Case study given as a keynote Drupalcamp Ottawa 2/22/13, discussing NYSenate.gov, the new Drupal AppCatalog distribution, and the role of Drupal in the civic technology ecosystem.
15. New NYSenate “CIO Office”
http://flickr.com/photos/rocketqueen/1573565705/
16. Open-Source Value Proposition
• No vendor lock-In / choice of consultants / ability to build in-
house capacity
• Collaborate w/ our peers (White House)
• Security transparency (US DoD is a major consumer for this
reason)
• Open-Source platforms often pay more heed to open formats
and standards (e.g.: DCAT, RDFa, OData, JSON vs Shapefiles, PDF,
etc.)
• Innovation: healthy open-source projects can aggregate more
engineering effort than proprietary alternatives, propagate great
new extensions faster
• Freedom of Hosting Options: consume as a cloud-hosted
service today, change our mind and host in-house tomorrow, etc.
17. Selected Drupal Because
• Considered Joomla, Django, Drupal and Wordpress
• Platform & Community Maturity:
•>1 million sites (2% of all sites), 3,718 Code commits/wk, 6,388
issue comments/wk
•transparent governance process for upgrades
•trajectory of the platform & community since 2004
•Extensibility:
•18,489 Modules, 1,512 Themes, 21,009 Contributors
•module feature set for constituent use cases
• Vendor Ecosystem:
•local availability of Drupal and PHP/MySQL talent
•Drupal specialized commercial cloud options
18. High Velocity Project
• Contracted outside consulting firm for requirements gathering,
design, coding, hosting
•*During* external development, hired one in-house developer
one project manager, & trained existing in-house staff for training &
QA
• Deployed 3.5 months after project start
• Maintained by one programmer and one project manager
• Hundreds of bugs and features implemented since
31. Results: Transparency, Yes...
“[NY Senate] is taking a critically important step to help restore trust in
government. At a time when confidence in government in general has
hit bottom, this is an extraordinarily valuable step forward” - Lawrence
Lessig, Harvard Law
“..clearly setting the place that all other legislative bodies will have to
follow. The U.S. Congress ought to be taking some clue” -Ellen Miller,
Executive Director, The Sunlight Foundation.
“..demonstrates the New York State Senate’s commitment to a
transparent and accessible government” - Dave McClure, U.S. GSA
Associate Administrator
“With this new system, New York State takes a leadership role in
accountability and transparency” - Craig Newmark, founder,
Craigslist.org & Craigslist Foundation.
“[We] applaud the State Senate for its efforts to further open the
legislative process,” Barbara Bartoletti, Legislative Director, League of
Women Voters.
Winner of three “Best of New York” Awards
32. But Also More Efficient...
• No technical skill required to
manage content
• Content managed as
mashable data
• Modernize Antiquated
Systems, Terminate
Expensive Software
Licenses
• Open-source platforms &
developer tools, &
collaborative development
• Government-certified
Commercial Cloud hosting
• Net saving $1MM off ~
$8MM budget
33. And Newly Participatory...
• 10,000s watching live events
• 100,000s of YouTube views
• 100s of public comments on bills
• @NYSenate 1000s of Followers
58. Drupal Now Also Becoming a Public Sector Data
Management System (“DKAN” is a “DMS” Distro)
59. Drupal Powers Data.gov, OpenGovPlatform, DKAN, etc.
http://flickr.com/photos/rocketqueen/1573565705/
60. Build The Next Great Innovations in Civic Technology
?? Gov CMS Open311 Transit Weather GPS
EMERGING GROWTH MATURE
API
government
industry
Distributed innovation
API
citizen API
61. Or in other words, be like Canada! :)
?? Gov CMS Open311 Transit Weather GPS
EMERGING GROWTH MATURE
API
government
industry
Distributed innovation
API
citizen API