3. CHARACTERISTICCHARACTERISTICSS OF SUCCESSFULOF SUCCESSFUL
INNOVATING COMPANIESINNOVATING COMPANIES - 1- 1
Systematic collection of all impulses that could lead toSystematic collection of all impulses that could lead to
innovationinnovation
Creativity of employeesCreativity of employees
Ability to evaluate the possibility of the innovation ideaAbility to evaluate the possibility of the innovation idea
Good team workGood team work
Project-based approach and ability to manage projectsProject-based approach and ability to manage projects
MAYUR
4. CHARACTERISTICCHARACTERISTICSS OF SUCCESSFULOF SUCCESSFUL
INNOVATINGINNOVATING COMPANIES - 2- 2
Cooperation with external experts (universities,Cooperation with external experts (universities,
research laboratories…)research laboratories…)
Proper rate of risk-takingProper rate of risk-taking
Employees’ motivation (the employees are willing toEmployees’ motivation (the employees are willing to
improve the product and the operation of the wholeimprove the product and the operation of the whole
company)company)
Continued education of employeesContinued education of employees
Ability to finance the innovation activitiesAbility to finance the innovation activities
5. WHAT ISWHAT IS INNOVATIONINNOVATION
An innovation is considered performed if it isAn innovation is considered performed if it is
introduced to the market (introduced to the market (product innovationproduct innovation))
or implemented in the production processor implemented in the production process
((process innovationprocess innovation).).
Innovation includes many research,Innovation includes many research,
technological, organizational, financial andtechnological, organizational, financial and
commercial activities.commercial activities.
6. CLASSIFICATION OF INNOVATIONS
SYSTEM New series of
cars, planes,
computers, TV
New generation
(MP3 and
download as
substitution of
CD)
Steam engine,
ICT,
biotechnology,
nanotechnology
COMPONENT
Improvement of
components
New
components for
existing systems
Advanced
materials
improving
component
properties
INCREMENTAL
„do better what
we already do“
„new for the
company“
RADICAL
„new for the
world“
7. INNOVATION CATEGORIES
SUSTAININGSUSTAINING – better products that can be sold with– better products that can be sold with
higher margin to demanding customers; incumbentshigher margin to demanding customers; incumbents
winwin
DISRUPTIVEDISRUPTIVE – commercialization of simpler, more– commercialization of simpler, more
user-friendly products, which are chepaer anduser-friendly products, which are chepaer and
targeted to new or less demanding customers; newtargeted to new or less demanding customers; new
entrants winentrants win
8. KEY ELEMENTS OF DISRUPTION
Customers at each market has limited absorptionCustomers at each market has limited absorption
capacitycapacity
Technological progress usually is faster that theTechnological progress usually is faster that the
ability of the market to employ it. Companies focusability of the market to employ it. Companies focus
on better products to be sold with higher margin toon better products to be sold with higher margin to
unsatisfied customers.unsatisfied customers.
9. SUSTAINING VS. DISRUPTIVE
SustainingSustaining: focused on demanding customers;: focused on demanding customers;
both incremental and radical. Incumbents haveboth incremental and radical. Incumbents have
resources and motivation.resources and motivation.
DisruptiveDisruptive: introduce products and services not: introduce products and services not
as advanced as existing ones, but offering otheras advanced as existing ones, but offering other
advantages (simpler, cheaper, more useradvantages (simpler, cheaper, more user
friendly, ...) and focus on new or less demandingfriendly, ...) and focus on new or less demanding
customers.customers.
10. TWO TYPES OF DISRUPTION
New markets: compete with non-consumption:New markets: compete with non-consumption:
simpler, more user frindly, can be used by lesssimpler, more user frindly, can be used by less
sophisticated customers (PC, transistor radio, desksophisticated customers (PC, transistor radio, desk
copiers).copiers).
Low-end: focus on lower tiers of main marketsLow-end: focus on lower tiers of main markets
(minimills, discount stores, Korean auto-makers);(minimills, discount stores, Korean auto-makers);
motivate incumbents to leave the marketmotivate incumbents to leave the market
11. SOURCES OF INNOVATION IMPULSESSOURCES OF INNOVATION IMPULSES
InInternalternal environmentenvironment
Own R&DOwn R&D
Technical divisions – design, technologyTechnical divisions – design, technology
Production divisions (production, provision ofProduction divisions (production, provision of
services)services)
Marketing and salesMarketing and sales
Logistics (purchase and supplies)Logistics (purchase and supplies)
Guarantee and post-guarantee serviceGuarantee and post-guarantee service
OwnersOwners
MANU
13. MARKET PULLMARKET PULL -- R&DR&D PUSHPUSH
Market pullMarket pull
– looking for the best way of satisfying a newlylooking for the best way of satisfying a newly
emerging customer demandemerging customer demand
– improvement of the existing products, extension ofimprovement of the existing products, extension of
the existing offer or decrease of pricethe existing offer or decrease of price
– iimpulses for continuous, incremental innovations ormpulses for continuous, incremental innovations or
for process innovationsfor process innovations
Research and Development pushResearch and Development push
– looking for commercial use of new impulseslooking for commercial use of new impulses
resulting from the R&D resultsresulting from the R&D results
– generating of new markets for conceptuallygenerating of new markets for conceptually
different productsdifferent products
14. OPEN INNOVATION
Chesbrough, H., “Chesbrough, H., “Open InnovationOpen Innovation”, Harvard”, Harvard
Business School Publishing, Boston MA, 2003Business School Publishing, Boston MA, 2003
Closed innovationClosed innovation - requires control- requires control
Open innovationOpen innovation
– companies use external as well as internal ideascompanies use external as well as internal ideas
and both external and internal ways to marketand both external and internal ways to market
– internal ideas can be taken to the market throughinternal ideas can be taken to the market through
external channels to generate additional valueexternal channels to generate additional value
15. COMPANY INNOVATION POTENTIALCOMPANY INNOVATION POTENTIAL
A company with high innovation potentialA company with high innovation potential
scores highscores high in the followingin the following areasareas::
Strategy and planningStrategy and planning
MarketingMarketing
Technological processTechnological process
Quality managementQuality management
LogisticsLogistics
Human resourcesHuman resources
KOWSHIK
16. INNOVATION POTENTIAL
ASSESSMENT
For a company, it is important to know its innovationFor a company, it is important to know its innovation
potential. It can use the questionnairepotential. It can use the questionnaire
FFor everyor every of the six areas, there are six question, eachof the six areas, there are six question, each
with four possible answers.with four possible answers. The answers areThe answers are
formulated so that they reflect the existing situation informulated so that they reflect the existing situation in
the company.the company.
17. A. STRATEGY AND PLANNING
1.1. Idea about the company futureIdea about the company future
2.2. Vision and employeesVision and employees
3.3. Company innovation programsCompany innovation programs
4.4. Plan modificationsPlan modifications
5.5. Financial indicators of the planFinancial indicators of the plan
6.6. Project managementProject management
18. B. MARKETING
1.1. Monitoring of current market trendsMonitoring of current market trends
2.2. Evaluation of the market competition positionEvaluation of the market competition position
3.3. Customer-orientationCustomer-orientation
4.4. Monitoring of customers’ attitudes to theMonitoring of customers’ attitudes to the
company productcompany product
5.5. Market information flow inside the companyMarket information flow inside the company
6.6. Marketing and financial controlMarketing and financial control
19. C. TECHNOLOGICAL PROCESS
1.1. Future company’s competitiveness in theFuture company’s competitiveness in the
industryindustry
2.2. Changes of technologiesChanges of technologies
3.3. Collection of impulses for implementationCollection of impulses for implementation
of technology changesof technology changes
4.4. Evaluation of theEvaluation of the return onreturn on investmentinvestment
5.5. CCalculationalculation of pof production costs and theirroduction costs and their
monitoringmonitoring
6.6. Creation of resources for developmentCreation of resources for development
20. D.D. QUALITY, ENVIRONMENTQUALITY, ENVIRONMENT
1.1. Monitoring of changes conditioning the qualityMonitoring of changes conditioning the quality
management in the companymanagement in the company
2.2. EEmployees’ personal contribution to themployees’ personal contribution to the
quality systemquality system
3.3. External quality audit in the companyExternal quality audit in the company
4.4. Monitoring of theMonitoring of the environmentenvironmentalal impactimpact
5.5. Impact of quality monitoring on the companyImpact of quality monitoring on the company
processprocesseses
6.6. Covering ofCovering of costs resulting from modificationscosts resulting from modifications
of standards, regulations and legislation in theof standards, regulations and legislation in the
sphere of quality and environmentsphere of quality and environment
21. EE.. LOGISTICSLOGISTICS
1.1. Organization of purchase and distributionOrganization of purchase and distribution
channels in the companychannels in the company
2.2. Optimization of the company logisticsOptimization of the company logistics
3.3. IInformation and communicationnformation and communication flowsflows
between thebetween the companycompany and itand its partnerss partners
4.4. Flexibility of logistics processesFlexibility of logistics processes
5.5. Introduction of innovations in logisticsIntroduction of innovations in logistics
6.6. Logistics and financial controlLogistics and financial control
22. FF.. ORGANIZATION AND HUMAN RESOURCESORGANIZATION AND HUMAN RESOURCES
1.1. Employees satisfactionEmployees satisfaction
2.2. Employees motivationEmployees motivation
3.3. Management and communicationManagement and communication
4.4. Conflict resolutionConflict resolution
5.5. Company information systemCompany information system
6.6. Company cultureCompany culture
23. AN EFFECTIVE INNOVATIONAN EFFECTIVE INNOVATION
STRATEGY ANSWERS THREE KEYSTRATEGY ANSWERS THREE KEY
QUESTIONS:QUESTIONS:
How will we
Create value?
How will we
Deliver value?
How will we
Capture value?
VIDYASHANKAR
24. STEP 1: CREATING VALUESTEP 1: CREATING VALUE
How will the technology evolve?How will the technology evolve?
How will the market change?How will the market change?
How will consumer preferences and behavior change?How will consumer preferences and behavior change?
Where will innovations come from?Where will innovations come from?
What is our value proposition?What is our value proposition?
25. STEP 2: CAPTURING VALUESTEP 2: CAPTURING VALUE
How should we design the business model?How should we design the business model?
Where should we compete in the value chain?Where should we compete in the value chain?
How should we compete if standards are important?How should we compete if standards are important?
26. STEP 3: DELIVERING VALUESTEP 3: DELIVERING VALUE
How do we manage the core business and growthHow do we manage the core business and growth
simultaneously?simultaneously?
How do we use our strategy to drive real resourceHow do we use our strategy to drive real resource
allocation?allocation?
What organizational structure, processes, measurements,What organizational structure, processes, measurements,
and incentive mechanisms do we use?and incentive mechanisms do we use?
28. A HARDER QUESTION:A HARDER QUESTION:
Can you think of an industry thatCan you think of an industry that
hashas notnot gone through drasticgone through drastic
changes in the past severalchanges in the past several
decades in terms of technology,decades in terms of technology,
business models, and majorbusiness models, and major
players?players?
30. THE TRADITIONAL MODEL OF INDUSTRY LIFE CYCLETHE TRADITIONAL MODEL OF INDUSTRY LIFE CYCLE
Time
Salesvolume
Fermentation Shakeout Maturity Decline
31. AN ALTERNATE MODEL OF INDUSTRY LIFE CYCLEAN ALTERNATE MODEL OF INDUSTRY LIFE CYCLE
Time
Salesvolume
Emergence Convergence Coexistence Dominance
Established
Industry
Emerging Industry
32. SOURCES OF INNOVATIONSOURCES OF INNOVATION
According to Peter F. DruckerAccording to Peter F. Drucker
Industry and market changesIndustry and market changes
Demographic changesDemographic changes
New knowledgeNew knowledge
Changes in perceptionChanges in perception
Unexpected occurrencesUnexpected occurrences
IncongruitiesIncongruities
Process needsProcess needs
45. THE SECOND OF THREE KEY QUESTIONS...THE SECOND OF THREE KEY QUESTIONS...
How will we
Create value?
How will we
Deliver value?
How will we
Capture value?
46. OR:OR:
WHAT DETERMINES THE INNOVATOR’SWHAT DETERMINES THE INNOVATOR’S
SHARE?SHARE?
Customers
Innovator
Suppliers
Imitators,
followers
47. SOURCES OF UNIQUENESSSOURCES OF UNIQUENESS
Intellectual property protectionIntellectual property protection
– PatentsPatents
• Finite lengthFinite length
• The right to prohibit “producing”The right to prohibit “producing”
– CopyrightsCopyrights
• The right to prohibit “copying”The right to prohibit “copying”
SecrecySecrecy
– Trade secrets & non-compete clausesTrade secrets & non-compete clauses
– ““Tacit” knowledgeTacit” knowledge
– Causal ambiguityCausal ambiguity
SpeedSpeed
48. UNIQUENESS IS POWERFUL BUT OFTENUNIQUENESS IS POWERFUL BUT OFTEN
DIFFICULT TO MAINTAINDIFFICULT TO MAINTAIN
Legal mechanisms can be costly to create, and thenLegal mechanisms can be costly to create, and then
even more costly to enforce: and sometimes theyeven more costly to enforce: and sometimes they
require public disclosurerequire public disclosure
Secrecy may be difficult to maintainSecrecy may be difficult to maintain
Speed is hard work, and sometimes imitableSpeed is hard work, and sometimes imitable
49. WHAT ARE COMPLEMENTARY ASSETS?WHAT ARE COMPLEMENTARY ASSETS?
Those assets that allow a firm to make money, even ifThose assets that allow a firm to make money, even if
the innovation is not unique.the innovation is not unique.
The answer to the question:The answer to the question:
– If our innovations were instantly available to ourIf our innovations were instantly available to our
competitors, would we still make money? Why?competitors, would we still make money? Why?
ANAND
50. TYPES OF COMPLEMENTARY ASSETSTYPES OF COMPLEMENTARY ASSETS
Things One can doThings One can do
– Manufacturing capabilitiesManufacturing capabilities
– Sales and service expertiseSales and service expertise
– Strategic alliancesStrategic alliances
Things One ownThings One own
– Brand nameBrand name
– Distribution channelsDistribution channels
– Customer relationshipsCustomer relationships
COMPETENCIES
RESOURCES
52. Uniqueness & Complementary AssetsUniqueness & Complementary Assets
over the Life Cycle:over the Life Cycle:
Ferment
Takeoff
Maturity
Uniqueness
Complementary
Assets
53. The last of three key questions...The last of three key questions...
How will we
Create value?
How will we
Deliver value?
How will we
Capture value?
54. DISCONTINUOUS INNOVATIONDISCONTINUOUS INNOVATION
as a strategic problemas a strategic problem
Genuine uncertaintyGenuine uncertainty
– It’s not going to happen – certainly not nowIt’s not going to happen – certainly not now
CannibalizationCannibalization
– It will compete with our current productsIt will compete with our current products
Shifts in the customer baseShifts in the customer base
– Our current customers don’t want itOur current customers don’t want it
Margin erosionMargin erosion
– It will make less moneyIt will make less money
55. The new opportunityThe new opportunity
doesn’t meet our currentdoesn’t meet our current
customer’s needscustomer’s needs
56. The new opportunityThe new opportunity
doesn’t offer nearly thedoesn’t offer nearly the
same margins and profitsame margins and profit
opportunityopportunity
58. My experience has been that creatingMy experience has been that creating
a compelling new technology is soa compelling new technology is so
much harder than you think it will bemuch harder than you think it will be
that you're almost dead when you getthat you're almost dead when you get
to the other shore.to the other shore.
--Steve Jobs--Steve Jobs
59. Discontinuous InnovationDiscontinuous Innovation
as an organizational problemas an organizational problem
Time horizons & IncentivesTime horizons & Incentives
Fear of (individual) cannibalizationFear of (individual) cannibalization
OverloadOverload
Competency TrapsCompetency Traps
Xerox
GM Saturn and Jobs Bank Whole system against innovation
Soft drinks
Ready-to-eat breakfast cereals
Diamonds
Business education?
Examples: fax machines, dial-up Internet service
VHS vs. DVD
Cell phones vs. landline phones
Dial-up vs. high-speed Internet services
Yellow pages vs. Internet-based local service
Industry and market changes: E-commerce
Demographic changes: assisted-living, senior communities
New knowledge: biotechnology, nanotechnology
Changes in perception: health consciousness, Whole Foods
Unexpected occurrences: Post-it, Viagra
Incongruities: Univ. of Phoenix, online education
Process needs: e-Bay, Alibaba, UPS
Competencies: Wal*Mart, Dell, Kodak’s relationships with retailers in photo development market
Resources: Coca-cola brand equity, De Beer’s mines
Electronics
PCs
In retrospect, what should Apple have done in 1981 in response to IBM? Open up design, license OS to IBM
Apple vs. Microsoft: Who was in a better position to develop a game system to compete with Nintendo?
What opportunities did Microsoft: search engine, web browser, anti-virus, PDF, etc
What opportunities did Sony miss: music player, music download, cell phones
GM vs. Toyota: fuel cell vs. hybrid
Barnes Noble vs. Amazon
Kodak
Auction houses Christie’s, Lloyds
Newspaper vs. Internet
IBM mainframe vs. PCs Boca Raton, FL 1980
PARC
Saturn SPRING HILL, Tennessee early 1990’s
Biotechnology