Fostering Friendships - Enhancing Social Bonds in the Classroom
Why She Feels Fat
1. Understanding and responding to college
students with food and body image
issues
Sara Weber, LPC
Counseling & Mental Health Center, UT Austin
2. Overview
Binge, Purge, Starve…What’s the difference?
Why does this happen?
Beyond the behaviors
College students and eating disorders
Treatments for Eating Disorders
The Phases of Recovery
How to help a friend or loved one.
Take Home Messages
3.
4. What’s the Difference?
Eating Disorders (anorexia, bulimia and binge eating) have
many things in common even though they manifest
differently. All eating disorders:
Seem like they are only about food and weight but it isn’t
that simple.
Are a way of coping: using food, exercise, and weight
obsession as a way to organize life & manage emotions.
Create a sense of security, control, predictability, etc.
Involve an intense emotional connection with food and
weight.
Can happen to men, women, old, and young.
5. Anorexia
Anorexia is characterized by the belief that “If I can get thin
enough, my life will be better”.
Start off as a desire to “get thinner”, “lose some weight”
Stability and success in life is dependent on being thin.
Even when others believe s/he is thin enough, s/he doesn’t
“feel” thin. Perception is warped by malnutrition.
Restricting foods, fasting, over-exercising, purging to lose
weight.
Malnutrition can promote restriction via delusions.
Physical complications complicate re-feeding.
6. Anorexia: Warning Signs
Preoccupation with weight Rapid, significant weight loss
Relentless drive to be thin Obsessively reading cookbooks
Withdrawal from friends or Cooking for other people
group activities Intense sensitivity to criticism
Irritability or mood swings Intense fear of failure
Fear of specific foods Food rituals
Compulsive calorie or fat gram Rigid and compulsive
counting scheduling
Lying about not eating Growth of fine hair (lanugo) on
Preoccupation with how food is arms, face, or back
prepared Hair loss
Perfectionist standards; high Injuries (fractures, pulled
achievement muscles)
7. Anorexia: Medical Complications
Weakening of the heart due to Osteoporosis (bone loss)
malnutrition (possible heart Lowered immune system
failure) function/ low resistance to
Low blood pressure infection
Low body temperature Low blood sugar
Low heart rate Kidney impairment or failure
Irregularities or loss of Bone, ligament, and tendon
menstruation injuries due to malnutrition
Fertility problems Memory loss
Dehydration Gastrointestinal disturbance
Electrolyte imbalance Metabolic changes
Anemia (low iron)
8. Bulimia
Bulimia is characterized by competing beliefs that food will solve every
problem (binge) and that it is “poisonous” and must be
avoided/eliminated (purge).
Like Anorexia, most people start off with the desire to lose “a little” weight.
Compensatory methods used to “purge” include: vomiting, laxatives, over-
exercise, or restricting after a binge. Purging methods are usually less effective
than the individual realizes.
What constitutes a binge depends on the perspective of the person engaged in
the binge and the difference can be vast.
Food is used to “numb out” but the anesthetizing effects are fleeting so the
urgent need to “get rid of” the food emerges. Purging can also feel numbing.
Typically average to high weight with sometimes dramatic weight changes .
Underweight individuals have higher health risks.
9. Bulimia: Warning Signs
Preoccupation with weight Intense sensitivity to criticism
Binge eating Withdrawal from friends or
Going to the bathroom right group activities
after eating Irritability or mood swings
Hoarding or stealing food Swollen facial glands (chipmunk
Overuse of laxatives, water pills, cheeks)
diet pills. Marks on knuckles
Secretive eating Depression (suicidal thoughts)
Eating when not hungry Feeling “out of control” with
Water retention, swollen limbs eating or life
Self-hatred or disgust Weight fluctuations
Withdrawal or isolation Perfectionist standards; high
achievement
10. Bulimia: Medical Complications
Abnormal heart rate (possible Lowered immune system
cardiac arrest) function/ low resistance to
Irregularities or loss of infection
menstruation Kidney impairment or failure
Fertility problems Gastrointestinal dysfunction
Dehydration (ulceration, pain, bleeding,
Electrolyte imbalance bloating, constipation, non-
responsive bowels)
Anemia (low iron)
Metabolic changes
Esophageal bleeding or rupture
Tooth decay
Increased risk of throat and
mouth cancer
11. Eating Disorder NOS
Eating Disorder Not Otherwise Specified includes all other
variations of disordered eating:
Sudden weight loss and restriction but not underweight or
hasn’t lost her menstrual cycle.
Binge eating / purging infrequently.
Binge eating but no purging, “binge eating disorder”.
Chewing food and spitting it out.
Chronic, excessive dieting, reducing quality of life.
Orthorexia: A fixation with healthy or righteous eating.
While an anorexic wants to be thin, an orthorexic does not
desire thinness but wants to feel pure, healthy and natural.
12.
13. Why does this happen?
Contributing factors are varied:
Physical changes in puberty
Brain Chemistry
Family
Changing family roles
Personality Characteristics
Overwhelming events
Cultural Factors
Dieting is a risk factor. Almost all EDs start with dieting.
14. Biology
Puberty Brain Chemistry
Both men and women Anxiety & depression are
experience dramatic changes in dictated by brain chemicals
their body during puberty. called neurotransmitters.
Women need to increase body Serotonin- Regulates hunger
fat in order to initiate and fullness. Disturbances are
menstruation. associated with binge/purge.
Women often don’t realize the Norepinephrine- Regulates
necessary changes of puberty mood, alertness, & response to
and resort to drastic behaviors to stress. Disturbance connected to
go back to pre-pubescent shape. Anorexia.
Genetics are a factor.
15. Family
Family Relationships Changing Family Roles
Families of people with eating Normal development of
disorders have some independence and identity is a
commonalities: product of family’s teaching.
Difficulty expressing Too much, too soon:
emotions. Expecting child to be
Lack healthy bonds: Too close independent and responsibly
(enmeshed), Too distant too quickly.
(neglect) or an erratic Overprotecting: Not trusting
combination of both. the child to make good choices
Remember families are typically on their own.
doing the best that they can!
16. Personality and Life Events
Personality Characteristics Overwhelming Events
There are varied personalities in Precipitated by an event that feels
those with ED but there are some overwhelming or traumatic.
commonalities: Leaving home for the 1st time
Perfectionist Death in the family/ friend
Highly-driven Bullying or teasing
Ambitious Verbal or physical abuse
Anxious or “high strung” Sexual trauma
Sensitive Moving homes
Intuitive Divorce
“People pleasing” Marriage
Self-doubting & insecure
18. Cultural Factors
Although it hasn’t always been this way, a person’s value
is often associated with thinness, fitness. Many of us
base our self-worth on the extent to which we can
conform to society’s idea of the “perfect” body.
19. Cultural Factors
Women: Unrealistic standards of thinness, beauty, &
shape
Female thin-ideal: thin, toned, busty
Thin = happy, successful, loved, accepted, desired.
Men: Unrealistic standards of strength, power, and
success
Male “buff”-ideal: cut, lean, muscular
22. The Language of Fat
1. How many times this week have you had negative
thoughts about your body or someone else’s body?
2. How many times this week have you thought about a
better life five pounds from now or when you are prettier,
sexier, more fit?
3. How many conversations have you had with other people
this week about food, weight, exercise, or dieting?
4. How many times this week have you compared yourself to
other people or to images in the media?
5. How many hours each day do you spend wishing you
looked different?
25. Beyond the Behaviors
The eating disorder is an adaptive behavior:
self-preservation.
Life is extremely intense for someone who develops an
ED. S/he wasn’t sure how to handle life before the ED.
The eating disorder is a source of support.
“Best friend” : shielding him/her from the
overwhelming parts of life that s/he can’t face alone.
Helping “numb out” when things get to be “too much”.
26. Beyond the Behaviors
Emotions
Feel emotions very intensely
Lack confidence in ability to tolerate emotions
ED behaviors “numb out” and the emotions are
avoided for the time being. “Stuffing” with food.
“Purging my feelings out”. “Starving denies I have
feelings”.
“I feel fat” is a cover up for emotions that are hard to
face.
Lost the ability to identify, face, and manage emotions.
27. Beyond the Behaviors
Self-Concept
Loss of identity: interests, personality, etc. Focus on food and
appearance as the solution to problems, prevents normal
development of self-concept and eats away at existing identity.
Life is the ED.
Negative self-concept: never good enough, smart enough, pretty
enough. Arguably a way to appease their drive (perfection) but it
actually sabotages success in life.
Perfection: “Be perfect, or be nothing”.
Innate inadequacy: Fraud myth- “one day, pe0ple will discover the
truth and abandon me”.
Body Image: Bases self-worth on body size.
28. Beyond the Behaviors
Relationships
Relating to others can be confusing, frightening, and distressing.
Values relationships greatly.
People pleasing and very good at reading others’ needs and
responding to them.
Doesn’t accept help/love very easily b/c of fear of being
vulnerable.
Vulnerability is debilitating so they often end relationships
before they get too close.
Doubts of their worth and fear of abandonment prevent them
from feeling safe or secure in relationships.
29.
30. College Survey ~ 1,000 students
● 20% of respondents believe that at some point they have suffered
from an eating disorder . National research says it is only .05-4%.
● More than half of those polled said they know at least one
person who has struggled with an eating disorder.
● Almost 80% of students have dieted & avoided or skipped meals.
● 45% of the students know someone who compulsively exercises,
almost 40% know someone who purges by vomiting, and 25%
know someone who abuses laxatives.
● Among those who confirmed they have had an eating disorder or
still suffer from it, nearly 75% of that group never received
treatment.
National Eating Disorders Association, 2007
31. College- Unique Challenges
Significant transition- academically, socially, time-
management, responsibility (bills, car, health), self-care (eating,
sleeping).
Communal eating. Eating schedule may depend on peers.
Roommates influence eating and body image.
Consistent interpersonal challenges- constant social interaction.
Getting “lost in the crowd”: Once the big fish in a little pond
but now a little fish in a big pond. Losing identity from high
school (sports, cheerleader, popular, best at…etc.)
Coping with and managing long-distance family & friend
relationships.
32. College- Unique Challenges
The college environment is especially toxic for body image:
Body change between age 18-22 years is normal yet
unexpected for most college students.
Fear of the freshman 15
Shopping together, sharing clothes, high pressure fashion
bubble.
Events focused on body image: Rush, “socials”, football,
parties, “going out”.
Prime-time for dating creates an incubator for dialogue &
concern about body and appearance.
Going back to home town during break encourages
comparison of body changes with peers from high school.
33.
34. Treatment
Eating Disorder specialists are necessary.
Choose a team from the beginning:
Psychotherapist – license not as important as training.
Dietitian – Using nutrition info for good and not evil
Physician – Medical monitoring is key!
Psychiatrist – Optional (as needed)
Group – Reducing shame, not feeling alone.
Family therapy- If needed, crucial for some people.
35. The Mindful Eating Program
Outpatient “light”
Assessment focused
“Academic Success” is our main goal
Strength-based
Not a treatment program.
Recovery support.
Services:
Bi-weekly therapy
group counseling, and
medical monitoring.
36. ME: Assessment & Referral
Students are asked to complete a thorough assessment.
Psychological
Medical
Dietetic
Sometimes psychiatric and/or off-campus specialists
(cardiologist) are required for the full assessment.
After this assessment we provide feedback about the next steps
and offer guidance in developing a treatment plan.
If a student is outside of our scope of care, they are given
treatment recommendations by the team.
Off-campus, outpatient treatment team (weekly, ongoing)
Intensive Outpatient Therapy
Inpatient treatment
37. The Phases of Recovery
Stabilization: Medical, behavioral, nutritional, &
psychological (anxiety/depression, insight, communication,
changing thinking, working with emotions).
Exploring: gaining a deeper understanding of how the
ED functions in their life. Developing healthier coping
strategies. Addressing body image.
Recovering life: 1) maintain progress, 2) resume life
activities & develop new ones, 3) become fully engaged
in life without relapse.
38. When a friend or a loved one is facing eating issues.
39. As a professional, you can help…
Know about eating disorders
Warning signs
Health risks
Costs (personal, financial, emotional) of the struggle
Bring it up (if it is your role)
“Do you have any concerns about your relationship with food or
exercise?”
Do not focus on weight
Focusing on weight, size, or good/bad eating is not helpful. Instead the
focus should be on health behaviors- movement, nutrition, self-care.
Listen and don’t judge
Remind yourself that they are struggling with an eating disorder
because they are trying to manage something that must be very
challenging for them right now. Have compassion for their struggle.
Acknowledge your emotions & take care of yourself
40. As a friend, you can help…
Learn about eating disorders
Talk to him/her
Be and stay aware
Break through secrecy
Listen
Help him/her get support
Acknowledge your emotions
Take care of yourself
Focus on life beyond the illness
Encourage authenticity
42. Don’t Diet…
• Avoid categorizing foods as “good/safe” vs. “bad/dangerous.”
Remember, we all need to eat a balanced variety of foods.
• You will not be happier just because you are thin, busty, or
fit. Look around and consider examples of thin people who are
miserable and large people who are happy.
• Dieting harms your body- yes even so-called “healthy”
diets. Your body needs variety and nutrition- don’t sacrifice your
health to be thin.
• Larger people can be healthy too. Eating nutritious foods and
staying active is the prescription for health- regardless of your
size.
• Encourage a culture that values a healthy relationship with
food. Slow down, enjoy food, & listen to your body.
43. Fat Talk – Stop it!
Begin listening more closely to the language other women
and men are using to speak to each other and the language
you are using with yourself.
Decide to avoid judging others and yourself on the basis
of body weight or shape. Turn off the voices in your head
that tell you that a person’s body weight says anything
about their character, personality, or value as a person.
Pay attention to the media messages that reinforce Fat Talk.
Begin to explore the emotions that are going on “behind” Fat
Talk…are you feeling scared, ashamed, vulnerable?
Request honesty and intimacy with others- change the
subject when the Fat Talk takes over your conversations.
44.
45. What you need to know!
Anyone can recover from an eating disorder.
Recovery is a tough road but a journey worth taking!
College is a prime time to develop an eating disorder
(or for an old struggle to come back).
Professionals can offer compassion for patients so that
the patients can have compassion for themselves.
Talk about eating disorders, weight, and food in ways
that challenge the status quo & change the paradigm.
Reach out to people you see struggling- you might
plant a seed, you might save a life.
46.
47. Why She Feels Fat by McShane & Paulson
www.gurze.com
www.austineds.com
www.edin-ga.org
www.nationaleatingdisorders.org
www.endfattalk.com
www.somethingfishy.org
www.eatingrecoverycenter.com
www.cmhc.utexas.edu/mindfuleating.html
48. As a friend, you can help…
Learn about eating disorders
Talk to him/her
Be and stay aware
Break through secrecy
Listen
Help him/her get support
Acknowledge your emotions
Take care of yourself
Focus on life beyond the illness
Encourage authenticity
49. You can help…
Learn about eating disorders
Websites, books, talking to a therapist and someone
who has been through it before.
Talk to him/her
Remember that they feel the ED is vital to their survival
and will feel threatened if you criticize it.
Use I statements, “I feel… when you…” or “I am worried
about ….(specific behavior)”.
Remind him/her that you are there to listen and check
in occasionally so that s/he doesn’t feel like you are
ignoring the issue now that you brought it up.
50. You can help…
Be and stay aware
Keep your eyes open for subtle improvements
Stay tuned into possible relapse behaviors and bring them up
the same way you did when you initially confronted him/her.
Break through secrecy
There is a strong drive to hide the ED, even after admission
that s/he wants to recover. Talk about this struggle to keep
the ED a secret and offer compassion for this desire while also
challenging him/her to be as transparent as possible.
Listen
Listening is one of the most important things you can do.
This is hard if you don’t know how to help or don’t
understand what they are going through but listening openly
is still a valuable support to offer.
51. You can help…
Help him/her get support
Offer your support in any way possible. Ask often if there is
anything you can do for him/her.
Help him/her find things to enjoy again- hobbies, activities,
interests. Encourage putting time and energy into things s/he
might enjoy and offer to go too.
Acknowledge your emotions & Take care of yourself
It can be maddening to be in a support position of someone
with an ED. Take care of yourself and get support when
needed.
It is ok if you can’t be the primary support person all the time.
You can model emotional awareness and self-care.
Rely on your own support system.
52. You can help…
Focus on life beyond the illness
Plan activities and enjoy time together that isn’t related to the
ED at all. These may need to be non-food events.
Don’t put life on hold for the ED (although be mindful of
limitations of recovery length, e.g. don’t start a new degree).
Focus on aspects of your friend or loved one that were there
before the ED took over (personality or interests)
Encourage authenticity
There is a tendency to deny that they are really struggling so
look ways s/he may be trying to look “fine” and intervene to
offer help and challenge them to acknowledge their struggles.