SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 7
Download to read offline
Read~ng  Research Quarterly
                                                                                                                         Vol. 35, N o . 2
                                                                                                                  Aprili3lay,June 2000
                                                                                               El999 International Readlng Association
                                                                                                                         (pp.276282)




     What will be the influences of media on literacy 

                 in the next millennium? 

                                           fiction and other entertaining books       limited to what he or she could ex-
                                           being regarded as frivolous and            pect from that library facility and with
                                           highly discouraged. Surrounded by          a few exceptions through interlibrary
       Susan B. Neuman                     tomes of great works. children were        loan, could use only the resources
      Temple Lhrvcrsrty, Phrladelphra, 
   to adopt the appropriate behavior          contained within its four walls.
           Pennsylvunru, USA 
             for reading in the library. They were             In the future. that same young
                                           to sit quietly, read silently, and never   reader entering public libraries in the

?=      arly supporters presented a
        halcyon picture of the public
        library at the turn of the last
                                           speak above a whisper.
                                                  As we consider literacy for the
                                           new millennium. what might the
                                                                                      U.S. will expect and demand global
                                                                                      resources. immediately and directly.
                                                                                      The library of the future will become
century (Garrison. 1979: Van House.        new philanthropists of the library en-     increasingly transformed from a fi-
1972). Building what amounted to           vision for the future? How might           nite space with finite resources to a
the modern library system, philan-         technology change the ways in              finite space with infinite resources.
thropist Andrew Carnegie sought no         which children use resources, ex-          But children will no longer be sitting
less than a social and cultural trans-     change ideas with others, and en-          quietly at their tables turning the
formation in society, hoping to uplift     gage in learning in such public            pages of a book. The library will
and enlighten the literary tastes of       spaces as the library? What will           look different, and children will be-
the masses, support education for          recreational and functional reading        have differently.
the underprivileged, and provide a         look like in the future?                          The library of the future will be
natural extension of free public edu-                                                 characterized by open shelves, a
cation for all (Van Slyck, 1995).          The modern library in the                  term once used to reflect free access.
Carnegie's concept was to build a li-      21st century                               Kow, however, it is used to describe
brary characterized by free access,              Even a decade ago, someone           the limited collection of books in the
services for children, separate chil-      entering a public library in the U.S.      library and the more limited atten-
dren's rooms. and cooperation with         could expect to find a scene highly        tion to circulation figures as indica-
local schools. Tens of thousands of        reminiscent of Carnegie's original vi-     tors of library activity. Instead, there
young readers benefited from his           sion. One could find books, maga-          will be computer terminals every-
largesse, borrowing books for the          zines, newspapers, and some                where, with keypads designed to
first time free of charge.                 educationally oriented audiovisual         match the age-appropriate hand size
        Yet Carnegie's great libraries     materials. The public library's collec-    of children of different ages. Hits on
exacted their own kind of payment.         tion would reflect the interests of the    various Web pages are now the
not in cash but in demeanor. Early         community, and the size of the col-        norm for determining amount and
libraries were collections of good         lection would be largely determined        type of library activity in the branch.
books, and librarians were their           by the size of the building. The most             Public libraries of the future
guardians. Activity at the library in-     desired books could be unavailable         will not merely support young pa-
volved reading what librarians             for weeks, having been recently            trons; they will cater to them. Due to
thought children should read, with         checked out. The young library user,       its massive resource capacity, the li-
brary will attract many nontraditional           If we ask our current philan-              the future of media and its effects on
young users. But not unlike the past      thropists what their vision of the                literacy is tricky business. But I'll
century, there will be continuing de-     public library might be, they proba-              step into my time machine, crank
bate about how these resources are        bly would say to transform society                the engine a few times, and give it a
used. Many will decry the young           by providing greater access and thus              try nonetheless.
children's interest in demanding the      ensure a more knowledgeable public                       One thing that I think will
very lowest level of reading material     than ever before. And perhaps chil-               change is the definition of literacy it-
in quality and taste. However, there      dren of the 21st century will be                  self, which historically has referred
will be something for everyone-           more sophisticated consumers of in-               to at least a rudimentary ability to
some typically advantaged children        formation and entertainment than                  decode, comprehend, and produce
will be using resources to their great-   ever before. But the ambiance of the              written language. even by such limit-
est capacity, while others will find      dark public library with patrons qui-             ed means as a signature. When the
their thrills in sexual kick-boxing       etly turning the pages of their books             world was a much simpler place.
and oddball chat rooms.                   will be forever changed.                          these definitions seemed adequate.
       The demeanor among children                                                          Language served as the primary
in the library will change from the       REFERENCES                                        medium through which people con-
pensive and the quiet to the social           GARRISON, D. (1979). Apostles of culture:     structed systematic representations of
                                          The public librarian and American society 1876-   their worlds, and written documents
playground, with large groups of           1920. New York: Free Press.
children waiting to get on, or in-            VAN HOUSE, W. (1972). Public library user
                                                                                            served as the basis for the structure
volved in, the Internet. Navigating       fees. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.              and machinery of society: laws, his-
for resources and sites will be easier
                                              VAN SLYCK, A. (1995). Free to all. Chicago:   tory, records. and so on. While liter-
                                          University of Chicago Press.
with multiple interfaces designed                                                           acy in terms of language is still
around the fourth-grade level with                                                          prerequisite to active participation in
                                                                                            much of modern life, it is now part
plenty of pictures to convey ideas
                                                                                            of what Wertsch (1991) has called a
along with the print. Children will
                                                                                            "tool kit" of mediational means (p.
read, but in brief bursts as they
                                                                                            93). While language is still no doubt
move from picture to picture. Books
                                                                                            the "tool of tools" (Cole. 1996. p.
will rarely be checked out; instead.
children will favor CDs and videos.               Peter Smagorinsky                         log), other communicative and me-
                                                                                            diational means are being developed
       The librarian of this coming            Universip o f Georgia. Athens, U S A



                                          w
                                                                                            that play a strong role in fin de siBcle
century will no longer be a biblio-
                                                                                            literacy and presumably will increas-
phile but a bit of a hacker and tech-                 riting on the future of me-
                                                                                            ingly help one to live the good life
nician, since equipment is always in                  dia and literacy brings to
                                                                                            in the new millennium.
need of repair. Rather than finding                   mind science fiction
                                                                                                   Before looking too far ahead. I
books for patrons or answering ref-       movies from the 1950s, with flying                would like to review an argument I
erence questions, now his or her ac-      saucers swinging across the screen                made a few years ago (Smagorinsky.
tivity will be more of an online          on not-so-transparent strings, and                1995). At that time I had spent a lot
personal help service, although           aliens with names like Zoltan wear-               of time visiting classes across the
painful back ailments from leaning        ing aluminum foil space suits and                 curriculum in a large public high
over people's shoulders may pre-          speaking very formal English. That                school and had tried to understand
vent long interactions. KO longer is      is. no matter what I say here, it is              how students made meaning as they
there time to get to know the pa-         bound to look a little silly before               moved from class to class, discipline
trons' names, or even their faces for     long because it's hard to say how                 to discipline. What I found raised
that matter, since most are always        media and technology will develop                 questions about the notion that writ-
looking forward at a screen. Despite      in the next few decades. When I was               ing across the curriculum is the most
all efforts, he or she will not filter    a kid, media referred to those large              worthwhile goal for schooling, given
the content of what children are          reel-to-reel projectors that always               that in many disciplines students
reading; in fact in the US, it won't      seemed to eat our science class                   produced highly meaningful texts
be allowed since challenged by the        films. Even 5 years ago, few people               consistent with disciplinary values
First Amendment to the U.S.               had even heard of the World Wide                  and conventions, yet through media
Constitution. Computer clubs have         Web, now a fixture in any home                    other than language. Students in an
replaced story hours.                     with a computer. And so forecasting               Equine Management and Production



What will be the influences of media on literacv in the next millennium?                                                       277
class, for instance. needed to learn a         ate vehicle for mediating students'
wide range of knowledge and skills             engagement with ideas.
for breeding and maintaining horses.                  As new media develop. I think
The culminating project for the se-            they will increasingly afford new sys-                        Patricia    E. Enciso
mester was to synthesize all of their          tems of representation. Recall that                                             Columbus, L1S/4
                                                                                                       O h i o State ITnrversry,
knowledge of horses in the design              many of the original educational
of a ranch that they might conceiv-
ably own and operate at a profit.
They combined multidisciplinary
knowledge in order to design their
ranches: geometry for designing an-
                                               programs for computers looked very
                                               similar to what already existed in
                                               workbooks; that is, the potential of
                                               computers was poorly exploited be-
                                               cause they were viewed as simply a
                                                                                                     T       he theories and practices of lit-
                                                                                                             erary interpretation are as old
                                                                                                             as Talmudic studies and as
                                                                                                     new as poststructuralist linguistics and
                                                                                                     postmodern identity politics. Yet
gles, mathematics for developing               different means for providing the                     across the centuries. studies of literary
feed mixes in the right proportion,            same texts. Now. sofmare designers                    interpretation have addressed the
physics to know how to situate                 work with animation, sound, interac-                  same intersections of reader, text, and
buildings for drainage, weather to             tion, voice activation. image making,                 context through questions that in-
know how to build for local condi-             and who-knows-what-awaits in or-                      clude these: Who are readers? What
tions (e.g.. one-story structures if tor-      der to provide computer users with                    should they read? What are the cir-
nadoes are a threat), economics for            useful and entertaining tools.                        cumstances of their reading? How?
deciding what crops to grow for                       If we assume that literacy serves              Why? Who benefits from these views
feed, and much more, including spe-            to construct, preserve, and document                  of reader, text, and context?
cific knowledge of how to accom-               frameworks for social practice-and                            Old and new approaches to lit-
modate the needs of particular                 to enable communication within                        erary education have been developed
breeds of horses.                              those frameworks-then it is conceiv-                  and critiqued in terms of these ques-
       The project took over a month           able that computers and software will                 tions and in relation to the production
to conlplete and involved a long-              provide tools for a different kind of                 of new literary forms. more fully artic-
term process of composition, includ-            literacy. In that sense, then, school                ulated theories of readerhext transac-
 ing planning, drafting, revising, and          production may change. Instead of                    tions. reconfigurations of philosophies
 the production of the final product            writing a research paper. for instance.              of the self, and assertions of political
 that the students regarded quite               students can create a multimedia pre-                power focused on containing particu-
 seriously. Work was conducted col-             sentation that includes film footage.                lar texts and relationships to texts. In
 laboratively, with students talking            scanned images, music, voice-overs,                  the coming century. I imagine these
 frequently with one another and                and so on. In my view, the key ques-                  influences will continue to shape the
 their teacher about their designs. In
                                                tion should be. in what ways does                     scholarship and teaching of literary
 short. the production of the horse
                                                the process of composition both lead                  interpretation. In addition, reading
 ranch designs included all of the as-
                                                to new learning and provide a repre-                  and literary education will continue to
 pects of writing that are usually the
                                                sentation of that learning that follows              wrestle with many of the same ques-
 basis for viewing writing as an es-
                                                appropriate cultural conventions? The                tions and problems that others have
 sential tool. The difference was that
                                                developnlent of new technologies                      attempted to resolve over the past
 words were only used as labels.
                                                and media, while changing the tools                   decades. I want to look to the past for
 with the spatial configuration of im-
                                                and forms through which students                      a moment. to describe one prescrip-
 ages being the primary vehicle for
                                                compose, should not change that                       tion for reading education that illumi-
 constructing and representing mean-
                                                fundamental question.                                 nates many of the issues we will face
 ingful ideas.
        From this class and many oth-                                                                 in the next millennium.
                                               REFERENCES                                                    On the cusp of the 20th centu-
 ers, I concluded that the concern of              COLE, M. (1996). Cu/iuralpsychology: A once
 educators ought to be with conzpos-           and future discipline. Cambr~dge,MA: Harvard
                                                                                                      ry, M.E. Burt. a veteran teacher, librar-
  ing across the c u t ~ c u l u m
                                 rather than   Un~versity Press.                                      ian. and member of the Chicago
 writing across the curriculum, given              SMAGORINSKY, P. (1995). Constructing               Board of Education, wrote a com-
                                               meaning In the disciplines: Reconceptualizing writ-
 that writing does not have exclusive          ing across the curr~culum composing across the
                                                                         as
                                                                                                      pelling, no-nonsense treatise on the
  properties for enabling people to            curr~culum. American Journal of Education, 103,        form and content of children's literary
  construct or represent meaning.              160-1 84.                                               educations. Her compact book. ~0111-
                                                   WERTSCH, J.V. (1991). Voices of the mind: A
  Furthermore, in some disciplines                                                                     plete with an annotated bibliography.
                                               soc~ocultural approach to mediated action.
 writing is not the culturally appropri-       Cambridge, MA: Haward University Press.                was entitled Litemly L a n d m a h ~ f o r



 278                                                        READING RESEARCH QUARTERLY ApriVMay/June 2000 35/2
Young People (1899). Burt outlined         She would have found a kindred spir-         ple are represented and interrelated? I
the selections of literature that should    it, no doubt, in E.D. Hirsch had they        am hopeful that today's multistoried,
be available to and read by all chil-       been contemporaries at the turn of           multimedia children and adults will
dren, what they should and should           the 20th century. She might also have        not be content with a singular line of
not attend to as they read ("He will        found much in common with litera-            literary landmarks that convey "a mas-
read with better expression if his          ture-based reading educators who en-         terpiece of creative goodness" (p. 1j).
mind is searching after the largest         courage deep and wide reading, as            That line, based almost exclusively on
thought in the piece than he will if he     James Britton proposed in the mid-           European male values, language, and
is continually nagged at concerning         1960s. Indeed, in the latter part of her     histories, thins and weakens rapidly,
the definitions of words") (p. 29), and     book, she presents a strong argument         leaving many children wondering
what adults should know before they         for the centrality of literature across      where they fit in to the process of
ventured their opinions on children's       the curriculum, particularly in science      making meaning.
reading ("It always excites my indig-       and social studies education. She cer-               If, at the turn of the last century,
nation and contempt to hear 'scholars'      tainly would have supported family           literary study and interpretation had
putting themselves on haughty               literacy research and practices, partic-     as its purpose the coherent mapping
pedestals of classicalism, speak dis-       ularly those located within middle           of historical relationships associated
paragingly of giving the greatest           class and economically depressed             with the writer's art, then, at the be-
works to laboring men or their              neighborhoods, that bring children           ginning of the next century the chal-
children") (p. 23).                         and adults together around the best          lenges for researchers, teachers, and
       Burt had no patience with            books available.                             students may be to comprehend the
scholars or publishers who suggested               Burt's perspectives on literature     incoherences in stories, the unstated
that children's texts should be limited     selection and literary interpretation        histories, the long-denied and mis-
in literary style or content. She argued    placed high value on universal access        placed representations within literary
that children needed the best of liter-     to ideas, art, and goodness. In her          forms. Unlike Burt, who advised
ary art and ideas if they were to gain      day. these views would have been ac-         teachers to guide children toward "the
a sense of the continuous chain of          ceptable to most teachers, librarians,       big ideas" within literature. future
events and ideas that have formed           politicians, and labor organizers (but       teachers and researchers will need to
modern thought. Her comprehensive           not scholars!). The United States was        consider what could possibly be con-
plan for literary studies included bibli-   seeking a political compass at the           strued as a shared idea. "Big ideas" or
cal stories and Arthurian legends for       turn of the century and found much           themes, the staple of literary interpre-
young children, Fenelon's Lives o the
                                   f        to support its largely immigrant popu-       tation, are intentionally obscured by
Philosophers and Chaucer's Griselda         lation in the form of socialist and pro-     today's artists and authors working
for upper elementar).-aged children,        gressive politics, the equity politics       across media-based and book-like art-
and a study of Dante's poetry and           reflected in Burt's vision of literary ed-   forms (see, for example, Monster,
Marlowe's Fazrst for adolescents. As is     ucation. Her writing was also a reac-        1999. by Walter Dean Myers).
apparent from her recommended               tion against the modernist vision of         Students may be far ahead of teachers
reading list, she saw no reason to          social change that imposed catego-           and researchers in recognizing that
separate adult and children's reading:      rization, efficiency, and reductionism       themes are precisely what limits
"Any book is not good enough for            on school curricula. particularly read-      meaning: the artform and the artist
the youngest child in the primary           ing education.                               are questioning. not sustaining, the
grade unless it would be a good book               I wonder, now, how Burt's per-        reader's assumption of an answer.
for the teacher or parent." She argued      spectives on literature selections and               The future of literary interpreta-
that, in the company of great books         interpretations might persist while the      tion promises to be an exciting
and avid adult readers. children            form and substance might be                  scramble through texts and images.
would soon discover and delight in          changed in the 21st century. How             Still. the key question for future liter-
the interrelatedness of literary struc-     would she, in these postmodern and           ary and reading educators, in the
tures, themes, and historic events.         postcolonial times, organize histories       United States and other emerging
       Many advocates of Western            that cannot be made commensurable            den~ocracies, not so much what
                                                                                                           is
classical literature might wholeheart-      as a continuous chain? And what cri-         new literary forms and interpretations
edly agree with Burt that a chain of        teria would she use to select from the       might be possible, but whether teach-
events can and should be gleaned            extensive body of literary art forms         ers will have authority within the po-
from the guided selection and inter-        and ideas so that the exemplary voic-        litical struggles over the form and
pretation of well-wrought literary art.     es and visions of all the world's peo-       substance of reading education, to



What will be the influences of media on literacy in the next millennium?                                                        279
determine how any text will be se-                              textbooks, and government docu-            variety of specific search constraints
lected and interpreted. The future of                           ments will sit out there on the            (Boolean, proximity. case matching.
research and teaching regarding liter-                          Internet in a full-text, searchable for-    and more). A search for the phrase
asy education will be played out                                mat that elin~inates need for cellu-
                                                                                      the                   emef-gentliteracy. for example.
against a landscape of definitions, val-                        loid archives on each and evesy            n,ould result in the almost instanta-
ues. and civil rights. And here we can                          college campus. There is already a         neous identification of every occur-
return to Burt's vision. Should we.                             wide range of virtual librasy services     rence of the phrase in all volun~es,
like Burt, demand the most compre-                              including academic periodical collec-      issues, and articles. To obtain the
hensive and remarkable exemplars of                             tions such as First Search and EBSCO.      same result from a Web site, the user
the world's narratives and literasy                             which claim several thousand period-       would have to don,nload the entire
forms-based in local and global                                 icals online and fully searchable. The     database from the site, which would
texts, music, film. CD-KOMs, and oth-                           logical extension is a complete librasy    take hours or days. The sophisticated
er media-for all of our children? Or                            accessible by Internet. There is, how-     searching I have just described can-
a-ill inequitable funding continue to                                                           y
                                                                ever, an alternative: m e lib?-a cozild    not be conducted by remote because
place magnificent libraries in some                             exist inside yozi r PC                     the bandwidth of the Internet limits
schools for a few children, while a                                    It's been exactly 20 years since    the speed at which information can
majority of children pick through last                          I bought my first home computer.           be exchanged. In the a1ternatix.e it is
centuT's worn-out paperbacks?                                   an Apple 11+ with a Halloween              possible to tag issues or articles-if
Should we, like Burt, fear loss of liter-                       screen monitor, two external 5.25-         each article is its own file-with key
acy among fourth graders and then                               inch floppy disk drives. 64k of =!I.       a~ords.   Issues or articles tagged for
focus attention on "the theosy that                             and a daisy~vheelline printer that         the kelword can then be down-
reading should be v e v simple and                              sounded like a muffled machine             loaded for printing or further inspec-
monosyllabic" (p. 28). Or should n,e.                           gun. Hard drives and the Internet          tion. Current online services operate
like Burt, argue long and loud for                              were still in the future. The storage      in this fashion. In a few years band-
"spirited discussions," that "leave the                         capacity of my Apple 11+ was 128           width may be expanded to the point
question open?" (p. 49). The right to                           kilobytes, about one eighth of a           where full-text, indexed searches as I
interpret is always contested. I inlag-                         megabyte. In 1987 I bought a 286           have described here will be possible
ine researchers and teachers becom-                             PC with a 20-megaby-te hard drive.         from a Web site.
ing more infornled and more vocal in                            which represented a 15.000% in-                   Given the choice. I would
the effort to determine both the rights                         crease in storage capacity over the        much rather access information from
to, and the contests over. images                               old Apple II+. The PC on which I           n ~ y ard drive than from the Internet.
                                                                                                                h
and ideas.                                                      work now has a 6.5-gigaby-te DVD           It's a lot faster. and I don't have to
                                                                (digital video disk) drive and a 9-gi-     xvorT about connect//disconnect
REFERENCES                                                      gabyte (9,000 megabytes) hard dri-         dilemmas. Imagine what it would be
   BURT, M.E. (1899). Literarylandmarks for                     ve, a 77.500%)increase over the            like to do word processing from a
young people. New York: Houghton Mifflin.
   MYERS. W.D. (1999). Monster. New York:                       storage capacity of my old PC. To          Web site instead of having the pro-
Har~erCollins.                                                  give this some everyday perspective,       gram inside your own computer!
                                                                a single DVD disk could hold the                  If the internal storage capability
                                                                sum total of all publications of the       and processing speeds of PCs contin-
                                                                International Reading Association,         ue at their current pace. in 10 years
                                                                the National Keading Conference.           the hard drives and peripheral stor-
                                                                and the College Keading                    age devices of PCs will be able to
                                                                Association, all volumes of all jour-      hold the complete archives of a col-
                                                                nals, books. monographs, and               lege librasy as easily as they hold
            R. Scott Baldwin                                    newsletters ever published in their        Microsoft Word. Of course, the speed
       ,-ii,lrm St(1tL' CG//L'$c,, -  l L 7 1 1 l ~ ~ ' 7 ,   combined histories, And. all of these      and accessibility of the Internet will
                    C0101~L7d0,         LTS,4                   publications could be hypertext            continue to advance at its own warp
                                                                linked and fully searchable in a           speed: the Internet may be the ulti-


M          ost people seem to think
           that the university librav
           of the fi~turewill be virtual
and Web based. In this scenario tens
of thousands of digitized periodicals.
                                                                few seconds.
                                                                      A DVD database with a stan-
                                                                dard search engine (e.g..Adobe
                                                                Acrobat) could be searched in sec-
                                                                onds for any word or phrase under a
                                                                                                           mate solution when it comes to
                                                                                                           transacting business and getting cur-
                                                                                                           rent information fast. However, my
                                                                                                           prediction is that when it comes to
                                                                                                           archiving professional knowledge,



280                                                                      READLNG RESEARCH QUARTERLY ApriVMay/June 2000 35/2
the librasy of the fi~ture
                         will end up                ,I.fonoli?zgz~al-> :Vlztltilingzral.   (MTL', for example) are a mix of im-
inside your computer and not on              No one language can fully represent           age. talk. Web referencing, call-in.
somebody's Web site.                         the range of information, knon.1-             visual clips, music. and so on-a
                                             edge, and perspectives possible. As           pastiche of semiotic systems at the
                                             the pressures grow to know and un-            s e r i c e of a singular message.
                                             derstand beyond one's national, cul-                    Te.~tzlal-> Intetle.~tzral.
                                             tural, and linguistic borders. and            Because no single text, or informa-
                                             access to other linguistic knowledges         tion source, can possibly contain all
                                             and understandings becomes easier             there is to know about a topic, idea.
                                             through technological tools, the limi-        person, or event, it is increasingly
     Douglas K.Hartman                       tations of being literate in one lan-         important that students know how to
                                             guage (which is true for most in the          select. connect, and organize infor-
                                             1I.S.) will move our thinking toward          mation from a large number of tex-
           y approach to thinking            reading in-and writing in-more                tual sources across extended periods
           about how media will in-          than one language. The monotonous             of time. Most of the materials in the
             uence literacy in the new       sound of one language will give way           20th centusy have been designed to
millennium is much like futurists do         to the stereophonic sensibilities of a        outline master narratives or para-
in corporate America: They look at           larger n,orld with which to c o n ~ n ~ u -   digms in a single text for students to
present patterns, and based on these         nicate. Imagine most LT.S.   elementan        conlprehend and conlpose. Reading
patterns. project scenarios for what         students moving toward reading and            and writing in the next millennium
could exist tomorron7.These scenar-          writing fluency in two or more lan-           will increasingly deinand the relating
ios are not predictions, but stories         guages. with the help of electronic           and rerelating of information across
that present alternative i~xages of          speech and print coaches that can             multiple texts and learning situa-
possible tomorrows. I see a number           assist with translation and mediation         tions. It will be a time where the
of patterns that suggest scenarios in        among the languages.                          reading of one text leads to another
three areas: conceptions, materials.                                                       and another, back and forth across
and methods of literacy.                     Materials for literacy                        histosy and across language and cul-
                                                   The materials to be used in lit-        tures: where readers are challenged
Conceptions of literacy                      erate activities are also being re-           and surprised often by unexpected,
      What constitutes literacy is al-       shaped by the influence of media.             serendipitous linking discoveries in
ready being reshaped by the influ-           The shape of these nlaterial move-            their reading: where readers continu-
ence of media. The movement of               ments are from:                               ally revise their understandings and
these changing conceptions is from:                 Linguistic -> Selniotic. In this       responses to previous texts: where
      Literacjl-> Litemcies. For             centun we have largely valued and             readers exploit the rich literary and
most of this millennium a singular           used linguistic texts-that is. fixed          artistic possibilities kvithin, across.
conception of literacy has prevailed:        print on a bounded paper page-for             and beyond texts: and where readers
the production and reception of              communicating, learning, and                  spend their days waist high in works
meaning through print. But a more            recording information in school.              that can be traversed in one direc-
pluralistic conception is taking             work. and community. We are wit-              tion, and then in another and still
shape. It includes print-based,              nessing a dramatic shift to the use of        another.
meaning-making practices. but much           other text types-to those known as                     Hzlndled -> Distrihzited. In
more. The relative ease by which             semiotic texts. These new text types          our professional lifetime we've seen
someone can represent thoughts,              are both paper and digital in form.           the commercial materials used for in-
knonings. and meanings through               requiring a reader to read not only           stn~ction     bundled together in kits or
iconography. movement, sound. and            print, but images. icons. and sounds;         packages. Beginning with the Dick
so on m-ill make other forms of pro-         they are a virtual mix of various sign        & Jane readers around midcentuq-,
duction and reception just as valued         systems on the same page or screen            this bundling of teacher edition, stu-
as print has been for so long. This          that must be read in relation to one          dent edition, big flip charts. trade
open, inclusive set of literacies nil1       another. Print. film. music. art, nlove-      books. cassette tapes, flash cards,
require neu- languages for talking           ment, photographs, and other modes            tests. and so on has I>ecome the
about the sense-making practices             of representation will be counted as          norm. The hallmark of this deliven
n-ithin a particular literacy. as n.ell as   text that can be read and written.            approach is that you can have all
across the various literacies.               The digital semiotic texts of today           necessan materials located in one



What will be the influences of media on literacy in the next millennium?                                                       281
place for easy access and use. The        shaped as well. The shape of these       ist. therapist, director, producer, me-
downside has been the one-size-fits-      pedagogical movements are from:          dia resource specialist, salesperson,
all conception it usually propagates.            Assignments -> Workshops          and engineer, to name a few. The
       But the move is toward a more      -> Projects. The pressures of media      learning communiv formed within
distributed means of locating the         are already extending literate activiv   these classroon~s   reaches far beyond
materials. Some conlmercial publish-      beyond assignments and workshops         its walls and uses the resources with-
ers are already using their Web sites     to the use of comprehending and          in them more imaginatively.
as an integral part of the material       composing in the context of project             Intramediation -> Transmed-
package, with certain parts of the        work. Project work involves students     iation. The prevailing literacy meth-
bundle available only from or             investigating sustainable topics and     ods of the last millennium operated
through remote access to these sites.     ideas in considerable depth, often       in an intramediato~    fashion-they
Teachers can get background infor-        for a sizable part of the school day     worked back and forth within one
mation and video footage of the au-       and year. The literacy instruction fo-   medium (print). from reading to writ-
thor not available in the printed form    cuses on helping students locate and     ing and back again. With expanded
of the teachers' edition; students can    use textual resources to reconstruct     conceptions of literacy and the media
locate a mountain of story-related        their environment, knowledge, and        tools to represent meaning in other
material when and if they want or         social relations. Furthermore, stu-      modes, a new set of literacy methods
need it: and there are additional skill   dents explore complex and impor-         n,ill be needed to operate in a trans-
and strategy practice opportunities       tant ideas and systems through           mediatory fashion-working back
that dovetail into the minilessons        project work, using and reusing a        and forth across media, from print to
yo~l've already provided. And imag-       broad range of literacy tools and        video to sculpture to iconic notations
ine a Web-based smart teachers' edi-      modes to research, report, and re-       to music and so on. Imagine class-
tion, where teachers can tailor-fit the   spond to what they are learning. As      rooms everywhere that possess the
distributed materials to the unique       such, the literacy instruction is em-    tools and know-how to transform a
features of students in their class-      bedded in classrooms that are part       book into a film-from writing the
room. The hallmark of distributed         museum, publishing house, think          script, acting the parts, choreograph-
material usage will be its customiz-      tank, writers' workshop, artists' stu-   ing the moves, shooting the footage.
ing power.                                dio, theater, drafting room, computer    editing the film, dubbing the music
                                          lab, library, bookstore, gallery,        and sound effects, advertising the
Methods in literacy                       recording studio, and more. As a re-     production on a Web site-and then
      Finally, the methods for teach-     sult, the teacher's role becomes that    use the film as the basis for writing a
ing or using literacy are being re-       of curator, impresario, editor, futur-   sequel to the book.




282                                                READING RESEARCH QUARTERLY April/May/June 2000 35/2

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Handout 1: Inovation Generation Broadband Policy Summit
Handout 1:  Inovation Generation Broadband Policy SummitHandout 1:  Inovation Generation Broadband Policy Summit
Handout 1: Inovation Generation Broadband Policy SummitDouglas K. Hartman
 
IRA-West Research Poster Session--Handout, Phoenix, AZ
IRA-West Research Poster Session--Handout, Phoenix, AZIRA-West Research Poster Session--Handout, Phoenix, AZ
IRA-West Research Poster Session--Handout, Phoenix, AZDouglas K. Hartman
 
Webinar - Mann Arts & Science Magnet Middle School - 5-31-11 - Handout
Webinar - Mann Arts & Science Magnet Middle School - 5-31-11 - HandoutWebinar - Mann Arts & Science Magnet Middle School - 5-31-11 - Handout
Webinar - Mann Arts & Science Magnet Middle School - 5-31-11 - HandoutDouglas K. Hartman
 
Hartman 2004 Deconstructing the Reader
Hartman 2004 Deconstructing the ReaderHartman 2004 Deconstructing the Reader
Hartman 2004 Deconstructing the ReaderDouglas K. Hartman
 
Hartman1995 Eight Readers Reading
Hartman1995 Eight Readers ReadingHartman1995 Eight Readers Reading
Hartman1995 Eight Readers ReadingDouglas K. Hartman
 
From Print to Pixels: The Evolution of Cognitive Conceptions of Reading Comp...
From Print to Pixels:  The Evolution of Cognitive Conceptions of Reading Comp...From Print to Pixels:  The Evolution of Cognitive Conceptions of Reading Comp...
From Print to Pixels: The Evolution of Cognitive Conceptions of Reading Comp...Douglas K. Hartman
 
Hartman1996 inquiry Discussions Multiple Textss
Hartman1996 inquiry Discussions Multiple TextssHartman1996 inquiry Discussions Multiple Textss
Hartman1996 inquiry Discussions Multiple TextssDouglas K. Hartman
 
Monaghan Hartman (2010) Handout
Monaghan Hartman (2010) HandoutMonaghan Hartman (2010) Handout
Monaghan Hartman (2010) HandoutDouglas K. Hartman
 
Monaghan Hartman 2011 Integrating the Elementary Language Arts: A History
Monaghan Hartman 2011 Integrating the Elementary Language Arts: A HistoryMonaghan Hartman 2011 Integrating the Elementary Language Arts: A History
Monaghan Hartman 2011 Integrating the Elementary Language Arts: A HistoryDouglas K. Hartman
 
Using iPad & iPhone Apps for Learning with Literacy
Using iPad & iPhone Apps for Learning with LiteracyUsing iPad & iPhone Apps for Learning with Literacy
Using iPad & iPhone Apps for Learning with LiteracyDouglas K. Hartman
 
Stahl Hartman 2011 Historical Research
Stahl Hartman 2011 Historical ResearchStahl Hartman 2011 Historical Research
Stahl Hartman 2011 Historical ResearchDouglas K. Hartman
 
Reading at a Millions Crossroads
Reading at a Millions CrossroadsReading at a Millions Crossroads
Reading at a Millions CrossroadsDouglas K. Hartman
 
Bean zigmond Hartman-1994-Adapted Use of Social Studies Textbooks
Bean zigmond Hartman-1994-Adapted Use of Social Studies TextbooksBean zigmond Hartman-1994-Adapted Use of Social Studies Textbooks
Bean zigmond Hartman-1994-Adapted Use of Social Studies TextbooksDouglas K. Hartman
 
Monaghan Hartman (2010) Integrating the Elementary Language Arts
Monaghan Hartman (2010) Integrating the Elementary Language ArtsMonaghan Hartman (2010) Integrating the Elementary Language Arts
Monaghan Hartman (2010) Integrating the Elementary Language ArtsDouglas K. Hartman
 
Hartman Davis 2008 Edmund Burkey Huey
Hartman Davis 2008 Edmund Burkey HueyHartman Davis 2008 Edmund Burkey Huey
Hartman Davis 2008 Edmund Burkey HueyDouglas K. Hartman
 
Vocabulary Slides - Selecting & Teaching
Vocabulary Slides - Selecting & TeachingVocabulary Slides - Selecting & Teaching
Vocabulary Slides - Selecting & TeachingDouglas K. Hartman
 

Viewers also liked (17)

Handout 1: Inovation Generation Broadband Policy Summit
Handout 1:  Inovation Generation Broadband Policy SummitHandout 1:  Inovation Generation Broadband Policy Summit
Handout 1: Inovation Generation Broadband Policy Summit
 
IRA-West Research Poster Session--Handout, Phoenix, AZ
IRA-West Research Poster Session--Handout, Phoenix, AZIRA-West Research Poster Session--Handout, Phoenix, AZ
IRA-West Research Poster Session--Handout, Phoenix, AZ
 
Webinar - Mann Arts & Science Magnet Middle School - 5-31-11 - Handout
Webinar - Mann Arts & Science Magnet Middle School - 5-31-11 - HandoutWebinar - Mann Arts & Science Magnet Middle School - 5-31-11 - Handout
Webinar - Mann Arts & Science Magnet Middle School - 5-31-11 - Handout
 
Website links handout
Website links handoutWebsite links handout
Website links handout
 
Hartman 2004 Deconstructing the Reader
Hartman 2004 Deconstructing the ReaderHartman 2004 Deconstructing the Reader
Hartman 2004 Deconstructing the Reader
 
Hartman1995 Eight Readers Reading
Hartman1995 Eight Readers ReadingHartman1995 Eight Readers Reading
Hartman1995 Eight Readers Reading
 
From Print to Pixels: The Evolution of Cognitive Conceptions of Reading Comp...
From Print to Pixels:  The Evolution of Cognitive Conceptions of Reading Comp...From Print to Pixels:  The Evolution of Cognitive Conceptions of Reading Comp...
From Print to Pixels: The Evolution of Cognitive Conceptions of Reading Comp...
 
Hartman1996 inquiry Discussions Multiple Textss
Hartman1996 inquiry Discussions Multiple TextssHartman1996 inquiry Discussions Multiple Textss
Hartman1996 inquiry Discussions Multiple Textss
 
Monaghan Hartman (2010) Handout
Monaghan Hartman (2010) HandoutMonaghan Hartman (2010) Handout
Monaghan Hartman (2010) Handout
 
Monaghan Hartman 2011 Integrating the Elementary Language Arts: A History
Monaghan Hartman 2011 Integrating the Elementary Language Arts: A HistoryMonaghan Hartman 2011 Integrating the Elementary Language Arts: A History
Monaghan Hartman 2011 Integrating the Elementary Language Arts: A History
 
Using iPad & iPhone Apps for Learning with Literacy
Using iPad & iPhone Apps for Learning with LiteracyUsing iPad & iPhone Apps for Learning with Literacy
Using iPad & iPhone Apps for Learning with Literacy
 
Stahl Hartman 2011 Historical Research
Stahl Hartman 2011 Historical ResearchStahl Hartman 2011 Historical Research
Stahl Hartman 2011 Historical Research
 
Reading at a Millions Crossroads
Reading at a Millions CrossroadsReading at a Millions Crossroads
Reading at a Millions Crossroads
 
Bean zigmond Hartman-1994-Adapted Use of Social Studies Textbooks
Bean zigmond Hartman-1994-Adapted Use of Social Studies TextbooksBean zigmond Hartman-1994-Adapted Use of Social Studies Textbooks
Bean zigmond Hartman-1994-Adapted Use of Social Studies Textbooks
 
Monaghan Hartman (2010) Integrating the Elementary Language Arts
Monaghan Hartman (2010) Integrating the Elementary Language ArtsMonaghan Hartman (2010) Integrating the Elementary Language Arts
Monaghan Hartman (2010) Integrating the Elementary Language Arts
 
Hartman Davis 2008 Edmund Burkey Huey
Hartman Davis 2008 Edmund Burkey HueyHartman Davis 2008 Edmund Burkey Huey
Hartman Davis 2008 Edmund Burkey Huey
 
Vocabulary Slides - Selecting & Teaching
Vocabulary Slides - Selecting & TeachingVocabulary Slides - Selecting & Teaching
Vocabulary Slides - Selecting & Teaching
 

Similar to Hartman 2000 Influence of Media on Liteacy

Kid'spgs
Kid'spgsKid'spgs
Kid'spgsxaky
 
Future of libraries talk
Future of libraries talkFuture of libraries talk
Future of libraries talkECMatKU
 
Historical background
Historical backgroundHistorical background
Historical background10-30-06
 
O Porter- Digital Research Presentation
O Porter- Digital Research PresentationO Porter- Digital Research Presentation
O Porter- Digital Research PresentationOlivia Porter
 
Hill Lee Lib Virtual Worlds
Hill Lee Lib Virtual WorldsHill Lee Lib Virtual Worlds
Hill Lee Lib Virtual WorldsValerie Hill
 
Pre-thesis seminar (LESSON THROUGH SPACE)- shruthi s prabhu.pptx
Pre-thesis seminar (LESSON THROUGH SPACE)- shruthi s prabhu.pptxPre-thesis seminar (LESSON THROUGH SPACE)- shruthi s prabhu.pptx
Pre-thesis seminar (LESSON THROUGH SPACE)- shruthi s prabhu.pptxThrishula2
 
Research, Technology, and Engagement
Research, Technology, and EngagementResearch, Technology, and Engagement
Research, Technology, and EngagementRobert J. Stein
 
What are Libraries Good For?
What are Libraries Good For?What are Libraries Good For?
What are Libraries Good For?Johan Koren
 
Public and School Library Partnerships
Public and School Library PartnershipsPublic and School Library Partnerships
Public and School Library Partnershipsjmthuma
 
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300kllmata
 
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300Dina Cmps
 
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300rafiqui1671
 
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300anysil
 
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300Aminta Escobar
 
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300alejandrosegura27
 
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300kllmata
 

Similar to Hartman 2000 Influence of Media on Liteacy (20)

Passion
PassionPassion
Passion
 
Kid'spgs
Kid'spgsKid'spgs
Kid'spgs
 
Library Essay Writing
Library Essay WritingLibrary Essay Writing
Library Essay Writing
 
Future of libraries talk
Future of libraries talkFuture of libraries talk
Future of libraries talk
 
Library Essay In English
Library Essay In EnglishLibrary Essay In English
Library Essay In English
 
Historical background
Historical backgroundHistorical background
Historical background
 
O Porter- Digital Research Presentation
O Porter- Digital Research PresentationO Porter- Digital Research Presentation
O Porter- Digital Research Presentation
 
Hill Lee Lib Virtual Worlds
Hill Lee Lib Virtual WorldsHill Lee Lib Virtual Worlds
Hill Lee Lib Virtual Worlds
 
Library Essays
Library EssaysLibrary Essays
Library Essays
 
Pre-thesis seminar (LESSON THROUGH SPACE)- shruthi s prabhu.pptx
Pre-thesis seminar (LESSON THROUGH SPACE)- shruthi s prabhu.pptxPre-thesis seminar (LESSON THROUGH SPACE)- shruthi s prabhu.pptx
Pre-thesis seminar (LESSON THROUGH SPACE)- shruthi s prabhu.pptx
 
Research, Technology, and Engagement
Research, Technology, and EngagementResearch, Technology, and Engagement
Research, Technology, and Engagement
 
What are Libraries Good For?
What are Libraries Good For?What are Libraries Good For?
What are Libraries Good For?
 
Public and School Library Partnerships
Public and School Library PartnershipsPublic and School Library Partnerships
Public and School Library Partnerships
 
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
 
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
 
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
 
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
 
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
 
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
 
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
How do americans use public libraries flyer 300
 

More from Douglas K. Hartman

From Writer's Workshop to Designer's Studio
From Writer's Workshop to Designer's StudioFrom Writer's Workshop to Designer's Studio
From Writer's Workshop to Designer's StudioDouglas K. Hartman
 
Michigan Reading Association 2013 - Bena Hartman
Michigan Reading Association 2013 - Bena HartmanMichigan Reading Association 2013 - Bena Hartman
Michigan Reading Association 2013 - Bena HartmanDouglas K. Hartman
 
Castek Leu Hartman 2005 Comprehension Online Learning
Castek Leu Hartman 2005 Comprehension Online LearningCastek Leu Hartman 2005 Comprehension Online Learning
Castek Leu Hartman 2005 Comprehension Online LearningDouglas K. Hartman
 
Hartman1996 Using Informational Books
Hartman1996 Using Informational BooksHartman1996 Using Informational Books
Hartman1996 Using Informational BooksDouglas K. Hartman
 
Hartman1992 Intertextuality Reading
Hartman1992 Intertextuality ReadingHartman1992 Intertextuality Reading
Hartman1992 Intertextuality ReadingDouglas K. Hartman
 
Hartman 1996 Inquiry Oriented Discussions
Hartman 1996 Inquiry Oriented DiscussionsHartman 1996 Inquiry Oriented Discussions
Hartman 1996 Inquiry Oriented DiscussionsDouglas K. Hartman
 
Hartman1993 Reading Across Texts
Hartman1993 Reading Across TextsHartman1993 Reading Across Texts
Hartman1993 Reading Across TextsDouglas K. Hartman
 
Hartman 2004 Reading Across Multiple Texts
Hartman 2004 Reading Across Multiple TextsHartman 2004 Reading Across Multiple Texts
Hartman 2004 Reading Across Multiple TextsDouglas K. Hartman
 
Hartman 2001 Content Area Reading
Hartman 2001 Content Area ReadingHartman 2001 Content Area Reading
Hartman 2001 Content Area ReadingDouglas K. Hartman
 
Monaghan Hartman 2002 Undertaking Historical Research Literacy
Monaghan Hartman 2002 Undertaking Historical Research LiteracyMonaghan Hartman 2002 Undertaking Historical Research Literacy
Monaghan Hartman 2002 Undertaking Historical Research LiteracyDouglas K. Hartman
 
Kaufman Hartman 2007 Reflections Reading Pioneers
Kaufman Hartman 2007 Reflections Reading PioneersKaufman Hartman 2007 Reflections Reading Pioneers
Kaufman Hartman 2007 Reflections Reading PioneersDouglas K. Hartman
 
Leu Hartman Reinking 2008 Research Online Reading Comprehension
Leu Hartman Reinking 2008 Research Online Reading ComprehensionLeu Hartman Reinking 2008 Research Online Reading Comprehension
Leu Hartman Reinking 2008 Research Online Reading ComprehensionDouglas K. Hartman
 
Castek Hartman Leu 2007 Future Researchers New Literacies
Castek Hartman Leu 2007 Future Researchers New LiteraciesCastek Hartman Leu 2007 Future Researchers New Literacies
Castek Hartman Leu 2007 Future Researchers New LiteraciesDouglas K. Hartman
 
Hartman 1995 8 Readers Reading
Hartman 1995 8 Readers ReadingHartman 1995 8 Readers Reading
Hartman 1995 8 Readers ReadingDouglas K. Hartman
 
Monaghan Hartman 2000 Undertakng Historical Research in Literacy
Monaghan Hartman 2000 Undertakng Historical Research in LiteracyMonaghan Hartman 2000 Undertakng Historical Research in Literacy
Monaghan Hartman 2000 Undertakng Historical Research in LiteracyDouglas K. Hartman
 
Hefflin Hartman 2002 Writing to Improve Comprehension
Hefflin Hartman 2002 Writing to Improve ComprehensionHefflin Hartman 2002 Writing to Improve Comprehension
Hefflin Hartman 2002 Writing to Improve ComprehensionDouglas K. Hartman
 
Leu McVerry O'Byrne Zawilinski Castek Hartman 2009 New Literacies & NCLB
Leu McVerry O'Byrne Zawilinski Castek Hartman 2009 New Literacies & NCLBLeu McVerry O'Byrne Zawilinski Castek Hartman 2009 New Literacies & NCLB
Leu McVerry O'Byrne Zawilinski Castek Hartman 2009 New Literacies & NCLBDouglas K. Hartman
 
Castek Coiro Hartman Henry Leu Zawilinsky 2010 New Literacies
Castek Coiro Hartman Henry Leu Zawilinsky 2010 New LiteraciesCastek Coiro Hartman Henry Leu Zawilinsky 2010 New Literacies
Castek Coiro Hartman Henry Leu Zawilinsky 2010 New LiteraciesDouglas K. Hartman
 

More from Douglas K. Hartman (18)

From Writer's Workshop to Designer's Studio
From Writer's Workshop to Designer's StudioFrom Writer's Workshop to Designer's Studio
From Writer's Workshop to Designer's Studio
 
Michigan Reading Association 2013 - Bena Hartman
Michigan Reading Association 2013 - Bena HartmanMichigan Reading Association 2013 - Bena Hartman
Michigan Reading Association 2013 - Bena Hartman
 
Castek Leu Hartman 2005 Comprehension Online Learning
Castek Leu Hartman 2005 Comprehension Online LearningCastek Leu Hartman 2005 Comprehension Online Learning
Castek Leu Hartman 2005 Comprehension Online Learning
 
Hartman1996 Using Informational Books
Hartman1996 Using Informational BooksHartman1996 Using Informational Books
Hartman1996 Using Informational Books
 
Hartman1992 Intertextuality Reading
Hartman1992 Intertextuality ReadingHartman1992 Intertextuality Reading
Hartman1992 Intertextuality Reading
 
Hartman 1996 Inquiry Oriented Discussions
Hartman 1996 Inquiry Oriented DiscussionsHartman 1996 Inquiry Oriented Discussions
Hartman 1996 Inquiry Oriented Discussions
 
Hartman1993 Reading Across Texts
Hartman1993 Reading Across TextsHartman1993 Reading Across Texts
Hartman1993 Reading Across Texts
 
Hartman 2004 Reading Across Multiple Texts
Hartman 2004 Reading Across Multiple TextsHartman 2004 Reading Across Multiple Texts
Hartman 2004 Reading Across Multiple Texts
 
Hartman 2001 Content Area Reading
Hartman 2001 Content Area ReadingHartman 2001 Content Area Reading
Hartman 2001 Content Area Reading
 
Monaghan Hartman 2002 Undertaking Historical Research Literacy
Monaghan Hartman 2002 Undertaking Historical Research LiteracyMonaghan Hartman 2002 Undertaking Historical Research Literacy
Monaghan Hartman 2002 Undertaking Historical Research Literacy
 
Kaufman Hartman 2007 Reflections Reading Pioneers
Kaufman Hartman 2007 Reflections Reading PioneersKaufman Hartman 2007 Reflections Reading Pioneers
Kaufman Hartman 2007 Reflections Reading Pioneers
 
Leu Hartman Reinking 2008 Research Online Reading Comprehension
Leu Hartman Reinking 2008 Research Online Reading ComprehensionLeu Hartman Reinking 2008 Research Online Reading Comprehension
Leu Hartman Reinking 2008 Research Online Reading Comprehension
 
Castek Hartman Leu 2007 Future Researchers New Literacies
Castek Hartman Leu 2007 Future Researchers New LiteraciesCastek Hartman Leu 2007 Future Researchers New Literacies
Castek Hartman Leu 2007 Future Researchers New Literacies
 
Hartman 1995 8 Readers Reading
Hartman 1995 8 Readers ReadingHartman 1995 8 Readers Reading
Hartman 1995 8 Readers Reading
 
Monaghan Hartman 2000 Undertakng Historical Research in Literacy
Monaghan Hartman 2000 Undertakng Historical Research in LiteracyMonaghan Hartman 2000 Undertakng Historical Research in Literacy
Monaghan Hartman 2000 Undertakng Historical Research in Literacy
 
Hefflin Hartman 2002 Writing to Improve Comprehension
Hefflin Hartman 2002 Writing to Improve ComprehensionHefflin Hartman 2002 Writing to Improve Comprehension
Hefflin Hartman 2002 Writing to Improve Comprehension
 
Leu McVerry O'Byrne Zawilinski Castek Hartman 2009 New Literacies & NCLB
Leu McVerry O'Byrne Zawilinski Castek Hartman 2009 New Literacies & NCLBLeu McVerry O'Byrne Zawilinski Castek Hartman 2009 New Literacies & NCLB
Leu McVerry O'Byrne Zawilinski Castek Hartman 2009 New Literacies & NCLB
 
Castek Coiro Hartman Henry Leu Zawilinsky 2010 New Literacies
Castek Coiro Hartman Henry Leu Zawilinsky 2010 New LiteraciesCastek Coiro Hartman Henry Leu Zawilinsky 2010 New Literacies
Castek Coiro Hartman Henry Leu Zawilinsky 2010 New Literacies
 

Recently uploaded

General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual Proper...
General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual  Proper...General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual  Proper...
General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual Proper...Poonam Aher Patil
 
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptxBasic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptxDenish Jangid
 
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdfQucHHunhnh
 
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptxICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptxAreebaZafar22
 
PROCESS RECORDING FORMAT.docx
PROCESS      RECORDING        FORMAT.docxPROCESS      RECORDING        FORMAT.docx
PROCESS RECORDING FORMAT.docxPoojaSen20
 
Application orientated numerical on hev.ppt
Application orientated numerical on hev.pptApplication orientated numerical on hev.ppt
Application orientated numerical on hev.pptRamjanShidvankar
 
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104misteraugie
 
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy ConsultingGrant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy ConsultingTechSoup
 
Energy Resources. ( B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II) Natural Resources
Energy Resources. ( B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II) Natural ResourcesEnergy Resources. ( B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II) Natural Resources
Energy Resources. ( B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II) Natural ResourcesShubhangi Sonawane
 
Sociology 101 Demonstration of Learning Exhibit
Sociology 101 Demonstration of Learning ExhibitSociology 101 Demonstration of Learning Exhibit
Sociology 101 Demonstration of Learning Exhibitjbellavia9
 
How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17
How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17
How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17Celine George
 
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfActivity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfciinovamais
 
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global ImpactBeyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global ImpactPECB
 
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdfHoldier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdfagholdier
 
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...Shubhangi Sonawane
 
Food Chain and Food Web (Ecosystem) EVS, B. Pharmacy 1st Year, Sem-II
Food Chain and Food Web (Ecosystem) EVS, B. Pharmacy 1st Year, Sem-IIFood Chain and Food Web (Ecosystem) EVS, B. Pharmacy 1st Year, Sem-II
Food Chain and Food Web (Ecosystem) EVS, B. Pharmacy 1st Year, Sem-IIShubhangi Sonawane
 
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdfMaking and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdfChris Hunter
 
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...EduSkills OECD
 

Recently uploaded (20)

General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual Proper...
General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual  Proper...General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual  Proper...
General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual Proper...
 
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptxBasic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
 
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
 
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptxICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
 
PROCESS RECORDING FORMAT.docx
PROCESS      RECORDING        FORMAT.docxPROCESS      RECORDING        FORMAT.docx
PROCESS RECORDING FORMAT.docx
 
Application orientated numerical on hev.ppt
Application orientated numerical on hev.pptApplication orientated numerical on hev.ppt
Application orientated numerical on hev.ppt
 
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
 
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy ConsultingGrant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
 
Energy Resources. ( B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II) Natural Resources
Energy Resources. ( B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II) Natural ResourcesEnergy Resources. ( B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II) Natural Resources
Energy Resources. ( B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II) Natural Resources
 
Sociology 101 Demonstration of Learning Exhibit
Sociology 101 Demonstration of Learning ExhibitSociology 101 Demonstration of Learning Exhibit
Sociology 101 Demonstration of Learning Exhibit
 
Asian American Pacific Islander Month DDSD 2024.pptx
Asian American Pacific Islander Month DDSD 2024.pptxAsian American Pacific Islander Month DDSD 2024.pptx
Asian American Pacific Islander Month DDSD 2024.pptx
 
How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17
How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17
How to Give a Domain for a Field in Odoo 17
 
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfActivity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
 
INDIA QUIZ 2024 RLAC DELHI UNIVERSITY.pptx
INDIA QUIZ 2024 RLAC DELHI UNIVERSITY.pptxINDIA QUIZ 2024 RLAC DELHI UNIVERSITY.pptx
INDIA QUIZ 2024 RLAC DELHI UNIVERSITY.pptx
 
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global ImpactBeyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
 
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdfHoldier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
 
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
Ecological Succession. ( ECOSYSTEM, B. Pharmacy, 1st Year, Sem-II, Environmen...
 
Food Chain and Food Web (Ecosystem) EVS, B. Pharmacy 1st Year, Sem-II
Food Chain and Food Web (Ecosystem) EVS, B. Pharmacy 1st Year, Sem-IIFood Chain and Food Web (Ecosystem) EVS, B. Pharmacy 1st Year, Sem-II
Food Chain and Food Web (Ecosystem) EVS, B. Pharmacy 1st Year, Sem-II
 
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdfMaking and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
 
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
 

Hartman 2000 Influence of Media on Liteacy

  • 1. Read~ng Research Quarterly Vol. 35, N o . 2 Aprili3lay,June 2000 El999 International Readlng Association (pp.276282) What will be the influences of media on literacy in the next millennium? fiction and other entertaining books limited to what he or she could ex- being regarded as frivolous and pect from that library facility and with highly discouraged. Surrounded by a few exceptions through interlibrary Susan B. Neuman tomes of great works. children were loan, could use only the resources Temple Lhrvcrsrty, Phrladelphra, to adopt the appropriate behavior contained within its four walls. Pennsylvunru, USA for reading in the library. They were In the future. that same young to sit quietly, read silently, and never reader entering public libraries in the ?= arly supporters presented a halcyon picture of the public library at the turn of the last speak above a whisper. As we consider literacy for the new millennium. what might the U.S. will expect and demand global resources. immediately and directly. The library of the future will become century (Garrison. 1979: Van House. new philanthropists of the library en- increasingly transformed from a fi- 1972). Building what amounted to vision for the future? How might nite space with finite resources to a the modern library system, philan- technology change the ways in finite space with infinite resources. thropist Andrew Carnegie sought no which children use resources, ex- But children will no longer be sitting less than a social and cultural trans- change ideas with others, and en- quietly at their tables turning the formation in society, hoping to uplift gage in learning in such public pages of a book. The library will and enlighten the literary tastes of spaces as the library? What will look different, and children will be- the masses, support education for recreational and functional reading have differently. the underprivileged, and provide a look like in the future? The library of the future will be natural extension of free public edu- characterized by open shelves, a cation for all (Van Slyck, 1995). The modern library in the term once used to reflect free access. Carnegie's concept was to build a li- 21st century Kow, however, it is used to describe brary characterized by free access, Even a decade ago, someone the limited collection of books in the services for children, separate chil- entering a public library in the U.S. library and the more limited atten- dren's rooms. and cooperation with could expect to find a scene highly tion to circulation figures as indica- local schools. Tens of thousands of reminiscent of Carnegie's original vi- tors of library activity. Instead, there young readers benefited from his sion. One could find books, maga- will be computer terminals every- largesse, borrowing books for the zines, newspapers, and some where, with keypads designed to first time free of charge. educationally oriented audiovisual match the age-appropriate hand size Yet Carnegie's great libraries materials. The public library's collec- of children of different ages. Hits on exacted their own kind of payment. tion would reflect the interests of the various Web pages are now the not in cash but in demeanor. Early community, and the size of the col- norm for determining amount and libraries were collections of good lection would be largely determined type of library activity in the branch. books, and librarians were their by the size of the building. The most Public libraries of the future guardians. Activity at the library in- desired books could be unavailable will not merely support young pa- volved reading what librarians for weeks, having been recently trons; they will cater to them. Due to thought children should read, with checked out. The young library user, its massive resource capacity, the li-
  • 2. brary will attract many nontraditional If we ask our current philan- the future of media and its effects on young users. But not unlike the past thropists what their vision of the literacy is tricky business. But I'll century, there will be continuing de- public library might be, they proba- step into my time machine, crank bate about how these resources are bly would say to transform society the engine a few times, and give it a used. Many will decry the young by providing greater access and thus try nonetheless. children's interest in demanding the ensure a more knowledgeable public One thing that I think will very lowest level of reading material than ever before. And perhaps chil- change is the definition of literacy it- in quality and taste. However, there dren of the 21st century will be self, which historically has referred will be something for everyone- more sophisticated consumers of in- to at least a rudimentary ability to some typically advantaged children formation and entertainment than decode, comprehend, and produce will be using resources to their great- ever before. But the ambiance of the written language. even by such limit- est capacity, while others will find dark public library with patrons qui- ed means as a signature. When the their thrills in sexual kick-boxing etly turning the pages of their books world was a much simpler place. and oddball chat rooms. will be forever changed. these definitions seemed adequate. The demeanor among children Language served as the primary in the library will change from the REFERENCES medium through which people con- pensive and the quiet to the social GARRISON, D. (1979). Apostles of culture: structed systematic representations of The public librarian and American society 1876- their worlds, and written documents playground, with large groups of 1920. New York: Free Press. children waiting to get on, or in- VAN HOUSE, W. (1972). Public library user served as the basis for the structure volved in, the Internet. Navigating fees. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press. and machinery of society: laws, his- for resources and sites will be easier VAN SLYCK, A. (1995). Free to all. Chicago: tory, records. and so on. While liter- University of Chicago Press. with multiple interfaces designed acy in terms of language is still around the fourth-grade level with prerequisite to active participation in much of modern life, it is now part plenty of pictures to convey ideas of what Wertsch (1991) has called a along with the print. Children will "tool kit" of mediational means (p. read, but in brief bursts as they 93). While language is still no doubt move from picture to picture. Books the "tool of tools" (Cole. 1996. p. will rarely be checked out; instead. children will favor CDs and videos. Peter Smagorinsky log), other communicative and me- diational means are being developed The librarian of this coming Universip o f Georgia. Athens, U S A w that play a strong role in fin de siBcle century will no longer be a biblio- literacy and presumably will increas- phile but a bit of a hacker and tech- riting on the future of me- ingly help one to live the good life nician, since equipment is always in dia and literacy brings to in the new millennium. need of repair. Rather than finding mind science fiction Before looking too far ahead. I books for patrons or answering ref- movies from the 1950s, with flying would like to review an argument I erence questions, now his or her ac- saucers swinging across the screen made a few years ago (Smagorinsky. tivity will be more of an online on not-so-transparent strings, and 1995). At that time I had spent a lot personal help service, although aliens with names like Zoltan wear- of time visiting classes across the painful back ailments from leaning ing aluminum foil space suits and curriculum in a large public high over people's shoulders may pre- speaking very formal English. That school and had tried to understand vent long interactions. KO longer is is. no matter what I say here, it is how students made meaning as they there time to get to know the pa- bound to look a little silly before moved from class to class, discipline trons' names, or even their faces for long because it's hard to say how to discipline. What I found raised that matter, since most are always media and technology will develop questions about the notion that writ- looking forward at a screen. Despite in the next few decades. When I was ing across the curriculum is the most all efforts, he or she will not filter a kid, media referred to those large worthwhile goal for schooling, given the content of what children are reel-to-reel projectors that always that in many disciplines students reading; in fact in the US, it won't seemed to eat our science class produced highly meaningful texts be allowed since challenged by the films. Even 5 years ago, few people consistent with disciplinary values First Amendment to the U.S. had even heard of the World Wide and conventions, yet through media Constitution. Computer clubs have Web, now a fixture in any home other than language. Students in an replaced story hours. with a computer. And so forecasting Equine Management and Production What will be the influences of media on literacv in the next millennium? 277
  • 3. class, for instance. needed to learn a ate vehicle for mediating students' wide range of knowledge and skills engagement with ideas. for breeding and maintaining horses. As new media develop. I think The culminating project for the se- they will increasingly afford new sys- Patricia E. Enciso mester was to synthesize all of their tems of representation. Recall that Columbus, L1S/4 O h i o State ITnrversry, knowledge of horses in the design many of the original educational of a ranch that they might conceiv- ably own and operate at a profit. They combined multidisciplinary knowledge in order to design their ranches: geometry for designing an- programs for computers looked very similar to what already existed in workbooks; that is, the potential of computers was poorly exploited be- cause they were viewed as simply a T he theories and practices of lit- erary interpretation are as old as Talmudic studies and as new as poststructuralist linguistics and postmodern identity politics. Yet gles, mathematics for developing different means for providing the across the centuries. studies of literary feed mixes in the right proportion, same texts. Now. sofmare designers interpretation have addressed the physics to know how to situate work with animation, sound, interac- same intersections of reader, text, and buildings for drainage, weather to tion, voice activation. image making, context through questions that in- know how to build for local condi- and who-knows-what-awaits in or- clude these: Who are readers? What tions (e.g.. one-story structures if tor- der to provide computer users with should they read? What are the cir- nadoes are a threat), economics for useful and entertaining tools. cumstances of their reading? How? deciding what crops to grow for If we assume that literacy serves Why? Who benefits from these views feed, and much more, including spe- to construct, preserve, and document of reader, text, and context? cific knowledge of how to accom- frameworks for social practice-and Old and new approaches to lit- modate the needs of particular to enable communication within erary education have been developed breeds of horses. those frameworks-then it is conceiv- and critiqued in terms of these ques- The project took over a month able that computers and software will tions and in relation to the production to conlplete and involved a long- provide tools for a different kind of of new literary forms. more fully artic- term process of composition, includ- literacy. In that sense, then, school ulated theories of readerhext transac- ing planning, drafting, revising, and production may change. Instead of tions. reconfigurations of philosophies the production of the final product writing a research paper. for instance. of the self, and assertions of political that the students regarded quite students can create a multimedia pre- power focused on containing particu- seriously. Work was conducted col- sentation that includes film footage. lar texts and relationships to texts. In laboratively, with students talking scanned images, music, voice-overs, the coming century. I imagine these frequently with one another and and so on. In my view, the key ques- influences will continue to shape the their teacher about their designs. In tion should be. in what ways does scholarship and teaching of literary short. the production of the horse the process of composition both lead interpretation. In addition, reading ranch designs included all of the as- to new learning and provide a repre- and literary education will continue to pects of writing that are usually the sentation of that learning that follows wrestle with many of the same ques- basis for viewing writing as an es- appropriate cultural conventions? The tions and problems that others have sential tool. The difference was that developnlent of new technologies attempted to resolve over the past words were only used as labels. and media, while changing the tools decades. I want to look to the past for with the spatial configuration of im- and forms through which students a moment. to describe one prescrip- ages being the primary vehicle for compose, should not change that tion for reading education that illumi- constructing and representing mean- fundamental question. nates many of the issues we will face ingful ideas. From this class and many oth- in the next millennium. REFERENCES On the cusp of the 20th centu- ers, I concluded that the concern of COLE, M. (1996). Cu/iuralpsychology: A once educators ought to be with conzpos- and future discipline. Cambr~dge,MA: Harvard ry, M.E. Burt. a veteran teacher, librar- ing across the c u t ~ c u l u m rather than Un~versity Press. ian. and member of the Chicago writing across the curriculum, given SMAGORINSKY, P. (1995). Constructing Board of Education, wrote a com- meaning In the disciplines: Reconceptualizing writ- that writing does not have exclusive ing across the curr~culum composing across the as pelling, no-nonsense treatise on the properties for enabling people to curr~culum. American Journal of Education, 103, form and content of children's literary construct or represent meaning. 160-1 84. educations. Her compact book. ~0111- WERTSCH, J.V. (1991). Voices of the mind: A Furthermore, in some disciplines plete with an annotated bibliography. soc~ocultural approach to mediated action. writing is not the culturally appropri- Cambridge, MA: Haward University Press. was entitled Litemly L a n d m a h ~ f o r 278 READING RESEARCH QUARTERLY ApriVMay/June 2000 35/2
  • 4. Young People (1899). Burt outlined She would have found a kindred spir- ple are represented and interrelated? I the selections of literature that should it, no doubt, in E.D. Hirsch had they am hopeful that today's multistoried, be available to and read by all chil- been contemporaries at the turn of multimedia children and adults will dren, what they should and should the 20th century. She might also have not be content with a singular line of not attend to as they read ("He will found much in common with litera- literary landmarks that convey "a mas- read with better expression if his ture-based reading educators who en- terpiece of creative goodness" (p. 1j). mind is searching after the largest courage deep and wide reading, as That line, based almost exclusively on thought in the piece than he will if he James Britton proposed in the mid- European male values, language, and is continually nagged at concerning 1960s. Indeed, in the latter part of her histories, thins and weakens rapidly, the definitions of words") (p. 29), and book, she presents a strong argument leaving many children wondering what adults should know before they for the centrality of literature across where they fit in to the process of ventured their opinions on children's the curriculum, particularly in science making meaning. reading ("It always excites my indig- and social studies education. She cer- If, at the turn of the last century, nation and contempt to hear 'scholars' tainly would have supported family literary study and interpretation had putting themselves on haughty literacy research and practices, partic- as its purpose the coherent mapping pedestals of classicalism, speak dis- ularly those located within middle of historical relationships associated paragingly of giving the greatest class and economically depressed with the writer's art, then, at the be- works to laboring men or their neighborhoods, that bring children ginning of the next century the chal- children") (p. 23). and adults together around the best lenges for researchers, teachers, and Burt had no patience with books available. students may be to comprehend the scholars or publishers who suggested Burt's perspectives on literature incoherences in stories, the unstated that children's texts should be limited selection and literary interpretation histories, the long-denied and mis- in literary style or content. She argued placed high value on universal access placed representations within literary that children needed the best of liter- to ideas, art, and goodness. In her forms. Unlike Burt, who advised ary art and ideas if they were to gain day. these views would have been ac- teachers to guide children toward "the a sense of the continuous chain of ceptable to most teachers, librarians, big ideas" within literature. future events and ideas that have formed politicians, and labor organizers (but teachers and researchers will need to modern thought. Her comprehensive not scholars!). The United States was consider what could possibly be con- plan for literary studies included bibli- seeking a political compass at the strued as a shared idea. "Big ideas" or cal stories and Arthurian legends for turn of the century and found much themes, the staple of literary interpre- young children, Fenelon's Lives o the f to support its largely immigrant popu- tation, are intentionally obscured by Philosophers and Chaucer's Griselda lation in the form of socialist and pro- today's artists and authors working for upper elementar).-aged children, gressive politics, the equity politics across media-based and book-like art- and a study of Dante's poetry and reflected in Burt's vision of literary ed- forms (see, for example, Monster, Marlowe's Fazrst for adolescents. As is ucation. Her writing was also a reac- 1999. by Walter Dean Myers). apparent from her recommended tion against the modernist vision of Students may be far ahead of teachers reading list, she saw no reason to social change that imposed catego- and researchers in recognizing that separate adult and children's reading: rization, efficiency, and reductionism themes are precisely what limits "Any book is not good enough for on school curricula. particularly read- meaning: the artform and the artist the youngest child in the primary ing education. are questioning. not sustaining, the grade unless it would be a good book I wonder, now, how Burt's per- reader's assumption of an answer. for the teacher or parent." She argued spectives on literature selections and The future of literary interpreta- that, in the company of great books interpretations might persist while the tion promises to be an exciting and avid adult readers. children form and substance might be scramble through texts and images. would soon discover and delight in changed in the 21st century. How Still. the key question for future liter- the interrelatedness of literary struc- would she, in these postmodern and ary and reading educators, in the tures, themes, and historic events. postcolonial times, organize histories United States and other emerging Many advocates of Western that cannot be made commensurable den~ocracies, not so much what is classical literature might wholeheart- as a continuous chain? And what cri- new literary forms and interpretations edly agree with Burt that a chain of teria would she use to select from the might be possible, but whether teach- events can and should be gleaned extensive body of literary art forms ers will have authority within the po- from the guided selection and inter- and ideas so that the exemplary voic- litical struggles over the form and pretation of well-wrought literary art. es and visions of all the world's peo- substance of reading education, to What will be the influences of media on literacy in the next millennium? 279
  • 5. determine how any text will be se- textbooks, and government docu- variety of specific search constraints lected and interpreted. The future of ments will sit out there on the (Boolean, proximity. case matching. research and teaching regarding liter- Internet in a full-text, searchable for- and more). A search for the phrase asy education will be played out mat that elin~inates need for cellu- the emef-gentliteracy. for example. against a landscape of definitions, val- loid archives on each and evesy n,ould result in the almost instanta- ues. and civil rights. And here we can college campus. There is already a neous identification of every occur- return to Burt's vision. Should we. wide range of virtual librasy services rence of the phrase in all volun~es, like Burt, demand the most compre- including academic periodical collec- issues, and articles. To obtain the hensive and remarkable exemplars of tions such as First Search and EBSCO. same result from a Web site, the user the world's narratives and literasy which claim several thousand period- would have to don,nload the entire forms-based in local and global icals online and fully searchable. The database from the site, which would texts, music, film. CD-KOMs, and oth- logical extension is a complete librasy take hours or days. The sophisticated er media-for all of our children? Or accessible by Internet. There is, how- searching I have just described can- a-ill inequitable funding continue to y ever, an alternative: m e lib?-a cozild not be conducted by remote because place magnificent libraries in some exist inside yozi r PC the bandwidth of the Internet limits schools for a few children, while a It's been exactly 20 years since the speed at which information can majority of children pick through last I bought my first home computer. be exchanged. In the a1ternatix.e it is centuT's worn-out paperbacks? an Apple 11+ with a Halloween possible to tag issues or articles-if Should we, like Burt, fear loss of liter- screen monitor, two external 5.25- each article is its own file-with key acy among fourth graders and then inch floppy disk drives. 64k of =!I. a~ords. Issues or articles tagged for focus attention on "the theosy that and a daisy~vheelline printer that the kelword can then be down- reading should be v e v simple and sounded like a muffled machine loaded for printing or further inspec- monosyllabic" (p. 28). Or should n,e. gun. Hard drives and the Internet tion. Current online services operate like Burt, argue long and loud for were still in the future. The storage in this fashion. In a few years band- "spirited discussions," that "leave the capacity of my Apple 11+ was 128 width may be expanded to the point question open?" (p. 49). The right to kilobytes, about one eighth of a where full-text, indexed searches as I interpret is always contested. I inlag- megabyte. In 1987 I bought a 286 have described here will be possible ine researchers and teachers becom- PC with a 20-megaby-te hard drive. from a Web site. ing more infornled and more vocal in which represented a 15.000% in- Given the choice. I would the effort to determine both the rights crease in storage capacity over the much rather access information from to, and the contests over. images old Apple II+. The PC on which I n ~ y ard drive than from the Internet. h and ideas. work now has a 6.5-gigaby-te DVD It's a lot faster. and I don't have to (digital video disk) drive and a 9-gi- xvorT about connect//disconnect REFERENCES gabyte (9,000 megabytes) hard dri- dilemmas. Imagine what it would be BURT, M.E. (1899). Literarylandmarks for ve, a 77.500%)increase over the like to do word processing from a young people. New York: Houghton Mifflin. MYERS. W.D. (1999). Monster. New York: storage capacity of my old PC. To Web site instead of having the pro- Har~erCollins. give this some everyday perspective, gram inside your own computer! a single DVD disk could hold the If the internal storage capability sum total of all publications of the and processing speeds of PCs contin- International Reading Association, ue at their current pace. in 10 years the National Keading Conference. the hard drives and peripheral stor- and the College Keading age devices of PCs will be able to Association, all volumes of all jour- hold the complete archives of a col- nals, books. monographs, and lege librasy as easily as they hold R. Scott Baldwin newsletters ever published in their Microsoft Word. Of course, the speed ,-ii,lrm St(1tL' CG//L'$c,, - l L 7 1 1 l ~ ~ ' 7 , combined histories, And. all of these and accessibility of the Internet will C0101~L7d0, LTS,4 publications could be hypertext continue to advance at its own warp linked and fully searchable in a speed: the Internet may be the ulti- M ost people seem to think that the university librav of the fi~turewill be virtual and Web based. In this scenario tens of thousands of digitized periodicals. few seconds. A DVD database with a stan- dard search engine (e.g..Adobe Acrobat) could be searched in sec- onds for any word or phrase under a mate solution when it comes to transacting business and getting cur- rent information fast. However, my prediction is that when it comes to archiving professional knowledge, 280 READLNG RESEARCH QUARTERLY ApriVMay/June 2000 35/2
  • 6. the librasy of the fi~ture will end up ,I.fonoli?zgz~al-> :Vlztltilingzral. (MTL', for example) are a mix of im- inside your computer and not on No one language can fully represent age. talk. Web referencing, call-in. somebody's Web site. the range of information, knon.1- visual clips, music. and so on-a edge, and perspectives possible. As pastiche of semiotic systems at the the pressures grow to know and un- s e r i c e of a singular message. derstand beyond one's national, cul- Te.~tzlal-> Intetle.~tzral. tural, and linguistic borders. and Because no single text, or informa- access to other linguistic knowledges tion source, can possibly contain all and understandings becomes easier there is to know about a topic, idea. through technological tools, the limi- person, or event, it is increasingly Douglas K.Hartman tations of being literate in one lan- important that students know how to guage (which is true for most in the select. connect, and organize infor- 1I.S.) will move our thinking toward mation from a large number of tex- y approach to thinking reading in-and writing in-more tual sources across extended periods about how media will in- than one language. The monotonous of time. Most of the materials in the uence literacy in the new sound of one language will give way 20th centusy have been designed to millennium is much like futurists do to the stereophonic sensibilities of a outline master narratives or para- in corporate America: They look at larger n,orld with which to c o n ~ n ~ u - digms in a single text for students to present patterns, and based on these nicate. Imagine most LT.S. elementan conlprehend and conlpose. Reading patterns. project scenarios for what students moving toward reading and and writing in the next millennium could exist tomorron7.These scenar- writing fluency in two or more lan- will increasingly deinand the relating ios are not predictions, but stories guages. with the help of electronic and rerelating of information across that present alternative i~xages of speech and print coaches that can multiple texts and learning situa- possible tomorrows. I see a number assist with translation and mediation tions. It will be a time where the of patterns that suggest scenarios in among the languages. reading of one text leads to another three areas: conceptions, materials. and another, back and forth across and methods of literacy. Materials for literacy histosy and across language and cul- The materials to be used in lit- tures: where readers are challenged Conceptions of literacy erate activities are also being re- and surprised often by unexpected, What constitutes literacy is al- shaped by the influence of media. serendipitous linking discoveries in ready being reshaped by the influ- The shape of these nlaterial move- their reading: where readers continu- ence of media. The movement of ments are from: ally revise their understandings and these changing conceptions is from: Linguistic -> Selniotic. In this responses to previous texts: where Literacjl-> Litemcies. For centun we have largely valued and readers exploit the rich literary and most of this millennium a singular used linguistic texts-that is. fixed artistic possibilities kvithin, across. conception of literacy has prevailed: print on a bounded paper page-for and beyond texts: and where readers the production and reception of communicating, learning, and spend their days waist high in works meaning through print. But a more recording information in school. that can be traversed in one direc- pluralistic conception is taking work. and community. We are wit- tion, and then in another and still shape. It includes print-based, nessing a dramatic shift to the use of another. meaning-making practices. but much other text types-to those known as Hzlndled -> Distrihzited. In more. The relative ease by which semiotic texts. These new text types our professional lifetime we've seen someone can represent thoughts, are both paper and digital in form. the commercial materials used for in- knonings. and meanings through requiring a reader to read not only stn~ction bundled together in kits or iconography. movement, sound. and print, but images. icons. and sounds; packages. Beginning with the Dick so on m-ill make other forms of pro- they are a virtual mix of various sign & Jane readers around midcentuq-, duction and reception just as valued systems on the same page or screen this bundling of teacher edition, stu- as print has been for so long. This that must be read in relation to one dent edition, big flip charts. trade open, inclusive set of literacies nil1 another. Print. film. music. art, nlove- books. cassette tapes, flash cards, require neu- languages for talking ment, photographs, and other modes tests. and so on has I>ecome the about the sense-making practices of representation will be counted as norm. The hallmark of this deliven n-ithin a particular literacy. as n.ell as text that can be read and written. approach is that you can have all across the various literacies. The digital semiotic texts of today necessan materials located in one What will be the influences of media on literacy in the next millennium? 281
  • 7. place for easy access and use. The shaped as well. The shape of these ist. therapist, director, producer, me- downside has been the one-size-fits- pedagogical movements are from: dia resource specialist, salesperson, all conception it usually propagates. Assignments -> Workshops and engineer, to name a few. The But the move is toward a more -> Projects. The pressures of media learning communiv formed within distributed means of locating the are already extending literate activiv these classroon~s reaches far beyond materials. Some conlmercial publish- beyond assignments and workshops its walls and uses the resources with- ers are already using their Web sites to the use of comprehending and in them more imaginatively. as an integral part of the material composing in the context of project Intramediation -> Transmed- package, with certain parts of the work. Project work involves students iation. The prevailing literacy meth- bundle available only from or investigating sustainable topics and ods of the last millennium operated through remote access to these sites. ideas in considerable depth, often in an intramediato~ fashion-they Teachers can get background infor- for a sizable part of the school day worked back and forth within one mation and video footage of the au- and year. The literacy instruction fo- medium (print). from reading to writ- thor not available in the printed form cuses on helping students locate and ing and back again. With expanded of the teachers' edition; students can use textual resources to reconstruct conceptions of literacy and the media locate a mountain of story-related their environment, knowledge, and tools to represent meaning in other material when and if they want or social relations. Furthermore, stu- modes, a new set of literacy methods need it: and there are additional skill dents explore complex and impor- n,ill be needed to operate in a trans- and strategy practice opportunities tant ideas and systems through mediatory fashion-working back that dovetail into the minilessons project work, using and reusing a and forth across media, from print to yo~l've already provided. And imag- broad range of literacy tools and video to sculpture to iconic notations ine a Web-based smart teachers' edi- modes to research, report, and re- to music and so on. Imagine class- tion, where teachers can tailor-fit the spond to what they are learning. As rooms everywhere that possess the distributed materials to the unique such, the literacy instruction is em- tools and know-how to transform a features of students in their class- bedded in classrooms that are part book into a film-from writing the room. The hallmark of distributed museum, publishing house, think script, acting the parts, choreograph- material usage will be its customiz- tank, writers' workshop, artists' stu- ing the moves, shooting the footage. ing power. dio, theater, drafting room, computer editing the film, dubbing the music lab, library, bookstore, gallery, and sound effects, advertising the Methods in literacy recording studio, and more. As a re- production on a Web site-and then Finally, the methods for teach- sult, the teacher's role becomes that use the film as the basis for writing a ing or using literacy are being re- of curator, impresario, editor, futur- sequel to the book. 282 READING RESEARCH QUARTERLY April/May/June 2000 35/2