1. Adam Little, Eilidh Dickson and Siddharth Muthyala
service design CIID / DKDS Pilot Year
Friday 3rd April 2009
from user experience to systemic innovation
2. Initial Visits to the Library to understand people’s mental models they have of it. What role does it play in
their lives? We used active card sorting & drawing tools to trigger discussion
3. “Being in a Library make you feel like
you are part of a community, you can
see what other people in your
neighbourhood are interested in....It
has a really positive atmosphere”
Anne, 19, American, Just moved to CPH
initial insights and inspiration Quotes from our initial research that stood out for us and triggered us to
explore further
4. “I am here (at the library) while my
friends are at work”
Anna, Visiting friends in Copenhagen
initial insights and inspiration Quotes from our initial research that stood out for us and triggered us to
explore further
5. “It would be romantic to meet
someone at the library”
Eda, 19, Danish but just moved to
Copenhagen
initial insights and inspiration Quotes from our initial research that stood out for us and triggered us to
explore further
6. Regardless of what country you are in, the library is seen as a free public space
you can spend time in with access to a variety of services
Using the library services, or even being in the libary space can make you feel
more like a ‘local’
The Library has a special ‘romantic’ quality about it
Assumptions we made from our initial research that we wanted to persue further and test
through more research
7. Foreign visitors and new residents are interested in local knowledge and
Danish culture that matches their own interests and tastes. The library is seen
as a trustworthy source of information, and for the few foreigners that visit the
library, it makes them feel part of the local community. But for most foreign
visitors, the library plays no role in exploring Denmark.
How can the library bring its services to foreign visitors and guests so they
have access to Danish knowledge and culture that is both personalised and
trustworthy?
The main goal for our service. This is the question we wanted to answer through our final
concept
8. concept video A collaborative service between the Library and hotels within Copenhagen that enables visitors to
Copenhagen learn more about danish culture and access library materials
9.
10. “We know nothing about copenhagen, we are using
our friend as a guide, we are only here for the
weekend”
Adrian and Natalie, American, on holiday to
Copenhagen
After deciding to focus on visitors to Copenhagen, we headed to the airport to
conduct interviews
11. ‘Sure i would like to know more about local films and
music.....I expect to have to ask a lot of questions and talk to
a lot of people’
Patrick, Oregan, Travelling around Scandanavia
After deciding to focus on visitors to Copenhagen, we headed to the airport to
conduct interviews
12. ‘Knowing more about Danish culture would be cool, there is no
easy way to access this that i have found. I am a big fan of
music, so any Danish music would be awesome”
Sam, New York, Been studying in Copenhagen (6 months)
After deciding to focus on visitors to Copenhagen, we headed to the airport to
conduct interviews
13. “The typical customer is someone coming off a
cruise ship who has about 2 hours to spend, they
want to get the best out of Copenhagen in this time.
The only reason I direct people to the library is for
free Wi Fi. If they want information in specific Danish
book or author i tell them where the
nearest bookshop is”
Gabrielle, tourist information empoyee
We visited the tourist information get their view on the library and the
services they provide
14. Tourists and new-comers to Copenhagen are not in touch with local youth culture
Bookshops are percieved to contain more specialised content
The libraries free services are not recognised as being suitable or
accessible for visitors
The mental model of a library is not associated with services for tourists
The tourist information is seen as a place to find information on the ‘must see’ tourist
attractions. People staying in Copenhagen for more than a few days might have time
to see more than just tourist attractions and there for avoid the tourist information.
Our assumptions based on the insights we gained from our interviews which supported our
idea to design for tourists to Copenhagen or people who had just moved to the city
15. We collected and filtered all our insights and learnings. We created how created ‘how might we
statements in preperation for our brainstorming
16. Giving the library presence in other public and private places throughout the
visitors travel experience
Visitors becoming more equainted with the city,
Providing specific services for foreigners to feel like a ‘local’
Providing visitors with library material based on their personal interests on
arrival to the city
Before brainstorming ideas these are some of the key values we wanted to generate ideas around,
and provide solutions for.
17. After grouping all of our ideas we voted and developed three ideas and built scenarios around them, to
further explain the concept
18. We chose to focus on how the library and hotels could collaborate as we felt this had most potential to
create the most core values we wanted to achieve in our concept
19.
20. The hotel guests can now pre-order
Library sets up a new service where The Hotels collaborate with the
books before their trip or use the
visitors to Copenhagen can check out library and can now offer their guests
library services and facilities once
library material. Library begins by offering a book service as part of their stay.
they arrive. Their transactions are
the service to Hotels as a way to reach The Hotel premotes the new service
tied to their credit card used to book
the visitors. on their website and when guests
their hotel.
arrive, face to face.
The primary stakeholders involved in our system, that are neccessary for it to function
21. A simple diagram explaining the interaction between the different stakeholders within the system
26. -Library material
-Website
-Delivery system
-Increased visitors
to the library
-User generated
recommendations
-Direct access to books,
music and DVD’s
-Personalised hotel
experience
27. -Library material
-Website
-Delivery system
-Increased visitors
to the library
-User generated
recommendations
-Direct access to books,
-All the information
music and DVD’s
about Danish culture on
-Personalised hotel
the library website
experience
28. -Library material
-Website
-Delivery system
$$$ potential
business model
-Increased visitors
to the library
-User generated
recommendations
-Direct access to books,
-All the information
music and DVD’s
about Danish culture on
-Personalised hotel
the library website
experience
29. Continue it’s mission of providing free
access to culture and information
Lead the way in promoting Denmark as a
country which places a high value in the
sharing of knowledge to people who are not
residents of their own country
Explore Danish culture through the
library and have books, CDs and
DVDs waiting at their hotel room
when they arrive, all for free
Unique service that allows them give their
guests a personalized experience.
Hotels will also find out what interests
their guests have and use this to improve
their service exeperience of the hotel.
value for stakeholders
30. Key touchpoints that tell the story of the service throughout the user experience
31.
32.
33.
34.
35. 4. using the service : library-hotel-customer 6. quiting:
2. evaluate and commit: 5. benefits:
1. awareness: 3. learn and implement:
library-hotel-customer
library-hotel library-hotel-customer
library-hotel library-hotel choosing books
awareness: hotel-customer receiving the books changing the books returning the books
learning about the service
-requested books
-door hanger form
Welcome Pack containing: -hotel bill if they
-Welcome pack
-Printed material given to the hotels to make them -door hanger form
-Printed material given to the hotels to make them -The Library -Library
-printed flyer explaining to hotel cusomers about -confirmation email -library & user
physical
-information flyer given to guests choose to buy the
-information flyer given to guest on
understand what services the library can offer. -any new books/media
understand what services the library can offer. -An print based advertising material -Hotels
how the new service, using this to promote the (to visitor and hotel) recommendations
on arrival at the hotel book or have lost it
arrival at the hotel with details on
-forms of agreement between the library and hotel they receive used to promote the hotels. -Writen agreements of cancellation of service
hotel contains name of cards/notes
-order forms, feedback forms -airport drop box
the different ways to reserve,
-Any legal documents needed to complete the -temporary library card -feedback forms: give the hotel from either parties
books, date wanted, -hotel bookmark,
-recommended book brochure -Library
change and return books
agreement. (for use in library) insight into what they like.
ref.No -book bundles with
touchpoints
specialised maps.
-library website: can
libary website: provide all the
-link from hotel homepage after -Library website -Library website -Library website
-Library website
-The Library website
-The library website that allows customers to order -Links from hotel websites to the library website (so
web based
choose by title,
information about the service, can
booking your room -Hotel Website pages that show
their books, which also provdides general guests can access the library material)
category, or by the
browse material by name,
-reminder about the service within what services they offer.
information for visitors to copnehagen, availble to -Promotional content of hotel websites to introduce
‘danish classics’
category, linking to your itinary or
your booking confirmation email -An web based advertising material
those who are not staying in a partnering hotel. the new service
-pre-made book
through pre-made ‘bundles’
-Library Website used to promote the hotels.
-The Library website
bundles on website
-librarian if they decided -receptionist at the -Librarians
-hotel receptionist who reminds -librarian -librarian if they decide
-receptionist at the hotel can
-The representatives from the library system
-The representatives from the library system -Librarians
to pick up themselves hotel (return books on -Hotel Staff
the customer about the service -book ‘room service’ to choose books at the
provide more information on how -Hotel Staff
people
from the library check-out)
on arrival (over the phone) library.
it works
-library delivery guy -librarian if guests
-book ‘room service’
-library staff
-hotel staff if they bring return books directly
(over the phone)
it to the guests room -library delivery guy
-the hotel allows the -the hotel will notify
-hotel provides entry point for -the hotel will process -the hotel checks that
-the hotel staff are on hand to -The hotel can use this new service they offer, as a
The Hotel needs to decide whether to sign up for the
The hotel can see what the library will offer to them At this stage the hotel has to develop how they For the library to quit they must give adequate
customers to order the guest when there
the customer to reserve books new orders placed by all the books are
help their guests no more about selling point to potential customers. So when
service the library can offer them. They need to
as a service: can use the services that the notice to the library (would be in a contract)
(new) books books have arrived
through the hotel homepage the guests through returned either on customers are looking at what hotel to choose they
the book service, and explain
decide whether the monthly investment for the
-A website for hotel guests to order books through library has offered them into their existing however they will then not have the full resources
hotel role
through room and bring them to
website link or reminder the order form or will see the books service logo along side the Wi-Fi,
check-out or via post, if
service will add more value to their hotel in the eyes how it works
infrastructure. They will have to produce printed of the library that they can offer their guests. If
service or by using their room if they
email(with link) swimming pool etc. they can promote it as a exclusive
book ‘room service’
of their potentail customers. they have been lost or
-a system to keep track of the guests borrowed material to explain how to use the service to their they were to create their own book service it
a fill out form,the order them over the service they provide, that not all hotels do.
and notify the guest are not returned by the
material customers and add links from their website to the would be far more limited. After quitting they will
hotel will then send book ‘room service’
-receptionist reminds customers when these books agreed date the guest
library website, so they can order books online have to get rid of any promotional hotel material
-by knowing what books their guests are interested in,
the request to the -hotel brands the
about the service on arrival and have arrived at the is charged for the book
-a delivery and pick up service between the library that offers the book service to their guests
the hotel can also gain an insight into other services
library for the books with a hotel
provides them with an hotel through their credit
and hotel.
thy could provide specific to their guests interests.
guest bookmark or other
information flyer card, so the library can
souvineir be reimbursed
-the library will be seen as a public institution that
-The library must create a system that would track the library website allows the guest to find out about the service, choosing, changing and reserving books. -As the library is the main provider of the
The library must try and convince the hotels that
The library wants to promote more about danish does not only provide for tax payers, and people
which books were on loan to which hotels. infrastructure for this service,they will have to notify
the collaborative service will create benefits for
culture to foreign visitors and play a role in living within Denmark. They will be part of spreading all the hotels they provide to if they wish to stop
when a book is reserved they send confirmation to the guest and transfer
the end user, the visitor to copenhagen, and in
speading knowledge to a wider audience, so danish culture and knowledge to visitors to
-they would need to implement a system that is (with an agreed period of notice) By stopping this
the data to the hotel records.
turn this will bring benefits to both the hotel and
they offer a collaborative service to hotels. The
library role
Copenhagen and helping Denmark be the best
continually processing the orders though the service they will reduce their amount ot customers
library. They will be part of helping promote
libraries target hotels directly to tell them about country to promote knowledge and learning.
website, directly from the hotel customer and via and any profit they receive from the hotels
library processing orders, delivering and picking up books from the hotel and airport on the required dates
denmark as a leading city of knowledge
the service they would like to offer. they show the hotel reception. business.
spreading, not only to danish citizens.
them how the system would work.
carrying out face to the library checks that
-A delivery system between the hotels and library
face transactions if all the books have
for the books would have to be implemented.
the hotel guest been returned by the
comes directly to the required date, and
library to change their charges the hotel if
books this is not the case
Full system diagram of our service, outlining the roles of the hotel, library and the key
touchpoints that are needed for the system to work
36.
37. Are guests interested in looking at books and potentially other library
material they did not bring with them?
Are hotels willing to implement a book service into their existing system?
What material would guests of hotels most like to see, what books would
be most useful?
What sort of hotels would this collaborative service suit?
Does the library have a problem charging hotels money for this service?
Questions we wanted to try and answer
through our experience prototyping
38. Initial visits to hotels to promote the new service and speak to guests and
members of staff, to gage initial reactions.
Dan Hostel
Radisson SAS, Fredriksberg
Comfort Hotel, østerbro
D’angleterre
A one week experience prototype at Hotel Fox
Getting Feedback from Pernille about the service concept (showing her inital concept video)
Different methods we used to try and answer our assumptions we
had made
39. “When i get home i just want to sit and relax, I may not always read, but it would
be great to have the option of having them their, reading a little is good, it is good
for the eyes and good for the mind”
“This hotel definitly needs it, there is nothing here at all, you even have to order in
your own food!”
Indian Business Man
“If I was really interested in a book i was reading and didn’t have time to read it all
(captain Mehra)
before i left, i would try and find it in the next place he was going”
Travels between India and
Copenhagen Frequently
Had been staying the the
Comfort Hotel for 3 months
to date
“People very rarely ask for books, our guests are either on holiday or
business men, they don’t want books, i am chief concierge here, i know my
guests and they are not the sort of people who want books, if they need
information we provide it for them on Copenhagen, we provide the service for
them!”
Head Concierge at
D’angleterre
Opinions we got from visiting hotels in the initial stages of our experience
prototyping
40. We were lucky enough to be able to conduct a 1 week
experiment at hotel fox
41. A selection of books that were mainly promoting Danish design and culture
42. Bookmarks with advice on other books to read and places to visit if they
enjoyed that book
43. Welcome packs containing an information brochure, a catalogue of the books, order forms and
feedback forms. These were give to the guests on arrival to the hotel
44. “oh wow thats lovely”
An english couple’s reaction when
hearing about the service during
check-in
45. “ I Would like to see ‘classic’ books
and Films/DVDs’s would be useful”
Pedersen, regular guest at hotel FOX (didn’t
loan a book, but filled in the feedback form)
46.
47. The Hotel FOX was very interested and happy to take part in the pilot service
The hotel found the service easy to integrate, the receptionists were great at
promoting the new service and handing out brochures was natural to them as the guests
checked in
The best responses came from people who stayed for more than a couple nights,
who had more relaxation time
‘Copenhagen Architecture’ was first book to be checked out!
Guests of the hotel were generally very happy when told about the service, they liked the
idea of having the option there if they wanted it
People enjoyed reading recommendations that were pre-placed in the books
The service was easy to implement, but difficult to manage with a single stakeholder,
and without a system in place
learnings from experience prototyping Insights we gained from our experience prototyping
48.
49. What happens when library books can be accessed through multiple stakeholders? Books travel in
new ways?
50. What happens when library books can be accessed anywhere in the world? People travel in new ways?
51. This is possible with ebooks, but what about physical books? A new business opportunity exists. Business
people and other frequent travelers, people and airlines that want to carry less and all who love to read can
benefit