SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  27
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
MEDICINMANField Force Excellence
TM
May 2013 | www.medicinman.net
Graduatesas Medical Reps.
- Editorial
ScienceVs.
Non-Science
2 | MedicinMan May 2013
EDITORIAL | Science Vs. Non-Science Graduates as Medical Reps
The top management of each company must have
a clear understanding and ask - are we a ‘science’
company or are we a ‘sales organization’?
H
ere’s the question: Do all
the thousands of companies
promoting the 100th generic
molecule need to talk science? Even if
they want to, is the doctor interested in
listening to a ‘detailing talk’ by a poorly
motivated field force that changes their
company every year?
Sure, companies promoting IP prod-
ucts and even Indian companies
focusing on a particular therapy area
or niche market segment may need
B. Pharma or B.Sc candidates.
You need B. Pharma and B. Sc candi-
dates as MRs when the job role is to
generate prescriptions by giving highly
scientific information. Do you need
them when the job is largely a sales
job?
We have over 60,000 brands in Indian
Pharma Market - how many of them
are novel IP products?
Today the role of an MR/FLM in most
Indian Pharma companies is ‘science’
by title and ‘sales’ by necessity. Why
then this emphasis on science can-
didates? Will they really enjoy doing
an ultra high pressure sales job? Are
they cut-out for the role where 80%
of the time is spent waiting and only
20% in actually talking and listening to
doctors? How much science can an MR
talk in 180 seconds? The attrition rate
is clearly an indicator of dissatisfaction
brought about by mismatch.
Pharma is busy fitting square pegs in
round holes and as a result neither
the candidates are happy nor are the
companies getting enough productivity
from the field force.
Time to re-think?
I think the top management of each
company must have a clear under-
standing and ask - “are we a ‘science’
company or are we a sales organiza-
tion?”
Once this is clear, it becomes easier to
adopt the right strategy, hire the right
people and give the right training.
So far only a few Indian companies
like Mankind Pharma have dared to
address this issue head-on and their
splendid field force productivity and
low attrition is a proof that it works.
Even when it comes to product
management in most Indian Pharma
companies, the PMs are busy designing
sales schemes and not product man-
agement or brand building.
A strong, sales oriented field force
led by FLMs with good leadership
and managerial skills and supported
by field force friendly, physician-fo-
cused and patient centric, on-call
medico-marketing team might be a
better option.
What do you think? - MM
For further reading:
1. Report by the iOpener Institute for People
and Performance:“Job Fulfillment, Not Money,
Retains Gen-YTalent”. Full report is available
at - http://medicinman.net/2013/04/job-
fulfillment-not-pay-retains-gen-y-talent/
2.What Do MRs Need to MakeTheirWork
Enjoyable? A MedicinMan Survey. For full article
please download MedicinMan December 2011
issue -http://medicinman.net/archives/
3. How to Attract Freshers to Opt for Pharma/
Healthcare Career? LinkedIn Discussion - http://
lnkd.in/D7WAEj
Connect with Anup Soans on LinkedIn | Facebook | Twitter
Visit anupsoans.com.
Meet the Editor
Anup Soans is an Author, Facilitator and the Editor of MedicinMan.
Write in to him: anupsoans@medicinman.net
Editorial
“You need B. Pharma and B. Sc
candidates as MRs when the job
role is to generate prescriptions
by giving highly scientific infor-
mation. Do you need them when
the job is largely a sales job?”
Buy 1 get 1 free !
MRP Rs. 799/- MRP Rs. 599/-
For Individuals*
Buy SuperVision for the SuperWiser Front-line Manager and Get HardKnocks for the
GreenHorn FREE.
For Corporates*
INR 500/- for a set of SuperVision for the SuperWiser Front-line Manager (1 copy)
and HardKnocks for the GreenHorn (1 copy) for purchase of 50 sets and above.
*Inclusive of Shipping to One Location.
Please pay through bank transfer to SB account no. *07141000006761* of “Anup Soans” HDFC Bank, Mosque Road, Frazer
Town Branch, Bangalore – 560005. RTGS/NEFT IFSC: HDFC0000714 and inform by email and SMS - anupsoans@gmail.
com | +91-93422-32949.
Or you can send a cheque favoring “Anup Soans” to:
Anup Soans
101 - North Forte Apts;
22, North Road,
Cooke Town,
St. Thomas Town P.O.
Bangalore - 560084
Field Force Excellence Tools for Individuals and Corporates
Field Force Excellence
1. Employee Engagement for Field Force
Excellence - Part I..................................................6
Who is an “engaged employee”? Why are engaged
employees so critical to a company’s success? How
can we bring about enployee engagement?
Joshua Soans
2. So, You’re the Boss Now................................10
How to make the transition from ‘sales’ to
‘people management’ (without intimidating team
members, micro-managing or losing your cool).
K. Hariram
3. Stakeholders in Field Force Excellence .......13
Many people in an organization are repsonsible
for FFE. A brief look at some of their roles and
responsibilities.
Vishal V. Bhaiyya
Marketing for the MR
4. Segmentation for the Medical Rep................16
Segmentation of customers is a critical skill and
tool for Medical Reps to increase the ROI of their
sales call.
Anup Soans from “HardKnocks for the GreenHorn”
In Memoriam
5. ‘Crocin Man’ Passes Away..............................19
Gurudas Masurkar was an industry veteran who
launched landmark brands like Crocin and Lacto
Calamine. He was Chairman Emeritus at Entod
Pharmaceuticals.
Vivek Hattangadi
Contents (click to navigate)
Emerging Areas in Healthcare
6. What is Pharmacoeconomics? .....................20
Pharmacoeconomics exposes the true cost to
society of a particular drug therapy in treating a
condition.
Richa Goyal and Mahendra Rai
7. Pharmacoeconomic Analysis........................22
An in-depth look at pharmacoeconomics - the
types of cost calculation, how they are calculated
and what they mean for different stakeholders.
Javed Shailk and Shafaq Shaikh
Coaching
8. Ten Coaching Nuggets for FLMs ..................27
Ten tips on how to get the best out of your team
by Coaching them.
K. Hariram
Contents (click to navigate)
MedicinMan Volume 3 Issue 5 | May 2013
Editor and Publisher
Anup Soans
CEO
Chhaya Sankath
COO
Arvind Nair
Chief Mentor
K. Hariram
Advisory Board
Vivek Hattangadi; Jolly Mathews
Editorial Board
Salil Kallianpur; Dr. Shalini Ratan; Shashin
Bodawala; Prabhakar Shetty; Vardarajan S;
Dr. Mandar Kubal; Dr. Surinder Kumar
International Editorial Board
Hanno Wolfram; Renie McClay
Executive Editor
Joshua Soans
MedicinMan Academy:
Prof. Vivek Hattangaadi, Dean, Professional
Skills Development
MedicinMan ChangeMakers
Saurabh Kumar
Make a difference in Pharma. Join MedicinMan
ChangeMakers. Write in to our editor to find out
more:
anupsoans@medicinman.net
Letters to the Editor: anupsoans@medicinman.net
FFE 20135
x
10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
y
Date: Saturday, 8th June 2013
Theme:FieldForceProductivity
Place: Courtyard Marriott, Mumbai
Registrations
Open. Hurry!
Visit: medicinman.net/
ffe13-registration
E
6 | MedicinMan May 2013
Employee Engagement for Field Force Excellence | Joshua Soans
Employee
Engagement
for Field Force
Excellence.
Studies involving hundreds of thousands of employees across the globe have
shown that engaged employees invest more “discretionary effort”, have a
better understanding of their work, are far less likely to leave the organization,
positively recommend the organization to others and take fewer days off from
work. This article is the 1st
in a series on Employee Engagement.
Employee Engagement is a serious
commitment to aligning employee
aspirations with organizational goals. For
engaged employees, the line between
“work” and “life” is blurred or non-
existant - like this woman reporter in the
Sichuan Province of China who was on
her way to her wedding when a massive
earthquake struck on April 20th, 2013.
She immediately got to work interviewing
bystanders and reporting on the quake (see
video: http://youtu.be/bLsTs4DRv18)
FFE 20135
x
10 15 20 25 30 35 35 40 45 50 55
y
SPECIAL REPORT
Employee Engagement for Field Force Excellence | Joshua Soans
7 | MedicinMan May 2013
Introduction.
E
very manager in charge of
achieving company goals
through a team of employees
would like to know how to motivate
them to put in 100 per cent effort and
some more. A pharma sales manager
would like to know how to get his
team to generate more sales, increase
customer satisfaction, take lesser time
off from work, make fewer mistakes
on the job, recommend the company
to others and motivate his colleagues
to do all of the above as well.
A number of authoritative studies
in recent years show that employees
who are “fully” or “highly” engaged
are much more likely to do all of the
above compared to their counterparts
with low engagement levels or who
are “actively disengaged”. The results
from these studies – involving up to
6.5 lakh employees globally1
– even
show a direct and stunningly large
correlation between increased profits
and employee engagement.
Consider these figures.
Research from organisations
representing more than five million
employees worldwide in the Aon
Hewitt database showed that in 2010
organisations with engagement
levels of 65% or greater posted total
shareholder returns that were 22%
higher than average; companies with
engagement levels of 45% or less had
a total shareholder return that was
28% lower than the average return
in 20102
.
A Gallup study (2006) looking at data
from over 23 thousand business units
demonstrated that those with the
highest engagement scores (top 25%)
averaged 18% higher productivity
and 12% higher profitability than
those with the lowest engagement
scores (bottom 25%)3
.
70% of the more engaged have a
good understanding of customer
needs against only 17% of the
disengaged (PwC). 67% of engaged
employees were happy to advocate
their organisations compared to only
3% of the disengaged4
.
Companies with highly engaged
staff report employees taking an
average of 7 absence days per year,
approximately half the 14 days per
year reported in low engagement
companies (bottom 25%). Those
employees in high engagement
companies also report significantly
less workplace stress, 28% versus 39%
(Aon Hewitt 2012)5
.
The CLC reports that highly engaged
organisations have the potential to
reduce staff turnover by 87%; the
disengaged are four times more likely
to leave the organisation than the
average employee (CLC 2008)6
.
What is Employee
Engagement?
As a manager, imagine if every
member of your team acted as though
he or she were the owner/CEO of the
company – taking direct responsibility
for increased sales, lower expenses,
better customer engagement,
increased territory coverage,
motivation of fellow team members
etc. Imagine all of this happening
without you having to constantly run
behind these individuals with a carrot
or a stick to prod them along.
Such employees can be said to be at
the highest levels of engagement with
the company and their jobs. They are
not working to win the “Salesman of
the Year” award. They are not working
for fear of losing their jobs. They do
what they do because they believe that
their work is meaningful, in tune with
their self-image and career goals and
makes a difference to the company
they work for and perhaps even to the
society they live in.
It is true that not everyone on your
team will reach such a state of “flow”
with their work – i.e. work for work’s
sake. Many will be working to get
References
1. Towers Perrin-ISR (2006) “The ISR Employee
Engagement Report” as cited in Macleod and Clarke
“Engaging for Success: Enhancing performance
through employee engagement.”
2. “Trends in Employee Engagement”. Aon Hewitt
(2011).
3. Harter, James K., Schmidt, F. L., Killham, E. A.
and Agrawal, S. (2012). “Q12® Meta-Analysis:
The Relationship Between Engagement at Work and
Organizational Outcomes.” (Gallup Organization.)
4. Fleming, J., Coffman, C. and Harter, J. (2005),
“Manage Your Human Sigma.” Harvard Business
Review 83(7): 106-114.
5. “2012 Trends in Employee Engagement (Aon
Hewitt 2012)
6. Corporate Leadership Council (2004). “Driving
Performance and Retention Through Employee
Engagement” Corporate Executive Board.
“employees... at the highest
levels of engagement with the
company and their jobs... are not
working to win the “Salesman
of the Year” award. They are
not working for fear of losing
their jobs. They do what they do
because they believe that their
work is meaningful, in tune
with their self-image and career
goals and makes a difference to
the company they work for and
perhaps even to the society they
live in.
8 | MedicinMan May 2013
Employee Engagement for Field Force Excellence | Joshua Soans
that “Salesman of the Year award”,
that promised foreign trip or merely
to avoid getting reprimanded. But
the closer you move your team to
full engagement, the better for you,
your company and your employees
themselves.
What Engagement is Not.
It is important to reiterate here that
employee engagement is not a loose
concept of getting employees to
participate in the company cricket
tournament, write poetry for the
company newsletter or take part
in potluck lunches – although
these might make an important
contribution to overall engagement.
HR professionals are often in
the dark about what engagement
really means (perhaps many are
themselves disengaged?) Take
this poll on a large HR forum
on Linkedin, for example. The
question was to do with “employee
engagement activities” that could
be taken up presumably by the
HRM of the company7
. While the
responses in themselves were quite
colorful (“best looser award - weight”,
“dance competition”) they essentially
seemed to be lists of how to distract
employees from work. What they
seemed to convey was “we know your
works sucks, so here’s something
to keep your spirits up.” Imagine
the Indian cricket team going for a
match because they later got to play
antakshari in the dressing room.
Again this is not to undermine the
importance of these activities. As
part of a broader strategy they can,
for example, increase social capital
at the workplace – a critical aspect
of engagement. But in isolation, they
might actually reduce employee
engagement. In any case most
employees today are smart enough
to figure out when their time is being
taken simply because HR is required
to use its budgets – they may prefer to
spend this time at their own discretion.
a test for engagement.
Fundamentally, employee engagement
has 2 aspects to it – the employee’s
satisfaction with his work/company
and the company’s satisfaction with
the employee’s contribution. If either
of this is missing, one can say that the
employee is not fully engaged.
BessingWhite, a Training and Human
Resources firm based out of Princeton,
USA defines full engagement of
an employee as the alignment of
“maximum job satisfaction” with
“maximum job contribution” (see Fig.
1). Employees are not just “passionate
and proud” of their work. They are not
just “committed” to the organization.
They have an eye on their own career
goals and the business goals of the
organization. They are convinced
that to achieve the former, they must
embrace the latter8
.
The BlessingWhite model of
engagement is particularly interesting
because it shows how employees
can be extremely happy with their
organization (maybe they love the
recognition they get because of the
comapany’s reputation) and yet not be
fully engaged – the “honeymooners
and hamsters”. Or they can be highly
productive but burnt out, and thus not
fully engaged – the “crash and burn”
folks.
Then there are the “almost engaged”
– highly productive employees who
love their jobs, but are still a little
unconvinced that another company
where perhaps they are appreciated
a little more, might not in fact be a
better fit for them. These people are the
easiest to move into full engagement.
Finally we have the disengaged –
people who actively dislike their
jobs and are liable to spread their
negative feelings to coworkers. These
are often employees with poor job
fit, poor attitudes to work or those
whose attention is entirely caught
References
7. http://www.citehr.com/237126-summary-
discussion-employee-engagement-activities.html
8. BlessingWhite 2008. “The Employee Engagement
Equation in India.”
Fig. 1: The BlessingWhite Engagement Model. © BlessingWhite
9 | MedicinMan May 2013
Employee Engagement for Field Force Excellence | Joshua Soans
up elsewhere. Unless brought into
engagement or politely asked to
leave, these employees are often a
drag on the company.
How to Bring About
Engagement
The HayGroup, in its report on
Employee Engagement titled:
“Engage Employees and Boost
Performance”, tells the following
story:
Patrick, a call center team manager,
was a “good” employee. He was
prompt, did what he was asked and
was liked by his subordinates. Ask
Patrick how his job was going and he’d
say, “Fine, they pay me pretty well.”
Suddenly he resigned, citing no
complaints and saying only that a
competitor offered him slightly more
money.
But Patrick quit because he was
disengaged. He, like millions of
other employees, needed to believe
his job was important, that he was
contributing daily to the company.
That his work had meaning.
Former colleagues who talked to
him six months later said he was a
different person. His work was no
different, but he clearly had passion
for his job. His explanation? “My
team’s hourly sales are 40 percent
higher than before. But it's more than
that. My first day I got ‘induction
training,’where they explained the
company vision and values. My first
week my boss, Stephanie, explained
what I needed to do to meet the
company’s goals and act in sync with
its values. She spent time coaching me
on my managerial skills, something I
needed badly.”
Soon, Patrick received a “most
promising newcomer” award. At the
company picnic, Stephanie’s boss
asked him how he was doing. After
six months Patrick had an in-depth
performance review where he and
Stephanie candidly discussed his
performance and outlined training
and career growth options for him.
“I work extra hard when it’s needed
because they really care about me,”
Patrick told his ex-colleagues. “They
even let me leave early twice a week
to pick up my kids, which means a lot.
But in the end it really comes down to
leadership. My new company doesn’t
just have a business model; it has a
people model.”9
The HayGroup defines employee
engagement as: “a result that is
achieved by stimulating employees’
enthusiasm for their work and
directing it toward organizational
success.”10
An employee spends a significant
portion of his/her life at work. It is
important that they feel their work
is meaningful and that it matters to
the organization. This is what lies at
the heart of engagement. One cannot
simply trick or coerce employees into
feeling engaged with their jobs – it
is a mental and emotional connect
that is generated through a well
thought out process that enables the
employee to flourish by doing well
what he/she does best.
Think of what might enable an
employee to become attached to
his work and company. At the top
of mind are clearly defined roles
and KPIs, a belief in the vision and
mission of the organization, trust in
his immediate manager and senior
management (that they too believe
in the goals of the organization and
are willing to walk the talk), the right
tools to do his job well (including
training and skills), open and free
communication and voice in the
decisions of the company etc.
These are all serious points which
need further elaboration. And there
are many more. More on how to
bring about Employee Engagement
in the next issue. -MM
References
9. HayGroup 2001. “Engage Employees and Boost
Performance.
10.Ibid.
“An employee spends
a significant portion of
his/her life at work. It is
important that they feel
their work is meaningful
and that it matters to
the organization. This is
what lies at the heart of
engagement.”
Joshua Soans is the Executive Editor
of MedicinMan
joshuasoans@medicinman.net
10 | MedicinMan May 2013
W
hen I was promoted
from a MR to DM
(FLM) and that too at
a young age of 24 years, besides the
fear of unknown and the trepidation
of bigger responsibilities, the first
thought that came to my mind was
‘ I made it’. I felt that all my hard
work and consistent performance
has finally been rewarded. So it was
all celebrations at a reasonably good
restaurant with close friends apart
from my family members. More than
all these, I strongly believed that I
was more than ready to take on the
managerial role.
If I now sit and reflect on this part of
my transition, I have some interest-
ing perspectives to share which may
help many young managers and ‘to
be’ promoted managers.
The reality is, to be successful as a
first-time manager one needs to go
through a major transition for which
many people are not adequately
prepared.
Perhaps the most challenging aspect
of this transition is that first-time
managers are responsible for getting
work done through others rather
than on their own.
While a new manager may recognize
this transition theoretically, they
often refuse to accept it psychologi-
cally, as reflected by their on the job
behaviors.
Most often, they intimidate their
team members with their experience
and expertise. For example, a newly
promoted manager might start doing
So, YOU’RE THE
BOSS NOW.
K. Hariram is the former MD (retd.) at Galderma India.
He is Chief Mentor at MedicinMan and a regular contributor.
khariram25@yahoo.com
Howtomakethetransitionfromsalestopeoplemanagement(without
intimidating team members, micro managing or losing your cool).
“Perhaps the most challenging aspect
of this transition is that first-time
managers are responsible for getting
work done through others rather than
on their own.
While a new manager may recognize
this transition theoretically, they often
refuse to accept it psychologically, as
reflected by their on the job behaviors.”
E
11 | MedicinMan May 2013
So, Your the Boss Now | K. Hariram
everything from talking to doctors/re-
tailers to taking orders etc, himself rather
than helping his team member to do it;
this is all the more if he is well versed
with the customers and the market,
enjoying the thrill of exhibiting to every-
one his established skill in this area. In
other situations, the new manager may
end up challenging/competing with his
team members on assignments and lose
patience when the team member is slow
or shoddy in his approach.
Letting go of the tasks and responsibil-
ities that earned them a promotion in
the first place is a tremendously difficult
aspect of this transition.
Since these behaviors may impact
the overall development, morale and
therefore the productivity of the team
members, organizations must do more
than the normal induction to help the
newly promoted go through this import-
ant transition. The ‘transition training’
should include specific shift in skills,
time frame applications, and work values
in terms of ‘what’ and ‘how’. The new
manager should also understand how the
team members have progressed in their
performance, their skill areas, events
that have shaped them and their value
systems.
In today’s times the era of ‘command and
control’ type of managers do not help
or sustain the performance or for that
matter, the team members, too. Infor-
mation is accessible at all level and the
Generation-Y looks for more latitude in
handling their assignments. Unlike in the
past, they demand career opportunities
and loyalty is the thing of past.
First-line managers and the first time
managers need to wake up to these new
realities and not to the old ones. Not
always easy, because many of the people
who are promoted to this first manageri-
al level are/were good sales people; they
have spent their time developing great
skills at reaching their targets by manag-
ing themself rather than being in touch
with the expectations of their colleagues.
So, let us look at what could help first
time Manager to help through this tran-
sition to meet the needs and maximize
the performance of their team members:
Managers must cease thinking only
about themselves and start thinking
about their team members, their report-
ing managers, other supporting func-
tions, etc. Of course, saying this is easy,
but practicing and orienting takes time.
Clearly defining and assigning
work to be done, including
communicating with the boss and others
about needs or expectations, planning,
organizing, choosing people, and dele-
gating.
Enabling the team members to do
the work by monitoring, coach-
ing, providing feedback, helping with
resources, problem solving, and commu-
nicating.
Establishing relationships with
direct reports, bosses, and sup-
port functions that facilitate two-way
communication including building trust.
Bringing in the necessary
ATTITUDINAL shift from ‘self
to others’.
Investing the necessary time with
the team members. Joint working
with all the team members covering all
the important markets irrespective of
the discomforts of travel, weather, long
working hours and other hardships.
Of course, there are many other aspects
of this management function - and many
other techniques, skills and tools for per-
forming them - than what is mentioned
here.
I have attempted to bring these points to
help people who have transited or going
through the transition to have a basic
understanding of the requirements. I
am sure as one gets deeper into their job
they will be looking for new ideas, new
tools and new techniques.
The conventional definition of a manager
is ‘getting things done through the efforts
of people’.
The new version in the context of
knowledge era is “also helping people to
develop and evolve through work”. -MM
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
“Letting go of the tasks and
responsibilities that earned
them (managers) a promotion
in the first place is a tremen-
dously difficult aspect of this
transition.”
“In today’s times the era of
‘command and control’ type
of managers do not help or
sustain the performance or for
that matter, the team mem-
bers, too.
Information is accessible at
all level and the Generation-Y
looks for more latitude in
handling their assignments.
Unlike in the past, they de-
mand career opportunities and
loyalty is the thing of past.”
12 | MedicinMan April 2013
Speakers at FFE 2012
FFE 20135
x
10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
y
Date: Saturday, 8th June 2013
Theme:FieldForceProductivity
Place: Courtyard Marriott, Mumbai
13 | MedicinMan May 2013
O
ne man can be a crucial
ingredient on a team, but
one man cannot make a
team.” - Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
The famous quote by former NBA
player can be applied in Field Force
Effectiveness (FFE).
Here, if we consider FFE is team-
work, then it cannot be achieved by
Medical Reps or line managers alone.
There must be active involvement of
all other team players in the organi-
zation.
In regular industry practice, sales
persons are held responsible for FFE.
Whereas there are various depart-
ments which are directly or indirect-
ly working towards FFE and there-
fore should made accountable for it.
Consider the following scenarios:
Scenario 1 – Company whose
Medical Reps visit Doctors regularly,
delivering the same message which
marketing team wants to convey, able
to attract good number of customers
under company’s umbrella and have
good hold in territory .
Even after this, if they fail to fetch
the sales numbers it is considered as
their ineffectiveness.
Scenario 2 – Medical Reps of
another company not at all working
efficiently in terms of number of
visits, brand communication and
other activities, even then company
is making satisfactory sales from
heritage brand. This is considered as
effectiveness of sales force.
However both the above cases show
that companies have to look beyond
field force to achieve FFE.
Stakeholders of
Field
Force
ExcellenceMedical Representative
Senior Management
Line Managers
HR
Marketing
Training
Field Force Excellence is the
responsibility of a group of
individuals and not just the Medical
Rep. Each stakeholder in selling
process has a precise and important
role to play.
Vishal V. Bhaiyya is a Consultant - Pharma and Healthcare Projects,
Strategic Analysis Inc.
Follow Vishal Bhaiyya on Twitter: @bhaiya_vishal
vishalbhaiyyapharma.blogspot.in
E
14 | MedicinMan May 2013
Stakeholders of Field Force Excellence | Vishal Bhaiyya
Therefore, there is definite need of map-
ping the accountability of other stake-
holders by their contribution such as
brand strategy, medical communication,
innovation in the molecule, company
reputation in the market and others.
All these stakeholders can impact FFE
beyond their respective tasks.
Roles & Responsibilities for FFE
1) HR and Administration
• Recruitment of members in the team
with good communication skills, clarity
of thoughts and learning ability, and
overall charming personality.
• Transparency in appraisal and other
admin related activities.
2) Training
• Product And Product Related Techni-
cal Knowledge - Trainers can ignite the
minds of sales people with knowledge
required to sell the products in the high-
ly competitive market.
• Calling Skills - Medical Reps who
are the face of company should be well
versed with the skills required to impress
the customers during the call.
3) Marketing and Medical
Communication
• Product Brand Equity
- Marketing team can con-
tribute to FFE in terms of
continuously improving the
brand equity of its products
in the minds of clinicians.
• Brand Communication -
Leveraging USP of prod-
uct to differentiate from
competitors and be able to
force customers to think
twice before switching over
to competitor’s product.
• Medical Communication
- Medical communication
must be so convincing, that KOLs and
influential customers must be convinced
about product before the field force visit.
• CME - This is the best way for a com-
pany to get close to customers so that
field force can nurture the opportunity.
4) Senior Management
• Product Innovation and Introduction
– Pioneers always have an advantage.
Therefore company management should
focus on launching innovative prod-
ucts so that field force can leverage the
advantage.
• Relationship Through CSR – By CSR
activities company can build corporate
image in the society and influence cus-
tomers positively.
5) Line Managers
• Motivation – This is the most import-
ant factor that enabeles line managers to
keep the field force engaged.
• Day To Day Follow-Ups
6) Medical Representative
• Effective Implementation – This should
be the motto of Medical Reps. Whether
it is brand message, medical commu-
nication or any campaign - all must be
implemented as per plan.
• Visit Frequency and Consistency –
There must be continuous and fruitful
visit to customers according to their
category.
• Efficiency in Reaping Benefits – CSR
activities, CMEs, patient education
programs and other activities make the
Medical Reps and Doctors come closer
Conclusion
By this multidimensional and approach,
the company can allocate responsibilities
and make the strategy more and more
focused, leading to FFE -MM
Fig. 1 – Responsibilities of Stakeholders in FFE
)+91-93422-32949
* anupsoans@medicinman.net22 North Road, Cooke Town, Bangalore - 575084
FFE 20135
x
10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
y
Date: Saturday, 8th June 2013
Theme:FieldForceProductivity
Place: Courtyard Marriott, Mumbai
MORNINGAFTERNOON
Session 1: Keynote Address: Shakti Chakraborty, President, Lupin
Session 4: Panel Discussion: “Employee Engagement: The New Paradigm for Enhanc-
ing Field Force Productivity.”
Moderator: Anup Soans - Editor, MedicinMan
Panelists: Deep Bhandari - Director, Marketing and Sales Excellence, UCB
	 	 	 	 -Confirmation awaited from other panelists
Networking Breakfast
Lunch
Session 2: CEO Roundtable: “Field Force Productivity: Opportunities and Challenges”
Moderator: Sujay Shetty, Partner and Lead, Pharma and Life Sciences, PwC
Roundtable Members:
Shakti Chakraborty, President, Lupin
Bhaskar Iyer, Divisional vice president, India Commercial Operations, Abbott
	 	     	 	 -Confirmation awaited from other panelists-
Session 5: Amlesh Ranjan, Associate Director, Sanofi: “New Pharma Sales Model for
Healthcare Opportunity”
Session 3: Panel Discussion: “Business Intelligence for Field Force Productivity.”
Moderator: Vikas Dandekar, India Bureau Chief, Elsevier Business Intelligence
Panelists: Salil Kallianpur, Commercial Head - Classic Brands Center of Excellence, GSK
				-Confirmation awaited from other panelists-
Session 6: K. Hariram, Chief Mentor at MedicinMan, Former (Retd) Managing Director at
Galderma India: “Role Clarity for Field Sales Managers to enhance Field Force Productivity.”
www.medicinman.net
Register Now!
Click here or go to
www.medicinman.net/ffe13-
registrations
Delegate Registration
Pharma Delegates: INR 8,500/-
Non-Pharma Delegates/ Service Providers: INR 9,500/-
Early Bird Discount (for full payment before 10 May 2013): INR 1,000/-
Theme: Field Force Productivity - Opportunities and Challenges
Segmentationforthe
medicalRep.
16 | MedicinMan May 2013
This Article is extacted from
the book “HardKnocks for the
GreenHorn” by Anup Soans.
“HardKnocks for the GreenHorn
is available at a special 1+1 FREE
offer. For Details see page 18.
Segmentation for the Medical Rep | Anup Soans
S
egmentation refers to the
grouping of prospective
customers into segments that
have common needs and will respond
in an identical manner to a marketing
input. Segmentation begins with
understanding customers and allowing
marketers to build relationships with
them. It is the first step in a marketing
strategy. Once marketers divide the
market into various groups, they can
then select their 'targeted segments'
and design products and the marketing
strategy to match their needs.
Pharmaceutical marketing managers
are well-versed in the traditional
aspects of segmenting according
to the speciality of the doctor, the
prescription potential of the doctor,
and the location of his practice, private
practices, institutional businesses,
and the like. These are processes
of demographic and geographic
segmentation, which tell you who the
doctor is and where he practises. It
focuses on the features and benefits of
the product and its price.
It does not, however, take into account
what motivates him, what are his
aspirations, what intangibles move
him, and his personal preferences,
including the aesthetics of the product,
its presentation, the persons who
promote it, and the way it is promoted.
Nonetheless, this type of segmentation,
while difficult, is more personalised
E
17 | MedicinMan May 2013
Segmentation for the Medical Rep | Anup Soans
and, therefore, more effective. For
example, in order to be effective while
promoting a product to a lady doctor,
one needs to be more sensitive to the
nature of her personality. Similarly, in
order to be effective while promoting a
product to a senior doctor, one needs to
take into account his emotional need for
recognition. In short, one size does not
fit all, and the imaginative and informed
MR will strive to be more empathetic
while promoting products to various
segments of doctors. This will make his
job more interesting and will increase
his productivity.
The psychographic profile of the doctor
can make product-promotion more
specific and effective. The prescription
pattern of a doctor or group of doctors
when analysed can reveal the individual
preferences, which are called specific
graphics. They can be used to tailor-
make the promotion so as to influence
the doctor favourably towards the
product, the MR, and his company. The
MR with knowledge, understanding
and an appreciation of the processes
of segmentation, differentiation,
positioning, branding, and pricing can
study individual doctors and groups of
them, and may be in a position to get a
higher return on efforts by adapting the
presentation to suit the doctor's profile.
There are at least six categories of
customer characteristics that form the
basis for segmentation:
Geographic segmentation: The market
is divided according to location. It is
based on the assumption that people
living in the same area share similar
habits and wants.
Demographic segmentation: It is based
on characteristics such as age, sex,
marital status, income, education, and
specialisation of the doctor.
Psychographic segmentation:
Psychological characteristics refer to the
traits of a person. Doctors are divided
on the basis of their needs, personality,
perceptions, knowledge, and level of
engagement, motivations and attitudes.
Specific-graphics segmentation:
Doctors are divided depending on the
product or brand usage characteristics,
such as the rate of usage (doctors are
divided depending on the number
of times they prescribe a product);
awareness status (doctors are divided
based on their knowledge of a product;
for instance, if a doctor instantly
recalls all of the product’s features, his
awareness-level is high and so is his
brand loyalty).
Benefit-segmentation: The market is
divided into segments depending on the
benefits of the products. This method
is used to communicate the product’s
features to consumers. For instance, OD
dosage can be marketed as a form of
convenience and for better compliance.
Hybrid segmentation: Instead of
sticking to one particular segmentation
style, marketers combine one or two
segmentation variables and arrive at
another segmentation. This style is
referred to as Hybrid segmentation.
What are the benefits of Segmentation?
1. You are able to lend focus to your
marketing strategy:
You need to deliver your marketing
message to a relevant doctor group. If
the target market is too broad, there is
a strong risk that the key customers will
be missed. By segmenting markets, the
target doctor can be reached more often
and at a lower cost.
2. You can gain a share of the market
segment:
Unless your products have a strong
or leading market share, they will
be unlikely to get you much profit.
Minor brands suffer from pressures
from distributors and less space on the
chemists’ shelves. Proper segmentation
and targeting will allow you to achieve
a competitive position and become
the preferred choice of doctors and
chemists. Segmentation enables smaller
firms to compete with bigger ones. -MM
Anup Soans is the author of
“HardKnocks for the GreenHorn”,
SuperVision for the SuperWiser
Front-line Manager”and“Repeat Rx”.
He is a facilitator of Learning and
Development Programs for Managers
and Medical Reps at India’s top
Pharma Company’s
Contact:
anupsoans@gmail.com
+91-93422-32949
“In order to be effective while
promoting a product to a senior
doctor, one needs to take into
account his emotional need
for recognition. In short, one
size does not fit all, and the
imaginative and informed
MR will strive to be more
empathetic while promoting
products to various segments
of doctors. This will make his
job more interesting and will
increase his productivity.”
Buy 1 get 1 free !
MRP Rs. 799/- MRP Rs. 599/-
For Individuals*
Buy SuperVision for the SuperWiser Front-line Manager and Get HardKnocks for the
GreenHorn FREE.
For Corporates*
INR 500/- for a set of SuperVision for the SuperWiser Front-line Manager (1 copy)
and HardKnocks for the GreenHorn (1 copy) for purchase of 50 sets and above.
*Inclusive of Shipping to One Location.
Please pay through bank transfer to SB account no. *07141000006761* of “Anup Soans” HDFC Bank, Mosque Road, Frazer
Town Branch, Bangalore – 560005. RTGS/NEFT IFSC: HDFC0000714 and inform by email and SMS - anupsoans@gmail.
com | +91-93422-32949.
Or you can send a cheque favoring “Anup Soans” to:
Anup Soans
101 - North Forte Apts;
22, North Road,
Cooke Town,
St. Thomas Town P.O.
Bangalore - 560084
Field Force Excellence Tools for Individuals and Corporates
19 | MedicinMan May 2013
J
ust the day
before ‘Brand-
Drift 2013’,
when I called on
Gurudas Masurkar at his office, to present him my book,
‘PHARMA FIRST-LINE LEADER TO CEO: THE ROAD-
MAP TO SUCCESS’, I never thought that this would be my
last meeting. Just imagine, at 91, attending office, albeit on
a wheelchair! Late Gurudas Masurkar was the Chairman
Emeritus of Entod Pharmaceuticals, a company he founded
after he retired from an illustrious 29 year career with Duphar
Interfran. Late Gurudas Masurkar was better known as the
‘Crocin Man’.
Gurudas’s journey from a farming family in Masur village of
North Kanara District (Karnataka) to a successful entrepre-
neur is fascinating. After BA he did D.Pharma. He literally
gate-crashed into Crookes Laboratories as a medical represen-
tative (the company later became Duphar Interfran and then
Solvay)! He began his career as a clerk in Popular Pharmacy,
Gurgaon, Mumbai. He was impressed by the well dressed gen-
tlemen, with polished manners, speaking fluent English often
calling on him at Popular Pharmacy. They were the medical
representatives. He decided to pursue his career in pharma-
ceutical selling.
One fine afternoon he went to the office of Crookes Labora-
tories and submitted his application, but was told that there
was no vacancy. He left the office but waited outside for the
managing director. As soon as he saw him, he approached
him and told him of his desire. The MD seeing his bold and
courageous approach recruited him. He eventually rose to
become the head of sales and marketing at Crookes.
Late Gurudas Masurkar launched two successful brands viz.
Crocin and Lacto Calamine. In India, the history of Cro-
cin was more than 50 years when it was first introduced by
Crookes. Competition to Crocin was tough - from Metacin
(by Themis), Malidens (by British Schering, now with Abbott
via the Nicholas Piramal route) and Calpol (by Burroughs
Wellcome, now GSK). Although the brand management con-
cept did not exist in India those days, he once told me, there
used to be healthy marketing battles for brand leadership.
It was a brutal battle which Crocin won. He gives the entire
credit of the success of Crocin to the medical representatives
and field managers. Who would do this in today’s age? My
close friend Shirish Gore who was a Field Manager in Duphar
once said “Masurkar Sir cares a lot for the people and our
development. We will do anything for him. His best trait is
giving honest feedback without offending anyone. Feedback
from him is always a positive experience.” A great lesson to be
learnt by the sales and brand managers!
I asked him about the genesis of the name Crocin. Very simple
he answered. “‘cin’ was a popular suffix for pain killers in those
days. The pain killer from Crookes became Crocin”!
Apart from a brilliant marketing strategist, he was a great
philanthropist and cared even for people he did not know.
When he went on Board of Directors of the second largest
cooperative bank in India, viz. SVC Bank, he remembered
the days when he had to struggle for finances when he floated
Entod Pharmaceuticals. He cut off the red tape so that young
entrepreneurs did not have to wait long for finances. He made
the entire process very smooth and swift.
He has helped in the shaping the careers of many young peo-
ple; and I am one of the beneficiaries.
A great era has come to end. May his soul be in peace! - MM
P.S. Those who have read my book ‘PHARMA FIRST-LINE
LEADER TO CEO: THE ROADMAP TO SUCCESS’ may
remember the two central characters in this book: ‘The Mentor’
and ‘Vinod Kamat‘. ‘The Mentor’ in this book is Late Gurudas
Masurkar while ‘Vinod Kamat’ represents the author.
‘Crocin Man’ passes away.
Gurudas Masurkar was an industry veteran who launched landmark brands like
Crocin and Lacto Calamine. He was Chairman Emeritus at Entod Pharmaceuticals.
A tribute to a Mentor by one of his Mentee.
Prof. Vivek Hattangadi is a Consultant in Pharma Brand Management and
Sales Training at The Enablers. He is also visiting faculty at CIPM Calcutta (Vidyasagar
University) for their MBA course in Pharmaceutical Management.
vivekhattangadi@theenablers.org
E
20 | MedicinMan May 2013
What is
Pharmaco-
economics?
P
harmacoeconomics can be
defined as the description
and analysis of the cost
of drug therapy to the healthcare
systems and the society1
. It is the
process of identifying, measuring
and comparing the costs, risks and
benefits of programs, services or
therapies and determining the best
alternative for health outcomes
for the resource invested. Applied
Pharmacoeconomics can be defined
as combining Pharmacoeconomic
principles, methods and theories
into practice to quantify the
value of pharmacy products and
pharmaceutical care services used in
the real world environments.
Pharamcoeconomics, outcomes
research and pharmaceutical
care can be related to each other.
Pharmacoeconomics is a division
of outcomes research that can
be used to quantify the value of
pharmaceutical care products and
services. Outcomes research can be
defined as the studies that identify,
measure and evaluate the results of
healthcare services. Pharmaceutical
care has been defined as the provision
of drug therapy for achieving definite
outcomes2
.
Perspectives
The perspective of the analysis
determines from whose point of
view the decision is being made.
Defining the perspective of the
analysis is especially important
in pharmacoeconomic analyses
because the costs that are
incurred depend heavily on the
perspective. Assessment of costs
and consequences and the value
of pharmaceutical product or
service depend on the perspective
evaluation. Common perspectives
include patient, provider, payer, and
society.
1. Patient
perspective
It is of utmost importance as the
patients are the ultimate consumers
of healthcare services. These costs
are essentially paid by the patients
Mahendra Rai is a Senior Consultant (HEOR,
Pricing and Market Access) at Capita India.
He is an expert in HEOR, Market Access, and
Outcomes Research.
mahendra.rai@gmail.com
Richa Goyal is a Consultant (HEOR, Pricing and Market
Access) at Capita India, Mumbai. She is an expert in
HEOR, Market Access, Outcomes Research and medical
communications services.
richapharmacist@gmail.com
References
1. Townsend RJ. Post-marketing drug research and
development. Ann Pharmacother 1987;21:134-136.
2. Drummond M, Smith GT, Wells N. Economic evaluation in the
development of medicines. London: Office of Health Economics,
1988:33.
3. http://www.institute.nhs.uk/quality_and_service_
improvement_tools/quality_and_service_improvement_
tools/patient_perspectives.html. Accessed on 28th April 2013
Pharmacoeconomics can be defined as the description and analysis of
the cost of drug therapy to the healthcare systems and the society.
- EMERGINGING AREAS IN HEALTHCARE -
E
21 | MedicinMan May 2013
Pharmacoeconomics: Perspectives in Cost Evaluation | Richa Goyal & Mahendra Rai
for a product or service and are
not covered by the insurance
companies. This perspective should
be considered when assessing the
impact of drug therapy on quality
of life or if a patient pays out of
pocket expense for a healthcare
service3
.
2. Provider
perspective
These are the actual expense of
providing a product or service,
regardless of what is charged
by the provider. Providers
can be hospitals, managed
care organizations, or private
practice physicians. From this
perspective, direct costs like drugs,
hospitalization, laboratory tests,
supplies and salaries of healthcare
professionals can be identified,
measured and compared4
.
3. Payer
perspective
Payers comprise of insurance
companies, employers or the
government. The costs from this
perspective represent the charges
for healthcare products and
services allowed or reimbursed
by the payer. The primary cost
of the payer comes under the
direct costs. Indirect costs such
as lost work days (absenteeism),
low productivity (presenteeism)
also contribute to the total cost of
healthcare to the payer5
.
4. Societal
perspective
This is the broadest of all
perspectives, as it is the only
one that considers the benefit to
society. All direct and indirect
costs are included in the economic
evaluation performed by the
societal perspective. Costs from
this perspective include patient
morbidity and mortality and the
overall costs of giving and receiving
medical care6
.
Conclusion
Analyses can be done from one
or several perspectives, which
will help in determining the
distribution of disease costs across
multiple stakeholders. To conclude,
pharmacoeconomic data can be a
powerful tool to support various
clinical decisions, ranging from
the level of patient to the entire
healthcare system. - MM
References
4. Gail R. Wilensky. Reforming Medicare’s Physician Payment
System. N Engl J Med 2009; 360:653-655.
5. Lancry PJ, Oconnor R, Stempel D, Raz M. Using health
outcomes data to inform decision-making: healthcare payer
perspective. Pharmacoeconomics. 2001;19 Suppl 2:39-47.
6. Russell LB, Fryback DG, Sonnenberg FA. Is the societal
perspective in cost-effectiveness analysis useful for decision
makers? Jt Comm J Qual Improv. 1999 Sep;25(9):447-54.
FFE 20135
x
10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
y
Date: Saturday, 8th June 2013
Theme:FieldForceProductivity
Place: Courtyard Marriott, Mumbai
Registrations
Open
Visit: medicinman.net/
ffe13-registrations
22 | MedicinMan May 2013
Pharmacoeconomic
Analysis
Introduction
T
he rising healthcare
cost is a major concern
to patients, healthcare
professionals, and various
stakeholders involved in
the decision-making. As the
affordability of new medical
technologies continues to be
the subject of heated debate,
attention is increasingly focused
on providing quality, cost-effective
healthcare to patients. In this era
of cost-conscious healthcare
delivery, pharmacoeconomic
research has evolved as a
significant and important field of
research.
Pharmacoeconomic evaluation
identifies, measures and
compares the costs and
consequences of pharmaceutical
products and services. The
numerous stakeholders in the
healthcare landscape must
understand the basics of
pharmacoeconomic principles
and how these may be applied to
make rational therapeutic choices.
Types of
Pharmacoeconomic
Analysis
There are four main types of
pharmacoeconomic evaluations:
1.	 Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
(CEA)
2.	 Cost-Utility Analysis (CUA)
3.	 Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA)
4.	 Cost-Minimisation Analysis
(CMA)
1. Cost-Effectiveness
Analysis (CEA): Compares
the relative difference of costs
and consequences of different
treatment alternatives. In CEA,
costs are measured in monetary
terms and health consequences
are measured in natural or
physical units.
2. Cost-Utility Analysis (CUA):
CUA has the same principle as
a CEA, but includes measures
of the impact on the quality of
life. CUA is often used when
quantity and quality of life are both
important.
3. Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA):
Compares treatment alternatives
where both costs and benefits are
expressed in monetary terms.
4. Cost-Minimisation Analysis
(CMA): Compares treatment
alternatives that yield similar
health consequences. Once
the health consequences are
established to be the same, a
CMA would compare all cost
between treatments to determine
the option with the least cost.
Pharmacoeconomic evaluation
identifies, measures and compares
the costs and consequences
of pharmaceutical products
and services. The numerous
stakeholders in the healthcare
landscape must understand the
basics of pharmacoeconomic
principles and how these may
be applied to make rational
therapeutic choices.
Javed Shaikh is a Consultant (HEOR, Pricing,
Reimbursement and Market Access) at Capita
India, Mumbai.
cpnjaved@gmail.com
Shafaq Shaikh is an Associate (HEOR, Pricing,
Reimbursement and Market Access) at Capita
India, Mumbai.
shafaq07@gmail.com
E
23 | MedicinMan May 2013
Pharmacoeconomic Analysis: Javed Shaikh and Shafaq Shaikh
Types of Costs in
Pharmacoeconomic
Analysis
Costs in health economic
analyses are divided into three
main groups (see Table):
1.	 Direct cost
2.	 Indirect cost
3.	 Intangible cost
Direct Costs Indirect Costs Intangible Costs
Cost of resources
used related to the
illness: medical cost
and non-medical cost
Refers to resources
lost as a result of the
treatment and illness
that involve morbidity
and mortality
Represents costs
as a consequence
of the treatment
not measurable in
monetary terms
Direct medical cost:
Cost of medication,
diagnostic,
treatment, follow-up,
rehabilitation, and
hospital admission
Includes both
paid and unpaid
productivity
loss such as
temporary sickness
absenteeism,
permanent functional
impairment,
premature death, etc.
These costs can
be pain, grief, and
suffering
Direct non-medical
cost: Costs for
personal facilities,
travel, food, lodging,
paid personal care,
etc.
Indirect cost can
be measured by
approaches such as
the Human Capital or
Frictional Methods
Can be quantified
using approved
outcome-
measurement
techniques
Measurements
of Outcomes in
Pharmacoeconomic
Analysis
Health outcomes are
consequences of a treatment/
intervention or programme
which results in changes of
quantity and quality of life.
Health consequences can be
final, intermediate or surrogate
outcomes. Final outcomes are
usually measured as life years
or quality adjusted life years
(QALYs). Intermediate outcomes
are usually measured by clinical
parameters that have evidence-
based correlation with the final
outcome. A surrogate outcome
is an end point that substitutes
and can be predictive of a final
outcome. Final outcomes are
measured over a natural course
of the disease whilst intermediate
outcomes are measured over
a short time horizon. Changes
in quality of life can be valued
directly by several methods such
as rating scale or time trade-off.
It can also be valued indirectly by
employing instruments such as
EQ-5D, HUI3, or SF-6D.
24 | MedicinMan May 2013
Pharmacoeconomic Analysis: Javed Shaikh and Shafaq Shaikh
Decision Analytic Model
Modelling is necessary in health
economic analysis in order
to inform decision-making. It
consists of a series of health
states, representing the expected
health consequences of different
treatments. Modelling provides
an important framework for
synthesizing available evidence
and generating estimates of
clinical and cost-effectiveness.
Modelling can be used to
extrapolate short-term outcome
data or surrogate measures
to long-term outcomes using
modelling techniques. It may
also be used to generate data
from clinical trial settings to
routine practice and to estimate
the relative effectiveness of the
technologies where these have
not been directly compared.
Discounting
The reason for the need to
discount in an economic
evaluation is ‘time preference’
which refers to the desire to enjoy
benefits in the present while
deferring any negative effects
of doing so. Future costs are
discounted to account for the
time value of money, and future
health benefits are discounted
to account for the delay in
satisfaction from these outcomes.
The effect of discounting is to
give future costs and health
benefits less weight in an
economic analysis.
Sensitivity Analysis
Uncertainty could arise in
pharmacoeconomic studies
from the natural variation
in populations and also the
heterogeneous external data
sources used. Sensitivity
analysis is performed for all
key parameters in an analysis,
in order to test the validity and
robustness of the conclusion.
Incremental Cost-
Effectiveness Ratio
(ICER) and Average Cost-
Effectiveness Ratio (ACER)
ICER compares the difference
between the costs and health
consequences of two alternative
interventions that compete for the
same resources. It is generally
described as the additional
cost per additional health
consequence.
ACER is the ratio of the cost to
benefit of an intervention without
reference to a comparator. It
deals with a single intervention
and evaluates that intervention.
ACER is calculated by dividing
the net cost of the intervention
by the total number of health
consequences prevented by
the intervention. It is generally
described as cost per unit of
outcome.
Budget Impact Analysis
(BIA)
BIA estimates the financial
consequences of adopting
a new health technology in
a clearly specified setting.
BIA complements the
pharmacoeconomic evaluations
by providing additional
information for decision making
as it addresses the issue of
affordability and sustainability.
BIA provides information on the
overall impact of a new health
technology to a budget.
25 | MedicinMan May 2013
Pharmacoeconomic Analysis: Javed Shaikh and Shafaq Shaikh
Summary
In order to achieve the goal of
the least expensive treatment
with the best possible outcome,
pharmacoeconomics should be
implemented into the healthcare
decision-making process.
Healthcare resources are not
easily accessible and affordable
to many patients, therefore
pharmacoeconomic evaluations
play an important role in the
allocation of these resources.
Pharmacoeconomics is also
important to drug manufacturers
in terms of communicating
to external decision-makers
(payers, physicians, patients) the
value of their products, achieving
regulatory and reimbursement
approval, and contributing to
commercial success. The use
of pharmacoeconomics in early
drug development phases is
likely to enhance the efficiency
of R&D resource use and also
provide a solid foundation for
communicating product value to
external decision-makers.- MM
References
1. Pharmacoeconomics: From Theory to Practice, Renee J. G.
Arnold (Editor), Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. 2009. 264. ISBN-
13: 978-1420084221.
2. Pharmacoeconomics. Sule NS, Nerurkar RP, Kamath SA. J
Assoc Physicians India. 2002 Aug;50:1057-62.
3. Principles of Good Practice for Decision Analytic Modeling
in Health-Care Evaluation: Report of the ISPOR Task Force
on Good Research Practices—Modeling Studies. Available
from: http://www.ispor.org/workpaper/research_practices/
PrinciplesofGoodPracticeforDecisionAnalyticModeling-
ModelingStudies.pdf
4. Pharmacoeconomics: basic concepts and terminology: T.
Walley & A. Haycox, Br J Clin Pharmacol 1997; 43: 343–348.
Missing something important?
You can access all past issues of MedicinMan
at: http://medicinman.net/archives
Be sure to Subscribe on our website
(top-right corner: www.medicinman.net)
to stay up-to-date with us.
Trainingthat
Stands Out
From the team that brings you
MedicinMan, Brand Drift, Field
Force Excellence seminars and
other breakthrough learning and
development events.
Ad
Training that is RELEVANT and grabs the
ATTENTION of the participants, appealing to
EMOTIONS and firing the INTELLECT to bring about
CHANGE in MINDSET and BEHAVIOR on the FIELD
leading to VALUE CREATION in the DOCTOR’s
CHAMBER and REPEAT Rx for the Company.
For customized programs for Medical Reps, Front-line Managers and Senior Professionals call:
+91 93422 32939 | anupsoans@medicinman.net
27 | MedicinMan May 2013
10 Coaching
Nuggets for FLMs
H
ave you (FLM) ever
thought of building
a sales team that is a
great DIFFERENTIATOR in the
crowded market place? Here are
10 nuggets to help you do this:
1.As an FLM and as a coach,
you have to be accessible
when the team member has a
problem or a need.
2.To be effective as
an FLM, you must have
developed something
through experience that
you can demonstrate and
that will be respected by
your sales people. Merely
demanding results may
not be accepted by your team
members.
3.As an effective sales coach,
you need to ‘walk the talk’ by
modeling those behaviors that you
tell your sales people to exhibit.
4. TELLING is not
COACHING. Your ability
to INFLUENCE with proper
INTERPERSONAL skills become
very vital as part of your coaching
efforts.
5.In coaching activities, as
an FLM and as a coach you are
looking for those behaviors that
influence your sales person’s
selling capabilities. They are
(a) knowledge of the products
and services offered, (b) clear
understanding of sales strategies
and the communication skills,
and (c) knowledge of the market,
including customers.
6.As a coach, you must be
committed and involved in
making each of your team
members...Successful.
7.Sales coaching is a two-way,
one-on-one process that enables
improvement of sales person’s
performance.
8. As an effective coach,
you need to develop the skill
of listening, observing and
objectively putting across the
truth.
9. As a coach you should
promote openness and trust.
10.You need to have
a clear understanding of
sales productivity and more
importantly, the skills in
developing your sales people
to successfully handle the
competitive environment. - MM
This article is 7th in a series on
“Coaching” by the author.
K. Hariram is the former MD (retd.) at Galderma India.
He is Chief Mentor at MedicinMan and a regular
contributor. khariram25@yahoo.com
As an effective coach, you need
to develop the skill of listening,
observing and objectively
putting across the truth.
To be effective as FLM, you
must have developed something
through experience that you can
demonstrate and that will be
respected by your sales people.
Merely demanding results may
not be accepted by your team
members.
E

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Selling Smart: Transactional Analysis and the Psychology of Sales
Selling Smart: Transactional Analysis and the Psychology of SalesSelling Smart: Transactional Analysis and the Psychology of Sales
Selling Smart: Transactional Analysis and the Psychology of SalesAnnArborSPARK
 
Sales force Effectiveness and Productivity Overview SummaryV2
Sales force Effectiveness and Productivity Overview SummaryV2Sales force Effectiveness and Productivity Overview SummaryV2
Sales force Effectiveness and Productivity Overview SummaryV2FredGregg1957
 
Sales Force Effectiveness, Introduction
Sales Force Effectiveness, IntroductionSales Force Effectiveness, Introduction
Sales Force Effectiveness, IntroductionDragan Cirkovic
 
The State of Sales & Marketing at the 50 Fastest-Growing B2B Companies
The State of Sales & Marketing at the 50 Fastest-Growing B2B CompaniesThe State of Sales & Marketing at the 50 Fastest-Growing B2B Companies
The State of Sales & Marketing at the 50 Fastest-Growing B2B CompaniesMattermark
 
Network Marketing Tools
Network Marketing ToolsNetwork Marketing Tools
Network Marketing ToolsJames Dillehay
 
CPSG Presentation
CPSG PresentationCPSG Presentation
CPSG Presentationjayallen77
 
Follow up strategies
Follow up strategiesFollow up strategies
Follow up strategiesDave Kirk
 
signmesh snapshot - the best of sustainability
signmesh snapshot - the best of sustainabilitysignmesh snapshot - the best of sustainability
signmesh snapshot - the best of sustainabilitysignmesh
 
Marketing Presentation For 2011 MBA Program
Marketing Presentation For 2011 MBA ProgramMarketing Presentation For 2011 MBA Program
Marketing Presentation For 2011 MBA Programjreidglass1
 
IQ Work Hacks : Verbal communication
IQ Work Hacks : Verbal communication IQ Work Hacks : Verbal communication
IQ Work Hacks : Verbal communication InterQuest Group
 
Coaching for better performance ok
Coaching for better performance    okCoaching for better performance    ok
Coaching for better performance okmohamed el shrbiny
 
The Art of Pharmaceutical Selling awais
The Art of Pharmaceutical Selling awaisThe Art of Pharmaceutical Selling awais
The Art of Pharmaceutical Selling awaisHasnain Gardezi
 
Finding Your First Customers
Finding Your First CustomersFinding Your First Customers
Finding Your First CustomersSovita Chander
 
Top Productivity Working Hacks by Jan Rezab
Top Productivity Working Hacks by Jan RezabTop Productivity Working Hacks by Jan Rezab
Top Productivity Working Hacks by Jan RezabJan Rezab
 
Sales & Marketing Development Plan - a template for the CRO
Sales & Marketing Development Plan - a template for the CROSales & Marketing Development Plan - a template for the CRO
Sales & Marketing Development Plan - a template for the CROFan Foundry
 
IN CLINIC EFFECTIVENESS
IN CLINIC EFFECTIVENESSIN CLINIC EFFECTIVENESS
IN CLINIC EFFECTIVENESSSCHANDRASEKAR5
 

Tendances (20)

Selling Smart: Transactional Analysis and the Psychology of Sales
Selling Smart: Transactional Analysis and the Psychology of SalesSelling Smart: Transactional Analysis and the Psychology of Sales
Selling Smart: Transactional Analysis and the Psychology of Sales
 
Sales force Effectiveness and Productivity Overview SummaryV2
Sales force Effectiveness and Productivity Overview SummaryV2Sales force Effectiveness and Productivity Overview SummaryV2
Sales force Effectiveness and Productivity Overview SummaryV2
 
Sales Force Effectiveness, Introduction
Sales Force Effectiveness, IntroductionSales Force Effectiveness, Introduction
Sales Force Effectiveness, Introduction
 
The State of Sales & Marketing at the 50 Fastest-Growing B2B Companies
The State of Sales & Marketing at the 50 Fastest-Growing B2B CompaniesThe State of Sales & Marketing at the 50 Fastest-Growing B2B Companies
The State of Sales & Marketing at the 50 Fastest-Growing B2B Companies
 
Sfe final
Sfe finalSfe final
Sfe final
 
Pharma sales territory management
Pharma sales territory managementPharma sales territory management
Pharma sales territory management
 
Network Marketing Closing
Network Marketing ClosingNetwork Marketing Closing
Network Marketing Closing
 
Network Marketing Tools
Network Marketing ToolsNetwork Marketing Tools
Network Marketing Tools
 
CPSG Presentation
CPSG PresentationCPSG Presentation
CPSG Presentation
 
Follow up strategies
Follow up strategiesFollow up strategies
Follow up strategies
 
signmesh snapshot - the best of sustainability
signmesh snapshot - the best of sustainabilitysignmesh snapshot - the best of sustainability
signmesh snapshot - the best of sustainability
 
Marketing Presentation For 2011 MBA Program
Marketing Presentation For 2011 MBA ProgramMarketing Presentation For 2011 MBA Program
Marketing Presentation For 2011 MBA Program
 
IQ Work Hacks : Verbal communication
IQ Work Hacks : Verbal communication IQ Work Hacks : Verbal communication
IQ Work Hacks : Verbal communication
 
Coaching for better performance ok
Coaching for better performance    okCoaching for better performance    ok
Coaching for better performance ok
 
The Art of Pharmaceutical Selling awais
The Art of Pharmaceutical Selling awaisThe Art of Pharmaceutical Selling awais
The Art of Pharmaceutical Selling awais
 
A complete Guide to Network Marketing (MLM) 53 Success Tips
A complete Guide to Network Marketing (MLM) 53 Success Tips A complete Guide to Network Marketing (MLM) 53 Success Tips
A complete Guide to Network Marketing (MLM) 53 Success Tips
 
Finding Your First Customers
Finding Your First CustomersFinding Your First Customers
Finding Your First Customers
 
Top Productivity Working Hacks by Jan Rezab
Top Productivity Working Hacks by Jan RezabTop Productivity Working Hacks by Jan Rezab
Top Productivity Working Hacks by Jan Rezab
 
Sales & Marketing Development Plan - a template for the CRO
Sales & Marketing Development Plan - a template for the CROSales & Marketing Development Plan - a template for the CRO
Sales & Marketing Development Plan - a template for the CRO
 
IN CLINIC EFFECTIVENESS
IN CLINIC EFFECTIVENESSIN CLINIC EFFECTIVENESS
IN CLINIC EFFECTIVENESS
 

En vedette

Clinical Quality Improvement - Dr. Croston's 7 Tips
Clinical Quality Improvement - Dr. Croston's 7 TipsClinical Quality Improvement - Dr. Croston's 7 Tips
Clinical Quality Improvement - Dr. Croston's 7 TipsHealth Catalyst
 
Pitch Training Startup Symposium Slovakia
Pitch Training Startup Symposium SlovakiaPitch Training Startup Symposium Slovakia
Pitch Training Startup Symposium SlovakiaCan Ertugrul
 
HR Policies in Lupin Limited
HR Policies in Lupin LimitedHR Policies in Lupin Limited
HR Policies in Lupin LimitedManik Kudyar
 
25 Employee Engagement Ideas
25 Employee Engagement Ideas25 Employee Engagement Ideas
25 Employee Engagement IdeasHppy
 
HRM Induction Process
HRM Induction ProcessHRM Induction Process
HRM Induction Processharmar
 
Human resource informtion system ppt
Human resource informtion system pptHuman resource informtion system ppt
Human resource informtion system pptAnkur Bhadauria
 
What is Employee Engagement?
What is Employee Engagement?What is Employee Engagement?
What is Employee Engagement?HRZoneHR
 
21 Mind-Blowing Sales Stats
21 Mind-Blowing Sales Stats21 Mind-Blowing Sales Stats
21 Mind-Blowing Sales StatsThe Brevet Group
 
The 5 Elements of Employee Engagement
The 5 Elements of Employee EngagementThe 5 Elements of Employee Engagement
The 5 Elements of Employee EngagementBonusly
 
Employee Engagement A To Z Slides
Employee Engagement A To Z SlidesEmployee Engagement A To Z Slides
Employee Engagement A To Z SlidesDavid Zinger
 
15 Employee Engagement activities that you can start doing now
15 Employee Engagement activities that you can start doing now15 Employee Engagement activities that you can start doing now
15 Employee Engagement activities that you can start doing nowHppy
 
Virtual Conferencing: A Roadmap for Pharma
Virtual Conferencing: A Roadmap for PharmaVirtual Conferencing: A Roadmap for Pharma
Virtual Conferencing: A Roadmap for PharmaLen Starnes
 
Training and development ppt
Training and development pptTraining and development ppt
Training and development pptfirdaus-zailani
 
1215 Bidwell, Alan To Vancouver City Council, 10 Dec 2009
1215 Bidwell, Alan To Vancouver City Council, 10 Dec 20091215 Bidwell, Alan To Vancouver City Council, 10 Dec 2009
1215 Bidwell, Alan To Vancouver City Council, 10 Dec 2009WestEnd Prepare
 
моите красавици,
моите  красавици,моите  красавици,
моите красавици,Zezka Rangelova
 

En vedette (20)

Clinical Quality Improvement - Dr. Croston's 7 Tips
Clinical Quality Improvement - Dr. Croston's 7 TipsClinical Quality Improvement - Dr. Croston's 7 Tips
Clinical Quality Improvement - Dr. Croston's 7 Tips
 
Employee Engagement
Employee EngagementEmployee Engagement
Employee Engagement
 
Pitch Training Startup Symposium Slovakia
Pitch Training Startup Symposium SlovakiaPitch Training Startup Symposium Slovakia
Pitch Training Startup Symposium Slovakia
 
HR Policies in Lupin Limited
HR Policies in Lupin LimitedHR Policies in Lupin Limited
HR Policies in Lupin Limited
 
25 Employee Engagement Ideas
25 Employee Engagement Ideas25 Employee Engagement Ideas
25 Employee Engagement Ideas
 
HRM Induction Process
HRM Induction ProcessHRM Induction Process
HRM Induction Process
 
Human resource informtion system ppt
Human resource informtion system pptHuman resource informtion system ppt
Human resource informtion system ppt
 
What is Employee Engagement?
What is Employee Engagement?What is Employee Engagement?
What is Employee Engagement?
 
21 Mind-Blowing Sales Stats
21 Mind-Blowing Sales Stats21 Mind-Blowing Sales Stats
21 Mind-Blowing Sales Stats
 
The 5 Elements of Employee Engagement
The 5 Elements of Employee EngagementThe 5 Elements of Employee Engagement
The 5 Elements of Employee Engagement
 
Employee Engagement A To Z Slides
Employee Engagement A To Z SlidesEmployee Engagement A To Z Slides
Employee Engagement A To Z Slides
 
15 Employee Engagement activities that you can start doing now
15 Employee Engagement activities that you can start doing now15 Employee Engagement activities that you can start doing now
15 Employee Engagement activities that you can start doing now
 
Virtual Conferencing: A Roadmap for Pharma
Virtual Conferencing: A Roadmap for PharmaVirtual Conferencing: A Roadmap for Pharma
Virtual Conferencing: A Roadmap for Pharma
 
Employee engagement
Employee engagementEmployee engagement
Employee engagement
 
Training and development ppt
Training and development pptTraining and development ppt
Training and development ppt
 
Maas Publications Portfolio 092110
Maas Publications Portfolio 092110Maas Publications Portfolio 092110
Maas Publications Portfolio 092110
 
1215 Bidwell, Alan To Vancouver City Council, 10 Dec 2009
1215 Bidwell, Alan To Vancouver City Council, 10 Dec 20091215 Bidwell, Alan To Vancouver City Council, 10 Dec 2009
1215 Bidwell, Alan To Vancouver City Council, 10 Dec 2009
 
E front it_221012
E front it_221012E front it_221012
E front it_221012
 
моите красавици,
моите  красавици,моите  красавици,
моите красавици,
 
Ss
SsSs
Ss
 

Similaire à Pharma Field Force - How To Bring About Engagement

Medical Rep to President - Inspiring Story of Subroto Banerjee
Medical Rep to President - Inspiring Story of Subroto BanerjeeMedical Rep to President - Inspiring Story of Subroto Banerjee
Medical Rep to President - Inspiring Story of Subroto BanerjeeAnup Soans
 
How Can Indian Pharma Better Manage Talent - Highlights of BCG Report
How Can Indian Pharma Better Manage Talent - Highlights of BCG ReportHow Can Indian Pharma Better Manage Talent - Highlights of BCG Report
How Can Indian Pharma Better Manage Talent - Highlights of BCG ReportAnup Soans
 
Pharma Field Sales Learning and Development
Pharma Field Sales Learning and DevelopmentPharma Field Sales Learning and Development
Pharma Field Sales Learning and DevelopmentAnup Soans
 
Pharma Marketing - Improvement or Insanity? August MedicinMan
Pharma Marketing - Improvement or Insanity? August MedicinManPharma Marketing - Improvement or Insanity? August MedicinMan
Pharma Marketing - Improvement or Insanity? August MedicinManAnup Soans
 
Marrying Medical Affairs with Marketing
Marrying Medical Affairs with MarketingMarrying Medical Affairs with Marketing
Marrying Medical Affairs with MarketingAnup Soans
 
Pharma Front-line Manager Certification Program
Pharma Front-line Manager Certification ProgramPharma Front-line Manager Certification Program
Pharma Front-line Manager Certification ProgramAnup Soans
 
MedicinMan August 2017 - Role of 2nd Line Manager in Pharma
MedicinMan August 2017 - Role of 2nd Line Manager in PharmaMedicinMan August 2017 - Role of 2nd Line Manager in Pharma
MedicinMan August 2017 - Role of 2nd Line Manager in PharmaAnup Soans
 
The Argumentative Indian Pharma Manager by Prof Vivek Hattangadi
The Argumentative Indian Pharma Manager by Prof Vivek HattangadiThe Argumentative Indian Pharma Manager by Prof Vivek Hattangadi
The Argumentative Indian Pharma Manager by Prof Vivek HattangadiAnup Soans
 
001_MedicinMan_August 2011
001_MedicinMan_August 2011001_MedicinMan_August 2011
001_MedicinMan_August 2011Hariram Krishnan
 
Is Pharma Losing Good Salespeople and Getting Bad Managers?
Is Pharma Losing Good Salespeople and Getting Bad Managers?Is Pharma Losing Good Salespeople and Getting Bad Managers?
Is Pharma Losing Good Salespeople and Getting Bad Managers?Anup Soans
 
How Can Medical Reps Achieve Breakthrough Performance?
How Can Medical Reps Achieve Breakthrough Performance?How Can Medical Reps Achieve Breakthrough Performance?
How Can Medical Reps Achieve Breakthrough Performance?Anup Soans
 
The 10 Most Admired Companies to Watch in 2019
The 10 Most Admired Companies to Watch in 2019The 10 Most Admired Companies to Watch in 2019
The 10 Most Admired Companies to Watch in 2019Merry D'souza
 
Pharma: Sky’s the Limit if You Have an ‘Entrepreneurial’ Mindset
Pharma: Sky’s the Limit if You Have an ‘Entrepreneurial’ MindsetPharma: Sky’s the Limit if You Have an ‘Entrepreneurial’ Mindset
Pharma: Sky’s the Limit if You Have an ‘Entrepreneurial’ MindsetAnup Soans
 
When Will Indian Pharma Get its Act Together?
When Will Indian Pharma Get its Act Together?  When Will Indian Pharma Get its Act Together?
When Will Indian Pharma Get its Act Together? Anup Soans
 
Optimism in the Healthcare Workplace Revealed
Optimism in the Healthcare Workplace RevealedOptimism in the Healthcare Workplace Revealed
Optimism in the Healthcare Workplace RevealedChief Optimist
 
FDC Ban - What's Right and What's Wrong?
FDC Ban - What's Right and What's Wrong?FDC Ban - What's Right and What's Wrong?
FDC Ban - What's Right and What's Wrong?Anup Soans
 
Why are there only 15% to 20% Women in Indian Pharma?
Why are there only 15% to 20% Women in Indian Pharma?Why are there only 15% to 20% Women in Indian Pharma?
Why are there only 15% to 20% Women in Indian Pharma?Anup Soans
 
8 Ways to Ensure Your Employees Give a Damn
8 Ways to Ensure Your Employees Give a Damn8 Ways to Ensure Your Employees Give a Damn
8 Ways to Ensure Your Employees Give a DamnKhorus
 
Why Pharma Front-line Managers Must Excel at Teamwork
Why Pharma Front-line Managers Must Excel at TeamworkWhy Pharma Front-line Managers Must Excel at Teamwork
Why Pharma Front-line Managers Must Excel at TeamworkAnup Soans
 
Five Disruptive Forces that are Shaking Up Indian Pharma!
Five Disruptive Forces that are Shaking Up Indian Pharma! Five Disruptive Forces that are Shaking Up Indian Pharma!
Five Disruptive Forces that are Shaking Up Indian Pharma! Anup Soans
 

Similaire à Pharma Field Force - How To Bring About Engagement (20)

Medical Rep to President - Inspiring Story of Subroto Banerjee
Medical Rep to President - Inspiring Story of Subroto BanerjeeMedical Rep to President - Inspiring Story of Subroto Banerjee
Medical Rep to President - Inspiring Story of Subroto Banerjee
 
How Can Indian Pharma Better Manage Talent - Highlights of BCG Report
How Can Indian Pharma Better Manage Talent - Highlights of BCG ReportHow Can Indian Pharma Better Manage Talent - Highlights of BCG Report
How Can Indian Pharma Better Manage Talent - Highlights of BCG Report
 
Pharma Field Sales Learning and Development
Pharma Field Sales Learning and DevelopmentPharma Field Sales Learning and Development
Pharma Field Sales Learning and Development
 
Pharma Marketing - Improvement or Insanity? August MedicinMan
Pharma Marketing - Improvement or Insanity? August MedicinManPharma Marketing - Improvement or Insanity? August MedicinMan
Pharma Marketing - Improvement or Insanity? August MedicinMan
 
Marrying Medical Affairs with Marketing
Marrying Medical Affairs with MarketingMarrying Medical Affairs with Marketing
Marrying Medical Affairs with Marketing
 
Pharma Front-line Manager Certification Program
Pharma Front-line Manager Certification ProgramPharma Front-line Manager Certification Program
Pharma Front-line Manager Certification Program
 
MedicinMan August 2017 - Role of 2nd Line Manager in Pharma
MedicinMan August 2017 - Role of 2nd Line Manager in PharmaMedicinMan August 2017 - Role of 2nd Line Manager in Pharma
MedicinMan August 2017 - Role of 2nd Line Manager in Pharma
 
The Argumentative Indian Pharma Manager by Prof Vivek Hattangadi
The Argumentative Indian Pharma Manager by Prof Vivek HattangadiThe Argumentative Indian Pharma Manager by Prof Vivek Hattangadi
The Argumentative Indian Pharma Manager by Prof Vivek Hattangadi
 
001_MedicinMan_August 2011
001_MedicinMan_August 2011001_MedicinMan_August 2011
001_MedicinMan_August 2011
 
Is Pharma Losing Good Salespeople and Getting Bad Managers?
Is Pharma Losing Good Salespeople and Getting Bad Managers?Is Pharma Losing Good Salespeople and Getting Bad Managers?
Is Pharma Losing Good Salespeople and Getting Bad Managers?
 
How Can Medical Reps Achieve Breakthrough Performance?
How Can Medical Reps Achieve Breakthrough Performance?How Can Medical Reps Achieve Breakthrough Performance?
How Can Medical Reps Achieve Breakthrough Performance?
 
The 10 Most Admired Companies to Watch in 2019
The 10 Most Admired Companies to Watch in 2019The 10 Most Admired Companies to Watch in 2019
The 10 Most Admired Companies to Watch in 2019
 
Pharma: Sky’s the Limit if You Have an ‘Entrepreneurial’ Mindset
Pharma: Sky’s the Limit if You Have an ‘Entrepreneurial’ MindsetPharma: Sky’s the Limit if You Have an ‘Entrepreneurial’ Mindset
Pharma: Sky’s the Limit if You Have an ‘Entrepreneurial’ Mindset
 
When Will Indian Pharma Get its Act Together?
When Will Indian Pharma Get its Act Together?  When Will Indian Pharma Get its Act Together?
When Will Indian Pharma Get its Act Together?
 
Optimism in the Healthcare Workplace Revealed
Optimism in the Healthcare Workplace RevealedOptimism in the Healthcare Workplace Revealed
Optimism in the Healthcare Workplace Revealed
 
FDC Ban - What's Right and What's Wrong?
FDC Ban - What's Right and What's Wrong?FDC Ban - What's Right and What's Wrong?
FDC Ban - What's Right and What's Wrong?
 
Why are there only 15% to 20% Women in Indian Pharma?
Why are there only 15% to 20% Women in Indian Pharma?Why are there only 15% to 20% Women in Indian Pharma?
Why are there only 15% to 20% Women in Indian Pharma?
 
8 Ways to Ensure Your Employees Give a Damn
8 Ways to Ensure Your Employees Give a Damn8 Ways to Ensure Your Employees Give a Damn
8 Ways to Ensure Your Employees Give a Damn
 
Why Pharma Front-line Managers Must Excel at Teamwork
Why Pharma Front-line Managers Must Excel at TeamworkWhy Pharma Front-line Managers Must Excel at Teamwork
Why Pharma Front-line Managers Must Excel at Teamwork
 
Five Disruptive Forces that are Shaking Up Indian Pharma!
Five Disruptive Forces that are Shaking Up Indian Pharma! Five Disruptive Forces that are Shaking Up Indian Pharma!
Five Disruptive Forces that are Shaking Up Indian Pharma!
 

Plus de Anup Soans

An Infectious Disease Specialist, Dr Mandar Kubal Speaks to Pharma on How it ...
An Infectious Disease Specialist, Dr Mandar Kubal Speaks to Pharma on How it ...An Infectious Disease Specialist, Dr Mandar Kubal Speaks to Pharma on How it ...
An Infectious Disease Specialist, Dr Mandar Kubal Speaks to Pharma on How it ...Anup Soans
 
Key Challenges Facing Pharma Industry and the Way Forward
Key Challenges Facing Pharma Industry and the Way ForwardKey Challenges Facing Pharma Industry and the Way Forward
Key Challenges Facing Pharma Industry and the Way ForwardAnup Soans
 
Trends in Pharma Marketing - Focus and Spending
Trends in Pharma Marketing - Focus and SpendingTrends in Pharma Marketing - Focus and Spending
Trends in Pharma Marketing - Focus and SpendingAnup Soans
 
MedicinMan CEO Roundtable 2021 is here... Saturday, Feb 27th
MedicinMan CEO Roundtable 2021 is here... Saturday, Feb 27thMedicinMan CEO Roundtable 2021 is here... Saturday, Feb 27th
MedicinMan CEO Roundtable 2021 is here... Saturday, Feb 27thAnup Soans
 
Key Account Management - Time for India Pharma to Adopt KAM
Key Account Management - Time for India Pharma to Adopt KAMKey Account Management - Time for India Pharma to Adopt KAM
Key Account Management - Time for India Pharma to Adopt KAMAnup Soans
 
MedicinMan Report on Digital Readiness of Indian Pharma 2021
MedicinMan Report on Digital Readiness of Indian Pharma 2021MedicinMan Report on Digital Readiness of Indian Pharma 2021
MedicinMan Report on Digital Readiness of Indian Pharma 2021Anup Soans
 
How can Pharma Use Digital to Engage Doctors and Understand Patients
How can Pharma Use Digital to Engage Doctors and Understand PatientsHow can Pharma Use Digital to Engage Doctors and Understand Patients
How can Pharma Use Digital to Engage Doctors and Understand PatientsAnup Soans
 
Why Indian Pharma Needs to Enable Managers to Develop Talent
Why Indian Pharma Needs to Enable Managers to Develop TalentWhy Indian Pharma Needs to Enable Managers to Develop Talent
Why Indian Pharma Needs to Enable Managers to Develop TalentAnup Soans
 
Digital Excellence Pharma Academy Certification Program
Digital Excellence Pharma Academy Certification ProgramDigital Excellence Pharma Academy Certification Program
Digital Excellence Pharma Academy Certification ProgramAnup Soans
 
Digital Excellent Pharma Academy Certification Program
Digital Excellent Pharma Academy Certification ProgramDigital Excellent Pharma Academy Certification Program
Digital Excellent Pharma Academy Certification ProgramAnup Soans
 
COVID-19 Vaccine Roll Out Plan by Ministry of Health and Family Affairs
COVID-19 Vaccine Roll Out Plan by Ministry of Health and Family AffairsCOVID-19 Vaccine Roll Out Plan by Ministry of Health and Family Affairs
COVID-19 Vaccine Roll Out Plan by Ministry of Health and Family AffairsAnup Soans
 
Architecture To Develop Pharma Business Leaders For Today and Tomorrow
Architecture To Develop Pharma Business Leaders  For Today and Tomorrow  Architecture To Develop Pharma Business Leaders  For Today and Tomorrow
Architecture To Develop Pharma Business Leaders For Today and Tomorrow Anup Soans
 
What is Indian Pharma Thinking about Digital? A Research Project
What is Indian Pharma Thinking about Digital? A Research ProjectWhat is Indian Pharma Thinking about Digital? A Research Project
What is Indian Pharma Thinking about Digital? A Research ProjectAnup Soans
 
Digital Excellence Pharma Academy - Webinar & Online Certification Program
Digital Excellence Pharma Academy - Webinar & Online Certification ProgramDigital Excellence Pharma Academy - Webinar & Online Certification Program
Digital Excellence Pharma Academy - Webinar & Online Certification ProgramAnup Soans
 
Telemedicine Guidelines for Indian Doctors
Telemedicine Guidelines for Indian DoctorsTelemedicine Guidelines for Indian Doctors
Telemedicine Guidelines for Indian DoctorsAnup Soans
 
The Mankind Pharma Story by Dr. Sumit Ghoshal
The Mankind Pharma Story by Dr. Sumit GhoshalThe Mankind Pharma Story by Dr. Sumit Ghoshal
The Mankind Pharma Story by Dr. Sumit GhoshalAnup Soans
 
Indian Pharma and Retail Pharmacies - Sales View Poll
Indian Pharma and Retail Pharmacies - Sales View PollIndian Pharma and Retail Pharmacies - Sales View Poll
Indian Pharma and Retail Pharmacies - Sales View PollAnup Soans
 
Healthcare's Future will be Patient Experience
Healthcare's Future will be Patient ExperienceHealthcare's Future will be Patient Experience
Healthcare's Future will be Patient ExperienceAnup Soans
 
Unethical Practices in Pharma - Interesting Study from Pakistan
Unethical Practices in Pharma - Interesting Study from Pakistan Unethical Practices in Pharma - Interesting Study from Pakistan
Unethical Practices in Pharma - Interesting Study from Pakistan Anup Soans
 
MedicinMan December 2018 Issue
MedicinMan December 2018 IssueMedicinMan December 2018 Issue
MedicinMan December 2018 IssueAnup Soans
 

Plus de Anup Soans (20)

An Infectious Disease Specialist, Dr Mandar Kubal Speaks to Pharma on How it ...
An Infectious Disease Specialist, Dr Mandar Kubal Speaks to Pharma on How it ...An Infectious Disease Specialist, Dr Mandar Kubal Speaks to Pharma on How it ...
An Infectious Disease Specialist, Dr Mandar Kubal Speaks to Pharma on How it ...
 
Key Challenges Facing Pharma Industry and the Way Forward
Key Challenges Facing Pharma Industry and the Way ForwardKey Challenges Facing Pharma Industry and the Way Forward
Key Challenges Facing Pharma Industry and the Way Forward
 
Trends in Pharma Marketing - Focus and Spending
Trends in Pharma Marketing - Focus and SpendingTrends in Pharma Marketing - Focus and Spending
Trends in Pharma Marketing - Focus and Spending
 
MedicinMan CEO Roundtable 2021 is here... Saturday, Feb 27th
MedicinMan CEO Roundtable 2021 is here... Saturday, Feb 27thMedicinMan CEO Roundtable 2021 is here... Saturday, Feb 27th
MedicinMan CEO Roundtable 2021 is here... Saturday, Feb 27th
 
Key Account Management - Time for India Pharma to Adopt KAM
Key Account Management - Time for India Pharma to Adopt KAMKey Account Management - Time for India Pharma to Adopt KAM
Key Account Management - Time for India Pharma to Adopt KAM
 
MedicinMan Report on Digital Readiness of Indian Pharma 2021
MedicinMan Report on Digital Readiness of Indian Pharma 2021MedicinMan Report on Digital Readiness of Indian Pharma 2021
MedicinMan Report on Digital Readiness of Indian Pharma 2021
 
How can Pharma Use Digital to Engage Doctors and Understand Patients
How can Pharma Use Digital to Engage Doctors and Understand PatientsHow can Pharma Use Digital to Engage Doctors and Understand Patients
How can Pharma Use Digital to Engage Doctors and Understand Patients
 
Why Indian Pharma Needs to Enable Managers to Develop Talent
Why Indian Pharma Needs to Enable Managers to Develop TalentWhy Indian Pharma Needs to Enable Managers to Develop Talent
Why Indian Pharma Needs to Enable Managers to Develop Talent
 
Digital Excellence Pharma Academy Certification Program
Digital Excellence Pharma Academy Certification ProgramDigital Excellence Pharma Academy Certification Program
Digital Excellence Pharma Academy Certification Program
 
Digital Excellent Pharma Academy Certification Program
Digital Excellent Pharma Academy Certification ProgramDigital Excellent Pharma Academy Certification Program
Digital Excellent Pharma Academy Certification Program
 
COVID-19 Vaccine Roll Out Plan by Ministry of Health and Family Affairs
COVID-19 Vaccine Roll Out Plan by Ministry of Health and Family AffairsCOVID-19 Vaccine Roll Out Plan by Ministry of Health and Family Affairs
COVID-19 Vaccine Roll Out Plan by Ministry of Health and Family Affairs
 
Architecture To Develop Pharma Business Leaders For Today and Tomorrow
Architecture To Develop Pharma Business Leaders  For Today and Tomorrow  Architecture To Develop Pharma Business Leaders  For Today and Tomorrow
Architecture To Develop Pharma Business Leaders For Today and Tomorrow
 
What is Indian Pharma Thinking about Digital? A Research Project
What is Indian Pharma Thinking about Digital? A Research ProjectWhat is Indian Pharma Thinking about Digital? A Research Project
What is Indian Pharma Thinking about Digital? A Research Project
 
Digital Excellence Pharma Academy - Webinar & Online Certification Program
Digital Excellence Pharma Academy - Webinar & Online Certification ProgramDigital Excellence Pharma Academy - Webinar & Online Certification Program
Digital Excellence Pharma Academy - Webinar & Online Certification Program
 
Telemedicine Guidelines for Indian Doctors
Telemedicine Guidelines for Indian DoctorsTelemedicine Guidelines for Indian Doctors
Telemedicine Guidelines for Indian Doctors
 
The Mankind Pharma Story by Dr. Sumit Ghoshal
The Mankind Pharma Story by Dr. Sumit GhoshalThe Mankind Pharma Story by Dr. Sumit Ghoshal
The Mankind Pharma Story by Dr. Sumit Ghoshal
 
Indian Pharma and Retail Pharmacies - Sales View Poll
Indian Pharma and Retail Pharmacies - Sales View PollIndian Pharma and Retail Pharmacies - Sales View Poll
Indian Pharma and Retail Pharmacies - Sales View Poll
 
Healthcare's Future will be Patient Experience
Healthcare's Future will be Patient ExperienceHealthcare's Future will be Patient Experience
Healthcare's Future will be Patient Experience
 
Unethical Practices in Pharma - Interesting Study from Pakistan
Unethical Practices in Pharma - Interesting Study from Pakistan Unethical Practices in Pharma - Interesting Study from Pakistan
Unethical Practices in Pharma - Interesting Study from Pakistan
 
MedicinMan December 2018 Issue
MedicinMan December 2018 IssueMedicinMan December 2018 Issue
MedicinMan December 2018 Issue
 

Dernier

Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdfIntro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdfpollardmorgan
 
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City GurgaonCall Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaoncallgirls2057
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607dollysharma2066
 
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy Verified Accounts
 
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted VersionFuture Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted VersionMintel Group
 
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03DallasHaselhorst
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?Olivia Kresic
 
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdf
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdfAPRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdf
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdfRbc Rbcua
 
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdfInnovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdfrichard876048
 
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMarket Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMintel Group
 
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...lizamodels9
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...lizamodels9
 
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,noida100girls
 
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesAnnual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesKeppelCorporation
 
Call Girls Miyapur 7001305949 all area service COD available Any Time
Call Girls Miyapur 7001305949 all area service COD available Any TimeCall Girls Miyapur 7001305949 all area service COD available Any Time
Call Girls Miyapur 7001305949 all area service COD available Any Timedelhimodelshub1
 
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent ChirchirMarketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchirictsugar
 
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu MenzaYouth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menzaictsugar
 

Dernier (20)

Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdfIntro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
Intro to BCG's Carbon Emissions Benchmark_vF.pdf
 
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City GurgaonCall Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
 
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
 
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
(Best) ENJOY Call Girls in Faridabad Ex | 8377087607
 
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
 
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted VersionFuture Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
 
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Tughlakabad Delhi NCR
 
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?
MAHA Global and IPR: Do Actions Speak Louder Than Words?
 
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdf
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdfAPRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdf
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdf
 
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdfInnovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
 
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMarket Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
 
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
 
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
 
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesAnnual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
 
Call Girls Miyapur 7001305949 all area service COD available Any Time
Call Girls Miyapur 7001305949 all area service COD available Any TimeCall Girls Miyapur 7001305949 all area service COD available Any Time
Call Girls Miyapur 7001305949 all area service COD available Any Time
 
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent ChirchirMarketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
Marketplace and Quality Assurance Presentation - Vincent Chirchir
 
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu MenzaYouth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
 

Pharma Field Force - How To Bring About Engagement

  • 1. MEDICINMANField Force Excellence TM May 2013 | www.medicinman.net Graduatesas Medical Reps. - Editorial ScienceVs. Non-Science
  • 2. 2 | MedicinMan May 2013 EDITORIAL | Science Vs. Non-Science Graduates as Medical Reps The top management of each company must have a clear understanding and ask - are we a ‘science’ company or are we a ‘sales organization’? H ere’s the question: Do all the thousands of companies promoting the 100th generic molecule need to talk science? Even if they want to, is the doctor interested in listening to a ‘detailing talk’ by a poorly motivated field force that changes their company every year? Sure, companies promoting IP prod- ucts and even Indian companies focusing on a particular therapy area or niche market segment may need B. Pharma or B.Sc candidates. You need B. Pharma and B. Sc candi- dates as MRs when the job role is to generate prescriptions by giving highly scientific information. Do you need them when the job is largely a sales job? We have over 60,000 brands in Indian Pharma Market - how many of them are novel IP products? Today the role of an MR/FLM in most Indian Pharma companies is ‘science’ by title and ‘sales’ by necessity. Why then this emphasis on science can- didates? Will they really enjoy doing an ultra high pressure sales job? Are they cut-out for the role where 80% of the time is spent waiting and only 20% in actually talking and listening to doctors? How much science can an MR talk in 180 seconds? The attrition rate is clearly an indicator of dissatisfaction brought about by mismatch. Pharma is busy fitting square pegs in round holes and as a result neither the candidates are happy nor are the companies getting enough productivity from the field force. Time to re-think? I think the top management of each company must have a clear under- standing and ask - “are we a ‘science’ company or are we a sales organiza- tion?” Once this is clear, it becomes easier to adopt the right strategy, hire the right people and give the right training. So far only a few Indian companies like Mankind Pharma have dared to address this issue head-on and their splendid field force productivity and low attrition is a proof that it works. Even when it comes to product management in most Indian Pharma companies, the PMs are busy designing sales schemes and not product man- agement or brand building. A strong, sales oriented field force led by FLMs with good leadership and managerial skills and supported by field force friendly, physician-fo- cused and patient centric, on-call medico-marketing team might be a better option. What do you think? - MM For further reading: 1. Report by the iOpener Institute for People and Performance:“Job Fulfillment, Not Money, Retains Gen-YTalent”. Full report is available at - http://medicinman.net/2013/04/job- fulfillment-not-pay-retains-gen-y-talent/ 2.What Do MRs Need to MakeTheirWork Enjoyable? A MedicinMan Survey. For full article please download MedicinMan December 2011 issue -http://medicinman.net/archives/ 3. How to Attract Freshers to Opt for Pharma/ Healthcare Career? LinkedIn Discussion - http:// lnkd.in/D7WAEj Connect with Anup Soans on LinkedIn | Facebook | Twitter Visit anupsoans.com. Meet the Editor Anup Soans is an Author, Facilitator and the Editor of MedicinMan. Write in to him: anupsoans@medicinman.net Editorial “You need B. Pharma and B. Sc candidates as MRs when the job role is to generate prescriptions by giving highly scientific infor- mation. Do you need them when the job is largely a sales job?”
  • 3. Buy 1 get 1 free ! MRP Rs. 799/- MRP Rs. 599/- For Individuals* Buy SuperVision for the SuperWiser Front-line Manager and Get HardKnocks for the GreenHorn FREE. For Corporates* INR 500/- for a set of SuperVision for the SuperWiser Front-line Manager (1 copy) and HardKnocks for the GreenHorn (1 copy) for purchase of 50 sets and above. *Inclusive of Shipping to One Location. Please pay through bank transfer to SB account no. *07141000006761* of “Anup Soans” HDFC Bank, Mosque Road, Frazer Town Branch, Bangalore – 560005. RTGS/NEFT IFSC: HDFC0000714 and inform by email and SMS - anupsoans@gmail. com | +91-93422-32949. Or you can send a cheque favoring “Anup Soans” to: Anup Soans 101 - North Forte Apts; 22, North Road, Cooke Town, St. Thomas Town P.O. Bangalore - 560084 Field Force Excellence Tools for Individuals and Corporates
  • 4. Field Force Excellence 1. Employee Engagement for Field Force Excellence - Part I..................................................6 Who is an “engaged employee”? Why are engaged employees so critical to a company’s success? How can we bring about enployee engagement? Joshua Soans 2. So, You’re the Boss Now................................10 How to make the transition from ‘sales’ to ‘people management’ (without intimidating team members, micro-managing or losing your cool). K. Hariram 3. Stakeholders in Field Force Excellence .......13 Many people in an organization are repsonsible for FFE. A brief look at some of their roles and responsibilities. Vishal V. Bhaiyya Marketing for the MR 4. Segmentation for the Medical Rep................16 Segmentation of customers is a critical skill and tool for Medical Reps to increase the ROI of their sales call. Anup Soans from “HardKnocks for the GreenHorn” In Memoriam 5. ‘Crocin Man’ Passes Away..............................19 Gurudas Masurkar was an industry veteran who launched landmark brands like Crocin and Lacto Calamine. He was Chairman Emeritus at Entod Pharmaceuticals. Vivek Hattangadi Contents (click to navigate)
  • 5. Emerging Areas in Healthcare 6. What is Pharmacoeconomics? .....................20 Pharmacoeconomics exposes the true cost to society of a particular drug therapy in treating a condition. Richa Goyal and Mahendra Rai 7. Pharmacoeconomic Analysis........................22 An in-depth look at pharmacoeconomics - the types of cost calculation, how they are calculated and what they mean for different stakeholders. Javed Shailk and Shafaq Shaikh Coaching 8. Ten Coaching Nuggets for FLMs ..................27 Ten tips on how to get the best out of your team by Coaching them. K. Hariram Contents (click to navigate) MedicinMan Volume 3 Issue 5 | May 2013 Editor and Publisher Anup Soans CEO Chhaya Sankath COO Arvind Nair Chief Mentor K. Hariram Advisory Board Vivek Hattangadi; Jolly Mathews Editorial Board Salil Kallianpur; Dr. Shalini Ratan; Shashin Bodawala; Prabhakar Shetty; Vardarajan S; Dr. Mandar Kubal; Dr. Surinder Kumar International Editorial Board Hanno Wolfram; Renie McClay Executive Editor Joshua Soans MedicinMan Academy: Prof. Vivek Hattangaadi, Dean, Professional Skills Development MedicinMan ChangeMakers Saurabh Kumar Make a difference in Pharma. Join MedicinMan ChangeMakers. Write in to our editor to find out more: anupsoans@medicinman.net Letters to the Editor: anupsoans@medicinman.net FFE 20135 x 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 y Date: Saturday, 8th June 2013 Theme:FieldForceProductivity Place: Courtyard Marriott, Mumbai Registrations Open. Hurry! Visit: medicinman.net/ ffe13-registration
  • 6. E 6 | MedicinMan May 2013 Employee Engagement for Field Force Excellence | Joshua Soans Employee Engagement for Field Force Excellence. Studies involving hundreds of thousands of employees across the globe have shown that engaged employees invest more “discretionary effort”, have a better understanding of their work, are far less likely to leave the organization, positively recommend the organization to others and take fewer days off from work. This article is the 1st in a series on Employee Engagement. Employee Engagement is a serious commitment to aligning employee aspirations with organizational goals. For engaged employees, the line between “work” and “life” is blurred or non- existant - like this woman reporter in the Sichuan Province of China who was on her way to her wedding when a massive earthquake struck on April 20th, 2013. She immediately got to work interviewing bystanders and reporting on the quake (see video: http://youtu.be/bLsTs4DRv18) FFE 20135 x 10 15 20 25 30 35 35 40 45 50 55 y SPECIAL REPORT
  • 7. Employee Engagement for Field Force Excellence | Joshua Soans 7 | MedicinMan May 2013 Introduction. E very manager in charge of achieving company goals through a team of employees would like to know how to motivate them to put in 100 per cent effort and some more. A pharma sales manager would like to know how to get his team to generate more sales, increase customer satisfaction, take lesser time off from work, make fewer mistakes on the job, recommend the company to others and motivate his colleagues to do all of the above as well. A number of authoritative studies in recent years show that employees who are “fully” or “highly” engaged are much more likely to do all of the above compared to their counterparts with low engagement levels or who are “actively disengaged”. The results from these studies – involving up to 6.5 lakh employees globally1 – even show a direct and stunningly large correlation between increased profits and employee engagement. Consider these figures. Research from organisations representing more than five million employees worldwide in the Aon Hewitt database showed that in 2010 organisations with engagement levels of 65% or greater posted total shareholder returns that were 22% higher than average; companies with engagement levels of 45% or less had a total shareholder return that was 28% lower than the average return in 20102 . A Gallup study (2006) looking at data from over 23 thousand business units demonstrated that those with the highest engagement scores (top 25%) averaged 18% higher productivity and 12% higher profitability than those with the lowest engagement scores (bottom 25%)3 . 70% of the more engaged have a good understanding of customer needs against only 17% of the disengaged (PwC). 67% of engaged employees were happy to advocate their organisations compared to only 3% of the disengaged4 . Companies with highly engaged staff report employees taking an average of 7 absence days per year, approximately half the 14 days per year reported in low engagement companies (bottom 25%). Those employees in high engagement companies also report significantly less workplace stress, 28% versus 39% (Aon Hewitt 2012)5 . The CLC reports that highly engaged organisations have the potential to reduce staff turnover by 87%; the disengaged are four times more likely to leave the organisation than the average employee (CLC 2008)6 . What is Employee Engagement? As a manager, imagine if every member of your team acted as though he or she were the owner/CEO of the company – taking direct responsibility for increased sales, lower expenses, better customer engagement, increased territory coverage, motivation of fellow team members etc. Imagine all of this happening without you having to constantly run behind these individuals with a carrot or a stick to prod them along. Such employees can be said to be at the highest levels of engagement with the company and their jobs. They are not working to win the “Salesman of the Year” award. They are not working for fear of losing their jobs. They do what they do because they believe that their work is meaningful, in tune with their self-image and career goals and makes a difference to the company they work for and perhaps even to the society they live in. It is true that not everyone on your team will reach such a state of “flow” with their work – i.e. work for work’s sake. Many will be working to get References 1. Towers Perrin-ISR (2006) “The ISR Employee Engagement Report” as cited in Macleod and Clarke “Engaging for Success: Enhancing performance through employee engagement.” 2. “Trends in Employee Engagement”. Aon Hewitt (2011). 3. Harter, James K., Schmidt, F. L., Killham, E. A. and Agrawal, S. (2012). “Q12® Meta-Analysis: The Relationship Between Engagement at Work and Organizational Outcomes.” (Gallup Organization.) 4. Fleming, J., Coffman, C. and Harter, J. (2005), “Manage Your Human Sigma.” Harvard Business Review 83(7): 106-114. 5. “2012 Trends in Employee Engagement (Aon Hewitt 2012) 6. Corporate Leadership Council (2004). “Driving Performance and Retention Through Employee Engagement” Corporate Executive Board. “employees... at the highest levels of engagement with the company and their jobs... are not working to win the “Salesman of the Year” award. They are not working for fear of losing their jobs. They do what they do because they believe that their work is meaningful, in tune with their self-image and career goals and makes a difference to the company they work for and perhaps even to the society they live in.
  • 8. 8 | MedicinMan May 2013 Employee Engagement for Field Force Excellence | Joshua Soans that “Salesman of the Year award”, that promised foreign trip or merely to avoid getting reprimanded. But the closer you move your team to full engagement, the better for you, your company and your employees themselves. What Engagement is Not. It is important to reiterate here that employee engagement is not a loose concept of getting employees to participate in the company cricket tournament, write poetry for the company newsletter or take part in potluck lunches – although these might make an important contribution to overall engagement. HR professionals are often in the dark about what engagement really means (perhaps many are themselves disengaged?) Take this poll on a large HR forum on Linkedin, for example. The question was to do with “employee engagement activities” that could be taken up presumably by the HRM of the company7 . While the responses in themselves were quite colorful (“best looser award - weight”, “dance competition”) they essentially seemed to be lists of how to distract employees from work. What they seemed to convey was “we know your works sucks, so here’s something to keep your spirits up.” Imagine the Indian cricket team going for a match because they later got to play antakshari in the dressing room. Again this is not to undermine the importance of these activities. As part of a broader strategy they can, for example, increase social capital at the workplace – a critical aspect of engagement. But in isolation, they might actually reduce employee engagement. In any case most employees today are smart enough to figure out when their time is being taken simply because HR is required to use its budgets – they may prefer to spend this time at their own discretion. a test for engagement. Fundamentally, employee engagement has 2 aspects to it – the employee’s satisfaction with his work/company and the company’s satisfaction with the employee’s contribution. If either of this is missing, one can say that the employee is not fully engaged. BessingWhite, a Training and Human Resources firm based out of Princeton, USA defines full engagement of an employee as the alignment of “maximum job satisfaction” with “maximum job contribution” (see Fig. 1). Employees are not just “passionate and proud” of their work. They are not just “committed” to the organization. They have an eye on their own career goals and the business goals of the organization. They are convinced that to achieve the former, they must embrace the latter8 . The BlessingWhite model of engagement is particularly interesting because it shows how employees can be extremely happy with their organization (maybe they love the recognition they get because of the comapany’s reputation) and yet not be fully engaged – the “honeymooners and hamsters”. Or they can be highly productive but burnt out, and thus not fully engaged – the “crash and burn” folks. Then there are the “almost engaged” – highly productive employees who love their jobs, but are still a little unconvinced that another company where perhaps they are appreciated a little more, might not in fact be a better fit for them. These people are the easiest to move into full engagement. Finally we have the disengaged – people who actively dislike their jobs and are liable to spread their negative feelings to coworkers. These are often employees with poor job fit, poor attitudes to work or those whose attention is entirely caught References 7. http://www.citehr.com/237126-summary- discussion-employee-engagement-activities.html 8. BlessingWhite 2008. “The Employee Engagement Equation in India.” Fig. 1: The BlessingWhite Engagement Model. © BlessingWhite
  • 9. 9 | MedicinMan May 2013 Employee Engagement for Field Force Excellence | Joshua Soans up elsewhere. Unless brought into engagement or politely asked to leave, these employees are often a drag on the company. How to Bring About Engagement The HayGroup, in its report on Employee Engagement titled: “Engage Employees and Boost Performance”, tells the following story: Patrick, a call center team manager, was a “good” employee. He was prompt, did what he was asked and was liked by his subordinates. Ask Patrick how his job was going and he’d say, “Fine, they pay me pretty well.” Suddenly he resigned, citing no complaints and saying only that a competitor offered him slightly more money. But Patrick quit because he was disengaged. He, like millions of other employees, needed to believe his job was important, that he was contributing daily to the company. That his work had meaning. Former colleagues who talked to him six months later said he was a different person. His work was no different, but he clearly had passion for his job. His explanation? “My team’s hourly sales are 40 percent higher than before. But it's more than that. My first day I got ‘induction training,’where they explained the company vision and values. My first week my boss, Stephanie, explained what I needed to do to meet the company’s goals and act in sync with its values. She spent time coaching me on my managerial skills, something I needed badly.” Soon, Patrick received a “most promising newcomer” award. At the company picnic, Stephanie’s boss asked him how he was doing. After six months Patrick had an in-depth performance review where he and Stephanie candidly discussed his performance and outlined training and career growth options for him. “I work extra hard when it’s needed because they really care about me,” Patrick told his ex-colleagues. “They even let me leave early twice a week to pick up my kids, which means a lot. But in the end it really comes down to leadership. My new company doesn’t just have a business model; it has a people model.”9 The HayGroup defines employee engagement as: “a result that is achieved by stimulating employees’ enthusiasm for their work and directing it toward organizational success.”10 An employee spends a significant portion of his/her life at work. It is important that they feel their work is meaningful and that it matters to the organization. This is what lies at the heart of engagement. One cannot simply trick or coerce employees into feeling engaged with their jobs – it is a mental and emotional connect that is generated through a well thought out process that enables the employee to flourish by doing well what he/she does best. Think of what might enable an employee to become attached to his work and company. At the top of mind are clearly defined roles and KPIs, a belief in the vision and mission of the organization, trust in his immediate manager and senior management (that they too believe in the goals of the organization and are willing to walk the talk), the right tools to do his job well (including training and skills), open and free communication and voice in the decisions of the company etc. These are all serious points which need further elaboration. And there are many more. More on how to bring about Employee Engagement in the next issue. -MM References 9. HayGroup 2001. “Engage Employees and Boost Performance. 10.Ibid. “An employee spends a significant portion of his/her life at work. It is important that they feel their work is meaningful and that it matters to the organization. This is what lies at the heart of engagement.” Joshua Soans is the Executive Editor of MedicinMan joshuasoans@medicinman.net
  • 10. 10 | MedicinMan May 2013 W hen I was promoted from a MR to DM (FLM) and that too at a young age of 24 years, besides the fear of unknown and the trepidation of bigger responsibilities, the first thought that came to my mind was ‘ I made it’. I felt that all my hard work and consistent performance has finally been rewarded. So it was all celebrations at a reasonably good restaurant with close friends apart from my family members. More than all these, I strongly believed that I was more than ready to take on the managerial role. If I now sit and reflect on this part of my transition, I have some interest- ing perspectives to share which may help many young managers and ‘to be’ promoted managers. The reality is, to be successful as a first-time manager one needs to go through a major transition for which many people are not adequately prepared. Perhaps the most challenging aspect of this transition is that first-time managers are responsible for getting work done through others rather than on their own. While a new manager may recognize this transition theoretically, they often refuse to accept it psychologi- cally, as reflected by their on the job behaviors. Most often, they intimidate their team members with their experience and expertise. For example, a newly promoted manager might start doing So, YOU’RE THE BOSS NOW. K. Hariram is the former MD (retd.) at Galderma India. He is Chief Mentor at MedicinMan and a regular contributor. khariram25@yahoo.com Howtomakethetransitionfromsalestopeoplemanagement(without intimidating team members, micro managing or losing your cool). “Perhaps the most challenging aspect of this transition is that first-time managers are responsible for getting work done through others rather than on their own. While a new manager may recognize this transition theoretically, they often refuse to accept it psychologically, as reflected by their on the job behaviors.” E
  • 11. 11 | MedicinMan May 2013 So, Your the Boss Now | K. Hariram everything from talking to doctors/re- tailers to taking orders etc, himself rather than helping his team member to do it; this is all the more if he is well versed with the customers and the market, enjoying the thrill of exhibiting to every- one his established skill in this area. In other situations, the new manager may end up challenging/competing with his team members on assignments and lose patience when the team member is slow or shoddy in his approach. Letting go of the tasks and responsibil- ities that earned them a promotion in the first place is a tremendously difficult aspect of this transition. Since these behaviors may impact the overall development, morale and therefore the productivity of the team members, organizations must do more than the normal induction to help the newly promoted go through this import- ant transition. The ‘transition training’ should include specific shift in skills, time frame applications, and work values in terms of ‘what’ and ‘how’. The new manager should also understand how the team members have progressed in their performance, their skill areas, events that have shaped them and their value systems. In today’s times the era of ‘command and control’ type of managers do not help or sustain the performance or for that matter, the team members, too. Infor- mation is accessible at all level and the Generation-Y looks for more latitude in handling their assignments. Unlike in the past, they demand career opportunities and loyalty is the thing of past. First-line managers and the first time managers need to wake up to these new realities and not to the old ones. Not always easy, because many of the people who are promoted to this first manageri- al level are/were good sales people; they have spent their time developing great skills at reaching their targets by manag- ing themself rather than being in touch with the expectations of their colleagues. So, let us look at what could help first time Manager to help through this tran- sition to meet the needs and maximize the performance of their team members: Managers must cease thinking only about themselves and start thinking about their team members, their report- ing managers, other supporting func- tions, etc. Of course, saying this is easy, but practicing and orienting takes time. Clearly defining and assigning work to be done, including communicating with the boss and others about needs or expectations, planning, organizing, choosing people, and dele- gating. Enabling the team members to do the work by monitoring, coach- ing, providing feedback, helping with resources, problem solving, and commu- nicating. Establishing relationships with direct reports, bosses, and sup- port functions that facilitate two-way communication including building trust. Bringing in the necessary ATTITUDINAL shift from ‘self to others’. Investing the necessary time with the team members. Joint working with all the team members covering all the important markets irrespective of the discomforts of travel, weather, long working hours and other hardships. Of course, there are many other aspects of this management function - and many other techniques, skills and tools for per- forming them - than what is mentioned here. I have attempted to bring these points to help people who have transited or going through the transition to have a basic understanding of the requirements. I am sure as one gets deeper into their job they will be looking for new ideas, new tools and new techniques. The conventional definition of a manager is ‘getting things done through the efforts of people’. The new version in the context of knowledge era is “also helping people to develop and evolve through work”. -MM 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. “Letting go of the tasks and responsibilities that earned them (managers) a promotion in the first place is a tremen- dously difficult aspect of this transition.” “In today’s times the era of ‘command and control’ type of managers do not help or sustain the performance or for that matter, the team mem- bers, too. Information is accessible at all level and the Generation-Y looks for more latitude in handling their assignments. Unlike in the past, they de- mand career opportunities and loyalty is the thing of past.”
  • 12. 12 | MedicinMan April 2013 Speakers at FFE 2012 FFE 20135 x 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 y Date: Saturday, 8th June 2013 Theme:FieldForceProductivity Place: Courtyard Marriott, Mumbai
  • 13. 13 | MedicinMan May 2013 O ne man can be a crucial ingredient on a team, but one man cannot make a team.” - Kareem Abdul-Jabbar The famous quote by former NBA player can be applied in Field Force Effectiveness (FFE). Here, if we consider FFE is team- work, then it cannot be achieved by Medical Reps or line managers alone. There must be active involvement of all other team players in the organi- zation. In regular industry practice, sales persons are held responsible for FFE. Whereas there are various depart- ments which are directly or indirect- ly working towards FFE and there- fore should made accountable for it. Consider the following scenarios: Scenario 1 – Company whose Medical Reps visit Doctors regularly, delivering the same message which marketing team wants to convey, able to attract good number of customers under company’s umbrella and have good hold in territory . Even after this, if they fail to fetch the sales numbers it is considered as their ineffectiveness. Scenario 2 – Medical Reps of another company not at all working efficiently in terms of number of visits, brand communication and other activities, even then company is making satisfactory sales from heritage brand. This is considered as effectiveness of sales force. However both the above cases show that companies have to look beyond field force to achieve FFE. Stakeholders of Field Force ExcellenceMedical Representative Senior Management Line Managers HR Marketing Training Field Force Excellence is the responsibility of a group of individuals and not just the Medical Rep. Each stakeholder in selling process has a precise and important role to play. Vishal V. Bhaiyya is a Consultant - Pharma and Healthcare Projects, Strategic Analysis Inc. Follow Vishal Bhaiyya on Twitter: @bhaiya_vishal vishalbhaiyyapharma.blogspot.in E
  • 14. 14 | MedicinMan May 2013 Stakeholders of Field Force Excellence | Vishal Bhaiyya Therefore, there is definite need of map- ping the accountability of other stake- holders by their contribution such as brand strategy, medical communication, innovation in the molecule, company reputation in the market and others. All these stakeholders can impact FFE beyond their respective tasks. Roles & Responsibilities for FFE 1) HR and Administration • Recruitment of members in the team with good communication skills, clarity of thoughts and learning ability, and overall charming personality. • Transparency in appraisal and other admin related activities. 2) Training • Product And Product Related Techni- cal Knowledge - Trainers can ignite the minds of sales people with knowledge required to sell the products in the high- ly competitive market. • Calling Skills - Medical Reps who are the face of company should be well versed with the skills required to impress the customers during the call. 3) Marketing and Medical Communication • Product Brand Equity - Marketing team can con- tribute to FFE in terms of continuously improving the brand equity of its products in the minds of clinicians. • Brand Communication - Leveraging USP of prod- uct to differentiate from competitors and be able to force customers to think twice before switching over to competitor’s product. • Medical Communication - Medical communication must be so convincing, that KOLs and influential customers must be convinced about product before the field force visit. • CME - This is the best way for a com- pany to get close to customers so that field force can nurture the opportunity. 4) Senior Management • Product Innovation and Introduction – Pioneers always have an advantage. Therefore company management should focus on launching innovative prod- ucts so that field force can leverage the advantage. • Relationship Through CSR – By CSR activities company can build corporate image in the society and influence cus- tomers positively. 5) Line Managers • Motivation – This is the most import- ant factor that enabeles line managers to keep the field force engaged. • Day To Day Follow-Ups 6) Medical Representative • Effective Implementation – This should be the motto of Medical Reps. Whether it is brand message, medical commu- nication or any campaign - all must be implemented as per plan. • Visit Frequency and Consistency – There must be continuous and fruitful visit to customers according to their category. • Efficiency in Reaping Benefits – CSR activities, CMEs, patient education programs and other activities make the Medical Reps and Doctors come closer Conclusion By this multidimensional and approach, the company can allocate responsibilities and make the strategy more and more focused, leading to FFE -MM Fig. 1 – Responsibilities of Stakeholders in FFE
  • 15. )+91-93422-32949 * anupsoans@medicinman.net22 North Road, Cooke Town, Bangalore - 575084 FFE 20135 x 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 y Date: Saturday, 8th June 2013 Theme:FieldForceProductivity Place: Courtyard Marriott, Mumbai MORNINGAFTERNOON Session 1: Keynote Address: Shakti Chakraborty, President, Lupin Session 4: Panel Discussion: “Employee Engagement: The New Paradigm for Enhanc- ing Field Force Productivity.” Moderator: Anup Soans - Editor, MedicinMan Panelists: Deep Bhandari - Director, Marketing and Sales Excellence, UCB -Confirmation awaited from other panelists Networking Breakfast Lunch Session 2: CEO Roundtable: “Field Force Productivity: Opportunities and Challenges” Moderator: Sujay Shetty, Partner and Lead, Pharma and Life Sciences, PwC Roundtable Members: Shakti Chakraborty, President, Lupin Bhaskar Iyer, Divisional vice president, India Commercial Operations, Abbott -Confirmation awaited from other panelists- Session 5: Amlesh Ranjan, Associate Director, Sanofi: “New Pharma Sales Model for Healthcare Opportunity” Session 3: Panel Discussion: “Business Intelligence for Field Force Productivity.” Moderator: Vikas Dandekar, India Bureau Chief, Elsevier Business Intelligence Panelists: Salil Kallianpur, Commercial Head - Classic Brands Center of Excellence, GSK -Confirmation awaited from other panelists- Session 6: K. Hariram, Chief Mentor at MedicinMan, Former (Retd) Managing Director at Galderma India: “Role Clarity for Field Sales Managers to enhance Field Force Productivity.” www.medicinman.net Register Now! Click here or go to www.medicinman.net/ffe13- registrations Delegate Registration Pharma Delegates: INR 8,500/- Non-Pharma Delegates/ Service Providers: INR 9,500/- Early Bird Discount (for full payment before 10 May 2013): INR 1,000/- Theme: Field Force Productivity - Opportunities and Challenges
  • 16. Segmentationforthe medicalRep. 16 | MedicinMan May 2013 This Article is extacted from the book “HardKnocks for the GreenHorn” by Anup Soans. “HardKnocks for the GreenHorn is available at a special 1+1 FREE offer. For Details see page 18. Segmentation for the Medical Rep | Anup Soans S egmentation refers to the grouping of prospective customers into segments that have common needs and will respond in an identical manner to a marketing input. Segmentation begins with understanding customers and allowing marketers to build relationships with them. It is the first step in a marketing strategy. Once marketers divide the market into various groups, they can then select their 'targeted segments' and design products and the marketing strategy to match their needs. Pharmaceutical marketing managers are well-versed in the traditional aspects of segmenting according to the speciality of the doctor, the prescription potential of the doctor, and the location of his practice, private practices, institutional businesses, and the like. These are processes of demographic and geographic segmentation, which tell you who the doctor is and where he practises. It focuses on the features and benefits of the product and its price. It does not, however, take into account what motivates him, what are his aspirations, what intangibles move him, and his personal preferences, including the aesthetics of the product, its presentation, the persons who promote it, and the way it is promoted. Nonetheless, this type of segmentation, while difficult, is more personalised E
  • 17. 17 | MedicinMan May 2013 Segmentation for the Medical Rep | Anup Soans and, therefore, more effective. For example, in order to be effective while promoting a product to a lady doctor, one needs to be more sensitive to the nature of her personality. Similarly, in order to be effective while promoting a product to a senior doctor, one needs to take into account his emotional need for recognition. In short, one size does not fit all, and the imaginative and informed MR will strive to be more empathetic while promoting products to various segments of doctors. This will make his job more interesting and will increase his productivity. The psychographic profile of the doctor can make product-promotion more specific and effective. The prescription pattern of a doctor or group of doctors when analysed can reveal the individual preferences, which are called specific graphics. They can be used to tailor- make the promotion so as to influence the doctor favourably towards the product, the MR, and his company. The MR with knowledge, understanding and an appreciation of the processes of segmentation, differentiation, positioning, branding, and pricing can study individual doctors and groups of them, and may be in a position to get a higher return on efforts by adapting the presentation to suit the doctor's profile. There are at least six categories of customer characteristics that form the basis for segmentation: Geographic segmentation: The market is divided according to location. It is based on the assumption that people living in the same area share similar habits and wants. Demographic segmentation: It is based on characteristics such as age, sex, marital status, income, education, and specialisation of the doctor. Psychographic segmentation: Psychological characteristics refer to the traits of a person. Doctors are divided on the basis of their needs, personality, perceptions, knowledge, and level of engagement, motivations and attitudes. Specific-graphics segmentation: Doctors are divided depending on the product or brand usage characteristics, such as the rate of usage (doctors are divided depending on the number of times they prescribe a product); awareness status (doctors are divided based on their knowledge of a product; for instance, if a doctor instantly recalls all of the product’s features, his awareness-level is high and so is his brand loyalty). Benefit-segmentation: The market is divided into segments depending on the benefits of the products. This method is used to communicate the product’s features to consumers. For instance, OD dosage can be marketed as a form of convenience and for better compliance. Hybrid segmentation: Instead of sticking to one particular segmentation style, marketers combine one or two segmentation variables and arrive at another segmentation. This style is referred to as Hybrid segmentation. What are the benefits of Segmentation? 1. You are able to lend focus to your marketing strategy: You need to deliver your marketing message to a relevant doctor group. If the target market is too broad, there is a strong risk that the key customers will be missed. By segmenting markets, the target doctor can be reached more often and at a lower cost. 2. You can gain a share of the market segment: Unless your products have a strong or leading market share, they will be unlikely to get you much profit. Minor brands suffer from pressures from distributors and less space on the chemists’ shelves. Proper segmentation and targeting will allow you to achieve a competitive position and become the preferred choice of doctors and chemists. Segmentation enables smaller firms to compete with bigger ones. -MM Anup Soans is the author of “HardKnocks for the GreenHorn”, SuperVision for the SuperWiser Front-line Manager”and“Repeat Rx”. He is a facilitator of Learning and Development Programs for Managers and Medical Reps at India’s top Pharma Company’s Contact: anupsoans@gmail.com +91-93422-32949 “In order to be effective while promoting a product to a senior doctor, one needs to take into account his emotional need for recognition. In short, one size does not fit all, and the imaginative and informed MR will strive to be more empathetic while promoting products to various segments of doctors. This will make his job more interesting and will increase his productivity.”
  • 18. Buy 1 get 1 free ! MRP Rs. 799/- MRP Rs. 599/- For Individuals* Buy SuperVision for the SuperWiser Front-line Manager and Get HardKnocks for the GreenHorn FREE. For Corporates* INR 500/- for a set of SuperVision for the SuperWiser Front-line Manager (1 copy) and HardKnocks for the GreenHorn (1 copy) for purchase of 50 sets and above. *Inclusive of Shipping to One Location. Please pay through bank transfer to SB account no. *07141000006761* of “Anup Soans” HDFC Bank, Mosque Road, Frazer Town Branch, Bangalore – 560005. RTGS/NEFT IFSC: HDFC0000714 and inform by email and SMS - anupsoans@gmail. com | +91-93422-32949. Or you can send a cheque favoring “Anup Soans” to: Anup Soans 101 - North Forte Apts; 22, North Road, Cooke Town, St. Thomas Town P.O. Bangalore - 560084 Field Force Excellence Tools for Individuals and Corporates
  • 19. 19 | MedicinMan May 2013 J ust the day before ‘Brand- Drift 2013’, when I called on Gurudas Masurkar at his office, to present him my book, ‘PHARMA FIRST-LINE LEADER TO CEO: THE ROAD- MAP TO SUCCESS’, I never thought that this would be my last meeting. Just imagine, at 91, attending office, albeit on a wheelchair! Late Gurudas Masurkar was the Chairman Emeritus of Entod Pharmaceuticals, a company he founded after he retired from an illustrious 29 year career with Duphar Interfran. Late Gurudas Masurkar was better known as the ‘Crocin Man’. Gurudas’s journey from a farming family in Masur village of North Kanara District (Karnataka) to a successful entrepre- neur is fascinating. After BA he did D.Pharma. He literally gate-crashed into Crookes Laboratories as a medical represen- tative (the company later became Duphar Interfran and then Solvay)! He began his career as a clerk in Popular Pharmacy, Gurgaon, Mumbai. He was impressed by the well dressed gen- tlemen, with polished manners, speaking fluent English often calling on him at Popular Pharmacy. They were the medical representatives. He decided to pursue his career in pharma- ceutical selling. One fine afternoon he went to the office of Crookes Labora- tories and submitted his application, but was told that there was no vacancy. He left the office but waited outside for the managing director. As soon as he saw him, he approached him and told him of his desire. The MD seeing his bold and courageous approach recruited him. He eventually rose to become the head of sales and marketing at Crookes. Late Gurudas Masurkar launched two successful brands viz. Crocin and Lacto Calamine. In India, the history of Cro- cin was more than 50 years when it was first introduced by Crookes. Competition to Crocin was tough - from Metacin (by Themis), Malidens (by British Schering, now with Abbott via the Nicholas Piramal route) and Calpol (by Burroughs Wellcome, now GSK). Although the brand management con- cept did not exist in India those days, he once told me, there used to be healthy marketing battles for brand leadership. It was a brutal battle which Crocin won. He gives the entire credit of the success of Crocin to the medical representatives and field managers. Who would do this in today’s age? My close friend Shirish Gore who was a Field Manager in Duphar once said “Masurkar Sir cares a lot for the people and our development. We will do anything for him. His best trait is giving honest feedback without offending anyone. Feedback from him is always a positive experience.” A great lesson to be learnt by the sales and brand managers! I asked him about the genesis of the name Crocin. Very simple he answered. “‘cin’ was a popular suffix for pain killers in those days. The pain killer from Crookes became Crocin”! Apart from a brilliant marketing strategist, he was a great philanthropist and cared even for people he did not know. When he went on Board of Directors of the second largest cooperative bank in India, viz. SVC Bank, he remembered the days when he had to struggle for finances when he floated Entod Pharmaceuticals. He cut off the red tape so that young entrepreneurs did not have to wait long for finances. He made the entire process very smooth and swift. He has helped in the shaping the careers of many young peo- ple; and I am one of the beneficiaries. A great era has come to end. May his soul be in peace! - MM P.S. Those who have read my book ‘PHARMA FIRST-LINE LEADER TO CEO: THE ROADMAP TO SUCCESS’ may remember the two central characters in this book: ‘The Mentor’ and ‘Vinod Kamat‘. ‘The Mentor’ in this book is Late Gurudas Masurkar while ‘Vinod Kamat’ represents the author. ‘Crocin Man’ passes away. Gurudas Masurkar was an industry veteran who launched landmark brands like Crocin and Lacto Calamine. He was Chairman Emeritus at Entod Pharmaceuticals. A tribute to a Mentor by one of his Mentee. Prof. Vivek Hattangadi is a Consultant in Pharma Brand Management and Sales Training at The Enablers. He is also visiting faculty at CIPM Calcutta (Vidyasagar University) for their MBA course in Pharmaceutical Management. vivekhattangadi@theenablers.org E
  • 20. 20 | MedicinMan May 2013 What is Pharmaco- economics? P harmacoeconomics can be defined as the description and analysis of the cost of drug therapy to the healthcare systems and the society1 . It is the process of identifying, measuring and comparing the costs, risks and benefits of programs, services or therapies and determining the best alternative for health outcomes for the resource invested. Applied Pharmacoeconomics can be defined as combining Pharmacoeconomic principles, methods and theories into practice to quantify the value of pharmacy products and pharmaceutical care services used in the real world environments. Pharamcoeconomics, outcomes research and pharmaceutical care can be related to each other. Pharmacoeconomics is a division of outcomes research that can be used to quantify the value of pharmaceutical care products and services. Outcomes research can be defined as the studies that identify, measure and evaluate the results of healthcare services. Pharmaceutical care has been defined as the provision of drug therapy for achieving definite outcomes2 . Perspectives The perspective of the analysis determines from whose point of view the decision is being made. Defining the perspective of the analysis is especially important in pharmacoeconomic analyses because the costs that are incurred depend heavily on the perspective. Assessment of costs and consequences and the value of pharmaceutical product or service depend on the perspective evaluation. Common perspectives include patient, provider, payer, and society. 1. Patient perspective It is of utmost importance as the patients are the ultimate consumers of healthcare services. These costs are essentially paid by the patients Mahendra Rai is a Senior Consultant (HEOR, Pricing and Market Access) at Capita India. He is an expert in HEOR, Market Access, and Outcomes Research. mahendra.rai@gmail.com Richa Goyal is a Consultant (HEOR, Pricing and Market Access) at Capita India, Mumbai. She is an expert in HEOR, Market Access, Outcomes Research and medical communications services. richapharmacist@gmail.com References 1. Townsend RJ. Post-marketing drug research and development. Ann Pharmacother 1987;21:134-136. 2. Drummond M, Smith GT, Wells N. Economic evaluation in the development of medicines. London: Office of Health Economics, 1988:33. 3. http://www.institute.nhs.uk/quality_and_service_ improvement_tools/quality_and_service_improvement_ tools/patient_perspectives.html. Accessed on 28th April 2013 Pharmacoeconomics can be defined as the description and analysis of the cost of drug therapy to the healthcare systems and the society. - EMERGINGING AREAS IN HEALTHCARE - E
  • 21. 21 | MedicinMan May 2013 Pharmacoeconomics: Perspectives in Cost Evaluation | Richa Goyal & Mahendra Rai for a product or service and are not covered by the insurance companies. This perspective should be considered when assessing the impact of drug therapy on quality of life or if a patient pays out of pocket expense for a healthcare service3 . 2. Provider perspective These are the actual expense of providing a product or service, regardless of what is charged by the provider. Providers can be hospitals, managed care organizations, or private practice physicians. From this perspective, direct costs like drugs, hospitalization, laboratory tests, supplies and salaries of healthcare professionals can be identified, measured and compared4 . 3. Payer perspective Payers comprise of insurance companies, employers or the government. The costs from this perspective represent the charges for healthcare products and services allowed or reimbursed by the payer. The primary cost of the payer comes under the direct costs. Indirect costs such as lost work days (absenteeism), low productivity (presenteeism) also contribute to the total cost of healthcare to the payer5 . 4. Societal perspective This is the broadest of all perspectives, as it is the only one that considers the benefit to society. All direct and indirect costs are included in the economic evaluation performed by the societal perspective. Costs from this perspective include patient morbidity and mortality and the overall costs of giving and receiving medical care6 . Conclusion Analyses can be done from one or several perspectives, which will help in determining the distribution of disease costs across multiple stakeholders. To conclude, pharmacoeconomic data can be a powerful tool to support various clinical decisions, ranging from the level of patient to the entire healthcare system. - MM References 4. Gail R. Wilensky. Reforming Medicare’s Physician Payment System. N Engl J Med 2009; 360:653-655. 5. Lancry PJ, Oconnor R, Stempel D, Raz M. Using health outcomes data to inform decision-making: healthcare payer perspective. Pharmacoeconomics. 2001;19 Suppl 2:39-47. 6. Russell LB, Fryback DG, Sonnenberg FA. Is the societal perspective in cost-effectiveness analysis useful for decision makers? Jt Comm J Qual Improv. 1999 Sep;25(9):447-54. FFE 20135 x 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 y Date: Saturday, 8th June 2013 Theme:FieldForceProductivity Place: Courtyard Marriott, Mumbai Registrations Open Visit: medicinman.net/ ffe13-registrations
  • 22. 22 | MedicinMan May 2013 Pharmacoeconomic Analysis Introduction T he rising healthcare cost is a major concern to patients, healthcare professionals, and various stakeholders involved in the decision-making. As the affordability of new medical technologies continues to be the subject of heated debate, attention is increasingly focused on providing quality, cost-effective healthcare to patients. In this era of cost-conscious healthcare delivery, pharmacoeconomic research has evolved as a significant and important field of research. Pharmacoeconomic evaluation identifies, measures and compares the costs and consequences of pharmaceutical products and services. The numerous stakeholders in the healthcare landscape must understand the basics of pharmacoeconomic principles and how these may be applied to make rational therapeutic choices. Types of Pharmacoeconomic Analysis There are four main types of pharmacoeconomic evaluations: 1. Cost-Effectiveness Analysis (CEA) 2. Cost-Utility Analysis (CUA) 3. Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA) 4. Cost-Minimisation Analysis (CMA) 1. Cost-Effectiveness Analysis (CEA): Compares the relative difference of costs and consequences of different treatment alternatives. In CEA, costs are measured in monetary terms and health consequences are measured in natural or physical units. 2. Cost-Utility Analysis (CUA): CUA has the same principle as a CEA, but includes measures of the impact on the quality of life. CUA is often used when quantity and quality of life are both important. 3. Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA): Compares treatment alternatives where both costs and benefits are expressed in monetary terms. 4. Cost-Minimisation Analysis (CMA): Compares treatment alternatives that yield similar health consequences. Once the health consequences are established to be the same, a CMA would compare all cost between treatments to determine the option with the least cost. Pharmacoeconomic evaluation identifies, measures and compares the costs and consequences of pharmaceutical products and services. The numerous stakeholders in the healthcare landscape must understand the basics of pharmacoeconomic principles and how these may be applied to make rational therapeutic choices. Javed Shaikh is a Consultant (HEOR, Pricing, Reimbursement and Market Access) at Capita India, Mumbai. cpnjaved@gmail.com Shafaq Shaikh is an Associate (HEOR, Pricing, Reimbursement and Market Access) at Capita India, Mumbai. shafaq07@gmail.com E
  • 23. 23 | MedicinMan May 2013 Pharmacoeconomic Analysis: Javed Shaikh and Shafaq Shaikh Types of Costs in Pharmacoeconomic Analysis Costs in health economic analyses are divided into three main groups (see Table): 1. Direct cost 2. Indirect cost 3. Intangible cost Direct Costs Indirect Costs Intangible Costs Cost of resources used related to the illness: medical cost and non-medical cost Refers to resources lost as a result of the treatment and illness that involve morbidity and mortality Represents costs as a consequence of the treatment not measurable in monetary terms Direct medical cost: Cost of medication, diagnostic, treatment, follow-up, rehabilitation, and hospital admission Includes both paid and unpaid productivity loss such as temporary sickness absenteeism, permanent functional impairment, premature death, etc. These costs can be pain, grief, and suffering Direct non-medical cost: Costs for personal facilities, travel, food, lodging, paid personal care, etc. Indirect cost can be measured by approaches such as the Human Capital or Frictional Methods Can be quantified using approved outcome- measurement techniques Measurements of Outcomes in Pharmacoeconomic Analysis Health outcomes are consequences of a treatment/ intervention or programme which results in changes of quantity and quality of life. Health consequences can be final, intermediate or surrogate outcomes. Final outcomes are usually measured as life years or quality adjusted life years (QALYs). Intermediate outcomes are usually measured by clinical parameters that have evidence- based correlation with the final outcome. A surrogate outcome is an end point that substitutes and can be predictive of a final outcome. Final outcomes are measured over a natural course of the disease whilst intermediate outcomes are measured over a short time horizon. Changes in quality of life can be valued directly by several methods such as rating scale or time trade-off. It can also be valued indirectly by employing instruments such as EQ-5D, HUI3, or SF-6D.
  • 24. 24 | MedicinMan May 2013 Pharmacoeconomic Analysis: Javed Shaikh and Shafaq Shaikh Decision Analytic Model Modelling is necessary in health economic analysis in order to inform decision-making. It consists of a series of health states, representing the expected health consequences of different treatments. Modelling provides an important framework for synthesizing available evidence and generating estimates of clinical and cost-effectiveness. Modelling can be used to extrapolate short-term outcome data or surrogate measures to long-term outcomes using modelling techniques. It may also be used to generate data from clinical trial settings to routine practice and to estimate the relative effectiveness of the technologies where these have not been directly compared. Discounting The reason for the need to discount in an economic evaluation is ‘time preference’ which refers to the desire to enjoy benefits in the present while deferring any negative effects of doing so. Future costs are discounted to account for the time value of money, and future health benefits are discounted to account for the delay in satisfaction from these outcomes. The effect of discounting is to give future costs and health benefits less weight in an economic analysis. Sensitivity Analysis Uncertainty could arise in pharmacoeconomic studies from the natural variation in populations and also the heterogeneous external data sources used. Sensitivity analysis is performed for all key parameters in an analysis, in order to test the validity and robustness of the conclusion. Incremental Cost- Effectiveness Ratio (ICER) and Average Cost- Effectiveness Ratio (ACER) ICER compares the difference between the costs and health consequences of two alternative interventions that compete for the same resources. It is generally described as the additional cost per additional health consequence. ACER is the ratio of the cost to benefit of an intervention without reference to a comparator. It deals with a single intervention and evaluates that intervention. ACER is calculated by dividing the net cost of the intervention by the total number of health consequences prevented by the intervention. It is generally described as cost per unit of outcome. Budget Impact Analysis (BIA) BIA estimates the financial consequences of adopting a new health technology in a clearly specified setting. BIA complements the pharmacoeconomic evaluations by providing additional information for decision making as it addresses the issue of affordability and sustainability. BIA provides information on the overall impact of a new health technology to a budget.
  • 25. 25 | MedicinMan May 2013 Pharmacoeconomic Analysis: Javed Shaikh and Shafaq Shaikh Summary In order to achieve the goal of the least expensive treatment with the best possible outcome, pharmacoeconomics should be implemented into the healthcare decision-making process. Healthcare resources are not easily accessible and affordable to many patients, therefore pharmacoeconomic evaluations play an important role in the allocation of these resources. Pharmacoeconomics is also important to drug manufacturers in terms of communicating to external decision-makers (payers, physicians, patients) the value of their products, achieving regulatory and reimbursement approval, and contributing to commercial success. The use of pharmacoeconomics in early drug development phases is likely to enhance the efficiency of R&D resource use and also provide a solid foundation for communicating product value to external decision-makers.- MM References 1. Pharmacoeconomics: From Theory to Practice, Renee J. G. Arnold (Editor), Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press. 2009. 264. ISBN- 13: 978-1420084221. 2. Pharmacoeconomics. Sule NS, Nerurkar RP, Kamath SA. J Assoc Physicians India. 2002 Aug;50:1057-62. 3. Principles of Good Practice for Decision Analytic Modeling in Health-Care Evaluation: Report of the ISPOR Task Force on Good Research Practices—Modeling Studies. Available from: http://www.ispor.org/workpaper/research_practices/ PrinciplesofGoodPracticeforDecisionAnalyticModeling- ModelingStudies.pdf 4. Pharmacoeconomics: basic concepts and terminology: T. Walley & A. Haycox, Br J Clin Pharmacol 1997; 43: 343–348. Missing something important? You can access all past issues of MedicinMan at: http://medicinman.net/archives Be sure to Subscribe on our website (top-right corner: www.medicinman.net) to stay up-to-date with us.
  • 26. Trainingthat Stands Out From the team that brings you MedicinMan, Brand Drift, Field Force Excellence seminars and other breakthrough learning and development events. Ad Training that is RELEVANT and grabs the ATTENTION of the participants, appealing to EMOTIONS and firing the INTELLECT to bring about CHANGE in MINDSET and BEHAVIOR on the FIELD leading to VALUE CREATION in the DOCTOR’s CHAMBER and REPEAT Rx for the Company. For customized programs for Medical Reps, Front-line Managers and Senior Professionals call: +91 93422 32939 | anupsoans@medicinman.net
  • 27. 27 | MedicinMan May 2013 10 Coaching Nuggets for FLMs H ave you (FLM) ever thought of building a sales team that is a great DIFFERENTIATOR in the crowded market place? Here are 10 nuggets to help you do this: 1.As an FLM and as a coach, you have to be accessible when the team member has a problem or a need. 2.To be effective as an FLM, you must have developed something through experience that you can demonstrate and that will be respected by your sales people. Merely demanding results may not be accepted by your team members. 3.As an effective sales coach, you need to ‘walk the talk’ by modeling those behaviors that you tell your sales people to exhibit. 4. TELLING is not COACHING. Your ability to INFLUENCE with proper INTERPERSONAL skills become very vital as part of your coaching efforts. 5.In coaching activities, as an FLM and as a coach you are looking for those behaviors that influence your sales person’s selling capabilities. They are (a) knowledge of the products and services offered, (b) clear understanding of sales strategies and the communication skills, and (c) knowledge of the market, including customers. 6.As a coach, you must be committed and involved in making each of your team members...Successful. 7.Sales coaching is a two-way, one-on-one process that enables improvement of sales person’s performance. 8. As an effective coach, you need to develop the skill of listening, observing and objectively putting across the truth. 9. As a coach you should promote openness and trust. 10.You need to have a clear understanding of sales productivity and more importantly, the skills in developing your sales people to successfully handle the competitive environment. - MM This article is 7th in a series on “Coaching” by the author. K. Hariram is the former MD (retd.) at Galderma India. He is Chief Mentor at MedicinMan and a regular contributor. khariram25@yahoo.com As an effective coach, you need to develop the skill of listening, observing and objectively putting across the truth. To be effective as FLM, you must have developed something through experience that you can demonstrate and that will be respected by your sales people. Merely demanding results may not be accepted by your team members. E