The document summarizes a session from the Coral Triangle Fishers Forum II on combating IUU fishing through the Coral Triangle Initiative. The CTI is a partnership between 6 countries aimed at safeguarding the Coral Triangle region's marine resources. The CTI goals include establishing MPAs, applying ecosystem approaches to fisheries management, and increasing climate change adaptation. The NOAA-led IUU team presented preliminary results from an MCS assessment identifying IUU fishing issues and capacity gaps. They discussed ongoing and planned IUU-related activities and trainings. Opportunities for further collaboration between the CTFF and CTI-IUU team were highlighted.
New from BookNet Canada for 2024: Loan Stars - Tech Forum 2024
Combating IUU Fishing through the CTI
1. Coral Triangle Fishers Forum II
Novotel Lami Bay, Suva, Fiji
18-20 June 2012
SESSION 4.2
Combating IUU Fishing through
the Coral Triangle Initiative
Ann Mooney (NOAA)
ann.mooney@noaa.gov
2. Coral Triangle Fishers Forum II
Novotel Lami Bay, Suva, Fiji
18-20 June 2012
Coral Triangle Initiative on Coral Reefs,
Fisheries, and Food Security (CTI)
Multilateral partnership to
safeguard Coral Triangle
Region’s marine & coastal
biological resources
Initiated 2007 by Indonesian
President Yudhoyono
Launched May 2009, when
CT6 heads of state signed CTI
The Coral Triangle is the hotspot of marine biological diversity,
shared within the waters of Indonesia, Malaysia, Papua New declaration & launched CTI
Guinea, Timor-Leste, the Philippines, and the Solomon Islands
Image: www.uscti.org Regional Plan of Action
3. CTI VISION
Improved Management of Biologically and
Economically Important Coastal and Marine Resources and its
Associated Ecosystems that Support the Livelihoods of Peoples
and Economies in the Coral Triangle
R1. Regional and national platforms strengthened to catalyze and sustain
integrated marine and coastal management in the Coral Triangle
NOAA’s focus w/in
IR1.1 Policies developed US CTI Results
and advanced
IR1.2 Institutional capacity and
Framework
collaboration strengthened
IR1.3 Learning and information
networks strengthened
IR1.4 Public and private sector
constituencies engaged
IR1.5 Sustainable financing mobilized
CTI GOAL 2
EAFM and other marine
resources fully applied
R2. EAFM improved in CT
CTI GOAL 3
MPAs established and
effectively managed
R3. MPA management
CTI GOAL 4
CC adaptation
measures achieved
R4. Capacity to adapt to
improved in CT climate change improved in CT
IR2.1 EAFM framework developed and IR3.1 MPA system framework IR4.1 Capacity to apply climate change
endorsed developed and endorsed adaptation strategies increased
IR2.2 Fisheries management capacity IR3.2 MPA management capacity IR4.2 Climate adaptation strategies
increased increased applied in priority geographies
IR2.3 Enforcement capacity increased IR3.3 MPA effectiveness improved in
IR2.4 EAFM applied in priority geographies priority geographies
4. Coral Triangle Fishers Forum II
Novotel Lami Bay, Suva, Fiji
18-20 June 2012
CT6/Partner Coordination
• Current IUU Group:
– CT6 MCS Organizations
• Sabah Fisheries, Sabah Parks
• Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources
• KKP
– NOAA Office of Law Enforcement
– NOAA Office of General Counsel for
Enforcement
– US Coast Guard
– US Dept. Of Justice
– International MCS Network
– Australia MCS Organizations
• Identify Additional CT6 MCS contacts
5. Coral Triangle Fishers Forum II
Novotel Lami Bay, Suva, Fiji
18-20 June 2012
NOAA-IUU team:
Todd Dubois (Assistant Director, NOAA Fisheries
Enforcement)
Meggan Engelke-Ros (NOAA General Counsel for
Enforcement)
Frank Giaretto (Pacific Island Division, NOAA
Fisheries Enforcement)
Gregg Casad (US Coast Guard)
Ann Mooney (NOAA Fisheries Enforcement)
6. Coral Triangle Fishers Forum II
Novotel Lami Bay, Suva, Fiji
18-20 June 2012
Coral Triangle Initiative
IUU Team Goals
– CT6 Participation in International MCS
Networks
– Integrated Fisheries MCS
– Coordinated Regional MCS Operations
(where appropriate)
– Harmonization of Legal
Frameworks/Fisheries Laws
– Self Sustained Fisheries MCS Training
Program
7. Coral Triangle Fishers Forum II
Novotel Lami Bay, Suva, Fiji
18-20 June 2012
Monitoring Control and Surveillance
Surveys
8. Coral Triangle Fishers Forum II
Novotel Lami Bay, Suva, Fiji
18-20 June 2012
Goals of the MCS Assessment:
Identify Areas of Known or
Suspected IUU Fishing Activity
Identify Fisheries MCS Capacity and
Gaps
Identify Applicable Fisheries
Legislation/Laws and Gaps
Identify Fisheries MCS Training
Needs
9. Coral Triangle Fishers Forum II
Novotel Lami Bay, Suva, Fiji
18-20 June 2012
MCS Assessment Results (Preliminary)
Papua New Guinea
Solomon Islands
Timor-Leste
Philippines
Indonesia
Malaysia
Foreign Vessels
Input : rules and regulations Domestic Vessels
catch accounting
gear
closed areas
output: rules and regulations electronic monitoring
at-sea
shoreside
legal
Enforcement System: communication
10. Coral Triangle Fishers Forum II
Novotel Lami Bay, Suva, Fiji
18-20 June 2012
CT6 requests for assistance
Papua New Guinea
Solomon Islands
Timor-Leste
Philippines
Indonesia
Malaysia
Foreign Vessels
Input : rules and regulations Domestic Vessels
catch accounting
gear
closed areas
output: rules and regulations electronic monitoring
at-sea
shoreside
legal
Enforcement System: communication
Foreign Vessels
Observer Program: presence Domestic Vessels
11. Coral Triangle Fishers Forum II
Novotel Lami Bay, Suva, Fiji
18-20 June 2012
EAFM REX I/II Objective 2: Reduce IUU fishing
through greater collaboration and increased
enforcement and awareness by 2017
1. Strengthen regional MCS through the RPOA IUU
2. Convene an MCS practitioner workshop (REX)
3. Develop best practices for MCS within CT
4. Develop proposal for Regional IUU information
centre
5. Analyse markets/trade routes of IUU to/from CT
12. Coral Triangle Fishers Forum II
Novotel Lami Bay, Suva, Fiji
18-20 June 2012
June 2012 IUU Team Activities
Port State Measures
Training 1 (Jakarta)
Coral Triangle Fishers
Forum-IUU
July 2012
Legal workshop
(Washington, DC)
August 2012
Transboundary training
(Philippines)
Port State Measures
Training 2 (tbd)
13. Coral Triangle Fishers Forum II
Novotel Lami Bay, Suva, Fiji
18-20 June 2012
Impacts of IUU Fishing
Worldwide: Up to US$23B lost
annually due to IUU activities
Economic
Resource
Social
Ecological
13
14. Coral Triangle Fishers Forum II
Novotel Lami Bay, Suva, Fiji
18-20 June 2012
Global IUU Initiatives
International Monitoring,
Control and Surveillance
(MCS) Network:
– enhanced cooperation
– coordination
– information collection/
exchange
INTERPOL IUU Working Group
– Initiated an ad hoc working group
on IUU Fishing (Bangkok – March
2012)
– Seeking international
collaboration on criminal IUU
activity
International Port State Measures
Agreement
15. Coral Triangle Fishers Forum II
Novotel Lami Bay, Suva, Fiji
18-20 June 2012
PSM Agreement Objectives
• First binding global
instrument focused
specifically on combating
IUU fishing
• Intended to combat IUU
fishing by eliminating “ports
of convenience,” thereby
preventing IUU fish from
entering the stream of
commerce.
• Sets minimum standards for
effective port state controls
16. Coral Triangle Fishers Forum II
Novotel Lami Bay, Suva, Fiji
18-20 June 2012
Port State Measures Agreement Training
Todd.Dubois@noaa.gov
Curriculum addresses:
• Inspection
• Denial of entry into port
or access to port services
to IUU vessels
• Flag State control
• Information sharing
• Capacity building
17. Coral Triangle Fishers Forum II
Novotel Lami Bay, Suva, Fiji
18-20 June 2012
Opportunities for collaboration
between CTFF and CTI-IUU team
Information sharing network/databases
Relationships/open dialogue outside G to G
Ideas??
6 million square kilometers of ocean and coastlines in Southeast Asia and the PacificOutline of triangle determined by the number of coral species foundIncludes all or part of the countries of Indonesia, Philippines, Papua New Guinea, Malaysia (only Sabah), East Timor, and the Solomon Islands (CT6)Eventually Fiji and Vanuatu will be added (CT6+2)More than 500 species of corals (example – Caribbean has maybe 100 species of coral and possibly 200 species of fish)More than 1000 species of fish Biodiversity – why it is important. Evolutionary safety net – when things fail, something can take its place. (north Atlantic – in less 50 years, collapse of cod drove failure of fishery)Potential pharmaceutical benefits
NOAA’s role within CTI is to focus on MPAs, CCA, and EAFM. Through the EAFM stream, The IUU team provides technical support and expertise to the planning process for fisheries managers and works with MCS practitioners to develop and strengthen their MCS capabilities
More specifically through CTI, the IUU team goals are to strengthen the capacity of the CT6 nations to combat IUU fishing within their waters and their shared maritime areas within the region. Before effective training could begin, an understanding of the current capacity was needed.
To facilitate gathering consistent information across the region, OLE and the IMCS Network developed an MCS-related questionnaire that walks through a national fishery, gathering information on the types of vessels fishing in domestic waters, target and bycatch species, authorized and illicit activity by foreign vessels, ports and port security, fisheries management practices, international legal obligations, and domestic legal frameworks. Representatives from the IUU team visited each of the CT6 countries to discuss and identify MCS colleagues across the region beginning in 2009 and wrapping up last fall. The MCS colleagues were identified by each country’s CTI national coordinating committee, the program integrator and also through using personal relationships developed over the years working to eliminate IUU Fishing. People present at the CTFF were really helpful, WWF Malaysia, NFA from PNG, WWF Philippines, Sabah Fisheries,
In an attempt to visualize the Summary results from the MCS assessments and identify the state of MCS capacity in each of the countries to develop the regional view of capacity to combat IUU fishing in the region we condensed all the results into a red/yellow/green chart where:Green=present and good to go (or minor tweaks needed)yellow= present but needs workRed=nonexistent, or lackingInput=controlling people who extract from the resource. ie how many boats/fishers are allowed to utilize the resource. Output=controlling what is coming out of the system. Fish extractedCommunication system=internal communications between MCS practitioners, and external communication with stakeholders.
Highlighted in blue are the CT6 requests for assistance which we use in addition to the survey results to ensure that our training plans are driven by the CT6 countries and meet the needs and wants of our country partners.
The most recent EAFM REX was held last month in Kuala Lumpur and an objective developed by the EAFM representatives was to reduce IUU fishing through greater collaboration and increased enforcement and awareness by 2017. The activities the CT6 countries identified as important to reach that goal are: 1,2,3,4,5 and over the course of a working session at the REX they identified key steps to make each of those action items happen. These activities, identified specifically by the CT6 countries in addition to the opportunities identified by the IUU team surveys can perhaps be a jumping off point for the CTFF members to engage with the CTI-IUU team both in the region and also in the broader, global context. From what we’ve discussed here, perhaps number 4 and 5 are a nice place to start.
Overview of the remainder of FY12, which in the US goes through September. FY13 plans have not been finalized but they will carryover on themes developed within this years’ trainings and workshops.
Why do we care? We are all aware of these issues but it’s good to remember that the effects span the entire spectrum from the artisanal fishers, to the small commercial, to the large commercial vessels engaged in the global market. At all levels there are impacts felt in:Economic: loss of revenue, loss of multiplier effects,Loss of potential export revenuesResource: damage to coastal stocks – overfishing, compromised management and assessment Social: conflict with domestic / artisanal fishers, food security/livelihoods jeopardised, undermine rule of lawEcological: damage to sensitive marine ecosystems, birds, turtles, sharks, mammals killed
Outside of the USCTI, NOAA’s role in international fisheries spans numerous Global IUU Initiatives. IMCS Coordination and Information sharing network, INTERPOL fisheries working group that was just established earlier this year and NOAA has been a leading force on the International Port State Measures Agreement to help keep IUU product out of the global market.MCS Network:A voluntary network of member countries committed to improving the efficiency and effectiveness of fisheries-related MCS activities through:
Inspection requirements:Requires annual level of inspections “sufficient to achieve the objectives” of the AgreementRequires Parties to designate ports to which vessels may request entry and ensure sufficient inspection capacity at those portsSets standardized requirements for advance notice of arrivalEstablishes criteria for prioritizing vessels to be inspectedSets minimum standards for the conduct of vessel inspections, including:Inspector training,Required inspection of all relevant areas, gear, equipment, documents, etc.,Inspection reports (completion and dissemination)Denial of Port Entry and Access to Port ServicesRequires Parties to deny entry into port to vessels included on RFMO IUU vessel lists.Port States may allow entry for inspection or other enforcement action.Requires Parties to deny entry into port and/or use of port services where the port State has sufficient proof that the vessel has been engaged in IUU fishing or fishing related activities in support of IUU fishing.Agreement requires Parties to:Require their vessels to cooperate with inspections by other PartiesInvestigate IUU activity detected during a port inspectionTake enforcement action in response to such activity where appropriate and share information about any such enforcement actionsEnsure that its flagged vessels are subject to measures that are at least as effective in preventing, deterring, and eliminating IUU fishing
PSM training is big push for the IUU team in response to the needs and requests of the CT6 nations. There is a training workshop being held in Indonesia this week to assist in developing appropriate legislation for Indonesia to be in compliance with this treaty. Part 2 of this training series will be focused on the operational side and should be happening in August, however the results of the current workshop will really drive that.