SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 4
Download to read offline
http://www.uneeducationpourdemain.org	
  
	
  
Page 1 sur 4	
  
Becoming a Teacher: one person's
experience - William Bernhardt
I'm not sure when I first thought about becoming a teacher but it couldn't have been any later
than the fourth grade when I was nine years old. Perhaps because I was often intimidated by
other children who seemed to be more intelligent and more forceful than myself, there was
something very appealing about being in control of a class. I daydreamed of the time when I
might stand in front of thirty children and impress them with the knowledge and authority
which I was unable to exert on my contemporaries.
How much my teachers seemed to know! It seemed that they could answer any question.
Often, when some wise guy in the class posed a difficult query to one of my teachers I felt a
sense of protective identification and a slight twinge of fear. How could she possibly find an
answer to this one? And then, without a moment's hesitation, the answer came, confidently
and forcefully. How proud and delighted I felt at such moments! How smart my teacher is, I
thought, but then a disquieting ripple passed over my mind as I wondered whether I could
ever know so much.
Later on, as my own store of information expanded, I was more critical and less admiring.
Now I secretly thrilled when one of my teachers was caught in a mistake or an evasion. Still
later, in College, I was shocked to discover that for many of my professors, teaching was a
matter of keeping one chapter ahead of the class, of turning unwelcome questions back on the
questioner ("and what do you think, Bill?") or of dismissing topics for which the instructor
had no ready supply of words ("I think we should defer this until next week").
Discovering the weaknesses of my teachers, and observing the strategies and tactics they
employed to cover their ignorance and defensiveness, made me feel more confident about
becoming a teacher myself. Not only had I acquired information to rival some of my
professors, but I fancied that I had prepared myself to be an unusually lively and entertaining
presence in the classroom.
At the time when I began my teaching career I felt that I had a very great deal to 'give' my
students. Comparatively speaking, I had read everything and they nothing. To what extent that
illusion was shared by those in my classes I can't say. My impression is that one or two people
in each of my courses were inspired by my performance (as I had been by certain of my own
instructors) to the extent of emulation my style of telling an anecdote, my way of turning
aside unwelcome questions, or my techniques for making dry topics slightly amusing. But, in
the main, those who entered the class as 'good students' were continuing an apprenticeship
launched somewhere else, and the rest endured with the same mixture of resignation and good
will that they brought to all of their other courses.
I enjoyed performing when a class "went well". But I couldn't fail to notice that what
transpired in the classroom was always less intense and engaging for me than the period of
http://www.uneeducationpourdemain.org	
  
	
  
Page 2 sur 4	
  
solitary preparation which preceded it. I felt that my own, independent acquisition of
knowledge was the "real" thing, whereas time spent with the students was a distraction from
what I perceived as "my own work".
That there was any alternative to these habitual ways of thinking and acting never occurred to
me during my first ten years as a college professor in Britain and the U.S. It was due to and
almost chance event -a workshop in Spanish which I took at Educational Solutions in New
York during July, 1971- that I first became aware of my lack of preparation as a teacher.
During the morning of the first day of the workshop, as I struggled to master the Spanish
sounds associated with each of the rods, the teacher asked me what seemed at the time to be
both a mysterious and irrelevant question: "What are you doing with yourself?" And when I
was unable to frame a reply she asked another question: "Are you using your energy to listen
or in trying to remember? Do you know the difference between 'trying' and 'opening up to the
sounds'?"
What struck me most forcibly was her attitude. It was clear that she didn't care much about
the Spanish vocabulary she had introduced or whether I would ever 'get it'. What concerned
her was what was happening inside me. She wanted to know whether I knew what I was
doing or if the whole experience was a blur.
I didn't learn much Spanish during that week. Learning to take account of what was
happening inside myself became my task instead. As the days passed, I became far more
attentive to my own inner movements and aware of how little attention I had habitually given
to such study. By the end of the week I could definitely discriminate between various internal
states and know, with certainty, when I was "with it", when I was distracted by my emotions
(such as my anxiety to appear as a 'good student'), when I was putting blocks in the way of the
sounds reaching me, and so on.
That week represented the first time in my life that I was actively monitoring my own inner
dynamics to observe what I was "doing with myself". Acquiring this new awareness made me
also acknowledge my previous unconsciousness. I saw that I had always viewed my own
learning as a mysterious (sometimes miraculous) phenomenon because I had no way of
observing it as it happened. Previously, my learning could only be tested through external
feedback. Now, I was acquiring my own inner criteria.
Many of the lessons of this week only came to me later on, through reflection and with the
added impact of additional seminars and workshops led by Dr. Gattegno. Even then, however,
I recognized that I had passed an important threshold. I realized that learning could, and must
be studied in what was for me a new way -as a psychological reality within my own mind.
Further, I acknowledged that teaching, as I had encountered it in the Spanish course, was
something different than I had always assumed it to be. Its primary focus was not a body of
content or skills but the learner.
Having arrived at these new awarenesses, I was also struck by the fact that, on a verbal level,
they were hardly 'new'. For years, I had heard (and spoken) of "knowing within oneself",
"understanding the process of learning", and other such phrases. But it was only during this
week, and its aftermath, that these words truly gained a concrete reality for me and assumed
the force of fresh perceptions. Thus, when I resumed teaching the following September, I
approached the classroom in a very different spirit than ever before and with many new
preoccupations:
▪ Learning is something which, when it happens, happens inside me; it is therefore a matter
of awareness or consciousness rather than behavior or performance.
▪ Because my learning is inner, private, it is only truly accessible to me... if I have prepared
myself to monitor its presence... and is largely invisible from outside.
http://www.uneeducationpourdemain.org	
  
	
  
Page 3 sur 4	
  
▪ Teaching, by contrast to learning, is a matter of externals. That I teach is no guarantee that
learning takes place.
▪ Because of the disjunction between teaching and learning, a teacher such as myself needs to
become a specialist in my own inner experience of learning. Without this, how can .I
ever hope to work with others?
▪ The challenge of becoming a specialist in my own learning is at least as difficult as
mastering the content of any academic field, probably more so.
Having these concerns prompted me to prepare for my courses in English Composition in a
new way, by studying my own internal process. I began by asking myself the questions "What
happens in me to produce writing? What do I do with myself?
As this was my first attempt to make an independent study of myself, I can't say that I
proceeded in a disciplined or systematic manner. I was frankly groping. I was probably too
easily satisfied by the first answers that came to mind. Still, I had to start somewhere. What
came to me was that writing had never been for me as it was described in the textbooks. It
was never triggered by outlines or notes, or thinking about my prospective audience. These all
came later. What I found to be crucial was a certain inner state or climate which I could call
'the writing state of mind'. Without this, no amount of outside pressure or 'motivation' would
elicit writing. Later on, I was to probe deeper, to find the precise attributes of this state, but at
this stage it was sufficient for me to recognize that the ground level of writing was a certain
inner preparation. So I asked myself further questions: "Are there external conditions which
seem particularly compatible with achieving the writing state of mind? Can I provide my
students with an environment that will encourage them to mobilize themselves the same way
that I do?"
During that term I began each class by asking the students to compose for a few minutes
(sometimes longer) in little blue examination booklets which I distributed to them for this
purpose. I demanded that they "keep the pencil moving continuously. If you can't think of
anything to write, simply write words selected at random." When each day's writing was
completed, the booklets were closed without reading or discussion of their content. Nor did I
ever read what the students had composed. I did, however, question them at the conclusion of
each day's writing experience, asking them "What has happened to you today? Do you know
what happens in you at the moment when the words start to come? Is the process today any
different today than it was yesterday, or last week?"
At first, most of the students found it difficult to talk about themselves rather than about what
was on the paper. They would start to report what they had written about, or the extent to
which they found it easy or hard to find something to say without a prompt from the teacher.
Gradually, however, individuals in the group began to notice the presence of an inner sense of
something to say which seemed prior to language. Some also reported on the existence of
mental imagery that triggered words and a variety of inner voices - some dictating, as it were,
to their writing hands; others criticizing and judging.
This was by no means a precisely formulated exercise, and there were some who seemed
totally unaffected by it. Still, it represented a new way of working for me:
▪ I was starting from what I knew of myself, with the assumption that the learners in my
classes were like me.
▪ I was focusing not on the product (what they wrote) or my own ideas and theories but on
what the students were doing with themselves and noticing about themselves.
▪ I had stopped trying to give the learners advice and tips.
▪ I was making the encounter with the learners in the classroom the center of my teaching
life.
▪ I was suspending my judgment about students who didn't respond favorably to what was
http://www.uneeducationpourdemain.org	
  
	
  
Page 4 sur 4	
  
happening in the class instead of viewing them as hostile or deficient.
These changes in my way of working did not, I want to emphasize, transform me into a good
teacher. But they did make me more of a teacher. That is, they helped my to approach my
students in a more conscious, more humble, and more empirical spirit.
As I continued to look into myself, with the aid of further workshops and seminars with Dr.
Gattegno and his staff, I was struck by many more questions:
▪ What inhibits me from writing? Can I be inhibited by my need to use words I can't spell?
By assigned topics which find no echo in my experience? By my own standards of
"good writing"?
▪ Do I know when I have something to say? How?
▪ Is there anything I can say orally but not write? Are there any significant differences .for
me between speaking and writing besides spelling?
▪ What role does mental imagery play in my composing? Does seeing the content in my mind
always help me find words?
▪ How do I cope with the fact that the words often come fast but my hand transcribes them
more slowly? Do I have a way of holding what I say until my hand catches up to my
voice?
▪ Where are my grammatical criteria? In my intellect? In my ears? In my voice? Where?
▪ How do I prepare myself to address a variety of different audiences (the readers of this
article, my students, my more scholarly colleagues, etc.)?
My reflection on these and other questions continues. I find that, as time goes on, I have more
rather than fewer questions to think about.
For me, becoming a teacher has been first and foremost a process of initiating an internal
dialogue. It has been a matter of learning to recognize the necessity of setting aside all the
knowledge that I have previously accumulated in order to examine myself from within and be
with the here and now. I can't claim that the last 19 years of self-examination accompanied by
experimentation and improvisation in the classroom have made me a great or even a good
teacher. But I am certain that I have become a teacher.
William Bernhardt New York, 1990
"Becoming a Teacher: one person's experience" by William Bernhardt is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.

More Related Content

What's hot

Tutoring Autobiography
Tutoring AutobiographyTutoring Autobiography
Tutoring AutobiographyGemma Luscombe
 
My reflection on my teaching event
My reflection on my teaching eventMy reflection on my teaching event
My reflection on my teaching eventAcademicallyCorrect
 
Constructivism in Education
Constructivism in EducationConstructivism in Education
Constructivism in EducationLynneveC2012
 
Practicum reflection-apr27
Practicum reflection-apr27Practicum reflection-apr27
Practicum reflection-apr27mimbyla
 
Self-Assessment: Kindergarten
Self-Assessment: KindergartenSelf-Assessment: Kindergarten
Self-Assessment: Kindergartenludmila81
 
Self-Assessment: Primary
Self-Assessment: PrimarySelf-Assessment: Primary
Self-Assessment: Primaryludmila81
 
Emotional Journal Entries 1-12
Emotional Journal Entries 1-12Emotional Journal Entries 1-12
Emotional Journal Entries 1-12Mirnell
 
Journals of Study Skills
Journals of Study SkillsJournals of Study Skills
Journals of Study SkillsAmmiBermudez
 
Reflection on my role and expectations of the professional practicum experience
Reflection on my role and expectations of the professional practicum experienceReflection on my role and expectations of the professional practicum experience
Reflection on my role and expectations of the professional practicum experiencedannaet
 
Internship Carolina
Internship CarolinaInternship Carolina
Internship Carolinapilibarrera
 
Students’ comments as a tool for teaching reflection
Students’ comments as a tool for teaching reflectionStudents’ comments as a tool for teaching reflection
Students’ comments as a tool for teaching reflectionA Faiz
 
Democratic Dialogue:Teachers\' Reflections on Learning Lead to New Practices ...
Democratic Dialogue:Teachers\' Reflections on Learning Lead to New Practices ...Democratic Dialogue:Teachers\' Reflections on Learning Lead to New Practices ...
Democratic Dialogue:Teachers\' Reflections on Learning Lead to New Practices ...Heather Duncan
 
statement of teaching and research interests
statement of teaching and research interestsstatement of teaching and research interests
statement of teaching and research interestsKellie McKinney
 
LESSON OBSERVATION Wayne Stagg 2014
LESSON OBSERVATION Wayne Stagg 2014LESSON OBSERVATION Wayne Stagg 2014
LESSON OBSERVATION Wayne Stagg 2014wayne140858
 
Kindergarten Journal
Kindergarten JournalKindergarten Journal
Kindergarten Journalludmila81
 

What's hot (20)

Tutoring Autobiography
Tutoring AutobiographyTutoring Autobiography
Tutoring Autobiography
 
My reflection on my teaching event
My reflection on my teaching eventMy reflection on my teaching event
My reflection on my teaching event
 
Constructivism in Education
Constructivism in EducationConstructivism in Education
Constructivism in Education
 
Practicum reflection-apr27
Practicum reflection-apr27Practicum reflection-apr27
Practicum reflection-apr27
 
Self-Assessment: Kindergarten
Self-Assessment: KindergartenSelf-Assessment: Kindergarten
Self-Assessment: Kindergarten
 
Self-Assessment: Primary
Self-Assessment: PrimarySelf-Assessment: Primary
Self-Assessment: Primary
 
Emotional Journal Entries 1-12
Emotional Journal Entries 1-12Emotional Journal Entries 1-12
Emotional Journal Entries 1-12
 
Journals of Study Skills
Journals of Study SkillsJournals of Study Skills
Journals of Study Skills
 
Reflection on my role and expectations of the professional practicum experience
Reflection on my role and expectations of the professional practicum experienceReflection on my role and expectations of the professional practicum experience
Reflection on my role and expectations of the professional practicum experience
 
Journal entries
Journal entriesJournal entries
Journal entries
 
Internship Carolina
Internship CarolinaInternship Carolina
Internship Carolina
 
REFLECTIONS
REFLECTIONS REFLECTIONS
REFLECTIONS
 
Portfolio
PortfolioPortfolio
Portfolio
 
Students’ comments as a tool for teaching reflection
Students’ comments as a tool for teaching reflectionStudents’ comments as a tool for teaching reflection
Students’ comments as a tool for teaching reflection
 
My Learning process
My Learning processMy Learning process
My Learning process
 
Democratic Dialogue:Teachers\' Reflections on Learning Lead to New Practices ...
Democratic Dialogue:Teachers\' Reflections on Learning Lead to New Practices ...Democratic Dialogue:Teachers\' Reflections on Learning Lead to New Practices ...
Democratic Dialogue:Teachers\' Reflections on Learning Lead to New Practices ...
 
statement of teaching and research interests
statement of teaching and research interestsstatement of teaching and research interests
statement of teaching and research interests
 
Minimizing the chaos
Minimizing the chaosMinimizing the chaos
Minimizing the chaos
 
LESSON OBSERVATION Wayne Stagg 2014
LESSON OBSERVATION Wayne Stagg 2014LESSON OBSERVATION Wayne Stagg 2014
LESSON OBSERVATION Wayne Stagg 2014
 
Kindergarten Journal
Kindergarten JournalKindergarten Journal
Kindergarten Journal
 

Viewers also liked

Potential mechanisms underlying the yogurt-body weight relationship
Potential mechanisms underlying the yogurt-body weight relationshipPotential mechanisms underlying the yogurt-body weight relationship
Potential mechanisms underlying the yogurt-body weight relationshipYogurt in Nutrition #YINI
 
Bo tui sq 02
Bo tui sq 02Bo tui sq 02
Bo tui sq 02lifaens
 
Мой любимый цветок
Мой любимый цветокМой любимый цветок
Мой любимый цветокgexarvest
 
04 relatorio-gerencial
04 relatorio-gerencial04 relatorio-gerencial
04 relatorio-gerencialredeminastv
 
Contoh Curiculum vitae pembicara UKMI NURUL `ILMI
Contoh Curiculum vitae pembicara UKMI NURUL `ILMIContoh Curiculum vitae pembicara UKMI NURUL `ILMI
Contoh Curiculum vitae pembicara UKMI NURUL `ILMIFitri Nofiati
 
11 а клас
11 а клас11 а клас
11 а класtan4ikbah
 
Proposal flue heat recover new
Proposal flue heat recover newProposal flue heat recover new
Proposal flue heat recover newEngr Asif Sultan
 

Viewers also liked (14)

Potential mechanisms underlying the yogurt-body weight relationship
Potential mechanisms underlying the yogurt-body weight relationshipPotential mechanisms underlying the yogurt-body weight relationship
Potential mechanisms underlying the yogurt-body weight relationship
 
ctchou-resume
ctchou-resumectchou-resume
ctchou-resume
 
Photo
PhotoPhoto
Photo
 
Bo tui sq 02
Bo tui sq 02Bo tui sq 02
Bo tui sq 02
 
แแ
 
Мой любимый цветок
Мой любимый цветокМой любимый цветок
Мой любимый цветок
 
Hikikomori power
Hikikomori powerHikikomori power
Hikikomori power
 
04 relatorio-gerencial
04 relatorio-gerencial04 relatorio-gerencial
04 relatorio-gerencial
 
Contoh Curiculum vitae pembicara UKMI NURUL `ILMI
Contoh Curiculum vitae pembicara UKMI NURUL `ILMIContoh Curiculum vitae pembicara UKMI NURUL `ILMI
Contoh Curiculum vitae pembicara UKMI NURUL `ILMI
 
cercadors
cercadorscercadors
cercadors
 
11 а клас
11 а клас11 а клас
11 а клас
 
Agribusiness Marketing Forum 2016
Agribusiness Marketing Forum 2016Agribusiness Marketing Forum 2016
Agribusiness Marketing Forum 2016
 
Proposal flue heat recover new
Proposal flue heat recover newProposal flue heat recover new
Proposal flue heat recover new
 
report2
report2report2
report2
 

Similar to Articles en learning_experiences_1

Characteristics of good teacher
Characteristics of good teacherCharacteristics of good teacher
Characteristics of good teacherGedion Firdawek
 
Self Evaluation And Self Reflection Essay
Self Evaluation And Self Reflection EssaySelf Evaluation And Self Reflection Essay
Self Evaluation And Self Reflection EssayEbony Bates
 

Similar to Articles en learning_experiences_1 (20)

Reflection Paper Essay
Reflection Paper EssayReflection Paper Essay
Reflection Paper Essay
 
Reflection Essays
Reflection EssaysReflection Essays
Reflection Essays
 
Leadership Resilience
Leadership ResilienceLeadership Resilience
Leadership Resilience
 
Essay About My Self
Essay About My SelfEssay About My Self
Essay About My Self
 
Sample Essay About Reading
Sample Essay About ReadingSample Essay About Reading
Sample Essay About Reading
 
I Am A Very Passionate And Emotional Person Essay
I Am A Very Passionate And Emotional Person EssayI Am A Very Passionate And Emotional Person Essay
I Am A Very Passionate And Emotional Person Essay
 
Personal Reflective Essay Examples
Personal Reflective Essay ExamplesPersonal Reflective Essay Examples
Personal Reflective Essay Examples
 
Characteristics of good teacher
Characteristics of good teacherCharacteristics of good teacher
Characteristics of good teacher
 
My First Childhood Across Cultures Class Essay
My First Childhood Across Cultures Class EssayMy First Childhood Across Cultures Class Essay
My First Childhood Across Cultures Class Essay
 
Self-Evaluation Writing Assignment
Self-Evaluation Writing AssignmentSelf-Evaluation Writing Assignment
Self-Evaluation Writing Assignment
 
How Has The Environment Affected My Life
How Has The Environment Affected My LifeHow Has The Environment Affected My Life
How Has The Environment Affected My Life
 
My Classroom Assessments
My Classroom AssessmentsMy Classroom Assessments
My Classroom Assessments
 
Self Evaluation And Self Reflection Essay
Self Evaluation And Self Reflection EssaySelf Evaluation And Self Reflection Essay
Self Evaluation And Self Reflection Essay
 
Final reflections
Final reflectionsFinal reflections
Final reflections
 
Do Your Essay
Do Your EssayDo Your Essay
Do Your Essay
 
My English Essay
My English EssayMy English Essay
My English Essay
 
Literacy Essay Topics
Literacy Essay TopicsLiteracy Essay Topics
Literacy Essay Topics
 
My Writing Habits
My Writing HabitsMy Writing Habits
My Writing Habits
 
My Writing Experience With Writing
My Writing Experience With WritingMy Writing Experience With Writing
My Writing Experience With Writing
 
Reflection On African American Studies
Reflection On African American StudiesReflection On African American Studies
Reflection On African American Studies
 

More from Centre de ressources pédagogique : formations et matériels

More from Centre de ressources pédagogique : formations et matériels (20)

La « classe » en pédagogie des Mathématiques - Caleb Gattegno
La « classe » en pédagogie des Mathématiques - Caleb GattegnoLa « classe » en pédagogie des Mathématiques - Caleb Gattegno
La « classe » en pédagogie des Mathématiques - Caleb Gattegno
 
Articles en silent way_13
Articles en silent way_13Articles en silent way_13
Articles en silent way_13
 
Articles fr les mathematiques_1
Articles fr les mathematiques_1Articles fr les mathematiques_1
Articles fr les mathematiques_1
 
Articles fr lecture en couleurs_12
Articles fr lecture en couleurs_12Articles fr lecture en couleurs_12
Articles fr lecture en couleurs_12
 
Articles en words_incolor_13
Articles en words_incolor_13Articles en words_incolor_13
Articles en words_incolor_13
 
Articles en words_incolor_12
Articles en words_incolor_12Articles en words_incolor_12
Articles en words_incolor_12
 
Articles en words_incolor_11
Articles en words_incolor_11Articles en words_incolor_11
Articles en words_incolor_11
 
Articles en words_incolor_10
Articles en words_incolor_10Articles en words_incolor_10
Articles en words_incolor_10
 
Articles en words_incolor_9
Articles en words_incolor_9Articles en words_incolor_9
Articles en words_incolor_9
 
Articles en words_incolor_8
Articles en words_incolor_8Articles en words_incolor_8
Articles en words_incolor_8
 
Articles en words_incolor_7
Articles en words_incolor_7Articles en words_incolor_7
Articles en words_incolor_7
 
Articles en words_incolor_5
Articles en words_incolor_5Articles en words_incolor_5
Articles en words_incolor_5
 
Articles en words_incolor_4
Articles en words_incolor_4Articles en words_incolor_4
Articles en words_incolor_4
 
Articles en words_incolor_3
Articles en words_incolor_3Articles en words_incolor_3
Articles en words_incolor_3
 
Articles en words_incolor_2
Articles en words_incolor_2Articles en words_incolor_2
Articles en words_incolor_2
 
Articles en therotical_reflections_9
Articles en therotical_reflections_9Articles en therotical_reflections_9
Articles en therotical_reflections_9
 
Articles en therotical_reflections_8
Articles en therotical_reflections_8Articles en therotical_reflections_8
Articles en therotical_reflections_8
 
Articles en therotical_reflections_6
Articles en therotical_reflections_6Articles en therotical_reflections_6
Articles en therotical_reflections_6
 
Articles en therotical_reflections_5
Articles en therotical_reflections_5Articles en therotical_reflections_5
Articles en therotical_reflections_5
 
Articles en therotical_reflections_4
Articles en therotical_reflections_4Articles en therotical_reflections_4
Articles en therotical_reflections_4
 

Articles en learning_experiences_1

  • 1. http://www.uneeducationpourdemain.org     Page 1 sur 4   Becoming a Teacher: one person's experience - William Bernhardt I'm not sure when I first thought about becoming a teacher but it couldn't have been any later than the fourth grade when I was nine years old. Perhaps because I was often intimidated by other children who seemed to be more intelligent and more forceful than myself, there was something very appealing about being in control of a class. I daydreamed of the time when I might stand in front of thirty children and impress them with the knowledge and authority which I was unable to exert on my contemporaries. How much my teachers seemed to know! It seemed that they could answer any question. Often, when some wise guy in the class posed a difficult query to one of my teachers I felt a sense of protective identification and a slight twinge of fear. How could she possibly find an answer to this one? And then, without a moment's hesitation, the answer came, confidently and forcefully. How proud and delighted I felt at such moments! How smart my teacher is, I thought, but then a disquieting ripple passed over my mind as I wondered whether I could ever know so much. Later on, as my own store of information expanded, I was more critical and less admiring. Now I secretly thrilled when one of my teachers was caught in a mistake or an evasion. Still later, in College, I was shocked to discover that for many of my professors, teaching was a matter of keeping one chapter ahead of the class, of turning unwelcome questions back on the questioner ("and what do you think, Bill?") or of dismissing topics for which the instructor had no ready supply of words ("I think we should defer this until next week"). Discovering the weaknesses of my teachers, and observing the strategies and tactics they employed to cover their ignorance and defensiveness, made me feel more confident about becoming a teacher myself. Not only had I acquired information to rival some of my professors, but I fancied that I had prepared myself to be an unusually lively and entertaining presence in the classroom. At the time when I began my teaching career I felt that I had a very great deal to 'give' my students. Comparatively speaking, I had read everything and they nothing. To what extent that illusion was shared by those in my classes I can't say. My impression is that one or two people in each of my courses were inspired by my performance (as I had been by certain of my own instructors) to the extent of emulation my style of telling an anecdote, my way of turning aside unwelcome questions, or my techniques for making dry topics slightly amusing. But, in the main, those who entered the class as 'good students' were continuing an apprenticeship launched somewhere else, and the rest endured with the same mixture of resignation and good will that they brought to all of their other courses. I enjoyed performing when a class "went well". But I couldn't fail to notice that what transpired in the classroom was always less intense and engaging for me than the period of
  • 2. http://www.uneeducationpourdemain.org     Page 2 sur 4   solitary preparation which preceded it. I felt that my own, independent acquisition of knowledge was the "real" thing, whereas time spent with the students was a distraction from what I perceived as "my own work". That there was any alternative to these habitual ways of thinking and acting never occurred to me during my first ten years as a college professor in Britain and the U.S. It was due to and almost chance event -a workshop in Spanish which I took at Educational Solutions in New York during July, 1971- that I first became aware of my lack of preparation as a teacher. During the morning of the first day of the workshop, as I struggled to master the Spanish sounds associated with each of the rods, the teacher asked me what seemed at the time to be both a mysterious and irrelevant question: "What are you doing with yourself?" And when I was unable to frame a reply she asked another question: "Are you using your energy to listen or in trying to remember? Do you know the difference between 'trying' and 'opening up to the sounds'?" What struck me most forcibly was her attitude. It was clear that she didn't care much about the Spanish vocabulary she had introduced or whether I would ever 'get it'. What concerned her was what was happening inside me. She wanted to know whether I knew what I was doing or if the whole experience was a blur. I didn't learn much Spanish during that week. Learning to take account of what was happening inside myself became my task instead. As the days passed, I became far more attentive to my own inner movements and aware of how little attention I had habitually given to such study. By the end of the week I could definitely discriminate between various internal states and know, with certainty, when I was "with it", when I was distracted by my emotions (such as my anxiety to appear as a 'good student'), when I was putting blocks in the way of the sounds reaching me, and so on. That week represented the first time in my life that I was actively monitoring my own inner dynamics to observe what I was "doing with myself". Acquiring this new awareness made me also acknowledge my previous unconsciousness. I saw that I had always viewed my own learning as a mysterious (sometimes miraculous) phenomenon because I had no way of observing it as it happened. Previously, my learning could only be tested through external feedback. Now, I was acquiring my own inner criteria. Many of the lessons of this week only came to me later on, through reflection and with the added impact of additional seminars and workshops led by Dr. Gattegno. Even then, however, I recognized that I had passed an important threshold. I realized that learning could, and must be studied in what was for me a new way -as a psychological reality within my own mind. Further, I acknowledged that teaching, as I had encountered it in the Spanish course, was something different than I had always assumed it to be. Its primary focus was not a body of content or skills but the learner. Having arrived at these new awarenesses, I was also struck by the fact that, on a verbal level, they were hardly 'new'. For years, I had heard (and spoken) of "knowing within oneself", "understanding the process of learning", and other such phrases. But it was only during this week, and its aftermath, that these words truly gained a concrete reality for me and assumed the force of fresh perceptions. Thus, when I resumed teaching the following September, I approached the classroom in a very different spirit than ever before and with many new preoccupations: ▪ Learning is something which, when it happens, happens inside me; it is therefore a matter of awareness or consciousness rather than behavior or performance. ▪ Because my learning is inner, private, it is only truly accessible to me... if I have prepared myself to monitor its presence... and is largely invisible from outside.
  • 3. http://www.uneeducationpourdemain.org     Page 3 sur 4   ▪ Teaching, by contrast to learning, is a matter of externals. That I teach is no guarantee that learning takes place. ▪ Because of the disjunction between teaching and learning, a teacher such as myself needs to become a specialist in my own inner experience of learning. Without this, how can .I ever hope to work with others? ▪ The challenge of becoming a specialist in my own learning is at least as difficult as mastering the content of any academic field, probably more so. Having these concerns prompted me to prepare for my courses in English Composition in a new way, by studying my own internal process. I began by asking myself the questions "What happens in me to produce writing? What do I do with myself? As this was my first attempt to make an independent study of myself, I can't say that I proceeded in a disciplined or systematic manner. I was frankly groping. I was probably too easily satisfied by the first answers that came to mind. Still, I had to start somewhere. What came to me was that writing had never been for me as it was described in the textbooks. It was never triggered by outlines or notes, or thinking about my prospective audience. These all came later. What I found to be crucial was a certain inner state or climate which I could call 'the writing state of mind'. Without this, no amount of outside pressure or 'motivation' would elicit writing. Later on, I was to probe deeper, to find the precise attributes of this state, but at this stage it was sufficient for me to recognize that the ground level of writing was a certain inner preparation. So I asked myself further questions: "Are there external conditions which seem particularly compatible with achieving the writing state of mind? Can I provide my students with an environment that will encourage them to mobilize themselves the same way that I do?" During that term I began each class by asking the students to compose for a few minutes (sometimes longer) in little blue examination booklets which I distributed to them for this purpose. I demanded that they "keep the pencil moving continuously. If you can't think of anything to write, simply write words selected at random." When each day's writing was completed, the booklets were closed without reading or discussion of their content. Nor did I ever read what the students had composed. I did, however, question them at the conclusion of each day's writing experience, asking them "What has happened to you today? Do you know what happens in you at the moment when the words start to come? Is the process today any different today than it was yesterday, or last week?" At first, most of the students found it difficult to talk about themselves rather than about what was on the paper. They would start to report what they had written about, or the extent to which they found it easy or hard to find something to say without a prompt from the teacher. Gradually, however, individuals in the group began to notice the presence of an inner sense of something to say which seemed prior to language. Some also reported on the existence of mental imagery that triggered words and a variety of inner voices - some dictating, as it were, to their writing hands; others criticizing and judging. This was by no means a precisely formulated exercise, and there were some who seemed totally unaffected by it. Still, it represented a new way of working for me: ▪ I was starting from what I knew of myself, with the assumption that the learners in my classes were like me. ▪ I was focusing not on the product (what they wrote) or my own ideas and theories but on what the students were doing with themselves and noticing about themselves. ▪ I had stopped trying to give the learners advice and tips. ▪ I was making the encounter with the learners in the classroom the center of my teaching life. ▪ I was suspending my judgment about students who didn't respond favorably to what was
  • 4. http://www.uneeducationpourdemain.org     Page 4 sur 4   happening in the class instead of viewing them as hostile or deficient. These changes in my way of working did not, I want to emphasize, transform me into a good teacher. But they did make me more of a teacher. That is, they helped my to approach my students in a more conscious, more humble, and more empirical spirit. As I continued to look into myself, with the aid of further workshops and seminars with Dr. Gattegno and his staff, I was struck by many more questions: ▪ What inhibits me from writing? Can I be inhibited by my need to use words I can't spell? By assigned topics which find no echo in my experience? By my own standards of "good writing"? ▪ Do I know when I have something to say? How? ▪ Is there anything I can say orally but not write? Are there any significant differences .for me between speaking and writing besides spelling? ▪ What role does mental imagery play in my composing? Does seeing the content in my mind always help me find words? ▪ How do I cope with the fact that the words often come fast but my hand transcribes them more slowly? Do I have a way of holding what I say until my hand catches up to my voice? ▪ Where are my grammatical criteria? In my intellect? In my ears? In my voice? Where? ▪ How do I prepare myself to address a variety of different audiences (the readers of this article, my students, my more scholarly colleagues, etc.)? My reflection on these and other questions continues. I find that, as time goes on, I have more rather than fewer questions to think about. For me, becoming a teacher has been first and foremost a process of initiating an internal dialogue. It has been a matter of learning to recognize the necessity of setting aside all the knowledge that I have previously accumulated in order to examine myself from within and be with the here and now. I can't claim that the last 19 years of self-examination accompanied by experimentation and improvisation in the classroom have made me a great or even a good teacher. But I am certain that I have become a teacher. William Bernhardt New York, 1990 "Becoming a Teacher: one person's experience" by William Bernhardt is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.