SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 18
Download to read offline
The Changing
   Face of War
  Impact of Drones On
  Society and Warfare

Technology, society and global dominance
(cultural, economic and military)
Background
   Analysis by an American think tank The Brookings Institution
   on drone attacks in Pakistan has shown that for every
   militant leader killed, 10 civilians also have died.


The use of armed drones           United States has been
by the United States in           using drones in Pakistan
Afghanistan and Pakistan          and other countries to
has increased massively,          assassinate “terrorist
with 131 drone strikes            leaders.”
reported in northwest
Pakistan alone since 2004,
of which a quarter took          Singapore has recently
place in the first five          invested in High Speed
months of 2010.                  Aerial Target Drones
What are Drones?
        • Unmanned Aerial
          Vehicles (UAVs)

        • Controlled from the
          ground or autonomous
          following a pre-
          programmed mission

        • Used for combat,
          reconnaissance and
          surveillance purposes
Interesting Points
‘Technology generally
evolves much more quickly
  than the laws of war.’
(P.W. Singer - Brookings Institution)
1. Laws of war has not caught up with
                     technology
No precedent or rule exists for the
placement of responsibility

                              Militaries operate with little heed
                              to the actual consequences
Keith Shurtleff, an army chaplain and ethics instructor at Fort
Jackson, South Carolina worries “that as war becomes safer
and easier, as soldiers are removed from the horrors of war
and see the enemy not as humans but as blips on a screen,
there is very real danger of losing the deterrent that such
horrors provide.”




                                            Noel Sharkey, Professor of
                                   Artificial Intelligence and Robotics
                                         at the University of Sheffield
                                   highlights: ‘The further away you
                                        are, the easier it is to kill…it’s
                                          changing the nature of war
                                                          dramatically’
2.Society’s changing view of war and
                  bloodshed
• “Sanitising” the act of
  killing

• Society and soldiers
  desensitized to the costs
  and effects of war

• War and bloodshed =
  entertainment?
3. Potential economic implications

                 • Growth of military-
                   industrial complex

                 • Defense contractors
                   grow in power and
                   influence
4. How drone warfare affects the current
       political distribution of power

• Manpower used to be
  significant in determining
  the power of a military or a
  nation

• Technological and financial
  capacity are now
  determinants of a powerful
  military force
5. Risk to society

• Vulnerable to loss of signal
  or a power surge

• Vulnerable to exploitation
  like hacking.
Key Takeaways
Drone warfare’s newly
impersonal qualities may change
our view of war or change the
world’s balance of power as we
know it


         Key takeaway messages
                         “The idea that slick, new
                         weapons will solve human
                         conflict is an old and enduring
                         myth. In truth, violence will not
                         bring an end to violence.”
Personal Ratings
Thought provoking and
relevant article that effectively
summarizes the several issues
with drone warfare
Issues For
Discussion
Issues for discussion



•Drones do have advantages
in warfare, however does that
make the usage of drones in
war acceptable?

•What kind of law should be
put in place with regards to
drone combatants?
References
• http://www.for.org.uk/files/PB8WEB.pdf
• http://triplehelixblog.com/2011/01/law-and-
  technology-the-changing-face-of-war-and-its-
  legal-ramifications/
• http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2
  010/feb/08/afghanistan-drones-defence-
  killing
• http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2011/jan/16/d
  rones-unmanned-aircraft

More Related Content

What's hot (11)

Military Robots and Canadian Defence and Foreign Policy
Military Robots and Canadian Defence and Foreign PolicyMilitary Robots and Canadian Defence and Foreign Policy
Military Robots and Canadian Defence and Foreign Policy
 
"Cross domain” deterrence, escalation geometries and the morphing of strategy
"Cross domain” deterrence, escalation geometries and the morphing of strategy"Cross domain” deterrence, escalation geometries and the morphing of strategy
"Cross domain” deterrence, escalation geometries and the morphing of strategy
 
Space and Cyber: Roles and Issues in Deterrence
Space and Cyber: Roles and Issues in DeterrenceSpace and Cyber: Roles and Issues in Deterrence
Space and Cyber: Roles and Issues in Deterrence
 
Endless War in the Drone Age
Endless War in the Drone AgeEndless War in the Drone Age
Endless War in the Drone Age
 
Scientific and technological development
Scientific and technological developmentScientific and technological development
Scientific and technological development
 
Cyberwarfare
CyberwarfareCyberwarfare
Cyberwarfare
 
Cross Domain Deterrence
Cross Domain DeterrenceCross Domain Deterrence
Cross Domain Deterrence
 
4 g wfinal (2)
4 g wfinal (2)4 g wfinal (2)
4 g wfinal (2)
 
Terrorism & nuclear prolifeeration
Terrorism & nuclear prolifeerationTerrorism & nuclear prolifeeration
Terrorism & nuclear prolifeeration
 
4GW
4GW4GW
4GW
 
FGAW
FGAWFGAW
FGAW
 

Similar to Shereen Woo - The Changing Face of War (Drones)

2014 Karles Invitational Conference
2014 Karles Invitational Conference2014 Karles Invitational Conference
2014 Karles Invitational ConferenceJohn Canning
 
Research Package
Research PackageResearch Package
Research PackageMelanie Liu
 
Technological Advancement of Warfare and IHL.pptx
Technological Advancement of Warfare and IHL.pptxTechnological Advancement of Warfare and IHL.pptx
Technological Advancement of Warfare and IHL.pptxAntaresCobodero1
 
Tabakian Pols 7 Fall/Spring 2014 Power 8
Tabakian Pols 7 Fall/Spring 2014 Power 8Tabakian Pols 7 Fall/Spring 2014 Power 8
Tabakian Pols 7 Fall/Spring 2014 Power 8John Paul Tabakian
 
Emerging Military Technologies, Civil Society, And Democracy
Emerging Military Technologies, Civil Society, And DemocracyEmerging Military Technologies, Civil Society, And Democracy
Emerging Military Technologies, Civil Society, And DemocracyHeatherOlsen1
 
In cyber, the generals should lead from behind - College of Air Warfare - Puk...
In cyber, the generals should lead from behind - College of Air Warfare - Puk...In cyber, the generals should lead from behind - College of Air Warfare - Puk...
In cyber, the generals should lead from behind - College of Air Warfare - Puk...Pukhraj Singh
 
Enhanced Warfighters: Risk, Ethics, and Policy
Enhanced Warfighters: Risk, Ethics, and PolicyEnhanced Warfighters: Risk, Ethics, and Policy
Enhanced Warfighters: Risk, Ethics, and PolicyIlya Klabukov
 
Dondi West Defcon 18 Slides
Dondi West Defcon 18 SlidesDondi West Defcon 18 Slides
Dondi West Defcon 18 Slidesdondiw
 
Virág Németh_ MA thesis
Virág Németh_ MA thesisVirág Németh_ MA thesis
Virág Németh_ MA thesisVirág Németh
 
Special Forces-future challenges
Special Forces-future challengesSpecial Forces-future challenges
Special Forces-future challengesadrian ciolponea
 
Nuclear detterrence in the post cold war scenario
Nuclear detterrence in the post cold war scenarioNuclear detterrence in the post cold war scenario
Nuclear detterrence in the post cold war scenarioAbdelhamied El-Rafie
 
Types & Shapes of Future Wars.pptx
Types & Shapes of Future Wars.pptxTypes & Shapes of Future Wars.pptx
Types & Shapes of Future Wars.pptxMohsinAzhar5
 
Autonomous weapon systems, quo vadis
Autonomous weapon systems, quo vadisAutonomous weapon systems, quo vadis
Autonomous weapon systems, quo vadisKaran Khosla
 
Lecture 1 -Technology, Innovation and Great Power Competition
Lecture 1 -Technology, Innovation and Great Power CompetitionLecture 1 -Technology, Innovation and Great Power Competition
Lecture 1 -Technology, Innovation and Great Power CompetitionStanford University
 
Kenneth geers-sun-tzu-and-cyber-war
Kenneth geers-sun-tzu-and-cyber-warKenneth geers-sun-tzu-and-cyber-war
Kenneth geers-sun-tzu-and-cyber-warMarioEliseo3
 
Special Operations West 2014
Special Operations West 2014 Special Operations West 2014
Special Operations West 2014 Katrina Savarino
 
Drone warfare- A Gray area
Drone warfare- A Gray areaDrone warfare- A Gray area
Drone warfare- A Gray areaAI Publications
 

Similar to Shereen Woo - The Changing Face of War (Drones) (20)

2014 Karles Invitational Conference
2014 Karles Invitational Conference2014 Karles Invitational Conference
2014 Karles Invitational Conference
 
Dean r berry pro and con drones
Dean r berry pro and con dronesDean r berry pro and con drones
Dean r berry pro and con drones
 
Research Package
Research PackageResearch Package
Research Package
 
Technological Advancement of Warfare and IHL.pptx
Technological Advancement of Warfare and IHL.pptxTechnological Advancement of Warfare and IHL.pptx
Technological Advancement of Warfare and IHL.pptx
 
Tabakian Pols 7 Fall/Spring 2014 Power 8
Tabakian Pols 7 Fall/Spring 2014 Power 8Tabakian Pols 7 Fall/Spring 2014 Power 8
Tabakian Pols 7 Fall/Spring 2014 Power 8
 
Emerging Military Technologies, Civil Society, And Democracy
Emerging Military Technologies, Civil Society, And DemocracyEmerging Military Technologies, Civil Society, And Democracy
Emerging Military Technologies, Civil Society, And Democracy
 
In cyber, the generals should lead from behind - College of Air Warfare - Puk...
In cyber, the generals should lead from behind - College of Air Warfare - Puk...In cyber, the generals should lead from behind - College of Air Warfare - Puk...
In cyber, the generals should lead from behind - College of Air Warfare - Puk...
 
Enhanced Warfighters: Risk, Ethics, and Policy
Enhanced Warfighters: Risk, Ethics, and PolicyEnhanced Warfighters: Risk, Ethics, and Policy
Enhanced Warfighters: Risk, Ethics, and Policy
 
Dondi West Defcon 18 Slides
Dondi West Defcon 18 SlidesDondi West Defcon 18 Slides
Dondi West Defcon 18 Slides
 
weapon development.pptx
weapon development.pptxweapon development.pptx
weapon development.pptx
 
Virág Németh_ MA thesis
Virág Németh_ MA thesisVirág Németh_ MA thesis
Virág Németh_ MA thesis
 
Special Forces-future challenges
Special Forces-future challengesSpecial Forces-future challenges
Special Forces-future challenges
 
Nuclear detterrence in the post cold war scenario
Nuclear detterrence in the post cold war scenarioNuclear detterrence in the post cold war scenario
Nuclear detterrence in the post cold war scenario
 
Types & Shapes of Future Wars.pptx
Types & Shapes of Future Wars.pptxTypes & Shapes of Future Wars.pptx
Types & Shapes of Future Wars.pptx
 
Autonomous weapon systems, quo vadis
Autonomous weapon systems, quo vadisAutonomous weapon systems, quo vadis
Autonomous weapon systems, quo vadis
 
Lecture 1 -Technology, Innovation and Great Power Competition
Lecture 1 -Technology, Innovation and Great Power CompetitionLecture 1 -Technology, Innovation and Great Power Competition
Lecture 1 -Technology, Innovation and Great Power Competition
 
Kegley chapter 8
Kegley chapter 8Kegley chapter 8
Kegley chapter 8
 
Kenneth geers-sun-tzu-and-cyber-war
Kenneth geers-sun-tzu-and-cyber-warKenneth geers-sun-tzu-and-cyber-war
Kenneth geers-sun-tzu-and-cyber-war
 
Special Operations West 2014
Special Operations West 2014 Special Operations West 2014
Special Operations West 2014
 
Drone warfare- A Gray area
Drone warfare- A Gray areaDrone warfare- A Gray area
Drone warfare- A Gray area
 

More from cynrx

Siti Zulaiha Bte Kamarudin (Article)
Siti Zulaiha Bte Kamarudin (Article)Siti Zulaiha Bte Kamarudin (Article)
Siti Zulaiha Bte Kamarudin (Article)cynrx
 
Siti Zulaiha Bte Kamarudin
Siti Zulaiha Bte KamarudinSiti Zulaiha Bte Kamarudin
Siti Zulaiha Bte Kamarudincynrx
 
Luo Jia (Article)
Luo Jia (Article)Luo Jia (Article)
Luo Jia (Article)cynrx
 
Luo Jia
Luo JiaLuo Jia
Luo Jiacynrx
 
Liu Rongxuan (Article)
Liu Rongxuan (Article)Liu Rongxuan (Article)
Liu Rongxuan (Article)cynrx
 
Liu Rongxuan
Liu RongxuanLiu Rongxuan
Liu Rongxuancynrx
 
Neo Hui Min Pearlyn
Neo Hui Min PearlynNeo Hui Min Pearlyn
Neo Hui Min Pearlyncynrx
 
Jolene Choo
Jolene ChooJolene Choo
Jolene Choocynrx
 
Ekjote Kaur
Ekjote KaurEkjote Kaur
Ekjote Kaurcynrx
 
Dustin Yu
Dustin YuDustin Yu
Dustin Yucynrx
 
Cheong Yin Ying
Cheong Yin YingCheong Yin Ying
Cheong Yin Yingcynrx
 
Radeya Parveen
Radeya ParveenRadeya Parveen
Radeya Parveencynrx
 
Chen Xin Ying
Chen Xin YingChen Xin Ying
Chen Xin Yingcynrx
 
Chayadi Karim
Chayadi KarimChayadi Karim
Chayadi Karimcynrx
 
Luke Phong
Luke PhongLuke Phong
Luke Phongcynrx
 
Sheryl Lim
Sheryl LimSheryl Lim
Sheryl Limcynrx
 
Lenard Lee - Food Ec & Consumer Choice
Lenard Lee - Food Ec & Consumer ChoiceLenard Lee - Food Ec & Consumer Choice
Lenard Lee - Food Ec & Consumer Choicecynrx
 
Terrence Liong
Terrence LiongTerrence Liong
Terrence Liongcynrx
 
Tristan Neo
Tristan NeoTristan Neo
Tristan Neocynrx
 
Lenard Lee
Lenard LeeLenard Lee
Lenard Leecynrx
 

More from cynrx (20)

Siti Zulaiha Bte Kamarudin (Article)
Siti Zulaiha Bte Kamarudin (Article)Siti Zulaiha Bte Kamarudin (Article)
Siti Zulaiha Bte Kamarudin (Article)
 
Siti Zulaiha Bte Kamarudin
Siti Zulaiha Bte KamarudinSiti Zulaiha Bte Kamarudin
Siti Zulaiha Bte Kamarudin
 
Luo Jia (Article)
Luo Jia (Article)Luo Jia (Article)
Luo Jia (Article)
 
Luo Jia
Luo JiaLuo Jia
Luo Jia
 
Liu Rongxuan (Article)
Liu Rongxuan (Article)Liu Rongxuan (Article)
Liu Rongxuan (Article)
 
Liu Rongxuan
Liu RongxuanLiu Rongxuan
Liu Rongxuan
 
Neo Hui Min Pearlyn
Neo Hui Min PearlynNeo Hui Min Pearlyn
Neo Hui Min Pearlyn
 
Jolene Choo
Jolene ChooJolene Choo
Jolene Choo
 
Ekjote Kaur
Ekjote KaurEkjote Kaur
Ekjote Kaur
 
Dustin Yu
Dustin YuDustin Yu
Dustin Yu
 
Cheong Yin Ying
Cheong Yin YingCheong Yin Ying
Cheong Yin Ying
 
Radeya Parveen
Radeya ParveenRadeya Parveen
Radeya Parveen
 
Chen Xin Ying
Chen Xin YingChen Xin Ying
Chen Xin Ying
 
Chayadi Karim
Chayadi KarimChayadi Karim
Chayadi Karim
 
Luke Phong
Luke PhongLuke Phong
Luke Phong
 
Sheryl Lim
Sheryl LimSheryl Lim
Sheryl Lim
 
Lenard Lee - Food Ec & Consumer Choice
Lenard Lee - Food Ec & Consumer ChoiceLenard Lee - Food Ec & Consumer Choice
Lenard Lee - Food Ec & Consumer Choice
 
Terrence Liong
Terrence LiongTerrence Liong
Terrence Liong
 
Tristan Neo
Tristan NeoTristan Neo
Tristan Neo
 
Lenard Lee
Lenard LeeLenard Lee
Lenard Lee
 

Shereen Woo - The Changing Face of War (Drones)

  • 1. The Changing Face of War Impact of Drones On Society and Warfare Technology, society and global dominance (cultural, economic and military)
  • 2. Background Analysis by an American think tank The Brookings Institution on drone attacks in Pakistan has shown that for every militant leader killed, 10 civilians also have died. The use of armed drones United States has been by the United States in using drones in Pakistan Afghanistan and Pakistan and other countries to has increased massively, assassinate “terrorist with 131 drone strikes leaders.” reported in northwest Pakistan alone since 2004, of which a quarter took Singapore has recently place in the first five invested in High Speed months of 2010. Aerial Target Drones
  • 3. What are Drones? • Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) • Controlled from the ground or autonomous following a pre- programmed mission • Used for combat, reconnaissance and surveillance purposes
  • 5. ‘Technology generally evolves much more quickly than the laws of war.’ (P.W. Singer - Brookings Institution)
  • 6. 1. Laws of war has not caught up with technology No precedent or rule exists for the placement of responsibility Militaries operate with little heed to the actual consequences
  • 7. Keith Shurtleff, an army chaplain and ethics instructor at Fort Jackson, South Carolina worries “that as war becomes safer and easier, as soldiers are removed from the horrors of war and see the enemy not as humans but as blips on a screen, there is very real danger of losing the deterrent that such horrors provide.” Noel Sharkey, Professor of Artificial Intelligence and Robotics at the University of Sheffield highlights: ‘The further away you are, the easier it is to kill…it’s changing the nature of war dramatically’
  • 8. 2.Society’s changing view of war and bloodshed • “Sanitising” the act of killing • Society and soldiers desensitized to the costs and effects of war • War and bloodshed = entertainment?
  • 9. 3. Potential economic implications • Growth of military- industrial complex • Defense contractors grow in power and influence
  • 10. 4. How drone warfare affects the current political distribution of power • Manpower used to be significant in determining the power of a military or a nation • Technological and financial capacity are now determinants of a powerful military force
  • 11. 5. Risk to society • Vulnerable to loss of signal or a power surge • Vulnerable to exploitation like hacking.
  • 13. Drone warfare’s newly impersonal qualities may change our view of war or change the world’s balance of power as we know it Key takeaway messages “The idea that slick, new weapons will solve human conflict is an old and enduring myth. In truth, violence will not bring an end to violence.”
  • 15. Thought provoking and relevant article that effectively summarizes the several issues with drone warfare
  • 17. Issues for discussion •Drones do have advantages in warfare, however does that make the usage of drones in war acceptable? •What kind of law should be put in place with regards to drone combatants?
  • 18. References • http://www.for.org.uk/files/PB8WEB.pdf • http://triplehelixblog.com/2011/01/law-and- technology-the-changing-face-of-war-and-its- legal-ramifications/ • http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2 010/feb/08/afghanistan-drones-defence- killing • http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2011/jan/16/d rones-unmanned-aircraft