SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  1
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
FAR FROM THE MADDING CROWD

Review of: F. Fraser Darling 1939. A Naturalist on Rona. Oxford: Clarendon 137 pp.
                  [Nineteenth in a series on "naturalist-in" books.]

                                    Christopher K. Starr
                    Dept of Life Sciences, University of the West Indies


      Frank Fraser Darling (1903-1979) did field work in the scottish highlands and islands over
many years, with emphasis on the biology of gregarious vertebrates (Darling 1947). His study of
the red deer, Cervus elaphus (Darling 1937), is a key work in the british animal-ecology tradition.
      The island of North Rona is both tiny and remote. Its area is only about one square
kilometer, and at 5907'N 0551'W it lies about 62 km above the north coast of
Scotland, beyond the Outer Hebrides. This book, subtitled Essays of a Biologist in Isolation, opens
with the remark that "The web of experience is largely of your own weaving when you live on a
small and remote island where there are no other human inhabitants." Depending on the person, it
can become a prison or a satisfying world in itself. Darling spent an extended period on the island
in 1938-39, together with his wife and son, although these appear only in the occasional use of "we"
and two photos with an unexplained woman in them.
      Rona has had small human communities off and on since antiquity, but the last of these had
died out a century before Darling's arrival. Even so, the landscape was enriched by many artefacts
of buildings and fields, from which he drew inferences on how the long-gone people had lived. And
he spent many happy hours restoring the cell of St Rónán (early 8th century), which had fallen into
ruins.
      Much of the natural history of any very small island is unavoidably at and around the shore.
Accordingly, the main focus of Darling's book is the littoral zone, with some attention to the
"interior". This flat island is raised above the sea on all sides, so that there is no beach. As you may
have noticed, people in any coastal area almost unavoidably spend a great deal of time looking
toward the sea, and Rona provides a wealth of vantage points. Darling found one particular cliff
especially suitable "for watching the pageant of the sea's edge." This pageant often included sharks
and marine mammals close to shore.
      Three shore-nesting birds -- turnstones, puffins and great black-backed gulls (for whom the
puffins are the main diet) -- come in for special attention. Among the special delights of this hard-
core little book is a thoughtful disquisition on the form and functioning of their courtship displays.
      Another treats the proximate causes of aggregation in birds and mammals; the ultimate causes
(why aggregation is favoured by natural selection) are not hard to grasp, but how do they go about
initiating and maintaining the group? This is mainly posed around a comparison of the red deer with
the atlantic grey seal, and Darling concludes that their rather similar social groupings arise out of
very different circumstances.
      A period of chosen isolation such as Darling undertook requires considerable sympathy with
one's surroundings and fellow creatures. One passage will serve to illustrate how this runs
throughout A Naturalist on Rona: "Puffins excite our sympathy because of their mingled solemnity
and ridiculousness. Their calm, dark eyes indicate a serene philosophy -- thought we are not
entitled to make that interpretation -- and it is easy to fancy about them a patient resignation to the
destiny of being a food supply."
      The book is illustrated with many fine black-and-white photos of landscapes and animals.

References
     Darling, F.F. 1937. A Herd of Red Deer. London: Oxford Univ. Press 215 pp.
     Darling, F.F. 1947. Natural History in the Highlands and Islands. London: Collins 303 pp.

Contenu connexe

En vedette

A Naturalist In Florida A C Carr Cs 16
A Naturalist In Florida A C Carr Cs 16A Naturalist In Florida A C Carr Cs 16
A Naturalist In Florida A C Carr Cs 16Bertrand Bhikarry
 
Intergenerational transmitted poverty and wealth a life course perspective;...
Intergenerational transmitted poverty and wealth   a life course perspective;...Intergenerational transmitted poverty and wealth   a life course perspective;...
Intergenerational transmitted poverty and wealth a life course perspective;...Mthokozisi Sidambe
 
Of biodiversity climate_change_and_law
Of biodiversity climate_change_and_lawOf biodiversity climate_change_and_law
Of biodiversity climate_change_and_lawBertrand Bhikarry
 

En vedette (6)

A Naturalist In Florida A C Carr Cs 16
A Naturalist In Florida A C Carr Cs 16A Naturalist In Florida A C Carr Cs 16
A Naturalist In Florida A C Carr Cs 16
 
INSIGHT SKN Election 2010
INSIGHT SKN Election 2010INSIGHT SKN Election 2010
INSIGHT SKN Election 2010
 
Intergenerational transmitted poverty and wealth a life course perspective;...
Intergenerational transmitted poverty and wealth   a life course perspective;...Intergenerational transmitted poverty and wealth   a life course perspective;...
Intergenerational transmitted poverty and wealth a life course perspective;...
 
We Are Labour We Deliver
We Are Labour We DeliverWe Are Labour We Deliver
We Are Labour We Deliver
 
Dossierpresse
DossierpresseDossierpresse
Dossierpresse
 
Of biodiversity climate_change_and_law
Of biodiversity climate_change_and_lawOf biodiversity climate_change_and_law
Of biodiversity climate_change_and_law
 

Similaire à Book Review: Naturalist On Rona

The Coral Reefs Of St. John At The Virgin Island Essay
The Coral Reefs Of St. John At The Virgin Island EssayThe Coral Reefs Of St. John At The Virgin Island Essay
The Coral Reefs Of St. John At The Virgin Island EssaySusan White
 
A Country Of Illusion Chapter 1 Summary
A Country Of Illusion Chapter 1 SummaryA Country Of Illusion Chapter 1 Summary
A Country Of Illusion Chapter 1 SummaryCarolina Abrams
 
Geospiza Filiginosa Hypothesis
Geospiza Filiginosa HypothesisGeospiza Filiginosa Hypothesis
Geospiza Filiginosa HypothesisClaudia Brown
 
Danube Delta Biosphere Reserve
Danube Delta Biosphere ReserveDanube Delta Biosphere Reserve
Danube Delta Biosphere Reservechiclayorumania
 
Ghosts of gone birds the brief
Ghosts of gone birds the briefGhosts of gone birds the brief
Ghosts of gone birds the briefghostsofgonebirds
 
09 Jan 1932 - DARWIN AND THE BEAGLE_.pdf
09 Jan 1932 - DARWIN AND THE BEAGLE_.pdf09 Jan 1932 - DARWIN AND THE BEAGLE_.pdf
09 Jan 1932 - DARWIN AND THE BEAGLE_.pdfBraydenStoch2
 
Challenging Terra Nullius of the Mind
Challenging Terra Nullius of the Mind Challenging Terra Nullius of the Mind
Challenging Terra Nullius of the Mind AustLit
 
Galapagos El Niño Events
Galapagos El Niño EventsGalapagos El Niño Events
Galapagos El Niño EventsSarah Griego
 
Taking A Look At The Kangaroo Rat
Taking A Look At The Kangaroo RatTaking A Look At The Kangaroo Rat
Taking A Look At The Kangaroo RatJill Baldwin
 
Skylar tasmanian aborigines project
Skylar tasmanian aborigines projectSkylar tasmanian aborigines project
Skylar tasmanian aborigines projecttodspedding
 
compare & contrast-Kate march 29.pptx
compare & contrast-Kate march 29.pptxcompare & contrast-Kate march 29.pptx
compare & contrast-Kate march 29.pptxPeterGuzmanGarces
 
Charles darwin and the evolution revolution full book in pdf Form
Charles darwin and the evolution revolution full book in pdf FormCharles darwin and the evolution revolution full book in pdf Form
Charles darwin and the evolution revolution full book in pdf FormYo yo Nody khan
 
Lighthouse enolagay
Lighthouse enolagayLighthouse enolagay
Lighthouse enolagayRoyGross56
 
22 Dec 1888 - ANCIENT AUSTRALIA_.pdf
22 Dec 1888 - ANCIENT AUSTRALIA_.pdf22 Dec 1888 - ANCIENT AUSTRALIA_.pdf
22 Dec 1888 - ANCIENT AUSTRALIA_.pdfBraydenStoch2
 
Charles darwin and the evolution revolution full book in pdf Form
Charles darwin and the evolution revolution full book in pdf FormCharles darwin and the evolution revolution full book in pdf Form
Charles darwin and the evolution revolution full book in pdf FormYo yo Nody khan
 
First Australians
First AustraliansFirst Australians
First AustraliansHotRock
 
First Australians
First AustraliansFirst Australians
First AustraliansHotRock
 
World Change-Personal Narrative
World Change-Personal NarrativeWorld Change-Personal Narrative
World Change-Personal NarrativeGina Alfaro
 

Similaire à Book Review: Naturalist On Rona (20)

Maroo Of The Winter Caves
Maroo Of The Winter CavesMaroo Of The Winter Caves
Maroo Of The Winter Caves
 
The Coral Reefs Of St. John At The Virgin Island Essay
The Coral Reefs Of St. John At The Virgin Island EssayThe Coral Reefs Of St. John At The Virgin Island Essay
The Coral Reefs Of St. John At The Virgin Island Essay
 
A Country Of Illusion Chapter 1 Summary
A Country Of Illusion Chapter 1 SummaryA Country Of Illusion Chapter 1 Summary
A Country Of Illusion Chapter 1 Summary
 
Blake's Powerpoint
Blake's PowerpointBlake's Powerpoint
Blake's Powerpoint
 
Geospiza Filiginosa Hypothesis
Geospiza Filiginosa HypothesisGeospiza Filiginosa Hypothesis
Geospiza Filiginosa Hypothesis
 
Danube Delta Biosphere Reserve
Danube Delta Biosphere ReserveDanube Delta Biosphere Reserve
Danube Delta Biosphere Reserve
 
Ghosts of gone birds the brief
Ghosts of gone birds the briefGhosts of gone birds the brief
Ghosts of gone birds the brief
 
09 Jan 1932 - DARWIN AND THE BEAGLE_.pdf
09 Jan 1932 - DARWIN AND THE BEAGLE_.pdf09 Jan 1932 - DARWIN AND THE BEAGLE_.pdf
09 Jan 1932 - DARWIN AND THE BEAGLE_.pdf
 
Challenging Terra Nullius of the Mind
Challenging Terra Nullius of the Mind Challenging Terra Nullius of the Mind
Challenging Terra Nullius of the Mind
 
Galapagos El Niño Events
Galapagos El Niño EventsGalapagos El Niño Events
Galapagos El Niño Events
 
Taking A Look At The Kangaroo Rat
Taking A Look At The Kangaroo RatTaking A Look At The Kangaroo Rat
Taking A Look At The Kangaroo Rat
 
Skylar tasmanian aborigines project
Skylar tasmanian aborigines projectSkylar tasmanian aborigines project
Skylar tasmanian aborigines project
 
compare & contrast-Kate march 29.pptx
compare & contrast-Kate march 29.pptxcompare & contrast-Kate march 29.pptx
compare & contrast-Kate march 29.pptx
 
Charles darwin and the evolution revolution full book in pdf Form
Charles darwin and the evolution revolution full book in pdf FormCharles darwin and the evolution revolution full book in pdf Form
Charles darwin and the evolution revolution full book in pdf Form
 
Lighthouse enolagay
Lighthouse enolagayLighthouse enolagay
Lighthouse enolagay
 
22 Dec 1888 - ANCIENT AUSTRALIA_.pdf
22 Dec 1888 - ANCIENT AUSTRALIA_.pdf22 Dec 1888 - ANCIENT AUSTRALIA_.pdf
22 Dec 1888 - ANCIENT AUSTRALIA_.pdf
 
Charles darwin and the evolution revolution full book in pdf Form
Charles darwin and the evolution revolution full book in pdf FormCharles darwin and the evolution revolution full book in pdf Form
Charles darwin and the evolution revolution full book in pdf Form
 
First Australians
First AustraliansFirst Australians
First Australians
 
First Australians
First AustraliansFirst Australians
First Australians
 
World Change-Personal Narrative
World Change-Personal NarrativeWorld Change-Personal Narrative
World Change-Personal Narrative
 

Plus de Bertrand Bhikarry

Plus de Bertrand Bhikarry (20)

Environmental News Tobago
Environmental News Tobago Environmental News Tobago
Environmental News Tobago
 
ET News December 2010
ET News December 2010ET News December 2010
ET News December 2010
 
Environment Tobago News September 2010
Environment Tobago News September 2010 Environment Tobago News September 2010
Environment Tobago News September 2010
 
Et newsletter june_2008
Et newsletter june_2008Et newsletter june_2008
Et newsletter june_2008
 
Book Review: Naturalist In Costa Rica
Book Review: Naturalist In Costa RicaBook Review: Naturalist In Costa Rica
Book Review: Naturalist In Costa Rica
 
Environment Tobago Newsletter March 2010
Environment Tobago Newsletter March 2010Environment Tobago Newsletter March 2010
Environment Tobago Newsletter March 2010
 
Inteview With A Farmer
Inteview With A FarmerInteview With A Farmer
Inteview With A Farmer
 
Environment Tobago Newsletter
Environment Tobago NewsletterEnvironment Tobago Newsletter
Environment Tobago Newsletter
 
Gps
GpsGps
Gps
 
SKN Labour Party Manifesto in brief
SKN Labour Party Manifesto in briefSKN Labour Party Manifesto in brief
SKN Labour Party Manifesto in brief
 
December Pages of Insight SKN
December Pages of Insight SKNDecember Pages of Insight SKN
December Pages of Insight SKN
 
Labour pepperpot for St. Kitts election
Labour pepperpot for St. Kitts electionLabour pepperpot for St. Kitts election
Labour pepperpot for St. Kitts election
 
Somethings Wrong Here
Somethings Wrong HereSomethings Wrong Here
Somethings Wrong Here
 
Insight November News
Insight November NewsInsight November News
Insight November News
 
September 2009
September 2009September 2009
September 2009
 
Cocoa And Coffee
Cocoa And CoffeeCocoa And Coffee
Cocoa And Coffee
 
Et Newletter June 2009
Et Newletter   June 2009Et Newletter   June 2009
Et Newletter June 2009
 
Rainforest Booklet Final Version
Rainforest Booklet Final VersionRainforest Booklet Final Version
Rainforest Booklet Final Version
 
E T Newletter June 2009
E T Newletter    June 2009E T Newletter    June 2009
E T Newletter June 2009
 
E T Newsletter Dec 2008
E T Newsletter    Dec 2008E T Newsletter    Dec 2008
E T Newsletter Dec 2008
 

Book Review: Naturalist On Rona

  • 1. FAR FROM THE MADDING CROWD Review of: F. Fraser Darling 1939. A Naturalist on Rona. Oxford: Clarendon 137 pp. [Nineteenth in a series on "naturalist-in" books.] Christopher K. Starr Dept of Life Sciences, University of the West Indies Frank Fraser Darling (1903-1979) did field work in the scottish highlands and islands over many years, with emphasis on the biology of gregarious vertebrates (Darling 1947). His study of the red deer, Cervus elaphus (Darling 1937), is a key work in the british animal-ecology tradition. The island of North Rona is both tiny and remote. Its area is only about one square kilometer, and at 5907'N 0551'W it lies about 62 km above the north coast of Scotland, beyond the Outer Hebrides. This book, subtitled Essays of a Biologist in Isolation, opens with the remark that "The web of experience is largely of your own weaving when you live on a small and remote island where there are no other human inhabitants." Depending on the person, it can become a prison or a satisfying world in itself. Darling spent an extended period on the island in 1938-39, together with his wife and son, although these appear only in the occasional use of "we" and two photos with an unexplained woman in them. Rona has had small human communities off and on since antiquity, but the last of these had died out a century before Darling's arrival. Even so, the landscape was enriched by many artefacts of buildings and fields, from which he drew inferences on how the long-gone people had lived. And he spent many happy hours restoring the cell of St Rónán (early 8th century), which had fallen into ruins. Much of the natural history of any very small island is unavoidably at and around the shore. Accordingly, the main focus of Darling's book is the littoral zone, with some attention to the "interior". This flat island is raised above the sea on all sides, so that there is no beach. As you may have noticed, people in any coastal area almost unavoidably spend a great deal of time looking toward the sea, and Rona provides a wealth of vantage points. Darling found one particular cliff especially suitable "for watching the pageant of the sea's edge." This pageant often included sharks and marine mammals close to shore. Three shore-nesting birds -- turnstones, puffins and great black-backed gulls (for whom the puffins are the main diet) -- come in for special attention. Among the special delights of this hard- core little book is a thoughtful disquisition on the form and functioning of their courtship displays. Another treats the proximate causes of aggregation in birds and mammals; the ultimate causes (why aggregation is favoured by natural selection) are not hard to grasp, but how do they go about initiating and maintaining the group? This is mainly posed around a comparison of the red deer with the atlantic grey seal, and Darling concludes that their rather similar social groupings arise out of very different circumstances. A period of chosen isolation such as Darling undertook requires considerable sympathy with one's surroundings and fellow creatures. One passage will serve to illustrate how this runs throughout A Naturalist on Rona: "Puffins excite our sympathy because of their mingled solemnity and ridiculousness. Their calm, dark eyes indicate a serene philosophy -- thought we are not entitled to make that interpretation -- and it is easy to fancy about them a patient resignation to the destiny of being a food supply." The book is illustrated with many fine black-and-white photos of landscapes and animals. References Darling, F.F. 1937. A Herd of Red Deer. London: Oxford Univ. Press 215 pp. Darling, F.F. 1947. Natural History in the Highlands and Islands. London: Collins 303 pp.