SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  22
Central West End Story: How a Walkable, Diverse
   Neighborhood Bounced Back from Decline


                       Todd Swanstrom,
Des Lee Professor of Community Collaboration and Public Policy
                     Administration, UMSL
With the assistance of Will Winter and Derrick Redhead, UMSL



                   Bold Community Visions
              Livable St. Louis Conference 2012

                      October 26, 2012
Questions
1. How has the CWE changed over time (upward
   or downward trajectory)?

2. How does the CWE compare to the City of St.
   Louis (convergence or divergence)?

3. Is the CWE a classic case of “gentrification?

4. What were the main forces shaping the
   development of the CWE (private
   market, public policies, civil society)?
Mapping Change: Census Tracts and the CWE
Change in Population by Census Year: 1970-2010*

120




100




 80



                                                              Central West End
 60                                                           St. Louis City




 40




 20




 0
        1970          1980   1990     2000      2010


       * 1970 = 100                                    US Census Bureau
Change in Number of Households by Census Year: 1970-2010*

120




100




 80



                                                       Central West End
 60                                                    St. Louis City




 40




 20




  0
         1970        1980   1990   2000      2010
                                                    US Census Bureau

      * 1970 = 100
Vacant Housing Units as a Percent of All Units: 1970-2010


25%




20%




15%
                                                                   Central West End

                                                                   St. Louis City



10%




5%



                                                      Source: US Census Bureau



0%
        1970      1980     1990      2000     2010
Change in Median Housing Values: 1970-2010

$300,000




$250,000




$200,000


                                                                          Central West End
                                                                          St. Louis City
$150,000




$100,000




 $50,000


                                                           Source: US Census Bureau

     $0
           1970         1980      1990     2000     2010
Average (Gross) Monthly Rent in 2011 Dollars: 1970-2010

$900



$800



$700



$600



$500                                                                          Central West End
                                                                              St. Louis City


$400



$300



$200


                                                                 Sources: US Census Bureau &
$100                                                              Bureau of Labor Statistics




  $0
         1970        1980        1990       2000        2010
Is the CWE a classic case of
            “gentrification?

1. Average income goes up as “gentry” (YUPPIES) move
   in.
2. Average family size decreases (more young singles and
   “empty nesters”).
3. Low-income, working class, and minority residents are
   displaced by rising rents and house prices.
4. A heterogeneous neighborhood is transformed into a
   homogenous community with a suburban cultural
   feel.
Average Family Incomes in 2011 Dollars: 1970-2010

$100,000



 $90,000



 $80,000



 $70,000



 $60,000

                                                                              Central West End
                                                                              St. Louis City
 $50,000



 $40,000



 $30,000



 $20,000



 $10,000
                                                                 Sources: US Census Bureau &
                                                                    Bureau of Labor Statistics

     $0
              1970       1980       1990       2000       2010
Percent of Families Living in Poverty: 1970-2010

25%




20%




15%

                                                                     Central West End
                                                                     St. Louis City


10%




5%




0%
      1970      1980      1990      2000      2010
                                                          US Census Bureau
Nonfamily Households as Percent of all Households: 1980-2010

80%




70%




60%




50%

                                                                     Central West End
                                                                     St. Louis City
40%




30%




20%




10%




0%                                                             US Census Bureau
          1980         1990          2000         2010
Distribution of Population by Age: Central West End vs St. Louis City 1970


60.0%




50.0%




40.0%

                                                                                   Central West End

                                                                                   St. Louis City

30.0%




20.0%




10.0%




 0.0%
        Under 18 years   18 to 34 years   35 to 64 years   65 and over   Source: US Census Bureau
Distribution of Population by Age: Central West End vs St. Louis City 2010
60.00%




50.00%




40.00%



                                                                                 Central West End

30.00%                                                                           St. Louis City




20.00%




10.00%




 0.00%
         Under 18 years   18 to 34 years   35 to 64 years   65 and over   Source: US Census Bureau
Population by Race in the Central West End: 1970-2010


20,000



18,000



16,000



14,000



12,000                                                                     White

                                                                           Black
10,000                                                                     Hispanic & Latino


 8,000



 6,000



 4,000



 2,000


                                                                 Source: US Census Bureau
    -
           1970      1980       1990      2000      2010
CWE has all the characteristics of
 a gentrified neighborhood …

             …but…

      It is still racially and
     economically diverse.
Racial/Ethnic Com
            3%
      11%


                          White
                          African American
28%
                          Asian
                 58%      Other
How a Walkable Urban Neighborhood in St. Louis Bounced Back from Decline
How a Walkable Urban Neighborhood in St. Louis Bounced Back from Decline
How a Walkable Urban Neighborhood in St. Louis Bounced Back from Decline

Contenu connexe

Similaire à How a Walkable Urban Neighborhood in St. Louis Bounced Back from Decline

The Importance of Immigrants to Boston's Continued prosperity
The Importance of Immigrants to Boston's Continued prosperityThe Importance of Immigrants to Boston's Continued prosperity
The Importance of Immigrants to Boston's Continued prosperityInstituto Diáspora Brasil (IDB)
 
Demographics of Senior and Veteran Housing in Rural America - Housing Assista...
Demographics of Senior and Veteran Housing in Rural America - Housing Assista...Demographics of Senior and Veteran Housing in Rural America - Housing Assista...
Demographics of Senior and Veteran Housing in Rural America - Housing Assista...Housing Assistance Council
 
The Silver Tsunami: Are We Prepared for a Senior Housing Population Boom in R...
The Silver Tsunami: Are We Prepared for a Senior Housing Population Boom in R...The Silver Tsunami: Are We Prepared for a Senior Housing Population Boom in R...
The Silver Tsunami: Are We Prepared for a Senior Housing Population Boom in R...Housing Assistance Council
 
Reardon Massachusetts Housing Institute
Reardon Massachusetts Housing InstituteReardon Massachusetts Housing Institute
Reardon Massachusetts Housing Institutetimothygreardon
 
Peter Meade Chamber May 2013
Peter Meade Chamber May 2013Peter Meade Chamber May 2013
Peter Meade Chamber May 2013bostonredevelop
 
Our Shared Future: Charting a Path for Immigrant Advancement in a New Politic...
Our Shared Future: Charting a Path for Immigrant Advancement in a New Politic...Our Shared Future: Charting a Path for Immigrant Advancement in a New Politic...
Our Shared Future: Charting a Path for Immigrant Advancement in a New Politic...Instituto Diáspora Brasil (IDB)
 
The hispanic community by the numbers feb 29
The hispanic community by the numbers   feb 29The hispanic community by the numbers   feb 29
The hispanic community by the numbers feb 29bixal
 
Transportation in Summit, New Jersey
Transportation in Summit, New JerseyTransportation in Summit, New Jersey
Transportation in Summit, New Jerseysfishb01
 
Learning About America from the 2010 Census
Learning About America from the 2010 CensusLearning About America from the 2010 Census
Learning About America from the 2010 CensusMichael Bystry
 
Moving Toward Integration?
Moving Toward Integration?Moving Toward Integration?
Moving Toward Integration?Rural Soc
 
Web housing meeting 1 data
Web housing meeting 1 dataWeb housing meeting 1 data
Web housing meeting 1 dataoneregionforward
 
The importance of Immigrants to Boston's Continued Prosperity
The importance of Immigrants to Boston's Continued ProsperityThe importance of Immigrants to Boston's Continued Prosperity
The importance of Immigrants to Boston's Continued ProsperityInstituto Diáspora Brasil (IDB)
 
Kotkin - Housing the Future - 2017
Kotkin - Housing the Future - 2017Kotkin - Housing the Future - 2017
Kotkin - Housing the Future - 2017ivar_admin
 

Similaire à How a Walkable Urban Neighborhood in St. Louis Bounced Back from Decline (20)

New York Mercury Bendixen 2011
New York Mercury Bendixen 2011New York Mercury Bendixen 2011
New York Mercury Bendixen 2011
 
New York Mercury Bendixen 2011
New York Mercury Bendixen 2011 New York Mercury Bendixen 2011
New York Mercury Bendixen 2011
 
The Importance of Immigrants to Boston's Continued prosperity
The Importance of Immigrants to Boston's Continued prosperityThe Importance of Immigrants to Boston's Continued prosperity
The Importance of Immigrants to Boston's Continued prosperity
 
Demographics of Senior and Veteran Housing in Rural America - Housing Assista...
Demographics of Senior and Veteran Housing in Rural America - Housing Assista...Demographics of Senior and Veteran Housing in Rural America - Housing Assista...
Demographics of Senior and Veteran Housing in Rural America - Housing Assista...
 
The Diversity Explosion
The Diversity ExplosionThe Diversity Explosion
The Diversity Explosion
 
Boston's Equity Challenges
Boston's Equity ChallengesBoston's Equity Challenges
Boston's Equity Challenges
 
The Silver Tsunami: Are We Prepared for a Senior Housing Population Boom in R...
The Silver Tsunami: Are We Prepared for a Senior Housing Population Boom in R...The Silver Tsunami: Are We Prepared for a Senior Housing Population Boom in R...
The Silver Tsunami: Are We Prepared for a Senior Housing Population Boom in R...
 
Reardon Massachusetts Housing Institute
Reardon Massachusetts Housing InstituteReardon Massachusetts Housing Institute
Reardon Massachusetts Housing Institute
 
Peter Meade Chamber May 2013
Peter Meade Chamber May 2013Peter Meade Chamber May 2013
Peter Meade Chamber May 2013
 
Our Shared Future: Charting a Path for Immigrant Advancement in a New Politic...
Our Shared Future: Charting a Path for Immigrant Advancement in a New Politic...Our Shared Future: Charting a Path for Immigrant Advancement in a New Politic...
Our Shared Future: Charting a Path for Immigrant Advancement in a New Politic...
 
The hispanic community by the numbers feb 29
The hispanic community by the numbers   feb 29The hispanic community by the numbers   feb 29
The hispanic community by the numbers feb 29
 
Boston's Equity Challenges
Boston's Equity ChallengesBoston's Equity Challenges
Boston's Equity Challenges
 
Transportation in Summit, New Jersey
Transportation in Summit, New JerseyTransportation in Summit, New Jersey
Transportation in Summit, New Jersey
 
Learning About America from the 2010 Census
Learning About America from the 2010 CensusLearning About America from the 2010 Census
Learning About America from the 2010 Census
 
Moving Toward Integration?
Moving Toward Integration?Moving Toward Integration?
Moving Toward Integration?
 
Web housing meeting 1 data
Web housing meeting 1 dataWeb housing meeting 1 data
Web housing meeting 1 data
 
NAR
NARNAR
NAR
 
NAR
NARNAR
NAR
 
The importance of Immigrants to Boston's Continued Prosperity
The importance of Immigrants to Boston's Continued ProsperityThe importance of Immigrants to Boston's Continued Prosperity
The importance of Immigrants to Boston's Continued Prosperity
 
Kotkin - Housing the Future - 2017
Kotkin - Housing the Future - 2017Kotkin - Housing the Future - 2017
Kotkin - Housing the Future - 2017
 

Plus de Trailnet

Livable Streets Design
Livable Streets Design Livable Streets Design
Livable Streets Design Trailnet
 
Missouri Livable Streets Training - Boonslick Regional Planning Commission
Missouri Livable Streets Training - Boonslick Regional Planning CommissionMissouri Livable Streets Training - Boonslick Regional Planning Commission
Missouri Livable Streets Training - Boonslick Regional Planning CommissionTrailnet
 
Arch Women: A Pedal-Powered Movement - Trailnet Introduction
Arch Women: A Pedal-Powered Movement - Trailnet IntroductionArch Women: A Pedal-Powered Movement - Trailnet Introduction
Arch Women: A Pedal-Powered Movement - Trailnet IntroductionTrailnet
 
Trailnet Improving the Pedestrian Experience
Trailnet Improving the Pedestrian ExperienceTrailnet Improving the Pedestrian Experience
Trailnet Improving the Pedestrian ExperienceTrailnet
 
Effland.presentation
Effland.presentationEffland.presentation
Effland.presentationTrailnet
 
Cooper.ann arbor
Cooper.ann arborCooper.ann arbor
Cooper.ann arborTrailnet
 
The Minneapolis Bicycle Story David Peterson
The Minneapolis Bicycle Story David PetersonThe Minneapolis Bicycle Story David Peterson
The Minneapolis Bicycle Story David PetersonTrailnet
 
Indianapolis Modus Operandi Andy Lutz
Indianapolis Modus Operandi Andy LutzIndianapolis Modus Operandi Andy Lutz
Indianapolis Modus Operandi Andy LutzTrailnet
 
Indianapolis Best Practices Andy Lutz
Indianapolis Best Practices Andy LutzIndianapolis Best Practices Andy Lutz
Indianapolis Best Practices Andy LutzTrailnet
 
The State of Biking in St. Louis Rhonda Smythe
The State of Biking in St. Louis Rhonda SmytheThe State of Biking in St. Louis Rhonda Smythe
The State of Biking in St. Louis Rhonda SmytheTrailnet
 
State of Biking Todd Waelterman
State of Biking Todd WaeltermanState of Biking Todd Waelterman
State of Biking Todd WaeltermanTrailnet
 
Big Healthy Trees
Big Healthy TreesBig Healthy Trees
Big Healthy TreesTrailnet
 
Gateway Greening
Gateway GreeningGateway Greening
Gateway GreeningTrailnet
 
Pruitt Igoe Now
Pruitt Igoe NowPruitt Igoe Now
Pruitt Igoe NowTrailnet
 
Neighborhood Greenways
Neighborhood GreenwaysNeighborhood Greenways
Neighborhood GreenwaysTrailnet
 
Perennial transforming Objects Lives Communities
Perennial transforming Objects Lives CommunitiesPerennial transforming Objects Lives Communities
Perennial transforming Objects Lives CommunitiesTrailnet
 
Building a Better Metro: Possibilities for BRT
Building a Better Metro: Possibilities for BRTBuilding a Better Metro: Possibilities for BRT
Building a Better Metro: Possibilities for BRTTrailnet
 
Participatory Budgeting in New York City
Participatory Budgeting in New York CityParticipatory Budgeting in New York City
Participatory Budgeting in New York CityTrailnet
 
Food Security & Land Security: Saving the Small Farm
Food Security & Land Security: Saving the Small FarmFood Security & Land Security: Saving the Small Farm
Food Security & Land Security: Saving the Small FarmTrailnet
 
Bus Rapid Transit: Meeting international best practice
Bus Rapid Transit: Meeting international best practiceBus Rapid Transit: Meeting international best practice
Bus Rapid Transit: Meeting international best practiceTrailnet
 

Plus de Trailnet (20)

Livable Streets Design
Livable Streets Design Livable Streets Design
Livable Streets Design
 
Missouri Livable Streets Training - Boonslick Regional Planning Commission
Missouri Livable Streets Training - Boonslick Regional Planning CommissionMissouri Livable Streets Training - Boonslick Regional Planning Commission
Missouri Livable Streets Training - Boonslick Regional Planning Commission
 
Arch Women: A Pedal-Powered Movement - Trailnet Introduction
Arch Women: A Pedal-Powered Movement - Trailnet IntroductionArch Women: A Pedal-Powered Movement - Trailnet Introduction
Arch Women: A Pedal-Powered Movement - Trailnet Introduction
 
Trailnet Improving the Pedestrian Experience
Trailnet Improving the Pedestrian ExperienceTrailnet Improving the Pedestrian Experience
Trailnet Improving the Pedestrian Experience
 
Effland.presentation
Effland.presentationEffland.presentation
Effland.presentation
 
Cooper.ann arbor
Cooper.ann arborCooper.ann arbor
Cooper.ann arbor
 
The Minneapolis Bicycle Story David Peterson
The Minneapolis Bicycle Story David PetersonThe Minneapolis Bicycle Story David Peterson
The Minneapolis Bicycle Story David Peterson
 
Indianapolis Modus Operandi Andy Lutz
Indianapolis Modus Operandi Andy LutzIndianapolis Modus Operandi Andy Lutz
Indianapolis Modus Operandi Andy Lutz
 
Indianapolis Best Practices Andy Lutz
Indianapolis Best Practices Andy LutzIndianapolis Best Practices Andy Lutz
Indianapolis Best Practices Andy Lutz
 
The State of Biking in St. Louis Rhonda Smythe
The State of Biking in St. Louis Rhonda SmytheThe State of Biking in St. Louis Rhonda Smythe
The State of Biking in St. Louis Rhonda Smythe
 
State of Biking Todd Waelterman
State of Biking Todd WaeltermanState of Biking Todd Waelterman
State of Biking Todd Waelterman
 
Big Healthy Trees
Big Healthy TreesBig Healthy Trees
Big Healthy Trees
 
Gateway Greening
Gateway GreeningGateway Greening
Gateway Greening
 
Pruitt Igoe Now
Pruitt Igoe NowPruitt Igoe Now
Pruitt Igoe Now
 
Neighborhood Greenways
Neighborhood GreenwaysNeighborhood Greenways
Neighborhood Greenways
 
Perennial transforming Objects Lives Communities
Perennial transforming Objects Lives CommunitiesPerennial transforming Objects Lives Communities
Perennial transforming Objects Lives Communities
 
Building a Better Metro: Possibilities for BRT
Building a Better Metro: Possibilities for BRTBuilding a Better Metro: Possibilities for BRT
Building a Better Metro: Possibilities for BRT
 
Participatory Budgeting in New York City
Participatory Budgeting in New York CityParticipatory Budgeting in New York City
Participatory Budgeting in New York City
 
Food Security & Land Security: Saving the Small Farm
Food Security & Land Security: Saving the Small FarmFood Security & Land Security: Saving the Small Farm
Food Security & Land Security: Saving the Small Farm
 
Bus Rapid Transit: Meeting international best practice
Bus Rapid Transit: Meeting international best practiceBus Rapid Transit: Meeting international best practice
Bus Rapid Transit: Meeting international best practice
 

How a Walkable Urban Neighborhood in St. Louis Bounced Back from Decline

  • 1. Central West End Story: How a Walkable, Diverse Neighborhood Bounced Back from Decline Todd Swanstrom, Des Lee Professor of Community Collaboration and Public Policy Administration, UMSL With the assistance of Will Winter and Derrick Redhead, UMSL Bold Community Visions Livable St. Louis Conference 2012 October 26, 2012
  • 2. Questions 1. How has the CWE changed over time (upward or downward trajectory)? 2. How does the CWE compare to the City of St. Louis (convergence or divergence)? 3. Is the CWE a classic case of “gentrification? 4. What were the main forces shaping the development of the CWE (private market, public policies, civil society)?
  • 3. Mapping Change: Census Tracts and the CWE
  • 4. Change in Population by Census Year: 1970-2010* 120 100 80 Central West End 60 St. Louis City 40 20 0 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 * 1970 = 100 US Census Bureau
  • 5. Change in Number of Households by Census Year: 1970-2010* 120 100 80 Central West End 60 St. Louis City 40 20 0 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 US Census Bureau * 1970 = 100
  • 6. Vacant Housing Units as a Percent of All Units: 1970-2010 25% 20% 15% Central West End St. Louis City 10% 5% Source: US Census Bureau 0% 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010
  • 7. Change in Median Housing Values: 1970-2010 $300,000 $250,000 $200,000 Central West End St. Louis City $150,000 $100,000 $50,000 Source: US Census Bureau $0 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010
  • 8. Average (Gross) Monthly Rent in 2011 Dollars: 1970-2010 $900 $800 $700 $600 $500 Central West End St. Louis City $400 $300 $200 Sources: US Census Bureau & $100 Bureau of Labor Statistics $0 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11. Is the CWE a classic case of “gentrification? 1. Average income goes up as “gentry” (YUPPIES) move in. 2. Average family size decreases (more young singles and “empty nesters”). 3. Low-income, working class, and minority residents are displaced by rising rents and house prices. 4. A heterogeneous neighborhood is transformed into a homogenous community with a suburban cultural feel.
  • 12. Average Family Incomes in 2011 Dollars: 1970-2010 $100,000 $90,000 $80,000 $70,000 $60,000 Central West End St. Louis City $50,000 $40,000 $30,000 $20,000 $10,000 Sources: US Census Bureau & Bureau of Labor Statistics $0 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010
  • 13. Percent of Families Living in Poverty: 1970-2010 25% 20% 15% Central West End St. Louis City 10% 5% 0% 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 US Census Bureau
  • 14. Nonfamily Households as Percent of all Households: 1980-2010 80% 70% 60% 50% Central West End St. Louis City 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% US Census Bureau 1980 1990 2000 2010
  • 15. Distribution of Population by Age: Central West End vs St. Louis City 1970 60.0% 50.0% 40.0% Central West End St. Louis City 30.0% 20.0% 10.0% 0.0% Under 18 years 18 to 34 years 35 to 64 years 65 and over Source: US Census Bureau
  • 16. Distribution of Population by Age: Central West End vs St. Louis City 2010 60.00% 50.00% 40.00% Central West End 30.00% St. Louis City 20.00% 10.00% 0.00% Under 18 years 18 to 34 years 35 to 64 years 65 and over Source: US Census Bureau
  • 17. Population by Race in the Central West End: 1970-2010 20,000 18,000 16,000 14,000 12,000 White Black 10,000 Hispanic & Latino 8,000 6,000 4,000 2,000 Source: US Census Bureau - 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010
  • 18. CWE has all the characteristics of a gentrified neighborhood … …but… It is still racially and economically diverse.
  • 19. Racial/Ethnic Com 3% 11% White African American 28% Asian 58% Other