SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 22
Download to read offline
i
COVER PAGE
Title : Financial Performance of 2 companies in
Cement Industry
Subject : FFBD
Level / Semester : I / Feb 2010
Programme : MBA-FULL TIME
Subject Tutor : Mr. L. Augustine
Name of Student : Vivekanandan M
Student’s Registration Number : GPBL-B/F10/15
Date of Submission : Apr 09, 2010
Word Count : 1850 words
Word Limit : 2000 words
ii
Checklist
Students Name Vivekanandan M
Registration Number GPBL-B/F10/15
Date of submission of the Assignment
09/04/2010
Is the cover page in the correct format as indicated in the
“Guidelines to writing Assignments”?
Yes
Have I done a complete spell-check of the Assignment?
Yes
Have I done a complete word count for the Assignment?
Yes
Does the table of contents include numbers?
Yes
Are the pages numbered correctly?
Yes
Are the figures numbered correctly?
Yes
Are the tables/charts numbered correctly?
Yes
Are the captions for the tables and charts proper?
Yes
Are the references/bibliography listed in the Assignment?
Yes
Are the references cited correctly in the text?
NA
All references material has been cited from the books & the
University of Wales online library. Any other internet
source quoted is with the permission of the module tutor.
NA
Are the references in the text in the proper format as
indicated in the “Guidelines to Writing Assignments”
Yes
Has the soft copy of the Assignment been enclosed?
Yes
Declaration:
All material written in this assignment is my own and I have not used any material,
content or information of others claiming them to be mine. Wherever materials have
been used, proper citation has been done in the text. I am fully aware of the rules
and regulations governing plagiarism. Should at any point of time my work be
suspected/investigated and established to have been plagiarized, I am aware of the
consequences. I have read the Student’s Handbook in detail.
___________________
Signature of the student Date: 09/04/2010
iii
TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE No.
List of Tables iv
List of Figures v
Introduction 1
Company Analysis for the period 2007 – 2009 3
Breakeven Volume Analysis 12
Conclusion 16
Bibliography 17
iv
LIST OF TABLES PAGE No.
Table 1 - Financial performance of ACC Ltd 1
Table 2 - Financial performance of JK Cement 2
Table – 3 - Computation of Cost of goods sold for ACC Ltd 4
Table 4: Cost of goods sold computation for JK Cement 6
Table 5: Production capacity and production volume for ACC Ltd
and JK Cement
7
Table 6: Computation of market price of cement (per 100 kg) 8
Table 7: Volume produced by top 7 cement companies in India
9
Table 8: Computation of average market price for cement (per
100kg)
10
Table 9: Computation of volume produced by the cement industry
11
Table 10: Breakeven Volume computation for ACC Ltd
13
Table 11: Breakeven Volume computation for JK Cement
15
v
LIST OF FIGURES PAGE No.
Figure 1: Sales Volume and Growth 2
Figure 2: Profit before Tax and Profit after Tax 2
Figure 3: Trend in cost of finished goods for ACC Ltd 4
Figure 4: Trend in cost of finished goods for JK Cement 6
Figure 5: Comparison between volume produced and production
capacity for ACC Ltd
7
Figure 6: Comparison between volume produced and production
capacity for JK Cement
8
Figure 7: Comparison between ACC Ltd selling price and average
market price
10
Figure 8: Comparison between JK Cement selling price and average
market price
11
1
Introduction
Indian economy is expected to grow at 7 to 8% during the fiscal year 2010. This growth is fueled
by growth in housing sector and infrastructure sector. The demand for housing sector and
infrastructure sector has fueled cement industry’s growth. Cement industry is growing at 13%,
which looks attractive to investors.
Following 2 companies are selected for the analysis,
a. ACC Ltd
b. JK Cements
ACC Ltd is the market leader in cement industry and JK Cements is the second largest producer
of white cement. These 2 companies are selected to analyze the growth of cement industry with
respect to the volume and the average market price.
ACC Ltd have reported 20% growth (Y-O-Y) in net profit during second half of the FY 2009
and JK cements have reported 140% growth (Y-O-Y) in net profit during second half of the FY
2009.
a) Analyst view on ACC Ltd
ACC Ltd is the largest cement producer in India, with the market share of 12%. The
company has added 1.1 MT per annum capacity at Bargarh. The company will add 3MT
per annum capacity by Q1 2010 by increasing the griding facilities at Wadi, Thondebhavi
and Kudithini.
FY 2009 (in Lac) FY 2008 (in Lac) Change (%)
Sales 91719.6 86336.6 6
PBDIT 27081.9 19853.3 36
PBIT 23350.6 16648 40
PBT 22507 16248.2 38
PAT 15639.1 10996.5 42
EPS 79.31 55.13 43
Dividend 23 20 15
Table 1: Financial performance of ACC Ltd
Currently the stock is trading at 11 times its earnings (CMP = 957.30). With the addition
of the new facilities, the company will increase the production capacity by 14%.
2
Figure 1: Sales Volume and Growth (Source: ACC Ltd Balance Sheet 2009)
Figure 2: Profit before Tax and Profit after Tax (Source: ACC Ltd Balance Sheet 2009)
b) Performance analysis of JK Cement
JK Cement is the second largest producer of white cement. Global economic slowdown
and the domestic demand have affected the company’s performance during the year
2009. With the growth of infrastructure and housing sector in this financial year, the
company is also expected to grow with the increase in demand for cements.
FY 2009 (in Lac) FY 2008 (in Lac) Change (%)
Sales 16644.2 15955.7 4
PBDIT 3401.6 4388.5 -22
PBIT 2877.3 3977.8 -27
PBT 2330.6 3465.7 -32
PAT 1414.4 2651.7 -46
EPS 20.36 37.94 -47
Table 2: Financial performance of JK Cement
3
Company Analysis for the period 2007 - 2009
a. Analysis of price of finished goods for the period 2007 - 2009
Items 2009 2008 2007
(Rs. Cr) (Rs. Cr) (Rs. Cr)
ACC Ltd
Manufacturing expenses
Purchase of Cement 93.16 87.36 93.31
Raw materials consumed 891.51 799.12 767.73
Stores and spare parts consumed 10.03 13.86 20.78
Packing material consumed 238.72 280.14 230.01
Power and fuel 1539.65 1598.96 1243.63
Repairs to building 14.14 14.72 9.57
Repairs to Machinery 323.3 276.21 264.34
Repairs to Other Items 67.87 70.92 75.5
Royalties 98.39 86.69 84.95
Excise Duties 84.54 117.08 110.02
Payment To and Provision for employees
Salaries, wages, dearness allowance and bonus 318.27 311.23 268.76
Contribution / Provision to and for Provident and Other
funds 18 63.53 31.48
Workmen and staff welfare expenses 31.44 41.56 53.03
Administrative, Selling and Other Expenses
Rent 32.59 33.22 34.14
Rates and Taxes 101.45 98.75 112.2
Insurance 17.6 17.86 18.3
Loading, Transportation and othercharges 169.69 176.98 163.91
Discounts,rebates and allowances 93.49 105.2 114.08
Commission on sales 23.12 20.24 15.5
Other Expenses (loss on sale / write off of fixed assert) 270.48 286.55 253.35
Provision for bad and doubtfuldebt 31.26 0.71 26.33
Advertisement 53.16 47.56 41.77
Outward freight charges on cement 1054.41 1001.58 944.22
(Increase) / Decrease in stocks in trade and work-in-
progress
Closing Stock
4
Finished Goods 88.08 78.86 81.26
Work-in-progress 168.96 149.44 146.71
Opening Stock
Finished Goods 78.86 81.26 63.98
Work-in-progress 149.44 146.71 157.06
Cost of Goods Sold 5547.53 5549.7 4969.98
Sales Volume (Million Tonnes) 21.52 21.01 19.97
Price of finished goods (per 100 Kg) 257 264 248
Table 3: Computation of Cost of goods sold for ACC Ltd
Figure 3: Trend in cost of finished goods for ACC Ltd
For the period 2007-2008, the cost of finished goods has been increased by Rs: 14. 4%
increase in raw materials cost, 28% increase in power and fuel cost, 16% increase in
salaries, 100% increase in PF contribution and 6% increase in freight charges has led to
increase of 5% in the manufacturing cost.
For the period 2008-2009, the cost of finished goods has been decreased by Rs: 7. 15%
reduction in packaging materials cost, 27% reduction in excise duty, 71% reduction in PF
contribution and 11% reduction in discount/rebates has lead to the reduction in the
manufacturing cost by 2%.
240
245
250
255
260
265
270
2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009
Cost of finished goods (per 100 kg)
Cost of finished goods
(100 kg)
5
Company Items 2009 2008 2007
(Rs. Cr) (Rs. Cr) (Rs. Cr)
JK Cement
Manufacturing expenses
Purchase of Trading goods 0.48 0.31 0.45
Raw materials consumed 162.96 140.59 122.3
Stores and spare consumed 30.75 36.72 28.45
Packing material consumed 64.8 57.43 55.25
Power and fuel 376.14 329.69 309.7
Repairs to building 4.43 3.18 3.21
Repairs to Machinery 21.08 16.89 13.75
Repairs to Other Items 0.21 0.38 0.36
Insurance 2.59 2.66 3.11
Excise Duties 1.08 -1.05 1.06
Payment To and Provision for employees
Salaries, wages and bonus 64.06 50.18 35.19
Contribution to Provident fund and Other funds 10.3 7.95 5.5
Welfare expenses 9.41 9.5 8.13
Administrative and Other Expenses
Rent 3.53 2.62 2.14
Lease Rent 0 0.36 0.39
Rates and Taxes 11.08 2.18 2.08
Travelling and Conveyance Expenses 8.93 7.61 6.68
Provision for doubtful debts and advances 0.16 3.99 4.52
Debts written off 1.59 0 0.59
Loss on sale / impairment of fixed assert (net) 0.3 0.46 0.56
Expenses relating to previous year 0.1 0.08 0
Misc. Expenses 40.45 33.11 27.57
Selling and Distribution Expenses
Advertisement and Publicity 14.72 11.95 10.57
Commission, brokerage and incentives 22.04 13.46 11.99
Selling expenses 14.86 7.789 7.99
Freight and handling outward 311.9 287.17 244.35
(Increase) / Decrease in stocks in trade and work-in-
progress
Closing Stock
Finished Goods 11.33 10.13 15.1
6
Work-in-progress 14.93 10.9 23.2
Opening Stock
Finished Goods 10.13 15.1 11.94
Work-in-progress 10.9 23.2 24.52
Cost of Goods Sold 809.2 722.11 629.15
Sales Volume (Million Tonnes) 3.79 3.76 3.77
Price of finished goods (per 100 Kg) 213 192 166
Table 4: Cost of goods sold computation for JK Cement
Figure 4: Trend in cost of finished goods for JK Cement
For the period 2007-2008, the cost of finished goods has been increased by Rs: 26. 15% increase
in raw material cost, 6% increase in power and fuel, 42% increase in salaries and 17% increase
in freight has led to increase in cement price by 15%.
For the period 2008-2009, the cost of finished goods has been increased by Rs: 21. 15% increase
in raw materials cost, 12% increase in packaging materials cost, 28% increase in salaries, 450%
increase in taxes, 21% increase in miscellaneous expenses, 22% increase in advertisement
expenditure has lead to the increase in cement price by 10%.
0
50
100
150
200
250
2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009
Cost of finished goods (per 100 kg)
Cost of finished goods
(100 kg)
7
b. Analysis of volume produced by 2 companies for the period 2007 - 2009
Volume Produced (in Million
Tonne)
Installed Capacity (in Million
Tonne)
Company/Ye
ar 2009 2008 2007 2009 2008 2007
ACC Ltd 21.52 21.01 19.97 26 22.62 22.4
JK Cement 3.79 3.76 3.77 4.47 4 4
Table 5: Production capacity and production volume for ACC Ltd
and JK Cement
Figure 5: Comparison between volume produced and production capacity for ACC Ltd
For the period 2007-2008, ACC LTd, has increased the production volume by 5% and the
company’s production capacity was increased by 1%. At the beginning of the year 2007, the
capacity utilization was 90%, which was increased to 93% by the end of 2008.
For the period 2008-2009, ACC LTd, has increased the production volume by 2% and the
company’s production capacity was increased by 15%. At the beginning of the year 2008, the
capacity utilization was 93%, which got decreased to 83% by the end of 2009.
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009
ACC Ltd Volume
Produced (Million
Tonne)
ACC Ltd Installed
Capacity (Million
Tonne)
8
Figure 6: Comparison between volume produced and production capacity for JK Cement
For the period 2007-2008, JK Cement, has marginally decreased the production volume. At the
beginning of the year 2007, the capacity utilization was 94.25%, which got marginally decreased
by the end of 2008.
For the period 2008-2009, JK Cement, has marginally increased the production volume and the
company’s production capacity was increased by 17%. At the beginning of the year 2008, the
capacity utilization was 94%, which got decreased to 85% by the end of 2009.
The capacity utilization of JK cement is consistently higher when compared with ACC cement
for the period 2007 to 2009.
c. Analysis of market price of 2 companies for the period 2007 - 2009
Volume Sold (in Million Tonne) Sales Turnover (Rs. Cr)
Average Market Price (Rs/100
kg)
Company/Year 2009 2008 2007 2009 2008 2007 2009 2008 2007
ACC Ltd 21.52 21.01 19.97 8724.24 8234.02 7848.32 405 391 393
JK Cement 3.79 3.76 3.77 1876.45 1812.84 1458.25 495 482 386
Table 6: Computation of market price of cement (per 100 kg)
3.4
3.6
3.8
4
4.2
4.4
4.6
2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009
JK Cement Volume
Produced (Million
Tonne)
JK Cement Installed
Capacity (Million
Tonne)
9
During the period 2007-2008, ACC Ltd selling price (of 100kg cement) was marginally
decreased and the sales was increased by 4% to maintain the same operating margin. During the
same period, JK Cement selling price was increased by 25% and the sales was increased by 3%.
During this period, inflation touched 16%, which increased the cost of funds, which has lead to
the increase in cement price by some companies.
During 2008-2009, ACC Ltd selling price was increased by 3% and sales was increased to 6% to
maintain the same operating margin. JK Cement selling price was also increased by 3% and sales
was increased by 4%.
d. Analysis of total volume produced by the market for the period 2007 - 2009
Volume Produced (in Million
Tonne)
Company/Year 2009 2008 2007
ACC Ltd 21 20.83 19.92
JK Cement 3.79 3.76 3.64
Ultratech Cement 15.8 15.06 14.63
Grasim 16.31 15.36 14.41
India Cements 9.11 9.23 8.42
Madras Cements 6.52 5.84 5.66
Birla Corp. 5.28 5.27 5.25
Total 77.81 75.35 71.93
Table 7: Volume produced by top 7 cement companies in India
During the period 2007-2008, the market has grown by 5%, wherelse ACC Ltd has grown by 4%
and JK Cement has grown by 3%. The growth for ACC Ltd has come through the production
capacity expansion. Although JK Cement has not increased the capacity, with their strong
distribution network, they increased their sales by 3%.
During 2008-2009 periods, the market has grown by 3% and ACC Ltd has grown marginally
(below 1%) and JK Cement has also grown marginally.
10
e. Analysis of price change of 2 companies with price movement for the period 2007 –
2009.
Volume Sold (in Million Tonne) Sales Turnover (Rs. Cr)
Average Market Price (Rs/100
kg)
Company/Year 2009 2008 2007 2009 2008 2007 2009 2008 2007
ACC Ltd 21.52 21.01 19.97 8724.24 8234.02 7848.32 405 391 393
JK Cement 3.79 3.76 3.77 1876.45 1812.84 1458.25 495 482 386
Ambhuja Cement 0 17.75 16.77 0 7075.51 6454.75 0 398 384
Ultratech Cement 15.8 15.01 15.16 5396.02 4838.88 4459.37 341 322 294
Grasim 16.31 15.12 14.84 6371.66 5721.46 5026.68 390 378 338
India Cements 9.11 9.21 8.41 3757.96 3535.16 2599.83 412 383 309
Madras Cements 6.47 5.72 5.62 2300.63 1898.64 1511.32 355 331 268
Birla Corp. 5.29 5.26 5.23 1866.02 1841.76 1647.5 352 350 315
Average = 392 379 335
Table 8: Computation of average market price for cement (per 100kg)
Figure 7: Comparison between ACC Ltd selling price and average market price
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009
ACC Ltd Selling cost
(per 100 kg)
Avg. Market Price (per
100kg)
11
Figure 8: Comparison between JK Cement selling price and average market price
During 2007-2008, the average market price was increased by 13%, ACC Ltd selling
price was decreased marginally and JK Cement selling price was increased by 25%.
During 2008-2009, the average market price was increased by 3% and ACC Ltd has also
increased the price by 3% and JK Cement also increased the price by 3%.
f. Analysis of volume produced by these 2 companies with the total volume produced by
the market for the period 2007 - 2009
Volume Produced (in Million
Tonne)
Company/Year 2009 2008 2007
ACC Ltd 21 20.83 19.92
JK Cement 3.79 3.76 3.64
Ultratech Cement 15.8 15.06 14.63
Grasim 16.31 15.36 14.41
India Cements 9.11 9.23 8.42
Madras Cements 6.52 5.84 5.66
Birla Corp. 5.28 5.27 5.25
Total 77.81 75.35 71.93
Table 9: Computation of volume produced by the cement industry
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009
JK Cement Selling cost
(per 100 kg)
Avg. Market Price (per
100kg)
12
During the year 2007, ACC Ltd market share was 27% and JK Cement market share was 5%. In
the year 2008, ACC Ltd market share was increased to 28% and JK Cement market share
remained at 5%. In the year 2009, ACC Ltd market share decreased to 27% and JK cement
market share fell below 5%.
Break Even Volume Analysis
Company Items 2009 2008 2007
Variable
Cost
Fixed
Cost
Variable
Cost
Fixed
Cost
Variable
Cost
Fixed
Cost
ACC Ltd
Manufacturing expenses
Purchase of Cement 93.16 87.36 93.31
Raw materials consumed 891.51 799.12 767.73
Stores and spare parts consumed 10.03 13.86 20.78
Packing material consumed 238.72 280.14 230.01
Power and fuel 1539.65 1598.96 1243.63
Repairs to building 14.14 14.72 9.57
Repairs to Machinery 323.3 276.21 264.34
Repairs to Other Items 67.87 70.92 75.5
Royalties 98.39 86.69 84.95
Excise Duties 84.54 117.08 110.02
Payment To and Provision for
employees
Salaries, wages, dearness allowance
and bonus 318.27 311.23 268.76
Contribution / Provision to and for
Provident and Other funds 18 63.53 31.48
Workmen and staff welfare
expenses 31.44 41.56 53.03
Administrative, Selling and Other
Expenses
Rent 32.59 33.22 34.14
Rates and Taxes 101.45 98.75 112.2
Insurance 17.6 17.86 18.3
Loading, Transportation and other
charges 169.69 176.98 163.91
Discounts,rebates and allowances 93.49 105.2 114.08
Commission on sales 23.12 20.24 15.5
Other Expenses (loss on sale / write
off of fixed assert) 270.48 286.55 253.35
Provision for bad and doubtfuldebt 31.26 0.71 26.33
Advertisement 53.16 47.56 41.77
Outward freight charges on cement 1054.41 1001.58 944.22
13
(Increase) / Decrease in stocks in
trade and work-in-progress
Closing Stock
Finished Goods 88.08 78.86 81.26
Work-in-progress 168.96 149.44 146.71
Opening Stock
Finished Goods 78.86 81.26 63.98
Work-in-progress 149.44 146.71 157.06
Total 5068.36 479.17 5016.2 533.5 4487.27 482.71
Sales Volume (Million Tonnes) 21 21 20.83 20.83 19.92 19.92
Cost (per 100 Kg) 241 22 240 25 225 24
2009 2008 2007
Break Even Volume Analysis
Total Fixed Cost 479.17 533.5 482.71
Sales per 100kg 405 391 393
Variable cost per 100kg 241 240 225
Break Even Volume (lac Tonne) 2.00 3.00 2.00
Net Profit 2294.39 1687.74 1717.18
Sales 21.52 21.01 19.97
Break Even Volume 29 31 27
Profit per 100 kg 117 93 95
Market Price 405 391 393
Cost of Goods sold 257 264 248
Profit per 100kg 148 127 145
Table 10: Breakeven Volume computation for ACC Ltd
14
Company Items 2009 2008 2007
Variable
Cost
Fixed
Cost
Variable
Cost
Fixed
Cost
Variable
Cost
Fixed
Cost
JK
Cement
Manufacturing expenses
Purchaseof Tradinggoods 0.48 0.31 0.45
Raw materials consumed 162.96 140.59 122.3
Stores and spareconsumed 30.75 36.72 28.45
Packingmaterial consumed 64.8 57.43 55.25
Power and fuel 376.14 329.69 309.7
Repairs to building 4.43 3.18 3.21
Repairs to Machinery 21.08 16.89 13.75
Repairs to Other Items 0.21 0.38 0.36
Insurance 2.59 2.66 3.11
ExciseDuties 1.08 -1.05 1.06
Payment To and Provision for employees
Salaries,wages and bonus 64.06 50.18 35.19
Contribution to Provident fund and Other
funds 10.3 7.95 5.5
Welfareexpenses 9.41 9.5 8.13
Administrative and Other Expenses
Rent 3.53 2.62 2.14
Lease Rent 0 0.36 0.39
Rates and Taxes 11.08 2.18 2.08
Travellingand Conveyance Expenses 8.93 7.61 6.68
Provision for doubtful debts and
advances 0.16 3.99 4.52
Debts written off 1.59 0 0.59
Loss on sale/ impairmentof fixed assert
(net) 0.3 0.46 0.56
Expenses relatingto previous year 0.1 0.08 0
Misc.Expenses 40.45 33.11 27.57
Selling and Distribution Expenses
Advertisement and Publicity 14.72 11.95 10.57
Commission,brokerage and incentives 22.04 13.46 11.99
Sellingexpenses 14.86 7.789 7.99
Freight and handlingoutward 311.9 287.17 244.35
(Increase) / Decrease in stocks in trade
and work-in-progress
Closing Stock
Finished Goods 11.33 10.13 15.1
Work-in-progress 14.93 10.9 23.2
Opening Stock
Finished Goods 10.13 15.1 11.94
15
Work-in-progress 10.9 23.2 24.52
Total 712.27 87.3 626.801 70.25 572.04 50.96
Sales Volume (Million Tonnes) 3.79 3.79 3.76 3.76 3.77 3.77
Cost (per 100 Kg) 187 23 166 18 151 13
2009 2008 2007
Break Even Volume Analysis
Total Fixed Cost 23 18 13
Sales per 100kg 495 482 386
Variable cost per 100kg 187 166 151
Break Even Volume (Million kg) 74.67 56.96 55.31
Table 11: Breakeven Volume computation for JK Cement
In the above breakeven volume computation for ACC Ltd and JK Cement, some costs are
classified as variable cost and some costs are classified as fixed cost.
Fixed costs are the cost, which does not depend on the volume of production. Eg. Rent,
employee salaries, PF, bonus is fixed cost.
Variable costs are the cost, which depend on the volume of the production. Eg. Raw materials
(directly depend on the volume of production), stores and spares (number of spares used,
depends on the wear and tear of the machinery), packaging material (depends on the volume
produced), power and fuel (depends on the volume of produced), repairs, insurance (to insure the
finished goods against natural damages – this depends on the volume produced), advertisement
(this depends on the volume produced), selling expenses (directly depends on the volume
produced).
For the period 2007-2008, the fixed cost for ACC Ltd has increased by 10%, which has lead to
increase in breakeven volume by 15%. During the same period, JK Cements fixed cost was
increased by 37%, which has lead to the increase in breakeven volume by 3%.
During 2008-2009, ACC Ltd fixed cost was decreased by 10%, which has lead to decrease in
breakeven volume by 6%. During the same period, JK Cement fixed cost was increased by 27%,
which has lead to increase in breakeven volume by 31%.
Companies which has less breakeven volume, has the potential to make more profits, than the
companies which has high breakeven volume, assuming both the companies will have same sales
volume.
16
Conclusion
a. During 2007-2008, ACC Ltd has marginally decreased the selling price, when compared
to 25% increase in the selling price by JK Cement.
During 2008-2009, ACC Ltd has increased the selling price by 3% and JK Cement has
also increased the selling price by 3%.
b. The market share of ACC Ltd is 27% and the market share of JK Cement is 5%.
17
Bibliography
1. http://www.jkcement.com/flash/pdfs/J_K_Cement_Annual_Report_2008-09_-
_Final_(23-07-09).pdf
2. http://www.jkcement.com/flash/pdfs/JK%20Cement%20AR%202007-08.pdf
3. http://www.jkcement.com/flash/pdfs/annualreport0607.pdf
4. Capital line software
5. http://www.acclimited.com/newsite/pdf/conso_results_09.pdf
6. http://www.acclimited.com/newsite/finance/Financialresults_2009.pdf
7. http://www.acclimited.com/newsite/finance/Financialresults-DEC-2008.pdf
8. http://www.acclimited.com/newsite/finance/Financialresults31122007.asp
9. http://www.nse-india.com
10. http://www.cmaindia.org/
11. http://www.ibef.org/industry/cement.aspx
12. http://www.moneycontrol.com

More Related Content

Similar to Financial Performance of 2 companies in Cement industry

Bosch 3 qcy2010ru-281010
Bosch 3 qcy2010ru-281010Bosch 3 qcy2010ru-281010
Bosch 3 qcy2010ru-281010Angel Broking
 
AAC Blocks (Autoclaved Aerated Concrete Blocks) - Market Survey cum Detailed ...
AAC Blocks (Autoclaved Aerated Concrete Blocks) - Market Survey cum Detailed ...AAC Blocks (Autoclaved Aerated Concrete Blocks) - Market Survey cum Detailed ...
AAC Blocks (Autoclaved Aerated Concrete Blocks) - Market Survey cum Detailed ...Ajjay Kumar Gupta
 
U.S. Concrete Block And Brick Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020
U.S. Concrete Block And Brick Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020U.S. Concrete Block And Brick Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020
U.S. Concrete Block And Brick Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020IndexBox Marketing
 
Sumitomo Corporation Annual Report 2012
Sumitomo Corporation Annual Report 2012Sumitomo Corporation Annual Report 2012
Sumitomo Corporation Annual Report 2012Mr Nyak
 
Irb ru2 qfy2011-281010
Irb ru2 qfy2011-281010Irb ru2 qfy2011-281010
Irb ru2 qfy2011-281010Angel Broking
 
Project feasibilty report on Pricision Auto pistons aniket kulkarni
Project feasibilty report on Pricision Auto pistons aniket kulkarniProject feasibilty report on Pricision Auto pistons aniket kulkarni
Project feasibilty report on Pricision Auto pistons aniket kulkarniANIKET KULKARNI
 
IND_United Tractors_FY16 Guidance Confirms Our Contrarian Bearish View 6 Nove...
IND_United Tractors_FY16 Guidance Confirms Our Contrarian Bearish View 6 Nove...IND_United Tractors_FY16 Guidance Confirms Our Contrarian Bearish View 6 Nove...
IND_United Tractors_FY16 Guidance Confirms Our Contrarian Bearish View 6 Nove...Hariyanto Wijaya, CFA, CFP
 
New report provides insights on setting up a cement manufacturing plant
New report provides insights on setting up a cement manufacturing plantNew report provides insights on setting up a cement manufacturing plant
New report provides insights on setting up a cement manufacturing plantIMARC Group
 
World: Parts And Accessories Of Motor Vehicles - Market Report. Analysis and ...
World: Parts And Accessories Of Motor Vehicles - Market Report. Analysis and ...World: Parts And Accessories Of Motor Vehicles - Market Report. Analysis and ...
World: Parts And Accessories Of Motor Vehicles - Market Report. Analysis and ...IndexBox Marketing
 
U.S. Asphalt Paving Mixture And Block Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020
U.S. Asphalt Paving Mixture And Block Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020U.S. Asphalt Paving Mixture And Block Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020
U.S. Asphalt Paving Mixture And Block Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020IndexBox Marketing
 
VN Automotive Eng
VN Automotive EngVN Automotive Eng
VN Automotive EngThuy Nguyen
 
[Final] vietnam white paper_2019 (web)
[Final] vietnam white paper_2019 (web)[Final] vietnam white paper_2019 (web)
[Final] vietnam white paper_2019 (web)Thuy Nguyen
 
AMRO(ASEAN+3 MACROECONOMIC RESEARCH OFFICE) AND MYANMAR
AMRO(ASEAN+3 MACROECONOMIC RESEARCH OFFICE) AND MYANMARAMRO(ASEAN+3 MACROECONOMIC RESEARCH OFFICE) AND MYANMAR
AMRO(ASEAN+3 MACROECONOMIC RESEARCH OFFICE) AND MYANMARMYO AUNG Myanmar
 
Firstcall man industries 21jul15
Firstcall man industries 21jul15Firstcall man industries 21jul15
Firstcall man industries 21jul15IndiaNotes.com
 

Similar to Financial Performance of 2 companies in Cement industry (19)

Bosch 3 qcy2010ru-281010
Bosch 3 qcy2010ru-281010Bosch 3 qcy2010ru-281010
Bosch 3 qcy2010ru-281010
 
AAC Blocks (Autoclaved Aerated Concrete Blocks) - Market Survey cum Detailed ...
AAC Blocks (Autoclaved Aerated Concrete Blocks) - Market Survey cum Detailed ...AAC Blocks (Autoclaved Aerated Concrete Blocks) - Market Survey cum Detailed ...
AAC Blocks (Autoclaved Aerated Concrete Blocks) - Market Survey cum Detailed ...
 
U.S. Concrete Block And Brick Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020
U.S. Concrete Block And Brick Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020U.S. Concrete Block And Brick Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020
U.S. Concrete Block And Brick Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020
 
Sumitomo Corporation Annual Report 2012
Sumitomo Corporation Annual Report 2012Sumitomo Corporation Annual Report 2012
Sumitomo Corporation Annual Report 2012
 
Tc10 bq 2011
Tc10 bq 2011Tc10 bq 2011
Tc10 bq 2011
 
Tc10 bqd13
Tc10 bqd13Tc10 bqd13
Tc10 bqd13
 
Irb ru2 qfy2011-281010
Irb ru2 qfy2011-281010Irb ru2 qfy2011-281010
Irb ru2 qfy2011-281010
 
Paper W3 2003
Paper W3 2003Paper W3 2003
Paper W3 2003
 
Project feasibilty report on Pricision Auto pistons aniket kulkarni
Project feasibilty report on Pricision Auto pistons aniket kulkarniProject feasibilty report on Pricision Auto pistons aniket kulkarni
Project feasibilty report on Pricision Auto pistons aniket kulkarni
 
IND_United Tractors_FY16 Guidance Confirms Our Contrarian Bearish View 6 Nove...
IND_United Tractors_FY16 Guidance Confirms Our Contrarian Bearish View 6 Nove...IND_United Tractors_FY16 Guidance Confirms Our Contrarian Bearish View 6 Nove...
IND_United Tractors_FY16 Guidance Confirms Our Contrarian Bearish View 6 Nove...
 
New report provides insights on setting up a cement manufacturing plant
New report provides insights on setting up a cement manufacturing plantNew report provides insights on setting up a cement manufacturing plant
New report provides insights on setting up a cement manufacturing plant
 
Auto pistons
Auto pistonsAuto pistons
Auto pistons
 
World: Parts And Accessories Of Motor Vehicles - Market Report. Analysis and ...
World: Parts And Accessories Of Motor Vehicles - Market Report. Analysis and ...World: Parts And Accessories Of Motor Vehicles - Market Report. Analysis and ...
World: Parts And Accessories Of Motor Vehicles - Market Report. Analysis and ...
 
U.S. Asphalt Paving Mixture And Block Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020
U.S. Asphalt Paving Mixture And Block Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020U.S. Asphalt Paving Mixture And Block Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020
U.S. Asphalt Paving Mixture And Block Market. Analysis And Forecast to 2020
 
VN Automotive Eng
VN Automotive EngVN Automotive Eng
VN Automotive Eng
 
[Final] vietnam white paper_2019 (web)
[Final] vietnam white paper_2019 (web)[Final] vietnam white paper_2019 (web)
[Final] vietnam white paper_2019 (web)
 
Management information Question Anaysis ICAB KL
Management information Question Anaysis ICAB KLManagement information Question Anaysis ICAB KL
Management information Question Anaysis ICAB KL
 
AMRO(ASEAN+3 MACROECONOMIC RESEARCH OFFICE) AND MYANMAR
AMRO(ASEAN+3 MACROECONOMIC RESEARCH OFFICE) AND MYANMARAMRO(ASEAN+3 MACROECONOMIC RESEARCH OFFICE) AND MYANMAR
AMRO(ASEAN+3 MACROECONOMIC RESEARCH OFFICE) AND MYANMAR
 
Firstcall man industries 21jul15
Firstcall man industries 21jul15Firstcall man industries 21jul15
Firstcall man industries 21jul15
 

More from Vivekanandan M

SWOT Analysis and formulation of Marketing Mix for Colgate sensitive
SWOT Analysis and formulation of Marketing Mix for Colgate sensitiveSWOT Analysis and formulation of Marketing Mix for Colgate sensitive
SWOT Analysis and formulation of Marketing Mix for Colgate sensitiveVivekanandan M
 
SWOT Analysis and formulation of Marketing Mix for Colgate sensitive PPT
SWOT Analysis and formulation of Marketing Mix for Colgate sensitive PPTSWOT Analysis and formulation of Marketing Mix for Colgate sensitive PPT
SWOT Analysis and formulation of Marketing Mix for Colgate sensitive PPTVivekanandan M
 
Pricing Models in IT Industry
Pricing Models in IT IndustryPricing Models in IT Industry
Pricing Models in IT IndustryVivekanandan M
 
Personality and Big Five Model
Personality and Big Five ModelPersonality and Big Five Model
Personality and Big Five ModelVivekanandan M
 
Microeconomic Analysis of a FMCG prod
Microeconomic Analysis of a FMCG prodMicroeconomic Analysis of a FMCG prod
Microeconomic Analysis of a FMCG prodVivekanandan M
 
Ethical Issues in Corporate Governance
Ethical Issues in Corporate GovernanceEthical Issues in Corporate Governance
Ethical Issues in Corporate GovernanceVivekanandan M
 
Ethical Issues in Corporate Governance PPT
Ethical Issues in Corporate Governance PPTEthical Issues in Corporate Governance PPT
Ethical Issues in Corporate Governance PPTVivekanandan M
 
Env anal eval of veg oil ind att in India
Env anal eval of veg oil ind att in IndiaEnv anal eval of veg oil ind att in India
Env anal eval of veg oil ind att in IndiaVivekanandan M
 
Env anal eval of veg oil ind att in India PPT
Env anal eval of veg oil ind att in India PPTEnv anal eval of veg oil ind att in India PPT
Env anal eval of veg oil ind att in India PPTVivekanandan M
 
Country Analysis - South Korea
Country Analysis - South KoreaCountry Analysis - South Korea
Country Analysis - South KoreaVivekanandan M
 
Computer hacking – Is it Ethical
Computer hacking – Is it EthicalComputer hacking – Is it Ethical
Computer hacking – Is it EthicalVivekanandan M
 
Computer hacking – Is it Ethical PPT
Computer hacking – Is it Ethical PPTComputer hacking – Is it Ethical PPT
Computer hacking – Is it Ethical PPTVivekanandan M
 
Case Analysis – Hedging Foreign
Case Analysis – Hedging ForeignCase Analysis – Hedging Foreign
Case Analysis – Hedging ForeignVivekanandan M
 
A Study on Trends and Determinants of Outward Foreign Direct Investment and I...
A Study on Trends and Determinants of Outward Foreign Direct Investment and I...A Study on Trends and Determinants of Outward Foreign Direct Investment and I...
A Study on Trends and Determinants of Outward Foreign Direct Investment and I...Vivekanandan M
 

More from Vivekanandan M (16)

Talent Management
Talent ManagementTalent Management
Talent Management
 
Talent Management PPT
Talent Management PPTTalent Management PPT
Talent Management PPT
 
SWOT Analysis and formulation of Marketing Mix for Colgate sensitive
SWOT Analysis and formulation of Marketing Mix for Colgate sensitiveSWOT Analysis and formulation of Marketing Mix for Colgate sensitive
SWOT Analysis and formulation of Marketing Mix for Colgate sensitive
 
SWOT Analysis and formulation of Marketing Mix for Colgate sensitive PPT
SWOT Analysis and formulation of Marketing Mix for Colgate sensitive PPTSWOT Analysis and formulation of Marketing Mix for Colgate sensitive PPT
SWOT Analysis and formulation of Marketing Mix for Colgate sensitive PPT
 
Pricing Models in IT Industry
Pricing Models in IT IndustryPricing Models in IT Industry
Pricing Models in IT Industry
 
Personality and Big Five Model
Personality and Big Five ModelPersonality and Big Five Model
Personality and Big Five Model
 
Microeconomic Analysis of a FMCG prod
Microeconomic Analysis of a FMCG prodMicroeconomic Analysis of a FMCG prod
Microeconomic Analysis of a FMCG prod
 
Ethical Issues in Corporate Governance
Ethical Issues in Corporate GovernanceEthical Issues in Corporate Governance
Ethical Issues in Corporate Governance
 
Ethical Issues in Corporate Governance PPT
Ethical Issues in Corporate Governance PPTEthical Issues in Corporate Governance PPT
Ethical Issues in Corporate Governance PPT
 
Env anal eval of veg oil ind att in India
Env anal eval of veg oil ind att in IndiaEnv anal eval of veg oil ind att in India
Env anal eval of veg oil ind att in India
 
Env anal eval of veg oil ind att in India PPT
Env anal eval of veg oil ind att in India PPTEnv anal eval of veg oil ind att in India PPT
Env anal eval of veg oil ind att in India PPT
 
Country Analysis - South Korea
Country Analysis - South KoreaCountry Analysis - South Korea
Country Analysis - South Korea
 
Computer hacking – Is it Ethical
Computer hacking – Is it EthicalComputer hacking – Is it Ethical
Computer hacking – Is it Ethical
 
Computer hacking – Is it Ethical PPT
Computer hacking – Is it Ethical PPTComputer hacking – Is it Ethical PPT
Computer hacking – Is it Ethical PPT
 
Case Analysis – Hedging Foreign
Case Analysis – Hedging ForeignCase Analysis – Hedging Foreign
Case Analysis – Hedging Foreign
 
A Study on Trends and Determinants of Outward Foreign Direct Investment and I...
A Study on Trends and Determinants of Outward Foreign Direct Investment and I...A Study on Trends and Determinants of Outward Foreign Direct Investment and I...
A Study on Trends and Determinants of Outward Foreign Direct Investment and I...
 

Financial Performance of 2 companies in Cement industry

  • 1. i COVER PAGE Title : Financial Performance of 2 companies in Cement Industry Subject : FFBD Level / Semester : I / Feb 2010 Programme : MBA-FULL TIME Subject Tutor : Mr. L. Augustine Name of Student : Vivekanandan M Student’s Registration Number : GPBL-B/F10/15 Date of Submission : Apr 09, 2010 Word Count : 1850 words Word Limit : 2000 words
  • 2. ii Checklist Students Name Vivekanandan M Registration Number GPBL-B/F10/15 Date of submission of the Assignment 09/04/2010 Is the cover page in the correct format as indicated in the “Guidelines to writing Assignments”? Yes Have I done a complete spell-check of the Assignment? Yes Have I done a complete word count for the Assignment? Yes Does the table of contents include numbers? Yes Are the pages numbered correctly? Yes Are the figures numbered correctly? Yes Are the tables/charts numbered correctly? Yes Are the captions for the tables and charts proper? Yes Are the references/bibliography listed in the Assignment? Yes Are the references cited correctly in the text? NA All references material has been cited from the books & the University of Wales online library. Any other internet source quoted is with the permission of the module tutor. NA Are the references in the text in the proper format as indicated in the “Guidelines to Writing Assignments” Yes Has the soft copy of the Assignment been enclosed? Yes Declaration: All material written in this assignment is my own and I have not used any material, content or information of others claiming them to be mine. Wherever materials have been used, proper citation has been done in the text. I am fully aware of the rules and regulations governing plagiarism. Should at any point of time my work be suspected/investigated and established to have been plagiarized, I am aware of the consequences. I have read the Student’s Handbook in detail. ___________________ Signature of the student Date: 09/04/2010
  • 3. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE No. List of Tables iv List of Figures v Introduction 1 Company Analysis for the period 2007 – 2009 3 Breakeven Volume Analysis 12 Conclusion 16 Bibliography 17
  • 4. iv LIST OF TABLES PAGE No. Table 1 - Financial performance of ACC Ltd 1 Table 2 - Financial performance of JK Cement 2 Table – 3 - Computation of Cost of goods sold for ACC Ltd 4 Table 4: Cost of goods sold computation for JK Cement 6 Table 5: Production capacity and production volume for ACC Ltd and JK Cement 7 Table 6: Computation of market price of cement (per 100 kg) 8 Table 7: Volume produced by top 7 cement companies in India 9 Table 8: Computation of average market price for cement (per 100kg) 10 Table 9: Computation of volume produced by the cement industry 11 Table 10: Breakeven Volume computation for ACC Ltd 13 Table 11: Breakeven Volume computation for JK Cement 15
  • 5. v LIST OF FIGURES PAGE No. Figure 1: Sales Volume and Growth 2 Figure 2: Profit before Tax and Profit after Tax 2 Figure 3: Trend in cost of finished goods for ACC Ltd 4 Figure 4: Trend in cost of finished goods for JK Cement 6 Figure 5: Comparison between volume produced and production capacity for ACC Ltd 7 Figure 6: Comparison between volume produced and production capacity for JK Cement 8 Figure 7: Comparison between ACC Ltd selling price and average market price 10 Figure 8: Comparison between JK Cement selling price and average market price 11
  • 6. 1 Introduction Indian economy is expected to grow at 7 to 8% during the fiscal year 2010. This growth is fueled by growth in housing sector and infrastructure sector. The demand for housing sector and infrastructure sector has fueled cement industry’s growth. Cement industry is growing at 13%, which looks attractive to investors. Following 2 companies are selected for the analysis, a. ACC Ltd b. JK Cements ACC Ltd is the market leader in cement industry and JK Cements is the second largest producer of white cement. These 2 companies are selected to analyze the growth of cement industry with respect to the volume and the average market price. ACC Ltd have reported 20% growth (Y-O-Y) in net profit during second half of the FY 2009 and JK cements have reported 140% growth (Y-O-Y) in net profit during second half of the FY 2009. a) Analyst view on ACC Ltd ACC Ltd is the largest cement producer in India, with the market share of 12%. The company has added 1.1 MT per annum capacity at Bargarh. The company will add 3MT per annum capacity by Q1 2010 by increasing the griding facilities at Wadi, Thondebhavi and Kudithini. FY 2009 (in Lac) FY 2008 (in Lac) Change (%) Sales 91719.6 86336.6 6 PBDIT 27081.9 19853.3 36 PBIT 23350.6 16648 40 PBT 22507 16248.2 38 PAT 15639.1 10996.5 42 EPS 79.31 55.13 43 Dividend 23 20 15 Table 1: Financial performance of ACC Ltd Currently the stock is trading at 11 times its earnings (CMP = 957.30). With the addition of the new facilities, the company will increase the production capacity by 14%.
  • 7. 2 Figure 1: Sales Volume and Growth (Source: ACC Ltd Balance Sheet 2009) Figure 2: Profit before Tax and Profit after Tax (Source: ACC Ltd Balance Sheet 2009) b) Performance analysis of JK Cement JK Cement is the second largest producer of white cement. Global economic slowdown and the domestic demand have affected the company’s performance during the year 2009. With the growth of infrastructure and housing sector in this financial year, the company is also expected to grow with the increase in demand for cements. FY 2009 (in Lac) FY 2008 (in Lac) Change (%) Sales 16644.2 15955.7 4 PBDIT 3401.6 4388.5 -22 PBIT 2877.3 3977.8 -27 PBT 2330.6 3465.7 -32 PAT 1414.4 2651.7 -46 EPS 20.36 37.94 -47 Table 2: Financial performance of JK Cement
  • 8. 3 Company Analysis for the period 2007 - 2009 a. Analysis of price of finished goods for the period 2007 - 2009 Items 2009 2008 2007 (Rs. Cr) (Rs. Cr) (Rs. Cr) ACC Ltd Manufacturing expenses Purchase of Cement 93.16 87.36 93.31 Raw materials consumed 891.51 799.12 767.73 Stores and spare parts consumed 10.03 13.86 20.78 Packing material consumed 238.72 280.14 230.01 Power and fuel 1539.65 1598.96 1243.63 Repairs to building 14.14 14.72 9.57 Repairs to Machinery 323.3 276.21 264.34 Repairs to Other Items 67.87 70.92 75.5 Royalties 98.39 86.69 84.95 Excise Duties 84.54 117.08 110.02 Payment To and Provision for employees Salaries, wages, dearness allowance and bonus 318.27 311.23 268.76 Contribution / Provision to and for Provident and Other funds 18 63.53 31.48 Workmen and staff welfare expenses 31.44 41.56 53.03 Administrative, Selling and Other Expenses Rent 32.59 33.22 34.14 Rates and Taxes 101.45 98.75 112.2 Insurance 17.6 17.86 18.3 Loading, Transportation and othercharges 169.69 176.98 163.91 Discounts,rebates and allowances 93.49 105.2 114.08 Commission on sales 23.12 20.24 15.5 Other Expenses (loss on sale / write off of fixed assert) 270.48 286.55 253.35 Provision for bad and doubtfuldebt 31.26 0.71 26.33 Advertisement 53.16 47.56 41.77 Outward freight charges on cement 1054.41 1001.58 944.22 (Increase) / Decrease in stocks in trade and work-in- progress Closing Stock
  • 9. 4 Finished Goods 88.08 78.86 81.26 Work-in-progress 168.96 149.44 146.71 Opening Stock Finished Goods 78.86 81.26 63.98 Work-in-progress 149.44 146.71 157.06 Cost of Goods Sold 5547.53 5549.7 4969.98 Sales Volume (Million Tonnes) 21.52 21.01 19.97 Price of finished goods (per 100 Kg) 257 264 248 Table 3: Computation of Cost of goods sold for ACC Ltd Figure 3: Trend in cost of finished goods for ACC Ltd For the period 2007-2008, the cost of finished goods has been increased by Rs: 14. 4% increase in raw materials cost, 28% increase in power and fuel cost, 16% increase in salaries, 100% increase in PF contribution and 6% increase in freight charges has led to increase of 5% in the manufacturing cost. For the period 2008-2009, the cost of finished goods has been decreased by Rs: 7. 15% reduction in packaging materials cost, 27% reduction in excise duty, 71% reduction in PF contribution and 11% reduction in discount/rebates has lead to the reduction in the manufacturing cost by 2%. 240 245 250 255 260 265 270 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009 Cost of finished goods (per 100 kg) Cost of finished goods (100 kg)
  • 10. 5 Company Items 2009 2008 2007 (Rs. Cr) (Rs. Cr) (Rs. Cr) JK Cement Manufacturing expenses Purchase of Trading goods 0.48 0.31 0.45 Raw materials consumed 162.96 140.59 122.3 Stores and spare consumed 30.75 36.72 28.45 Packing material consumed 64.8 57.43 55.25 Power and fuel 376.14 329.69 309.7 Repairs to building 4.43 3.18 3.21 Repairs to Machinery 21.08 16.89 13.75 Repairs to Other Items 0.21 0.38 0.36 Insurance 2.59 2.66 3.11 Excise Duties 1.08 -1.05 1.06 Payment To and Provision for employees Salaries, wages and bonus 64.06 50.18 35.19 Contribution to Provident fund and Other funds 10.3 7.95 5.5 Welfare expenses 9.41 9.5 8.13 Administrative and Other Expenses Rent 3.53 2.62 2.14 Lease Rent 0 0.36 0.39 Rates and Taxes 11.08 2.18 2.08 Travelling and Conveyance Expenses 8.93 7.61 6.68 Provision for doubtful debts and advances 0.16 3.99 4.52 Debts written off 1.59 0 0.59 Loss on sale / impairment of fixed assert (net) 0.3 0.46 0.56 Expenses relating to previous year 0.1 0.08 0 Misc. Expenses 40.45 33.11 27.57 Selling and Distribution Expenses Advertisement and Publicity 14.72 11.95 10.57 Commission, brokerage and incentives 22.04 13.46 11.99 Selling expenses 14.86 7.789 7.99 Freight and handling outward 311.9 287.17 244.35 (Increase) / Decrease in stocks in trade and work-in- progress Closing Stock Finished Goods 11.33 10.13 15.1
  • 11. 6 Work-in-progress 14.93 10.9 23.2 Opening Stock Finished Goods 10.13 15.1 11.94 Work-in-progress 10.9 23.2 24.52 Cost of Goods Sold 809.2 722.11 629.15 Sales Volume (Million Tonnes) 3.79 3.76 3.77 Price of finished goods (per 100 Kg) 213 192 166 Table 4: Cost of goods sold computation for JK Cement Figure 4: Trend in cost of finished goods for JK Cement For the period 2007-2008, the cost of finished goods has been increased by Rs: 26. 15% increase in raw material cost, 6% increase in power and fuel, 42% increase in salaries and 17% increase in freight has led to increase in cement price by 15%. For the period 2008-2009, the cost of finished goods has been increased by Rs: 21. 15% increase in raw materials cost, 12% increase in packaging materials cost, 28% increase in salaries, 450% increase in taxes, 21% increase in miscellaneous expenses, 22% increase in advertisement expenditure has lead to the increase in cement price by 10%. 0 50 100 150 200 250 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009 Cost of finished goods (per 100 kg) Cost of finished goods (100 kg)
  • 12. 7 b. Analysis of volume produced by 2 companies for the period 2007 - 2009 Volume Produced (in Million Tonne) Installed Capacity (in Million Tonne) Company/Ye ar 2009 2008 2007 2009 2008 2007 ACC Ltd 21.52 21.01 19.97 26 22.62 22.4 JK Cement 3.79 3.76 3.77 4.47 4 4 Table 5: Production capacity and production volume for ACC Ltd and JK Cement Figure 5: Comparison between volume produced and production capacity for ACC Ltd For the period 2007-2008, ACC LTd, has increased the production volume by 5% and the company’s production capacity was increased by 1%. At the beginning of the year 2007, the capacity utilization was 90%, which was increased to 93% by the end of 2008. For the period 2008-2009, ACC LTd, has increased the production volume by 2% and the company’s production capacity was increased by 15%. At the beginning of the year 2008, the capacity utilization was 93%, which got decreased to 83% by the end of 2009. 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009 ACC Ltd Volume Produced (Million Tonne) ACC Ltd Installed Capacity (Million Tonne)
  • 13. 8 Figure 6: Comparison between volume produced and production capacity for JK Cement For the period 2007-2008, JK Cement, has marginally decreased the production volume. At the beginning of the year 2007, the capacity utilization was 94.25%, which got marginally decreased by the end of 2008. For the period 2008-2009, JK Cement, has marginally increased the production volume and the company’s production capacity was increased by 17%. At the beginning of the year 2008, the capacity utilization was 94%, which got decreased to 85% by the end of 2009. The capacity utilization of JK cement is consistently higher when compared with ACC cement for the period 2007 to 2009. c. Analysis of market price of 2 companies for the period 2007 - 2009 Volume Sold (in Million Tonne) Sales Turnover (Rs. Cr) Average Market Price (Rs/100 kg) Company/Year 2009 2008 2007 2009 2008 2007 2009 2008 2007 ACC Ltd 21.52 21.01 19.97 8724.24 8234.02 7848.32 405 391 393 JK Cement 3.79 3.76 3.77 1876.45 1812.84 1458.25 495 482 386 Table 6: Computation of market price of cement (per 100 kg) 3.4 3.6 3.8 4 4.2 4.4 4.6 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009 JK Cement Volume Produced (Million Tonne) JK Cement Installed Capacity (Million Tonne)
  • 14. 9 During the period 2007-2008, ACC Ltd selling price (of 100kg cement) was marginally decreased and the sales was increased by 4% to maintain the same operating margin. During the same period, JK Cement selling price was increased by 25% and the sales was increased by 3%. During this period, inflation touched 16%, which increased the cost of funds, which has lead to the increase in cement price by some companies. During 2008-2009, ACC Ltd selling price was increased by 3% and sales was increased to 6% to maintain the same operating margin. JK Cement selling price was also increased by 3% and sales was increased by 4%. d. Analysis of total volume produced by the market for the period 2007 - 2009 Volume Produced (in Million Tonne) Company/Year 2009 2008 2007 ACC Ltd 21 20.83 19.92 JK Cement 3.79 3.76 3.64 Ultratech Cement 15.8 15.06 14.63 Grasim 16.31 15.36 14.41 India Cements 9.11 9.23 8.42 Madras Cements 6.52 5.84 5.66 Birla Corp. 5.28 5.27 5.25 Total 77.81 75.35 71.93 Table 7: Volume produced by top 7 cement companies in India During the period 2007-2008, the market has grown by 5%, wherelse ACC Ltd has grown by 4% and JK Cement has grown by 3%. The growth for ACC Ltd has come through the production capacity expansion. Although JK Cement has not increased the capacity, with their strong distribution network, they increased their sales by 3%. During 2008-2009 periods, the market has grown by 3% and ACC Ltd has grown marginally (below 1%) and JK Cement has also grown marginally.
  • 15. 10 e. Analysis of price change of 2 companies with price movement for the period 2007 – 2009. Volume Sold (in Million Tonne) Sales Turnover (Rs. Cr) Average Market Price (Rs/100 kg) Company/Year 2009 2008 2007 2009 2008 2007 2009 2008 2007 ACC Ltd 21.52 21.01 19.97 8724.24 8234.02 7848.32 405 391 393 JK Cement 3.79 3.76 3.77 1876.45 1812.84 1458.25 495 482 386 Ambhuja Cement 0 17.75 16.77 0 7075.51 6454.75 0 398 384 Ultratech Cement 15.8 15.01 15.16 5396.02 4838.88 4459.37 341 322 294 Grasim 16.31 15.12 14.84 6371.66 5721.46 5026.68 390 378 338 India Cements 9.11 9.21 8.41 3757.96 3535.16 2599.83 412 383 309 Madras Cements 6.47 5.72 5.62 2300.63 1898.64 1511.32 355 331 268 Birla Corp. 5.29 5.26 5.23 1866.02 1841.76 1647.5 352 350 315 Average = 392 379 335 Table 8: Computation of average market price for cement (per 100kg) Figure 7: Comparison between ACC Ltd selling price and average market price 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009 ACC Ltd Selling cost (per 100 kg) Avg. Market Price (per 100kg)
  • 16. 11 Figure 8: Comparison between JK Cement selling price and average market price During 2007-2008, the average market price was increased by 13%, ACC Ltd selling price was decreased marginally and JK Cement selling price was increased by 25%. During 2008-2009, the average market price was increased by 3% and ACC Ltd has also increased the price by 3% and JK Cement also increased the price by 3%. f. Analysis of volume produced by these 2 companies with the total volume produced by the market for the period 2007 - 2009 Volume Produced (in Million Tonne) Company/Year 2009 2008 2007 ACC Ltd 21 20.83 19.92 JK Cement 3.79 3.76 3.64 Ultratech Cement 15.8 15.06 14.63 Grasim 16.31 15.36 14.41 India Cements 9.11 9.23 8.42 Madras Cements 6.52 5.84 5.66 Birla Corp. 5.28 5.27 5.25 Total 77.81 75.35 71.93 Table 9: Computation of volume produced by the cement industry 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 2006-2007 2007-2008 2008-2009 JK Cement Selling cost (per 100 kg) Avg. Market Price (per 100kg)
  • 17. 12 During the year 2007, ACC Ltd market share was 27% and JK Cement market share was 5%. In the year 2008, ACC Ltd market share was increased to 28% and JK Cement market share remained at 5%. In the year 2009, ACC Ltd market share decreased to 27% and JK cement market share fell below 5%. Break Even Volume Analysis Company Items 2009 2008 2007 Variable Cost Fixed Cost Variable Cost Fixed Cost Variable Cost Fixed Cost ACC Ltd Manufacturing expenses Purchase of Cement 93.16 87.36 93.31 Raw materials consumed 891.51 799.12 767.73 Stores and spare parts consumed 10.03 13.86 20.78 Packing material consumed 238.72 280.14 230.01 Power and fuel 1539.65 1598.96 1243.63 Repairs to building 14.14 14.72 9.57 Repairs to Machinery 323.3 276.21 264.34 Repairs to Other Items 67.87 70.92 75.5 Royalties 98.39 86.69 84.95 Excise Duties 84.54 117.08 110.02 Payment To and Provision for employees Salaries, wages, dearness allowance and bonus 318.27 311.23 268.76 Contribution / Provision to and for Provident and Other funds 18 63.53 31.48 Workmen and staff welfare expenses 31.44 41.56 53.03 Administrative, Selling and Other Expenses Rent 32.59 33.22 34.14 Rates and Taxes 101.45 98.75 112.2 Insurance 17.6 17.86 18.3 Loading, Transportation and other charges 169.69 176.98 163.91 Discounts,rebates and allowances 93.49 105.2 114.08 Commission on sales 23.12 20.24 15.5 Other Expenses (loss on sale / write off of fixed assert) 270.48 286.55 253.35 Provision for bad and doubtfuldebt 31.26 0.71 26.33 Advertisement 53.16 47.56 41.77 Outward freight charges on cement 1054.41 1001.58 944.22
  • 18. 13 (Increase) / Decrease in stocks in trade and work-in-progress Closing Stock Finished Goods 88.08 78.86 81.26 Work-in-progress 168.96 149.44 146.71 Opening Stock Finished Goods 78.86 81.26 63.98 Work-in-progress 149.44 146.71 157.06 Total 5068.36 479.17 5016.2 533.5 4487.27 482.71 Sales Volume (Million Tonnes) 21 21 20.83 20.83 19.92 19.92 Cost (per 100 Kg) 241 22 240 25 225 24 2009 2008 2007 Break Even Volume Analysis Total Fixed Cost 479.17 533.5 482.71 Sales per 100kg 405 391 393 Variable cost per 100kg 241 240 225 Break Even Volume (lac Tonne) 2.00 3.00 2.00 Net Profit 2294.39 1687.74 1717.18 Sales 21.52 21.01 19.97 Break Even Volume 29 31 27 Profit per 100 kg 117 93 95 Market Price 405 391 393 Cost of Goods sold 257 264 248 Profit per 100kg 148 127 145 Table 10: Breakeven Volume computation for ACC Ltd
  • 19. 14 Company Items 2009 2008 2007 Variable Cost Fixed Cost Variable Cost Fixed Cost Variable Cost Fixed Cost JK Cement Manufacturing expenses Purchaseof Tradinggoods 0.48 0.31 0.45 Raw materials consumed 162.96 140.59 122.3 Stores and spareconsumed 30.75 36.72 28.45 Packingmaterial consumed 64.8 57.43 55.25 Power and fuel 376.14 329.69 309.7 Repairs to building 4.43 3.18 3.21 Repairs to Machinery 21.08 16.89 13.75 Repairs to Other Items 0.21 0.38 0.36 Insurance 2.59 2.66 3.11 ExciseDuties 1.08 -1.05 1.06 Payment To and Provision for employees Salaries,wages and bonus 64.06 50.18 35.19 Contribution to Provident fund and Other funds 10.3 7.95 5.5 Welfareexpenses 9.41 9.5 8.13 Administrative and Other Expenses Rent 3.53 2.62 2.14 Lease Rent 0 0.36 0.39 Rates and Taxes 11.08 2.18 2.08 Travellingand Conveyance Expenses 8.93 7.61 6.68 Provision for doubtful debts and advances 0.16 3.99 4.52 Debts written off 1.59 0 0.59 Loss on sale/ impairmentof fixed assert (net) 0.3 0.46 0.56 Expenses relatingto previous year 0.1 0.08 0 Misc.Expenses 40.45 33.11 27.57 Selling and Distribution Expenses Advertisement and Publicity 14.72 11.95 10.57 Commission,brokerage and incentives 22.04 13.46 11.99 Sellingexpenses 14.86 7.789 7.99 Freight and handlingoutward 311.9 287.17 244.35 (Increase) / Decrease in stocks in trade and work-in-progress Closing Stock Finished Goods 11.33 10.13 15.1 Work-in-progress 14.93 10.9 23.2 Opening Stock Finished Goods 10.13 15.1 11.94
  • 20. 15 Work-in-progress 10.9 23.2 24.52 Total 712.27 87.3 626.801 70.25 572.04 50.96 Sales Volume (Million Tonnes) 3.79 3.79 3.76 3.76 3.77 3.77 Cost (per 100 Kg) 187 23 166 18 151 13 2009 2008 2007 Break Even Volume Analysis Total Fixed Cost 23 18 13 Sales per 100kg 495 482 386 Variable cost per 100kg 187 166 151 Break Even Volume (Million kg) 74.67 56.96 55.31 Table 11: Breakeven Volume computation for JK Cement In the above breakeven volume computation for ACC Ltd and JK Cement, some costs are classified as variable cost and some costs are classified as fixed cost. Fixed costs are the cost, which does not depend on the volume of production. Eg. Rent, employee salaries, PF, bonus is fixed cost. Variable costs are the cost, which depend on the volume of the production. Eg. Raw materials (directly depend on the volume of production), stores and spares (number of spares used, depends on the wear and tear of the machinery), packaging material (depends on the volume produced), power and fuel (depends on the volume of produced), repairs, insurance (to insure the finished goods against natural damages – this depends on the volume produced), advertisement (this depends on the volume produced), selling expenses (directly depends on the volume produced). For the period 2007-2008, the fixed cost for ACC Ltd has increased by 10%, which has lead to increase in breakeven volume by 15%. During the same period, JK Cements fixed cost was increased by 37%, which has lead to the increase in breakeven volume by 3%. During 2008-2009, ACC Ltd fixed cost was decreased by 10%, which has lead to decrease in breakeven volume by 6%. During the same period, JK Cement fixed cost was increased by 27%, which has lead to increase in breakeven volume by 31%. Companies which has less breakeven volume, has the potential to make more profits, than the companies which has high breakeven volume, assuming both the companies will have same sales volume.
  • 21. 16 Conclusion a. During 2007-2008, ACC Ltd has marginally decreased the selling price, when compared to 25% increase in the selling price by JK Cement. During 2008-2009, ACC Ltd has increased the selling price by 3% and JK Cement has also increased the selling price by 3%. b. The market share of ACC Ltd is 27% and the market share of JK Cement is 5%.
  • 22. 17 Bibliography 1. http://www.jkcement.com/flash/pdfs/J_K_Cement_Annual_Report_2008-09_- _Final_(23-07-09).pdf 2. http://www.jkcement.com/flash/pdfs/JK%20Cement%20AR%202007-08.pdf 3. http://www.jkcement.com/flash/pdfs/annualreport0607.pdf 4. Capital line software 5. http://www.acclimited.com/newsite/pdf/conso_results_09.pdf 6. http://www.acclimited.com/newsite/finance/Financialresults_2009.pdf 7. http://www.acclimited.com/newsite/finance/Financialresults-DEC-2008.pdf 8. http://www.acclimited.com/newsite/finance/Financialresults31122007.asp 9. http://www.nse-india.com 10. http://www.cmaindia.org/ 11. http://www.ibef.org/industry/cement.aspx 12. http://www.moneycontrol.com