2024's Top PPC Tactics: Triple Your Google Ads Local Leads
The Marketer's Funnel and Path to Conversion - A New Perspective at DAS, 10/20/14
1. 1
Rethink the Funnel:
A New Perspective on Attribution
Peter O’Sullivan, Senior Sales Director, Western Region, Quantcast
Lauren Marks, Account Leader, iProspect
| Copyright 2014 Quantcast | Confidential
Know ahead. Act before. TM
2. 2
About Quantcast
The most effective advertising from the people who really get audiences
Quantcast Measure Quantcast Advertise
| Copyright 2014 Quantcast | Confidential
Knows your customer’s next move, so
you can make yours first.
Measures millions of customer
behaviors in the moment.
Directly measuring audiences spanning
hundreds of millions of web destinations
Advertising that acts on real-time
audience behavior.
3. 3
Agenda
The Consumer Journey Down The Funnel
It’s Time To Evolve
An Example By The Numbers
| Copyright 2014 Quantcast | Confidential
4. 4
54% of marketers still use last touch attribution
LAST TOUCH
Conve rsion
Source: Econsultancy, “Marketing attribution: Valuing the Customer Journey”, February 2012
| Copyright 2014 Quantcast | Confidential
Challenges
• Upper funnel is missed.
• All partners on the plan “fight”
to get last touch.
• Creates the wrong incentives
and a lose, lose, lose situation
for consumers, marketers and
media partners.
• Easily manipulated and
gamed.
5. 5
It’s Time To Evolve
….And It’s Not That Hard
| Copyright 2014 Quantcast | Confidential
6. 6
A new perspective: Split Funnel Attribution
| Copyright 2014 Quantcast | Confidential
Benefits
• Clean way to measure
Prospecting and Retargeting.
• Creates a partnership between
upper and lower funnel tactics.
• Aligns incentives for splitting
credit and managing budget.
• Enhances all methods of
attribution modeling.
7. 7
Strike the right balance for splitting
credit, not just budget. Align your incentives:
| Copyright 2014 Quantcast | Confidential
Split Credit for
each Conversion 1
You Decide How
to Divide Credit 2
Upper Funnel Credit
Prospecting Phase
Lower Funnel Credit
Retargeting Phase
8. 8
Split Funnel In Action:
iProspect Case Study, Lauren
Marks
| Copyright 2014 Quantcast | Copyright 2014 Quantcas t | | C Coonnfifdideenntitaial l
9. 9
Campaign Overview
Client: Leading Niche Retailer
Campaign Goal: 2:1 ROI (~$35 CPA)
Budget: $12.5K
Time Period: August 2014
Attribution Methodology: Last Touch
Total number of partners: 6, including Quantcast
Breakdown of tactics by partner: 5 Full-Funnel, 1 Retargeting-only
| Copyright 2014 Quantcast | Confidential
10. 10
Partner Overview
15%
64% 44%
| Copyright 2014 Quantcast | Confidential
14,000,000
12,000,000
10,000,000
8,000,000
6,000,000
4,000,000
2,000,000
0
Impression Mix by Partner
13%
Partner 1 Partner 2 Partner 3 Quantcast Partner 5 Partner 6
40% Overall Retargeting %
Retargeting
Prospecting
88%
1%
Partners 1, 3 and
Quantcast are running
full funnel targeting, with
Partner 3 retargeting
fairly heavily.
Partner 6 is running
prospecting only.
Partner 2 and Partner 5
are running retargeting
only.
11. 11
Prospecting Effectiveness
| Copyright 2014 Quantcast | Confidential
Quantcast and Partner 3
have the lowest
prospecting cost per
converter, while driving
the highest conversion
rates.
Despite running mostly
prospecting impressions,
Partner 1 is not effective
in prospecting
Prospecting impression volume Prospecting cost per converter
$70
$60
$50
$40
$30
$20
$10
$0
0.140%
0.120%
0.100%
0.080%
0.060%
0.040%
0.020%
0.000%
Prospecting conversion rate
12. 12
Retargeting Effectiveness
| Copyright 2014 Quantcast | Confidential
Partner 5 is the most
effective retargeting partner.
Quantcast has the lowest
cost per retargeted
converter.
Despite running high volume
of retargeting impressions,
Partner 2 is not retargeting
$3.50
$3.00
$2.50
$2.00
$1.50
$1.00
$0.50
$0.00 effectively.
2.00%
1.80%
1.60%
1.40%
1.20%
1.00%
0.80%
0.60%
0.40%
0.20%
0.00%
Retargeting conversion rate Retargeting impression volume Retargeting cost per converter
13. 13
Last Touch and Split-Funnel CPA (Low CPA is Good)
Average CPA Last Touch CPA Split Funnel CPA
$60
$50
$40
$30
$20
$10
*CPA calculated assuming all partners on the same CPM rate
| Copyright 2014 Quantcast | Confidential
Quantcast becomes the best
performing partner once their
Prospecting performance is
taken into account.
Partner 6, who is doing mostly
prospecting looks better once
their prospecting contribution is
credited with Split Funnel
Attribution, but still does not
match other partner’s
performances.
Results will change with
correct CPM Rates
$-
14. 14
Key Takeaways
Split funnel attribution makes this all possible
1. Know your funnel metrics - what is actually happening
2. Understand your funnel dynamics – what you want to happen
3. Set the right incentives to maximize your desired results – influence
the outcome
| Copyright 2014 Quantcast | Confidential
15. 15
Questions?
| Copyright 2014 Quantcast | Copyright 2014 Quantcas t | | C Coonnfifdideenntitaial l
16. 16
Thank you.
| Copyright 2014 Quantcast | Copyright 2014 Quantcas t | | C Coonnfifdideenntitaial l
16
Notes de l'éditeur
I am very excited to be here today and help illuminate what I believe is fundamentally new way of looking at attribution
What I will be sharing with you isn’t something unique just to quantcast
It is an open source solution that we are actively using and sharing with attribution platforms, adservers and other vendors
By openly discussing the methodologies and metrics around what we are calling Split funnel attribution
we can hopefully, with everyones help, evolve the current attribution standards for the betterment of our entire industry as a whole
But before we get started down that path
I do want to remind people who Quantcast is incase there may be a few folks that are wondering why we are leading a discussion about attribution
Quantcast is a digital advertising company specialized in audience measurement and real-time advertising.
We were an early pioneer in online audience measurement back in 2006 and we continue to be today.
We have insights on over 100 million web destinations and we are currently one of the top 5 largest processors of data in the world
This unique digital footprint gives us one of the most in-depth understandings of digital audiences across the web
and it is this understanding that has allowed us be an early pioneer in attribution as well
So hopefully that gives you a little background on why the data I am going to share with you today is worth listening to…
so lets jump into it…
Today I am going to give you a conceptual overview of split funnel attribution
Then dig a bit deeper into it via the consumers path to conversion
After that we’ll discuss evolution of measurement and the new metrics and insights it gives you
And at the end I’ll try to wrap it all up with a campaign example by the numbers to hopefully drive it all home.
today’s targeting tools have become significantly more precise.
In the last ten years, and really… the last 5 years,
online targeting, with the advent of big data and RTB, have created precision surgical instruments that have outpaced the outdated last touch models in use today.
To the point that it is now almost easier to manipulate and game these outdated models than it is to actually work within them.
The most widely used model today is still the basic last touch model.
The harsh reality is that last touch is outdated and very easily gamed.
All upper funnel activity is missed and partners on the plan “fight” to get last touch.
This ultimately creates the wrong incentive and a lose, lose, lose situation for all parties involved.
The ad targeting vendors, the marketers, and the consumers all lose out.
The consumer loses because they are over saturated with retargeting ads to the point of annoyance.
(We have all likely experienced a pair of shoes or other product following us around the internet at some point)
The marketer loses because their budgets are over allocated to those most likely to convert anyway.
The ad targeting vendors lose because they are forced to optimize to an inferior attribution game and significantly dulls their targeting toolset and potential.
By only rewarding the last ad it incentivizes everyone to focus on gaming rather than maximizing conversions as a team.
It is time to evolve our outdated attribution measurement.
Let’s take a closer look at how split funnel gives us new perspective on attribution.
This is how we split the funnel.
Now, I want to point out again that there is a difference between the first site visit and just any visit to your site.
From an attribution perspective the first site visit only counts for those consumers that actually convert.
If a prospecting partner brings a visitor to your site but they do not convert, it doesn’t count.
It’s an interesting metric to know, how many total site visitors a prospecting partner is bringing to your site for the first time,
but it only counts when that first time visitor also eventually converts.
If all we were interested in from prospecting
was only new visitors,
then there are plenty of click farms out there that will be happy to sell you clicks all day long, I am sure
but we know that doesn’t work.
The goal here is to only reward for reaching qualified prospects that visit for the first time AND convert. Both events are required to count
One of the most beneficial aspects of being able to distinguish between who contributed to a conversion from both the prospecting and retargeting phases is that now you’ve created a partnership between the two efforts.
Now each phase is rooting for the other to do their job.
The prospector brings a visitor to the site for the first time and if they don’t convert on that first visit
they actively root for the retargeting partners to bring that lead across the finish line so that they can reap the rewards as well.
Same goes for the retargeters.
Now they are yelling up at the prospectors saying “ bring me more qualified leads”.
You now have a holistic partnership where each leg of the race is rooting for the other.
Even if a targeting partner is full funnel targeting on both phases,
it removes the unnecessary competition between the the two legs of the race for everyone involved.
This is how you properly balance your funnel and create an inclusive partnership between the two distinct marketing tactics.
Implement your strategy by using measurement to set the right incentives through credit allocation to maximize your desired results.
This is where the true power of the split funnel comes into play,
this is where you gain even more control over the execution of your funnel mix.
Allocating your budget inline with how you want your dollars to be spent is one part of the equation,
but having a transparent way to set the right incentive to guide your targeting partners to align with your desired goals is just as important.
And this is where the concept of a split credit comes into play.
Let’s say your funnel metrics tell you that you should ideally have a 70/30 mix of prospecting to retargeting.
So you choose your partners and allocate your budgets accordingly.
How do you ensure that your targeting partners, especially those that might be full funnel targeting, are proactively carrying out your desired plan?
With split funnel it’s Easy,
you tell them from the beginning that 70% of the conversion credit will be given to the ad or ads that were responsible for getting converters to the site for the fist time
and 30% will be allocated to the ad or ads that got the converter over the finish line.
Whether you are using a last touch model, multi touch or regression, it works in every case.
It doesn’t matter if your mix is 50/50, 90/10 or 10/90 the split credit approach is openly transparent and obvious to everyone what you want their focus to be.
Simple and effective, it’s a Win, win win,
Okay, so that was a lot of information in a short amount of time.
Let’s take a look at some real numbers in action to help further illustrate and hopefully drive it all home.
One, Know your funnel metrics –
leverage the first site visit
and know what is actually happening on your campaign for each leg of the race
Two, Use those metrics to understand your ideal funnel dynamics–
This is what you want to happen in an ideal scenario
And three, Leverage the open transparency of split funnel
to set the right incentives through measurement and credit allocation
to maximize your desired results –
Basically, try to load the deck as much as you can in your favor
to influence the optimal outcome