SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  36
• Initiatives for Access: pioneering British
                                                      Library programme from 1993-1997
                                                    • Variety of experimental projects
                                                    • High level of risk, but many of the
                                                      experimental projects have turned into
 Electronic Beowulf         Patent Office Express
                                                      key services such as the online
                                                      catalogue, newspaper digitisation and
                                                      online patent access
                                                    • PLURAL, TRANSVERSAL AND
                                                      GENERATIVE
                                                    • This translates to: no one single
  Dunhuang Project          Network catalogues        approach, piece of kit or infrastructure
                                                      which will enable us to deliver, master or
                                                      manage the digital.
                                                    • The digital is shape shifting, so it adapts
                                                      to our interests and preoccupations
                                                    • It is (and should be) like riding a tiger.

Digitisation of microfilm   Turning the Pages
(Burney Newspapers)
lichfield.as.uky.edu
www.connectedhistories.org
Visiblearchive.blogspot.co.uk
Model of Newcomen Steam Engine
at the University of Glasgow
repaired by James Watt in 1765.

A plaything to start with, but
‘everything became science in his
hands’

Not immediately disruptive.

Partnership with Boulton and move
to Birmingham was key.
Development of Sheffield as a steel
                 city
• 1740: Huntsman’s first experiments with crucible steel
• 1770: Huntsman’s process begins to be used by other
  Sheffield cutlers
• 1786: steam power first used to power hammers in the city
• 1851: less than a quarter of city’s workers in heavy
  industries
• 1859: Bessemer opens his new steelworks in Sheffield
  because he wanted to shock the conservative steelmakers
  there
• 1891: two thirds of city’s workers in heavy industries
• The creation of a ‘steel city’ took over 150 years – perhaps
  even longer
Sidney Pollard on the Industrial Revolution in
          Sheffield and Birmingham
“a visitor to the metalworking areas of
Birmingham or Sheffield in the mid nineteenth-
century would have found little to distinguish
them superficially from the same industries a
hundred years earlier. The men worked as
independent sub-contractors in their own or
rented workshops using their own or hired
equipment … These industries .. were still
waiting for their Industrial Revolution”
Changes to Environment
• Wheels powered by steam
• New gadgets available to speed up tasks such as
  stamping and cutting
• Workshop lit by gas and has water supply
• Railways improve distribution
• Cheap advertising increases demand
• Is much of what we are seeing similar to the
  experience of the ‘small mester’ in the industrial
  revolution?
The Industrial Revolution was by no means as
‘transformative’ as the Olympic opening
ceremony might suggest:
• Impact often very localised and patchy
• Micro invention just as important as large-
   scale innovation
• Social as important as technical: Lunar Society
• Economic growth hard to show: Crafts
   suggests annual economic growth of just 2%
• Changes in
   communication, advertising, access to
   markets as important as chane in
   manufacturing
What of Other Transformations?
“the Gutenberg Bible led to religious reformation
while the Web appears to be leading towards social
and economic reformation. But the Digital Industrial
revolution, because of the issues and phenomena
surrounding the Web and its interactions with
society, is occurring at lightning speed with
profound impacts on society, the economy, politics,
and more”.
                              Michael Brodie, Verizon
Anne Alexander and Miriyam Aouragh:

“the Egyptian activists we interviewed rightly reject simplistic claims that technology
somehow caused the 2011 uprisings, and they say it undermines the agency of the
millions of people who participated in the movement that brought down Hosni
Mubarak”

“platitudes do not help us understand the dual character of the Internet: It
empowers and disempowers”

“we propose a shift away from perspectives that isolate “the Internet” from other
media by examining the shift in media architecture exposed by the powerful synergy
between social media and satellite broadcasters during the January 25 uprising”

“we call for an understanding of the dialectical relationship between online and
offline political action. We argue that without one, the other cannot have meaning.
To a large extent, Internet spaces and tools were the choice of young revolutionaries
in Egypt because they were already the spaces and tools that people of their
generation had chosen for communication in daily life”.

‘The Egyptian Experience: Sense and Nonsense of the Internet
Revolution’, International Journal of Communication 5 (2011)

Contenu connexe

En vedette

New Alliances: the Digital Arts and the Digital Humanities
New Alliances: the Digital Arts and the Digital HumanitiesNew Alliances: the Digital Arts and the Digital Humanities
New Alliances: the Digital Arts and the Digital HumanitiesAndrew Prescott
 
Alternative Postgraduate Careers
Alternative Postgraduate CareersAlternative Postgraduate Careers
Alternative Postgraduate CareersAndrew Prescott
 
Big Data in the Arts and Humanities: Stirling presentation
Big Data in the Arts and Humanities: Stirling presentationBig Data in the Arts and Humanities: Stirling presentation
Big Data in the Arts and Humanities: Stirling presentationAndrew Prescott
 
AHRC Digital Transformations theme: the Story So Far
AHRC Digital Transformations theme: the Story So FarAHRC Digital Transformations theme: the Story So Far
AHRC Digital Transformations theme: the Story So FarAndrew Prescott
 
Big Data: Some Initial Reflectons
Big Data: Some Initial ReflectonsBig Data: Some Initial Reflectons
Big Data: Some Initial ReflectonsAndrew Prescott
 
Does My Project Look Big in This?
Does My Project Look Big in This?Does My Project Look Big in This?
Does My Project Look Big in This?Andrew Prescott
 
New Materialities of the Book
New Materialities of the BookNew Materialities of the Book
New Materialities of the BookAndrew Prescott
 
Big Data in the Arts and Humanities
Big Data in the Arts and HumanitiesBig Data in the Arts and Humanities
Big Data in the Arts and HumanitiesAndrew Prescott
 
Big Data in the Arts and Humanities
Big Data in the Arts and HumanitiesBig Data in the Arts and Humanities
Big Data in the Arts and HumanitiesAndrew Prescott
 
AHRC Digital Transformations
AHRC Digital TransformationsAHRC Digital Transformations
AHRC Digital TransformationsAndrew Prescott
 
The Digital Aura: riffs on Walter Benjamin
The Digital Aura: riffs on Walter BenjaminThe Digital Aura: riffs on Walter Benjamin
The Digital Aura: riffs on Walter BenjaminAndrew Prescott
 

En vedette (19)

New Alliances: the Digital Arts and the Digital Humanities
New Alliances: the Digital Arts and the Digital HumanitiesNew Alliances: the Digital Arts and the Digital Humanities
New Alliances: the Digital Arts and the Digital Humanities
 
Interdisciplinarity
InterdisciplinarityInterdisciplinarity
Interdisciplinarity
 
Alternative Postgraduate Careers
Alternative Postgraduate CareersAlternative Postgraduate Careers
Alternative Postgraduate Careers
 
Big Data in the Arts and Humanities: Stirling presentation
Big Data in the Arts and Humanities: Stirling presentationBig Data in the Arts and Humanities: Stirling presentation
Big Data in the Arts and Humanities: Stirling presentation
 
AHRC Digital Transformations theme: the Story So Far
AHRC Digital Transformations theme: the Story So FarAHRC Digital Transformations theme: the Story So Far
AHRC Digital Transformations theme: the Story So Far
 
Big Data: Some Initial Reflectons
Big Data: Some Initial ReflectonsBig Data: Some Initial Reflectons
Big Data: Some Initial Reflectons
 
Prescottcopenhagen
PrescottcopenhagenPrescottcopenhagen
Prescottcopenhagen
 
Prescott Emda2015
Prescott Emda2015Prescott Emda2015
Prescott Emda2015
 
Does My Project Look Big in This?
Does My Project Look Big in This?Does My Project Look Big in This?
Does My Project Look Big in This?
 
New Materialities of the Book
New Materialities of the BookNew Materialities of the Book
New Materialities of the Book
 
Prescottyork
PrescottyorkPrescottyork
Prescottyork
 
Being Transformed
Being TransformedBeing Transformed
Being Transformed
 
Big Data in the Arts and Humanities
Big Data in the Arts and HumanitiesBig Data in the Arts and Humanities
Big Data in the Arts and Humanities
 
Electronic Beowulf @ 21
Electronic Beowulf @ 21Electronic Beowulf @ 21
Electronic Beowulf @ 21
 
Big Data in the Arts and Humanities
Big Data in the Arts and HumanitiesBig Data in the Arts and Humanities
Big Data in the Arts and Humanities
 
Prescottleicesterquad
PrescottleicesterquadPrescottleicesterquad
Prescottleicesterquad
 
Nias
NiasNias
Nias
 
AHRC Digital Transformations
AHRC Digital TransformationsAHRC Digital Transformations
AHRC Digital Transformations
 
The Digital Aura: riffs on Walter Benjamin
The Digital Aura: riffs on Walter BenjaminThe Digital Aura: riffs on Walter Benjamin
The Digital Aura: riffs on Walter Benjamin
 

Similaire à Digital Transformations: Some Historical Perspectives

Pamela Varley, 'Sustainable Digital Neighbourhoods' presented at 'Communities...
Pamela Varley, 'Sustainable Digital Neighbourhoods' presented at 'Communities...Pamela Varley, 'Sustainable Digital Neighbourhoods' presented at 'Communities...
Pamela Varley, 'Sustainable Digital Neighbourhoods' presented at 'Communities...Agnes Gulyas
 
5G for Museums, Galleries and Heritage - unlocking the full potential
5G for Museums, Galleries and Heritage - unlocking the full potential5G for Museums, Galleries and Heritage - unlocking the full potential
5G for Museums, Galleries and Heritage - unlocking the full potentialKTN
 
The unravelling of the 'modern infrastructural ideal' ? Holes in the networks...
The unravelling of the 'modern infrastructural ideal' ? Holes in the networks...The unravelling of the 'modern infrastructural ideal' ? Holes in the networks...
The unravelling of the 'modern infrastructural ideal' ? Holes in the networks...Fionn MacKillop
 
RESEARCH METODOLOGY AND IR 4.0
RESEARCH METODOLOGY AND IR 4.0RESEARCH METODOLOGY AND IR 4.0
RESEARCH METODOLOGY AND IR 4.0Mad Noor MadJapuni
 
Smart Cities Day 2 Urban Innovation
Smart Cities Day 2 Urban InnovationSmart Cities Day 2 Urban Innovation
Smart Cities Day 2 Urban Innovation4 All of Us
 
Next Generation Innovation Platform for Research and Economic Development in ...
Next Generation Innovation Platform for Research and Economic Development in ...Next Generation Innovation Platform for Research and Economic Development in ...
Next Generation Innovation Platform for Research and Economic Development in ...Ed Dodds
 
Living with Machines year two update
Living with Machines year two updateLiving with Machines year two update
Living with Machines year two updateMia
 
Internet of Things- A Plant and Marine Perspective
Internet of Things- A Plant and Marine PerspectiveInternet of Things- A Plant and Marine Perspective
Internet of Things- A Plant and Marine Perspectivekotahinet
 
Infrastructure Innovations in the Rail Industry #COMIT2017
Infrastructure Innovations in the Rail Industry #COMIT2017Infrastructure Innovations in the Rail Industry #COMIT2017
Infrastructure Innovations in the Rail Industry #COMIT2017Comit Projects Ltd
 
DIGITAL LIBRARY SERVICES IN THE DIGITAL AGE
DIGITAL LIBRARY SERVICES IN THE DIGITAL AGE DIGITAL LIBRARY SERVICES IN THE DIGITAL AGE
DIGITAL LIBRARY SERVICES IN THE DIGITAL AGE IAEME Publication
 
Thrive in a New Economy
Thrive in a New EconomyThrive in a New Economy
Thrive in a New EconomyRupak Parajuli
 
The Network Society : Manuel Castells
The Network Society : Manuel CastellsThe Network Society : Manuel Castells
The Network Society : Manuel CastellsYadwinder Singh
 
Chapter I Introduction.pptx
Chapter I Introduction.pptxChapter I Introduction.pptx
Chapter I Introduction.pptxsolomonmihiret1
 
Introduction to Computer Networks Basics.pptx
Introduction to Computer Networks Basics.pptxIntroduction to Computer Networks Basics.pptx
Introduction to Computer Networks Basics.pptxBlerta50
 
Manchester inca smart cities 2012
Manchester inca smart cities 2012Manchester inca smart cities 2012
Manchester inca smart cities 2012Fredo De Smet
 

Similaire à Digital Transformations: Some Historical Perspectives (20)

Pamela Varley, 'Sustainable Digital Neighbourhoods' presented at 'Communities...
Pamela Varley, 'Sustainable Digital Neighbourhoods' presented at 'Communities...Pamela Varley, 'Sustainable Digital Neighbourhoods' presented at 'Communities...
Pamela Varley, 'Sustainable Digital Neighbourhoods' presented at 'Communities...
 
5G for Museums, Galleries and Heritage - unlocking the full potential
5G for Museums, Galleries and Heritage - unlocking the full potential5G for Museums, Galleries and Heritage - unlocking the full potential
5G for Museums, Galleries and Heritage - unlocking the full potential
 
The unravelling of the 'modern infrastructural ideal' ? Holes in the networks...
The unravelling of the 'modern infrastructural ideal' ? Holes in the networks...The unravelling of the 'modern infrastructural ideal' ? Holes in the networks...
The unravelling of the 'modern infrastructural ideal' ? Holes in the networks...
 
RESEARCH METODOLOGY AND IR 4.0
RESEARCH METODOLOGY AND IR 4.0RESEARCH METODOLOGY AND IR 4.0
RESEARCH METODOLOGY AND IR 4.0
 
Evolution of the internet
Evolution of the internetEvolution of the internet
Evolution of the internet
 
Smart Cities Day 2 Urban Innovation
Smart Cities Day 2 Urban InnovationSmart Cities Day 2 Urban Innovation
Smart Cities Day 2 Urban Innovation
 
298 winter
298 winter298 winter
298 winter
 
Next Generation Innovation Platform for Research and Economic Development in ...
Next Generation Innovation Platform for Research and Economic Development in ...Next Generation Innovation Platform for Research and Economic Development in ...
Next Generation Innovation Platform for Research and Economic Development in ...
 
Living with Machines year two update
Living with Machines year two updateLiving with Machines year two update
Living with Machines year two update
 
Internet of Things- A Plant and Marine Perspective
Internet of Things- A Plant and Marine PerspectiveInternet of Things- A Plant and Marine Perspective
Internet of Things- A Plant and Marine Perspective
 
Infrastructure Innovations in the Rail Industry #COMIT2017
Infrastructure Innovations in the Rail Industry #COMIT2017Infrastructure Innovations in the Rail Industry #COMIT2017
Infrastructure Innovations in the Rail Industry #COMIT2017
 
DIGITAL LIBRARY SERVICES IN THE DIGITAL AGE
DIGITAL LIBRARY SERVICES IN THE DIGITAL AGE DIGITAL LIBRARY SERVICES IN THE DIGITAL AGE
DIGITAL LIBRARY SERVICES IN THE DIGITAL AGE
 
Living Lab Expo 12102012
Living Lab Expo 12102012Living Lab Expo 12102012
Living Lab Expo 12102012
 
Living Lab Expo ENoLL presentatio
Living Lab Expo ENoLL presentatioLiving Lab Expo ENoLL presentatio
Living Lab Expo ENoLL presentatio
 
Thrive in a New Economy
Thrive in a New EconomyThrive in a New Economy
Thrive in a New Economy
 
The Network Society : Manuel Castells
The Network Society : Manuel CastellsThe Network Society : Manuel Castells
The Network Society : Manuel Castells
 
Chapter I Introduction.pptx
Chapter I Introduction.pptxChapter I Introduction.pptx
Chapter I Introduction.pptx
 
Willie Donnelly IFIF
Willie Donnelly IFIFWillie Donnelly IFIF
Willie Donnelly IFIF
 
Introduction to Computer Networks Basics.pptx
Introduction to Computer Networks Basics.pptxIntroduction to Computer Networks Basics.pptx
Introduction to Computer Networks Basics.pptx
 
Manchester inca smart cities 2012
Manchester inca smart cities 2012Manchester inca smart cities 2012
Manchester inca smart cities 2012
 

Plus de Andrew Prescott

Researching Freemasonry in a Time of Coronavirus: Resources and Opportunities
Researching Freemasonry in a Time of Coronavirus: Resources and OpportunitiesResearching Freemasonry in a Time of Coronavirus: Resources and Opportunities
Researching Freemasonry in a Time of Coronavirus: Resources and OpportunitiesAndrew Prescott
 
Artistic Practice and The Archive
Artistic Practice and The ArchiveArtistic Practice and The Archive
Artistic Practice and The ArchiveAndrew Prescott
 
Is Search the Right Way?
Is Search the Right Way?Is Search the Right Way?
Is Search the Right Way?Andrew Prescott
 
Medieval Studies: Some Hopes and Fears for the Future
Medieval Studies: Some Hopes and Fears for the FutureMedieval Studies: Some Hopes and Fears for the Future
Medieval Studies: Some Hopes and Fears for the FutureAndrew Prescott
 
New Modernist Editing meeting
New Modernist Editing meetingNew Modernist Editing meeting
New Modernist Editing meetingAndrew Prescott
 
What Happens When the Internet of Things Meets the Middle Ages?
What Happens When the Internet of Things Meets the Middle Ages?What Happens When the Internet of Things Meets the Middle Ages?
What Happens When the Internet of Things Meets the Middle Ages?Andrew Prescott
 
Avoiding the Rear View Mirror
Avoiding the Rear View MirrorAvoiding the Rear View Mirror
Avoiding the Rear View MirrorAndrew Prescott
 
Challenges in the Digital Humanities
Challenges in the Digital HumanitiesChallenges in the Digital Humanities
Challenges in the Digital HumanitiesAndrew Prescott
 
Doing the Digital: How Scholars Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Computer
Doing the Digital: How Scholars Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the ComputerDoing the Digital: How Scholars Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Computer
Doing the Digital: How Scholars Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the ComputerAndrew Prescott
 
What are the Digital Humanities and what use are they to me?
What are the Digital Humanities and what use are they to me?What are the Digital Humanities and what use are they to me?
What are the Digital Humanities and what use are they to me?Andrew Prescott
 
The Arts and Humanities in a Digital Age: Disruptions and Continuities
The Arts and Humanities in a Digital Age: Disruptions and ContinuitiesThe Arts and Humanities in a Digital Age: Disruptions and Continuities
The Arts and Humanities in a Digital Age: Disruptions and ContinuitiesAndrew Prescott
 
Beyond the REF: the Role of Repositories
Beyond the REF: the Role of RepositoriesBeyond the REF: the Role of Repositories
Beyond the REF: the Role of RepositoriesAndrew Prescott
 
The Digitisation of Chaucer
The Digitisation of Chaucer The Digitisation of Chaucer
The Digitisation of Chaucer Andrew Prescott
 

Plus de Andrew Prescott (17)

Researching Freemasonry in a Time of Coronavirus: Resources and Opportunities
Researching Freemasonry in a Time of Coronavirus: Resources and OpportunitiesResearching Freemasonry in a Time of Coronavirus: Resources and Opportunities
Researching Freemasonry in a Time of Coronavirus: Resources and Opportunities
 
Working with Archives
Working with ArchivesWorking with Archives
Working with Archives
 
Artistic Practice and The Archive
Artistic Practice and The ArchiveArtistic Practice and The Archive
Artistic Practice and The Archive
 
Is Search the Right Way?
Is Search the Right Way?Is Search the Right Way?
Is Search the Right Way?
 
Medieval Studies: Some Hopes and Fears for the Future
Medieval Studies: Some Hopes and Fears for the FutureMedieval Studies: Some Hopes and Fears for the Future
Medieval Studies: Some Hopes and Fears for the Future
 
New Modernist Editing meeting
New Modernist Editing meetingNew Modernist Editing meeting
New Modernist Editing meeting
 
What Happens When the Internet of Things Meets the Middle Ages?
What Happens When the Internet of Things Meets the Middle Ages?What Happens When the Internet of Things Meets the Middle Ages?
What Happens When the Internet of Things Meets the Middle Ages?
 
Avoiding the Rear View Mirror
Avoiding the Rear View MirrorAvoiding the Rear View Mirror
Avoiding the Rear View Mirror
 
Challenges in the Digital Humanities
Challenges in the Digital HumanitiesChallenges in the Digital Humanities
Challenges in the Digital Humanities
 
Sustainability
SustainabilitySustainability
Sustainability
 
Doing the Digital: How Scholars Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Computer
Doing the Digital: How Scholars Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the ComputerDoing the Digital: How Scholars Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Computer
Doing the Digital: How Scholars Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Computer
 
New Materialities
New MaterialitiesNew Materialities
New Materialities
 
What are the Digital Humanities and what use are they to me?
What are the Digital Humanities and what use are they to me?What are the Digital Humanities and what use are they to me?
What are the Digital Humanities and what use are they to me?
 
The Arts and Humanities in a Digital Age: Disruptions and Continuities
The Arts and Humanities in a Digital Age: Disruptions and ContinuitiesThe Arts and Humanities in a Digital Age: Disruptions and Continuities
The Arts and Humanities in a Digital Age: Disruptions and Continuities
 
Beyond the REF: the Role of Repositories
Beyond the REF: the Role of RepositoriesBeyond the REF: the Role of Repositories
Beyond the REF: the Role of Repositories
 
The Digitisation of Chaucer
The Digitisation of Chaucer The Digitisation of Chaucer
The Digitisation of Chaucer
 
Trier
TrierTrier
Trier
 

Digital Transformations: Some Historical Perspectives

  • 1.
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14. • Initiatives for Access: pioneering British Library programme from 1993-1997 • Variety of experimental projects • High level of risk, but many of the experimental projects have turned into Electronic Beowulf Patent Office Express key services such as the online catalogue, newspaper digitisation and online patent access • PLURAL, TRANSVERSAL AND GENERATIVE • This translates to: no one single Dunhuang Project Network catalogues approach, piece of kit or infrastructure which will enable us to deliver, master or manage the digital. • The digital is shape shifting, so it adapts to our interests and preoccupations • It is (and should be) like riding a tiger. Digitisation of microfilm Turning the Pages (Burney Newspapers)
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 18.
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 25. Model of Newcomen Steam Engine at the University of Glasgow repaired by James Watt in 1765. A plaything to start with, but ‘everything became science in his hands’ Not immediately disruptive. Partnership with Boulton and move to Birmingham was key.
  • 26. Development of Sheffield as a steel city • 1740: Huntsman’s first experiments with crucible steel • 1770: Huntsman’s process begins to be used by other Sheffield cutlers • 1786: steam power first used to power hammers in the city • 1851: less than a quarter of city’s workers in heavy industries • 1859: Bessemer opens his new steelworks in Sheffield because he wanted to shock the conservative steelmakers there • 1891: two thirds of city’s workers in heavy industries • The creation of a ‘steel city’ took over 150 years – perhaps even longer
  • 27. Sidney Pollard on the Industrial Revolution in Sheffield and Birmingham “a visitor to the metalworking areas of Birmingham or Sheffield in the mid nineteenth- century would have found little to distinguish them superficially from the same industries a hundred years earlier. The men worked as independent sub-contractors in their own or rented workshops using their own or hired equipment … These industries .. were still waiting for their Industrial Revolution”
  • 28. Changes to Environment • Wheels powered by steam • New gadgets available to speed up tasks such as stamping and cutting • Workshop lit by gas and has water supply • Railways improve distribution • Cheap advertising increases demand • Is much of what we are seeing similar to the experience of the ‘small mester’ in the industrial revolution?
  • 29.
  • 30.
  • 31.
  • 32. The Industrial Revolution was by no means as ‘transformative’ as the Olympic opening ceremony might suggest: • Impact often very localised and patchy • Micro invention just as important as large- scale innovation • Social as important as technical: Lunar Society • Economic growth hard to show: Crafts suggests annual economic growth of just 2% • Changes in communication, advertising, access to markets as important as chane in manufacturing
  • 33. What of Other Transformations? “the Gutenberg Bible led to religious reformation while the Web appears to be leading towards social and economic reformation. But the Digital Industrial revolution, because of the issues and phenomena surrounding the Web and its interactions with society, is occurring at lightning speed with profound impacts on society, the economy, politics, and more”. Michael Brodie, Verizon
  • 34.
  • 35.
  • 36. Anne Alexander and Miriyam Aouragh: “the Egyptian activists we interviewed rightly reject simplistic claims that technology somehow caused the 2011 uprisings, and they say it undermines the agency of the millions of people who participated in the movement that brought down Hosni Mubarak” “platitudes do not help us understand the dual character of the Internet: It empowers and disempowers” “we propose a shift away from perspectives that isolate “the Internet” from other media by examining the shift in media architecture exposed by the powerful synergy between social media and satellite broadcasters during the January 25 uprising” “we call for an understanding of the dialectical relationship between online and offline political action. We argue that without one, the other cannot have meaning. To a large extent, Internet spaces and tools were the choice of young revolutionaries in Egypt because they were already the spaces and tools that people of their generation had chosen for communication in daily life”. ‘The Egyptian Experience: Sense and Nonsense of the Internet Revolution’, International Journal of Communication 5 (2011)