationArticle  Presentation
Article PresentationAlyson
 
Severe Acute Malnutrition by Moracha
Severe Acute Malnutrition by MorachaSevere Acute Malnutrition by Moracha
Severe Acute Malnutrition by MorachaKevin Moracha
 
Journal 1 Presentation Powerpoint
Journal 1 Presentation PowerpointJournal 1 Presentation Powerpoint
Journal 1 Presentation PowerpointKelsey
 
Example of article presentation
Example of article presentationExample of article presentation
Example of article presentationCameliaN
 
Review Paper – Power Point Presentation
Review Paper – Power Point PresentationReview Paper – Power Point Presentation
Review Paper – Power Point PresentationFerglapanter
 
How to present a journal club
How to present a journal clubHow to present a journal club
How to present a journal clubsanch1684
 
How to review a journal paper and prepare oral presentation
How to review a journal paper and prepare oral presentationHow to review a journal paper and prepare oral presentation
How to review a journal paper and prepare oral presentationSeppo Karrila
 

En vedette (11)

Scientific literature & format of journal article
Scientific literature & format of journal articleScientific literature & format of journal article
Scientific literature & format of journal article
 
Article Presentation
Article  PresentationArticle  Presentation
Article Presentation
 
Severe Acute Malnutrition by Moracha
Severe Acute Malnutrition by MorachaSevere Acute Malnutrition by Moracha
Severe Acute Malnutrition by Moracha
 
Severe acute malnutrition
Severe acute malnutritionSevere acute malnutrition
Severe acute malnutrition
 
Journal Club Presentation
Journal Club PresentationJournal Club Presentation
Journal Club Presentation
 
Journal 1 Presentation Powerpoint
Journal 1 Presentation PowerpointJournal 1 Presentation Powerpoint
Journal 1 Presentation Powerpoint
 
Example of article presentation
Example of article presentationExample of article presentation
Example of article presentation
 
Review Paper – Power Point Presentation
Review Paper – Power Point PresentationReview Paper – Power Point Presentation
Review Paper – Power Point Presentation
 
journal presentation
 journal presentation journal presentation
journal presentation
 
How to present a journal club
How to present a journal clubHow to present a journal club
How to present a journal club
 
How to review a journal paper and prepare oral presentation
How to review a journal paper and prepare oral presentationHow to review a journal paper and prepare oral presentation
How to review a journal paper and prepare oral presentation
 

Similaire à Publishing in Public Health

Running head PSYCHOLOGY1PSYCHOLOGY7Programmatic pur.docx
Running head PSYCHOLOGY1PSYCHOLOGY7Programmatic pur.docxRunning head PSYCHOLOGY1PSYCHOLOGY7Programmatic pur.docx
Running head PSYCHOLOGY1PSYCHOLOGY7Programmatic pur.docxtoltonkendal
 
Improving practice through evidence not only helps lower healthcare improve.docx
Improving practice through evidence not only helps lower healthcare improve.docxImproving practice through evidence not only helps lower healthcare improve.docx
Improving practice through evidence not only helps lower healthcare improve.docxwrite4
 
Population health improvement plan.docx
Population health improvement plan.docxPopulation health improvement plan.docx
Population health improvement plan.docxsdfghj21
 
Helping chronically ill or disabled people into work: what can we learn from ...
Helping chronically ill or disabled people into work: what can we learn from ...Helping chronically ill or disabled people into work: what can we learn from ...
Helping chronically ill or disabled people into work: what can we learn from ...StephenClayton11
 
National Institute of Health: Theory at a Glance, A Guide for Health Promotio...
National Institute of Health: Theory at a Glance, A Guide for Health Promotio...National Institute of Health: Theory at a Glance, A Guide for Health Promotio...
National Institute of Health: Theory at a Glance, A Guide for Health Promotio...Zach Lukasiewicz
 
Agenda Setting.docx
Agenda Setting.docxAgenda Setting.docx
Agenda Setting.docxwrite22
 
Assignment WK 9Assessing a Healthcare ProgramPolicy Evaluation.docx
Assignment WK 9Assessing a Healthcare ProgramPolicy Evaluation.docxAssignment WK 9Assessing a Healthcare ProgramPolicy Evaluation.docx
Assignment WK 9Assessing a Healthcare ProgramPolicy Evaluation.docxjesuslightbody
 
Assessment 3PRINTLetter to the Editor Population Health P.docx
Assessment 3PRINTLetter to the Editor Population Health P.docxAssessment 3PRINTLetter to the Editor Population Health P.docx
Assessment 3PRINTLetter to the Editor Population Health P.docxgalerussel59292
 
Agenda SettingA key aspect of the policy process is agenda
Agenda SettingA key aspect of the policy process is agendaAgenda SettingA key aspect of the policy process is agenda
Agenda SettingA key aspect of the policy process is agendacheryllwashburn
 
Write a letter to the editor of an academic or professional jo.docx
Write a letter to the editor of an academic or professional jo.docxWrite a letter to the editor of an academic or professional jo.docx
Write a letter to the editor of an academic or professional jo.docxwashingtonrosy
 
Population Health Improvement Plan Assignment 3.docx
Population Health Improvement Plan Assignment 3.docxPopulation Health Improvement Plan Assignment 3.docx
Population Health Improvement Plan Assignment 3.docxsdfghj21
 
Assessment 2PRINTBiopsychosocial Population Health Policy .docx
Assessment 2PRINTBiopsychosocial Population Health Policy .docxAssessment 2PRINTBiopsychosocial Population Health Policy .docx
Assessment 2PRINTBiopsychosocial Population Health Policy .docxgalerussel59292
 
Initial PostWhile working as a registered nurse on the Alzheimer.docx
Initial PostWhile working as a registered nurse on the Alzheimer.docxInitial PostWhile working as a registered nurse on the Alzheimer.docx
Initial PostWhile working as a registered nurse on the Alzheimer.docxLaticiaGrissomzz
 
Evidence-Informed Public Health Decisions Made Easier: Take it one Step at a ...
Evidence-Informed Public Health Decisions Made Easier: Take it one Step at a ...Evidence-Informed Public Health Decisions Made Easier: Take it one Step at a ...
Evidence-Informed Public Health Decisions Made Easier: Take it one Step at a ...Health Evidence™
 
Practical Guidance for Incorporating Health Equity Learning_Jennifer Winestoc...
Practical Guidance for Incorporating Health Equity Learning_Jennifer Winestoc...Practical Guidance for Incorporating Health Equity Learning_Jennifer Winestoc...
Practical Guidance for Incorporating Health Equity Learning_Jennifer Winestoc...CORE Group
 
After completing the processes from beginning to the.docx
After completing the processes from beginning to the.docxAfter completing the processes from beginning to the.docx
After completing the processes from beginning to the.docxwrite4
 

Similaire à Publishing in Public Health (20)

Running head PSYCHOLOGY1PSYCHOLOGY7Programmatic pur.docx
Running head PSYCHOLOGY1PSYCHOLOGY7Programmatic pur.docxRunning head PSYCHOLOGY1PSYCHOLOGY7Programmatic pur.docx
Running head PSYCHOLOGY1PSYCHOLOGY7Programmatic pur.docx
 
Improving practice through evidence not only helps lower healthcare improve.docx
Improving practice through evidence not only helps lower healthcare improve.docxImproving practice through evidence not only helps lower healthcare improve.docx
Improving practice through evidence not only helps lower healthcare improve.docx
 
Population health improvement plan.docx
Population health improvement plan.docxPopulation health improvement plan.docx
Population health improvement plan.docx
 
Helping chronically ill or disabled people into work: what can we learn from ...
Helping chronically ill or disabled people into work: what can we learn from ...Helping chronically ill or disabled people into work: what can we learn from ...
Helping chronically ill or disabled people into work: what can we learn from ...
 
Epe talk for Supervisors
Epe talk for SupervisorsEpe talk for Supervisors
Epe talk for Supervisors
 
National Institute of Health: Theory at a Glance, A Guide for Health Promotio...
National Institute of Health: Theory at a Glance, A Guide for Health Promotio...National Institute of Health: Theory at a Glance, A Guide for Health Promotio...
National Institute of Health: Theory at a Glance, A Guide for Health Promotio...
 
Agenda Setting.docx
Agenda Setting.docxAgenda Setting.docx
Agenda Setting.docx
 
Theory at a Glance
Theory at a GlanceTheory at a Glance
Theory at a Glance
 
Agenda Setting Empire Essays.pdf
Agenda Setting Empire Essays.pdfAgenda Setting Empire Essays.pdf
Agenda Setting Empire Essays.pdf
 
Assignment WK 9Assessing a Healthcare ProgramPolicy Evaluation.docx
Assignment WK 9Assessing a Healthcare ProgramPolicy Evaluation.docxAssignment WK 9Assessing a Healthcare ProgramPolicy Evaluation.docx
Assignment WK 9Assessing a Healthcare ProgramPolicy Evaluation.docx
 
Assessment 3PRINTLetter to the Editor Population Health P.docx
Assessment 3PRINTLetter to the Editor Population Health P.docxAssessment 3PRINTLetter to the Editor Population Health P.docx
Assessment 3PRINTLetter to the Editor Population Health P.docx
 
Agenda SettingA key aspect of the policy process is agenda
Agenda SettingA key aspect of the policy process is agendaAgenda SettingA key aspect of the policy process is agenda
Agenda SettingA key aspect of the policy process is agenda
 
Write a letter to the editor of an academic or professional jo.docx
Write a letter to the editor of an academic or professional jo.docxWrite a letter to the editor of an academic or professional jo.docx
Write a letter to the editor of an academic or professional jo.docx
 
Population Health Improvement Plan Assignment 3.docx
Population Health Improvement Plan Assignment 3.docxPopulation Health Improvement Plan Assignment 3.docx
Population Health Improvement Plan Assignment 3.docx
 
Enhancing health systems and role of health policy and systems research and a...
Enhancing health systems and role of health policy and systems research and a...Enhancing health systems and role of health policy and systems research and a...
Enhancing health systems and role of health policy and systems research and a...
 
Assessment 2PRINTBiopsychosocial Population Health Policy .docx
Assessment 2PRINTBiopsychosocial Population Health Policy .docxAssessment 2PRINTBiopsychosocial Population Health Policy .docx
Assessment 2PRINTBiopsychosocial Population Health Policy .docx
 
Initial PostWhile working as a registered nurse on the Alzheimer.docx
Initial PostWhile working as a registered nurse on the Alzheimer.docxInitial PostWhile working as a registered nurse on the Alzheimer.docx
Initial PostWhile working as a registered nurse on the Alzheimer.docx
 
Evidence-Informed Public Health Decisions Made Easier: Take it one Step at a ...
Evidence-Informed Public Health Decisions Made Easier: Take it one Step at a ...Evidence-Informed Public Health Decisions Made Easier: Take it one Step at a ...
Evidence-Informed Public Health Decisions Made Easier: Take it one Step at a ...
 
Practical Guidance for Incorporating Health Equity Learning_Jennifer Winestoc...
Practical Guidance for Incorporating Health Equity Learning_Jennifer Winestoc...Practical Guidance for Incorporating Health Equity Learning_Jennifer Winestoc...
Practical Guidance for Incorporating Health Equity Learning_Jennifer Winestoc...
 
After completing the processes from beginning to the.docx
After completing the processes from beginning to the.docxAfter completing the processes from beginning to the.docx
After completing the processes from beginning to the.docx
 

Publishing in Public Health

  • 1. Publishing Roundtable: Publishing results of program evaluations Peter Winch, Houkje Ross, Jim Ricca CORE Fall Membership Meeting 2008
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17. Level of evidence Higher Lower Causal attribution of change to prg. Yes (or a qualified yes) No - doesn’t control for other changes Statements in your paper about the links between the observed changes and the intervention or program “ The intervention was effective in increasing X” “ The intervention had a significant impact” “ The program produced a large drop in mortality” “ A triumph for humanity” “ Two thumbs up” “ We observed higher coverage in the intervention area” “ The intervention was associated with increases in X and Y” “ We recorded fewer deaths in the intervention area, which may be due to X, Y or Z…..”
  • 18.
  • 20.
  • 21. YOUR PAPER NEEDS A FOCUS
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 25. Try Clustering Changing Cultural Norms Behavior Change Methods Grandmother Solidarity Circles Training and Supervision of Volunteers M & E Revitalized Health Huts DOTS Bamako Initiative 1987 TB Services at Community Level? Cultural Views of disease What are its components? Senegal Health System
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28.
  • 29. CSHGP Lives Saved Article Case Study Submitted to The Lancet March 2008 Publishing Roundtable CORE Fall Meeting October 2, 2008
  • 30.
  • 31.
  • 32.
  • 33.
  • 34.
  • 35. Reviewer #4 :  I have some problems with Figure 3. The figure as it stands ONLY applies to these specific programmes and the specific areas and populations they covered. It is incorrect to interpret this as showing which interventions save the most lives, since not all interventions were included in all the programmes.
  • 36.