SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 23
Download to read offline
PPM and PMO in the current market

 In relation with Strategic Goals, IT Governance and
     lessons learned from implemented Solutions




Spring 2012




Capgemini
Authors:         Klaas Bruinsma
                 Erwin Dunnink
                 Yves Vervloesem
                 Hendrik Zondag




Capgemini Nederland B.V.                                            Capgemini Belgium N.V./S.A.
Papendorpse weg 100                                                 Bessenveldstraat 19
PO Box 2575 – 3500 GN Utrecht                                       B-1831 Diegem
Phone. +31 30 689 00 00                                             Phone: +32 2 708 1111


© 2012 Capgemini. No part of this document may be modified, deleted or expanded by any process or
means without prior written approval from Capgemini
Table of Contents
Foreword........................................................................................................................ 3

1.     Introduction ........................................................................................................... 4

2.     PPM and Strategic Goals ...................................................................................... 5

3.     Governance is Key in the PPM Organization ...................................................... 9

4.     PPM Solutions (Processes, Methods and Tools) .............................................. 13

5.     Our vision on the future of PPM and PMO ........................................................ 17




                                                                                 PPM and PMO in the current market                   1
PPM and PMO in the current market   2
Foreword

At Capgemini, we have a passion for Project Portfolio Management (PPM) and Project
Management, and our thought leadership in this area is evidenced by the books, surveys and
papers that our consultants contributed to in the past few years. In these publications we aim to
share our insights and experiences gained in the field.
The last couple of years, supporting functions like PMOs have become an increasingly important
element in improving governance of the project-based organization. Therefore, this study is built
on a survey that treats PPM processes and tools, as well as the role of PMOs in organizations.
The authors (Klaas Bruinsma, Erwin Dunnink, Yves Vervloesem, and Hendrik Zondag) have
distilled the main findings from the survey and placed these in light of recent developments in the
area of PPM and PMOs.
I would like to thank the respondents for their time and effort to share their experience.
I hope that you enjoy reading this paper and especially that you can combine our thought
leadership with yours, in order to help you grow even further.


Lia de Zoete
Principal Consultant PPM/PMO




                                                                PPM and PMO in the current market     3
1.      Introduction

In 2011 we sent out a questionnaire of 51 questions to learn more about how our customers and
other contacts are dealing with their Project and Portfolio Management (PPM) including the
support and governance around it enabled by the PMO’s, and received responses from 34 of our
customers and contacts, in a variety of organizations.

Exhibit 1: Distribution of responses across industries

                                                                                Finance
                                                                                Public
                                                                                Industry
                                                                                Retail
                                                                                Non-Profit
                                                                                Consultancy & IT
                                                                                Research & Development

Based on our integrated approach (exhibit 2) to Project Portfolio Management (PPM) and Project
Management Offices (PMO’s), the findings are clustered around the following four topics:
■ PPM and Strategic Goals
■ Governance is Key in the PPM Organization
■ PPM Solutions (Processes, Methods and Tools)
■ Our vision on the future of PPM and PMO


In our experience, the components in the figure below are key in bringing about improvement in
project-based organizations. And in order to bring or maintain this continuous and sustainable
improvement, all the areas (exhibit 2) need to be addressed in a pace that can be absorbed by
the organization. The bottom-line is that we see organizations getting grip on status and financials
of their investment portfolios through an integrated approach.


Exhibit 2: Our integrated approach for improving Project-based organizations

                                            Strategy
                             Strategic Mapping & KPI Dashboarding
                                  Benefits Mapping & Tracking
                                         Benefits Logic


                  People                                     Organization
            Competence profiles                       Project- versus line organization
        Personal development of PM’s                  Project Management organization
          PM training & Assessment                             Portfolio Office
                   Coaching                              Project Management Office
         PM Awareness for sponsors                         Project Support Office
           Change way of working                   Assessments (Quick Scan, P3M3, OPM3)
          Project team collaboration                            Project Centre


                Processes
             Integrate new methods
      Management of issues, risk, changes                Methods and Tools
      Project and Programme Management              Project Portfolio Management Solutions
                    processes                                        Reporting
       Portfolio Management processes:                              Interfacing
            Transformation mapping                   Project archiving and lessons learned
                 Road mapping                           Project Management Templates
      Capacity and Resource Management
               Portfolio constrains




                                                                                   PPM and PMO in the current market   4
2.        PPM and Strategic Goals

Project Portfolio Management (PPM) and Project Management Offices (PMO) contain the
disciplines of strategic alignment, prioritization and governance of initiatives, projects and
programs. Within this definition, governance encompasses the structures, accountabilities,
policies, standards, processes and control mechanisms that are the basis for decision-making.
They help to answer the key strategic questions 'Are we doing the right things?', 'Are we doing
them the right way?' and ‘Are we realizing the benefits?’.
Project and programs are set up related to a variety of strategic goals. The survey shows that
‘Cost Reduction’ is the most common objective, followed by ‘Quality Improvement’ and ‘Quality &
Governance’. ‘Growth’ is not today’s most important objective, our respondents claim.

Exhibit 3: Programs/Projects are carried out with the following strategic goals


                          1. Cost Reduction                             54

                    2. Quality Improvement                         46

                   3. Quality & Governance                         46

 4. Projects external customers as a service                  42

                     5. Compliance Legacy                    38

                                  6. Growth             25

                                               0   25              50              75

Project and program governance is needed to provide a decision-making framework that is
logical, robust and repeatable to govern an organization’s capital investments. In this way,
strategic goals remain the guiding lines.
Respondents indicate that Project Portfolio Governance works best in the areas of ‘Planning’ and
‘Progress Monitoring and Control’. For risk management the survey shows that there is still a
large area of improvement. Too often risk & issue management has a detailed project-based
view. With regard to risk management, the solutions used could improve by offering an integrated
approach to risks and issues for the investments that are part of the portfolio. This may explain
the increasing interest for methods like Management of Risk (MoR ™).




                                                                  PPM and PMO in the current market   5
Exhibit 4: Governance of Project Portfolio works well in these areas

 100%

  75%

  50%

  25%
                                                                                                                                                        N/A
   0%                                                                                                                                                   Disagree



                                                 Planning




                                                                                                                                         Organization
                                                            Progress (Monitoring &
           Change management



                               Risk management




                                                                                     Business Case Management



                                                                                                                    Quality Management
                                                                                                                                                        Agree




                                                                   Control)


Portfolios are mainly defined per business line (62%) and not in the first place per strategic goal
(23%).

Exhibit 5: Criteria around which portfolios are created


                                                                                                                Business Line (62%)

                                                                                                                Supplier (0%)

                                                                                                                Funder (0%)

                                                                                                                Product Line (8% )

                                                                                                                Strategic goal (23%)

                                                                                                                Other (8%)


Management of these portfolios is seen on all levels from corporate (31%), divisional (23%), to
department (15%) level. This requires different levels of analysis of partially the same data.

Exhibit 6: Levels of Portfolio Management


                                                                                                                 Corporate (31%)

                                                                                                                 Division (23%)

                                                                                                                 Department (15%)

                                                                                                                 Other (31%)



If we look at the criteria around which portfolios are created it seems contradictory that the survey
showed that strategic goals are the guiding lines for balancing portfolios. This is however not a
contradiction: business lines (product lines in some organizations) contain and translate corporate
strategic goals into their portfolios, and these strategic drivers are then used to align portfolios on.


                                                                                                                                         PPM and PMO in the current market   6
To balance the portfolio, the main criteria on which projects are prioritized are ‘Strategic
alignment’ and ‘Resource Utilization’.

Exhibit 7: Basis for balancing portfolios

 100%

  75%

  50%

  25%
                                                                                                                                                              Disagree
                                                                                                                                                              Agree
      0%



                                                                             Resource Utilization


                                                                                                    Time-to-Market
                Optimize risk


                                Short and long term




                                                                                                                              We Don't prioritize and
                                                      Strategic Alignment




                                                                                                                     Budget
                                      effects




                                                                                                                                   optimize
Two-thirds of respondents acknowledge rebalancing portfolios is an essential part of truly
‘managing’ portfolios. Still more than half of the respondents indicate that their organizations’
portfolios are not well-balanced. For most, the Portfolio balance and content is reviewed several
times per year and most portfolios (67%) are re-balanced up to 3 times a year. Over 50% thinks
that their portfolio is not balanced well enough. The frequency of re-balancing however (multiple
times per year) indicates that portfolio management becomes decoupled from an annual budget
cycle (once per year). The importance of re-balancing portfolios seems acknowledged, and also
the importance as an input for the budget cycle.
One explanation for this high number of sub-optimally balanced portfolios is that more than half of
respondents answered that projects, once underway, are not killed. Even when their business
case is no longer valid, or projects with a higher priority need to be absorbed in the portfolio.

Exhibit 8: Respondents that actually stop Projects (and Programs)

 50



 25



  0
           Strongly Agree                     Agree (25%)                   Disagree (42%) Strongly disagree
               (17%)                                                                            (17%)



Further improvement can be found in re-evaluating running projects when re-balancing the
portfolio (so not contemplating future projects only).




                                                                                                                                                        PPM and PMO in the current market   7
Exhibit 9: Biggest challenges to establish a well functioning Portfolio Management

                         1. Required Competence
                        2. Decision making power
                       3. Mandate and Ownership
       4. Aggregation and availability of right data
           5. Internal Politics and power struggles
                 6. Clear process and procedures
               7. Guidelines and methods/models
 8. Too many interdependencies between projects
     9. Too many programs programs and projects

                                                       0           25            50             75              100

The multiple challenges above suggest that true Portfolio Management is still hampered,
especially by a lack of mandate, decision making power and in the first place by the required
competences for managing portfolios.
On the other hand we notice in our engagements that portfolio management and governance
practices have increased significantly. In a study of 2008, a number of challenges for IT portfolio
management were defined1. How well are some of these challenges currently addressed,
according to this survey?

Exhibit 10: Challenges for IT Portfolio Management
                 Study of 2008                                                  This Survey
Make IT portfolio selection a continuous                   With 67% updating 1-3 times a year, this challenge
process with frequent update cycles                        seems to be addressed
Consider financial but also non-financial                  With strong focus on strategic alignment and
criteria e.g. impact on strategy,                          resource utilization this indicates a shift away from
attractiveness, or probability of success                  only using financial criteria.
Aim for a more systematic approach and                     ‘Mandate and Ownership’ as well as ‘Internal Politics
accept the dominating factor of IT project                 and power struggles ‘still appear as clear challenges.
selection is still gut feeling and political               New Portfolio Management standards and
influence                                                  frameworks address this challenge (by setting up e.g.
                                                           Portfolio Offices, and by making management buy-in
                                                           a condition for portfolio management)


All together we see that the governance of Project Portfolio Management still has room for
improvement. It is noted as well that a process running well is not a given. Facilitating governance
by setting up specific organizational structures (like PMOs) or supporting Project Portfolio
Management (PPM) solutions can help.
In the introduction, we also mentioned Organization as a key component in improving project
based organizations. Let us take a look at how PMOs, as part of the organization, can improve
PPM practices.



 1
  Empirical Study into the State of Practice and Challenges in IT Project Portfolio Management’ [2008 -
Egon Gleisberg, Hendrik Zondag, Michel R.V. Chaudron]

                                                                            PPM and PMO in the current market         8
3.      Governance is Key in the PPM Organization

In the last couple of years, companies improved their Project and Portfolio Management by
defining and improving the processes within the PPM domain, especially concerning the resource
and capacity management and the project and portfolio management. Organizations also
implemented Project delivery methodologies like PRINCE2 and PPM Tools.
All respondents in the survey have adopted a formal project method, and only 15% indicated that
projects are not always managed according to this –formal by definition- method.

Exhibit 11: Projects are managed according a formal project methodology

 75

 50

 25

  0
       Strongly Agree   Agree (62%)   Disagree (15%)   Strongly disagree
           (23%)                                             (0%)

Having these PPM processes, methodologies and tools in place enables a company in getting
more grip on managing investments. Reaching a higher level of maturity can be achieved when
the organization around these PPM processes, methods and tools is set up correctly as well.
A PMO Office contributes to the right governance by:
■ Checking that the agreed methodologies and processes are followed;
■ Supporting the correct usage of tools;
■ Providing the means for control (as well on project level as on a higher managerial level).
In this way, a well functioning PMO can establish a standardized way of gathering project
intelligence and facilitate the right governance within the project and portfolio management of an
organization.
From our survey we learn that over 75% of the organizations have a support organization in
place. The majority of these organizations (54%) have a support organization set up per Business
Line, 8% have a centralized PMO set up and 15% have it set up according the Hub and Spoke
model where there is a centralized PMO with multiple smaller support offices located in different
parts of the business.


Exhibit 12: Organizational forms of PMOs



                                                                    Hub and Spoke Model (15%)

                                                                    Decentralised PMO's per BL (54%)

                                                                    One centralized PMO (8%)

                                                                    N/A (23%)




                                                                   PPM and PMO in the current market   9
The maturity of a support organization can be determined based on the tasks & responsibilities of
the PMO, how well PPM is covered by processes, methodologies and tools and if the organization
is set up with clear governance structure to get the best out of these processes and tools.

Exhibit 13: Main responsibilities of a PMO
     Project Management                             Program Management                        Portfolio Management
            Office                                         Office                                      Office
                                                                                     1. Administering
  1. Giving support                        1. Giving support                            the project,
                                                                                    program, portfolio
2. Administering the                        2. Administering
                                                                                            2. Staffing
 project, program,                             the project,
                                                                                             projects
       portfolio                           program, portfolio
     3. Supplying                              3. Supplying
                                                                                       3. Advising top
 standards for tools                          standards for
                                                                                        management
      for projects                          tools for projects
                                               4. Maintaining                        4. Managing the
 4. Staffing projects                          processes and                        portfolio, program,
                                                  methods                                 project
     5. Maintaining                                5. Staffing
     processes and                                  projects                         5. Giving support
        methods
                                              6. Advising top                          6. Supplying
  6. IT-Projects and
                                               management                           standards for tools
  business projects
                                                                                       for projects
  7. Managing the                            7. Competence                              7. Maintaining
 portfolio, program,                          Development                               processes and
       project                                                                             methods
     8. Advising top                       8. IT-Projects and                          8. Competence
      management                           business projects                            Development
                                            9. Managing the
    9. Competence                               portfolio,                          9. IT-Projects and
     Development                            program, project                        business projects

                        0   25   50   75                         0   25   50   75                         0   25   50   75




The survey shows that the main responsibility of the project and program support offices lies
within giving support and administering the projects and programs as well as supplying standards
for tools. The portfolio office main responsibility besides administrating the portfolio is to staff
projects and advise top management.




                                                                                PPM and PMO in the current market            10
Exhibit 14: Areas in which the governance of project portfolios works well

 100%

  75%

  50%

  25%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        N/A
   0%                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Disagree




                                                                                                                                          Planning




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Organization
                                                                                                                                                                                             Progress (Monitoring &
                      Change management




                                                                                   Risk management




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Business Case Management




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Quality Management
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Agree




                                                                                                                                                                                                    Control)
Having the processes and tooling in place should enable the right governance within the
organization. According to the survey we see that governance of the project portfolio works well
for ‘Change Management’, ‘Planning’ and ‘Progress (Monitoring and Control)’.


Exhibit 15: Areas in which the governance of programs works well

  100%


  75%


  50%


  25%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        N/A
   0%                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Disagree
                                                                                                                                                     Planning




                                                                                                                                                                                                           Monitoring & Control




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Organization
          Blueprint




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               Communication & Stakeholder Mngt
                                                                                                                                                                Management of Dependencies
                                          Benefit management

                                                               change management

                                                                                                     issue management

                                                                                                                        risk management




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Financial Management

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Business Case Management

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   Quality Management




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Resource Management




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Agree




Governance of programs works well for ‘Management of Dependencies’, ‘Monitoring & Control’,
‘Business Case Management’ and ‘Communication & Stakeholder Management’.
The survey however show that the governance of ‘risk management’ is not working well for both
programs and the project portfolio. An area to which a support office (PMO) can clearly contribute.



                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   PPM and PMO in the current market                                                                               11
Companies seem to acknowledge the added value of a good functioning PMO because
respondents indicate that organizations with temporary PMOs consider setting up a permanent
PMO.

Exhibit 16: Plan to extend/improve PMO Services within the next 2 years

                  6 Months                             12 months                                2 years


   1. Supplying tools                       1. Maintaining                         1. Competence
       for projects                         processes and                           Development
                                               methods
      2. Maintaining
                                                                                    2. Operational
      processes and                    2. Administering the
                                                                                       Projects
         methods                          project portfolio
                                                                                3. Managing the
                                         3. Managing the
  3. Staffing projects                                                         portfolio, program,
                                        portfolio, program,
                                              project                                project
 4. Administering the
                                         4. Giving Support                      4. Giving Support
    project portfolio

   5. IT-Projects and                                                           5. Supplying tools
   Business projects                    5. Staffing projects                        for projects

   6. Managing the
                                            6. Operational                    6. Administering the
  portfolio, program,
                                               Projects                          project portfolio
        project
      7. Operational                     7. Supplying tools                        7. Advising top
         Projects                            for projects                           Management

                                           8. Competence                        8. IT-Projects and
   8. Giving Support
                                            Development                         Business projects
                                                                                   9. Maintaining
     9. Competence                          9. Advising top                        processes and
      Development                            Management
                                                                                      methods
    10. Advising top                   10. IT-Projects and
                                                                              10. Staffing projects
     Management                         Business projects

                         0   25   50                           0   25   50                            0   25   50


Respondents indicate they expect that within the next six months PMO Services will focus on
supplying tools for projects and maintaining processes and methods. Within the next year there
will be more focus on portfolio management and giving support. On the longer run (2 years)
PMOs will start focusing on competence development within the organization.
These increasing responsibilities of support offices require that the project portfolio processes are
truly embedded and have matured.




                                                                        PPM and PMO in the current market           12
4.      PPM Solutions (Processes, Methods and Tools)

In this section, we focus on automated solutions called Project Portfolio Management applications
(tools) including the methods and processes around it.
Most participant in the survey use some form of PPM solutions to help support the project related
processes in their organization. And they use a wide variety of solutions. Some have chosen for a
full blown PPM solution, others manage their processes with home-grown solutions. The
important resemblance is that a common way to register and track projects, programmes and
portfolios in an organization is key. A PPM solution offers this support.
The following figure shows the solutions in use among the respondents in this survey.

Exhibit 17: PPM Solutions/tools in use

                                                    Home Grown
          Principal Toolbox                            6%
                                                                 Clarity
                10%
                                                                  32%
       Other PPM Tool
             10%




                                                                           EPM
                  None                                                     13%
                  26%
                                              MS Project
                                                 3%

Next to “real” PPM solutions, spreadsheets play an important role in controlling and managing the
project-related processes. This is common in almost all organizations. The main reason for this is
that everyone has spreadsheet software installed on their personal computer, and because of the
enormous flexibility it offers. There are however also some pitfalls, particularly from an
organizational point of view, the main one being that there is no single source of truth.
Over the past years, 74% of the participants have chosen to implement a PPM solution to boost
support for the PPM processes. Still it is recognized by 77% of the respondents that the role of
the project manager is a more important factor in project success than processes and solutions. It
underscores the title of this section that PPM solutions can only support.
Several studies have made clear that it is not easy for organizations to really gain the benefits of
PPM applications. Also this survey shows that only a very limited portion of the available
functionality is actually used. Next to this it is recognized that developing the key project portfolio
management necessities are a prerequisite for a proper use of the application. An approach we
recognize and which is also clearly visible in the results of this survey. When asked which
processes are supported in their organizations respondents indicated the following:




                                                                  PPM and PMO in the current market       13
Exhibit 18: PPM Management areas that are supported by IT Tooling

 100%

  75%

  50%

  25%                                                                                                                                                      N/A
     0%                                                                                                                                                    Disagree



                                                Program / Project




                                                                                              Management




                                                                                                             Project Control
                 Portfolio Management




                                                                        Resource Management




                                                                                                                                    Knowledge Management
                                                                                              Project Cost
                                                                                                                                                           Agree


                                                  Management




We also learn that the main PPM processes covered by tooling are ‘Program / Project
Management’, ‘Resource Management’ and ‘Knowledge Management’. Surprisingly respondents
indicate tooling is hardly used for actual ‘Portfolio Management’, while this is a PPM process that
can benefit from an appropriate use of tooling (although there is more than just a mathematical
character to it, e.g. politics).
This is significantly lower than the outcomes of a previous survey conducted by Capgemini in 2007
                                            2
around PPM Solutions and IT Governance . At that time 44% of the respondents in that survey
indicated they used some form of tooling to support portfolio management. The same trend was noted
in the area of ‘Resource Management’.
Another interesting angle is the question whether the objectives stated before implementation of a
PPM solution are actually reached. Most respondents at least partially reached the most
important goals set beforehand, being getting more grip on ‘Planning and Control’ and improved
‘Standardization’ of the PPM processes. The figures are however not very promising. Not even
half of the respondents feel they have at least partially reached the goals for ‘Coordination &
Communication’ and for ‘Transparency’.


Exhibit 19: Objectives for implementing a PPM Solution


               1. Planning & Control
                   2. Standardization
 3. Coordination and Communication
                     4. Transparency
                   5. Time to Market
          6. Knowledge Management
                                    7. Cost reduction
                                    8. Quality Control
                                                                    0                           25                             50                                  75




 2
     PPM Solutions for IT Governance – The User Perspective [2007-08 – Tjie-Jau Man, Erwin Dunnink]

                                                                                                             PPM and PMO in the current market                          14
Exhibit 20: Overview of how well the objectives of the 4 most important goals for a PPM
solution have been reached after implementation

                 Planning & Control                                                   Standardization
 50                                                                50




 25                                                                25




  0                                                                 0
      Not reached Hardly    Reached        Well      Fully              Not reached Hardly    Reached       Well      Fully
         at all   reached   half way     reached   reached                 at all   reached   half way    reached   reached



          Coordination & Communication                                                 Transparency
 50                                                                50




 25                                                                25




  0                                                                 0
      Not reached Hardly    Reached        Well      Fully              Not reached Hardly    Reached       Well      Fully
         at all   reached   half way     reached   reached                 at all   reached   half way    reached   reached


When comparing the figures to the results of the survey of 2007, the most important differences is
the area of what has been achieved. In 2007 we published the following graph:

Exhibit 21: Objectives of the Tool, versus achieved (Survey 2007)

               Planning&Control

                   Transparency

                 Standardisation

 Coordination&Communication

                  Cost reduction

                 Time-to-market

                            Other

                  Quality Control

                                    0%      10%    20%       30%        40%   50%     60%     70%        80%   90%    100%


                                            % respondents selecting this objective
                                            % achieved after software implementation

Next to some minor differences in what respondent see as the most important goals, the scores
for “achieve after software implementation” are lower now in 2012.
These differences might be explained by something we already recognized in 2007. When asked
for the satisfaction with the PPM solution versus any other home-grown solutions (often based on
Excel) we reported that about 25% was very satisfied with their PPM solution whereas almost
40% was very satisfied with their home-grown solution. The last couple of years organizations

                                                                                  PPM and PMO in the current market           15
started to move away from the idea that the PPM solution should support all their PPM processes
and invested more in point solutions, if needed based on Excel.

Exhibit 22:



                     50%
  % of respondents




                     40%
                     30%
                     20%
                     10%
                     0%
                           Very dissatisfied                          Very satisfied

                                           PPM solution   Other tools


Of course there always remain aspects to be improved. When asked on which areas the
respondents envision to invest the next 12 -18 months regarding PPM solutions the scores are
more or less evenly spread:

Exhibit 23: Functional areas to invest in

                             Portfolio Management                                Program / Project Management
 60                                                                      60
 40                                                                      40
 20                                                                      20
  0                                                                       0
                       Improve or      (Switch to)    No plans for               Improve or      (Switch to)    No plans for
                     extend current     New tool     improvement               extend current     New tool     improvement
                          tool                                                      tool


                            Resource Management                                        Project Cost Management
 60                                                                      60
 40                                                                      40
 20                                                                      20
  0                                                                       0
                       Improve or      (Switch to)    No plans for               Improve or      (Switch to)    No plans for
                     extend current     New tool     improvement               extend current     New tool     improvement
                          tool                                                      tool


                                  Project Control                                      Knowledge Management
 60                                                                       60
 40                                                                       40
 20                                                                       20
  0                                                                        0
                       Improve or      (Switch to)     No plans for               Improve or     (Switch to)    No plans for
                      extend current    New tool      improvement               extend current    New tool     improvement
                           tool                                                      tool

Looking at these figures the respondents want to invest in a further enhancement of the support
by the solutions. Some by extending an existing solution, others by implementing a new
application. These initiatives will further improve the support of PPM processes.



                                                                                           PPM and PMO in the current market   16
5.           Our vision on the future of PPM and PMO

Now that we have an idea on how most organizations work today, let us assess the directions in
which organizations could evolve in terms of PPM and PMO over the next two years.
When looking at the processes to be supported the respondents indicated the following:

Exhibit 24: Plan to extend/improve PPM Processes within the next 2 years

                   6 Months                            12 months                               2 years

          1. Resource
           Allocation                    1. Time & Expense                     1. Financial Project
          Management                        Management                            Management

 2. Project Execution                       2. Customer and
                                                                               2. Program Delivery
     Management                                 Partner
                                                                                   Management
                                              management

 3. Program Delivery                      3. Idea & Portfolio                    3. Idea & Portfolio
     Management                              Management                             Management

  4. Service Delivery                    4. Financial Project                  4. Project Execution
     Management                             Management                             Management

  5. Financial Project                         5. Resource
                                                                                5. Service Delivery
     Management                                 Allocation
                                                                                   Management
                                               Management
                                                6. Project
  6. Time & Expense                                                            6. Time & Expense
                                                Execution
     Management                                                                   Management
                                               Management
                                                                                      7. Resource
  7. Customer and                         7. Service Delivery
                                                                                       Allocation
Partner management                           Management
                                                                                      Management

     8. Idea & Portfolio                 8. Program Delivery                    8. Customer and
        Management                           Management                       Partner management

                           0   25   50                          0   25   50                            0   25   50




Based on the results from the survey as well as our experience we note a number of interesting
trends in the organizations we serve:
■ On the Organization side: a demand from the business to participate more actively in PPM,
  both as an information provider to IT (what are the business strategies and requirements) as
  well as an IT-information user (what is the status of the projects that I’m funding IT for). We
  could call this “Corporate” Project Portfolio Management, moving away from IT PPM, thereby
  further strengthening the focus on value delivered through projects, and further aligning
  Business with IT, a trend started in the mid-2000s. This will also cause support offices
  (portfolio offices) to continue to grow, as traditionally IT has been slightly more mature in PPM.
  We see PMOs moving from a temporary project level to a continuous support entity for
  portfolios of projects, on a higher level in the organization. Understanding the project pipeline
  is key in true project portfolio management. This necessitates a sufficiently frequent updating
  of individual project information, like current schedule, value, planned cost, and strategic
  alignment. PMOs, empowered by senior management, continue to drive further
  professionalization of the PPM organization, which includes the quest for more reliable and
  timely project information quality. Enhancing this project information quality enables more
  dynamic Project Portfolio Management.
■ On the Process side: an increased demand for executing projects in an agile mode. As more
  and more product or software-developing organizations adopt an agile approach to

                                                                         PPM and PMO in the current market           17
development, it should also leave the liberty to these self-organizing teams to choose how
   they plan and track. This means the organization as a whole will have to provide operating
   environments in which continuously help to remove the impediments that hinder teams
   executing their project (using a Scrum framework, but also the more classic waterfall
   frameworks).
   Furthermore, currently the planned benefit (value) that projects will deliver is often not properly
   measured or followed through. However, in an environment of continuous improvement and of
   frequent re-ordering of priority, management of value during the execution phase will increase
   in importance.
■ On the Tools/Solutions side: a demand for BYO (Bring Your Own) Devices. An increasing
  number of employees in every organizations have purchased their own ICT device such as a
  personal netbook, smartphone, tablet, etcetera, because this device fits their needs better than
  the devices offered by their own organization. Although this may seems trivial in the area of
  PPM, we note the first PPM Solution vendors offering access to (part of) their solution through
  tablet, smartphone, and so on. This trend supports (and is supported by) another ‘continuing’
  trend: SaaS or zero-client applications, and apps that support very personal productivity
  needs, so that personal devices can still ‘contribute to’ enterprise-level management
  information. With regard to communication: a demand for Collaborative Communication and
  Document Sharing, replacing e-mail and attachments. In the coming years, as total change
  budgets are expected to remain rather flat, it is key to optimize which initiatives to fund and
  which to discard. Within departmental portfolios, we see rebalancing of funds between
  projects. However, in order to optimize even further, departmental portfolios will increasingly
  be an integral part of the organizational (corporate) portfolio. This means a multi-level,
  integrated portfolio management, and will therefore also necessitate proper departmental and
  corporate portfolio management, in addition to a solution that supports these management
  activities.
The above, in our opinion, will have the following impacts on PPM/PMO processes and tools:
■ Organizations will continue to focus on implementing PPM tool support as “vanilla” as
  possible. This means they are willing to adapt their processes to a certain extent to the
  standard possibilities which a tool offers. Processes supported include pure planning and
  tracking purposes both in a very detailed and a very high-level manner, so that Scrum teams
  can still participate in the tooling ecosystem. Data ‘related’ to the PPM processes, like HR,
  Finance, and so on, will be managed only in the respective tools that support those functions
  (HR applications, Finance & Accounting systems, and so on). Organizations will move away
  from an approach in which the PPM solution is highly customized to be able to deal with this
  data. Organizations will rather ‘integrate’ the data collected in the PPM tool with data collected
  in non-PPM tools by means of business intelligence (BI) solutions. With the reporting out of
  these BI solutions, useful ‘integrated views’ can be produced.
■ Secondly we expect to see more PPM processes (and tools) that deal with Project and Service
  Portfolio Management. After all, resources (infrastructure, financial, and human) are allocated
  to both projects and services, so they need to be managed as one ecosystem.
■ Finally, organizations looking at “the cost of PPM” realize that PPM and PMOs have become a
  necessary investment, which is returning not only qualitative benefits, but also quantitative.
  They also realize they can further improve or rationalize the organization (e.g. find synergies,
  centralize), people competences (e.g., coach on data quality, and proper use of process and
  tooling), the tooling (e.g. keep the tooling useful, use only what you need), and processes
  (straight-through processing of project-based information with less manual intervention, and
  ‘good enough’ processes). These investments in improvement, while reducing overall cost, will
  even increase the benefits, as the capability increases to actually manage project portfolios,
  and not just ‘look at’ project portfolios.




                                                                PPM and PMO in the current market        18
Final Conclusion
In line with our surveys and research of the past, this survey again indicates that PMOs and PPM
Solutions are important, although not the most important part in improving the project-based
organization.
A holistic, balanced approach to a step-by-step but simultaneous improvement of People /
Organization / Process / Tools (all in support of the Business Strategy) is still the most likely to
yield positive results in project-based organizations.




                                                               PPM and PMO in the current market       19

More Related Content

What's hot (20)

PMO - Added value instead of administration
PMO - Added value instead of administrationPMO - Added value instead of administration
PMO - Added value instead of administration
 
Establishing an Effective PMO
Establishing an Effective PMOEstablishing an Effective PMO
Establishing an Effective PMO
 
Project Management Office (PMO)
Project Management Office (PMO)Project Management Office (PMO)
Project Management Office (PMO)
 
Program & project management (pmo)
Program & project management (pmo)Program & project management (pmo)
Program & project management (pmo)
 
eCIO PPT What is a PMO
eCIO PPT What is a PMOeCIO PPT What is a PMO
eCIO PPT What is a PMO
 
Pmo final 1
Pmo final 1Pmo final 1
Pmo final 1
 
Business PMO & IT Pmo What Is The Difference
Business PMO & IT Pmo What Is The DifferenceBusiness PMO & IT Pmo What Is The Difference
Business PMO & IT Pmo What Is The Difference
 
Setting up a Project Management Office (PMO)
Setting up a Project Management Office (PMO)Setting up a Project Management Office (PMO)
Setting up a Project Management Office (PMO)
 
PMO (Project Management Office)
PMO (Project Management Office)PMO (Project Management Office)
PMO (Project Management Office)
 
PMO 101
PMO 101PMO 101
PMO 101
 
Pmo Why?
Pmo Why?Pmo Why?
Pmo Why?
 
PMO - Delivering Business Results
PMO - Delivering Business ResultsPMO - Delivering Business Results
PMO - Delivering Business Results
 
PMO View Interactive Dashboard
PMO View Interactive DashboardPMO View Interactive Dashboard
PMO View Interactive Dashboard
 
Establishing an effective epmo
Establishing an effective epmoEstablishing an effective epmo
Establishing an effective epmo
 
Setting up a pmo
Setting up a pmoSetting up a pmo
Setting up a pmo
 
PMO Presentation
PMO PresentationPMO Presentation
PMO Presentation
 
Oim Pmo It Governance Structure Cox
Oim Pmo It Governance Structure CoxOim Pmo It Governance Structure Cox
Oim Pmo It Governance Structure Cox
 
Creating & Maturing a PMO
Creating & Maturing a PMOCreating & Maturing a PMO
Creating & Maturing a PMO
 
Real example of PMO deployment
Real example of PMO deploymentReal example of PMO deployment
Real example of PMO deployment
 
Building a pmo
Building a pmoBuilding a pmo
Building a pmo
 

Viewers also liked

Ppm Solutions For It Governance, The User Perspective
Ppm Solutions For It Governance, The User PerspectivePpm Solutions For It Governance, The User Perspective
Ppm Solutions For It Governance, The User Perspectiveerwin_dunnink
 
Ppm Solutions Functional Perspective
Ppm Solutions Functional PerspectivePpm Solutions Functional Perspective
Ppm Solutions Functional Perspectiveerwin_dunnink
 
SAFe portfolio management @ Knowit nov 28
SAFe portfolio management @ Knowit nov 28SAFe portfolio management @ Knowit nov 28
SAFe portfolio management @ Knowit nov 28Knowit_TM
 
Project Management Framework automation for Project and Portfolio Management ...
Project Management Framework automation for Project and Portfolio Management ...Project Management Framework automation for Project and Portfolio Management ...
Project Management Framework automation for Project and Portfolio Management ...PMILebanonChapter
 
Glue and sticking together - a story by Capgemini on Yammer
Glue and sticking together - a story by Capgemini on YammerGlue and sticking together - a story by Capgemini on Yammer
Glue and sticking together - a story by Capgemini on YammerCapgemini
 
Geeli all(2)
Geeli all(2)Geeli all(2)
Geeli all(2)Apoorva
 
List posts: Why people love and hate Lists. Curation Tips for List Makers
List posts: Why people love and hate Lists. Curation Tips for List MakersList posts: Why people love and hate Lists. Curation Tips for List Makers
List posts: Why people love and hate Lists. Curation Tips for List MakersNick Kellet
 
Acatistul Sf. Nicolae
Acatistul Sf. NicolaeAcatistul Sf. Nicolae
Acatistul Sf. NicolaeAlin Cazacu
 
Uganda Martyrs University
Uganda Martyrs UniversityUganda Martyrs University
Uganda Martyrs UniversityAbraham Kule
 
Lxsykj
LxsykjLxsykj
Lxsykj880205
 
Cristian frasinaru curs practic de java
Cristian frasinaru   curs practic de javaCristian frasinaru   curs practic de java
Cristian frasinaru curs practic de javaCorniciuc Oana
 
Hướng dẫn cài đặt và crack Vijeo Designer 6
Hướng dẫn cài đặt và crack Vijeo Designer 6Hướng dẫn cài đặt và crack Vijeo Designer 6
Hướng dẫn cài đặt và crack Vijeo Designer 6locbachkhoa
 
Gingko Biloba Revista Fitomédica
Gingko Biloba Revista FitomédicaGingko Biloba Revista Fitomédica
Gingko Biloba Revista FitomédicaNeuromon 21
 
Finding Singapore Cases and Legislation
Finding Singapore Cases and LegislationFinding Singapore Cases and Legislation
Finding Singapore Cases and Legislationisc_library
 

Viewers also liked (20)

PMO Frameworks
PMO FrameworksPMO Frameworks
PMO Frameworks
 
Gartner pmo best in class
Gartner pmo best in classGartner pmo best in class
Gartner pmo best in class
 
Ppm Solutions For It Governance, The User Perspective
Ppm Solutions For It Governance, The User PerspectivePpm Solutions For It Governance, The User Perspective
Ppm Solutions For It Governance, The User Perspective
 
Ppm Solutions Functional Perspective
Ppm Solutions Functional PerspectivePpm Solutions Functional Perspective
Ppm Solutions Functional Perspective
 
SAFe portfolio management @ Knowit nov 28
SAFe portfolio management @ Knowit nov 28SAFe portfolio management @ Knowit nov 28
SAFe portfolio management @ Knowit nov 28
 
Project Management Framework automation for Project and Portfolio Management ...
Project Management Framework automation for Project and Portfolio Management ...Project Management Framework automation for Project and Portfolio Management ...
Project Management Framework automation for Project and Portfolio Management ...
 
Glue and sticking together - a story by Capgemini on Yammer
Glue and sticking together - a story by Capgemini on YammerGlue and sticking together - a story by Capgemini on Yammer
Glue and sticking together - a story by Capgemini on Yammer
 
Geeli all(2)
Geeli all(2)Geeli all(2)
Geeli all(2)
 
History Design_ Surrealism
History Design_ SurrealismHistory Design_ Surrealism
History Design_ Surrealism
 
List posts: Why people love and hate Lists. Curation Tips for List Makers
List posts: Why people love and hate Lists. Curation Tips for List MakersList posts: Why people love and hate Lists. Curation Tips for List Makers
List posts: Why people love and hate Lists. Curation Tips for List Makers
 
Acatistul Sf. Nicolae
Acatistul Sf. NicolaeAcatistul Sf. Nicolae
Acatistul Sf. Nicolae
 
Uganda Martyrs University
Uganda Martyrs UniversityUganda Martyrs University
Uganda Martyrs University
 
TEXOCT2015
TEXOCT2015TEXOCT2015
TEXOCT2015
 
Lxsykj
LxsykjLxsykj
Lxsykj
 
Geografía
GeografíaGeografía
Geografía
 
Cristian frasinaru curs practic de java
Cristian frasinaru   curs practic de javaCristian frasinaru   curs practic de java
Cristian frasinaru curs practic de java
 
Hướng dẫn cài đặt và crack Vijeo Designer 6
Hướng dẫn cài đặt và crack Vijeo Designer 6Hướng dẫn cài đặt và crack Vijeo Designer 6
Hướng dẫn cài đặt và crack Vijeo Designer 6
 
Cap1 limites e continuidade
Cap1   limites e continuidadeCap1   limites e continuidade
Cap1 limites e continuidade
 
Gingko Biloba Revista Fitomédica
Gingko Biloba Revista FitomédicaGingko Biloba Revista Fitomédica
Gingko Biloba Revista Fitomédica
 
Finding Singapore Cases and Legislation
Finding Singapore Cases and LegislationFinding Singapore Cases and Legislation
Finding Singapore Cases and Legislation
 

Similar to PPM and PMO In The Current Market

Project Management - Beyond the Finish Line
Project Management - Beyond the Finish LineProject Management - Beyond the Finish Line
Project Management - Beyond the Finish LineDATA Inc.
 
Project Management Career Seminar
Project Management Career SeminarProject Management Career Seminar
Project Management Career SeminarOjiugo Ajunwa
 
Project management career seminar
Project management career seminarProject management career seminar
Project management career seminarOjiugo Ajunwa
 
Project Portfolio Management - An insiders overview
Project Portfolio Management - An insiders overviewProject Portfolio Management - An insiders overview
Project Portfolio Management - An insiders overviewSaji Madapat
 
Vijay Prasad - Project Management - part 2 (Ukrainian PM Community)
Vijay Prasad - Project Management  - part 2 (Ukrainian PM Community)Vijay Prasad - Project Management  - part 2 (Ukrainian PM Community)
Vijay Prasad - Project Management - part 2 (Ukrainian PM Community)mandrew182
 
Vijay Prasad - Project Management - part 2 (Ukrainian PM Community)
Vijay Prasad - Project Management - part 2 (Ukrainian PM Community)Vijay Prasad - Project Management - part 2 (Ukrainian PM Community)
Vijay Prasad - Project Management - part 2 (Ukrainian PM Community)mandrew182
 
Project Management . The Change Agent
Project Management . The Change AgentProject Management . The Change Agent
Project Management . The Change AgentSoftServe
 
Project Management . The Change Agent Vijay Prasad M.Tech, PMP
Project Management . The Change Agent Vijay Prasad M.Tech, PMPProject Management . The Change Agent Vijay Prasad M.Tech, PMP
Project Management . The Change Agent Vijay Prasad M.Tech, PMPSoftServe
 
How Project Management Office (PMO) Can Revolutionize Your Business.pdf
How Project Management Office (PMO) Can Revolutionize Your Business.pdfHow Project Management Office (PMO) Can Revolutionize Your Business.pdf
How Project Management Office (PMO) Can Revolutionize Your Business.pdfPMOGlobalInstitute
 
Pmi ppm 100514 keynote
 Pmi ppm 100514 keynote Pmi ppm 100514 keynote
Pmi ppm 100514 keynoteRobert Twiddy
 
Soutenance These Gianluca Costanzi
Soutenance These Gianluca CostanziSoutenance These Gianluca Costanzi
Soutenance These Gianluca CostanziGianluca Costanzi
 
Taking Your Pmo To The Next Level
Taking Your Pmo To The Next  LevelTaking Your Pmo To The Next  Level
Taking Your Pmo To The Next Levelrrigores
 
P3M3 - Discovery Assessment
P3M3 - Discovery AssessmentP3M3 - Discovery Assessment
P3M3 - Discovery AssessmentProfeo
 
Nicolas Schobinger | Business Transformation Academy - Post Merger Integratio...
Nicolas Schobinger | Business Transformation Academy - Post Merger Integratio...Nicolas Schobinger | Business Transformation Academy - Post Merger Integratio...
Nicolas Schobinger | Business Transformation Academy - Post Merger Integratio...Nicolas Schobinger
 
Austerity Implications for Project Management
Austerity Implications for Project ManagementAusterity Implications for Project Management
Austerity Implications for Project ManagementAndyMurray
 
PMO of the Year Award 2011 eBook
PMO of the Year Award 2011 eBookPMO of the Year Award 2011 eBook
PMO of the Year Award 2011 eBookPM Solutions
 
Project Management Office Vol. 1 - One Page Gold Vol. 1
Project Management Office Vol. 1  - One Page Gold Vol. 1Project Management Office Vol. 1  - One Page Gold Vol. 1
Project Management Office Vol. 1 - One Page Gold Vol. 1ken martin
 

Similar to PPM and PMO In The Current Market (20)

Project Management - Beyond the Finish Line
Project Management - Beyond the Finish LineProject Management - Beyond the Finish Line
Project Management - Beyond the Finish Line
 
Project Management Career Seminar
Project Management Career SeminarProject Management Career Seminar
Project Management Career Seminar
 
Project management career seminar
Project management career seminarProject management career seminar
Project management career seminar
 
Project Portfolio Management - An insiders overview
Project Portfolio Management - An insiders overviewProject Portfolio Management - An insiders overview
Project Portfolio Management - An insiders overview
 
Vijay Prasad - Project Management - part 2 (Ukrainian PM Community)
Vijay Prasad - Project Management  - part 2 (Ukrainian PM Community)Vijay Prasad - Project Management  - part 2 (Ukrainian PM Community)
Vijay Prasad - Project Management - part 2 (Ukrainian PM Community)
 
Vijay Prasad - Project Management - part 2 (Ukrainian PM Community)
Vijay Prasad - Project Management - part 2 (Ukrainian PM Community)Vijay Prasad - Project Management - part 2 (Ukrainian PM Community)
Vijay Prasad - Project Management - part 2 (Ukrainian PM Community)
 
Project Management . The Change Agent
Project Management . The Change AgentProject Management . The Change Agent
Project Management . The Change Agent
 
Project Management . The Change Agent Vijay Prasad M.Tech, PMP
Project Management . The Change Agent Vijay Prasad M.Tech, PMPProject Management . The Change Agent Vijay Prasad M.Tech, PMP
Project Management . The Change Agent Vijay Prasad M.Tech, PMP
 
Building a Case for PPM
Building a Case for PPMBuilding a Case for PPM
Building a Case for PPM
 
How Project Management Office (PMO) Can Revolutionize Your Business.pdf
How Project Management Office (PMO) Can Revolutionize Your Business.pdfHow Project Management Office (PMO) Can Revolutionize Your Business.pdf
How Project Management Office (PMO) Can Revolutionize Your Business.pdf
 
Pmi ppm 100514 keynote
 Pmi ppm 100514 keynote Pmi ppm 100514 keynote
Pmi ppm 100514 keynote
 
Soutenance These Gianluca Costanzi
Soutenance These Gianluca CostanziSoutenance These Gianluca Costanzi
Soutenance These Gianluca Costanzi
 
Taking Your Pmo To The Next Level
Taking Your Pmo To The Next  LevelTaking Your Pmo To The Next  Level
Taking Your Pmo To The Next Level
 
P3M3 - Discovery Assessment
P3M3 - Discovery AssessmentP3M3 - Discovery Assessment
P3M3 - Discovery Assessment
 
Nicolas Schobinger | Business Transformation Academy - Post Merger Integratio...
Nicolas Schobinger | Business Transformation Academy - Post Merger Integratio...Nicolas Schobinger | Business Transformation Academy - Post Merger Integratio...
Nicolas Schobinger | Business Transformation Academy - Post Merger Integratio...
 
Austerity Implications for Project Management
Austerity Implications for Project ManagementAusterity Implications for Project Management
Austerity Implications for Project Management
 
PMC4
PMC4PMC4
PMC4
 
Presentation Moscow December 2014
Presentation Moscow December 2014Presentation Moscow December 2014
Presentation Moscow December 2014
 
PMO of the Year Award 2011 eBook
PMO of the Year Award 2011 eBookPMO of the Year Award 2011 eBook
PMO of the Year Award 2011 eBook
 
Project Management Office Vol. 1 - One Page Gold Vol. 1
Project Management Office Vol. 1  - One Page Gold Vol. 1Project Management Office Vol. 1  - One Page Gold Vol. 1
Project Management Office Vol. 1 - One Page Gold Vol. 1
 

PPM and PMO In The Current Market

  • 1. PPM and PMO in the current market In relation with Strategic Goals, IT Governance and lessons learned from implemented Solutions Spring 2012 Capgemini
  • 2.
  • 3. Authors: Klaas Bruinsma Erwin Dunnink Yves Vervloesem Hendrik Zondag Capgemini Nederland B.V. Capgemini Belgium N.V./S.A. Papendorpse weg 100 Bessenveldstraat 19 PO Box 2575 – 3500 GN Utrecht B-1831 Diegem Phone. +31 30 689 00 00 Phone: +32 2 708 1111 © 2012 Capgemini. No part of this document may be modified, deleted or expanded by any process or means without prior written approval from Capgemini
  • 4.
  • 5. Table of Contents Foreword........................................................................................................................ 3 1. Introduction ........................................................................................................... 4 2. PPM and Strategic Goals ...................................................................................... 5 3. Governance is Key in the PPM Organization ...................................................... 9 4. PPM Solutions (Processes, Methods and Tools) .............................................. 13 5. Our vision on the future of PPM and PMO ........................................................ 17 PPM and PMO in the current market 1
  • 6. PPM and PMO in the current market 2
  • 7. Foreword At Capgemini, we have a passion for Project Portfolio Management (PPM) and Project Management, and our thought leadership in this area is evidenced by the books, surveys and papers that our consultants contributed to in the past few years. In these publications we aim to share our insights and experiences gained in the field. The last couple of years, supporting functions like PMOs have become an increasingly important element in improving governance of the project-based organization. Therefore, this study is built on a survey that treats PPM processes and tools, as well as the role of PMOs in organizations. The authors (Klaas Bruinsma, Erwin Dunnink, Yves Vervloesem, and Hendrik Zondag) have distilled the main findings from the survey and placed these in light of recent developments in the area of PPM and PMOs. I would like to thank the respondents for their time and effort to share their experience. I hope that you enjoy reading this paper and especially that you can combine our thought leadership with yours, in order to help you grow even further. Lia de Zoete Principal Consultant PPM/PMO PPM and PMO in the current market 3
  • 8. 1. Introduction In 2011 we sent out a questionnaire of 51 questions to learn more about how our customers and other contacts are dealing with their Project and Portfolio Management (PPM) including the support and governance around it enabled by the PMO’s, and received responses from 34 of our customers and contacts, in a variety of organizations. Exhibit 1: Distribution of responses across industries Finance Public Industry Retail Non-Profit Consultancy & IT Research & Development Based on our integrated approach (exhibit 2) to Project Portfolio Management (PPM) and Project Management Offices (PMO’s), the findings are clustered around the following four topics: ■ PPM and Strategic Goals ■ Governance is Key in the PPM Organization ■ PPM Solutions (Processes, Methods and Tools) ■ Our vision on the future of PPM and PMO In our experience, the components in the figure below are key in bringing about improvement in project-based organizations. And in order to bring or maintain this continuous and sustainable improvement, all the areas (exhibit 2) need to be addressed in a pace that can be absorbed by the organization. The bottom-line is that we see organizations getting grip on status and financials of their investment portfolios through an integrated approach. Exhibit 2: Our integrated approach for improving Project-based organizations Strategy Strategic Mapping & KPI Dashboarding Benefits Mapping & Tracking Benefits Logic People Organization Competence profiles Project- versus line organization Personal development of PM’s Project Management organization PM training & Assessment Portfolio Office Coaching Project Management Office PM Awareness for sponsors Project Support Office Change way of working Assessments (Quick Scan, P3M3, OPM3) Project team collaboration Project Centre Processes Integrate new methods Management of issues, risk, changes Methods and Tools Project and Programme Management Project Portfolio Management Solutions processes Reporting Portfolio Management processes: Interfacing Transformation mapping Project archiving and lessons learned Road mapping Project Management Templates Capacity and Resource Management Portfolio constrains PPM and PMO in the current market 4
  • 9. 2. PPM and Strategic Goals Project Portfolio Management (PPM) and Project Management Offices (PMO) contain the disciplines of strategic alignment, prioritization and governance of initiatives, projects and programs. Within this definition, governance encompasses the structures, accountabilities, policies, standards, processes and control mechanisms that are the basis for decision-making. They help to answer the key strategic questions 'Are we doing the right things?', 'Are we doing them the right way?' and ‘Are we realizing the benefits?’. Project and programs are set up related to a variety of strategic goals. The survey shows that ‘Cost Reduction’ is the most common objective, followed by ‘Quality Improvement’ and ‘Quality & Governance’. ‘Growth’ is not today’s most important objective, our respondents claim. Exhibit 3: Programs/Projects are carried out with the following strategic goals 1. Cost Reduction 54 2. Quality Improvement 46 3. Quality & Governance 46 4. Projects external customers as a service 42 5. Compliance Legacy 38 6. Growth 25 0 25 50 75 Project and program governance is needed to provide a decision-making framework that is logical, robust and repeatable to govern an organization’s capital investments. In this way, strategic goals remain the guiding lines. Respondents indicate that Project Portfolio Governance works best in the areas of ‘Planning’ and ‘Progress Monitoring and Control’. For risk management the survey shows that there is still a large area of improvement. Too often risk & issue management has a detailed project-based view. With regard to risk management, the solutions used could improve by offering an integrated approach to risks and issues for the investments that are part of the portfolio. This may explain the increasing interest for methods like Management of Risk (MoR ™). PPM and PMO in the current market 5
  • 10. Exhibit 4: Governance of Project Portfolio works well in these areas 100% 75% 50% 25% N/A 0% Disagree Planning Organization Progress (Monitoring & Change management Risk management Business Case Management Quality Management Agree Control) Portfolios are mainly defined per business line (62%) and not in the first place per strategic goal (23%). Exhibit 5: Criteria around which portfolios are created Business Line (62%) Supplier (0%) Funder (0%) Product Line (8% ) Strategic goal (23%) Other (8%) Management of these portfolios is seen on all levels from corporate (31%), divisional (23%), to department (15%) level. This requires different levels of analysis of partially the same data. Exhibit 6: Levels of Portfolio Management Corporate (31%) Division (23%) Department (15%) Other (31%) If we look at the criteria around which portfolios are created it seems contradictory that the survey showed that strategic goals are the guiding lines for balancing portfolios. This is however not a contradiction: business lines (product lines in some organizations) contain and translate corporate strategic goals into their portfolios, and these strategic drivers are then used to align portfolios on. PPM and PMO in the current market 6
  • 11. To balance the portfolio, the main criteria on which projects are prioritized are ‘Strategic alignment’ and ‘Resource Utilization’. Exhibit 7: Basis for balancing portfolios 100% 75% 50% 25% Disagree Agree 0% Resource Utilization Time-to-Market Optimize risk Short and long term We Don't prioritize and Strategic Alignment Budget effects optimize Two-thirds of respondents acknowledge rebalancing portfolios is an essential part of truly ‘managing’ portfolios. Still more than half of the respondents indicate that their organizations’ portfolios are not well-balanced. For most, the Portfolio balance and content is reviewed several times per year and most portfolios (67%) are re-balanced up to 3 times a year. Over 50% thinks that their portfolio is not balanced well enough. The frequency of re-balancing however (multiple times per year) indicates that portfolio management becomes decoupled from an annual budget cycle (once per year). The importance of re-balancing portfolios seems acknowledged, and also the importance as an input for the budget cycle. One explanation for this high number of sub-optimally balanced portfolios is that more than half of respondents answered that projects, once underway, are not killed. Even when their business case is no longer valid, or projects with a higher priority need to be absorbed in the portfolio. Exhibit 8: Respondents that actually stop Projects (and Programs) 50 25 0 Strongly Agree Agree (25%) Disagree (42%) Strongly disagree (17%) (17%) Further improvement can be found in re-evaluating running projects when re-balancing the portfolio (so not contemplating future projects only). PPM and PMO in the current market 7
  • 12. Exhibit 9: Biggest challenges to establish a well functioning Portfolio Management 1. Required Competence 2. Decision making power 3. Mandate and Ownership 4. Aggregation and availability of right data 5. Internal Politics and power struggles 6. Clear process and procedures 7. Guidelines and methods/models 8. Too many interdependencies between projects 9. Too many programs programs and projects 0 25 50 75 100 The multiple challenges above suggest that true Portfolio Management is still hampered, especially by a lack of mandate, decision making power and in the first place by the required competences for managing portfolios. On the other hand we notice in our engagements that portfolio management and governance practices have increased significantly. In a study of 2008, a number of challenges for IT portfolio management were defined1. How well are some of these challenges currently addressed, according to this survey? Exhibit 10: Challenges for IT Portfolio Management Study of 2008 This Survey Make IT portfolio selection a continuous With 67% updating 1-3 times a year, this challenge process with frequent update cycles seems to be addressed Consider financial but also non-financial With strong focus on strategic alignment and criteria e.g. impact on strategy, resource utilization this indicates a shift away from attractiveness, or probability of success only using financial criteria. Aim for a more systematic approach and ‘Mandate and Ownership’ as well as ‘Internal Politics accept the dominating factor of IT project and power struggles ‘still appear as clear challenges. selection is still gut feeling and political New Portfolio Management standards and influence frameworks address this challenge (by setting up e.g. Portfolio Offices, and by making management buy-in a condition for portfolio management) All together we see that the governance of Project Portfolio Management still has room for improvement. It is noted as well that a process running well is not a given. Facilitating governance by setting up specific organizational structures (like PMOs) or supporting Project Portfolio Management (PPM) solutions can help. In the introduction, we also mentioned Organization as a key component in improving project based organizations. Let us take a look at how PMOs, as part of the organization, can improve PPM practices. 1 Empirical Study into the State of Practice and Challenges in IT Project Portfolio Management’ [2008 - Egon Gleisberg, Hendrik Zondag, Michel R.V. Chaudron] PPM and PMO in the current market 8
  • 13. 3. Governance is Key in the PPM Organization In the last couple of years, companies improved their Project and Portfolio Management by defining and improving the processes within the PPM domain, especially concerning the resource and capacity management and the project and portfolio management. Organizations also implemented Project delivery methodologies like PRINCE2 and PPM Tools. All respondents in the survey have adopted a formal project method, and only 15% indicated that projects are not always managed according to this –formal by definition- method. Exhibit 11: Projects are managed according a formal project methodology 75 50 25 0 Strongly Agree Agree (62%) Disagree (15%) Strongly disagree (23%) (0%) Having these PPM processes, methodologies and tools in place enables a company in getting more grip on managing investments. Reaching a higher level of maturity can be achieved when the organization around these PPM processes, methods and tools is set up correctly as well. A PMO Office contributes to the right governance by: ■ Checking that the agreed methodologies and processes are followed; ■ Supporting the correct usage of tools; ■ Providing the means for control (as well on project level as on a higher managerial level). In this way, a well functioning PMO can establish a standardized way of gathering project intelligence and facilitate the right governance within the project and portfolio management of an organization. From our survey we learn that over 75% of the organizations have a support organization in place. The majority of these organizations (54%) have a support organization set up per Business Line, 8% have a centralized PMO set up and 15% have it set up according the Hub and Spoke model where there is a centralized PMO with multiple smaller support offices located in different parts of the business. Exhibit 12: Organizational forms of PMOs Hub and Spoke Model (15%) Decentralised PMO's per BL (54%) One centralized PMO (8%) N/A (23%) PPM and PMO in the current market 9
  • 14. The maturity of a support organization can be determined based on the tasks & responsibilities of the PMO, how well PPM is covered by processes, methodologies and tools and if the organization is set up with clear governance structure to get the best out of these processes and tools. Exhibit 13: Main responsibilities of a PMO Project Management Program Management Portfolio Management Office Office Office 1. Administering 1. Giving support 1. Giving support the project, program, portfolio 2. Administering the 2. Administering 2. Staffing project, program, the project, projects portfolio program, portfolio 3. Supplying 3. Supplying 3. Advising top standards for tools standards for management for projects tools for projects 4. Maintaining 4. Managing the 4. Staffing projects processes and portfolio, program, methods project 5. Maintaining 5. Staffing processes and projects 5. Giving support methods 6. Advising top 6. Supplying 6. IT-Projects and management standards for tools business projects for projects 7. Managing the 7. Competence 7. Maintaining portfolio, program, Development processes and project methods 8. Advising top 8. IT-Projects and 8. Competence management business projects Development 9. Managing the 9. Competence portfolio, 9. IT-Projects and Development program, project business projects 0 25 50 75 0 25 50 75 0 25 50 75 The survey shows that the main responsibility of the project and program support offices lies within giving support and administering the projects and programs as well as supplying standards for tools. The portfolio office main responsibility besides administrating the portfolio is to staff projects and advise top management. PPM and PMO in the current market 10
  • 15. Exhibit 14: Areas in which the governance of project portfolios works well 100% 75% 50% 25% N/A 0% Disagree Planning Organization Progress (Monitoring & Change management Risk management Business Case Management Quality Management Agree Control) Having the processes and tooling in place should enable the right governance within the organization. According to the survey we see that governance of the project portfolio works well for ‘Change Management’, ‘Planning’ and ‘Progress (Monitoring and Control)’. Exhibit 15: Areas in which the governance of programs works well 100% 75% 50% 25% N/A 0% Disagree Planning Monitoring & Control Organization Blueprint Communication & Stakeholder Mngt Management of Dependencies Benefit management change management issue management risk management Financial Management Business Case Management Quality Management Resource Management Agree Governance of programs works well for ‘Management of Dependencies’, ‘Monitoring & Control’, ‘Business Case Management’ and ‘Communication & Stakeholder Management’. The survey however show that the governance of ‘risk management’ is not working well for both programs and the project portfolio. An area to which a support office (PMO) can clearly contribute. PPM and PMO in the current market 11
  • 16. Companies seem to acknowledge the added value of a good functioning PMO because respondents indicate that organizations with temporary PMOs consider setting up a permanent PMO. Exhibit 16: Plan to extend/improve PMO Services within the next 2 years 6 Months 12 months 2 years 1. Supplying tools 1. Maintaining 1. Competence for projects processes and Development methods 2. Maintaining 2. Operational processes and 2. Administering the Projects methods project portfolio 3. Managing the 3. Managing the 3. Staffing projects portfolio, program, portfolio, program, project project 4. Administering the 4. Giving Support 4. Giving Support project portfolio 5. IT-Projects and 5. Supplying tools Business projects 5. Staffing projects for projects 6. Managing the 6. Operational 6. Administering the portfolio, program, Projects project portfolio project 7. Operational 7. Supplying tools 7. Advising top Projects for projects Management 8. Competence 8. IT-Projects and 8. Giving Support Development Business projects 9. Maintaining 9. Competence 9. Advising top processes and Development Management methods 10. Advising top 10. IT-Projects and 10. Staffing projects Management Business projects 0 25 50 0 25 50 0 25 50 Respondents indicate they expect that within the next six months PMO Services will focus on supplying tools for projects and maintaining processes and methods. Within the next year there will be more focus on portfolio management and giving support. On the longer run (2 years) PMOs will start focusing on competence development within the organization. These increasing responsibilities of support offices require that the project portfolio processes are truly embedded and have matured. PPM and PMO in the current market 12
  • 17. 4. PPM Solutions (Processes, Methods and Tools) In this section, we focus on automated solutions called Project Portfolio Management applications (tools) including the methods and processes around it. Most participant in the survey use some form of PPM solutions to help support the project related processes in their organization. And they use a wide variety of solutions. Some have chosen for a full blown PPM solution, others manage their processes with home-grown solutions. The important resemblance is that a common way to register and track projects, programmes and portfolios in an organization is key. A PPM solution offers this support. The following figure shows the solutions in use among the respondents in this survey. Exhibit 17: PPM Solutions/tools in use Home Grown Principal Toolbox 6% Clarity 10% 32% Other PPM Tool 10% EPM None 13% 26% MS Project 3% Next to “real” PPM solutions, spreadsheets play an important role in controlling and managing the project-related processes. This is common in almost all organizations. The main reason for this is that everyone has spreadsheet software installed on their personal computer, and because of the enormous flexibility it offers. There are however also some pitfalls, particularly from an organizational point of view, the main one being that there is no single source of truth. Over the past years, 74% of the participants have chosen to implement a PPM solution to boost support for the PPM processes. Still it is recognized by 77% of the respondents that the role of the project manager is a more important factor in project success than processes and solutions. It underscores the title of this section that PPM solutions can only support. Several studies have made clear that it is not easy for organizations to really gain the benefits of PPM applications. Also this survey shows that only a very limited portion of the available functionality is actually used. Next to this it is recognized that developing the key project portfolio management necessities are a prerequisite for a proper use of the application. An approach we recognize and which is also clearly visible in the results of this survey. When asked which processes are supported in their organizations respondents indicated the following: PPM and PMO in the current market 13
  • 18. Exhibit 18: PPM Management areas that are supported by IT Tooling 100% 75% 50% 25% N/A 0% Disagree Program / Project Management Project Control Portfolio Management Resource Management Knowledge Management Project Cost Agree Management We also learn that the main PPM processes covered by tooling are ‘Program / Project Management’, ‘Resource Management’ and ‘Knowledge Management’. Surprisingly respondents indicate tooling is hardly used for actual ‘Portfolio Management’, while this is a PPM process that can benefit from an appropriate use of tooling (although there is more than just a mathematical character to it, e.g. politics). This is significantly lower than the outcomes of a previous survey conducted by Capgemini in 2007 2 around PPM Solutions and IT Governance . At that time 44% of the respondents in that survey indicated they used some form of tooling to support portfolio management. The same trend was noted in the area of ‘Resource Management’. Another interesting angle is the question whether the objectives stated before implementation of a PPM solution are actually reached. Most respondents at least partially reached the most important goals set beforehand, being getting more grip on ‘Planning and Control’ and improved ‘Standardization’ of the PPM processes. The figures are however not very promising. Not even half of the respondents feel they have at least partially reached the goals for ‘Coordination & Communication’ and for ‘Transparency’. Exhibit 19: Objectives for implementing a PPM Solution 1. Planning & Control 2. Standardization 3. Coordination and Communication 4. Transparency 5. Time to Market 6. Knowledge Management 7. Cost reduction 8. Quality Control 0 25 50 75 2 PPM Solutions for IT Governance – The User Perspective [2007-08 – Tjie-Jau Man, Erwin Dunnink] PPM and PMO in the current market 14
  • 19. Exhibit 20: Overview of how well the objectives of the 4 most important goals for a PPM solution have been reached after implementation Planning & Control Standardization 50 50 25 25 0 0 Not reached Hardly Reached Well Fully Not reached Hardly Reached Well Fully at all reached half way reached reached at all reached half way reached reached Coordination & Communication Transparency 50 50 25 25 0 0 Not reached Hardly Reached Well Fully Not reached Hardly Reached Well Fully at all reached half way reached reached at all reached half way reached reached When comparing the figures to the results of the survey of 2007, the most important differences is the area of what has been achieved. In 2007 we published the following graph: Exhibit 21: Objectives of the Tool, versus achieved (Survey 2007) Planning&Control Transparency Standardisation Coordination&Communication Cost reduction Time-to-market Other Quality Control 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% % respondents selecting this objective % achieved after software implementation Next to some minor differences in what respondent see as the most important goals, the scores for “achieve after software implementation” are lower now in 2012. These differences might be explained by something we already recognized in 2007. When asked for the satisfaction with the PPM solution versus any other home-grown solutions (often based on Excel) we reported that about 25% was very satisfied with their PPM solution whereas almost 40% was very satisfied with their home-grown solution. The last couple of years organizations PPM and PMO in the current market 15
  • 20. started to move away from the idea that the PPM solution should support all their PPM processes and invested more in point solutions, if needed based on Excel. Exhibit 22: 50% % of respondents 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Very dissatisfied Very satisfied PPM solution Other tools Of course there always remain aspects to be improved. When asked on which areas the respondents envision to invest the next 12 -18 months regarding PPM solutions the scores are more or less evenly spread: Exhibit 23: Functional areas to invest in Portfolio Management Program / Project Management 60 60 40 40 20 20 0 0 Improve or (Switch to) No plans for Improve or (Switch to) No plans for extend current New tool improvement extend current New tool improvement tool tool Resource Management Project Cost Management 60 60 40 40 20 20 0 0 Improve or (Switch to) No plans for Improve or (Switch to) No plans for extend current New tool improvement extend current New tool improvement tool tool Project Control Knowledge Management 60 60 40 40 20 20 0 0 Improve or (Switch to) No plans for Improve or (Switch to) No plans for extend current New tool improvement extend current New tool improvement tool tool Looking at these figures the respondents want to invest in a further enhancement of the support by the solutions. Some by extending an existing solution, others by implementing a new application. These initiatives will further improve the support of PPM processes. PPM and PMO in the current market 16
  • 21. 5. Our vision on the future of PPM and PMO Now that we have an idea on how most organizations work today, let us assess the directions in which organizations could evolve in terms of PPM and PMO over the next two years. When looking at the processes to be supported the respondents indicated the following: Exhibit 24: Plan to extend/improve PPM Processes within the next 2 years 6 Months 12 months 2 years 1. Resource Allocation 1. Time & Expense 1. Financial Project Management Management Management 2. Project Execution 2. Customer and 2. Program Delivery Management Partner Management management 3. Program Delivery 3. Idea & Portfolio 3. Idea & Portfolio Management Management Management 4. Service Delivery 4. Financial Project 4. Project Execution Management Management Management 5. Financial Project 5. Resource 5. Service Delivery Management Allocation Management Management 6. Project 6. Time & Expense 6. Time & Expense Execution Management Management Management 7. Resource 7. Customer and 7. Service Delivery Allocation Partner management Management Management 8. Idea & Portfolio 8. Program Delivery 8. Customer and Management Management Partner management 0 25 50 0 25 50 0 25 50 Based on the results from the survey as well as our experience we note a number of interesting trends in the organizations we serve: ■ On the Organization side: a demand from the business to participate more actively in PPM, both as an information provider to IT (what are the business strategies and requirements) as well as an IT-information user (what is the status of the projects that I’m funding IT for). We could call this “Corporate” Project Portfolio Management, moving away from IT PPM, thereby further strengthening the focus on value delivered through projects, and further aligning Business with IT, a trend started in the mid-2000s. This will also cause support offices (portfolio offices) to continue to grow, as traditionally IT has been slightly more mature in PPM. We see PMOs moving from a temporary project level to a continuous support entity for portfolios of projects, on a higher level in the organization. Understanding the project pipeline is key in true project portfolio management. This necessitates a sufficiently frequent updating of individual project information, like current schedule, value, planned cost, and strategic alignment. PMOs, empowered by senior management, continue to drive further professionalization of the PPM organization, which includes the quest for more reliable and timely project information quality. Enhancing this project information quality enables more dynamic Project Portfolio Management. ■ On the Process side: an increased demand for executing projects in an agile mode. As more and more product or software-developing organizations adopt an agile approach to PPM and PMO in the current market 17
  • 22. development, it should also leave the liberty to these self-organizing teams to choose how they plan and track. This means the organization as a whole will have to provide operating environments in which continuously help to remove the impediments that hinder teams executing their project (using a Scrum framework, but also the more classic waterfall frameworks). Furthermore, currently the planned benefit (value) that projects will deliver is often not properly measured or followed through. However, in an environment of continuous improvement and of frequent re-ordering of priority, management of value during the execution phase will increase in importance. ■ On the Tools/Solutions side: a demand for BYO (Bring Your Own) Devices. An increasing number of employees in every organizations have purchased their own ICT device such as a personal netbook, smartphone, tablet, etcetera, because this device fits their needs better than the devices offered by their own organization. Although this may seems trivial in the area of PPM, we note the first PPM Solution vendors offering access to (part of) their solution through tablet, smartphone, and so on. This trend supports (and is supported by) another ‘continuing’ trend: SaaS or zero-client applications, and apps that support very personal productivity needs, so that personal devices can still ‘contribute to’ enterprise-level management information. With regard to communication: a demand for Collaborative Communication and Document Sharing, replacing e-mail and attachments. In the coming years, as total change budgets are expected to remain rather flat, it is key to optimize which initiatives to fund and which to discard. Within departmental portfolios, we see rebalancing of funds between projects. However, in order to optimize even further, departmental portfolios will increasingly be an integral part of the organizational (corporate) portfolio. This means a multi-level, integrated portfolio management, and will therefore also necessitate proper departmental and corporate portfolio management, in addition to a solution that supports these management activities. The above, in our opinion, will have the following impacts on PPM/PMO processes and tools: ■ Organizations will continue to focus on implementing PPM tool support as “vanilla” as possible. This means they are willing to adapt their processes to a certain extent to the standard possibilities which a tool offers. Processes supported include pure planning and tracking purposes both in a very detailed and a very high-level manner, so that Scrum teams can still participate in the tooling ecosystem. Data ‘related’ to the PPM processes, like HR, Finance, and so on, will be managed only in the respective tools that support those functions (HR applications, Finance & Accounting systems, and so on). Organizations will move away from an approach in which the PPM solution is highly customized to be able to deal with this data. Organizations will rather ‘integrate’ the data collected in the PPM tool with data collected in non-PPM tools by means of business intelligence (BI) solutions. With the reporting out of these BI solutions, useful ‘integrated views’ can be produced. ■ Secondly we expect to see more PPM processes (and tools) that deal with Project and Service Portfolio Management. After all, resources (infrastructure, financial, and human) are allocated to both projects and services, so they need to be managed as one ecosystem. ■ Finally, organizations looking at “the cost of PPM” realize that PPM and PMOs have become a necessary investment, which is returning not only qualitative benefits, but also quantitative. They also realize they can further improve or rationalize the organization (e.g. find synergies, centralize), people competences (e.g., coach on data quality, and proper use of process and tooling), the tooling (e.g. keep the tooling useful, use only what you need), and processes (straight-through processing of project-based information with less manual intervention, and ‘good enough’ processes). These investments in improvement, while reducing overall cost, will even increase the benefits, as the capability increases to actually manage project portfolios, and not just ‘look at’ project portfolios. PPM and PMO in the current market 18
  • 23. Final Conclusion In line with our surveys and research of the past, this survey again indicates that PMOs and PPM Solutions are important, although not the most important part in improving the project-based organization. A holistic, balanced approach to a step-by-step but simultaneous improvement of People / Organization / Process / Tools (all in support of the Business Strategy) is still the most likely to yield positive results in project-based organizations. PPM and PMO in the current market 19