SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  5
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Volume Cost &
its importance in
Plastic applications:
Siddhartha Roy
Consultant, RoyPlasTech, Pune
royplastech@rediffmail.com
+919890366632

What is Volume Cost?
The Volume Cost of a Raw Material
input is the purchase cost of a unit
volume of the material. It is extremely
important to understand the Volume
cost of Polymers and its additives as it
plays a key role in their selection for a
particular application.
Volume cost (Rs./Litre)= Purchase
Cost (Rs./Kg.) x Density (Kg./Litre or
gm/cc)
Let us examine the Volume costs of
the major commodity Polymer families.
One of the first characteristic of a
polymer that a designer looks at before
specifying it as the material of
construction is its price. These vary from

time to time, sometimes wildly, but tend
to maintain their proportion vis a vis
other polymers. Here are the recent
prices of the Commodity thermoplastics
(Ball park figures for sure, I am not going
into specific grades etc.).
While it would look that UPVC is by far
the cheapest Polymer, the natural
question is that why does it have such
limited applications in, say moulded
products? Assuming, just for arguments
sake that UPVC was as easy to mould as
the other Commodity Thermoplastics,
why is it not used in such widespread
applications like, say, buckets?
At this point we have to look at one of
the very important properties of
Polymers, which many a time is

Polymer

Abbr.

Price
Rs./Kg

Unplasticised PVC

UPVC

48

Plasticised PVC

FPVC

60

Low Density Polyethylene

LDPE

70

High Density Polyethylene

HDPE

67

PP

68

PPCO

70

Polypropylene Homopolymer
Polypropylene Copolymer

PS

80

High Impact Polystyrene

Polystyrene

HIPS

82

Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene

ABS

85

Visit : www.ipiindia.com

overlooked. Fortunately this is not a
property which changes with time!
Polymer. Density Polymer
Kg/Ltr

Density
Kg/Ltr

UPVC

1.40

PS

1.05

FPVC

1.25

HIPS

1.05

LDPE

0.92

ABS

1.05

HDPE

0.96

PP

0.90

PPCO

0.905

The Density of a polymer is
measured from a fully gelled and fused
sample and should not be confused with
Bulk Density, which is the apparent
density of the granules or powder that
the Polymer is sold as and is measured
prior to processing. Bulk density has
more relevance to rate of flow through
hopper throat of the processing
machine, tendency to bridge/stick and
other handling and storage
considerations. Bulk density can
change depending on particle
size/shape, but Density of a Polymer is
constant.
When the volume cost is plotted, a
completely different picture appears.
Polypropylene now becomes the
cheapest
IPI JOURNAL February / March, 10

27
compounded with additives. The
density of the final product can change
considerably especially when mineral
fillers are added primarily to reduce
costs.

Prices v/s Volume Cost
90

Rs/Kg

80
70

Rs./Kg
Rs/Ltr.

60
50
40

UPVC FPVC LDPE HDPE

PP

PPCO

PS

HIPS

ABS

Rs./Kg

48

60

70

67

68

70

80

82

85

Rs/Ltr.

67.2

75

64.4

64.32

61.2

63.35

84

86.1

89.25

As we have taken the example of the
household bucket, it is interesting to
note that they were first moulded in
LDPE in the early 60s. As HDPE became
available in the late 60s, its lower volume
cost was one of the reasons why there
was a whole scale shift by bucket
manufacturers to HDPE. Of course the
better stiffness and warm water
resistance of HDPE were major factors
for the shift, but the lower Volume Cost
helped.
In the 90s, Polypropylene has also
made inroads into the Bucket market,
aided no doubt by its lower Volume cost,
though its superior clarity, stiffness and
temperature resistance were also
factors. It is smart marketing which has
positioned the clearer and stiffer PP
Bucket as a premium product sold at
higher prices than its HDPE cousin. As
they say, “pricing depends on
marketing policy while Costing depends
on facts”, and the fact is that the volume
cost of the higher priced PP Bucket is
lower than the HDPE one. That is to say
that if PP and HDPE are injected into the
same bucket mould volume, lesser
amount of PP in Kgs would be required.
It is a separate matter that the PP bucket
mould would be different with perhaps a
thinner wall to cash in on PP's higher
28

IPI JOURNAL February / March, 10

rigidity, but the reality of better volume
cost remains.
PVC was never in the picture
because of its higher Volume cost. If its
volume cost had been lower than the
Polyolefins, ways and means would
have been devised to mould it into
buckets!
Perhaps this example is too
simplified as there are many factors
which have to be considered to select
the correct plastic for a specific
application, but the point I am getting at
is that Volume cost is a less understood
but extremely important factor. Factors
affecting selection of plastics will be
taken up in another article.
On the basis of volume cost I had
formulated a directive to our Luggage
designers when I was chief of R&D of
VIP Industries. The directive was that
any new Plastic Component will be
designed with PP Copolymer unless the
design intent cannot be met by the
properties of PPCP. Only then is there a
need to look at other higher volume cost
polymers.
Importance of Volume Cost to the
Plastics formulator
The consideration of volume cost is
even more important when Polymers are

Volume cost and its implications are
not properly understood by many
entrepreneurs, formulators and persons
undertaking cost reduction/value
engineering. It is vital to understand its
implications before embarking on cost
reduction exercises.
Plastic finished goods are rarely sold
by weight. They are priced either per
piece (Mouldings) or per unit length
(Pipes, Cables, Tape). Thus the costing
and pricing are for fixed Volumes. As the
Plastic Raw materials are always
purchased per unit weight, the tendency
is to do cost calculations on a Per Kilo
basis, and the finished product is priced
accordingly to the weight per piece.
However, in the marketplace,
competitive pressures often force the
entrepreneur to offer discounts to
protect market share. The discount is
normally a percentage of the existing
selling price, which, in the majority of
cases is the realization on volume basis.
If cost calculations are done on Per
Kilo basis, many times the reduction in
cost by adding fillers/extenders is
calculated as a percentage of original
formulation cost. The savings may be
translated into a price reduction based
on this percentage. After some time the
entrepreneur realizes that he is
sustaining losses as the reduction in
Volume cost was nowhere near the Per
kg. cost reduction on which the
discounts were based, especially when
mineral fillers are the main cost reducing
input. All Mineral fillers have a higher
density than most plastics.
Rigid PVC Pipes is a prime example.
The ease with which Calcium Carbonate
can be loaded and processed by
modern twin screw extruders has led to
mindless loading of fillers in a desperate
bid to reduce costs. The pitfalls are
many as is illustrated by this example:
Visit : www.ipiindia.com
It is interesting to note that even
though these are theoretical
calculations, the predicted density is
quite near the actually measured
density with the difference being a few
points in the third decimal place. Rarely
do we find errors in the second decimal
place. Assuming that the pipe is gelled
fully and has no voids, the density
figures predicted are quite close to
actuals. There is some volatile loss, but
in a Pipe formulation this is a low
percentage.

unusual in commercial grade PVC Water
supply Pipe and in the non pressure
applications like SWR) the expected
cost reduction appears to be a healthy
25%. However, in actuality, the Volume
cost has reduced only 11%. Such a high
loading of filler not only ruins Pipe impact
strength and pressure resistance, the
wear and tear on costly twin screw
equipment is severe. Thus it is not worth
sacrificing so much of quality
deterioration and machine life reduction
for a mere 11% reduction in cost.

The graphical representation shows
the big difference in the reduction in cost
when measured per kg & the volume
cost by adding 50 PHR Calcium
Carbonate (which I understand is not

This should be understood by all PVC
pipe manufacturers and other sectors
which rely on dense mineral fillers
primarily for cost reduction. Of course
nobody makes pipes with 0PHR filler,

Visit : www.ipiindia.com

around 8-10 PHR filler is the optimum
level for good quality pipe conforming to
BIS 4985, and also acceptable Screw
Barrel life, and it is heartening to note
that most of the quality conscious PVC
Pipe manufacturers have persisted with
such formulations and have been
successful in the long run.
It is when higher loadings are
resorted to for cost reduction that a
vicious cycle starts. Let us say a
manufacturer increases his Filler
loading from 10 PHR to 40 PHR. Relying
on formulation costing he expects a
reduction of 15.5%. He reduces the
prices of his pipes by 15% from his BIS
4985 price. However his cost per length
of pipe has gone down only by only 6.5%
IPI JOURNAL February / March, 10

29
other technical parts is the driving force
for filler addition. It is only at filler levels of
over 50%, as in filler masterbatches, that
the cost per kilo dips below Polymer cost
levels, but the volume cost will be
adverse. Thus normally filler addition
does not automatically lead to cost
savings with Polyolefins as it does with
PVC.
Glass Filled Polymers is a special
case with the fillers price sometimes
exceeding the Polymer prices. It should
be obvious that Glass filling is done
purely to improve mechanicals.

(the Volume Cost reduction). Soon he
finds out that he is losing money, so what
is the next step? More filler loading
coupled with decreasing the wall
thickness of the pipe, deteriorating
quality even further. And the downward
spiral in quality and shrinking returns
continues.
This is a most dangerous trend. Many
Polymer applications in India have faced
declining demand due to loss in
confidence of the consumers because of
repeated failures of poor quality cheap
products. Examples are too numerous,
and is most saddening to persons and
companies who have worked so hard in
establishing such applications. In the
Pipe field itself one can recall the
hammering HDPE pipes took in the early
eighties due to large scale failure of
pipes made from scrap HDPE and sold
to prestigious Government projects as
prime grade pipes. While HDPE pipe
market languished because of the bad
name, PVC Pipes surged ahead. Even
major companies like PIL were so badly
affected that they had to close down the
manufacture of their well established
Hasti brand. It has taken two decades for
HDPE pipes to claw back to good
volumes, which involved consistent
quality and development of new
application areas like Drip and Sprinkler
Irrigation, Gas piping, Large diameter
30

IPI JOURNAL February / March, 10

sewerage pipes etc. as well as
consolidation in the core water supply
sector with good quality pipe with 2nd
generation HDPE grades.
A dangerous fallout of mindless filler
loadings is when markets change from
pricing per piece or in the case of pipes,
per unit length of specified thickness to
pricing on a per kilo basis. Such a
change encourages higher filler
loadings and should be resisted by all
discerning manufacturers. In plastics,
heavier does not mean more “Mazboot”.
Physical properties are seriously
compromised in PVC products made
heavy by excessive filler additions.
With Polyolefins, the situation is
different. Here Fillers like Talc and
Calcium carbonate are added to
improve stiffness to PP, or desired
properties like antifibrilation in HDPE or
PP Rafia Tape. Incorporation of Fillers in
Polyolefins is an expensive process,
requiring costly co-rotating Twin screw
extruders. Compounding costs for filling
Polyolefins can be as high as Rs. 10-15/
kg., while in PVC the increase in
dryblending cost is negligible. Filled
Polyolefins (10-40%) are costlier than the
base polymer because compounding
costs outweigh the lower filler cost. The
volume costs go up sharply, but
requirements of better stiffness in Auto
Components, Moulded Furniture and

In Flexible PVC, considerations of
Volume costs come into play. Large
amounts of Plasticisers and extenders
(Secondary Plasticisers) are used. The
volume cost calculations are similar,
though the contraction in volume in
Flexible PVC compounds is a bit more
because of volatile constituents in the
liquid added.
Here is a simple example of a soft
PVC compound stabilised with a mixed
metal Stabiliser/ESO mix. It is interesting
to note how the relative costs of the other
ingredients change in relation to PVC
Resin when viewed from the Volume
cost angle.
Plasticisers like DOP which per kilo is
much more expensive than resin has
always been thought to be the reason
why Plasticised PVC is costlier than
RPVC. But DOP, for example, is not that
costly from the Volume cost viewpoint. In
fact when PVC prices had flared up,
DOP was actually cheaper than Resin on
a per liter basis!
Here again, an expected cost
reduction by tripling the filler loading is
considerably eroded on a Volume cost
basis.
Secondary Plasticisers like the
popular Chlorinated Paraffin family have
a higher density than the primary
plasticiser. Higher the chlorination,
higher the density and lesser the
cheapening effect. Apart from Filler, CP
is the favoured cost reduction tool. It
takes considerable skill to balance the
Visit : www.ipiindia.com
Volume Cost of Major Ingredients
Ingredient

Cost Rs/Kg

PVC

Rs.50.00

Stabiliser

Volume
Cost Rs/Ltr.

Density
Kg/Ltr

Rs.50.00

CP

% of Resin
Cost

% of Resin
Vol. Cost

1.4

Rs.70.00

62.50%

1.25

Rs.62.50

89.29%

Rs.150.00

187.50%

1.05

Rs.157.50

225.00%

Rs.12.00

15.00%

2.7

Rs.32.40

46.29%

Filler

Formula 1

Formula 2

Recipe
Kgs

Cost
Rs/ Kg

Litres

PVC

60

Rs.3,000.00

42.86

DOP

30

Rs.2,400.00

CP

15

Rs.750.00

Total

117

Recipe
Kgs

Cost
Rs/ Kg

Litres

PVC

60

Rs.3,000.00

42.86

30.61

DOP

30

Rs.2,400.00

30.61

12.00

CP

15

Rs.750.00

12.00

Rs.6,570.00 91.08
Cost/Kg
Rs/ Litre
Rs. 56.15 Rs. 72.14

Total

137

Rs.6,810.00 98.49
Rs/ Litre
Cost/Kg

compatibility with the chlorination level
of the CP selected with the addition PHR
to achieve an effective cost reduction
without compromising quality.
I hope those PVC processors
tempted to take the high filler route
pause and rethink their strategy. One of
the reasons that so many PVC Pipe and
profile extrusion firms have collapsed
and closed shop is that they got caught
in this vicious cycle higher filler loadingdecreased wall thickness – product
failures – compensation claims and
were trapped with heavy losses.
There are other ways of reducing
costs which do not impact quality and
offer value for money. I hope PVC
processors will explore and exhaust all
these other routes before going up on
filler levels. If so this article on Volume
Costs would have served its purpose.

Rs. 49.71 Rs. 69.15
4.14%

Reduction 11.48%

Patel Orbetury

Visit : www.ipiindia.com

IPI JOURNAL February / March, 10

31

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Pvc(poly vinyle chloride)
Pvc(poly vinyle chloride) Pvc(poly vinyle chloride)
Pvc(poly vinyle chloride) faheem maqsood
 
Poly vinyl chloride(polymers)
Poly vinyl chloride(polymers)Poly vinyl chloride(polymers)
Poly vinyl chloride(polymers)sai anjaneya
 
Development of one pack stabiliser systems
Development of one pack stabiliser systemsDevelopment of one pack stabiliser systems
Development of one pack stabiliser systemsSiddhartha Roy
 
Pvc Pipe manufacturing its procedure , cost & application
Pvc Pipe manufacturing its procedure , cost & applicationPvc Pipe manufacturing its procedure , cost & application
Pvc Pipe manufacturing its procedure , cost & applicationUmair Raza
 
Production of PE Wax Emulsion (Polyethylene Wax Emulsion)
Production of PE Wax Emulsion (Polyethylene Wax Emulsion)Production of PE Wax Emulsion (Polyethylene Wax Emulsion)
Production of PE Wax Emulsion (Polyethylene Wax Emulsion)Ajjay Kumar Gupta
 
Pvc compounding ingredients, The essential Ingredients
Pvc compounding ingredients, The essential IngredientsPvc compounding ingredients, The essential Ingredients
Pvc compounding ingredients, The essential IngredientsSiddhartha Roy
 
Production of Urea Formaldehyde UF85
Production of Urea Formaldehyde UF85Production of Urea Formaldehyde UF85
Production of Urea Formaldehyde UF85Ajjay Kumar Gupta
 
PVC Compounding1-NSA WITH DIAGRAMS & FORMULATIONS-1.pdf
PVC Compounding1-NSA WITH DIAGRAMS & FORMULATIONS-1.pdfPVC Compounding1-NSA WITH DIAGRAMS & FORMULATIONS-1.pdf
PVC Compounding1-NSA WITH DIAGRAMS & FORMULATIONS-1.pdfKoolLeisure
 
Polyisocyanates and Prepolymers.pdf
Polyisocyanates and Prepolymers.pdfPolyisocyanates and Prepolymers.pdf
Polyisocyanates and Prepolymers.pdfHoaPhamThai2
 
formation and uses of pvc and nylon
formation and uses of pvc and nylonformation and uses of pvc and nylon
formation and uses of pvc and nylonAfzal Zubair
 
Function of Waxes in PVC Pipe Extrusion
Function of Waxes in PVC Pipe ExtrusionFunction of Waxes in PVC Pipe Extrusion
Function of Waxes in PVC Pipe ExtrusionTom Pedersen
 
Polyurethane coatings
Polyurethane coatingsPolyurethane coatings
Polyurethane coatingsFaisal Nadeem
 
Formulation and Manufacturing Process of Adhesives, Glues and Resins (Glues o...
Formulation and Manufacturing Process of Adhesives, Glues and Resins (Glues o...Formulation and Manufacturing Process of Adhesives, Glues and Resins (Glues o...
Formulation and Manufacturing Process of Adhesives, Glues and Resins (Glues o...Ajjay Kumar Gupta
 
Polyurethane-structure,types,properties,preparation,application
Polyurethane-structure,types,properties,preparation,applicationPolyurethane-structure,types,properties,preparation,application
Polyurethane-structure,types,properties,preparation,applicationEmayavarambanA
 
Flammability Testing Of Plastics Jinish Doshi
Flammability Testing Of Plastics Jinish DoshiFlammability Testing Of Plastics Jinish Doshi
Flammability Testing Of Plastics Jinish DoshiJinish Doshi
 
Release coats presentation-pstc
Release coats presentation-pstcRelease coats presentation-pstc
Release coats presentation-pstcXin Zheng
 

Tendances (20)

Pvc(poly vinyle chloride)
Pvc(poly vinyle chloride) Pvc(poly vinyle chloride)
Pvc(poly vinyle chloride)
 
Poly vinyl chloride(polymers)
Poly vinyl chloride(polymers)Poly vinyl chloride(polymers)
Poly vinyl chloride(polymers)
 
Development of one pack stabiliser systems
Development of one pack stabiliser systemsDevelopment of one pack stabiliser systems
Development of one pack stabiliser systems
 
Pvc Pipe manufacturing its procedure , cost & application
Pvc Pipe manufacturing its procedure , cost & applicationPvc Pipe manufacturing its procedure , cost & application
Pvc Pipe manufacturing its procedure , cost & application
 
Production of PE Wax Emulsion (Polyethylene Wax Emulsion)
Production of PE Wax Emulsion (Polyethylene Wax Emulsion)Production of PE Wax Emulsion (Polyethylene Wax Emulsion)
Production of PE Wax Emulsion (Polyethylene Wax Emulsion)
 
Pvc compounding ingredients, The essential Ingredients
Pvc compounding ingredients, The essential IngredientsPvc compounding ingredients, The essential Ingredients
Pvc compounding ingredients, The essential Ingredients
 
Production of Urea Formaldehyde UF85
Production of Urea Formaldehyde UF85Production of Urea Formaldehyde UF85
Production of Urea Formaldehyde UF85
 
PVC Compounding1-NSA WITH DIAGRAMS & FORMULATIONS-1.pdf
PVC Compounding1-NSA WITH DIAGRAMS & FORMULATIONS-1.pdfPVC Compounding1-NSA WITH DIAGRAMS & FORMULATIONS-1.pdf
PVC Compounding1-NSA WITH DIAGRAMS & FORMULATIONS-1.pdf
 
Polyisocyanates and Prepolymers.pdf
Polyisocyanates and Prepolymers.pdfPolyisocyanates and Prepolymers.pdf
Polyisocyanates and Prepolymers.pdf
 
formation and uses of pvc and nylon
formation and uses of pvc and nylonformation and uses of pvc and nylon
formation and uses of pvc and nylon
 
Heat and light stabilizer
Heat and light stabilizerHeat and light stabilizer
Heat and light stabilizer
 
pvc pipe
pvc pipepvc pipe
pvc pipe
 
Function of Waxes in PVC Pipe Extrusion
Function of Waxes in PVC Pipe ExtrusionFunction of Waxes in PVC Pipe Extrusion
Function of Waxes in PVC Pipe Extrusion
 
Polyurethane coatings
Polyurethane coatingsPolyurethane coatings
Polyurethane coatings
 
Hdpe
HdpeHdpe
Hdpe
 
Formulation and Manufacturing Process of Adhesives, Glues and Resins (Glues o...
Formulation and Manufacturing Process of Adhesives, Glues and Resins (Glues o...Formulation and Manufacturing Process of Adhesives, Glues and Resins (Glues o...
Formulation and Manufacturing Process of Adhesives, Glues and Resins (Glues o...
 
Polyurethane-structure,types,properties,preparation,application
Polyurethane-structure,types,properties,preparation,applicationPolyurethane-structure,types,properties,preparation,application
Polyurethane-structure,types,properties,preparation,application
 
Urea formaldehyde
Urea formaldehydeUrea formaldehyde
Urea formaldehyde
 
Flammability Testing Of Plastics Jinish Doshi
Flammability Testing Of Plastics Jinish DoshiFlammability Testing Of Plastics Jinish Doshi
Flammability Testing Of Plastics Jinish Doshi
 
Release coats presentation-pstc
Release coats presentation-pstcRelease coats presentation-pstc
Release coats presentation-pstc
 

En vedette

Pvc formulation perstorp_eng 2014
Pvc formulation perstorp_eng 2014Pvc formulation perstorp_eng 2014
Pvc formulation perstorp_eng 2014Perstorp Group
 
PVC Compounding Ingredients Part 1
PVC Compounding Ingredients Part 1PVC Compounding Ingredients Part 1
PVC Compounding Ingredients Part 1Siddhartha Roy
 
Plasticizer class ppt
Plasticizer class pptPlasticizer class ppt
Plasticizer class pptvedg007
 
Additives in plastics
Additives in plasticsAdditives in plastics
Additives in plasticsVasudev Singh
 
Pvc pipes past present and future 6 Slide handouts in PDF Format
Pvc pipes past present and future 6 Slide handouts in PDF FormatPvc pipes past present and future 6 Slide handouts in PDF Format
Pvc pipes past present and future 6 Slide handouts in PDF FormatSiddhartha Roy
 
Plasticizer Presentation Final
Plasticizer Presentation FinalPlasticizer Presentation Final
Plasticizer Presentation Finaldeepa_nair93
 
Volume Costs in Plastic Applications
Volume Costs in Plastic ApplicationsVolume Costs in Plastic Applications
Volume Costs in Plastic ApplicationsSiddhartha Roy
 
Fire retardant and environmental impact of polymer additives
Fire retardant and environmental impact of polymer additivesFire retardant and environmental impact of polymer additives
Fire retardant and environmental impact of polymer additivesMuin Ramli
 
Apache Etch Introduction @ FOSDEM 2011
Apache Etch Introduction @ FOSDEM 2011Apache Etch Introduction @ FOSDEM 2011
Apache Etch Introduction @ FOSDEM 2011grandyho
 
Formulation of field databased model a case study at pvc pipe manu
Formulation of field databased model a case study at pvc pipe manuFormulation of field databased model a case study at pvc pipe manu
Formulation of field databased model a case study at pvc pipe manuIAEME Publication
 
Curling in multilayer films
Curling in multilayer filmsCurling in multilayer films
Curling in multilayer filmsTed Brink
 
PVC as a construction material
PVC as a construction materialPVC as a construction material
PVC as a construction materialAlok Mishra
 

En vedette (17)

Pvc formulation perstorp_eng 2014
Pvc formulation perstorp_eng 2014Pvc formulation perstorp_eng 2014
Pvc formulation perstorp_eng 2014
 
PVC Compounding Ingredients Part 1
PVC Compounding Ingredients Part 1PVC Compounding Ingredients Part 1
PVC Compounding Ingredients Part 1
 
Plasticizer class ppt
Plasticizer class pptPlasticizer class ppt
Plasticizer class ppt
 
Plasticizer
PlasticizerPlasticizer
Plasticizer
 
Additives in plastics
Additives in plasticsAdditives in plastics
Additives in plastics
 
Additives
AdditivesAdditives
Additives
 
Pvc pipes past present and future 6 Slide handouts in PDF Format
Pvc pipes past present and future 6 Slide handouts in PDF FormatPvc pipes past present and future 6 Slide handouts in PDF Format
Pvc pipes past present and future 6 Slide handouts in PDF Format
 
Plasticizer Presentation Final
Plasticizer Presentation FinalPlasticizer Presentation Final
Plasticizer Presentation Final
 
Volume Costs in Plastic Applications
Volume Costs in Plastic ApplicationsVolume Costs in Plastic Applications
Volume Costs in Plastic Applications
 
Fire retardant and environmental impact of polymer additives
Fire retardant and environmental impact of polymer additivesFire retardant and environmental impact of polymer additives
Fire retardant and environmental impact of polymer additives
 
Plasticizer
PlasticizerPlasticizer
Plasticizer
 
Apply etch
Apply etchApply etch
Apply etch
 
Apache Etch Introduction @ FOSDEM 2011
Apache Etch Introduction @ FOSDEM 2011Apache Etch Introduction @ FOSDEM 2011
Apache Etch Introduction @ FOSDEM 2011
 
Formulation of field databased model a case study at pvc pipe manu
Formulation of field databased model a case study at pvc pipe manuFormulation of field databased model a case study at pvc pipe manu
Formulation of field databased model a case study at pvc pipe manu
 
Curling in multilayer films
Curling in multilayer filmsCurling in multilayer films
Curling in multilayer films
 
Etching
EtchingEtching
Etching
 
PVC as a construction material
PVC as a construction materialPVC as a construction material
PVC as a construction material
 

Similaire à PVC volume cost, How to use Fillers judicously

Volume Cost concept with reference to Filled Polyolefins
Volume Cost concept with reference to Filled PolyolefinsVolume Cost concept with reference to Filled Polyolefins
Volume Cost concept with reference to Filled PolyolefinsSiddhartha Roy
 
Portable pipe system (cipet)
Portable pipe system (cipet)Portable pipe system (cipet)
Portable pipe system (cipet)ArvIND Kumar
 
6.benchmarking of
6.benchmarking of6.benchmarking of
6.benchmarking oflibfsb
 
ECO-FRIENDLY AND SUSTAINABLE SOLUTIONS PROGRESSING CIRCULAR ECONOMY
ECO-FRIENDLY AND SUSTAINABLE SOLUTIONS PROGRESSING CIRCULAR ECONOMYECO-FRIENDLY AND SUSTAINABLE SOLUTIONS PROGRESSING CIRCULAR ECONOMY
ECO-FRIENDLY AND SUSTAINABLE SOLUTIONS PROGRESSING CIRCULAR ECONOMYiQHub
 
Zero and Low GWP HCFC Alternatives
Zero and Low GWP HCFC AlternativesZero and Low GWP HCFC Alternatives
Zero and Low GWP HCFC AlternativesUNEP OzonAction
 
IRJET- Study on the Performance of Rubberised Bitumen with Plastic Waste
IRJET-  	  Study on the Performance of Rubberised Bitumen with Plastic WasteIRJET-  	  Study on the Performance of Rubberised Bitumen with Plastic Waste
IRJET- Study on the Performance of Rubberised Bitumen with Plastic WasteIRJET Journal
 
Fibre from corn
Fibre from cornFibre from corn
Fibre from cornAdane Nega
 
Fibre from corn
Fibre from cornFibre from corn
Fibre from cornAdane Nega
 
Fibre from corn
Fibre from cornFibre from corn
Fibre from cornAdane Nega
 
The effect of phthalate on health
The effect of phthalate on healthThe effect of phthalate on health
The effect of phthalate on healthDec-Lam
 
IntroductIonForest Hill Paper Company (FHPC) is a small, c
IntroductIonForest Hill Paper Company (FHPC) is a small, cIntroductIonForest Hill Paper Company (FHPC) is a small, c
IntroductIonForest Hill Paper Company (FHPC) is a small, cTatianaMajor22
 
Practical Methods to Manufacture Sustainable Plastics Products I. Partial Foa...
Practical Methods to Manufacture Sustainable Plastics Products I. Partial Foa...Practical Methods to Manufacture Sustainable Plastics Products I. Partial Foa...
Practical Methods to Manufacture Sustainable Plastics Products I. Partial Foa...Ata Zad, Ph.D.
 
IntroductIonForest Hill Paper Company (FHPC) is a small, c.docx
IntroductIonForest Hill Paper Company (FHPC) is a small, c.docxIntroductIonForest Hill Paper Company (FHPC) is a small, c.docx
IntroductIonForest Hill Paper Company (FHPC) is a small, c.docxmariuse18nolet
 
Business Fitness Guide for Manufacturing
Business Fitness Guide for ManufacturingBusiness Fitness Guide for Manufacturing
Business Fitness Guide for ManufacturingAlan Birse
 

Similaire à PVC volume cost, How to use Fillers judicously (20)

Volume Cost concept with reference to Filled Polyolefins
Volume Cost concept with reference to Filled PolyolefinsVolume Cost concept with reference to Filled Polyolefins
Volume Cost concept with reference to Filled Polyolefins
 
Portable pipe system (cipet)
Portable pipe system (cipet)Portable pipe system (cipet)
Portable pipe system (cipet)
 
6.benchmarking of
6.benchmarking of6.benchmarking of
6.benchmarking of
 
ECO-FRIENDLY AND SUSTAINABLE SOLUTIONS PROGRESSING CIRCULAR ECONOMY
ECO-FRIENDLY AND SUSTAINABLE SOLUTIONS PROGRESSING CIRCULAR ECONOMYECO-FRIENDLY AND SUSTAINABLE SOLUTIONS PROGRESSING CIRCULAR ECONOMY
ECO-FRIENDLY AND SUSTAINABLE SOLUTIONS PROGRESSING CIRCULAR ECONOMY
 
Zero and Low GWP HCFC Alternatives
Zero and Low GWP HCFC AlternativesZero and Low GWP HCFC Alternatives
Zero and Low GWP HCFC Alternatives
 
IRJET- Study on the Performance of Rubberised Bitumen with Plastic Waste
IRJET-  	  Study on the Performance of Rubberised Bitumen with Plastic WasteIRJET-  	  Study on the Performance of Rubberised Bitumen with Plastic Waste
IRJET- Study on the Performance of Rubberised Bitumen with Plastic Waste
 
GPEC conference 2014
GPEC conference 2014 GPEC conference 2014
GPEC conference 2014
 
bio_71432_final
bio_71432_finalbio_71432_final
bio_71432_final
 
Fibre from corn
Fibre from cornFibre from corn
Fibre from corn
 
Fibre from corn
Fibre from cornFibre from corn
Fibre from corn
 
Fibre from corn
Fibre from cornFibre from corn
Fibre from corn
 
The effect of phthalate on health
The effect of phthalate on healthThe effect of phthalate on health
The effect of phthalate on health
 
Cost Management : Focus
Cost Management : FocusCost Management : Focus
Cost Management : Focus
 
IntroductIonForest Hill Paper Company (FHPC) is a small, c
IntroductIonForest Hill Paper Company (FHPC) is a small, cIntroductIonForest Hill Paper Company (FHPC) is a small, c
IntroductIonForest Hill Paper Company (FHPC) is a small, c
 
Bioplastics: Myth or Solution by Dr Jim Jem
Bioplastics: Myth or Solution by Dr Jim JemBioplastics: Myth or Solution by Dr Jim Jem
Bioplastics: Myth or Solution by Dr Jim Jem
 
Practical Methods to Manufacture Sustainable Plastics Products I. Partial Foa...
Practical Methods to Manufacture Sustainable Plastics Products I. Partial Foa...Practical Methods to Manufacture Sustainable Plastics Products I. Partial Foa...
Practical Methods to Manufacture Sustainable Plastics Products I. Partial Foa...
 
2014 SPE TPO conference / FibreTuff
2014 SPE TPO conference / FibreTuff2014 SPE TPO conference / FibreTuff
2014 SPE TPO conference / FibreTuff
 
IntroductIonForest Hill Paper Company (FHPC) is a small, c.docx
IntroductIonForest Hill Paper Company (FHPC) is a small, c.docxIntroductIonForest Hill Paper Company (FHPC) is a small, c.docx
IntroductIonForest Hill Paper Company (FHPC) is a small, c.docx
 
Continuous open width treatment english
Continuous open width treatment englishContinuous open width treatment english
Continuous open width treatment english
 
Business Fitness Guide for Manufacturing
Business Fitness Guide for ManufacturingBusiness Fitness Guide for Manufacturing
Business Fitness Guide for Manufacturing
 

Dernier

UiPath Community: AI for UiPath Automation Developers
UiPath Community: AI for UiPath Automation DevelopersUiPath Community: AI for UiPath Automation Developers
UiPath Community: AI for UiPath Automation DevelopersUiPathCommunity
 
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 6
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 6UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 6
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 6DianaGray10
 
UiPath Clipboard AI: "A TIME Magazine Best Invention of 2023 Unveiled"
UiPath Clipboard AI: "A TIME Magazine Best Invention of 2023 Unveiled"UiPath Clipboard AI: "A TIME Magazine Best Invention of 2023 Unveiled"
UiPath Clipboard AI: "A TIME Magazine Best Invention of 2023 Unveiled"DianaGray10
 
Comparing Sidecar-less Service Mesh from Cilium and Istio
Comparing Sidecar-less Service Mesh from Cilium and IstioComparing Sidecar-less Service Mesh from Cilium and Istio
Comparing Sidecar-less Service Mesh from Cilium and IstioChristian Posta
 
The Data Metaverse: Unpacking the Roles, Use Cases, and Tech Trends in Data a...
The Data Metaverse: Unpacking the Roles, Use Cases, and Tech Trends in Data a...The Data Metaverse: Unpacking the Roles, Use Cases, and Tech Trends in Data a...
The Data Metaverse: Unpacking the Roles, Use Cases, and Tech Trends in Data a...Aggregage
 
activity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdf
activity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdf
activity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfJamie (Taka) Wang
 
Artificial Intelligence & SEO Trends for 2024
Artificial Intelligence & SEO Trends for 2024Artificial Intelligence & SEO Trends for 2024
Artificial Intelligence & SEO Trends for 2024D Cloud Solutions
 
Governance in SharePoint Premium:What's in the box?
Governance in SharePoint Premium:What's in the box?Governance in SharePoint Premium:What's in the box?
Governance in SharePoint Premium:What's in the box?Juan Carlos Gonzalez
 
All in AI: LLM Landscape & RAG in 2024 with Mark Ryan (Google) & Jerry Liu (L...
All in AI: LLM Landscape & RAG in 2024 with Mark Ryan (Google) & Jerry Liu (L...All in AI: LLM Landscape & RAG in 2024 with Mark Ryan (Google) & Jerry Liu (L...
All in AI: LLM Landscape & RAG in 2024 with Mark Ryan (Google) & Jerry Liu (L...Daniel Zivkovic
 
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability Adventure
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability AdventureOpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability Adventure
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability AdventureEric D. Schabell
 
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDEADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDELiveplex
 
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 8
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 8UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 8
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 8DianaGray10
 
Valere | Digital Solutions & AI Transformation Portfolio | 2024
Valere | Digital Solutions & AI Transformation Portfolio | 2024Valere | Digital Solutions & AI Transformation Portfolio | 2024
Valere | Digital Solutions & AI Transformation Portfolio | 2024Alexander Turgeon
 
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?IES VE
 
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdf
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdfMachine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdf
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdfAijun Zhang
 
Nanopower In Semiconductor Industry.pdf
Nanopower  In Semiconductor Industry.pdfNanopower  In Semiconductor Industry.pdf
Nanopower In Semiconductor Industry.pdfPedro Manuel
 
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019IES VE
 
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just Minutes
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just MinutesAI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just Minutes
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just MinutesMd Hossain Ali
 
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBX
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBXVoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBX
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBXTarek Kalaji
 

Dernier (20)

UiPath Community: AI for UiPath Automation Developers
UiPath Community: AI for UiPath Automation DevelopersUiPath Community: AI for UiPath Automation Developers
UiPath Community: AI for UiPath Automation Developers
 
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 6
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 6UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 6
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 6
 
UiPath Clipboard AI: "A TIME Magazine Best Invention of 2023 Unveiled"
UiPath Clipboard AI: "A TIME Magazine Best Invention of 2023 Unveiled"UiPath Clipboard AI: "A TIME Magazine Best Invention of 2023 Unveiled"
UiPath Clipboard AI: "A TIME Magazine Best Invention of 2023 Unveiled"
 
Comparing Sidecar-less Service Mesh from Cilium and Istio
Comparing Sidecar-less Service Mesh from Cilium and IstioComparing Sidecar-less Service Mesh from Cilium and Istio
Comparing Sidecar-less Service Mesh from Cilium and Istio
 
The Data Metaverse: Unpacking the Roles, Use Cases, and Tech Trends in Data a...
The Data Metaverse: Unpacking the Roles, Use Cases, and Tech Trends in Data a...The Data Metaverse: Unpacking the Roles, Use Cases, and Tech Trends in Data a...
The Data Metaverse: Unpacking the Roles, Use Cases, and Tech Trends in Data a...
 
activity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdf
activity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdf
activity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdf
 
Artificial Intelligence & SEO Trends for 2024
Artificial Intelligence & SEO Trends for 2024Artificial Intelligence & SEO Trends for 2024
Artificial Intelligence & SEO Trends for 2024
 
Governance in SharePoint Premium:What's in the box?
Governance in SharePoint Premium:What's in the box?Governance in SharePoint Premium:What's in the box?
Governance in SharePoint Premium:What's in the box?
 
All in AI: LLM Landscape & RAG in 2024 with Mark Ryan (Google) & Jerry Liu (L...
All in AI: LLM Landscape & RAG in 2024 with Mark Ryan (Google) & Jerry Liu (L...All in AI: LLM Landscape & RAG in 2024 with Mark Ryan (Google) & Jerry Liu (L...
All in AI: LLM Landscape & RAG in 2024 with Mark Ryan (Google) & Jerry Liu (L...
 
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability Adventure
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability AdventureOpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability Adventure
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability Adventure
 
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDEADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
 
201610817 - edge part1
201610817 - edge part1201610817 - edge part1
201610817 - edge part1
 
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 8
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 8UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 8
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 8
 
Valere | Digital Solutions & AI Transformation Portfolio | 2024
Valere | Digital Solutions & AI Transformation Portfolio | 2024Valere | Digital Solutions & AI Transformation Portfolio | 2024
Valere | Digital Solutions & AI Transformation Portfolio | 2024
 
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?
 
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdf
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdfMachine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdf
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdf
 
Nanopower In Semiconductor Industry.pdf
Nanopower  In Semiconductor Industry.pdfNanopower  In Semiconductor Industry.pdf
Nanopower In Semiconductor Industry.pdf
 
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
 
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just Minutes
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just MinutesAI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just Minutes
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just Minutes
 
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBX
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBXVoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBX
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBX
 

PVC volume cost, How to use Fillers judicously

  • 1. Volume Cost & its importance in Plastic applications: Siddhartha Roy Consultant, RoyPlasTech, Pune royplastech@rediffmail.com +919890366632 What is Volume Cost? The Volume Cost of a Raw Material input is the purchase cost of a unit volume of the material. It is extremely important to understand the Volume cost of Polymers and its additives as it plays a key role in their selection for a particular application. Volume cost (Rs./Litre)= Purchase Cost (Rs./Kg.) x Density (Kg./Litre or gm/cc) Let us examine the Volume costs of the major commodity Polymer families. One of the first characteristic of a polymer that a designer looks at before specifying it as the material of construction is its price. These vary from time to time, sometimes wildly, but tend to maintain their proportion vis a vis other polymers. Here are the recent prices of the Commodity thermoplastics (Ball park figures for sure, I am not going into specific grades etc.). While it would look that UPVC is by far the cheapest Polymer, the natural question is that why does it have such limited applications in, say moulded products? Assuming, just for arguments sake that UPVC was as easy to mould as the other Commodity Thermoplastics, why is it not used in such widespread applications like, say, buckets? At this point we have to look at one of the very important properties of Polymers, which many a time is Polymer Abbr. Price Rs./Kg Unplasticised PVC UPVC 48 Plasticised PVC FPVC 60 Low Density Polyethylene LDPE 70 High Density Polyethylene HDPE 67 PP 68 PPCO 70 Polypropylene Homopolymer Polypropylene Copolymer PS 80 High Impact Polystyrene Polystyrene HIPS 82 Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene ABS 85 Visit : www.ipiindia.com overlooked. Fortunately this is not a property which changes with time! Polymer. Density Polymer Kg/Ltr Density Kg/Ltr UPVC 1.40 PS 1.05 FPVC 1.25 HIPS 1.05 LDPE 0.92 ABS 1.05 HDPE 0.96 PP 0.90 PPCO 0.905 The Density of a polymer is measured from a fully gelled and fused sample and should not be confused with Bulk Density, which is the apparent density of the granules or powder that the Polymer is sold as and is measured prior to processing. Bulk density has more relevance to rate of flow through hopper throat of the processing machine, tendency to bridge/stick and other handling and storage considerations. Bulk density can change depending on particle size/shape, but Density of a Polymer is constant. When the volume cost is plotted, a completely different picture appears. Polypropylene now becomes the cheapest IPI JOURNAL February / March, 10 27
  • 2. compounded with additives. The density of the final product can change considerably especially when mineral fillers are added primarily to reduce costs. Prices v/s Volume Cost 90 Rs/Kg 80 70 Rs./Kg Rs/Ltr. 60 50 40 UPVC FPVC LDPE HDPE PP PPCO PS HIPS ABS Rs./Kg 48 60 70 67 68 70 80 82 85 Rs/Ltr. 67.2 75 64.4 64.32 61.2 63.35 84 86.1 89.25 As we have taken the example of the household bucket, it is interesting to note that they were first moulded in LDPE in the early 60s. As HDPE became available in the late 60s, its lower volume cost was one of the reasons why there was a whole scale shift by bucket manufacturers to HDPE. Of course the better stiffness and warm water resistance of HDPE were major factors for the shift, but the lower Volume Cost helped. In the 90s, Polypropylene has also made inroads into the Bucket market, aided no doubt by its lower Volume cost, though its superior clarity, stiffness and temperature resistance were also factors. It is smart marketing which has positioned the clearer and stiffer PP Bucket as a premium product sold at higher prices than its HDPE cousin. As they say, “pricing depends on marketing policy while Costing depends on facts”, and the fact is that the volume cost of the higher priced PP Bucket is lower than the HDPE one. That is to say that if PP and HDPE are injected into the same bucket mould volume, lesser amount of PP in Kgs would be required. It is a separate matter that the PP bucket mould would be different with perhaps a thinner wall to cash in on PP's higher 28 IPI JOURNAL February / March, 10 rigidity, but the reality of better volume cost remains. PVC was never in the picture because of its higher Volume cost. If its volume cost had been lower than the Polyolefins, ways and means would have been devised to mould it into buckets! Perhaps this example is too simplified as there are many factors which have to be considered to select the correct plastic for a specific application, but the point I am getting at is that Volume cost is a less understood but extremely important factor. Factors affecting selection of plastics will be taken up in another article. On the basis of volume cost I had formulated a directive to our Luggage designers when I was chief of R&D of VIP Industries. The directive was that any new Plastic Component will be designed with PP Copolymer unless the design intent cannot be met by the properties of PPCP. Only then is there a need to look at other higher volume cost polymers. Importance of Volume Cost to the Plastics formulator The consideration of volume cost is even more important when Polymers are Volume cost and its implications are not properly understood by many entrepreneurs, formulators and persons undertaking cost reduction/value engineering. It is vital to understand its implications before embarking on cost reduction exercises. Plastic finished goods are rarely sold by weight. They are priced either per piece (Mouldings) or per unit length (Pipes, Cables, Tape). Thus the costing and pricing are for fixed Volumes. As the Plastic Raw materials are always purchased per unit weight, the tendency is to do cost calculations on a Per Kilo basis, and the finished product is priced accordingly to the weight per piece. However, in the marketplace, competitive pressures often force the entrepreneur to offer discounts to protect market share. The discount is normally a percentage of the existing selling price, which, in the majority of cases is the realization on volume basis. If cost calculations are done on Per Kilo basis, many times the reduction in cost by adding fillers/extenders is calculated as a percentage of original formulation cost. The savings may be translated into a price reduction based on this percentage. After some time the entrepreneur realizes that he is sustaining losses as the reduction in Volume cost was nowhere near the Per kg. cost reduction on which the discounts were based, especially when mineral fillers are the main cost reducing input. All Mineral fillers have a higher density than most plastics. Rigid PVC Pipes is a prime example. The ease with which Calcium Carbonate can be loaded and processed by modern twin screw extruders has led to mindless loading of fillers in a desperate bid to reduce costs. The pitfalls are many as is illustrated by this example: Visit : www.ipiindia.com
  • 3. It is interesting to note that even though these are theoretical calculations, the predicted density is quite near the actually measured density with the difference being a few points in the third decimal place. Rarely do we find errors in the second decimal place. Assuming that the pipe is gelled fully and has no voids, the density figures predicted are quite close to actuals. There is some volatile loss, but in a Pipe formulation this is a low percentage. unusual in commercial grade PVC Water supply Pipe and in the non pressure applications like SWR) the expected cost reduction appears to be a healthy 25%. However, in actuality, the Volume cost has reduced only 11%. Such a high loading of filler not only ruins Pipe impact strength and pressure resistance, the wear and tear on costly twin screw equipment is severe. Thus it is not worth sacrificing so much of quality deterioration and machine life reduction for a mere 11% reduction in cost. The graphical representation shows the big difference in the reduction in cost when measured per kg & the volume cost by adding 50 PHR Calcium Carbonate (which I understand is not This should be understood by all PVC pipe manufacturers and other sectors which rely on dense mineral fillers primarily for cost reduction. Of course nobody makes pipes with 0PHR filler, Visit : www.ipiindia.com around 8-10 PHR filler is the optimum level for good quality pipe conforming to BIS 4985, and also acceptable Screw Barrel life, and it is heartening to note that most of the quality conscious PVC Pipe manufacturers have persisted with such formulations and have been successful in the long run. It is when higher loadings are resorted to for cost reduction that a vicious cycle starts. Let us say a manufacturer increases his Filler loading from 10 PHR to 40 PHR. Relying on formulation costing he expects a reduction of 15.5%. He reduces the prices of his pipes by 15% from his BIS 4985 price. However his cost per length of pipe has gone down only by only 6.5% IPI JOURNAL February / March, 10 29
  • 4. other technical parts is the driving force for filler addition. It is only at filler levels of over 50%, as in filler masterbatches, that the cost per kilo dips below Polymer cost levels, but the volume cost will be adverse. Thus normally filler addition does not automatically lead to cost savings with Polyolefins as it does with PVC. Glass Filled Polymers is a special case with the fillers price sometimes exceeding the Polymer prices. It should be obvious that Glass filling is done purely to improve mechanicals. (the Volume Cost reduction). Soon he finds out that he is losing money, so what is the next step? More filler loading coupled with decreasing the wall thickness of the pipe, deteriorating quality even further. And the downward spiral in quality and shrinking returns continues. This is a most dangerous trend. Many Polymer applications in India have faced declining demand due to loss in confidence of the consumers because of repeated failures of poor quality cheap products. Examples are too numerous, and is most saddening to persons and companies who have worked so hard in establishing such applications. In the Pipe field itself one can recall the hammering HDPE pipes took in the early eighties due to large scale failure of pipes made from scrap HDPE and sold to prestigious Government projects as prime grade pipes. While HDPE pipe market languished because of the bad name, PVC Pipes surged ahead. Even major companies like PIL were so badly affected that they had to close down the manufacture of their well established Hasti brand. It has taken two decades for HDPE pipes to claw back to good volumes, which involved consistent quality and development of new application areas like Drip and Sprinkler Irrigation, Gas piping, Large diameter 30 IPI JOURNAL February / March, 10 sewerage pipes etc. as well as consolidation in the core water supply sector with good quality pipe with 2nd generation HDPE grades. A dangerous fallout of mindless filler loadings is when markets change from pricing per piece or in the case of pipes, per unit length of specified thickness to pricing on a per kilo basis. Such a change encourages higher filler loadings and should be resisted by all discerning manufacturers. In plastics, heavier does not mean more “Mazboot”. Physical properties are seriously compromised in PVC products made heavy by excessive filler additions. With Polyolefins, the situation is different. Here Fillers like Talc and Calcium carbonate are added to improve stiffness to PP, or desired properties like antifibrilation in HDPE or PP Rafia Tape. Incorporation of Fillers in Polyolefins is an expensive process, requiring costly co-rotating Twin screw extruders. Compounding costs for filling Polyolefins can be as high as Rs. 10-15/ kg., while in PVC the increase in dryblending cost is negligible. Filled Polyolefins (10-40%) are costlier than the base polymer because compounding costs outweigh the lower filler cost. The volume costs go up sharply, but requirements of better stiffness in Auto Components, Moulded Furniture and In Flexible PVC, considerations of Volume costs come into play. Large amounts of Plasticisers and extenders (Secondary Plasticisers) are used. The volume cost calculations are similar, though the contraction in volume in Flexible PVC compounds is a bit more because of volatile constituents in the liquid added. Here is a simple example of a soft PVC compound stabilised with a mixed metal Stabiliser/ESO mix. It is interesting to note how the relative costs of the other ingredients change in relation to PVC Resin when viewed from the Volume cost angle. Plasticisers like DOP which per kilo is much more expensive than resin has always been thought to be the reason why Plasticised PVC is costlier than RPVC. But DOP, for example, is not that costly from the Volume cost viewpoint. In fact when PVC prices had flared up, DOP was actually cheaper than Resin on a per liter basis! Here again, an expected cost reduction by tripling the filler loading is considerably eroded on a Volume cost basis. Secondary Plasticisers like the popular Chlorinated Paraffin family have a higher density than the primary plasticiser. Higher the chlorination, higher the density and lesser the cheapening effect. Apart from Filler, CP is the favoured cost reduction tool. It takes considerable skill to balance the Visit : www.ipiindia.com
  • 5. Volume Cost of Major Ingredients Ingredient Cost Rs/Kg PVC Rs.50.00 Stabiliser Volume Cost Rs/Ltr. Density Kg/Ltr Rs.50.00 CP % of Resin Cost % of Resin Vol. Cost 1.4 Rs.70.00 62.50% 1.25 Rs.62.50 89.29% Rs.150.00 187.50% 1.05 Rs.157.50 225.00% Rs.12.00 15.00% 2.7 Rs.32.40 46.29% Filler Formula 1 Formula 2 Recipe Kgs Cost Rs/ Kg Litres PVC 60 Rs.3,000.00 42.86 DOP 30 Rs.2,400.00 CP 15 Rs.750.00 Total 117 Recipe Kgs Cost Rs/ Kg Litres PVC 60 Rs.3,000.00 42.86 30.61 DOP 30 Rs.2,400.00 30.61 12.00 CP 15 Rs.750.00 12.00 Rs.6,570.00 91.08 Cost/Kg Rs/ Litre Rs. 56.15 Rs. 72.14 Total 137 Rs.6,810.00 98.49 Rs/ Litre Cost/Kg compatibility with the chlorination level of the CP selected with the addition PHR to achieve an effective cost reduction without compromising quality. I hope those PVC processors tempted to take the high filler route pause and rethink their strategy. One of the reasons that so many PVC Pipe and profile extrusion firms have collapsed and closed shop is that they got caught in this vicious cycle higher filler loadingdecreased wall thickness – product failures – compensation claims and were trapped with heavy losses. There are other ways of reducing costs which do not impact quality and offer value for money. I hope PVC processors will explore and exhaust all these other routes before going up on filler levels. If so this article on Volume Costs would have served its purpose. Rs. 49.71 Rs. 69.15 4.14% Reduction 11.48% Patel Orbetury Visit : www.ipiindia.com IPI JOURNAL February / March, 10 31