2. Core challenges
Systems designed to manage building
resources and student teacher ratios –
not teaching and learning
Multiplicity of funding streams has
generated many parallel – non-
connected systems
New analytical demands rapidly
exceeded system capacity and new
demands increasing in scale and speed
3. Logic of performance
systems
Inputs Activities Outputs Outcomes
Design Program Public &
Goals Educators
Project Measures Educator Effort
Receive
Funds Incentives
Information
Goals
Deliver New Measures
Project Incentives
Staff Program Changes in
Instruction
Educator
Measure Participation
Top Mgmt & Performance
Key Improved
Stakeholder Leadership & Student
Support Educators Achievement.
Report
Receive
Outcomes
Appropriate
Recognition
Context Other District
Opportunities
Programs &
& Resources
Initiatives
4. Core data system concerns
Data quality and quantity adequate
Timeliness of results – both formative
feedback along the way and summative
reports on performance
Instrumentation for collecting non-test
score measures
Ability to federate data from multiple
sources
5. Technology support
broadens
Original concerns about creating valid
performance calculations for payout
Out-year tasks are reducing burden of
observation, logs, and other data
streams
Challenge of creating systems to track
implementation of interventions at all
levels to enhance evaluation capabilities
6. Where we are working
Connect resources to outcomes
Track resource expenditures down to
school, classroom, and student
Value Added Analysis
Connect data to operational decisions
and improvement planning
Build new measures into KPI
frameworks
9. Bottom Line for Tech
Strategy
Moving to performance compensation
changes the game
Evaluation of programs, practices,
teacher prep partners, etc. becomes a
core business function
Culture of evidence can grow from focus
on productivity
Substantial new demands on socio-
technical systems
10. Inventory
SIS (granularity and S-T links)
DW (refresh, reports, and dashboards)
IMS/LMS
HR/Finance
PD
Platforms in schools/models of use
Network (backbone & building deployed)
Wrote about these problems back in 2001 and did a new more detailed book chapter in 2007. Core of accountability has be fiscal and contract compliance and has flowed up to state and federal agencies around a service-area model.Now that the measures of success have changed, the infrastructure is inadequate to support the demand for data.