SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  21
Agnieszka Kazimierczuk (PADEV) Presentation prepared for: “ Insights in complexity: possibilities for scaling-up a bottom-up evaluation approach.” Utrecht, 15.09.2010
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
“ A poor   person  is not well-recognized in society and is not involved in any social processes either;  while  a very poor  person  is not respected by others, neither recognized in the community, (s)he is not considered in the decision-making processes, nor attending social gatherings; (s)he is isolated and has no friends.”  Kazimierczuk 2009
 
 
Housing Farm Animals Transport Category Short Description Very rich Rich Not Rich/Not Poor Poor Very poor Transport Owns a car No No No No No Owns a motorbike Yes Yes No No No Owns a bicycle Yes Yes Yes No No Goes bare-footed No No No No Yes Family Has a family (wife/children) Yes Yes Yes Yes No Education Children in SSS Yes Some Some No No Children in basic education Yes Some Some No No Housing House made with cement blocks Yes Some Some No No House roofed with zinc Yes Some Some No No Cloths Goes well-dressed Yes Yes Yes Some No Eating habits 3 meals a day Yes No No No No 2 meals a day Yes Yes Yes No No Farm Use tractor to farm Yes Yes No No No Use bullocks to farm Yes Yes No No No Animals Owns cattle Yes Yes Some No No Owns small ruminants Yes Yes Yes No No Owns poultry Yes Yes Yes Yes No Health Has access to good health care Yes Yes Some Some No Ceremonies Big and recognised ceremonies Yes Some Some No No Position in the society Involved in decision-making Yes Yes Sometimes No No Respected Yes Yes Some No No State of mind Happy Yes Yes Sometimes No No Others Able to support others Yes Yes Sometimes No No Depends on help from others No No Sometimes Yes Yes Has to beg No No No No Yes
The number of households in particular wealth group Wealth Group N Poor 20 Average 77 Rich 69 Very Rich 21
[object Object],N Average age Men 21 52 Elderly Men 12 62 Younger Men 9 39 Women 18 45 Elderly Women 8 59 Younger Women 10 34 Total  39 49
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
 
*excluding the overlapping projects between the groups. ,[object Object],n Older man I 5 Older men II 6 Younger Men I 7 Younger Men II 11 Older women I 6 Older women II 5 Younger women I 5 Younger women II 9 Total* 18
[object Object],Sector Gbangu the Poor 2010 Gbangu Follow up 2010 Education 4 12 Crops 8 12 Health 6 19 Infrastructure 1 4 Water 1 3 Credit/Trade/Business 2 4 Livestock 1 4 Social 0 4 Natural Environment 3 7 Food 2 3 Others 0 3 Total 28 75
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Public Goods
[object Object],Project n 1 School 8 2 Clinic 7 3 Grinding Mill 7 4 Borehole 6 5 Dry-season garden 3 6 Warehouse 2
[object Object]
“ The group of the very poor  contains mostly physically and mentally challenged people or single people, like bachelors or widows. A very poor person does not really have an occupation and depends on relatives or begs in public. Some, if their health allows, are labourers who farm or fetch water for other people. ” Kazimierczuk, 2010
[object Object],Amount of inhabitants Classification of the compound People considered to be the very poor 16 Poor A bachelor 51 Average 2 widows 62 Average 2 old widows 18 Average Aged very poor married couple 60 Average A single old man 27 Rich 2 widows 25 Very rich A blind man and his wife
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],“ The (very) poor are invisible!!”  The efforts on the ground need to be greater in order to properly address development divides.
Local definition of poverty and understanding of local context  Most vulnerable and excluded  people,  children
 

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Social Protection in Rwanda
Social Protection in RwandaSocial Protection in Rwanda
Social Protection in RwandaSIANI
 
Dr Robin Hadley - Future of Ageing
Dr Robin Hadley - Future of AgeingDr Robin Hadley - Future of Ageing
Dr Robin Hadley - Future of AgeingILC- UK
 
How to Initiate and Manage Microfinance Projects
How to Initiate and Manage Microfinance ProjectsHow to Initiate and Manage Microfinance Projects
How to Initiate and Manage Microfinance ProjectsRotary International
 
Housing situation in Roma settlements in Slovakia
Housing situation in Roma settlements in SlovakiaHousing situation in Roma settlements in Slovakia
Housing situation in Roma settlements in Slovakiahabitatmacedonia
 
Social Entreprenuership in Urban America
Social Entreprenuership in Urban AmericaSocial Entreprenuership in Urban America
Social Entreprenuership in Urban AmericaRobert Caldwell
 
Introducing North Kathmandu Development Network by Govinda Narayan
Introducing North Kathmandu Development Network by Govinda NarayanIntroducing North Kathmandu Development Network by Govinda Narayan
Introducing North Kathmandu Development Network by Govinda NarayanSouvihdya Manoz Khadka
 
Corporate Social Responsibility and People with Disabilities
Corporate Social Responsibility and People with DisabilitiesCorporate Social Responsibility and People with Disabilities
Corporate Social Responsibility and People with DisabilitiesOmid Omidvar
 
Measuring inequalities (Dialogue on Inequalities)
Measuring inequalities (Dialogue on Inequalities)Measuring inequalities (Dialogue on Inequalities)
Measuring inequalities (Dialogue on Inequalities)Mihail Peleah
 
The Next Generation of Farmers in Laos
The Next Generation of Farmers in LaosThe Next Generation of Farmers in Laos
The Next Generation of Farmers in LaosAndrew Bartlett
 
Data to capture those at risk of exclusion
Data to capture those at risk of exclusionData to capture those at risk of exclusion
Data to capture those at risk of exclusionMihail Peleah
 
Spatial Justice and the Irish Crisis: Poverty - Des McCafferty and Eileen Hum...
Spatial Justice and the Irish Crisis: Poverty - Des McCafferty and Eileen Hum...Spatial Justice and the Irish Crisis: Poverty - Des McCafferty and Eileen Hum...
Spatial Justice and the Irish Crisis: Poverty - Des McCafferty and Eileen Hum...The Royal Irish Academy
 
A brief introduction to basic income
A brief introduction to basic incomeA brief introduction to basic income
A brief introduction to basic incomeCitizen Network
 
Maximising the potential of the UK's ageing population. Lessons from Asia and...
Maximising the potential of the UK's ageing population. Lessons from Asia and...Maximising the potential of the UK's ageing population. Lessons from Asia and...
Maximising the potential of the UK's ageing population. Lessons from Asia and...ILC- UK
 
08May14 - Community Matters: Are our communities ready for ageing?
08May14 - Community Matters: Are our communities ready for ageing?08May14 - Community Matters: Are our communities ready for ageing?
08May14 - Community Matters: Are our communities ready for ageing?ILC- UK
 
Promoting Health and Wellbeing - Vision, Practice and Reality | Dr Neil Hamlet
Promoting Health and Wellbeing - Vision, Practice and Reality | Dr Neil HamletPromoting Health and Wellbeing - Vision, Practice and Reality | Dr Neil Hamlet
Promoting Health and Wellbeing - Vision, Practice and Reality | Dr Neil HamletScottish Cancer Prevention Network
 
02Nov15 - Drink Wise Age Well programme launch
02Nov15 - Drink Wise Age Well programme launch02Nov15 - Drink Wise Age Well programme launch
02Nov15 - Drink Wise Age Well programme launchILC- UK
 

Tendances (20)

Social Protection in Rwanda
Social Protection in RwandaSocial Protection in Rwanda
Social Protection in Rwanda
 
Dr Robin Hadley - Future of Ageing
Dr Robin Hadley - Future of AgeingDr Robin Hadley - Future of Ageing
Dr Robin Hadley - Future of Ageing
 
How to Initiate and Manage Microfinance Projects
How to Initiate and Manage Microfinance ProjectsHow to Initiate and Manage Microfinance Projects
How to Initiate and Manage Microfinance Projects
 
Nwaf ppt
Nwaf pptNwaf ppt
Nwaf ppt
 
Ewan Fisher
Ewan Fisher Ewan Fisher
Ewan Fisher
 
Housing situation in Roma settlements in Slovakia
Housing situation in Roma settlements in SlovakiaHousing situation in Roma settlements in Slovakia
Housing situation in Roma settlements in Slovakia
 
Social Entreprenuership in Urban America
Social Entreprenuership in Urban AmericaSocial Entreprenuership in Urban America
Social Entreprenuership in Urban America
 
Introducing North Kathmandu Development Network by Govinda Narayan
Introducing North Kathmandu Development Network by Govinda NarayanIntroducing North Kathmandu Development Network by Govinda Narayan
Introducing North Kathmandu Development Network by Govinda Narayan
 
Corporate Social Responsibility and People with Disabilities
Corporate Social Responsibility and People with DisabilitiesCorporate Social Responsibility and People with Disabilities
Corporate Social Responsibility and People with Disabilities
 
Nick Mickinski
Nick MickinskiNick Mickinski
Nick Mickinski
 
Measuring inequalities (Dialogue on Inequalities)
Measuring inequalities (Dialogue on Inequalities)Measuring inequalities (Dialogue on Inequalities)
Measuring inequalities (Dialogue on Inequalities)
 
The Next Generation of Farmers in Laos
The Next Generation of Farmers in LaosThe Next Generation of Farmers in Laos
The Next Generation of Farmers in Laos
 
Data to capture those at risk of exclusion
Data to capture those at risk of exclusionData to capture those at risk of exclusion
Data to capture those at risk of exclusion
 
Spatial Justice and the Irish Crisis: Poverty - Des McCafferty and Eileen Hum...
Spatial Justice and the Irish Crisis: Poverty - Des McCafferty and Eileen Hum...Spatial Justice and the Irish Crisis: Poverty - Des McCafferty and Eileen Hum...
Spatial Justice and the Irish Crisis: Poverty - Des McCafferty and Eileen Hum...
 
A brief introduction to basic income
A brief introduction to basic incomeA brief introduction to basic income
A brief introduction to basic income
 
Maximising the potential of the UK's ageing population. Lessons from Asia and...
Maximising the potential of the UK's ageing population. Lessons from Asia and...Maximising the potential of the UK's ageing population. Lessons from Asia and...
Maximising the potential of the UK's ageing population. Lessons from Asia and...
 
Afternoon keynote - Margaret Casely-Hayford, Chair, Action Aid
Afternoon keynote - Margaret Casely-Hayford, Chair, Action AidAfternoon keynote - Margaret Casely-Hayford, Chair, Action Aid
Afternoon keynote - Margaret Casely-Hayford, Chair, Action Aid
 
08May14 - Community Matters: Are our communities ready for ageing?
08May14 - Community Matters: Are our communities ready for ageing?08May14 - Community Matters: Are our communities ready for ageing?
08May14 - Community Matters: Are our communities ready for ageing?
 
Promoting Health and Wellbeing - Vision, Practice and Reality | Dr Neil Hamlet
Promoting Health and Wellbeing - Vision, Practice and Reality | Dr Neil HamletPromoting Health and Wellbeing - Vision, Practice and Reality | Dr Neil Hamlet
Promoting Health and Wellbeing - Vision, Practice and Reality | Dr Neil Hamlet
 
02Nov15 - Drink Wise Age Well programme launch
02Nov15 - Drink Wise Age Well programme launch02Nov15 - Drink Wise Age Well programme launch
02Nov15 - Drink Wise Age Well programme launch
 

En vedette

Antti Koskinen - Grasping the Future - Learning Cafe
Antti Koskinen - Grasping the Future - Learning CafeAntti Koskinen - Grasping the Future - Learning Cafe
Antti Koskinen - Grasping the Future - Learning Cafegtf08
 
Women entrepeneurs help each other grow with Yente's Sparring Partner Programme
Women entrepeneurs help each other grow with Yente's Sparring Partner ProgrammeWomen entrepeneurs help each other grow with Yente's Sparring Partner Programme
Women entrepeneurs help each other grow with Yente's Sparring Partner ProgrammeICCO Cooperation
 

En vedette (6)

Antti Koskinen - Grasping the Future - Learning Cafe
Antti Koskinen - Grasping the Future - Learning CafeAntti Koskinen - Grasping the Future - Learning Cafe
Antti Koskinen - Grasping the Future - Learning Cafe
 
Roles of ICCO Alliance
Roles of ICCO AllianceRoles of ICCO Alliance
Roles of ICCO Alliance
 
Poultry vcd
Poultry  vcdPoultry  vcd
Poultry vcd
 
Women entrepeneurs help each other grow with Yente's Sparring Partner Programme
Women entrepeneurs help each other grow with Yente's Sparring Partner ProgrammeWomen entrepeneurs help each other grow with Yente's Sparring Partner Programme
Women entrepeneurs help each other grow with Yente's Sparring Partner Programme
 
Class17
Class17Class17
Class17
 
Class17
Class17Class17
Class17
 

Similaire à "Are the poor invisible?" - PADEV with the poor

Personalisation - Emerging Challenges
Personalisation - Emerging ChallengesPersonalisation - Emerging Challenges
Personalisation - Emerging ChallengesCitizen Network
 
Recently problems of bangladesh and probably solution
Recently problems of bangladesh and probably solutionRecently problems of bangladesh and probably solution
Recently problems of bangladesh and probably solutionmithuja
 
Focus on poor session 5
Focus on poor session 5Focus on poor session 5
Focus on poor session 5Pallavi Singh
 
National social protection strategy in Bangladesh, David Hulme, Brooks World ...
National social protection strategy in Bangladesh, David Hulme, Brooks World ...National social protection strategy in Bangladesh, David Hulme, Brooks World ...
National social protection strategy in Bangladesh, David Hulme, Brooks World ...Global Development Institute
 
Ashraya Project
Ashraya ProjectAshraya Project
Ashraya ProjectAnish Alex
 
UnLtd Czech Republic March 2011 ENG
UnLtd Czech Republic March 2011 ENGUnLtd Czech Republic March 2011 ENG
UnLtd Czech Republic March 2011 ENGInnovation Tank
 
Contextualizing Health and Aging in Mexico: An Opinion Nationwide Survey - Ma...
Contextualizing Health and Aging in Mexico: An Opinion Nationwide Survey - Ma...Contextualizing Health and Aging in Mexico: An Opinion Nationwide Survey - Ma...
Contextualizing Health and Aging in Mexico: An Opinion Nationwide Survey - Ma...University of Texas at San Antonio
 
The role of the youth in alleviating poverty
The role of the youth in alleviating povertyThe role of the youth in alleviating poverty
The role of the youth in alleviating povertyAko JB
 
problems of elderly people 2.pptx
problems of elderly people 2.pptxproblems of elderly people 2.pptx
problems of elderly people 2.pptxManojPawar890235
 
The End of Our Illusions
The End of Our IllusionsThe End of Our Illusions
The End of Our IllusionsCitizen Network
 
Youth and the Global Goals
Youth and the Global GoalsYouth and the Global Goals
Youth and the Global GoalsOlivier Serrat
 
141029 how to design an inclusive urban environment for people of all ages
141029 how to design an inclusive urban environment for people of all ages141029 how to design an inclusive urban environment for people of all ages
141029 how to design an inclusive urban environment for people of all agesibasho_org
 
SDG 8 Presentation by Jane Harrison
SDG 8 Presentation by Jane HarrisonSDG 8 Presentation by Jane Harrison
SDG 8 Presentation by Jane HarrisonHealthOERUCT
 
Care bangladesh 05.11.10
Care bangladesh 05.11.10Care bangladesh 05.11.10
Care bangladesh 05.11.10genderassets
 

Similaire à "Are the poor invisible?" - PADEV with the poor (20)

Personalisation - Emerging Challenges
Personalisation - Emerging ChallengesPersonalisation - Emerging Challenges
Personalisation - Emerging Challenges
 
Poverty Workshop 2009
Poverty Workshop 2009Poverty Workshop 2009
Poverty Workshop 2009
 
Recently problems of bangladesh and probably solution
Recently problems of bangladesh and probably solutionRecently problems of bangladesh and probably solution
Recently problems of bangladesh and probably solution
 
Focus on poor session 5
Focus on poor session 5Focus on poor session 5
Focus on poor session 5
 
GGS PROFILE finel
GGS PROFILE finelGGS PROFILE finel
GGS PROFILE finel
 
National social protection strategy in Bangladesh, David Hulme, Brooks World ...
National social protection strategy in Bangladesh, David Hulme, Brooks World ...National social protection strategy in Bangladesh, David Hulme, Brooks World ...
National social protection strategy in Bangladesh, David Hulme, Brooks World ...
 
The social cause of poverty
The social cause of povertyThe social cause of poverty
The social cause of poverty
 
Ashraya Project
Ashraya ProjectAshraya Project
Ashraya Project
 
UnLtd Czech Republic March 2011 ENG
UnLtd Czech Republic March 2011 ENGUnLtd Czech Republic March 2011 ENG
UnLtd Czech Republic March 2011 ENG
 
Contextualizing Health and Aging in Mexico: An Opinion Nationwide Survey - Ma...
Contextualizing Health and Aging in Mexico: An Opinion Nationwide Survey - Ma...Contextualizing Health and Aging in Mexico: An Opinion Nationwide Survey - Ma...
Contextualizing Health and Aging in Mexico: An Opinion Nationwide Survey - Ma...
 
The role of the youth in alleviating poverty
The role of the youth in alleviating povertyThe role of the youth in alleviating poverty
The role of the youth in alleviating poverty
 
problems of elderly people 2.pptx
problems of elderly people 2.pptxproblems of elderly people 2.pptx
problems of elderly people 2.pptx
 
The End of Our Illusions
The End of Our IllusionsThe End of Our Illusions
The End of Our Illusions
 
Youth and the Global Goals
Youth and the Global GoalsYouth and the Global Goals
Youth and the Global Goals
 
Poverty and its ground reality
Poverty and its ground realityPoverty and its ground reality
Poverty and its ground reality
 
POOR AND RICH
POOR AND RICHPOOR AND RICH
POOR AND RICH
 
Week 10.pptx
Week 10.pptxWeek 10.pptx
Week 10.pptx
 
141029 how to design an inclusive urban environment for people of all ages
141029 how to design an inclusive urban environment for people of all ages141029 how to design an inclusive urban environment for people of all ages
141029 how to design an inclusive urban environment for people of all ages
 
SDG 8 Presentation by Jane Harrison
SDG 8 Presentation by Jane HarrisonSDG 8 Presentation by Jane Harrison
SDG 8 Presentation by Jane Harrison
 
Care bangladesh 05.11.10
Care bangladesh 05.11.10Care bangladesh 05.11.10
Care bangladesh 05.11.10
 

Plus de ICCO Cooperation

Knowledge[at]iccopresentation4kitbyhwa
Knowledge[at]iccopresentation4kitbyhwaKnowledge[at]iccopresentation4kitbyhwa
Knowledge[at]iccopresentation4kitbyhwaICCO Cooperation
 
IDH presentation Partner workshop
IDH presentation Partner workshopIDH presentation Partner workshop
IDH presentation Partner workshopICCO Cooperation
 
ICT as Business Development Service
ICT as Business Development Service ICT as Business Development Service
ICT as Business Development Service ICCO Cooperation
 
Ruggie on Business and Human Rights, what's in it for Civil Society?
Ruggie on Business and Human Rights, what's in it for Civil Society?Ruggie on Business and Human Rights, what's in it for Civil Society?
Ruggie on Business and Human Rights, what's in it for Civil Society?ICCO Cooperation
 
Women’s Empowerment Principles, UNIFEM
Women’s Empowerment Principles, UNIFEMWomen’s Empowerment Principles, UNIFEM
Women’s Empowerment Principles, UNIFEMICCO Cooperation
 
Sustainable Fair Economic Development Philippines - Evaluation Report
Sustainable Fair Economic Development Philippines - Evaluation ReportSustainable Fair Economic Development Philippines - Evaluation Report
Sustainable Fair Economic Development Philippines - Evaluation ReportICCO Cooperation
 
Multi stakeholders processes mar2012
Multi stakeholders processes mar2012Multi stakeholders processes mar2012
Multi stakeholders processes mar2012ICCO Cooperation
 
Vc ct integration-methodology_feb 28
Vc ct integration-methodology_feb 28Vc ct integration-methodology_feb 28
Vc ct integration-methodology_feb 28ICCO Cooperation
 
Guidance note for the Programmatic Approach (version 31-12-2011)
Guidance note for the Programmatic Approach (version 31-12-2011)Guidance note for the Programmatic Approach (version 31-12-2011)
Guidance note for the Programmatic Approach (version 31-12-2011)ICCO Cooperation
 
Benchmarking c4 c_ethiopia
Benchmarking c4 c_ethiopiaBenchmarking c4 c_ethiopia
Benchmarking c4 c_ethiopiaICCO Cooperation
 
Pr c factsheet_partnership_box1
Pr c factsheet_partnership_box1Pr c factsheet_partnership_box1
Pr c factsheet_partnership_box1ICCO Cooperation
 
Powerpoint capacity building tmf 2011 10 11 (no quiz))
Powerpoint capacity building tmf 2011 10 11 (no quiz))Powerpoint capacity building tmf 2011 10 11 (no quiz))
Powerpoint capacity building tmf 2011 10 11 (no quiz))ICCO Cooperation
 
Powerpoint learning communities networked learning (sept 30 2011)[1]
Powerpoint learning communities networked learning (sept 30 2011)[1]Powerpoint learning communities networked learning (sept 30 2011)[1]
Powerpoint learning communities networked learning (sept 30 2011)[1]ICCO Cooperation
 
Programmatic approach: External presentation may 2011
Programmatic approach: External presentation may 2011Programmatic approach: External presentation may 2011
Programmatic approach: External presentation may 2011ICCO Cooperation
 
Programmatic approach facilitators nov. 2010 print versie
Programmatic approach facilitators  nov. 2010 print versieProgrammatic approach facilitators  nov. 2010 print versie
Programmatic approach facilitators nov. 2010 print versieICCO Cooperation
 
Programmatic approach - facilitators ws Okt. 2009
Programmatic approach  - facilitators ws Okt.  2009 Programmatic approach  - facilitators ws Okt.  2009
Programmatic approach - facilitators ws Okt. 2009 ICCO Cooperation
 
Programmatic approach (appreciation process - Feb. 2010)
Programmatic approach (appreciation process - Feb. 2010)Programmatic approach (appreciation process - Feb. 2010)
Programmatic approach (appreciation process - Feb. 2010)ICCO Cooperation
 
Programmatic approach (Okt. 2008)
Programmatic approach (Okt. 2008)Programmatic approach (Okt. 2008)
Programmatic approach (Okt. 2008)ICCO Cooperation
 

Plus de ICCO Cooperation (20)

Knowledge[at]iccopresentation4kitbyhwa
Knowledge[at]iccopresentation4kitbyhwaKnowledge[at]iccopresentation4kitbyhwa
Knowledge[at]iccopresentation4kitbyhwa
 
IDH presentation Partner workshop
IDH presentation Partner workshopIDH presentation Partner workshop
IDH presentation Partner workshop
 
ICT as Business Development Service
ICT as Business Development Service ICT as Business Development Service
ICT as Business Development Service
 
Ruggie on Business and Human Rights, what's in it for Civil Society?
Ruggie on Business and Human Rights, what's in it for Civil Society?Ruggie on Business and Human Rights, what's in it for Civil Society?
Ruggie on Business and Human Rights, what's in it for Civil Society?
 
Women’s Empowerment Principles, UNIFEM
Women’s Empowerment Principles, UNIFEMWomen’s Empowerment Principles, UNIFEM
Women’s Empowerment Principles, UNIFEM
 
Sustainable Fair Economic Development Philippines - Evaluation Report
Sustainable Fair Economic Development Philippines - Evaluation ReportSustainable Fair Economic Development Philippines - Evaluation Report
Sustainable Fair Economic Development Philippines - Evaluation Report
 
Value chain finance
Value chain financeValue chain finance
Value chain finance
 
Multi stakeholders processes mar2012
Multi stakeholders processes mar2012Multi stakeholders processes mar2012
Multi stakeholders processes mar2012
 
Vc ct integration-methodology_feb 28
Vc ct integration-methodology_feb 28Vc ct integration-methodology_feb 28
Vc ct integration-methodology_feb 28
 
Guidance note for the Programmatic Approach (version 31-12-2011)
Guidance note for the Programmatic Approach (version 31-12-2011)Guidance note for the Programmatic Approach (version 31-12-2011)
Guidance note for the Programmatic Approach (version 31-12-2011)
 
Benchmarking c4 c_ethiopia
Benchmarking c4 c_ethiopiaBenchmarking c4 c_ethiopia
Benchmarking c4 c_ethiopia
 
Pr c factsheet_partnership_box1
Pr c factsheet_partnership_box1Pr c factsheet_partnership_box1
Pr c factsheet_partnership_box1
 
Powerpoint capacity building tmf 2011 10 11 (no quiz))
Powerpoint capacity building tmf 2011 10 11 (no quiz))Powerpoint capacity building tmf 2011 10 11 (no quiz))
Powerpoint capacity building tmf 2011 10 11 (no quiz))
 
Powerpoint learning communities networked learning (sept 30 2011)[1]
Powerpoint learning communities networked learning (sept 30 2011)[1]Powerpoint learning communities networked learning (sept 30 2011)[1]
Powerpoint learning communities networked learning (sept 30 2011)[1]
 
THEORY OF CHANGE
THEORY OF CHANGE THEORY OF CHANGE
THEORY OF CHANGE
 
Programmatic approach: External presentation may 2011
Programmatic approach: External presentation may 2011Programmatic approach: External presentation may 2011
Programmatic approach: External presentation may 2011
 
Programmatic approach facilitators nov. 2010 print versie
Programmatic approach facilitators  nov. 2010 print versieProgrammatic approach facilitators  nov. 2010 print versie
Programmatic approach facilitators nov. 2010 print versie
 
Programmatic approach - facilitators ws Okt. 2009
Programmatic approach  - facilitators ws Okt.  2009 Programmatic approach  - facilitators ws Okt.  2009
Programmatic approach - facilitators ws Okt. 2009
 
Programmatic approach (appreciation process - Feb. 2010)
Programmatic approach (appreciation process - Feb. 2010)Programmatic approach (appreciation process - Feb. 2010)
Programmatic approach (appreciation process - Feb. 2010)
 
Programmatic approach (Okt. 2008)
Programmatic approach (Okt. 2008)Programmatic approach (Okt. 2008)
Programmatic approach (Okt. 2008)
 

"Are the poor invisible?" - PADEV with the poor

  • 1. Agnieszka Kazimierczuk (PADEV) Presentation prepared for: “ Insights in complexity: possibilities for scaling-up a bottom-up evaluation approach.” Utrecht, 15.09.2010
  • 2.
  • 3. “ A poor person is not well-recognized in society and is not involved in any social processes either; while a very poor person is not respected by others, neither recognized in the community, (s)he is not considered in the decision-making processes, nor attending social gatherings; (s)he is isolated and has no friends.” Kazimierczuk 2009
  • 4.  
  • 5.  
  • 6. Housing Farm Animals Transport Category Short Description Very rich Rich Not Rich/Not Poor Poor Very poor Transport Owns a car No No No No No Owns a motorbike Yes Yes No No No Owns a bicycle Yes Yes Yes No No Goes bare-footed No No No No Yes Family Has a family (wife/children) Yes Yes Yes Yes No Education Children in SSS Yes Some Some No No Children in basic education Yes Some Some No No Housing House made with cement blocks Yes Some Some No No House roofed with zinc Yes Some Some No No Cloths Goes well-dressed Yes Yes Yes Some No Eating habits 3 meals a day Yes No No No No 2 meals a day Yes Yes Yes No No Farm Use tractor to farm Yes Yes No No No Use bullocks to farm Yes Yes No No No Animals Owns cattle Yes Yes Some No No Owns small ruminants Yes Yes Yes No No Owns poultry Yes Yes Yes Yes No Health Has access to good health care Yes Yes Some Some No Ceremonies Big and recognised ceremonies Yes Some Some No No Position in the society Involved in decision-making Yes Yes Sometimes No No Respected Yes Yes Some No No State of mind Happy Yes Yes Sometimes No No Others Able to support others Yes Yes Sometimes No No Depends on help from others No No Sometimes Yes Yes Has to beg No No No No Yes
  • 7. The number of households in particular wealth group Wealth Group N Poor 20 Average 77 Rich 69 Very Rich 21
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.  
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16. “ The group of the very poor contains mostly physically and mentally challenged people or single people, like bachelors or widows. A very poor person does not really have an occupation and depends on relatives or begs in public. Some, if their health allows, are labourers who farm or fetch water for other people. ” Kazimierczuk, 2010
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20. Local definition of poverty and understanding of local context Most vulnerable and excluded people, children
  • 21.  

Notes de l'éditeur

  1. By using the consolidated list of projects, the facilitator asked about extra ten-fifteen interventions that were judged by the participants of previous workshops as “having an impact on the whole community” or the one who impacted the poor directly. The participants were asked whether they know the funder of the initiative, do they hear about the project and whether they directly benefited from it. Because in most cases, the participants did hear about the project but did not benefit from it, asking them to judge the impact of the projects was considered to be irrelevant.
  2. Generally speaking, the ranking of the best projects was dominated by the projects introduced by the government. It gives the impression that the only way for the poor to benefit from a project is only when it is a public good accessible for everyone and preferably does not require any kind of contribution. Such an outcome also suggests that the government is practically the only actor that is able to uplift the poor directly.
  3. Imposible to trace a “very poor” household; Rely on the in-sight knowledge of the research assistant Nevertheless, it did not mean that there are no very poor people in the village, as the participants were always indicating them to be a part of the society, but it yet again proved that they are invisible and extremely hard to reach.
  4. The very poor are not living separately, but they are “attached” to a household. African compounds are very complex constructions. They are made up from many smaller huts and buildings where even more than a hundred people can live in. As it turned out within one compound a very rich person can live next to a very poor man. That is also a reason why it is so difficult to reach the poor and the very poor, as they are hidden within the compound’s mazes. In order to reach the very poor, six compounds were re-visited with a particular focus on their most destitute inhabitants. The choice of the compound was based on the insight knowledge of the research assistant – Haruna, who after facilitating twelve rounds of the workshops was fully aware of who was considered to be the very poor. The very poor were asked about their occupation and what they do for survival and whether they experience any help from their in-compound neighbors or a NGO? The very poor are indeed single persons, such as widows and bachelors, but there are also two very poor married couples. For them the health state was the main factor of the poverty. Within the married couple, one of the husbands is deaf, the other is blind, and one of the wives is mentally challenged, thus they all are practically unable to do any work. None of the very poor directly benefited from any of the projects (with one exception: borehole).
  5. The main purpose of this research was to trace how exclusion of the poor wealth class from the previously performed workshops (both Gbangu 2010 and Langbinsi 2008) influenced the outcome of the exercises. The main purpose of the PADEV methodology is to give an honest valuation of the development projects, but the participants should be aware of them in order to properly judge their impact.
  6. Confirmation of the previously given definition; Confirmation of the marginalisation and exclusion of these groups;
  7. Very poor and poor are exposed to very specific problems, thus require a specific approach Outcomes Targeting Toolkit: which means are necessary to reach the poor, very poor and excluded. Policy recommendations (especially related to the very poor group).