1. Dell’s Future Beyond
the PC Business
MOT 5223
James Groh ● Stuart Bankey ● Ryan Zapata ● Daniel Montemayor
2. Overview of Industry
Industry Background:
• The industry is highly concentrated, with the four largest companies
controlling 79.9% of industry revenue. During the five years to 2011,
fierce competition has made computer manufacturing an increasingly
commoditized business.
• Despite declining revenue,
domestic demand for computers
has increased during the past
five years highlighted by the
increasing proportion of
Americans that own computers.
4. Competitors Position
The industry is highly concentrated, with the four largest
companies controlling 79.9% of industry revenue. Major
players have been extremely aggressive in acquisitions
during the past five years, and IBISWorld expects further
concentration of industry revenue in the future as these
acquisitions continue.
5. Overview of Dell
Dell has shifted its strategy toward higher margin products. For
instance, Dell is expanding its enterprise solutions and services,
which include servers, networking, storage and related services.
To achieve growth in this
category, Dell expects to
leverage its existing customer
base, partner with other
companies and invest in
strategic acquisitions.
6. Dell’s Leadership
Michael Dell built this company in the personal computer
business. The company has changed considerable, especially
since Michael Dell returned as chief executive in January 2007.
“A lot of people think of
Dell as what it was five
or 10 years ago, but
we’ve moved much
more into the core of
information technology,
into the data center.”
7. Problem
• What is the problem?
– “Just a PC company.”
– How to expand into services for mid-sized
businesses?
8. Problem
• Root Cause
– 2005 stock price drop.
• $40.29/share to $30.64/share
• Continued to drop in 2006 ($26.16/share EOY
2006)
– Lost #1 title to HP
– Customer service problem
11. Problem
• Turning Point
– Mr. Dell’s return as CEO in January 2007.
• Controlling Points
– Focus of company
– Current and future product portfolio
12. Problem Summary
• Dell was number 1 but lost it shortly
after Rollins took over.
• Michael Dell returned and
determined the company’s difficulty
were are result of the lack of
services.
13. PC Vendor Unit Shipment
Estimates 4th Quarter 2011
Company 4Q11 4Q11 4Q10 4Q10 4Q11-
Shipments Market Shipments Market 4Q10
Share Share Growth
(%) (%) (%)
HP 4,137,833 23.1 5,598,619 29.4 -26.1
Dell 4,020,549 22.4 4,210,000 22.1 -4.5
Apple 2,074,800 11.6 1,718,400 9.0 20.7
Toshiba 1,925,100 10.7 1,968,091 10.3 -2.2
Acer Group 1,756,838 9.8 1,982,477 10.4 -11.4
Others 4,014,644 22.4 3,583,418 18.8 12.0
Total 17,929,764 100.0 19,061,005 100.0 -5.9
14. iPad eats PC market share
• Improvements to the iPad turn it into a
potential PC replacement for more and more
people.
• More powerful chips mean more
sophisticated aps can reside on the iPad.
• The iCloud should make the iPad's limited
storage capacity less relevant.
• Built in LTE makes the tablet an attractive
alternative for travelers who don’t want to
hunt for a Wi-Fi hotspot.
15. Reaction to Problem
• Since 2007 Dell has grown by both increasing
its customer base and through acquisitions.
• Dell has expanded into new markets. Most
notably business services.
• As of February 27, 2012, 47,000 out of Dell’s
110,000 employees work in business services
• $7.7 billion a year business and about 12% of
total revenue.
16. Dell’s Server Division
• One notable acquisition was of Perot
Systems, in 2009, which had a large
health consulting and services business.
• Dell is now the #1 provider of health
technology services
• The company stores more than 4 billion
medical images in its data centers, so
hospitals do not have to grapple with that
chore on their own.
17. Dell’s Server Division (cont.)
• In addition to acquiring companies. Dell
has innovated.
• Server customers have many diverse
choices and often cannot afford
comprehensive upgrades.
• Therefore, Dell’s products must work with
all kinds of new and older networking and
data storage equipment.
18. Dell’s Server Division (cont.)
• Dell servers run at 5 watts (about as much
as a night light).
• They manage internal temperature, since
a machine’s cooling fans use more power
than anything else.
19. Midsized Businesses Services
• Michael Dell believes the big potential
market is offering services to midsize
businesses, typically companies with from
a few hundred to a few thousand
employees
• According to him, Rivals I.B.M. and
Hewlett-Packard, have a more costly
business models aimed at large
corporations.
20. Midsized Businesses Services (Cont.)
• On February 10, 2010 Dell acquired KACE
Networks, a leader in Systems
Management Appliances.
• Dell stated it was buying KACE to expand
its systems management offerings to
better address IT administrators in mid-
size organizations.
21. Midsized Businesses Services
(Cont.)
• Support Services
• Configuration and Deployment
• Cloud and IT Management
• Business Continuity and Protection
• Training Services
22. Our Evaluation of Dell’s case
• Do we agree with the Dell’s decision to evolve
into more of a services company?
– YES!!!
– Helps diversify its business
– IT industry is evolving; get with the program…
– Maintain their “affordable and efficient” tradition
– Affordable & Efficient Hardware + Service = $$$
+ =
23. Our Evaluation of Dell’s case
• What would we do to remedy the problem
at hand?
– What problem?
– Dell already in most midsized datacenters
– Service via cloud or data center management
– Develop a sound market strategy
– Continue to appeal to medical information
record management organizations
24. Our Evaluation of Dell’s case
• Breakdown on their decision
– Dell is trying to be recognized as
more than a hardware
– Already has a foot in the
datacenter door with their
hardware
– Continue to appeal to midsized
datacenters
– Companies may look to Dell for
both hardware and service needs
25. Our Evaluation of Dell’s case
• Competition?
– HP, IBM and other IT service support
organizations.
• IBM – “Building a Smarter Planet”
• HP – Has HP Services division in government market
• Harris IT Services (My Company)
– Division of Harris
• Has numerous IT services support contracts
– Medical & Dental
– Commercial and Government Sectors
26. Our Evaluation of Dell’s case
• What if we were against the services
initiative?
– Dell may have lost out on millions if not
billions
– Could have filed for bankruptcy
27. Our Evaluation of Dell’s case
• Remember, “If there is a will there is a
way”
– Don’t overlook these IT giants evolving their
business into service oriented businesses
– One multi million dollar service contract can
make a difference
28. Our final thoughts…
• Dell will need to market themselves as a
reputable service leader
• Focus on IT service for midsized
businesses
• Continue going after medical IT market
• Perhaps price leverage their hardware and
service into an affordable bundle plan
• Spend a little now to continue making
billions…
Revenue for the Computer Manufacturing industry is estimated to decline at an average annual rate of 2.5% over the period. In 2011, industry revenue is expected to decline by 4.8% to $40.7 billion as import penetration into this industry ramps up and domestic manufacturers benefit little from unfavorable exchange rates.Indeed, PC penetration (the share of US households with at least one personal computer, or PC) has increased from 67.3% in 2006 to 75.4% in 2011. As Americans become more computer-literate, the market for computer-related goods and services grows.
This chart shows where the industry lies within the three key life cycle stages, growth, maturity or decline, by plotting the relationship between the industry’s change in contribution to the economy and the percentage change in the number of industry establishments. To show the industry’s relative position in the economy, the life cycle stages of its key supply, demand and competing industries are also shown. Each life cycle stage represents unique characteristics that may be used to make strategic decisions and to determine the level of competition and opportunities that may exist. Most industries move counter clockwise around the chart segments: from growth to maturity and then to decline.
When Michael Dell resigned as CEO in 2005, Kevin Rollins took over as CEO. After a couple of years of difficulty, Rollins stepped down as CEO and Michael Dell came back. Dell attributed the company’s loses to only focusing on one market.
the stock drop of 25% in 2005 and another drop of 15% in 2006. http://finance.yahoo.com (http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=DELL+Interactive#symbol=dell;range=20060508,20120409;compare=;indicator=volume;charttype=area;crosshair=on;ohlcvalues=0;logscale=off;source=undefined;)losing its number 1 spot in the PC market to HP (HP shipped 9,831,000 PCs to 9,803,000 shipped by Dell) http://www.crn.com/news/components-peripherals/193400459/hp-passes-dell-as-top-pc-maker-worldwide.htm;jsessionid=7RiagoDX2Bg-4p045rJFYA**.ecappj03numerous complaints about customer service (http://www.pcworld.com/article/132492/lawsuit_highlights_complaints_of_angry_dell_customers.html and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dell)-couldn’t keep up with customer growth-was outsourced to foreign countries
the stock drop of 25% in 2005 and another drop of 15% in 2006. http://finance.yahoo.com (http://finance.yahoo.com/echarts?s=DELL+Interactive#symbol=dell;range=20060508,20120409;compare=;indicator=volume;charttype=area;crosshair=on;ohlcvalues=0;logscale=off;source=undefined;)losing its number 1 spot in the PC market to HP (HP shipped 9,831,000 PCs to 9,803,000 shipped by Dell) http://www.crn.com/news/components-peripherals/193400459/hp-passes-dell-as-top-pc-maker-worldwide.htm;jsessionid=7RiagoDX2Bg-4p045rJFYA**.ecappj03numerous complaints about customer service (http://www.pcworld.com/article/132492/lawsuit_highlights_complaints_of_angry_dell_customers.html and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dell)-couldn’t keep up with customer growth-was outsourced to foreign countries
losing its number 1 spot in the PC market to HP (HP shipped 9,831,000 PCs to 9,803,000 shipped by Dell) http://www.crn.com/news/components-peripherals/193400459/hp-passes-dell-as-top-pc-maker-worldwide.htm;jsessionid=7RiagoDX2Bg-4p045rJFYA**.ecappj03numerous complaints about customer service (http://www.pcworld.com/article/132492/lawsuit_highlights_complaints_of_angry_dell_customers.html and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dell)-couldn’t keep up with customer growth-was outsourced to foreign countries
Source: Gartner (January 2012)Data includes desk-based PCs, mobile PCs, including mini-notebooks but not media tablets such as the iPad, which have also been eroding PC sales.
#1 According to Gartner, a respected research firm that tracks the PC business
All KACE products are sold as "black box" appliances. These systems are delivered as 19" rack servers and, except for initial IP network settings via a console login, all communication with the product is done using the web-based GUI.
Dell is more than just a server company, and offers a diverse array of services to midsize companies.Support Services:Provide end users and IT professionals with remote and on-site technical support forDell and non-Dell hardware and software.Configuration and Deployment: Dell promises to lower costs, avoid downtime and reduce installation times with preconfigured systems that are ready for use, straight out of the box, and the aid of certified technicians during deployment.Cloud and IT Management: Dell Boomi® allows companies to connect and integrate any combination of cloud, Software as a Service (SaaS) or on-premise applications with no appliances, software or coding.Business Continuity and Protection: Asset Protection, for example repair or replace a damaged laptop no matter where you are in the world. Data Protection, protect valuable and sensitive data in the event of loss, theft or failed hard drive and help recover, delete or destroy your important data.Training Services: Dell trainsIT professionals and end users.
Do you agree with the company’s decisions taken?Yes but as long as they remember their roots. Yes we agree on the Dell’s decision to branch out into services because we see it as a way for the company to diversify itself. With more and more IT companies buying smaller companies and software companies merging with hardware companies, the future for IT businesses is all about evolution and change. Change from within the company’s traditional business model. Goods producing companies that have reached their market share potential are evolving into service oriented companies that are willing to provide automated services to organizations that have a major need for business automation. If Dell maintains its tradition of being affordable and efficient in their services as it did in the past with PC hardware, then we do feel that Dell is on the right track as far as their business mindset on services is concerned.
What would your group have done to remedy the problem at hand?We don’t actually see a problem with their new business strategy of focusing on services. We feel Dell understands that they can design and build state of the art servers that can be used for many critical business data centers, but they also want to show that they can support the data center. We see it that Dell will design and manage a company’s data either through services from a cloud perspective for a company or by managing the datacenter that hosts a hospital’s images. The best thing Dell can do is to develop a good PR strategy that strengthens their vision of being not only a sound hardware provider but also an effective and efficient datacenter service provider. As more and more hospitals continue to migrate from paper to electronic data/medical records, the need to have a sound and proved IT service organization to manage their information will become more and more in demand.
I want a detailed breakdown of all issues involved: their impact,Dell is trying to be recognized more for the services rather than just their hardware. They have already worked with many IT service support organizations as it pertains to their hardware and data center needs. Perhaps by being able to offer a discount on hardware with the purchase of their services, many companies and organizations may look to Dell for their complete data center needs.
how the competition and your company dealt with such issues, It is hard for many companies to evolve their business strategy. This is especially the case if they are recognized world wide for hardware instead of services. IBM has been pouring money into commercial advertising for “Building a smarter planet”. This has been their marketing strategy for saying they are more than just a IT hardware manufacturer. HP has a “Service” division that contracts out IT professionals to manage IT services for business, local and federal organizations and any other organization that they feel they can make a financial business impact with. My parent company, Harris, was primarily known for building radios and telecommunications parts for government agencies and DoD organizations. Now we have branched out into numerous smaller yet largely profitable business divisions, to include my business division, Harris IT services (HITS). Coincidentally, I personally know of several DoD Medical Health Care IT services support contracts that Dell Government services division and my company, Harris IT services (HITS) have competed on. HITS is known for providing world-class, customer service oriented, information technology services to numerous government agencies, DoD organizations and both private and commercial medical and dental organizations across the US.
how any decisions your group made could have yielded different results, If we felt, that Dell should have never tried to evolve into a services oriented business and Dell followed this mindset, perhaps Dell would have lost out on millions of dollars for various IT support contracts, cloud services contracts and any other support services that they are currently making millions of dollars on.
any things overlooked by your company, If there is a will, there is a way… Not to overlook Dell or any of the other brand name companies such as Dell, HP or IBM. All it takes is one successful multi-billion dollar contract under their belt and then everyone will be flocking to them.
the impacts of financial issues, etcDell will need to market themselves as being a leader in providing quality IT services. According to the article, Dell’s primary goal is to focus on going after the IT service needs of midsized business. They may have more pricing leverage as it pertains to being able to bundle both their hardware and services into an affordable package that will appeal to the midsized businesses. This could potentially cost them at first but could have greater rewards once they can be successful within the market.