SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  17
Industry Approach to Consequential Damages How to maintain a win-win environment For  Banner Health A review by  Arpita Ghosh
What is a Consequential Damage ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Direct Damage  VS  Consequential Damage
Consequential Damages are hard to recover ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Problem faced by Banner Health ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
1 .  Why negotiation is a problem?? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
“ Perini Corp. VS Great Bay Hotel” Is it fair to the contractor??? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
2. Mutual Waiver Is it fair to the owner?? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],No bright line b/w Consequential & Direct damage
Alternatives: ,[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],4. Advantages of liquidated damages:
Disadvantages of liquidated damages: ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Industry approaches 1 ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Industry approaches 2 ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Can this be replicated? Registered/post Speed post Analogy ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Questions and Answers
References ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Lessons from the Courts: How to Limit Your Professional Liability
Lessons from the Courts: How to Limit Your Professional LiabilityLessons from the Courts: How to Limit Your Professional Liability
Lessons from the Courts: How to Limit Your Professional Liability EDR
 
Liquidated Damages post Cavendish v Makdessi
Liquidated Damages post Cavendish v MakdessiLiquidated Damages post Cavendish v Makdessi
Liquidated Damages post Cavendish v MakdessiAdam Ramlugon
 
Managing concessions in protected areas, Paul F J Eagles
Managing concessions in protected areas, Paul F J EaglesManaging concessions in protected areas, Paul F J Eagles
Managing concessions in protected areas, Paul F J EaglesAnna Spenceley
 
When Do Liquidated Damages Become an Irrecoverable Penalty?
When Do Liquidated Damages Become an Irrecoverable Penalty?When Do Liquidated Damages Become an Irrecoverable Penalty?
When Do Liquidated Damages Become an Irrecoverable Penalty?Sarah Fox
 
D&O Liability Insurance
D&O Liability InsuranceD&O Liability Insurance
D&O Liability InsuranceRam Garg
 
Allocation oct2013 WRAPs OCIPs Soup to Nuts or Nuts to Soup
Allocation oct2013 WRAPs OCIPs Soup to Nuts or Nuts to SoupAllocation oct2013 WRAPs OCIPs Soup to Nuts or Nuts to Soup
Allocation oct2013 WRAPs OCIPs Soup to Nuts or Nuts to SoupHB Litigation Conferences
 
Canterbury Earthquake - Homeowners Legal Perspective
Canterbury Earthquake - Homeowners Legal PerspectiveCanterbury Earthquake - Homeowners Legal Perspective
Canterbury Earthquake - Homeowners Legal PerspectiveEQCfix New Zealand
 
Subcontract Agreements
Subcontract AgreementsSubcontract Agreements
Subcontract AgreementsKevin Learned
 
Construction Accident Injury Coverage Options in NJ
Construction Accident Injury Coverage Options in NJConstruction Accident Injury Coverage Options in NJ
Construction Accident Injury Coverage Options in NJMike Dawson
 
Contractor's surety bond
Contractor's surety bondContractor's surety bond
Contractor's surety bondGary swiftbonds
 
Post Settlement Pitfalls 2009
Post Settlement Pitfalls 2009Post Settlement Pitfalls 2009
Post Settlement Pitfalls 2009bigfaz2009
 

Tendances (17)

Lessons from the Courts: How to Limit Your Professional Liability
Lessons from the Courts: How to Limit Your Professional LiabilityLessons from the Courts: How to Limit Your Professional Liability
Lessons from the Courts: How to Limit Your Professional Liability
 
Liquidated Damages post Cavendish v Makdessi
Liquidated Damages post Cavendish v MakdessiLiquidated Damages post Cavendish v Makdessi
Liquidated Damages post Cavendish v Makdessi
 
Umbrella
UmbrellaUmbrella
Umbrella
 
Managing concessions in protected areas, Paul F J Eagles
Managing concessions in protected areas, Paul F J EaglesManaging concessions in protected areas, Paul F J Eagles
Managing concessions in protected areas, Paul F J Eagles
 
When Do Liquidated Damages Become an Irrecoverable Penalty?
When Do Liquidated Damages Become an Irrecoverable Penalty?When Do Liquidated Damages Become an Irrecoverable Penalty?
When Do Liquidated Damages Become an Irrecoverable Penalty?
 
D&O Liability Insurance
D&O Liability InsuranceD&O Liability Insurance
D&O Liability Insurance
 
Allocation oct2013 WRAPs OCIPs
Allocation oct2013 WRAPs OCIPs Allocation oct2013 WRAPs OCIPs
Allocation oct2013 WRAPs OCIPs
 
Allocation oct2013 WRAPs OCIPs Soup to Nuts or Nuts to Soup
Allocation oct2013 WRAPs OCIPs Soup to Nuts or Nuts to SoupAllocation oct2013 WRAPs OCIPs Soup to Nuts or Nuts to Soup
Allocation oct2013 WRAPs OCIPs Soup to Nuts or Nuts to Soup
 
Ch11
Ch11Ch11
Ch11
 
R2R Meeting 5 pdf
R2R Meeting 5 pdfR2R Meeting 5 pdf
R2R Meeting 5 pdf
 
Canterbury Earthquake - Homeowners Legal Perspective
Canterbury Earthquake - Homeowners Legal PerspectiveCanterbury Earthquake - Homeowners Legal Perspective
Canterbury Earthquake - Homeowners Legal Perspective
 
Counseling
CounselingCounseling
Counseling
 
Subcontract Agreements
Subcontract AgreementsSubcontract Agreements
Subcontract Agreements
 
Construction Accident Injury Coverage Options in NJ
Construction Accident Injury Coverage Options in NJConstruction Accident Injury Coverage Options in NJ
Construction Accident Injury Coverage Options in NJ
 
Slide 3_Arpita
Slide 3_ArpitaSlide 3_Arpita
Slide 3_Arpita
 
Contractor's surety bond
Contractor's surety bondContractor's surety bond
Contractor's surety bond
 
Post Settlement Pitfalls 2009
Post Settlement Pitfalls 2009Post Settlement Pitfalls 2009
Post Settlement Pitfalls 2009
 

Similaire à Slide 2_Arpita

Master supply agreements - les régimes de responsabilité contractuelle aux usa
Master supply agreements - les régimes de responsabilité contractuelle aux usaMaster supply agreements - les régimes de responsabilité contractuelle aux usa
Master supply agreements - les régimes de responsabilité contractuelle aux usaEliot Norman
 
RFP and Negotiation Best Practices.pdf
RFP and Negotiation Best Practices.pdfRFP and Negotiation Best Practices.pdf
RFP and Negotiation Best Practices.pdfTaralee Zimmerman
 
Remedies of Contract Law | Main Principles
Remedies of Contract Law | Main PrinciplesRemedies of Contract Law | Main Principles
Remedies of Contract Law | Main Principlessahansathsarawegiriy1
 
Indemnity clauses - what they are, how they work and how to make them for you
Indemnity clauses - what they are, how they work and how to make them for youIndemnity clauses - what they are, how they work and how to make them for you
Indemnity clauses - what they are, how they work and how to make them for youmikaelastafrace
 
Liquidated damages contracts
Liquidated damages   contractsLiquidated damages   contracts
Liquidated damages contractsBhushan Goyal
 
Bulletin aerospace legal developments june 2013
Bulletin aerospace legal developments june 2013Bulletin aerospace legal developments june 2013
Bulletin aerospace legal developments june 2013Eliot Norman
 
Performance of Contracts to students.pptx
Performance of Contracts to students.pptxPerformance of Contracts to students.pptx
Performance of Contracts to students.pptxSharleeDekate
 
Subcontract Clauses.PPTX
Subcontract Clauses.PPTXSubcontract Clauses.PPTX
Subcontract Clauses.PPTXRyan Hatton
 
Rollits Construction Focus June 2016
Rollits Construction Focus June 2016 Rollits Construction Focus June 2016
Rollits Construction Focus June 2016 Pat Coyle
 
Surety Industry Overview: State of the Industry by Cissie Scoggin
Surety Industry Overview: State of the Industry by Cissie ScogginSurety Industry Overview: State of the Industry by Cissie Scoggin
Surety Industry Overview: State of the Industry by Cissie ScogginDon Grauel
 
Negotiating investor interest in indemnity clauses
Negotiating investor interest in indemnity clausesNegotiating investor interest in indemnity clauses
Negotiating investor interest in indemnity clausesAditi Duggal
 
RETS Presentation - Home Inspector's Insurance & Risk Management
RETS Presentation - Home Inspector's Insurance & Risk ManagementRETS Presentation - Home Inspector's Insurance & Risk Management
RETS Presentation - Home Inspector's Insurance & Risk ManagementGerald Brunker
 
Systech insights edition-Mark Woodward Smith
Systech insights edition-Mark Woodward Smith Systech insights edition-Mark Woodward Smith
Systech insights edition-Mark Woodward Smith mark woodward-smith
 
Subcontractor Default Insurance - Thomas Tripodianos & Anthony Carlucci, Welb...
Subcontractor Default Insurance - Thomas Tripodianos & Anthony Carlucci, Welb...Subcontractor Default Insurance - Thomas Tripodianos & Anthony Carlucci, Welb...
Subcontractor Default Insurance - Thomas Tripodianos & Anthony Carlucci, Welb...Ryan Slack
 
Home Inspector's Insurance & Risk Management - July 19, 2013
Home Inspector's Insurance & Risk Management - July 19, 2013Home Inspector's Insurance & Risk Management - July 19, 2013
Home Inspector's Insurance & Risk Management - July 19, 2013Gerald Brunker
 
PP2 - Seminar Presentation
PP2 - Seminar Presentation PP2 - Seminar Presentation
PP2 - Seminar Presentation Lin Hui
 
owner-controlled-insurance-programmes-ocips.pdf
owner-controlled-insurance-programmes-ocips.pdfowner-controlled-insurance-programmes-ocips.pdf
owner-controlled-insurance-programmes-ocips.pdfavenkatram
 
Contract and remedies
Contract and remedies Contract and remedies
Contract and remedies Babasab Patil
 

Similaire à Slide 2_Arpita (20)

Peo professional liability_mar15
Peo professional liability_mar15Peo professional liability_mar15
Peo professional liability_mar15
 
Master supply agreements - les régimes de responsabilité contractuelle aux usa
Master supply agreements - les régimes de responsabilité contractuelle aux usaMaster supply agreements - les régimes de responsabilité contractuelle aux usa
Master supply agreements - les régimes de responsabilité contractuelle aux usa
 
RFP and Negotiation Best Practices.pdf
RFP and Negotiation Best Practices.pdfRFP and Negotiation Best Practices.pdf
RFP and Negotiation Best Practices.pdf
 
Remedies of Contract Law | Main Principles
Remedies of Contract Law | Main PrinciplesRemedies of Contract Law | Main Principles
Remedies of Contract Law | Main Principles
 
Indemnity clauses - what they are, how they work and how to make them for you
Indemnity clauses - what they are, how they work and how to make them for youIndemnity clauses - what they are, how they work and how to make them for you
Indemnity clauses - what they are, how they work and how to make them for you
 
Liquidated damages contracts
Liquidated damages   contractsLiquidated damages   contracts
Liquidated damages contracts
 
Bulletin aerospace legal developments june 2013
Bulletin aerospace legal developments june 2013Bulletin aerospace legal developments june 2013
Bulletin aerospace legal developments june 2013
 
Performance of Contracts to students.pptx
Performance of Contracts to students.pptxPerformance of Contracts to students.pptx
Performance of Contracts to students.pptx
 
Subcontract Clauses.PPTX
Subcontract Clauses.PPTXSubcontract Clauses.PPTX
Subcontract Clauses.PPTX
 
Rollits Construction Focus June 2016
Rollits Construction Focus June 2016 Rollits Construction Focus June 2016
Rollits Construction Focus June 2016
 
Surety Industry Overview: State of the Industry by Cissie Scoggin
Surety Industry Overview: State of the Industry by Cissie ScogginSurety Industry Overview: State of the Industry by Cissie Scoggin
Surety Industry Overview: State of the Industry by Cissie Scoggin
 
Negotiating investor interest in indemnity clauses
Negotiating investor interest in indemnity clausesNegotiating investor interest in indemnity clauses
Negotiating investor interest in indemnity clauses
 
RETS Presentation - Home Inspector's Insurance & Risk Management
RETS Presentation - Home Inspector's Insurance & Risk ManagementRETS Presentation - Home Inspector's Insurance & Risk Management
RETS Presentation - Home Inspector's Insurance & Risk Management
 
Systech insights edition-Mark Woodward Smith
Systech insights edition-Mark Woodward Smith Systech insights edition-Mark Woodward Smith
Systech insights edition-Mark Woodward Smith
 
Subcontractor Default Insurance - Thomas Tripodianos & Anthony Carlucci, Welb...
Subcontractor Default Insurance - Thomas Tripodianos & Anthony Carlucci, Welb...Subcontractor Default Insurance - Thomas Tripodianos & Anthony Carlucci, Welb...
Subcontractor Default Insurance - Thomas Tripodianos & Anthony Carlucci, Welb...
 
Home Inspector's Insurance & Risk Management - July 19, 2013
Home Inspector's Insurance & Risk Management - July 19, 2013Home Inspector's Insurance & Risk Management - July 19, 2013
Home Inspector's Insurance & Risk Management - July 19, 2013
 
Bonds
BondsBonds
Bonds
 
PP2 - Seminar Presentation
PP2 - Seminar Presentation PP2 - Seminar Presentation
PP2 - Seminar Presentation
 
owner-controlled-insurance-programmes-ocips.pdf
owner-controlled-insurance-programmes-ocips.pdfowner-controlled-insurance-programmes-ocips.pdf
owner-controlled-insurance-programmes-ocips.pdf
 
Contract and remedies
Contract and remedies Contract and remedies
Contract and remedies
 

Slide 2_Arpita

Notes de l'éditeur

  1. No where in law it is said that the owner cannot recover consequential damages. But if the owner claims and the contractor disagrees there will be an inevitable dispute. If there is a dispute and the owner chooses to go to court it is extremely difficult to prove and recover consequential damages. So it is wise to avoid disputes.
  2. 2 nd problem-if AIA mutual waiver is practical for owner
  3. The plaintiff always attempt to prove consequential damage as direct damages to expedite recovery The contractor’s attempt is to describe the damages in consequential and waive it upfront while signing the contract
  4. Mention the foreseeable consequential damages