SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 8
Download to read offline
Journal, Vol. XXI, No. 1, 1-5, 2015
Submitted to Proceedings of the Directorate-General for Energy of the European Commission
Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project
Development and Supply Chain Processes With
Lean Principles
Stavros Philippou Thomas1*, Iberdrola Renovables2
Abstract
This project scopes to investigate, analyze and implement lean technologies and methods to improve project
development efficiency and provide cost reductions in offshore wind energy investments. Logically all products
and services in the wind power industry involve a supply chain structure. Some of these upstream entities
and activities located inside this multi-directional framework are completely independent-autonomous of one
another while some are interrelated. This process through manufacturing, distribution, installation and operation
creates waste in terms of process time, cost and quality of service. Lean principles-when implemented-work
together to identify, mitigate or even eliminate the waste produced during the life-cycle of a wind power project
and simplify the processes with the highest value and quality. Through a complete lifecycle analysis and under
the plethora of the integrated supply chain processes, this project focuses on developing innovative solutions
and procedures to optimise offshore wind plants installation, operation and maintenance (O&M) as well as
decommissioning-repowering. Finally a set of tools and methodologies to remove supply chain bottlenecks,
address the associated transport, logistics and equipment challenges and improve project management are also
presented. It has been shown that the wastes such as inventory costs and defects have been reduced which
improves the overall project feasibility.
Keywords
offshore wind — supply chain — lean management — portfolio management — project development
*Corresponding author: stavros.thomas@anemorphosis.com
Contents
Introduction 1
1 Market Trends in Offshore Development 2
1.1 Distance to Shore . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
1.2 Installed Capacity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
1.3 Offshore Development and Cost . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
2 Industry Structure and Supply Chain 4
3 Lean and Wind Energy 5
4 Project Life-Cycle and Lean Implementation 5
4.1 Research Methodology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6
5 Defining the Lean Supply Chain Survey Questions 7
Acknowledgments 7
References 7
Introduction
Wind energy industry is one of the fastest growing segments
of the world economy and has a mandate to continue growing
for the next decades. The wind energy market is expected
to increase further following the technology innovations and
cost of energy reduction in terms of supply chain, operation
and maintenance strategies, siting methodologies, weather
prognostic models and project management.
With the enormous growth in offshore wind energy instal-
lations, there will be hundreds of billions spent worldwide
not only to develop and improve the massive wind energy
turbines and their associated ancillary infrastructure but also
to transfer, operate and maintain these sophisticated systems
deployed in shallow-water environments around the world.
The selection of sites for offshore wind farms in deeper waters,
further from shore, with high wind energy potential, extreme
weather and complicated seabed conditions, has contributed
to dramatically driving up the costs faster than the develop-
ment of new technology has been able to bring the costs down.
Strong offshore winds(gusts of perhaps 25mph/40kph+), long
wave periods and other meteorological phenomena such as
sea ice, icing, hurricanes, and lightning make the use of more
robust and reliable wind turbines necessary.
The major challenge for offshore wind is to continue to
bring down the cost faster without compromising plant reliabil-
ity, performance, safety or quality. New technologies and tech-
niques have enormously contributed to mitigate the related
costs of the industry. Tools and techniques including, cellular
Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles — 2/8
manufacturing, condition monitoring, productive-predictive
maintenance and six sigma have been recently adopted from
several companies in a multi-directional effort to mitigate the
CoE [1].
The pace of technological advancement and innovations
in this sector is far too rapid for even a cursory review of
the technology in this article. Perhaps the biggest hurdle to
overcome, before deploying offshore wind technologies, is
the supply chain responsiveness and efficiency including the
relatively high cost of energy, the mitigation of environmen-
tal impacts-especially for plants located in environmentally
protected areas-NATURA 2000, the technical challenges of
project installation, the maintenance procedures and grid in-
terconnection.
Broadly speaking, process improvement is the system-
atic, continuous and methodical approach to identify, layer
and finally eliminate process or system performance gaps
for improving the process of delivering service or services.
Conducting process improvement is a very effective way to
streamline project development procedures and establish re-
liability. When it comes to the related set of techniques and
methods associated with the improvement ideology, lean prin-
ciples can facilitate decision making and increase productivity
and business performance.
Lean, when properly implemented, allows operators and
manufactures to develop and manage projects faster and more
efficiently [2]. Many manufacturing companies have imple-
mented Lean Management principles in a plethora of ways to
suit their needs [3]. Lean principles implementation is recog-
nized as a widespread and highly versatile tool, adopted over
a wide range of organizations and manufacturing companies.
Toyota, Honda, Ford, John Deere, GE, Danaher, Mitsubishi
Heavy Industry-Vestas Offshore are just some of them [4].
Lean is a well established manufacturing technique to
achieve excellence in the auto-motive manufacturing industry
and a very promising methodology for the renewable energy
sector and especially for the wind power industry. LEAN-
WIND [5], a 31-partner consortium project (Logistic Efficien-
cies And Naval architecture for Wind Installations with Novel
Developments) has recently been awarded 10 million euro by
the European Commission to investigate the lean principles ef-
fectiveness and challenges to the offshore wind. The primary
LEANWIND project objective is to provide cost reductions
across the entire offshore wind plants life-cycle from the de-
velopment to the supply chain through the implementation of
lean principles.
“The LEANWIND approach will ensure that unnecessarily
complex or wasteful stages of the development process are
removed, flow between the required stages is streamlined,
quality is enhanced and thus overall cost and time efficiency
improved to enable the industry to bridge the gap between
current costs and industry cost aspirations. Properly applied,
lean management will improve quality, reliability and H&S
standards across the project supply chain and throughout the
wind farm lifecycle.”
Although other project optimization and portfolio man-
agement methods have been established, lean is emerging
as a preferred technique to develop new methodologies and
practises and not only to provide proposals for improvements
in a wind energy project. The design, complexity and scale of
an offshore wind energy plant is too complex to be designed
through small incremental improvements and experimental
methods for the CoE mitigation.
The technology used to provide reliable and cost effective
products requires thinking outside the box and implement-
ing the lessons learned from the past to provide innovative
strategies and plans through manufacturing, design, planning,
transportation, installation and operation. The supply chain
in the wind power industry requires the integration of tech-
nological processes and the continuous flow of the industry
synergies. The development of an integrated supply chain
should be designed to keep inventory investment as low as
possible while simultaneously maintaining an adequate sup-
ply of products to the construction sites for installation when
needed. Not weeks before, or weeks after, but on time.
By implementing state-of-the-art lean technologies and
tools new wind energy products and equipment could be pro-
duced in a cost effective way, the effects of unforeseen risks
could be also mitigated or even eliminated while the technical,
economic, operational, and schedule feasibility of the project
can be significantly improved.
1. Market Trends in Offshore
Development
The competition in the wind energy industry is a polysynthetic
phenomenon due to the fact that a number of traditional sup-
pliers to the automotive and oil industry have adapted their
services and tools to wind turbines and many Asian compa-
nies have taken up production of cheaper versions of various
components.
The industry has suffered from the global market recession
and increased supply chain competition-especially from China
and India. However, according to the 2014 Global Wind
Energy Outlook Report [6] released by the Greenpeace and
the GWEC a coming global bloom in wind power will be
driven by China as well as by steady growth in the United
States Mexico, Brazil, and South Africa. Also India and the
European countries are expected to continue to drive strong
growth momentum.
The aforementioned report examines three ”energy sce-
narios” based on projections used by the International Energy
Agency. The ”New Policies” scenario attempts to capture
the direction and intentions of international climate policy
while other two scenarios—”moderate” and ”advanced”—
which reflect two different approaches to increase wind power
deployment under stable economic market conditions and
policies standardization are also discussed. Figure 2 has been
adapted and simplified from the report to prove that all signs
point to continued and strong growth in demand for wind
Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles — 3/8
Figure 1. Wind Energy Forecast Breakdown
energy projects.
Figure 2. Global Wind Energy Forecast
According to the ‘New Policies’ scenario, in which new
policies-regulations are established, economic framework and
incentives are optimized, the wind energy sector can represent
up to 9% of the global energy mix by 2020, and almost 20%
ten years later. Moreover, offshore wind is expected to be the
fastest growing segment in the global wind energy market with
average annual growth rates of around 30% from 2015-2020.
1.1 Distance to Shore
As offshore wind technology advances, wind resources further
offshore can be harnessed. Greater distances to shore usually
result in deeper waters. Fig. 3 shows that the average water
depth has increased throughout the years and it is expected
to continue [7]. The first projects registered low distances to
shore (¡ 10 km), while over the years, the average distance
to shore of the projects has been rapidly increasing. As il-
lustrated at Fig. 4 the average distance to shore of projects
commissioned between 2013-2015 was between 25-42 km[8].
Currently, the latest Offshore wind energy project located
the furthest distance from coast is the Global Tech 1. The
wind farm is located about 93 km north-west of the island of
Juist on an area of 41 square kilometers in water depths 39-41
meters, a distance circa 56 times higher than the modest 2.25
km of the Vindeby project.
Across Europe, approximately 80% of the resource is
Figure 3. Advanced Scenario - Wind Energy Forecast
located in water depths of greater than 60 meters while ap-
proximately 50% of the highest wind energy potential is de-
tected further than 100km from shore. It is therefore clear that
innovative technologies and methodologies deployment are
necessary perimeters to establish wind energy plants further
out to sea and in deeper water than other earlier adopters.
This is particularly applicable to remote areas on the At-
lantic Ocean-particularly in the southeastern part of the ocean-
and Mediterranean and Black Sea, where only a very small
proportion of the best wind resource lies in water depths where
offshore fixed-bottom wind turbine technology facilitate ex-
ploitation. As shown in Figure: 4 there is a clear trend for the
offshore wind industry to move to deeper waters and further
from shore. Thus, a reliable and flexible supply chain frame-
work is needed to satisfactory accommodate all the relevant
and required developments and accelerate wind turbine manu-
facturing, marine contractors, equipment suppliers and port
operators processes.
Figure 4. Planned Offshore Wind Farms
1.2 Installed Capacity
In 1991, the first offshore wind power plant with a total ca-
pacity of 4.95 MW installed 2.5 km off the Danish coast, in
Vindeby constructed. Twenty four years later, at the end of
July 2015 offshore wind capacity reached 8,759 megawatts
MW in Europe. Since the beginning of the decade, the share
of new offshore capacity in total new wind capacity additions
has been increasing. Between 2011 and 2012, the average
Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles — 4/8
offshore project size was almost doubled from 116 MW to 289
MW-60 times higher than the offshore installation at Vindeby.
Offshore wind installations in 2014 were 5.3% less than in
2013, with 1,483.3 MW of new capacity grid. However, as
the demand for cheaper and more sustainable energy grows,
even more turbines will be required [9].
CommissionYear
Figure 5. Planned Offshore Wind Farms
1.3 Offshore Development and Cost
Offshore wind projects total installed costs have risen over
time (See Figure: 6) because as the distance increases the
complexity of the project increases due to the development,
transportation and O&M requirements. The average name-
plate capacity has increased, from 2.9 MW in 2007 to 8 MW
in 2015 (Vestas V-164) as larger wind turbines reduce installa-
tion costs per MW and can also help reduce the related O&M
costs because of the systems optimization and significant im-
provements in equipment service life. In addition to the latter,
larger W.T rotors and higher hub heights, boosting expected
capacity factors and thus, facilitate the installed costs miti-
gation. In fact, research shows [10] that the average rotor
diameter has increased by 86% since 1999. The average rotor
diameter ballooned to 164 meters in 2015, up from 71 meters
in 2011 and 81.6 meters in 2009.
2015euro/kw
Figure 6. Offshore Projects and Costs
Despite the continued technological advancements in the
offshore wind industry and the considerable technological-
tactical progress that the wind energy sector has made in re-
cent years, the average project Capital expenditures (CAPEX)
have been rising dramatically, resulting in concerns over the
economic feasibility of some large and deep-water projects
(See Figure: 7).
Figure 7. Offshore Wind CAPEX Costs
Wind turbines located on deep-water sites with complex
seabed characteristics/properties, potentially long-period de-
commissioning processes and severe weather conditions may
explain the increased capital required in terms of logistics,
grid connection and installation [11]. What’s more, the related
costs of recent large offshore installations increased due to the
higher perceived information asymmetries (wind forecasting,
availability, AEP uncertainties, wave and wind condition, etc)
and market uncertainties because of the stock-market volatil-
ity. Offshore plants located on deep water area also lead to
higher Operational and Maintenance (OM) costs which can
represent up to 30% of the total project CAPEX [?].
2. Industry Structure and Supply Chain
The rapid pace of offshore-wind energy projects around the
world is leading wind turbine manufacturers and O&M ser-
vice providers to search qualified, capable and experienced
business partners and suppliers to meet customer demands and
industry challenges. The relevant costs and risks associated
with transportation, logistics and delivery time combined with
the supply chain challenges, has created an opportunity for
manufacturers and supply chain providers to gain high market
share.
In less than a decade, gigantic shifts in wind power man-
ufacturing competence have created “an integrated supply
chain” for manufacturing competitiveness. Asia appears to be
a protagon among the world’s most competitive manufactur-
ing markets — and its likely to hold this position in the next
decades.
The development of a strong wind turbine supply chain
takes a predictable path once flexible and nimble supply chain
strategies for wind farm development are established. In the
early stages of a project, Original wind turbine and Equip-
ment Manufacturers (OEM) should set up their operations in
a location that provides good accessibility standards (distance
from shore, port facilities etc) - centralized enough to allow
access to multiple wind farm developments - while ensur-
ing maximum capacity availability and with a multi-skilled
workforce.
Tier 1 suppliers, including tower, blades, nacelle assembly
Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles — 5/8
(OEM)
OriginalEquipment
Manufacturers
EXISTING
COMING
SpecializedSupply
ChainManagement
Figure 8. The Supply Chain Structure Transformation
manufacturers and crane components follow, and finally, sub-
component suppliers including nacelle components, control
systems, metal fabricators, foundation components condition
monitoring suppliers, enter the supply chain to support tier
1’s requirements and objectives.
However, the wind industry supply chain is rapidly under-
going change. Some years ago, the supplier structure to wind
turbine manufacturers was almost flat. During the past, the
majority of the companies in the supply chain was directly
related to the wind turbine manufacturers and regularly they
had only one wind turbine manufacturer as a customer. Thus,
there were limited interconnections and synergies between
sub-suppliers.
This has changed and the supply chain system is increas-
ingly organised in a more sophisticated tiered supply chain
structure [ See Figure: 8]. Nowadays, the supply chain rely
heavily on innovation, both in design and manufacturing meth-
ods and techniques. Wind power suppliers (tier one), design
and develop innovative solutions to achieve greater compo-
nent durability, longer service life and improved reliability as
well as more cost-efficient processes. Moreover, OEM’s take
on responsibility for more than simply providing parts and
components and increasingly become supplier of sub-systems
and services such as design, assembly and support to provide
more value and build more lasting relationships with the wind
turbine manufacturers.
3. Lean and Wind Energy
Global competition in wind energy techno-innovation and pro-
duction is intensifying. Suppliers, tenders, developers manu-
facturers and service providers are trying to take advantage of
the huge growth potential in this sector while their efforts to
improve the related services and procedures - under unstable
economic market environments and ever-changing regulation
frameworks-provide support for further growth within the
wind power industry as a whole.
The right mix of project planning, monitoring, and control-
ling methodologies, can establish the delivery of high-quality
projects on time, on budget and with high quality results.
Wind energy projects are no exception. Regardless of the
size or complexity, the success of managing an offshore wind
power project will most likely depends on the lessons learned
from the past and the available tools and methods to heuristi-
cally deal with the associated risks, hazards and uncertainties.
Although the techniques and tools vary dramatically in scale,
they share the potential to remove critical impediments to the
effective management of wind power projects.
Lean is an excellent manufacturing and administrative
technique to achieve excellence in the wind energy products
and services. What makes the implementation of Lean princi-
ples beneficial is the relentless focus on waste identification-
elimination and reduction in operating costs.
By significantly improving performance, optimizing ser-
vices responsiveness and dramatically reducing manufacturing
(including transportation and logistics) time, flexibility and
productivity are ensured while defects and variation phenom-
ena are mitigated. Especially for an industry like wind energy
where capital should be carefully managed and controlled to
attract and secure new investments-in economic viable and
technical feasible terms-lean tools are critically important.
Lean principles could be effectively applied for the entire
life-cycle process of an offshore wind energy project. From
deployment and installation to the development of novel O&M
strategies with the highest safety and quality standards.
However, the application of lean principles to the wind
power industry is greeted with much scepticism. To a cer-
tain degree this is true because industries such as wind - with
such as high volume and low variety of products and services,
long setup times and uncertainties because of the weather data
stochastic nature - are inherently more efficient and present rel-
atively less enthusiasm for improvement proposals when the
competitors use market intelligence techniques and procure-
ment excellence to mitigate the costs and gain even greater
share of this lucrative market.
This may explain why some managers hesitate to set new
performance objectives and standards by implementing lean
manufacturing tools and techniques to the traditional depart-
ment processes. As a real-life paradigm, it is difficult to apply
the cellular manufacturing concept [12] in an offshore wind
energy facility due to the fact that wind turbines are gigantic
and the ancillary infrastructure not easy to move. Ironically,
the wind power industry itself demands new technology, as
modern and high intelligence services required to go beyond
traditional technology solutions.
4. Project Life-Cycle and Lean
Implementation
Logically all products and services in the wind power industry
involve a supply chain structure. Some of these upstream enti-
ties and activities located inside this multi-directional frame-
work are completely independent-autonomous of one another
Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles — 6/8
while some are interrelated. This process through manufac-
turing, distribution, installation and operation creates waste
in terms of process time, cost and quality of service. Lean
principles-when implemented-work together to identify, miti-
gate or even eliminate the waste produced during the life-cycle
of a wind power project and simplify the processes with the
highest value and quality.
This project scope is to investigate how the lean principles
can be adapted from the offshore wind and to evaluate their
implementation benefits at a specific industrial concern. The
research hypothesizes that there are several opportunities for
improvement and wastes removal in the offshore wind energy
industry if lean tools are used. Thus, to improve and optimize
the life cycle processes for an offshore project and drive an ef-
fective portfolio management, the principles of lean should be
hypothetically implemented at three separate levels: the Oper-
ational Tactics, the Strategic Planning and the Technological
Innovations (Figure 9).
OperationalTactics
VesselDesigns,
AccessibilityTechno-
logiesandMethods,
ConditionMonitoring
Storm ControlSystems
Foundation/Platforms
RisksAssessmentRisksAssessment
PrognosticMaintenance
VesselDesigns,
AccessibilityTechno-
logiesandMethods,
ConditionMonitoring
Storm ControlSystems
Foundation/Platforms
RisksAssessmentRisksAssessment
PrognosticMaintenance
Transportation
Logistics
ProjectLifeCycle
BudgetEvaluation
EconomicAnalysis
PortfolioManagement
Transportation
Logistics
ProjectLifeCycle
BudgetEvaluation
EconomicAnalysis
PortfolioManagement
Technological
Procedures
StrategicPlanning
O&M Strategy
EconomicModels
LogisticModels
InfrastructureSelection
ProjectStageEvaluation
UncertaintiesModeling
O&M Strategy
EconomicModels
LogisticModels
InfrastructureSelection
ProjectStageEvaluation
UncertaintiesModeling
AnemorphosisResearchGroupAnemorphosisResearchGroup
Figure 9. Project Life-Cycle Innovations
The outcomes of these three individual yet interconnected
stages, should provide the required inputs to the proposed
improvements strategies and tools for the entire supply chain
life-cycle. The proposed research activities include a series
of improvements in the design and installation procedures to
the associated O&M infrastructure and methodologies, and
supply chain progress in terms of inventory management and
procurement excellence. Finally the O&M strategies improve-
ments in terms of cost-effective development tactics to ensure
the maximum reliability and availability of the offshore wind
energy plants are also presented (Figure 10).
4.1 Research Methodology
Apart from the related costs mitigation, this project methodol-
ogy looks at the new ways to plan and design offshore wind
projects, transport components and equipment, manage and
organise port terminal assets more efficiently, adapt fixed and
floating turbine foundations to facilitate and accelerate in-
stallation and consider new technologies for the O&M and
portfolio management. But how Lean principles could be
used to achieve this optimistic scenario?
Lean attacks waste mainly by shortening the time between
the components manufacturing process and transportation to
the installation site. However, lean is not just implementation
of a set of tools; it is a synergistic system that requires think-
ing and thorough understanding of the industry. To evaluate
the proposed benefits of Lean a survey based on eleven in-
terviews with companies and organizations operating in the
wind industry has been conducted.
The companies represent different parts of the wind power
value chain, from W.T manufacturers and suppliers to Logistic
and O&M providers. All sizes of the wind power businesses
were represented in a balanced manner to assess whether the
size and type of firm would have an impact on the investi-
gation results. In addition, a questionnaire-survey has been
0% 40% 50%10% 20% 30%
<249millioneuro
250-500millioneuro
<2billioneuro
Figure 11. Annual Sales of Survey Respondents
conducted with wind power research scientists from European
academic institutions. Both, the interviews and the survey re-
sults reflect factors such as the diversity of wind power supply
chain which in other word means that different approaches
and methodologies applied.
OffshoreWindProjectEvaluation
LeanPrinciplesImplementation
Figure 12. Interviewed Companies’ Position
Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles — 7/8
DesignandInstallation
Improvements
Planning
Construction
Development
Decommissioning
RepoweringRepowering
O&M Tools
andServices
Improvements
NewVessels
Helicopters
Cranes
HybridVesselsHybridVessels
SupportStructures
SupplyChain
Improvements
ProcurementExcellence
SetPerformance
Standards
IdentifyBottlenecks
LogisticsandInventoryLogisticsandInventory
Management
Configurationand
ChangeControl
O&M Strategies
Inprovements
ConditionMonitoring
Opportunistic
Maintenance
BoPManagement
AssetsIntegrityAssetsIntegrity
ResponseTime
RootCauseAnalysis
IntegratedLogistics
InfluenceonDesign
Manpowerand
Personnel
TransportLinks
SupplyChain
WarehousingWarehousing
Management
StrategicSourcing
Warehousingmanagement
ResearchResults
Acceptance
Testing
Validation
Implementation
IntegrationIntegration
Anemorphosis
ResearchGroup
MarketIntelligenceEvaluation
EconomicEvaluation
JobsCreation
CoEMitigation
AssociatedRisksAssessment
SupplyChainStandardization
LeanSixSigmaImprovementsLeanSixSigmaImprovements
ProcurementExcellence
ProposedStrategiesCommercialization
...
ResultsIntegration
Figure 10. CoE Mitigation for the Offshore Wind Energy Industry
5. Defining the Lean Supply Chain
Survey Questions
The Survey Questionnaire was designed to evaluate the ex-
isting offshore wind power investments planning processes
and to improve the synchronization and standardization of a
global supply chain framework. The related questions cover
the supply management principles and methods, IT integra-
tion, O&M strategies and production planning methodologies.
1. Would large firms differ significantly from smaller firms?
2. Would some industries be farther along in the Lean
journey than others?
3. Efficient or Effective Supply Chain?
4. What are the areas of overlap between Lean manufac-
turing and supply chain management?
5. How should manufacturing and supply chain profes-
sionals should respond to the challenge?
6. On what do they focus for an efficient Lean Supply
chain?
7. In which areas can firms partner with their suppliers
and customers, and what is the best way to approach a
shared Lean strategy?
8. What makes a Lean supply chain different from any
other supply chain?
9. How can a company deal with the scope of a global
marketplace and its supply chain, while retaining speed
and flexibility?
10. How can we eliminate wasted time, effort and materials
from all points in the supply chain?
11. How can a company meet the needs of a global mar-
ketplace without creating excessive work in process or
inventory held along the way?
Acknowledgments
References
[1] William A. Levinson. Lean management system
lms:2012: A framework for continual lean improvement.
Business and Economics, 2012.
[2] Glen Dennis Lucas Simmons, Robbie Holt. Lean imple-
mentation in a low volume manufacturing environment.
Industrial Engineering Research Conference, 2010.
DRAFT DOCUMENT
Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles — 8/8
Wouldlargefirmsdiffersignificantlyfrom smallerfirms?
WouldsomeindustriesbefartheralongintheLean
imolementationthanothers?
EffficientorFlexibleSupplyChain?
WhataretheareasofoverlapbetweenLeanmanufacturingand
supplychainmanagement
Howshouldmanufacturingandsupplychainprofessionals
respondtothechallenge?
OnwhatdotheyfocusforanefficientLeanSupplychain?
WhatisthebestwaytoapproachasharedLeanstrategy?
WhatmakesaLeansupplychaindifferent?
Howcanweeliminatewastedtime,effortandmaterials?
AreyoufamniliarwiththeLeanPrinciplesinWindPowerI?
HowImportantistheInventorymanagement?
SupplyChainorLeanSupplyChain?
Noclearresponse
Clearresponse
Figure 14. Survey Response
Figure 13. Lean Supply Chain Attributes
[3] Ana Sakura Zainal Abidin Rasli Muslimen, Sha’ri
Mohd Yusof. Lean manufacturing implementation in
malaysian automotive components manufacturer. World
Congress on Engineering, 1, 2011.
[4] Lars Stehn. Applicability of lean principles and prac-
tices in industrialized housing production manufacturer.
Construction Management and Economics, 26, 2008.
[5] LEANWIND. Logistic efficiencies and naval architecture
for wind installations with novel developments. Construc-
tion Management and Economics, 2013.
[6] Global Wind Energy Council. Global wind energy out-
look — 2014. http://www.gwec.net, 2014.
[7] EWEA. The european offshore wind industry—key
trends and statistics 2013. Technical Report, 2014.
[8] LORC. Offshore installed capaicity trends. Technical
Report, 2015.
[9] Justin Wilkes Iv´an Pineda. Wind in power 2014 european
statistic. Technical Report, 2014.
[10] Statista. Rotor diameter size of wind en-
ergy turbines from 1990 to 2015 (in meters)*.
http://www.statista.com/statistics/263901/changes-in-
the-size-of-wind-turbines/, 2015.
[11] European Environment Agency. Europe’s onshore and
offshore wind energy potential—an assessment of envi-
ronmental and economic constraints. Technical Report 6,
2009.
[12] Isidro Durazo-Cardenas Patrick McLaughlin. Cellular
manufacturing applications in mro operations. 2nd Inter-
national Through-life Engineering Services Conference,
11:Pages: 254–259, 2013.

More Related Content

What's hot

Market Briefing. USA. 28th January
Market Briefing. USA. 28th JanuaryMarket Briefing. USA. 28th January
Market Briefing. USA. 28th JanuaryUKTI2014
 
Industrial RCx Smith_Hawksley.doc
Industrial RCx Smith_Hawksley.docIndustrial RCx Smith_Hawksley.doc
Industrial RCx Smith_Hawksley.docRay Hawksley
 
International standardisation in_the_field_of_renewable_energy
International standardisation  in_the_field_of_renewable_energyInternational standardisation  in_the_field_of_renewable_energy
International standardisation in_the_field_of_renewable_energyfboshell
 
Cost effective Battery Factories
Cost effective Battery Factories  Cost effective Battery Factories
Cost effective Battery Factories M+W Group
 
Webinar: The Global Status of CCS: 2014 - Overcoming challenges in Europe
Webinar: The Global Status of CCS: 2014 - Overcoming challenges in EuropeWebinar: The Global Status of CCS: 2014 - Overcoming challenges in Europe
Webinar: The Global Status of CCS: 2014 - Overcoming challenges in EuropeGlobal CCS Institute
 
Accelerating the Benefits of Food and Bev Sustainability Programs
Accelerating the Benefits of Food and Bev Sustainability ProgramsAccelerating the Benefits of Food and Bev Sustainability Programs
Accelerating the Benefits of Food and Bev Sustainability ProgramsSchneider Electric
 
Webinar: Global Status of CCS: 2014 - Powering ahead in The Americas
Webinar: Global Status of CCS: 2014 - Powering ahead in The AmericasWebinar: Global Status of CCS: 2014 - Powering ahead in The Americas
Webinar: Global Status of CCS: 2014 - Powering ahead in The AmericasGlobal CCS Institute
 
UK AD Biogas 2016: Day One Purple Seminar - 6 July
UK AD Biogas 2016: Day One Purple Seminar - 6 July UK AD Biogas 2016: Day One Purple Seminar - 6 July
UK AD Biogas 2016: Day One Purple Seminar - 6 July UKADBiogas
 
Shock and Ore CIBSE TM56 supplement
Shock and Ore CIBSE TM56 supplementShock and Ore CIBSE TM56 supplement
Shock and Ore CIBSE TM56 supplementDave Cheshire
 
Primavera_large energy program case study
Primavera_large energy program case studyPrimavera_large energy program case study
Primavera_large energy program case studyCameron
 
ScottMadden's Energy Industry Update for the 2019 Utility Supply Chain Confer...
ScottMadden's Energy Industry Update for the 2019 Utility Supply Chain Confer...ScottMadden's Energy Industry Update for the 2019 Utility Supply Chain Confer...
ScottMadden's Energy Industry Update for the 2019 Utility Supply Chain Confer...ScottMadden, Inc.
 
Shell chemicalsseraya
Shell chemicalsserayaShell chemicalsseraya
Shell chemicalsserayaCameron
 
CMS’s Impact – Driven Collaboration Model Addressing Industrial GHGs, Richard...
CMS’s Impact – Driven Collaboration Model Addressing Industrial GHGs, Richard...CMS’s Impact – Driven Collaboration Model Addressing Industrial GHGs, Richard...
CMS’s Impact – Driven Collaboration Model Addressing Industrial GHGs, Richard...UK Carbon Capture and Storage Research Centre
 
01 17-12 itp tools training and other resources -pump-fan-motor focus panel
01 17-12  itp tools training and other resources -pump-fan-motor focus panel01 17-12  itp tools training and other resources -pump-fan-motor focus panel
01 17-12 itp tools training and other resources -pump-fan-motor focus panelPreston Roberts
 
Presentation Fredricton September 2009 general
Presentation Fredricton September 2009 generalPresentation Fredricton September 2009 general
Presentation Fredricton September 2009 generalAngelo Mangatal
 

What's hot (20)

Market Briefing. USA. 28th January
Market Briefing. USA. 28th JanuaryMarket Briefing. USA. 28th January
Market Briefing. USA. 28th January
 
Industrial RCx Smith_Hawksley.doc
Industrial RCx Smith_Hawksley.docIndustrial RCx Smith_Hawksley.doc
Industrial RCx Smith_Hawksley.doc
 
International standardisation in_the_field_of_renewable_energy
International standardisation  in_the_field_of_renewable_energyInternational standardisation  in_the_field_of_renewable_energy
International standardisation in_the_field_of_renewable_energy
 
Cost effective Battery Factories
Cost effective Battery Factories  Cost effective Battery Factories
Cost effective Battery Factories
 
Webinar: The Global Status of CCS: 2014 - Overcoming challenges in Europe
Webinar: The Global Status of CCS: 2014 - Overcoming challenges in EuropeWebinar: The Global Status of CCS: 2014 - Overcoming challenges in Europe
Webinar: The Global Status of CCS: 2014 - Overcoming challenges in Europe
 
Hawaii Utility Integration Efforts
Hawaii Utility Integration EffortsHawaii Utility Integration Efforts
Hawaii Utility Integration Efforts
 
Accelerating the Benefits of Food and Bev Sustainability Programs
Accelerating the Benefits of Food and Bev Sustainability ProgramsAccelerating the Benefits of Food and Bev Sustainability Programs
Accelerating the Benefits of Food and Bev Sustainability Programs
 
Webinar: Global Status of CCS: 2014 - Powering ahead in The Americas
Webinar: Global Status of CCS: 2014 - Powering ahead in The AmericasWebinar: Global Status of CCS: 2014 - Powering ahead in The Americas
Webinar: Global Status of CCS: 2014 - Powering ahead in The Americas
 
UK AD Biogas 2016: Day One Purple Seminar - 6 July
UK AD Biogas 2016: Day One Purple Seminar - 6 July UK AD Biogas 2016: Day One Purple Seminar - 6 July
UK AD Biogas 2016: Day One Purple Seminar - 6 July
 
Shock and Ore CIBSE TM56 supplement
Shock and Ore CIBSE TM56 supplementShock and Ore CIBSE TM56 supplement
Shock and Ore CIBSE TM56 supplement
 
Primavera_large energy program case study
Primavera_large energy program case studyPrimavera_large energy program case study
Primavera_large energy program case study
 
ScottMadden's Energy Industry Update for the 2019 Utility Supply Chain Confer...
ScottMadden's Energy Industry Update for the 2019 Utility Supply Chain Confer...ScottMadden's Energy Industry Update for the 2019 Utility Supply Chain Confer...
ScottMadden's Energy Industry Update for the 2019 Utility Supply Chain Confer...
 
22212 exe summ
22212 exe summ22212 exe summ
22212 exe summ
 
Shell chemicalsseraya
Shell chemicalsserayaShell chemicalsseraya
Shell chemicalsseraya
 
CV-WKD
CV-WKDCV-WKD
CV-WKD
 
CMS’s Impact – Driven Collaboration Model Addressing Industrial GHGs, Richard...
CMS’s Impact – Driven Collaboration Model Addressing Industrial GHGs, Richard...CMS’s Impact – Driven Collaboration Model Addressing Industrial GHGs, Richard...
CMS’s Impact – Driven Collaboration Model Addressing Industrial GHGs, Richard...
 
Energy STEP
Energy STEPEnergy STEP
Energy STEP
 
01 17-12 itp tools training and other resources -pump-fan-motor focus panel
01 17-12  itp tools training and other resources -pump-fan-motor focus panel01 17-12  itp tools training and other resources -pump-fan-motor focus panel
01 17-12 itp tools training and other resources -pump-fan-motor focus panel
 
Scott institute 101
Scott institute 101 Scott institute 101
Scott institute 101
 
Presentation Fredricton September 2009 general
Presentation Fredricton September 2009 generalPresentation Fredricton September 2009 general
Presentation Fredricton September 2009 general
 

Similar to Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles

LEANWIND-EUSEW-2017-06-20FDM 5.pptx
LEANWIND-EUSEW-2017-06-20FDM 5.pptxLEANWIND-EUSEW-2017-06-20FDM 5.pptx
LEANWIND-EUSEW-2017-06-20FDM 5.pptxachanana
 
The ORE Catapult and Future Opportunities,David Arnold,Technology strategy Board
The ORE Catapult and Future Opportunities,David Arnold,Technology strategy BoardThe ORE Catapult and Future Opportunities,David Arnold,Technology strategy Board
The ORE Catapult and Future Opportunities,David Arnold,Technology strategy BoardInvest Northern Ireland
 
2015-12 -- State of Green Economy Report 2016_ENGIE LABS_Amit Pathare_Acceler...
2015-12 -- State of Green Economy Report 2016_ENGIE LABS_Amit Pathare_Acceler...2015-12 -- State of Green Economy Report 2016_ENGIE LABS_Amit Pathare_Acceler...
2015-12 -- State of Green Economy Report 2016_ENGIE LABS_Amit Pathare_Acceler...Amit Pathare
 
Rel maint-final
Rel maint-finalRel maint-final
Rel maint-finalamar sadi
 
Bridging The Gap Between Innovation And Commercialization
Bridging The Gap Between Innovation And CommercializationBridging The Gap Between Innovation And Commercialization
Bridging The Gap Between Innovation And CommercializationNAES Corporation
 
Show & Tell - Data & Digitalisation, Weather & Predictive Analytics.pdf
Show & Tell - Data & Digitalisation, Weather & Predictive Analytics.pdfShow & Tell - Data & Digitalisation, Weather & Predictive Analytics.pdf
Show & Tell - Data & Digitalisation, Weather & Predictive Analytics.pdfSIFOfgem
 
IRJET- Study on Economic Sustainability of Industrial Buildings
IRJET-  	  Study on Economic Sustainability of Industrial BuildingsIRJET-  	  Study on Economic Sustainability of Industrial Buildings
IRJET- Study on Economic Sustainability of Industrial BuildingsIRJET Journal
 
SEAI Energy Show 2022 - Leveraging research to decarbonise the industrial and...
SEAI Energy Show 2022 - Leveraging research to decarbonise the industrial and...SEAI Energy Show 2022 - Leveraging research to decarbonise the industrial and...
SEAI Energy Show 2022 - Leveraging research to decarbonise the industrial and...SustainableEnergyAut
 
Doug Mader Us Eng Overview Public
Doug Mader Us Eng Overview  PublicDoug Mader Us Eng Overview  Public
Doug Mader Us Eng Overview Publicdmader
 
Contractor Track: Need for Speed - Project Acceleration, Tech Trends, Logisti...
Contractor Track: Need for Speed - Project Acceleration, Tech Trends, Logisti...Contractor Track: Need for Speed - Project Acceleration, Tech Trends, Logisti...
Contractor Track: Need for Speed - Project Acceleration, Tech Trends, Logisti...Energy Construction Forum
 
Overview of Variable Renewable Energy Regulatory Issues
Overview of Variable Renewable Energy Regulatory IssuesOverview of Variable Renewable Energy Regulatory Issues
Overview of Variable Renewable Energy Regulatory IssuesLeonardo ENERGY
 
Portsmouth University Presentation
Portsmouth University PresentationPortsmouth University Presentation
Portsmouth University PresentationStavros Thomas
 
IRJET- Application of Decision Making Tool in Sustainable Construction
IRJET- Application of Decision Making Tool in Sustainable ConstructionIRJET- Application of Decision Making Tool in Sustainable Construction
IRJET- Application of Decision Making Tool in Sustainable ConstructionIRJET Journal
 
Us er-electric-storage-paper
Us er-electric-storage-paperUs er-electric-storage-paper
Us er-electric-storage-paperSourav Bhunia
 
DISCUSSION ON THE WORKPROGRAMME OF ANNEX XVI
DISCUSSION ON THE WORKPROGRAMME OF ANNEX XVIDISCUSSION ON THE WORKPROGRAMME OF ANNEX XVI
DISCUSSION ON THE WORKPROGRAMME OF ANNEX XVIIEA-ETSAP
 

Similar to Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles (20)

LEANWIND-EUSEW-2017-06-20FDM 5.pptx
LEANWIND-EUSEW-2017-06-20FDM 5.pptxLEANWIND-EUSEW-2017-06-20FDM 5.pptx
LEANWIND-EUSEW-2017-06-20FDM 5.pptx
 
Society of Petroleum Engineers : Model Based Engineering
Society of Petroleum Engineers : Model Based EngineeringSociety of Petroleum Engineers : Model Based Engineering
Society of Petroleum Engineers : Model Based Engineering
 
The ORE Catapult and Future Opportunities,David Arnold,Technology strategy Board
The ORE Catapult and Future Opportunities,David Arnold,Technology strategy BoardThe ORE Catapult and Future Opportunities,David Arnold,Technology strategy Board
The ORE Catapult and Future Opportunities,David Arnold,Technology strategy Board
 
2015-12 -- State of Green Economy Report 2016_ENGIE LABS_Amit Pathare_Acceler...
2015-12 -- State of Green Economy Report 2016_ENGIE LABS_Amit Pathare_Acceler...2015-12 -- State of Green Economy Report 2016_ENGIE LABS_Amit Pathare_Acceler...
2015-12 -- State of Green Economy Report 2016_ENGIE LABS_Amit Pathare_Acceler...
 
Rel maint-final
Rel maint-finalRel maint-final
Rel maint-final
 
Solwatt Energy Performance Contract
Solwatt Energy Performance ContractSolwatt Energy Performance Contract
Solwatt Energy Performance Contract
 
Solwatt Energy Performance Contract
Solwatt Energy Performance ContractSolwatt Energy Performance Contract
Solwatt Energy Performance Contract
 
Bridging The Gap Between Innovation And Commercialization
Bridging The Gap Between Innovation And CommercializationBridging The Gap Between Innovation And Commercialization
Bridging The Gap Between Innovation And Commercialization
 
Show & Tell - Data & Digitalisation, Weather & Predictive Analytics.pdf
Show & Tell - Data & Digitalisation, Weather & Predictive Analytics.pdfShow & Tell - Data & Digitalisation, Weather & Predictive Analytics.pdf
Show & Tell - Data & Digitalisation, Weather & Predictive Analytics.pdf
 
IRJET- Study on Economic Sustainability of Industrial Buildings
IRJET-  	  Study on Economic Sustainability of Industrial BuildingsIRJET-  	  Study on Economic Sustainability of Industrial Buildings
IRJET- Study on Economic Sustainability of Industrial Buildings
 
Importance of O&M
Importance of O&MImportance of O&M
Importance of O&M
 
bca
bcabca
bca
 
SEAI Energy Show 2022 - Leveraging research to decarbonise the industrial and...
SEAI Energy Show 2022 - Leveraging research to decarbonise the industrial and...SEAI Energy Show 2022 - Leveraging research to decarbonise the industrial and...
SEAI Energy Show 2022 - Leveraging research to decarbonise the industrial and...
 
Doug Mader Us Eng Overview Public
Doug Mader Us Eng Overview  PublicDoug Mader Us Eng Overview  Public
Doug Mader Us Eng Overview Public
 
Contractor Track: Need for Speed - Project Acceleration, Tech Trends, Logisti...
Contractor Track: Need for Speed - Project Acceleration, Tech Trends, Logisti...Contractor Track: Need for Speed - Project Acceleration, Tech Trends, Logisti...
Contractor Track: Need for Speed - Project Acceleration, Tech Trends, Logisti...
 
Overview of Variable Renewable Energy Regulatory Issues
Overview of Variable Renewable Energy Regulatory IssuesOverview of Variable Renewable Energy Regulatory Issues
Overview of Variable Renewable Energy Regulatory Issues
 
Portsmouth University Presentation
Portsmouth University PresentationPortsmouth University Presentation
Portsmouth University Presentation
 
IRJET- Application of Decision Making Tool in Sustainable Construction
IRJET- Application of Decision Making Tool in Sustainable ConstructionIRJET- Application of Decision Making Tool in Sustainable Construction
IRJET- Application of Decision Making Tool in Sustainable Construction
 
Us er-electric-storage-paper
Us er-electric-storage-paperUs er-electric-storage-paper
Us er-electric-storage-paper
 
DISCUSSION ON THE WORKPROGRAMME OF ANNEX XVI
DISCUSSION ON THE WORKPROGRAMME OF ANNEX XVIDISCUSSION ON THE WORKPROGRAMME OF ANNEX XVI
DISCUSSION ON THE WORKPROGRAMME OF ANNEX XVI
 

More from Stavros Thomas

Passive House Constructions in Crete-Greece.pdf
Passive House Constructions in Crete-Greece.pdfPassive House Constructions in Crete-Greece.pdf
Passive House Constructions in Crete-Greece.pdfStavros Thomas
 
Passive-House-Constructions-in-Crete-Greece.pdf
Passive-House-Constructions-in-Crete-Greece.pdfPassive-House-Constructions-in-Crete-Greece.pdf
Passive-House-Constructions-in-Crete-Greece.pdfStavros Thomas
 
Wind Energy and COVID-19. Effects and Possible Impacts on the Wind Power Indu...
Wind Energy and COVID-19. Effects and Possible Impacts on the Wind Power Indu...Wind Energy and COVID-19. Effects and Possible Impacts on the Wind Power Indu...
Wind Energy and COVID-19. Effects and Possible Impacts on the Wind Power Indu...Stavros Thomas
 
Zero-subsidy Onshore Wind Energy Projects
Zero-subsidy Onshore Wind Energy ProjectsZero-subsidy Onshore Wind Energy Projects
Zero-subsidy Onshore Wind Energy ProjectsStavros Thomas
 
Knowledge sharing and continious improvement strategies for the offshore wind...
Knowledge sharing and continious improvement strategies for the offshore wind...Knowledge sharing and continious improvement strategies for the offshore wind...
Knowledge sharing and continious improvement strategies for the offshore wind...Stavros Thomas
 
Copywriting Infographic
Copywriting InfographicCopywriting Infographic
Copywriting InfographicStavros Thomas
 
Improve Social Acceptability of Wind Power Investments (with Sensitive Design...
Improve Social Acceptability of Wind Power Investments (with Sensitive Design...Improve Social Acceptability of Wind Power Investments (with Sensitive Design...
Improve Social Acceptability of Wind Power Investments (with Sensitive Design...Stavros Thomas
 
Intcompas Strategic Plan Guide
Intcompas Strategic Plan GuideIntcompas Strategic Plan Guide
Intcompas Strategic Plan GuideStavros Thomas
 
Wind Power Regulatory Framework Survey 2016
Wind Power Regulatory Framework  Survey 2016Wind Power Regulatory Framework  Survey 2016
Wind Power Regulatory Framework Survey 2016Stavros Thomas
 
Value Engineering. Measuring and managing risks in the wind energy industry
Value Engineering. Measuring and managing risks in the wind energy industryValue Engineering. Measuring and managing risks in the wind energy industry
Value Engineering. Measuring and managing risks in the wind energy industryStavros Thomas
 

More from Stavros Thomas (15)

Passive House Constructions in Crete-Greece.pdf
Passive House Constructions in Crete-Greece.pdfPassive House Constructions in Crete-Greece.pdf
Passive House Constructions in Crete-Greece.pdf
 
Passive-House-Constructions-in-Crete-Greece.pdf
Passive-House-Constructions-in-Crete-Greece.pdfPassive-House-Constructions-in-Crete-Greece.pdf
Passive-House-Constructions-in-Crete-Greece.pdf
 
Wind Energy and COVID-19. Effects and Possible Impacts on the Wind Power Indu...
Wind Energy and COVID-19. Effects and Possible Impacts on the Wind Power Indu...Wind Energy and COVID-19. Effects and Possible Impacts on the Wind Power Indu...
Wind Energy and COVID-19. Effects and Possible Impacts on the Wind Power Indu...
 
Zero-subsidy Onshore Wind Energy Projects
Zero-subsidy Onshore Wind Energy ProjectsZero-subsidy Onshore Wind Energy Projects
Zero-subsidy Onshore Wind Energy Projects
 
Knowledge sharing and continious improvement strategies for the offshore wind...
Knowledge sharing and continious improvement strategies for the offshore wind...Knowledge sharing and continious improvement strategies for the offshore wind...
Knowledge sharing and continious improvement strategies for the offshore wind...
 
Copywriting Infographic
Copywriting InfographicCopywriting Infographic
Copywriting Infographic
 
Improve Social Acceptability of Wind Power Investments (with Sensitive Design...
Improve Social Acceptability of Wind Power Investments (with Sensitive Design...Improve Social Acceptability of Wind Power Investments (with Sensitive Design...
Improve Social Acceptability of Wind Power Investments (with Sensitive Design...
 
Intcompas Strategic Plan Guide
Intcompas Strategic Plan GuideIntcompas Strategic Plan Guide
Intcompas Strategic Plan Guide
 
Guest intelligence
Guest intelligenceGuest intelligence
Guest intelligence
 
Wind Power Regulatory Framework Survey 2016
Wind Power Regulatory Framework  Survey 2016Wind Power Regulatory Framework  Survey 2016
Wind Power Regulatory Framework Survey 2016
 
Value Engineering. Measuring and managing risks in the wind energy industry
Value Engineering. Measuring and managing risks in the wind energy industryValue Engineering. Measuring and managing risks in the wind energy industry
Value Engineering. Measuring and managing risks in the wind energy industry
 
d
dd
d
 
Status of Wind
Status of WindStatus of Wind
Status of Wind
 
IPR and Wind
IPR and WindIPR and Wind
IPR and Wind
 
Practises in R and D
Practises in R and DPractises in R and D
Practises in R and D
 

Recently uploaded

Unit7-DC_Motors nkkjnsdkfnfcdfknfdgfggfg
Unit7-DC_Motors nkkjnsdkfnfcdfknfdgfggfgUnit7-DC_Motors nkkjnsdkfnfcdfknfdgfggfg
Unit7-DC_Motors nkkjnsdkfnfcdfknfdgfggfgsaravananr517913
 
UNIT III ANALOG ELECTRONICS (BASIC ELECTRONICS)
UNIT III ANALOG ELECTRONICS (BASIC ELECTRONICS)UNIT III ANALOG ELECTRONICS (BASIC ELECTRONICS)
UNIT III ANALOG ELECTRONICS (BASIC ELECTRONICS)Dr SOUNDIRARAJ N
 
Virtual memory management in Operating System
Virtual memory management in Operating SystemVirtual memory management in Operating System
Virtual memory management in Operating SystemRashmi Bhat
 
System Simulation and Modelling with types and Event Scheduling
System Simulation and Modelling with types and Event SchedulingSystem Simulation and Modelling with types and Event Scheduling
System Simulation and Modelling with types and Event SchedulingBootNeck1
 
Industrial Safety Unit-IV workplace health and safety.ppt
Industrial Safety Unit-IV workplace health and safety.pptIndustrial Safety Unit-IV workplace health and safety.ppt
Industrial Safety Unit-IV workplace health and safety.pptNarmatha D
 
welding defects observed during the welding
welding defects observed during the weldingwelding defects observed during the welding
welding defects observed during the weldingMuhammadUzairLiaqat
 
Crystal Structure analysis and detailed information pptx
Crystal Structure analysis and detailed information pptxCrystal Structure analysis and detailed information pptx
Crystal Structure analysis and detailed information pptxachiever3003
 
THE SENDAI FRAMEWORK FOR DISASTER RISK REDUCTION
THE SENDAI FRAMEWORK FOR DISASTER RISK REDUCTIONTHE SENDAI FRAMEWORK FOR DISASTER RISK REDUCTION
THE SENDAI FRAMEWORK FOR DISASTER RISK REDUCTIONjhunlian
 
11. Properties of Liquid Fuels in Energy Engineering.pdf
11. Properties of Liquid Fuels in Energy Engineering.pdf11. Properties of Liquid Fuels in Energy Engineering.pdf
11. Properties of Liquid Fuels in Energy Engineering.pdfHafizMudaserAhmad
 
CCS355 Neural Networks & Deep Learning Unit 1 PDF notes with Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Networks & Deep Learning Unit 1 PDF notes with Question bank .pdfCCS355 Neural Networks & Deep Learning Unit 1 PDF notes with Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Networks & Deep Learning Unit 1 PDF notes with Question bank .pdfAsst.prof M.Gokilavani
 
Research Methodology for Engineering pdf
Research Methodology for Engineering pdfResearch Methodology for Engineering pdf
Research Methodology for Engineering pdfCaalaaAbdulkerim
 
Internet of things -Arshdeep Bahga .pptx
Internet of things -Arshdeep Bahga .pptxInternet of things -Arshdeep Bahga .pptx
Internet of things -Arshdeep Bahga .pptxVelmuruganTECE
 
Earthing details of Electrical Substation
Earthing details of Electrical SubstationEarthing details of Electrical Substation
Earthing details of Electrical Substationstephanwindworld
 
Class 1 | NFPA 72 | Overview Fire Alarm System
Class 1 | NFPA 72 | Overview Fire Alarm SystemClass 1 | NFPA 72 | Overview Fire Alarm System
Class 1 | NFPA 72 | Overview Fire Alarm Systemirfanmechengr
 
IVE Industry Focused Event - Defence Sector 2024
IVE Industry Focused Event - Defence Sector 2024IVE Industry Focused Event - Defence Sector 2024
IVE Industry Focused Event - Defence Sector 2024Mark Billinghurst
 
Mine Environment II Lab_MI10448MI__________.pptx
Mine Environment II Lab_MI10448MI__________.pptxMine Environment II Lab_MI10448MI__________.pptx
Mine Environment II Lab_MI10448MI__________.pptxRomil Mishra
 
DM Pillar Training Manual.ppt will be useful in deploying TPM in project
DM Pillar Training Manual.ppt will be useful in deploying TPM in projectDM Pillar Training Manual.ppt will be useful in deploying TPM in project
DM Pillar Training Manual.ppt will be useful in deploying TPM in projectssuserb6619e
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Design and analysis of solar grass cutter.pdf
Design and analysis of solar grass cutter.pdfDesign and analysis of solar grass cutter.pdf
Design and analysis of solar grass cutter.pdf
 
Unit7-DC_Motors nkkjnsdkfnfcdfknfdgfggfg
Unit7-DC_Motors nkkjnsdkfnfcdfknfdgfggfgUnit7-DC_Motors nkkjnsdkfnfcdfknfdgfggfg
Unit7-DC_Motors nkkjnsdkfnfcdfknfdgfggfg
 
UNIT III ANALOG ELECTRONICS (BASIC ELECTRONICS)
UNIT III ANALOG ELECTRONICS (BASIC ELECTRONICS)UNIT III ANALOG ELECTRONICS (BASIC ELECTRONICS)
UNIT III ANALOG ELECTRONICS (BASIC ELECTRONICS)
 
Virtual memory management in Operating System
Virtual memory management in Operating SystemVirtual memory management in Operating System
Virtual memory management in Operating System
 
System Simulation and Modelling with types and Event Scheduling
System Simulation and Modelling with types and Event SchedulingSystem Simulation and Modelling with types and Event Scheduling
System Simulation and Modelling with types and Event Scheduling
 
Industrial Safety Unit-IV workplace health and safety.ppt
Industrial Safety Unit-IV workplace health and safety.pptIndustrial Safety Unit-IV workplace health and safety.ppt
Industrial Safety Unit-IV workplace health and safety.ppt
 
welding defects observed during the welding
welding defects observed during the weldingwelding defects observed during the welding
welding defects observed during the welding
 
Crystal Structure analysis and detailed information pptx
Crystal Structure analysis and detailed information pptxCrystal Structure analysis and detailed information pptx
Crystal Structure analysis and detailed information pptx
 
Designing pile caps according to ACI 318-19.pptx
Designing pile caps according to ACI 318-19.pptxDesigning pile caps according to ACI 318-19.pptx
Designing pile caps according to ACI 318-19.pptx
 
THE SENDAI FRAMEWORK FOR DISASTER RISK REDUCTION
THE SENDAI FRAMEWORK FOR DISASTER RISK REDUCTIONTHE SENDAI FRAMEWORK FOR DISASTER RISK REDUCTION
THE SENDAI FRAMEWORK FOR DISASTER RISK REDUCTION
 
11. Properties of Liquid Fuels in Energy Engineering.pdf
11. Properties of Liquid Fuels in Energy Engineering.pdf11. Properties of Liquid Fuels in Energy Engineering.pdf
11. Properties of Liquid Fuels in Energy Engineering.pdf
 
CCS355 Neural Networks & Deep Learning Unit 1 PDF notes with Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Networks & Deep Learning Unit 1 PDF notes with Question bank .pdfCCS355 Neural Networks & Deep Learning Unit 1 PDF notes with Question bank .pdf
CCS355 Neural Networks & Deep Learning Unit 1 PDF notes with Question bank .pdf
 
young call girls in Green Park🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
young call girls in Green Park🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Serviceyoung call girls in Green Park🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
young call girls in Green Park🔝 9953056974 🔝 escort Service
 
Research Methodology for Engineering pdf
Research Methodology for Engineering pdfResearch Methodology for Engineering pdf
Research Methodology for Engineering pdf
 
Internet of things -Arshdeep Bahga .pptx
Internet of things -Arshdeep Bahga .pptxInternet of things -Arshdeep Bahga .pptx
Internet of things -Arshdeep Bahga .pptx
 
Earthing details of Electrical Substation
Earthing details of Electrical SubstationEarthing details of Electrical Substation
Earthing details of Electrical Substation
 
Class 1 | NFPA 72 | Overview Fire Alarm System
Class 1 | NFPA 72 | Overview Fire Alarm SystemClass 1 | NFPA 72 | Overview Fire Alarm System
Class 1 | NFPA 72 | Overview Fire Alarm System
 
IVE Industry Focused Event - Defence Sector 2024
IVE Industry Focused Event - Defence Sector 2024IVE Industry Focused Event - Defence Sector 2024
IVE Industry Focused Event - Defence Sector 2024
 
Mine Environment II Lab_MI10448MI__________.pptx
Mine Environment II Lab_MI10448MI__________.pptxMine Environment II Lab_MI10448MI__________.pptx
Mine Environment II Lab_MI10448MI__________.pptx
 
DM Pillar Training Manual.ppt will be useful in deploying TPM in project
DM Pillar Training Manual.ppt will be useful in deploying TPM in projectDM Pillar Training Manual.ppt will be useful in deploying TPM in project
DM Pillar Training Manual.ppt will be useful in deploying TPM in project
 

Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles

  • 1. Journal, Vol. XXI, No. 1, 1-5, 2015 Submitted to Proceedings of the Directorate-General for Energy of the European Commission Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles Stavros Philippou Thomas1*, Iberdrola Renovables2 Abstract This project scopes to investigate, analyze and implement lean technologies and methods to improve project development efficiency and provide cost reductions in offshore wind energy investments. Logically all products and services in the wind power industry involve a supply chain structure. Some of these upstream entities and activities located inside this multi-directional framework are completely independent-autonomous of one another while some are interrelated. This process through manufacturing, distribution, installation and operation creates waste in terms of process time, cost and quality of service. Lean principles-when implemented-work together to identify, mitigate or even eliminate the waste produced during the life-cycle of a wind power project and simplify the processes with the highest value and quality. Through a complete lifecycle analysis and under the plethora of the integrated supply chain processes, this project focuses on developing innovative solutions and procedures to optimise offshore wind plants installation, operation and maintenance (O&M) as well as decommissioning-repowering. Finally a set of tools and methodologies to remove supply chain bottlenecks, address the associated transport, logistics and equipment challenges and improve project management are also presented. It has been shown that the wastes such as inventory costs and defects have been reduced which improves the overall project feasibility. Keywords offshore wind — supply chain — lean management — portfolio management — project development *Corresponding author: stavros.thomas@anemorphosis.com Contents Introduction 1 1 Market Trends in Offshore Development 2 1.1 Distance to Shore . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 1.2 Installed Capacity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 1.3 Offshore Development and Cost . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 2 Industry Structure and Supply Chain 4 3 Lean and Wind Energy 5 4 Project Life-Cycle and Lean Implementation 5 4.1 Research Methodology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 5 Defining the Lean Supply Chain Survey Questions 7 Acknowledgments 7 References 7 Introduction Wind energy industry is one of the fastest growing segments of the world economy and has a mandate to continue growing for the next decades. The wind energy market is expected to increase further following the technology innovations and cost of energy reduction in terms of supply chain, operation and maintenance strategies, siting methodologies, weather prognostic models and project management. With the enormous growth in offshore wind energy instal- lations, there will be hundreds of billions spent worldwide not only to develop and improve the massive wind energy turbines and their associated ancillary infrastructure but also to transfer, operate and maintain these sophisticated systems deployed in shallow-water environments around the world. The selection of sites for offshore wind farms in deeper waters, further from shore, with high wind energy potential, extreme weather and complicated seabed conditions, has contributed to dramatically driving up the costs faster than the develop- ment of new technology has been able to bring the costs down. Strong offshore winds(gusts of perhaps 25mph/40kph+), long wave periods and other meteorological phenomena such as sea ice, icing, hurricanes, and lightning make the use of more robust and reliable wind turbines necessary. The major challenge for offshore wind is to continue to bring down the cost faster without compromising plant reliabil- ity, performance, safety or quality. New technologies and tech- niques have enormously contributed to mitigate the related costs of the industry. Tools and techniques including, cellular
  • 2. Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles — 2/8 manufacturing, condition monitoring, productive-predictive maintenance and six sigma have been recently adopted from several companies in a multi-directional effort to mitigate the CoE [1]. The pace of technological advancement and innovations in this sector is far too rapid for even a cursory review of the technology in this article. Perhaps the biggest hurdle to overcome, before deploying offshore wind technologies, is the supply chain responsiveness and efficiency including the relatively high cost of energy, the mitigation of environmen- tal impacts-especially for plants located in environmentally protected areas-NATURA 2000, the technical challenges of project installation, the maintenance procedures and grid in- terconnection. Broadly speaking, process improvement is the system- atic, continuous and methodical approach to identify, layer and finally eliminate process or system performance gaps for improving the process of delivering service or services. Conducting process improvement is a very effective way to streamline project development procedures and establish re- liability. When it comes to the related set of techniques and methods associated with the improvement ideology, lean prin- ciples can facilitate decision making and increase productivity and business performance. Lean, when properly implemented, allows operators and manufactures to develop and manage projects faster and more efficiently [2]. Many manufacturing companies have imple- mented Lean Management principles in a plethora of ways to suit their needs [3]. Lean principles implementation is recog- nized as a widespread and highly versatile tool, adopted over a wide range of organizations and manufacturing companies. Toyota, Honda, Ford, John Deere, GE, Danaher, Mitsubishi Heavy Industry-Vestas Offshore are just some of them [4]. Lean is a well established manufacturing technique to achieve excellence in the auto-motive manufacturing industry and a very promising methodology for the renewable energy sector and especially for the wind power industry. LEAN- WIND [5], a 31-partner consortium project (Logistic Efficien- cies And Naval architecture for Wind Installations with Novel Developments) has recently been awarded 10 million euro by the European Commission to investigate the lean principles ef- fectiveness and challenges to the offshore wind. The primary LEANWIND project objective is to provide cost reductions across the entire offshore wind plants life-cycle from the de- velopment to the supply chain through the implementation of lean principles. “The LEANWIND approach will ensure that unnecessarily complex or wasteful stages of the development process are removed, flow between the required stages is streamlined, quality is enhanced and thus overall cost and time efficiency improved to enable the industry to bridge the gap between current costs and industry cost aspirations. Properly applied, lean management will improve quality, reliability and H&S standards across the project supply chain and throughout the wind farm lifecycle.” Although other project optimization and portfolio man- agement methods have been established, lean is emerging as a preferred technique to develop new methodologies and practises and not only to provide proposals for improvements in a wind energy project. The design, complexity and scale of an offshore wind energy plant is too complex to be designed through small incremental improvements and experimental methods for the CoE mitigation. The technology used to provide reliable and cost effective products requires thinking outside the box and implement- ing the lessons learned from the past to provide innovative strategies and plans through manufacturing, design, planning, transportation, installation and operation. The supply chain in the wind power industry requires the integration of tech- nological processes and the continuous flow of the industry synergies. The development of an integrated supply chain should be designed to keep inventory investment as low as possible while simultaneously maintaining an adequate sup- ply of products to the construction sites for installation when needed. Not weeks before, or weeks after, but on time. By implementing state-of-the-art lean technologies and tools new wind energy products and equipment could be pro- duced in a cost effective way, the effects of unforeseen risks could be also mitigated or even eliminated while the technical, economic, operational, and schedule feasibility of the project can be significantly improved. 1. Market Trends in Offshore Development The competition in the wind energy industry is a polysynthetic phenomenon due to the fact that a number of traditional sup- pliers to the automotive and oil industry have adapted their services and tools to wind turbines and many Asian compa- nies have taken up production of cheaper versions of various components. The industry has suffered from the global market recession and increased supply chain competition-especially from China and India. However, according to the 2014 Global Wind Energy Outlook Report [6] released by the Greenpeace and the GWEC a coming global bloom in wind power will be driven by China as well as by steady growth in the United States Mexico, Brazil, and South Africa. Also India and the European countries are expected to continue to drive strong growth momentum. The aforementioned report examines three ”energy sce- narios” based on projections used by the International Energy Agency. The ”New Policies” scenario attempts to capture the direction and intentions of international climate policy while other two scenarios—”moderate” and ”advanced”— which reflect two different approaches to increase wind power deployment under stable economic market conditions and policies standardization are also discussed. Figure 2 has been adapted and simplified from the report to prove that all signs point to continued and strong growth in demand for wind
  • 3. Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles — 3/8 Figure 1. Wind Energy Forecast Breakdown energy projects. Figure 2. Global Wind Energy Forecast According to the ‘New Policies’ scenario, in which new policies-regulations are established, economic framework and incentives are optimized, the wind energy sector can represent up to 9% of the global energy mix by 2020, and almost 20% ten years later. Moreover, offshore wind is expected to be the fastest growing segment in the global wind energy market with average annual growth rates of around 30% from 2015-2020. 1.1 Distance to Shore As offshore wind technology advances, wind resources further offshore can be harnessed. Greater distances to shore usually result in deeper waters. Fig. 3 shows that the average water depth has increased throughout the years and it is expected to continue [7]. The first projects registered low distances to shore (¡ 10 km), while over the years, the average distance to shore of the projects has been rapidly increasing. As il- lustrated at Fig. 4 the average distance to shore of projects commissioned between 2013-2015 was between 25-42 km[8]. Currently, the latest Offshore wind energy project located the furthest distance from coast is the Global Tech 1. The wind farm is located about 93 km north-west of the island of Juist on an area of 41 square kilometers in water depths 39-41 meters, a distance circa 56 times higher than the modest 2.25 km of the Vindeby project. Across Europe, approximately 80% of the resource is Figure 3. Advanced Scenario - Wind Energy Forecast located in water depths of greater than 60 meters while ap- proximately 50% of the highest wind energy potential is de- tected further than 100km from shore. It is therefore clear that innovative technologies and methodologies deployment are necessary perimeters to establish wind energy plants further out to sea and in deeper water than other earlier adopters. This is particularly applicable to remote areas on the At- lantic Ocean-particularly in the southeastern part of the ocean- and Mediterranean and Black Sea, where only a very small proportion of the best wind resource lies in water depths where offshore fixed-bottom wind turbine technology facilitate ex- ploitation. As shown in Figure: 4 there is a clear trend for the offshore wind industry to move to deeper waters and further from shore. Thus, a reliable and flexible supply chain frame- work is needed to satisfactory accommodate all the relevant and required developments and accelerate wind turbine manu- facturing, marine contractors, equipment suppliers and port operators processes. Figure 4. Planned Offshore Wind Farms 1.2 Installed Capacity In 1991, the first offshore wind power plant with a total ca- pacity of 4.95 MW installed 2.5 km off the Danish coast, in Vindeby constructed. Twenty four years later, at the end of July 2015 offshore wind capacity reached 8,759 megawatts MW in Europe. Since the beginning of the decade, the share of new offshore capacity in total new wind capacity additions has been increasing. Between 2011 and 2012, the average
  • 4. Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles — 4/8 offshore project size was almost doubled from 116 MW to 289 MW-60 times higher than the offshore installation at Vindeby. Offshore wind installations in 2014 were 5.3% less than in 2013, with 1,483.3 MW of new capacity grid. However, as the demand for cheaper and more sustainable energy grows, even more turbines will be required [9]. CommissionYear Figure 5. Planned Offshore Wind Farms 1.3 Offshore Development and Cost Offshore wind projects total installed costs have risen over time (See Figure: 6) because as the distance increases the complexity of the project increases due to the development, transportation and O&M requirements. The average name- plate capacity has increased, from 2.9 MW in 2007 to 8 MW in 2015 (Vestas V-164) as larger wind turbines reduce installa- tion costs per MW and can also help reduce the related O&M costs because of the systems optimization and significant im- provements in equipment service life. In addition to the latter, larger W.T rotors and higher hub heights, boosting expected capacity factors and thus, facilitate the installed costs miti- gation. In fact, research shows [10] that the average rotor diameter has increased by 86% since 1999. The average rotor diameter ballooned to 164 meters in 2015, up from 71 meters in 2011 and 81.6 meters in 2009. 2015euro/kw Figure 6. Offshore Projects and Costs Despite the continued technological advancements in the offshore wind industry and the considerable technological- tactical progress that the wind energy sector has made in re- cent years, the average project Capital expenditures (CAPEX) have been rising dramatically, resulting in concerns over the economic feasibility of some large and deep-water projects (See Figure: 7). Figure 7. Offshore Wind CAPEX Costs Wind turbines located on deep-water sites with complex seabed characteristics/properties, potentially long-period de- commissioning processes and severe weather conditions may explain the increased capital required in terms of logistics, grid connection and installation [11]. What’s more, the related costs of recent large offshore installations increased due to the higher perceived information asymmetries (wind forecasting, availability, AEP uncertainties, wave and wind condition, etc) and market uncertainties because of the stock-market volatil- ity. Offshore plants located on deep water area also lead to higher Operational and Maintenance (OM) costs which can represent up to 30% of the total project CAPEX [?]. 2. Industry Structure and Supply Chain The rapid pace of offshore-wind energy projects around the world is leading wind turbine manufacturers and O&M ser- vice providers to search qualified, capable and experienced business partners and suppliers to meet customer demands and industry challenges. The relevant costs and risks associated with transportation, logistics and delivery time combined with the supply chain challenges, has created an opportunity for manufacturers and supply chain providers to gain high market share. In less than a decade, gigantic shifts in wind power man- ufacturing competence have created “an integrated supply chain” for manufacturing competitiveness. Asia appears to be a protagon among the world’s most competitive manufactur- ing markets — and its likely to hold this position in the next decades. The development of a strong wind turbine supply chain takes a predictable path once flexible and nimble supply chain strategies for wind farm development are established. In the early stages of a project, Original wind turbine and Equip- ment Manufacturers (OEM) should set up their operations in a location that provides good accessibility standards (distance from shore, port facilities etc) - centralized enough to allow access to multiple wind farm developments - while ensur- ing maximum capacity availability and with a multi-skilled workforce. Tier 1 suppliers, including tower, blades, nacelle assembly
  • 5. Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles — 5/8 (OEM) OriginalEquipment Manufacturers EXISTING COMING SpecializedSupply ChainManagement Figure 8. The Supply Chain Structure Transformation manufacturers and crane components follow, and finally, sub- component suppliers including nacelle components, control systems, metal fabricators, foundation components condition monitoring suppliers, enter the supply chain to support tier 1’s requirements and objectives. However, the wind industry supply chain is rapidly under- going change. Some years ago, the supplier structure to wind turbine manufacturers was almost flat. During the past, the majority of the companies in the supply chain was directly related to the wind turbine manufacturers and regularly they had only one wind turbine manufacturer as a customer. Thus, there were limited interconnections and synergies between sub-suppliers. This has changed and the supply chain system is increas- ingly organised in a more sophisticated tiered supply chain structure [ See Figure: 8]. Nowadays, the supply chain rely heavily on innovation, both in design and manufacturing meth- ods and techniques. Wind power suppliers (tier one), design and develop innovative solutions to achieve greater compo- nent durability, longer service life and improved reliability as well as more cost-efficient processes. Moreover, OEM’s take on responsibility for more than simply providing parts and components and increasingly become supplier of sub-systems and services such as design, assembly and support to provide more value and build more lasting relationships with the wind turbine manufacturers. 3. Lean and Wind Energy Global competition in wind energy techno-innovation and pro- duction is intensifying. Suppliers, tenders, developers manu- facturers and service providers are trying to take advantage of the huge growth potential in this sector while their efforts to improve the related services and procedures - under unstable economic market environments and ever-changing regulation frameworks-provide support for further growth within the wind power industry as a whole. The right mix of project planning, monitoring, and control- ling methodologies, can establish the delivery of high-quality projects on time, on budget and with high quality results. Wind energy projects are no exception. Regardless of the size or complexity, the success of managing an offshore wind power project will most likely depends on the lessons learned from the past and the available tools and methods to heuristi- cally deal with the associated risks, hazards and uncertainties. Although the techniques and tools vary dramatically in scale, they share the potential to remove critical impediments to the effective management of wind power projects. Lean is an excellent manufacturing and administrative technique to achieve excellence in the wind energy products and services. What makes the implementation of Lean princi- ples beneficial is the relentless focus on waste identification- elimination and reduction in operating costs. By significantly improving performance, optimizing ser- vices responsiveness and dramatically reducing manufacturing (including transportation and logistics) time, flexibility and productivity are ensured while defects and variation phenom- ena are mitigated. Especially for an industry like wind energy where capital should be carefully managed and controlled to attract and secure new investments-in economic viable and technical feasible terms-lean tools are critically important. Lean principles could be effectively applied for the entire life-cycle process of an offshore wind energy project. From deployment and installation to the development of novel O&M strategies with the highest safety and quality standards. However, the application of lean principles to the wind power industry is greeted with much scepticism. To a cer- tain degree this is true because industries such as wind - with such as high volume and low variety of products and services, long setup times and uncertainties because of the weather data stochastic nature - are inherently more efficient and present rel- atively less enthusiasm for improvement proposals when the competitors use market intelligence techniques and procure- ment excellence to mitigate the costs and gain even greater share of this lucrative market. This may explain why some managers hesitate to set new performance objectives and standards by implementing lean manufacturing tools and techniques to the traditional depart- ment processes. As a real-life paradigm, it is difficult to apply the cellular manufacturing concept [12] in an offshore wind energy facility due to the fact that wind turbines are gigantic and the ancillary infrastructure not easy to move. Ironically, the wind power industry itself demands new technology, as modern and high intelligence services required to go beyond traditional technology solutions. 4. Project Life-Cycle and Lean Implementation Logically all products and services in the wind power industry involve a supply chain structure. Some of these upstream enti- ties and activities located inside this multi-directional frame- work are completely independent-autonomous of one another
  • 6. Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles — 6/8 while some are interrelated. This process through manufac- turing, distribution, installation and operation creates waste in terms of process time, cost and quality of service. Lean principles-when implemented-work together to identify, miti- gate or even eliminate the waste produced during the life-cycle of a wind power project and simplify the processes with the highest value and quality. This project scope is to investigate how the lean principles can be adapted from the offshore wind and to evaluate their implementation benefits at a specific industrial concern. The research hypothesizes that there are several opportunities for improvement and wastes removal in the offshore wind energy industry if lean tools are used. Thus, to improve and optimize the life cycle processes for an offshore project and drive an ef- fective portfolio management, the principles of lean should be hypothetically implemented at three separate levels: the Oper- ational Tactics, the Strategic Planning and the Technological Innovations (Figure 9). OperationalTactics VesselDesigns, AccessibilityTechno- logiesandMethods, ConditionMonitoring Storm ControlSystems Foundation/Platforms RisksAssessmentRisksAssessment PrognosticMaintenance VesselDesigns, AccessibilityTechno- logiesandMethods, ConditionMonitoring Storm ControlSystems Foundation/Platforms RisksAssessmentRisksAssessment PrognosticMaintenance Transportation Logistics ProjectLifeCycle BudgetEvaluation EconomicAnalysis PortfolioManagement Transportation Logistics ProjectLifeCycle BudgetEvaluation EconomicAnalysis PortfolioManagement Technological Procedures StrategicPlanning O&M Strategy EconomicModels LogisticModels InfrastructureSelection ProjectStageEvaluation UncertaintiesModeling O&M Strategy EconomicModels LogisticModels InfrastructureSelection ProjectStageEvaluation UncertaintiesModeling AnemorphosisResearchGroupAnemorphosisResearchGroup Figure 9. Project Life-Cycle Innovations The outcomes of these three individual yet interconnected stages, should provide the required inputs to the proposed improvements strategies and tools for the entire supply chain life-cycle. The proposed research activities include a series of improvements in the design and installation procedures to the associated O&M infrastructure and methodologies, and supply chain progress in terms of inventory management and procurement excellence. Finally the O&M strategies improve- ments in terms of cost-effective development tactics to ensure the maximum reliability and availability of the offshore wind energy plants are also presented (Figure 10). 4.1 Research Methodology Apart from the related costs mitigation, this project methodol- ogy looks at the new ways to plan and design offshore wind projects, transport components and equipment, manage and organise port terminal assets more efficiently, adapt fixed and floating turbine foundations to facilitate and accelerate in- stallation and consider new technologies for the O&M and portfolio management. But how Lean principles could be used to achieve this optimistic scenario? Lean attacks waste mainly by shortening the time between the components manufacturing process and transportation to the installation site. However, lean is not just implementation of a set of tools; it is a synergistic system that requires think- ing and thorough understanding of the industry. To evaluate the proposed benefits of Lean a survey based on eleven in- terviews with companies and organizations operating in the wind industry has been conducted. The companies represent different parts of the wind power value chain, from W.T manufacturers and suppliers to Logistic and O&M providers. All sizes of the wind power businesses were represented in a balanced manner to assess whether the size and type of firm would have an impact on the investi- gation results. In addition, a questionnaire-survey has been 0% 40% 50%10% 20% 30% <249millioneuro 250-500millioneuro <2billioneuro Figure 11. Annual Sales of Survey Respondents conducted with wind power research scientists from European academic institutions. Both, the interviews and the survey re- sults reflect factors such as the diversity of wind power supply chain which in other word means that different approaches and methodologies applied. OffshoreWindProjectEvaluation LeanPrinciplesImplementation Figure 12. Interviewed Companies’ Position
  • 7. Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles — 7/8 DesignandInstallation Improvements Planning Construction Development Decommissioning RepoweringRepowering O&M Tools andServices Improvements NewVessels Helicopters Cranes HybridVesselsHybridVessels SupportStructures SupplyChain Improvements ProcurementExcellence SetPerformance Standards IdentifyBottlenecks LogisticsandInventoryLogisticsandInventory Management Configurationand ChangeControl O&M Strategies Inprovements ConditionMonitoring Opportunistic Maintenance BoPManagement AssetsIntegrityAssetsIntegrity ResponseTime RootCauseAnalysis IntegratedLogistics InfluenceonDesign Manpowerand Personnel TransportLinks SupplyChain WarehousingWarehousing Management StrategicSourcing Warehousingmanagement ResearchResults Acceptance Testing Validation Implementation IntegrationIntegration Anemorphosis ResearchGroup MarketIntelligenceEvaluation EconomicEvaluation JobsCreation CoEMitigation AssociatedRisksAssessment SupplyChainStandardization LeanSixSigmaImprovementsLeanSixSigmaImprovements ProcurementExcellence ProposedStrategiesCommercialization ... ResultsIntegration Figure 10. CoE Mitigation for the Offshore Wind Energy Industry 5. Defining the Lean Supply Chain Survey Questions The Survey Questionnaire was designed to evaluate the ex- isting offshore wind power investments planning processes and to improve the synchronization and standardization of a global supply chain framework. The related questions cover the supply management principles and methods, IT integra- tion, O&M strategies and production planning methodologies. 1. Would large firms differ significantly from smaller firms? 2. Would some industries be farther along in the Lean journey than others? 3. Efficient or Effective Supply Chain? 4. What are the areas of overlap between Lean manufac- turing and supply chain management? 5. How should manufacturing and supply chain profes- sionals should respond to the challenge? 6. On what do they focus for an efficient Lean Supply chain? 7. In which areas can firms partner with their suppliers and customers, and what is the best way to approach a shared Lean strategy? 8. What makes a Lean supply chain different from any other supply chain? 9. How can a company deal with the scope of a global marketplace and its supply chain, while retaining speed and flexibility? 10. How can we eliminate wasted time, effort and materials from all points in the supply chain? 11. How can a company meet the needs of a global mar- ketplace without creating excessive work in process or inventory held along the way? Acknowledgments References [1] William A. Levinson. Lean management system lms:2012: A framework for continual lean improvement. Business and Economics, 2012. [2] Glen Dennis Lucas Simmons, Robbie Holt. Lean imple- mentation in a low volume manufacturing environment. Industrial Engineering Research Conference, 2010. DRAFT DOCUMENT
  • 8. Offshore Wind Energy: Improving Project Development and Supply Chain Processes With Lean Principles — 8/8 Wouldlargefirmsdiffersignificantlyfrom smallerfirms? WouldsomeindustriesbefartheralongintheLean imolementationthanothers? EffficientorFlexibleSupplyChain? WhataretheareasofoverlapbetweenLeanmanufacturingand supplychainmanagement Howshouldmanufacturingandsupplychainprofessionals respondtothechallenge? OnwhatdotheyfocusforanefficientLeanSupplychain? WhatisthebestwaytoapproachasharedLeanstrategy? WhatmakesaLeansupplychaindifferent? Howcanweeliminatewastedtime,effortandmaterials? AreyoufamniliarwiththeLeanPrinciplesinWindPowerI? HowImportantistheInventorymanagement? SupplyChainorLeanSupplyChain? Noclearresponse Clearresponse Figure 14. Survey Response Figure 13. Lean Supply Chain Attributes [3] Ana Sakura Zainal Abidin Rasli Muslimen, Sha’ri Mohd Yusof. Lean manufacturing implementation in malaysian automotive components manufacturer. World Congress on Engineering, 1, 2011. [4] Lars Stehn. Applicability of lean principles and prac- tices in industrialized housing production manufacturer. Construction Management and Economics, 26, 2008. [5] LEANWIND. Logistic efficiencies and naval architecture for wind installations with novel developments. Construc- tion Management and Economics, 2013. [6] Global Wind Energy Council. Global wind energy out- look — 2014. http://www.gwec.net, 2014. [7] EWEA. The european offshore wind industry—key trends and statistics 2013. Technical Report, 2014. [8] LORC. Offshore installed capaicity trends. Technical Report, 2015. [9] Justin Wilkes Iv´an Pineda. Wind in power 2014 european statistic. Technical Report, 2014. [10] Statista. Rotor diameter size of wind en- ergy turbines from 1990 to 2015 (in meters)*. http://www.statista.com/statistics/263901/changes-in- the-size-of-wind-turbines/, 2015. [11] European Environment Agency. Europe’s onshore and offshore wind energy potential—an assessment of envi- ronmental and economic constraints. Technical Report 6, 2009. [12] Isidro Durazo-Cardenas Patrick McLaughlin. Cellular manufacturing applications in mro operations. 2nd Inter- national Through-life Engineering Services Conference, 11:Pages: 254–259, 2013.