by Christopher Philips, Assistant Professor, Dept. of Entomology, University of Minnesota.
Presented at the 2015 Minnesota Statewide High Tunnel Growers Conference, Beginning Grower Workshop
Intro to High Tunnel Insect Pests and Natural Enemies, 2015
1. Introduction to High Tunnel Insect Pests
and Natural Enemies
Christopher Philips
Assistant Professor
Fruit and Vegetable Entomologist
University of Minnesota
Department of Entomology
North Central Research & Outreach Center (NCROC)
2. High Tunnel IPM
To reduce pests below damaging levels while maintaining economic profits,
environmental quality and safety.
3. IPM Implementation
• Step 1 – Identify the pest.
• Step 2 – Evaluate the pest infestation level
• (sampling, monitoring, amount of injury).
• Step 3 – Assess the tolerance level of the commodity to injury.
• Step 4 – Take an action (or no action!).
4. Insect identification
• Why do I need to identify it anyway?
• Determines your management strategy
• Different problems require different solutions
• NOT ALL INSECTS ARE BAD
6. Spotted wing Drosophila (SWD)
• Drosophila suzukii
• native to Asia
• lays eggs into healthy,
ripening soft fruits,
using a saw-like
ovipositor
SWD non-SWD Photo credits: N. Gompel (top); M. Hauser (bottom)
7. What are my management options?
1) Biological
2) Genetic
3) Cultural
4) Mechanical
5)…Chemical…
(last option, only when necessary)
10. Thrips
>7,000 species described worldwide
most are not pests
Biology
migrate into MN
Frequency
A recent survey of Midwest greenhouse
operators identified WFT as the most
difficult greenhouse pest to manage
20°C, ~ 19 days.
25°C, ~ 13 days.
11. Damage
have piercing-sucking, multi-purpose
mouthparts.
The mouthparts are used to pierce leaves,
flowers, seeds, pollen grains, and fruit, as
well as to drink open liquids such as nectar,
water, or insect secretions;
transmit pathogens
Thrips
Hosts and Damage
Extremely wide host range
12. Thrips feeding damage on
cucumber fruit.
Thrips feeding damage on
cucumber leaves
Thrips Damage
Oviposition scars and feeding
damage on sweet pepper.
Thrips egg-laying scars on tomato
Thrips feeding damage on pepper
leaves.
A very important aspect of thrips is the transmission of
virus diseases.
Tomato spotted wilt virus,
transmitted by the
• western flower thrips,
• tobacco thrips, and
• onion thrips.
13. Sanitation
• Remove weeds that act as a thrips (virus) refuge.
• Remove and destroy crop residues and affected
plants after harvest.
• Pasteurize soil to kill immature thrips.
• Pruning
Thrips
Cultural and Mechanical
14. Thrips
Biological Control
Amblyseius cucumeris
• Amblyseius cucumeris prefers a diet of thrips but is
considered a generalist because it can survive on pollen
and spider mites in the absence of thrips.
A. cucumeris will work best at a temperature of 70˚F or above
and RH > 65%.
Orius insidiosus
• Minute pirate bug is a common generalist predator found naturally
in many field-grown crops.
• It preys on thrips, whiteflies, spider mites, aphids and many other
pests. It can survive on pollen in the absence of prey.
15. Intrinsic capacity of Orius
insidiosus to reduce flower
thrips populations
Predator-Prey Ratios
1 : 217 = population suppression
1 : 51 = rapid local extinction
From: Sabelis & Van Rijn (1997) Thrips as Crop Pests. (Lewis, ed.) CAB International, UK
Thrips Predation
Photo Joe Funderburk
16. Whiteflies
Silverleaf and sweetpotato whiteflies
(Bemisia argentifolii and B. tabaci)
Greenhouse whitefly
(Trialeurodes vaporariorum)
Bandedwinged whitefly
(Trialeurodes abutilonea)
17. Biology
Do not overwinter in MN
continue from year to year in greenhouses
Frequency
Common pest in MN
Control
There is really no easy way to control
whiteflies
Whiteflies
18. Aphids
Melon/cotton aphid, Aphis gossypii
Green peach aphid, Myzus persicae
Biology
Overwinter and migrate into MN
Frequency
Common pest in MN
Control
Usually not necessary; biological control
19. Aphids and Whiteflies
Hosts and Damage
Numerous Host
Damage
• Piercing/sucking mouthparts,
• plant distortion and discoloration,
• leaf chlorosis,
• leaf withering and premature leaf drop plant
• death;
• Excrete honeydew, promotes the growth of sooty mold
20. Aphids and Whiteflies
Damage
Tomato yellow leaf curl virus
Vector taxa Vector group Total plant viruses
Hemiptera Aphids 197
Whiteflies 128
Melon aphids are known
to transmit 44 plant
viruses, while green
peach aphids are known
to transmit more than
100 plant viruses
21. Aphid and Whitefly
Management
• Prevent outbreaks of aphids by scouting weekly
and releasing natural enemies at the first sign of
damage.
• Inspect the upper and lower surfaces of plant
leaves
• If you disturb the plant foliage, whitefly adults
will fly up and be easier to spot.
• Use a hand lens
• Also check for evidence of natural enemies such
as lady beetles, lacewings, syrphid fly larvae and
the mummified skins of parasitized aphids. Look
for disease-killed aphids as well:
• They may appear off-color, bloated or
flattened.
22. Sanitation
• Remove weeds in and around high tunnels
Limit the use of quick-release fertilizer
Aphid and Whitefly
Cultural and Mechanical
Photo credit: Galen Weston,
23. Biological control of Aphids:
Parastitoids
Aphidius colemani
Works best at a temperature of 50 to 76˚F and tolerates
cool temperatures.
Aphidius ervi
This small, black wasp parasitizes all types of large aphids.
It prefers an air temperature of 86˚F.
24. Biological Control of Whiteflies:
Parasitoids
Encarsia formosa
(Hymenoptera: Aphelinidae)
8-10 eggs per day
Primary Prey: whiteflies and aphids
Key Characters: parasitized hosts turn black
Vegetable crops: release needed
Eretmocerus eremicus
E. formosa prefers an average temperature above 64˚F,
and RH >70%
25. Parasitoids
Insect which lives in or on
another insect during its
immature stages. Differs
from parasitism in that:
1. only larval stages are
parasitic, adults are
typically free flying
2. larvae eventually kill
their host
28. Feed on over 180 host plants, including
over 100 cultivated species
Damage
• Spider mites injure leaves by piercing cells
and sucking out cell contents.
• This injury produces white or yellow spots
or "stippling" that is heaviest on the
underside of the leaves
• As mite numbers increase, these white
speckles will increase in number, the leaf
will take on a bleached appearance and die.
Two-spotted Spider Mite
Host and Damage
29. • Chemical control of spider mites generally involves pesticides that are
specifically developed for spider mite control
• Few insecticides are effective for spider mites and many even aggravate
problems.
• Furthermore, strains of spider mites resistant to pesticides frequently
develop, making control difficult.
0
20
40
60
80
100
TSSM
94
Two-spotted Spider Mite
Management
30. Two-spotted Spider Mite
Cultural and Mechanical
Sanitation
• remove alternative hosts could reduce infestation of plants
nearby
• disposing of old or infested plant material
Inspections
Avoid over-fertilization
• promotes succulent new growth which is more susceptible
to two-spotted mites.
Use of high-pressure water spray or overhead irrigation to dislodge
spider mites
31. Predators are very important in regulating spider
mite populations and should be protected whenever
possible.
Important predators include:
the predatory mites,
• Phytoseiulus persimilis,
• Mesoseiulus longipes,
• Neoseiulus californicus,
• Neoseiulus fallicus
• Galendromus occidentalis
The lady beetle, Stethorus;
The minute pirate bugs, Orius;
Two-spotted Spider Mite
Biological control
34. Insect Growth and Development
Affected by two major factors, time and temperature
The amount of heat required by an organism to complete its development
is known as physiological time.
• Minimum or lower developmental threshold is the temperature below
which insect development is negligible.
• Maximum or upper developmental threshold is the temperature at which
insect growth stops.
35. Why Do Insect Pest Problems Occur?
• Almost unlimited food and improved environmental conditions
• Multiple generations - up to 12-15 / year
• Limited natural enemies to reduce populations
• Some life stages are not susceptible to treatment
• Major insecticide and miticide resistance
36. Biological control
• “the enemy of my enemy is my friend”
• e.g., predators, parasitoids, pathogens
• Biological control is a method of controlling
pests using other living organisms.
Types of Biological Control
Classical
Augmentation
inundative releases and
inoculative releases
Conservation
38. Getting Started
• Start small and start early
• Pesticide Residues and when needed use soft pesticides
• Good Sanitation
• Weed management is critical
• Clean Transplants
+
41. What are my management options?
1) Biological
2) Genetic
3) Cultural
4) Mechanical
5)…Chemical…
(last option, only when necessary)
42. Types of Natural Enemies
Generalists and Specialists
Predators and Parasitoids
Pathogens
43. Nymphs and adult stage
Primary Prey: whiteflies, thrips, aphids
Predatory Stage: nymphs and adults
Key Characters: very small, black and white coloration
Vegetable crops: most
Minute Pirate Bugs
Hemiptera: Anthocoridae
44. Intrinsic capacity of Orius
insidiosus to reduce flower
thrips populations
Predator-Prey Ratios
1 : 217 = population suppression
1 : 51 = rapid local extinction
From: Sabelis & Van Rijn (1997) Thrips as Crop Pests. (Lewis, ed.) CAB International, UK
Thrips Predation
Photo Joe Funderburk
45. Big-eyed bugs
Hemiptera: Goecoridae
Geocoris punctipes
Big-eyed bug
Primary Prey: insect eggs, small insects and larvae
Predatory Stage: nymphs and adults
Key Characters: small black, gray or tan with large
eyes
Vegetable crops: most
46. Damsel bugs
Hemiptera: Nabidae Nabis spp.
Primary Prey: insect eggs, small insects and larvae
Predatory Stage: nymphs and adults
Key Characters: slender yellowish-brown with narrow head,
prominent eyes and long antennae
Vegetable crops: most
47. Primary Prey: aphids and whiteflies
Predatory Stage: larvae
Key Characters: Mosquito-like adults; small
orange maggots
Vegetable crops: most attacked by aphids
Predatory Midge
Diptera: Cecidomyiidae
Predatory Midge: Feltiella acarisuga
48. Hover Flies
Diptera: Syrphidae
Primary Prey: aphids and small caterpillars
Predatory Stage: larvae
Key Characters: adults resemble bees,
maggots are tapered near head, green or
pinkish, near aphids
Vegetable crops: most attacked by aphids
49. Primary Prey: aphids, mites, small insects, eggs
Predatory Stage: larvae and adults
Key Characters: alligator-like larvae; red or orange
adults with black markings
Vegetable crops: most
Lady Beetles
Coleoptera: Coccinellidae
Coleomegilla maculata
Larva
C. septempunctata
Delphastus pusillusDelphastus catalinae Stethorus punctum
Harmonia axyridis
450 species of lady bugs in NA
50. Rove Beetles
Coleoptera: Staphylinidae
Primary Prey: root maggot eggs, other soft bodied
insects
Predatory Stage: larvae and adults
Key Characters: slender, short forwings
Vegetable crops: cole crops, onions, corn, and
others
51. Ground Beetles
Coleoptera: Carabidae
Many, many species - usually ground-dwelling generalist predators
Larva
Elaphrus
Clivina
Notiophilus
Lebia
Primary Prey: soil-dwelling eggs larvae and pupae
Predatory Stage: larvae and adults
Key Characters: dark, sometime metallic color; fast moving,
ground dwelling, thread-like antennae
Vegetable crops: most
eggs are inserted into soft plant tissues, including flowers, leaves, stems and fruit
two plant-feeding larval stages occur
the insect drops to the soil and enters a pupal stage
Both larvae and adults feed on flowers, leaves, twigs, or buds, using their piercing-sucking mouthparts, causing structural abnormalities of foliage in the form of leaf malformation (distorted, dwarfed, and matted), leaf fold, leaf roll, leaf blisters, and sometimes defoliation; causing discoloration of petals, deformation, or scarring of flowers
15
Whiteflies suck phloem sap. Large populations can cause leaves to turn yellow, appear dry, or fall off plants.
All major crops families
Substantial numbers of any of these natural control factors can mean that the aphid population may be reduced rapidly without the need for treatment.
Virtually nothing is known about the ecology of E. formosa in outdoor agricultural systems
Principal greenhouse crops include tomato and cucumber
probing with the ovipositor for up to six minutes and feeds from wounds
Very diverse group – thousands of species
Mostly wasps
Life history are unique and highly vary
Rarely seen due to their small size.
It is unlikely that you will see much I any parasitoid activity, but these are the types of thigs that you will see
good indication that parasitoids are at work.
Two-spotted spider mite populations may be higher in greenhouses that use only drip irrigation which keeps foliage dry. The use of occasional overhead irrigation will wash mites off plants.
Very susceptible to temp and humidity
Development is highly temp dependent
600 species of predators in 45 families of insects
And
Over 600 species in 23 families of spiders and mites
With this kind of diversity it is hard to make generalization about predators.
If you wait until you see pest or damage…it is too late.
Predators
Typically, insect predators are characterized by a set of attributes that distinguish them from parasitoids.
They are large relative to their prey - require more than one prey individual to complete development; they have free-living predatory immature stages - many species of insect predators are predacious as both immatures and adults and - predacious insects consume their prey immediately after attack.
================================================================
Parasitoids - Defined by the feeding habits of the larvae
The larvae feed exclusively on the body of another arthropods, its host, eventually killing it.
Only a single host is required, and many parasitoids can emerge from a single host. Godfray referes to parasitoids as a intermediate between predators and parasites. Like predators they always kill the host they attack, like parasites they require a single host to mature.
Insect pest and beneficials can be classified into two broad feeding groups, specialist and generalist. - It is estimated that 90% or more of all insect herbivore species are
There are a lot of grey areas with these terms. This is because insects can specialize on plant families, genera, or even be species specific.
ALL IPM requires an understanding of the cropping system including the pest their natural enemies and the surrounding environment.
Black and white color
Nymphs 33 spider mites a day
Important predator of corn earworm, corn leaf aphid, potato leafhopper
1940 research in VA 14-54% corn earworm egg destruction
44
Impacts are not well known
On cotton reported to consume 1600 mites over developmetn
Adults 80 mites per day
Can survive on plant provided resources when prey is scarce – may actually track high quality plant resources
May be susceptible to systemic insecticides
Slender yellowish brown
Common in alfalfa and grass cover crops
Females live up to 2 weeks
250 eggs
Common and abundant in many habitats
Important pollinators and many are bee mimics
Larvae develop over two to three weeks and can consume as many as 400 aphids in that time.
Adult can consume up to 50 aphids in a day
Delphastus avoids feeding on parasitized whiteflies
Adults can eat >600 whitefly eggs or 11 large larvae per day.
A single beetle can consume as many as 10,000 whitefly eggs or 700 larvae during its lifetime
S. punctum consume up to 100 mites per day they quickly lessen an outbreak of spider mites.
Over 30 species in some onion plantings
Up to 95%control of cabbage maggot
Ground dwellers – generally
Have been the most abundant predator in several surveys
Might be thinking what I am I showing you these ground predators for foliar pests….thats a good question…
Impale prey – inject a toxin that paralyzes the prey – then suck out the body fluids
Very diverse group
Really only two major predators
Largest and most diverse group of insects.
Hardened forewings are a key characteristic.
A single species impact may be minor but comebined the impact may be considerable.
Spiders are often over looked as beneficials in vegetabels and little is known about their biology
Mantids are true generalists
overwinter as eggs – several hundred nymphs from a single egg mass
Mites – good for spider mite and thrips…can get where sprays and other predators can not
Female can lay several hundred eggs
Larvae are highly mobile
cannibalistic
two to three weeks
Mostly aphid feeders
100 – 600 aphids during development