ALIGNING CREATIVE APPROACHES FOR TOURISM EDUCATION
1. ALIGNING CREATIVE
APPROACHES TOWARDS RE-
ENGINEERING OUR TOURISM
EDUCATION AND TRAINING
PROGRAM
IMELDA B. TAGANAS
OIC-Executive Director, Qualifications and
Standards Office,TESDA
2. What is a Qualification?
Package of competencies
describing a particular function or
job role existing in an economic
sector. It covers the work activities
required to undertake a particular
job role.
3. What is the Philippine Qualifications
Framework (PQF)?
It is a national policy, describes the
levels of educational qualifications and
sets the standards for qualification
outcomes.
A quality assured national system for the
development, recognition and award of
qualifications based on standards of
knowledge, skills and values acquired in
different ways and methods by learners
and workers of a certain country
4. It is competency-based.
It is labor market driven.
It is assessment based qualification
recognition.
5. President’s SONA 2011
“… ngayon pa lang, nagtatagpo na ang
kaisipan ng DOLE, CHED, TESDA at
DepEd upang tugunan and isyu ng job
mismatch. Susuriin ang mga curriculum
para maituon sa mga industriyang
naghahanap ng empleyado, at
gagabayan ang mga estudyante sa
pagpili ng mga kursong hitik sa
bakanteng trabaho.”
6. Objectives of the PQF:
To establish national standards and
levels for outcomes of education and
training, skills and competencies
To support the development and
maintenance of pathways and
equivalencies which provide access to
qualifications and assist people to
move easily and readily between the
different E & T sectors and between
these sectors and the labour market
7. Objectives of the PQF
To align the PQF with international
qualifications framework to support
the national and international
mobility of workers thru increased
recognition of the value and
comparability of Philippine
qualifications
8. Benefits of the PQF:
I. FOR THE PERSON
Encourages lifelong learning allowing the
person to start at the level that suits him
and then build-up his qualifications as his
needs and interests develop and change
over time
Certificates and licenses recognized by
government
9. II. FOR THE EMPLOYERS
Assures that standards and qualifications
are consistent to job
requirements/demand
Provides common understanding on
standards, qualifications and levels
10. III. FOR THE E & T PROVIDERS
Ensures transparency in training provision,
conformance to standards and preciseness
of accountability for learning outcomes
Provides common understanding of policies
and guidelines on credit transfers,
articulation, portability, bridges pathways
and RPL
11. IV. FOR THE AUTHORITIES
Provides the standards, taxonomy and
typology of qualifications as bases for
granting approvals to providers and
stakeholders
Harmonizes qualifications in E & T
across Philippines
12. The PQF:
INPUTS OUTPUTS
Industry needs Qualification Levels
Need for global Descriptors
recognition of
competencies Registers
Current qualifications
issues at all levels Philippine Working Groups
Qualification Pathways &
Qualifications issues
in recognition of s Framework Equivalencies
prior learning
Quality Assurance
Research and policy
papers on NQF Information &
Guidelines
NQFs of other
countries International
Alignment
Consultation and Advocacy
With Stakeholders
13. THE PHL QUALIFICATIONS FRAMEWORK
WAGE EMPLOYMENT/ENTREPRENEURSHIP/SELF-
EMPLOYMENT
Basic Ed TESD HE
L 8 POST DOCTORAL DEGREE
POST BACCALAUREATE
L 7 PROGRAMS
L 6 BACCALAUREATE
PROGRAMS
L 5 P A T H W A Y
NC V
L 4 S NC IV NC III - V
KNOWLEDGE-
L 3 BASED PERSON NC III
SPECIALIZATION CORE COMPETENCIES
12
L 2 NC II
11
10
L 1 NC I
9
COMMON COMPETENCIES
8 MENSURATION
and TECHNICAL USE OF
DRAFTING HANDTOOLS
OCCUPATIONAL
HEALTH & TOOLS/EQUIP
MAINTENACE
ARTS /
CALCULATION CRAFTS
7 APTITUDE & INTEREST
SAFETY
TECHNOPRENEURSHIP & GREEN SKILLS FOR GREEN JOBS
6 ASSESSMENT KNOWLEDGE-BASED COMPETENCIES
FOUNDATIONAL HIGHER ORDER THINKING
5 SKILLS (HOT) SKILLS
• Critical Thinking
4 • ENGLISH
• SCIENCE
•
•
Creative Thinking
Innovation
3 GEC • MATHEMATICS • Problem Solving
GENERIC SKILLS
2 • Work & Values Cluster
1 • Interpersonal Cluster LIFE SKILLS
• Cognitive Cluster
K LEARNING DOMAINS • Adaptability Cluster
14. THE PHL QUALIFICATIONS FRAMEWORK
(Approved by the NEDA SDC-Cabinet on May 18, 2012)
BASIC ED TESD HIGHER EDUCATION
L8 DOCTORAL AND
POST DOCTORAL
L7
POST BACCALAUREATE
L6
BACCALAUREATE
L5
DIPLOMA
L4
NC IV
L3
NC III
NC III
L2 G12
NC II
L1
10 NC I
15. LEVEL 1
Knowledge and skills that are manual or concrete or
KNOWLEDGE, practical and/or operational in focus.
SKILLS AND
VALUES
Applied in activities that are set in a limited range of
APPLICATION highly familiar and predictable contexts; involve
straightforward, routine issues which are addressed
by following set rules, guidelines or procedures.
In conditions where there is very close support,
DEGREE OF guidance or supervision; minimum judgment or
INDEPENDENCE discretion is needed.
QUALIFICATION NATIONAL CERTIFICATE I
TYPE
16. LEVEL 2
Knowledge and skills that are manual, practical
KNOWLEDGE, and/or operational in focus with a variety of options.
SKILLS AND
VALUES
Applied in activities that are set in a range of
APPLICATION familiar and predictable contexts; involve routine
issues which are identified and addressed by
selecting from and following a number of set rules,
guidelines or procedures.
In conditions where there is substantial support,
DEGREE OF guidance or supervision; limited judgment or
INDEPENDENCE discretion is needed.
QUALIFICATION NATIONAL CERTIFICATE II
TYPE
17. LEVEL 3
Knowledge and skills that are a balance of theoretical
KNOWLEDGE, and/or technical and practical.
SKILLS AND Work involves understanding the work process,
VALUES contributing to problem solving, and making decisions to
determine the process, equipment and materials to be
used.
Applied in activities that are set in contexts with some
APPLICATION unfamiliar or unpredictable aspects; involve routine and
non-routine issues which are identified and addressed by
interpreting and/or applying established guidelines or
procedures with some variations.
Application at this level may involve individual
DEGREE OF responsibility or autonomy, and/or may involve some
INDEPENDENCE responsibility for others. Participation in teams including
team or group coordination may be involved.
QUALIFICATION NATIONAL CERTIFICATE III
TYPE
18. LEVEL 4
Knowledge and skills that are mainly theoretical and/or
KNOWLEDGE, abstract with significant depth in one or more areas;
SKILLS AND contributing to technical solutions of a non-routine or
contingency nature; evaluation and analysis of current
VALUES practices and the development of new criteria and
procedures.
Applied in activities that are set in range of contexts, most
APPLICATION of which involve a number of unfamiliar and/or
unpredictable aspects; involve largely non-routine issues
which are addressed using guidelines or procedures
which require interpretation and/or adaptation.
Work involves some leadership and guidance when
DEGREE OF organizing activities of self and others
INDEPENDENCE
QUALIFICATION NATIONAL CERTIFICATE IV
TYPE
19. LEVEL 5
Knowledge and skills that are mainly theoretical and/or
KNOWLEDGE, abstract with significant depth in some areas together
SKILLS AND with wide-ranging, specialized technical, creative and
conceptual skills.
VALUES Perform work activities demonstrating breadth, depth
and complexity in the planning and initiation of
alternative approaches to skills and knowledge
applications across a broad range of technical and/or
management requirements, evaluation and
coordination.
Applied in activities that are supervisory, complex and
APPLICATION non-routine which require an extensive interpretation
and/or adaptation/ innovation.
DEGREE OF In conditions where there is broad guidance and
direction, where judgment is required in planning and
INDEPENDENCE selecting appropriate equipment, services and
techniques for self and others.
Undertake work involving participation in the
development of strategic initiatives, as well as personal
responsibility and autonomy in performing complex
technical operations or organizing others
QUALIFICATION DIPLOMA
20. LEVEL 6
KNOWLEDGE, Graduates at this level have broad
SKILLS AND and coherent knowledge and skills
VALUES in their field of study for professional
work and lifelong learning
APPLICATION Application in professional work or
research in a specialized field of
discipline and/or for further study
DEGREE OF Independent and /or in teams of
INDEPENDENCE related field with minimal
supervision
QUALIFICATION
Baccalaureate Degree
TYPE
21. LEVEL 7
KNOWLEDGE, Graduates at this level have
SKILLS AND advanced knowledge and skills in
VALUES specialized or multidisciplinary field
of study for professional practice or
self-directed research
APPLICATION Applied in professional work that
requires leadership and
management in a specialized or
multidisciplinary professional work,
research and/or for further study
DEGREE OF Independent and or in teams of
INDEPENDENCE multidisciplinary field with very
minimal supervision
QUALIFICATION
Post-Baccalaureate Program
TYPE
22. LEVEL 8
KNOWLEDGE, Graduates at this level have highly
SKILLS & advanced systematic knowledge and skills
VALUES in very specialized or complex
multidisciplinary field of learning for
multifaceted research or professional
practice or for the advancement of learning
APPLICATION Applied in highly specialized or complex
multidisciplinary field of professional work,
research and/or further study that require
management expertise, innovation and
leadership
DEGREE OF Independent and/or in teams of multi-
INDEPENDENC disciplinary and complex setting
E
QUALIFICATIO Doctoral Degree and Post-Doctoral
N TYPE Programs
25. P4A Model for TLE
Job Sheet Assignment
or Sheet
Operation
Sheet
Self-Check
Information
Sheet
26. From Supply to Demand
Driven TVET system
Supply-Driven Demand-Driven
Teacher focus Workplace focus
Group dynamics Individual needs
Set curriculum Customized learning
Sets periods of work Flexible delivery
Final exams Assessment on-going
All assessment off-the-job Assessment on and off the job
“Industry” (institution Specific industry qualification
determined) qualifications
Own performance
Performance relative to
others Outcomes oriented
Emphasis on time and Assessment criterion
process (competency) referenced and
customized
Assessment norm reference
and standardized Emphasis on what you can do in
the workplace
Emphasis on how to learn
Several paths to qualifications
Single path to qualifications
27. Demand Driven System
Industry Demands a Providers adjust Competent Industry recognized
Competent workforce programs to meet demand entrants ready for the
of Industry standards world of work
32. Demand-Driven TVET Systems
The Curriculum is determined and delivered
by staff working in partnership with
industry
Demand-driven TVET requires a confident
and mature governance system, education
and tourism sector
Assumes that personnel on both sides are
willing to work together and it demands a
shift in thinking
Requires the establishment of industry
standards at the national level
33. WHAT IS COMPETENCY-BASED
TVET?
A competency-based TVET is
learning methodology in TVET
provision which involve the
following 10 basic principles:
• The training is based on curriculum
developed from the competency
standars;
• Learning is modular in its structure;
• Training delivery is individualized and
self-paced;
34. 10 basic principles of Competency-
based TVET continuation…….
• Training is based on work that must
be performed;
• Training materials are directly
related to the competency standards
and the curriculum modules;
• Assessment is based in the
collection of evidence of the
performance of work to the industry
required standard;
35. 10 basic principles of Competency-
based TVET continuation…….
• Training is based both on and off-
the-job components;
• Allows for recognition of prior
learning (RPL) or current
competencies;
• Training allows for multiple entry and
exit; and
• Approved training programs are
Nationally Accredited
36. Benefits of CBT system for
graduates
• Training related to workplace practices
• Training requirements expressed as
outcomes
• Nationally recognized qualifications
• Creation of career paths
• Workplace-based assessment
• Increased employability
• Greater confidence in what people can
do in the workplace
37. Benefits of new TVET system for
employers
• Basis for common and clear
understanding of outcomes through
certification
• Improved recruitment effectiveness
• Workplace-based assessment
38. LIST OF 46 ASEAN TOOLBOXES
Nominal
Competencies
Hours
Common Core
1 Work effectively with customers and colleagues 30
2 Work in a socially diverse environment 25
3 Implement occupational health and safety procedures 35
4 Comply with workplace hygiene procedures 20
5 Perform clerical procedures 15
6 Access and retrieve computer-based data 25
7 Converse in English at a basic operational level 120
8 Communicate on the telephone 10
9 Maintain hospitality industry knowledge 20
10 Develop and update tourism industry knowledge 30
11 Promote products and services to customers 25
12 Manage and resolve conflict situations 25
13 Perform basic First Aid procedures 25
14 Perform child protection duties relevant to the tourism industry 15
15 Develop protective environments for children in tourism destinations 25
39. Housekeeping
16 Provide housekeeping services to guests 15
17 Clean public areas, facilities and equipment 60
18 Clean and prepare rooms for in-coming guests 30
19 Maintain and operate an industrial laundry 60
20 Launder linen and guests’ clothes 25
21 Provide valet services to guests 45
22 Clean and maintain industrial work area and equipment 40
English Language
23 Respond effectively to instructions given in English 60
24 Start conversations and develop good relations with guests 60
25 Communicate effectively in English on a telephone 60
26 Read general information texts or media 60
27 Write a short message in English 60
Human Resource Development
28 Plan, conduct and evaluate a staff performance assessment 60
29 Coach others in job skills 25
30 Prepare and deliver training sessions 40
Security Services
31 Manage intoxicated persons 10
32 Provide a lost and found facility 15
33 Plan and conduct an evacuation of premises 20
34 Establish and maintain a safe and secure workplace 60
40. Customer Service, Sales and Marketing
35 Develop and update local knowledge 30
36 Prepare and deliver a presentation 35
37 Establish and maintain a business relationship 60
General Administration
38 Use common business tools and technology 25
39 Plan, manage and conduct meetings 30
40 Receive and store stock 15
Financial Administration
41 Process a financial sale transaction 30
42 Prepare and monitor budgets 35
Resource Management
43 Monitor workplace operations 25
44 Manage quality customer/guest service 35
45 Recruit and select staff 45
46 Provide professional support to business colleagues 60
41. LEVEL NC II NC III NC IV
BASIC • Participate in workplace • Lead workplace communication • Utilize specialized
COMPETENCIES communication (7) (39) communication skills (1)
• Work in team environment (1) • Lead small teams • Develop teams and
• Practice occupational health and • Develop and practice negotiation individuals (29)
safety procedures (3) skills • Promote environmental
• Practice career professionalism • Use relevant technologies (38) protection (15)
(9) • Use mathematical concepts and • Collect, analyze and
techniques (41) organize information
• Solve problems related to work • Plan and organize work
activities (42) • Apply problem solving
techniques in the workplace
(12)
COMMON • Develop and update industry • Roster staff (45) • Conduct assessment (28)
COMPETENCIES knowledge (10, 35) • Control and order stock (40) • Manage workplace diversity
• Observe workplace hygiene • Establish and conduct business (2)
procedures (4) relationships (37) • Manage quality customer
• Provide effective customer • Train small groups (30, 46) service (44)
service (11) • Manage finances within a
• Perform workplace and safety budget (42)
practices (13)
• Perform computer operations (6)
CORE • Provide Housekeeping Services • Plan and schedule routine • Manage physical assets
COMPETENCIES to Guest (16) maintenance, repairs and • Manage stock purchases
• Prepare Rooms for Guest (18) modifications and inventory
• Laundry Linen and Guest Clothes • Escort, carry and store valuable • Provide a lost and found
(20) items facility (32)
• Provide Valet Service (21) • Observe and monitor people • Provide for the safety of VIPs
• Clean Premises (17) (43) (34)
• Contribute to the implementation
of emergency procedures (33)
42. TRAINER MANUAL TRAINEE MANUAL ASSESSOR MANUAL
• Competency •Unit Descriptor •Competency Standard
Assessment •Assessment Matrix •Oral Questions
• PowerPoint •Glossary •Written Questions
Presentation •Elements •Answer to Questions
• Training Equipment •Presentation of Written •Observation Checklist
•Instructions for Trainers Work •Third-Party Statement
for Using PowerPoint •Recommended Reading •Competency Recording
•Trainee Evaluation Sheet Sheet
43. SESSION PLAN LEARNING MATERIALS ASSESSMENT
•Module Title •How to Use the CBLM PACKAGE
•Learning Outcomes •Introductory Page •Self-Assessment
•Learning Activities 1.Module Title
Guide
1.Learning Content 2.Introduction
2.Methods 3.Performance Objectives •Assessor’s Guide
3.Presentation 4.Learning Outcomes •Rating Sheet
5.Assessment Criteria
4.Practice •Specific Instructions
5.Feedback 6.Assessment Methods
6.Resources •Learning Experiences/Activities for the Candidate
7.Time •Instruction Sheets •Competency
Information/Operation Sheet Assessment Results
1. Self-Check Summary
2. Answer Key
44. UPDATES ON TRAINING REGULATIONS
Promulgated Training Regulations Status
1. Bartending NCII Reviewed and promulgated
2. Food and Beverage Services NCII Reviewed but not yet
promulgated
3. Food and Beverage Services NCIII Reviewed but not yet
promulgated
4. Food and Beverage Services NCIV For review in 2013
5. Housekeeping NCII For review Oct-Dec 2012
6. Housekeeping NCIII For review in 2013
7. Housekeeping NCIV For review in 2013
45. UPDATES ON TRAINING REGULATIONS
Promulgated Training Regulations Status
8. Tour Guiding Services NCII For review Oct-Dec 2012
9. Travel Services NCII For review Oct-Dec 2012
10.Front Office Services NCII For review Oct-Dec 2012
11. Cookery NCII Reviewed and Promulgated
12. Commercial Cooking NCIII For review in 2013
13. Commercial Cooking NCIV For review in 2013
14. Bread and Pastry Production NCII For review in 2013
15. Events Management Services NCIII For review in 2013
16. Attraction& Theme Parks Operation NCII For review in 2013
17. Tourism Promotion Services NCII For review in 2013
46. www.tesda.gov.ph
Training Regulations
Competency-Based Curriculum Exemplar
Registry of Certified Workers
TESDA initially offers tourism related online
courses, namely:
Room Attendant Servicing, a core competency of the
Food and Beverage Servicing NCII;
Guestroom Attendant Servicing NC II, a core
competency of the Housekeeping NC II
Notes de l'éditeur
Aligning education and training on requirements of the Tourism industry would require the understanding of a Qualifications that would become a basis for defining competencies describing a particular function or job role. A qualification can be defined as: Package of or group of competencies that describes a particular function or job role existing in an industry sector. It consists of units of competency to cover the work activities required to undertake a particular job role. (PNQF 2004)
On the other hand, the Philippine Qualifications Framework (PQF) is characterized as follows: It is a national policy, describes the levels of educational qualifications and sets the standards for qualification outcomes. A quality assured national system for the development, recognition and award of qualifications based on standards of knowledge, skills and values acquired in different ways and methods by learners and workers of a certain country
It is: Competency-based. Labor market-driven. Assessment based qualification recognition.
During the State of the Nation Address of the President in 2011, he directed DOLE, CHED, TESDA, and DepEd to work together to address the issue of job-skills mismatch. One of the responses to the Presidential directive is the development of the Philippine Qualifications Framework (PQF). The Philippine Qualifications Framework was developed by an Inter-Agency Working Group from DepEd, TESDA, CHED, DOLE-BLE and PRC. The PQF was approved by the NEDA Social Development Committee-Cabinet Level during its meeting last May 18, 2012.
The PQF has a number of key objectives. They are: To establish national standards and levels for outcomes of education and training, skills and competencies To support the development and maintenance of pathways and equivalencies which provide access to qualifications and assist people to move easily and readily between the different E & T sectors and between these sectors and the labor market To align the PQF with international qualifications framework to support the national and international mobility of workers thru increased recognition of the value and comparability of Philippine qualifications
The formulation of the Philippine Qualifications Framework will have attendant benefits to various sectors: the person, employers, education and training providers and Authorities. Specifically, expected benefits include the following: I. For the PERSON Encourages lifelong learning allowing the person to start at the level that suits him and then build-up his qualifications as his needs and interests develop and change over time Certificates and licenses recognized by government
II. For the EMPLOYERS Assures that standards and qualifications are consistent to job requirements/demand Provides common understanding on standards, qualifications and levels
III. For the E & T PROVIDERS Ensures transparency in training provision, conformance to standards and preciseness of accountability for learning outcomes Provides common understanding of policies and guidelines on credit transfers, articulation, portability, bridges pathways and RPL
IV. For the AUTHORITIES Provides the standards, taxonomy and typology of qualifications as bases for granting approvals to providers and stakeholders Harmonizes qualifications in E & T across Philippines
The development of the Philippine Qualifications Framework has to be done in consideration of a number of inputs in order to generate the desired outputs. It shall utilized extensive consultations and advocacy with stakeholders towards the successful implementation of the PQF in the country.
The Department of Education, TESDA and CHED agreed to adopt the eight (8) Level Philippine Qualifications Framework (PQF) which was endorsed by the Social Development Committee of the National Economic Development Authority. The PQF recognizes the alternative learning system and the principles of lifelong learning, prior learning and equivalency. Though compartmentalization exists in the Philippine education system, quality is assured through a standards and accreditation system for basic and higher education institutions and through a unified registration and accreditation system for technical vocational institutions. The Assessment and Certification system likewise ensures the quality of students of the Philippine education system. The PQF showed that graduates of K to 12, may opt to proceed to the technical education and skills development track and higher education track. Please note that the PQF indicated the embedment and the alignment of the technical education and skills development (TESD) in the general secondary of the basic education from Exploratory Grades 7 and 8, and specialization in Grade 9 to 12. These are in the TLE programs that provide an enriched general education that will prepare our graduates for higher education, world of work and lifelong learning. The minds of the students as early as Exploratory Grade 7, will be opened to various employability possibilities identified in the five (5) common competencies required in 24 TR-aligned TLE programs. These are: 1) Use tools and equipment; 2) Maintain tools and equipment; 3) Perform mensuration and calculation; 4) Apply occupational health and safety procedures, and 5) Prepare and interpret technical drawing and plans The figure shows the Philippine Qualifications Framework that was presented and endorsed by the NEDA SDC-Technical Board during its meeting last February 21, 2012. Aside from defining the qualification levels, the detailed framework depicts the knowledge-based competencies, common competencies and specialization competencies to be acquired by the students. Also included are the support mechanisms towards wage/entrepreneurial or self-employment.
The second figure is a simplified presentation of the PQF as a result of the consultations with stakeholders. This was presented and approved by the SDC Cabinet Level last May 18, 2012. It outlines the 8-level qualifications covered by the PQF starting from NC I up to Doctoral and Post Doctoral programs.
What follows is the matrix showing the 8-Levels Philippine Qualifications Framework. The levels are defined in terms of knowledge, skills and values, application, degree of independence and qualification levels. It can be observed that as the level grows higher, additional competencies needs to be acquired by the person.
The K to 12 Curriculum has as its overarching goal the holistic development of every Filipino learner with 21 st century skills who is adequately prepared for work, entrepreneurship, middle level skills development and higher education. The overarching goal of the K to 12 curriculum, indicated that the teaching of Technology and Livelihood Education (TLE) plays a very important role in the realization of the overall goal of the curriculum. Whether or not the K to 12 graduate is skilled and ready for work, entrepreneurship and middle skills development depends to a great extent on how effectively you taught TLE. The teaching of the TLE in general secondary schools is guided by this Conceptual Framework. It shows that the TLE encompasses the various sectors in Information and Communications Technology, Agri-fishery and other technological proficiency. TLE is geared towards the development of technological proficiency and is anchored on knowledge and information, entrepreneurial concepts, process and delivery, work values and life skills. The TLE that is functional is one that equips students with skills for lifelong learning. is focused on mastery of skills and is founded on the cognitive, behavioral or psychomotor and affective dimensions of human development. So teaching TLE, is teaching facts, concepts, skills and values as a whole.
SLIDE 12 With the implementation of the new curriculum guides and learning modules for the TLE, we are assured that the K to 12 graduates are equipped with employable skills that match the industry requirements and prepare them into entrepreneurial venture that will provide income for the family and ultimately, uplift their economic status in life.