Healthcare environments are often designed with the needs of the working staff in mind. The experience of patients is often left as an afterthought and not fully integrated in the design process. When asked to design a spatial concept for a chain of laboratories, Diagonal chose to combine service design methods with interior architecture and to place the experience of their customers and staff at the center stage. The result presents a refreshing take on healthcare without diminishing the trust in the expertise of the staff.
Diagonal - Designing Servicescapes for Optimal Healthcare Experiences
1. ♥
Designing Servicescapes for
Optimal Healthcare Experiences
JUHA KRONQVIST
27.11.2013
1
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
2. Contents
1) On designing services for healthcare
2) Presenting the laboratory case
3) The results of the design
4) On taking the long view
2
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
4. Diagonal in short
Diagonal is a Helsinki based service design agency focusing on
innovative service and customer experiences. Our process
combines research skills with creative competence.
We design and execute
Focus on health and wellbeing
• Services
• Customer Experiences
• Servicescapes
4
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
5. Service Design Achievement
of the Year Competition
“The main judging criteria will be how much the project advances
the practice of service design in Finland; pushing the service design
envelope is a key criteria.
The novel application of service design can be related to methods
and processes, new business and co-operation models for service
design agencies and their customers, new areas of application, etc.”
5
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
6. Service Design Achievement
of the Year Competition
OUR ENTRY:
1. Highlights the design constraints in the healthcare context
2. Presents a method for involving people in the servicescape design process
3. Gives a concrete example on how to start building a strategic partnership
6
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
7. On service design
We are meaning-creating beings.
7
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
8. On service design
Service design is about understanding and
managing meaningful constellations of materials
and people.
8
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
9. On service design
They all need to be aligned in order for them to
make sense to people and to create positive
experiences.
prescription
waiting area
letter
nurse
doctor
website
staff
9
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
10. Designing for customer experience
SERVICESCAPE
SERVICE
STRATEGY
CUSTOMER
EXPERIENCE
PEOPLE
10
COMMUNICATION
ARTIFACTS
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
11. What is a servicescape?
"The immediate physical and social environment surrounding a service
experience, transaction or event… It plays a critical role in shaping
customer expectations, differentiating service firms, facilitating
customer and employee goals, and influencing the nature of customer
experiences."
– Bitner 1999
11
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
12. A servicescape for ideal
healthcare experiences?
12
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
13. We are all health seekers
HEALTHY
amount of agency
PATIENT
time
13
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
14. Components of healthcare design
PERFORMANCE
How well it does the job or is
fit for purpose.
PROCESS
EXPERIENCE
How safe, well engineered
and reliable it is.
How the whole interaction
with the product or
service "feels" or is
experienced.
Based on Bate & Robert 2006
14
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
17. The design process
CUSTOMER UNDERSTANDING
ASIAKASYMMÄRRYS
TOTEUTUS
IMPLEMENTATION
DESIGN
DESIGN
STRATEGIA
STRATEGY
OPPORTUNITIES
MAHDOLLISUUDET
>>>
YRITYKSEN
COMBINING
LIIKETOIMINTAA
ORGANIZATIONAL
AND CUSTOMER
TUKEVAT RATKAISUT
VALUE
JA MALLIT
17
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
18. lead
The design process
SERVICE DESIGN
t
men
lve
uous
n
onti
invo
er
tom
cus
c
INTERIOR ARCHITECTURE
time
18
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
19. The design process
CUSTOMER JOURNEY
19
ETHNOGRAPHIC
OBSERVATION
CARDBOARD
PROTOTYPING
IMPLEMENTATION
SCALING UP
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
20. Crafting a customer journey
ORIENTATION
TURN NUMBER
WAITING
INVITATION
03
SAMPLING
20
EKG & OTHERS
EXIT
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
25. Design Drivers
FUNCTIONALITY
The solutions are
based on an
understanding of
laboratory workers
and what makes their
work as fluent as
possible. The spatial
layout guides staff and
visitors through it.
CLARITY
Each step has been
assigned a simple and
understandable role. The
visitor understands what
they are supposed to do
and how to prepare for
the next one.
25
AMBIENCE
The space is a pleasant
environment that calms
the visitors down.
During the sample
taking visitors can avoid
seeing laboratory
equipment and watch
from the window or at
a picture. Art from
schools etc. can be
placed at a gallery wall.
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
26. Detailed customer journey
03
ORIENTATION
Patient enters
the health centre
and seeks the
laboratory.
26
TURN NUMBER
Identifying the
correct service and
taking a turn
number.
WAITING
INVITATION
Waiting for their
turn and calming
down.
Understanding
what is expected
next.
Patient is sees their
number or is called
in. Seeks the
correct door.
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
31. Pilot implementation
EXPERIENCE
“We’re happy about the well
functioning first version of the new
laboratory, in which the customers
point-of-view has been thoroughly
integrated.
…
According to the laboratory nurses
service is being constantly improved
with the help of the new concept and
a consistently working environment.”
Alueperiskooppi 23.10.2013
PROCESS
31
FUNCTION
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
32. Patients say
In comparison to the old one these are much
calmer and more private with clean nice walls
around.
It's a nice feeling. Small, but I
wouldn't need any bigger.
The are much more comfortable and
you don't get as anxious.
Nice that it's private.
Best was the woman who took the
sample like a pro.
32
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
33. Staff say
These are positively different. Very calm.
You have space for your tools. At times I
need to get something from the storage.
That's good on the other hand that you have
to move a bit at times.
It's efficient, fresh and clean. Positive, you
have all you need and you can be private.
The rooms are a bit small, but they work well.
They look nice and bring a warm feeling.
33
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
34. Scaling up
S
M
L
S - SMALL
L - LARGE
implementing the concept
for existing services with a
need for updating the
servicescape.
34
M - MEDIUM
implementing the concept
for services that are
larger or need significant
update in their
servicescapes.
implementing and
updating the concept for
services that take place in
new sites or that need a
significant change in the
operations model.
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
36. Next steps
We see service design as organizational transformation that is enabled
through involving the client through several design processes.
Patients are an underutilized resource in healthcare.
What are they expecting from laboratory services?
How do they want to be involved in the management of their health?
36
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.
37. Key Takeaways
1. HEALTHCARE PROVIDES SPECIFIC DESIGN CONSTRAINTS THAT
HAVE TO BE TAKEN IN ACCOUNT IN THE DESIGN PROCESS
2. THROUGH PHYSICAL PROTOTYPING YOU CAN CREATE EMPATHIC
UNDERSTANDING AND PROTOTYPE NEW SERVICE EXPERIENCES
3. BY TAKING A LONG VIEW IN SERVICE DESIGN YOU ADDRESS
DIFFERENT ASPECTS OF THE CUSTOMER EXPERIENCE
37
Copyright Diagonal Mental Structure Oy. All rights reserved.