SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 2
Firing the Canon
In Boston I had the chance to speak to several hundreds secondary teachers at their
Get Together on Thursday evening. I ended my presentation by asking them to
brainstorm lists of books they would use to create their own canon. Joan Kindig
suggests that a canon is a set of texts we hold sacred. So I asked these teachers to
come up with books they held sacred, books they wanted to be sure to pass along to
a new generation of readers. They posted them to Twitter using #canon as the
hashtag. I collected them for several days after the Get Together and I present them
here (and they will be up on SlideShare.net/professornana as well.
What is not at all surprising to me is that the books they listed are a diverse lot.
There are some traditional canonical texts. However, they are mixed in with more
than a few contemporary texts. Also unsurprising, there were not many titles listed
by more than 1 person. The only titles with multiple “votes” were:
THE FAULT IN OUR STARS
THE ABSOLUTELY TRUE DIARY OF A PART TIME INDIAN
ENDANGERED
SPEAK
THE POISONWOOD BIBLE
THE CHOCOLATE WAR.
If I were to ask a different audience this same question, I have no doubt that some of
the titles would be different. When Connie Epstein asked this question dozens of
years ago of Ivy League English professors, she found much the same thing: there
was little agreement about the specific books they wanted incoming freshmen to
know. What one professor remarked has stayed with me over those years: give us
kids who love to read; assign grades for reading by the pound. I feel the same way: I
want my grad students to love books and reading. I can give them titles and let them
explore children’s and YA literature if they already love to read and know the power
of a good book (the right book for the right reader at the right time as my subtitle to
Making the Match declares). I worry in our prescriptive CCSS Exemplar Text state
that we risk losing readers. And so, here is the rest of the CANON from NCTE’s
Secondary Get Together. May it be a starting point for more discussion and for more
celebration of books and reading.
REVOLUTION
THE GREAT GATSBY
THE COLOR PURPLE
THE DIARY OF ANNE FRANK
1984
THE GIVER
THE MIRACULOUS JOURNEY OF EDWARD TULANE
GRACELING
HURT GO HAPPY
IF I STAY
A WRINKE IN TIME
CHARLOTTE’S WEB
THE BOOK THIEF
LORD OF THE RINGS
THE POERKS OF BEING A WALLFLOWER
THE ONE AND ONLY IVAN
WONDER
WILFRID GORDON MACDONALD PARTRIDGE
TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD
THE TEMPEST
OF MICE AND MEN
DIVERGENET
THE CLOCKWORK PRINCESS
STUCK IN NEUTRAL
AMERICAN BORN CHINESE
WRAPPED IN A FLAG
FROM THE NOTEBOOKS OF MELANIN SUN
A FIRE IN MY HANDS
THE MOVES MAKE THE MAN
CHAOS WALKING SERIES
ELEVEN AND OTHER STORIES
IN DARKNESS
THE LITTLE PRINCE

More Related Content

What's hot

Fugitive Spaces: Matthew Guterl on radical practices of history and citizenship
Fugitive Spaces: Matthew Guterl on radical practices of history and citizenshipFugitive Spaces: Matthew Guterl on radical practices of history and citizenship
Fugitive Spaces: Matthew Guterl on radical practices of history and citizenshipYHRUploads
 
Spring 2011 9th Grade Reading Suggestions
Spring 2011 9th Grade Reading SuggestionsSpring 2011 9th Grade Reading Suggestions
Spring 2011 9th Grade Reading SuggestionsCatherine Kcls
 
Selection Tools for Children's Series
Selection Tools for Children's SeriesSelection Tools for Children's Series
Selection Tools for Children's SeriesMary Jo Chrabasz
 
Banned for social content
Banned for social contentBanned for social content
Banned for social contentKathleen Sacco
 
History personal statement
History personal statementHistory personal statement
History personal statementDB3igs
 
Professional resource project take 2
Professional resource project take 2Professional resource project take 2
Professional resource project take 2adeising13
 
Summer reading 2008
Summer reading 2008Summer reading 2008
Summer reading 2008guestd90cb0
 
Book discussiongroupfinal
Book discussiongroupfinalBook discussiongroupfinal
Book discussiongroupfinalmimbyla
 

What's hot (16)

Presentation1
Presentation1Presentation1
Presentation1
 
Fugitive Spaces: Matthew Guterl on radical practices of history and citizenship
Fugitive Spaces: Matthew Guterl on radical practices of history and citizenshipFugitive Spaces: Matthew Guterl on radical practices of history and citizenship
Fugitive Spaces: Matthew Guterl on radical practices of history and citizenship
 
Vita
VitaVita
Vita
 
Spring 2011 9th Grade Reading Suggestions
Spring 2011 9th Grade Reading SuggestionsSpring 2011 9th Grade Reading Suggestions
Spring 2011 9th Grade Reading Suggestions
 
Selection Tools for Children's Series
Selection Tools for Children's SeriesSelection Tools for Children's Series
Selection Tools for Children's Series
 
Introsection college
Introsection collegeIntrosection college
Introsection college
 
Bwf2017 youngreaders
Bwf2017 youngreadersBwf2017 youngreaders
Bwf2017 youngreaders
 
Readinglog3
Readinglog3Readinglog3
Readinglog3
 
Banned for social content
Banned for social contentBanned for social content
Banned for social content
 
History personal statement
History personal statementHistory personal statement
History personal statement
 
Professional resource project take 2
Professional resource project take 2Professional resource project take 2
Professional resource project take 2
 
Issues in Children's Literature
Issues in Children's LiteratureIssues in Children's Literature
Issues in Children's Literature
 
Summer reading 2008
Summer reading 2008Summer reading 2008
Summer reading 2008
 
Books and Brunch: Nonfiction Children's Books
Books and Brunch: Nonfiction Children's BooksBooks and Brunch: Nonfiction Children's Books
Books and Brunch: Nonfiction Children's Books
 
Book discussiongroupfinal
Book discussiongroupfinalBook discussiongroupfinal
Book discussiongroupfinal
 
Readinglog1
Readinglog1Readinglog1
Readinglog1
 

Viewers also liked

Recommended bb 2015
Recommended bb 2015Recommended bb 2015
Recommended bb 2015Teri Lesesne
 
N C T E Middle Mosaic booklist
N C T E Middle Mosaic booklistN C T E Middle Mosaic booklist
N C T E Middle Mosaic booklistTeri Lesesne
 
T C T E L A Booklist
T C T E L A BooklistT C T E L A Booklist
T C T E L A BooklistTeri Lesesne
 
T L A bibliography 2014
T L A bibliography  2014T L A bibliography  2014
T L A bibliography 2014Teri Lesesne
 
100 in 100 handout TLA
100 in 100 handout TLA100 in 100 handout TLA
100 in 100 handout TLATeri Lesesne
 
Lesesne & Perry T L A Booklist 2016
Lesesne & Perry T L A Booklist 2016Lesesne & Perry T L A Booklist 2016
Lesesne & Perry T L A Booklist 2016Teri Lesesne
 
Intermediate and Middle School Booklist
Intermediate and Middle School BooklistIntermediate and Middle School Booklist
Intermediate and Middle School BooklistTeri Lesesne
 
W H A C T E 2011 BOOKLIST
W H A C T E 2011 BOOKLISTW H A C T E 2011 BOOKLIST
W H A C T E 2011 BOOKLISTTeri Lesesne
 
Librarians and literacy some random thoughts
Librarians and literacy  some random thoughtsLibrarians and literacy  some random thoughts
Librarians and literacy some random thoughtsTeri Lesesne
 
Teri Lesesne's Best of 2011 (so far)
Teri Lesesne's Best of 2011 (so far)Teri Lesesne's Best of 2011 (so far)
Teri Lesesne's Best of 2011 (so far)Teri Lesesne
 
T L A booklist 2010
T L A booklist 2010T L A booklist 2010
T L A booklist 2010Teri Lesesne
 
Creating strong communities
Creating strong communitiesCreating strong communities
Creating strong communitiesTeri Lesesne
 
We need diverse books U C I
We need diverse books U C IWe need diverse books U C I
We need diverse books U C ITeri Lesesne
 
Humble I S D Follett December
Humble I S D  Follett DecemberHumble I S D  Follett December
Humble I S D Follett DecemberTeri Lesesne
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Recommended bb 2015
Recommended bb 2015Recommended bb 2015
Recommended bb 2015
 
Acceptance
AcceptanceAcceptance
Acceptance
 
N C T E Middle Mosaic booklist
N C T E Middle Mosaic booklistN C T E Middle Mosaic booklist
N C T E Middle Mosaic booklist
 
T C T E L A Booklist
T C T E L A BooklistT C T E L A Booklist
T C T E L A Booklist
 
T L A bibliography 2014
T L A bibliography  2014T L A bibliography  2014
T L A bibliography 2014
 
100 in 100 handout TLA
100 in 100 handout TLA100 in 100 handout TLA
100 in 100 handout TLA
 
Region X booklist
Region X booklistRegion X booklist
Region X booklist
 
Lesesne & Perry T L A Booklist 2016
Lesesne & Perry T L A Booklist 2016Lesesne & Perry T L A Booklist 2016
Lesesne & Perry T L A Booklist 2016
 
Intermediate and Middle School Booklist
Intermediate and Middle School BooklistIntermediate and Middle School Booklist
Intermediate and Middle School Booklist
 
W H A C T E 2011 BOOKLIST
W H A C T E 2011 BOOKLISTW H A C T E 2011 BOOKLIST
W H A C T E 2011 BOOKLIST
 
Librarians and literacy some random thoughts
Librarians and literacy  some random thoughtsLibrarians and literacy  some random thoughts
Librarians and literacy some random thoughts
 
Region 5
Region 5Region 5
Region 5
 
Teri Lesesne's Best of 2011 (so far)
Teri Lesesne's Best of 2011 (so far)Teri Lesesne's Best of 2011 (so far)
Teri Lesesne's Best of 2011 (so far)
 
T L A booklist 2010
T L A booklist 2010T L A booklist 2010
T L A booklist 2010
 
Pasadena I S D
Pasadena I S DPasadena I S D
Pasadena I S D
 
Middle mosaic
Middle mosaicMiddle mosaic
Middle mosaic
 
Creating strong communities
Creating strong communitiesCreating strong communities
Creating strong communities
 
We need diverse books U C I
We need diverse books U C IWe need diverse books U C I
We need diverse books U C I
 
Humble I S D Follett December
Humble I S D  Follett DecemberHumble I S D  Follett December
Humble I S D Follett December
 
#WNDB Heinemann
#WNDB  Heinemann#WNDB  Heinemann
#WNDB Heinemann
 

Similar to Firing the canon

Non Fiction: The Hungry Market
Non Fiction: The Hungry MarketNon Fiction: The Hungry Market
Non Fiction: The Hungry Marketggaldorisi
 
The New World Order - Ralph Epperson
The New World Order - Ralph EppersonThe New World Order - Ralph Epperson
The New World Order - Ralph EppersonRob Graham
 
TheNewWorldOrder A. Ralph Epperson - ENGLISH VERSION.pdf
TheNewWorldOrder A. Ralph Epperson - ENGLISH VERSION.pdfTheNewWorldOrder A. Ralph Epperson - ENGLISH VERSION.pdf
TheNewWorldOrder A. Ralph Epperson - ENGLISH VERSION.pdfHudsonPicoreli
 
Diversity in Children's Literature
Diversity in Children's LiteratureDiversity in Children's Literature
Diversity in Children's Literaturealizawerner
 
Example 1 Student Example Professor C.N. Myers .docx
Example 1  Student Example Professor C.N. Myers .docxExample 1  Student Example Professor C.N. Myers .docx
Example 1 Student Example Professor C.N. Myers .docxSANSKAR20
 
RA: Contemporary Realistic Fiction for Middle Grade Readers
RA: Contemporary Realistic Fiction for Middle Grade ReadersRA: Contemporary Realistic Fiction for Middle Grade Readers
RA: Contemporary Realistic Fiction for Middle Grade ReadersBeth Gallaway
 
John Miller Senior Exit Portfolio
John Miller Senior Exit PortfolioJohn Miller Senior Exit Portfolio
John Miller Senior Exit PortfolioJohn Miller
 
ENG 30 INTRODUCTION TO LITERATURE PROF. GENE MCQUILLANSPR
ENG 30 INTRODUCTION TO LITERATURE PROF. GENE MCQUILLANSPRENG 30 INTRODUCTION TO LITERATURE PROF. GENE MCQUILLANSPR
ENG 30 INTRODUCTION TO LITERATURE PROF. GENE MCQUILLANSPRTanaMaeskm
 
The Discovery of Genesis (Ingles)
The Discovery of Genesis (Ingles)The Discovery of Genesis (Ingles)
The Discovery of Genesis (Ingles)Julian Osorio
 

Similar to Firing the canon (12)

Non Fiction: The Hungry Market
Non Fiction: The Hungry MarketNon Fiction: The Hungry Market
Non Fiction: The Hungry Market
 
The new world_order-ralph_epperson
The new world_order-ralph_eppersonThe new world_order-ralph_epperson
The new world_order-ralph_epperson
 
The New World Order - Ralph Epperson
The New World Order - Ralph EppersonThe New World Order - Ralph Epperson
The New World Order - Ralph Epperson
 
TheNewWorldOrder A. Ralph Epperson - ENGLISH VERSION.pdf
TheNewWorldOrder A. Ralph Epperson - ENGLISH VERSION.pdfTheNewWorldOrder A. Ralph Epperson - ENGLISH VERSION.pdf
TheNewWorldOrder A. Ralph Epperson - ENGLISH VERSION.pdf
 
Diversity in Children's Literature
Diversity in Children's LiteratureDiversity in Children's Literature
Diversity in Children's Literature
 
Example 1 Student Example Professor C.N. Myers .docx
Example 1  Student Example Professor C.N. Myers .docxExample 1  Student Example Professor C.N. Myers .docx
Example 1 Student Example Professor C.N. Myers .docx
 
Speech
SpeechSpeech
Speech
 
NSHSS Member & Author Rania Kadavil Talks About Publishing Her Book "The Voic...
NSHSS Member & Author Rania Kadavil Talks About Publishing Her Book "The Voic...NSHSS Member & Author Rania Kadavil Talks About Publishing Her Book "The Voic...
NSHSS Member & Author Rania Kadavil Talks About Publishing Her Book "The Voic...
 
RA: Contemporary Realistic Fiction for Middle Grade Readers
RA: Contemporary Realistic Fiction for Middle Grade ReadersRA: Contemporary Realistic Fiction for Middle Grade Readers
RA: Contemporary Realistic Fiction for Middle Grade Readers
 
John Miller Senior Exit Portfolio
John Miller Senior Exit PortfolioJohn Miller Senior Exit Portfolio
John Miller Senior Exit Portfolio
 
ENG 30 INTRODUCTION TO LITERATURE PROF. GENE MCQUILLANSPR
ENG 30 INTRODUCTION TO LITERATURE PROF. GENE MCQUILLANSPRENG 30 INTRODUCTION TO LITERATURE PROF. GENE MCQUILLANSPR
ENG 30 INTRODUCTION TO LITERATURE PROF. GENE MCQUILLANSPR
 
The Discovery of Genesis (Ingles)
The Discovery of Genesis (Ingles)The Discovery of Genesis (Ingles)
The Discovery of Genesis (Ingles)
 

More from Teri Lesesne

Twu conference mar 19 lesesne and miller
Twu conference mar 19 lesesne and millerTwu conference mar 19 lesesne and miller
Twu conference mar 19 lesesne and millerTeri Lesesne
 
Conroe secondary feb 2019
Conroe secondary feb 2019Conroe secondary feb 2019
Conroe secondary feb 2019Teri Lesesne
 
Conroe isd feb 2019 elem
Conroe isd feb 2019 elemConroe isd feb 2019 elem
Conroe isd feb 2019 elemTeri Lesesne
 
Bring on the books tctela 2019
Bring on the books tctela 2019Bring on the books tctela 2019
Bring on the books tctela 2019Teri Lesesne
 
Books too good to miss
Books too good to missBooks too good to miss
Books too good to missTeri Lesesne
 
Metafiction usm 2018
Metafiction  usm 2018Metafiction  usm 2018
Metafiction usm 2018Teri Lesesne
 
Boothbay new books
Boothbay new booksBoothbay new books
Boothbay new booksTeri Lesesne
 
TLA Hot off the Press
TLA Hot off the PressTLA Hot off the Press
TLA Hot off the PressTeri Lesesne
 
Want to raise readers be literacy models
Want to raise readers  be literacy modelsWant to raise readers  be literacy models
Want to raise readers be literacy modelsTeri Lesesne
 
Give them what they want: Marantz PB Symposium Preso
Give them what they want: Marantz PB Symposium PresoGive them what they want: Marantz PB Symposium Preso
Give them what they want: Marantz PB Symposium PresoTeri Lesesne
 
Pop up nerd camp booktalks
Pop up nerd camp booktalksPop up nerd camp booktalks
Pop up nerd camp booktalksTeri Lesesne
 
Bookaday T L A 2016
Bookaday T L A 2016Bookaday T L A 2016
Bookaday T L A 2016Teri Lesesne
 

More from Teri Lesesne (20)

Hot off the press
Hot off the pressHot off the press
Hot off the press
 
Twu conference mar 19 lesesne and miller
Twu conference mar 19 lesesne and millerTwu conference mar 19 lesesne and miller
Twu conference mar 19 lesesne and miller
 
Conroe secondary feb 2019
Conroe secondary feb 2019Conroe secondary feb 2019
Conroe secondary feb 2019
 
Conroe isd feb 2019 elem
Conroe isd feb 2019 elemConroe isd feb 2019 elem
Conroe isd feb 2019 elem
 
Bring on the books tctela 2019
Bring on the books tctela 2019Bring on the books tctela 2019
Bring on the books tctela 2019
 
Elementary oct 22
Elementary oct 22Elementary oct 22
Elementary oct 22
 
Secondary oct 22
Secondary oct 22Secondary oct 22
Secondary oct 22
 
Books too good to miss
Books too good to missBooks too good to miss
Books too good to miss
 
Metafiction usm 2018
Metafiction  usm 2018Metafiction  usm 2018
Metafiction usm 2018
 
Hot off the press
Hot off the pressHot off the press
Hot off the press
 
Doors boothbay 17
Doors boothbay 17Doors boothbay 17
Doors boothbay 17
 
Nonfiction books
Nonfiction booksNonfiction books
Nonfiction books
 
Boothbay new books
Boothbay new booksBoothbay new books
Boothbay new books
 
TLA Hot off the Press
TLA Hot off the PressTLA Hot off the Press
TLA Hot off the Press
 
Want to raise readers be literacy models
Want to raise readers  be literacy modelsWant to raise readers  be literacy models
Want to raise readers be literacy models
 
Give them what they want: Marantz PB Symposium Preso
Give them what they want: Marantz PB Symposium PresoGive them what they want: Marantz PB Symposium Preso
Give them what they want: Marantz PB Symposium Preso
 
Nerd camp 16
Nerd camp 16Nerd camp 16
Nerd camp 16
 
Annual assembly
Annual assemblyAnnual assembly
Annual assembly
 
Pop up nerd camp booktalks
Pop up nerd camp booktalksPop up nerd camp booktalks
Pop up nerd camp booktalks
 
Bookaday T L A 2016
Bookaday T L A 2016Bookaday T L A 2016
Bookaday T L A 2016
 

Firing the canon

  • 1. Firing the Canon In Boston I had the chance to speak to several hundreds secondary teachers at their Get Together on Thursday evening. I ended my presentation by asking them to brainstorm lists of books they would use to create their own canon. Joan Kindig suggests that a canon is a set of texts we hold sacred. So I asked these teachers to come up with books they held sacred, books they wanted to be sure to pass along to a new generation of readers. They posted them to Twitter using #canon as the hashtag. I collected them for several days after the Get Together and I present them here (and they will be up on SlideShare.net/professornana as well. What is not at all surprising to me is that the books they listed are a diverse lot. There are some traditional canonical texts. However, they are mixed in with more than a few contemporary texts. Also unsurprising, there were not many titles listed by more than 1 person. The only titles with multiple “votes” were: THE FAULT IN OUR STARS THE ABSOLUTELY TRUE DIARY OF A PART TIME INDIAN ENDANGERED SPEAK THE POISONWOOD BIBLE THE CHOCOLATE WAR. If I were to ask a different audience this same question, I have no doubt that some of the titles would be different. When Connie Epstein asked this question dozens of years ago of Ivy League English professors, she found much the same thing: there was little agreement about the specific books they wanted incoming freshmen to know. What one professor remarked has stayed with me over those years: give us kids who love to read; assign grades for reading by the pound. I feel the same way: I want my grad students to love books and reading. I can give them titles and let them explore children’s and YA literature if they already love to read and know the power of a good book (the right book for the right reader at the right time as my subtitle to Making the Match declares). I worry in our prescriptive CCSS Exemplar Text state that we risk losing readers. And so, here is the rest of the CANON from NCTE’s Secondary Get Together. May it be a starting point for more discussion and for more celebration of books and reading. REVOLUTION THE GREAT GATSBY THE COLOR PURPLE THE DIARY OF ANNE FRANK 1984 THE GIVER THE MIRACULOUS JOURNEY OF EDWARD TULANE GRACELING
  • 2. HURT GO HAPPY IF I STAY A WRINKE IN TIME CHARLOTTE’S WEB THE BOOK THIEF LORD OF THE RINGS THE POERKS OF BEING A WALLFLOWER THE ONE AND ONLY IVAN WONDER WILFRID GORDON MACDONALD PARTRIDGE TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD THE TEMPEST OF MICE AND MEN DIVERGENET THE CLOCKWORK PRINCESS STUCK IN NEUTRAL AMERICAN BORN CHINESE WRAPPED IN A FLAG FROM THE NOTEBOOKS OF MELANIN SUN A FIRE IN MY HANDS THE MOVES MAKE THE MAN CHAOS WALKING SERIES ELEVEN AND OTHER STORIES IN DARKNESS THE LITTLE PRINCE