SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  29
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
John ǀ Cussen
                                          0655457
                                             0655457

                    Whiplash ǀ Rehabilitation ǀ Device




Research ǀ Report
M a y | 2010


Contents
Introduction ......................................................................................................... 2

Secondary ǀ research .......................................................................................... 3

   Literary ǀ research ............................................................................................ 3

   Patents ............................................................................................................ 4

      Australian Patent .......................................................................................... 5

      United States Patent .................................................................................... 6

      Canadian Patent ........................................................................................... 8

Primary ǀ research ............................................................................................... 9

   Focus ǀ groups ................................................................................................. 9

   Observations ................................................................................................. 10

   Behaviour ǀ mapping ...................................................................................... 11

   Interviews ǀ questionnaires ............................................................................ 12

   User trials ǀ Product–in-use ........................................................................... 15

   Market ǀ analysis ............................................................................................ 17

   Personality ǀ profiling ..................................................................................... 18

   Style ǀ analysis ............................................................................................... 19

Appendices ....................................................................................................... 20

   Interview with Professor Michele Sterling ...................................................... 21

   Pictures.......................................................................................................... 23

   Neck-brace experiment questions: ................................................................ 25

References........................................................................................................ 26

   Journals ......................................................................................................... 28




                                                                                                                  Page |1
M a y | 2010


Introduction

The author has chosen physiotherapy as his field of study. The aim is to create

a device for rehabilitation at home for patients suffering from whiplash.

Whiplash is an injury caused by or related to a sudden distortion of the neck.

The injury is commonly associated with motor vehicle accidents, usually when

the vehicle has been hit from the rear. The injury can relate from aches and

pains in the neck to serious back problems. Symptoms include:


    Neck pain

    Headache

    Shoulder pain

    Low back pain

    Difficulty swallowing

    Blurred vision

    Ringing in the ears

    Nausea

    Fatigue or weakness

    Irritability

    Dizziness

    Vertigo




A 2004 survey by Daniel G. Baldyga showed that almost 10% of all whiplash

victims became totally disabled for long periods after the initial injury. This

survey also found that 60% of whiplash victims needed long-term treatment for

recurrence of the injury. The survey also suggested that almost a quarter of

whiplash patients feel the effects of the injury for up to 6 months after the initial


                                                                                  Page |2
M a y | 2010


injury. Whiplash patients are usually scheduled for a single session of

physiotherapy each week. During this session the ‘Stabilizer Bio-Feedback’ is

used as treatment.


Once this session ends there is an array of exercises that the patient is given to

do at home. However if not done properly these exercises can cause as much

as they can help. It is for this reason that the authors believes a device needs to

be created that instils confidence in both physio and patient that the

rehabilitation can be correctly continued outside of the designated physio

sessions.




Secondary ǀ research


Literary ǀ research

Literary research has mostly consisted of books and publications regarding

neck stress and whiplash. The author acquired a booklist containing over 75

books with information on the above from a physiotherapist specialising on

neuro and physio treatment. One of the stand out books was ‘Whiplash

Headache and Neck Pain’ by Gwen Jull. The book deals with the initial

evaluation and diagnosis of the injury and the different ways in which the injury

should be dealt with, how much rest to get, exercises to do etc. Using Jull as a

reference the author looked into different publications specialising in whiplash

related injuries. The journal of Rehabilitation Medicine, 2005 included two very

interesting publications, ‘Do dorsal head contact forces have the potential to


                                                                                 Page |3
M a y | 2010


identify impairments during graded crainiocervical flexor muscle contractions’

and ’Smooth pursuit neck torsion test in whiplash associated orders –

relationship to self reports of neck pain and disability, dizziness and anxiety’.

Another important specialist the author found helpful was Professor Michele

Sterling PhD MPhty Bphty from the University of Queensland, Australia. She

was involved in the both ‘Do dorsal head contact forces have the potential to

identify impairments during graded crainiocervical flexor muscle contractions’

and ’Smooth pursuit neck torsion test in whiplash associated orders –

relationship to self reports of neck pain and disability, dizziness and anxiety’.

One of her own publications ‘Whiplash (grade II) and cervical radiculopathy

share a similar sensory presentation: an investigation using quantitative sensory

testing’ featured in Clinical Journal of Pain, offered an insight into the effects of

a whiplash injury on the different systems in the body, most notably the nervous

system. Having read her publications and researched her patents the author

subsequently contacted Professor Sterling and she was more than happy to

answer the questions posed to her, answers from which were very helpful.




Patents

The author has also carried out patent searches related to the area of research;

the following are patents from Australia and the USA for similar Bio-Feedback

products.




                                                                                 Page |4
M a y | 2010


Australian Patent

no. 657277




                                         1



Application details


Australian application no.: 85932/91 Patent application Type: standard Serial

no.: 657277         Application status: SEALED Paid to date: 18-10-2009 First

IPC mark: A61 5/22 (2006.01)                  Currently under opposition: No

proceeding type(s)

Invention title: Exercise monitoring device

Inventor(s): Jull, Gwendolen Anne; Richardson, Carolyn Anne

Agent name: Fisher & Kelly Address for legal service: 349 Coronation Drive

Milton QLD 4064               Filing date: 1991-10-18 Australian OPI date: 1993-

02-25 OPI published in journal                                  Effective date of

patent: 1991-10-18 Expiry date: 2011-10-18




                                                                                 Page |5
M a y | 2010


United States Patent

no. 5338276




                                          2

Application Details:

Application number: 783299

Filing date: October 1991

Summary of The Invention

The invention provides in one aspect an exercise monitoring device including a

pressure pad, an air pump, feedback means and an air line associated with the

pressure pad, air pump and feedback means to permit inflation of the pressure

pad for monitoring purposes.

The pressure pad may be of any suitable form and thus comprise a flexible

bladder or bag preferably formed of non-resilient or non-stretchable material

inclusive of plastics material such as vinyl, leather or fabrics like cotton or wool.

Although the pressure pad may comprise a single air chamber it is preferred

that there are provided a plurality of air chambers separated by boundaries only

permitting restricted air access between adjacent air chambers. It is preferred to

utilise a plurality of air chambers having restricted air access between the

chambers as this allows appropriate monitoring of variable changes (eg

rotation) of the patient's body position unlike a single air chamber.


                                                                                 Page |6
M a y | 2010


In another embodiment, the pressure pad may be formed of a plurality of

completely separate air chambers whereby each chamber has its own air line to

provide a plurality of air lines all communicating with a common manifold.

In a preferred embodiment therefore the pressure pad may comprise an air bag

which is suitably plate like in shape having a pair of opposed walls wherein

adjacent parts of each wall may be fused or welded together so as to form the

abovementioned boundaries with openings or air passages between each

boundary to provide access of air between adjacent air chambers.

The air pump may be of any suitable kind and suitably comprises an air bulb or

pressure bulb which may be actuated or pressurised manually. However this

does not preclude the use of other air pumps such as piston pumps or

diaphragm pumps for example.

The feedback means may be of any suitable type that permits monitoring or

metering of the pressure biofeedback which is transmitted by the pressure pad.

This may include an analogue meter for example such as an aneroid dial or

electronic or electrically operated meter such as a digital read out or a suitably

visual display unit or VDU.

In one form the feedback means may also include a pressure transducer such

as a strain gauge or pressure transducer based on a piezo electric effect or

variable resistance effect. In the latter arrangement this may operate with one

side or face of a membrane incorporating a circuit having the variable

resistance being subject to the pressure change which will result in a change in

the electrical resistance of the circuit which is related to or proportional to the

change.

The pressure transducer may be connected to the pressure pad in any suitable



                                                                                  Page |7
M a y | 2010


fashion such as by an air hose. The pressure transducer in turn may then be

connected to a digital read out or analogue meter or interfaced with a computer

which incorporates the VDU which if desired may be coupled to a printer. The

computer may use appropriate software so as to provide a thorough analysis of

the output of a patient undergoing an exercise routine which may be contained

in a suitable print out from the printer.

Preferably for ease and convenience the air bulb is directly coupled to an

aneroid dial so that the result on the aneroid dial may be read by the patient

undergoing the exercise so as to provide a form of self assessment.

There also may be provided valve means so as to adjust the pressure in the

pressure pad if required. In one form this may comprise a screw actuated valve

associated with an air passage between the aneroid dial and the air bulb. When

the valve is in an open position air may not reach the pressure pad but is

pumped directly to atmosphere. When the valve is closed or partially closed air

may be pumped to the pressure pad so as to inflate the pressure pad. Further

opening of the valve may decrease the pressure in the pressure pad as

recorded on the aneroid dial when required.


Canadian Patent

no. 2058233-2




                                            3



                                                                                 Page |8
M a y | 2010


In the patents there is no mention of the products being designed for home use.

Only the hand pump device is mentioned as a form of pressure gauge, this is an

aspect of the product I hope to develop as the current method can be

unreliable.




Primary ǀ research

Focus ǀ groups

Since the beginning of the project in September 2009 the author has been to

the West Limerick Neuro and Physio Rehabilitation Clinic in Newcastle West,

co. Limerick. On two of these occasions the author has met with two of the

physio’s for focus groups where ideas were put on the table, pro’s and con’s

discussed and decisions made. Along with the focus group aspect of the

meetings the physio’s involved the author in demonstrations of the different

exercises and routines the patient is put through during the session, in

preparation for continuation of the exercise at home. Seeing the preparation

that goes into selecting the exercises for the patient to be doing at home was a

very important aspect of these meetings. All that was given to the patient was a

set of exercises based around what was done during the session on the

‘Stabilizer Bio-Feedback’ device. The Bio-Feedback device is the only

recognised piece of equipment currently available for the treatment of whiplash.

Both physios and patients of whiplash expressed mixed emotions when it came

to the Bio-Feedback device. The patient confessed to a lack of motivation when



                                                                               Page |9
M a y | 2010


trying to recite exercises learned during physio sessions. The physio was

concerned in relation to mis-use of the exercise instructions given which may

lead to further aggravation of the injury.




                                 4 Stabilizer Bio Feedback




Observations

The observations carried out by the author have been to do with two different

forms of whiplash treatment the first was the use of lasers on pre-designed

charts. This method is used when there is an imbalance or a misalignment of

the cranium. The activity involves the attaching of a laser to the patients head

with the use of an elastic band and a hair band. Both parties found this

particularly difficult as the physio had to securely attach the laser pen to the hair

band with the elastic band, this was awkward and time consuming. The

patient’s issues were to do with the insecurity of the bond between the pen and

the hair, making it difficult to carry out the appropriate exercises.




                                                                               P a g e | 10
M a y | 2010




5 Laser pen used for correcting cranium alignment       6 Charts also used in treatment




The second observation made by the author was the use of the bio-feedback

device. This method involved the patient lying on his/her back with the blue

piece of the apparatus behind their head. They then have to hold the pressure

gauge aloft in order to read the pressure as they completed the exercise. The

exercise involved retracting the chin towards the neck, against the pressure

built up in the blue apparatus. This device appeared both problematic and

awkward for physiotherapist and patient. The patient described it as

‘uncomfortable’ and ‘difficult to figure out’. The physio described it as ‘awkward’

and ‘more time consuming than necessary’. This view was due to the fact the

physio had to stay with the patient for most of the exercise, to ensure it was

being done properly but also because the patients arm was becoming fatigued

as result of holding the pressure gauge aloft.




Behaviour ǀ mapping

The patient can have many different characteristics so it is hard to map

behaviour. Whiplash is mostly suffered by those involved in car accidents but

can also be as result of a fall on a hard surface, a sports injury or just

aggravation of muscles with a sharp movement of the neck. On the other side of




                                                                                          P a g e | 11
M a y | 2010


the treatment is the physiotherapist. He/she would generally work a regular

office day, often dealing with whiplash patients for one hour blocks at a time.

The use of the product is often determined by the seriousness of the injury

sustained, or the stage of the recovery the patient is at.




Interviews ǀ questionnaires

At the beginning of research, once the decision had been made to focus on the

neck, a questionnaire/social experiment was carried out with a neck brace. The

questionnaire involved candidates wearing the brace for a certain frame of time,

before rating the product on different qualities.

The aim of the experiment was to evaluate the effectiveness of the most basic

neck support products. The questionnaire had four questions, each answer was

to be given as a rating from 1 – 5 with 1 being weakest and 5 being strongest.

There were 12 candidates, 8 male, 4 female, 7 candidates fell in the 17-29 age

bracket, 1 in the 30-44, 3 in the 45-59 and 1 in the 60+.

For the age group 17-29 the average responses were Q1 moderate-okay, Q2

uncomfortable-noticeable, Q3 couldn’t move-restricted, Q4 supported-sufficient

support.

For the age group 30-44 Q1 okay, Q2 easy, Q3 slight movement, Q4 sturdy

support.

For the age group 45-59 Q1 okay, Q2 noticeable, Q3 no difference, Q4

supported-sufficient support. For the age group 60+Q1 difficult, Q2

uncomfortable, Q3 restricted, Q4 limited support.



                                                                              P a g e | 12
M a y | 2010


The social side of the experiment was carried out by the author and involved

him wearing a neck brace, while undertaking different activities during the

course of a regular day. These activities included reading a book, using a

laptop, eating a meal and watching TV. After approximately 5 minutes of

wearing the brace it because extremely uncomfortable and come the end of the

experiment found his neck muscles to be increasingly strained.

During the process of research and information gathering many different

therapists were interviewed by the author. The interviews were carried out at

different stages of the research; these offered both great insights into the range

of rehabilitation equipment already on the market and ideas as to what direction

that could be taken to improve this market range. The first official was in the

sports arena in UL, he agreed that there was little in the way of equipment for

those rehabilitating muscles other than thera-bands, which are prone to misuse.

The aspect of the idea that most appealed to him was the thought of a product

that would have the ability to be used for both sports injuries and general

physiotherapy. He recommended a meeting with more specialised

physiotherapists to get a more focused opinion on physical therapy.

Next to be interviewed were two physiotherapists based in Newcastle West, co.

Limerick. This was at a stage when the project was making a move towards

focusing on the neck. They have their own clinic, West Limerick Physiotherapy

& Neuro Rehabilitation Clinic in Newcastle West and were able to offer several

areas in the physiotherapy where products needed development. Products that

ranged from roller tubes for back pain to treatment tables.

The biggest problem they stated was cost, there was equipment out there but

because of increasing costs smaller practices like theirs were unable to afford



                                                                               P a g e | 13
M a y | 2010


them. On the second visit to the West Limerick Physiotherapy & Neuro

Rehabilitation Clinic the author was given demonstrations for several products

and could immediately see the areas either where new products or

improvements were needed. They gave a full list of books and publications to

read up on, and in particular mentioned Professor Michelle Sterling, an author

of several publications who is based in Queensland, Australia.

At this point the author successfully contacted Professor Sterling and she has

agreed to a Skype interview when she is free, but in the meantime offered to

answer any immediate questions.

The next interview carried out by the author was with a chartered

physiotherapist based in Castletroy, Limerick who has masters in sports

physiotherapy, he practices in the United Physiotherapy Clinic at Whitehorns,

Castletroy. The author asked him, what he felt were the major flaws in whiplash

treatment. He replied ‘after a trauma muscles become sensitised and the pain

felt by the affected neck muscles can spread through the nervous system,

making it difficult to treat, also with whiplash injuries, an x-ray of a perfectly

healthy neck and an x-ray of a neck post whiplash will look the exact same so it

can be hard to differentiate between tissue and muscle damage’. ‘Loads on

damaged muscles can leave them fatigued, hampering treatment and during

certain treatments the front neck muscles (deep neck flexors) become inhibited’.

The author then asked him his opinion on his own thoughts that home treatment

can be harmful as much as helpful! He agreed, stating that ‘there is a big

problem with home exercises as there is no guarantee the exercises are being

done properly and the exercises are being done at all’. He suggested maybe

some form of a video diary or clicker to indicate number of replications done. He



                                                                                     P a g e | 14
M a y | 2010


also talked about Ultrasound treatment, this form of treatment allows the

physiotherapist to view the muscles contracting.

The author also contacted and visited physiotherapists in St. Camillus,

Shelbourne road, Limerick. The physio echoed a lot of the points of view

already gathered by the author, but was unable to offer more as they did not

deal with whiplash first hand in the clinic.

On the visit to St. Camillus the author was referred to their specialist physio

clinic, located within a kilometre of the main clinic. The author was familiar with

this clinic as he had completed rehabilitation there previously. The physio met

there was very helpful and offered her opinions on several of the devices

currently in use for whiplash rehabilitation. She felt the laser head-band/chart

idea was effective but could be made more user-friendly. She did not have any

major trouble with the bio-feedback either but again felt it could be more user-

friendly. She did confess though that her patients had more negative feelings

towards the bio-feedback than her.




User trials ǀ Product–in-use

Testing carried out by the author has included trials on different neck braces

and on the ‘Stabilizer Bio-Feedback’. This testing helped distinguish the exact

issues and flaws with the different treatment devices used for whiplash.

Problems with neck braces included height around the neck that caused

discomfort, other than this flaw the issues were to do with comfort and

restriction of movement; these however were unavoidable with compromising

the purpose of the brace.



                                                                              P a g e | 15
M a y | 2010




                                   7 neck-brace front




                                   8 neck-brace back




                                   9 neck-brace side




Problems with the ‘Stabilizer Bio-Feedback’ were numerous. There were

complaints about the position it had to be used in, the struggle to get the exact

required pressure, having to keep the pressure gauge aloft for the duration of

the exercise and also the fact the patient couldn’t take the device home to

continue recovery.



                                                                              P a g e | 16
M a y | 2010


Videos involving these user trials for both the neck brace and the bio-feedback

device are available for viewing on www.johncussen.vox.com




Market ǀ analysis

At the moment Stabilizer are the only manufacturers of the bio feedback device.

As there are no other manufacturers, there are no other variations of the

product, meaning the current flaws remain constant. These flaws include a lack

of clarity over how exactly to use the product. The pressure is hard to correctly

gauge as there is constantly air moving between the tube connecting the

pressure pump and gauge to the head rest. The current version also requires

two people in order to use the device correctly for the duration of the exercise.

The rest which sits under the neck offers no support for the head, which leads

to doubt about how to position the device correctly this can also cause further

muscle issues. These flaws are mainly due to the fact the device was originally

invented for use by patients with back issues.

The author feels the following features need to be introduced to the device to

aid the physio and the patient.

           Ability to use the device anytime, anywhere and in any position.

           Easier to use.

           Better neck support.

           Incorporation of some sort of motivational device.

           More cost effective.

Currently, there are no other variations of this device on the market, or plans to

introduce a new variation into the market. This gives the author reassurance




                                                                             P a g e | 17
M a y | 2010


that there is a hole in the market that can be filled with a well designed and

manufactured product that already has a concrete target market.




Personality ǀ profiling

The primary user will be the patient, with the secondary being the

physiotherapist.

Mike, 23, is a young male who is currently doing his masters degree in Biology,

in University of Limerick. He is an independent individual who lives away from

home and pays his own way in life by virtue of his part-time job. Mike is an

active member of his local GAA club and enjoys kick-a-bouts with his friends

during free evenings. He also has an active social life.

One evening driving home from work Mike is rear ended by another vehicle but

doesn’t suffer immediate health issues. A few weeks later however he

complains of muscle pains, is referred to a physiotherapist, Linda, and is

diagnosed with whiplash. With restricted movement and having to attend

physiotherapy sessions once a week, Mike’s life is completely disrupted. He is

unable to attend college, work or play any sports. He feels his treatment could

be progressing faster, especially if he could continue his rehabilitation after

physio sessions at home...

Linda, 52, has been working as a physiotherapist for almost 30 years. She owns

her own clinic and is used to dealing with whiplash victims, none more so than

patients involved in road accidents. She has recently had to let a

physiotherapist go because of spiralling expenses so as a result has a heavier

workload. As her clinic is based in the city centre she has many whiplash



                                                                                  P a g e | 18
M a y | 2010


patients but little time to fit them all in for minimum one session a week. She

finds recovery times slow as well and wishes there was only some way she

could monitor her patients progress outside of sessions...




Style ǀ analysis

The styles a device for a neck muscle rehabilitation device would have to follow

the typical medical device features. These include the device being a clean soft

colour, having little or no ‘fancy tech add-ons’ and being designed to meet all

medical requirements especially the strict guidelines of what is and isn’t classed

as medical waste.

The device should also look comfortable and to wear. The patient will be

wearing the device for no longer than 10-15 minutes at any one time but it is still

important for the device to carry an appealing aesthetic.




                                                                             P a g e | 19
M a y | 2010


Appendices

The following is a list of individuals who have been interviewed, offered advice

or contributed to the project during research in any way.

Claire Noonan, Physiotherapist, West Limerick Physiotherapy and Neuro

Rehabilitation Clinic, Newcastle West

Fiona Taylor, Physiotherapist West Limerick Physiotherapy and Neuro

Rehabilitation Clinic, Newcastle West

Dr Johnson McEvoy, United Physiotherapy Clinic at Whitehorns, Castletroy

Dr Cian O’Neill, Course Director, health fitness, University of Limerick

Assoc Prof Michele Sterling, Associate Professor, University of Queensland,

Australia

Niall Deloughry, Lecturer, M&OE Department, UL

Dermot McInerney, Lecturer, M&OE Department, UL

Muireann McMahon, Lecturer, M&OE Department, UL

Sara Cox, Lecturer, M&OE Department, UL

Marion McCarthy, Physiotherapist, St.Camillus, Shelbourne Road

Sarah Breen, Post-graduate student, Department of physical education and

sport sciences, UL

Joseph Costello, Post-graduate student, Department of physical education and

sport sciences, UL

Dr Christy Gillick, Lecturer, M&OE department, UL

Dr Colin Fitzpatrick, Lecturer, Electronic Engineering, UL

Dr Pepijn Van de Ven, Lecturer, Electronic Engineering, UL




                                                                            P a g e | 20
M a y | 2010


Interview with Professor Michele Sterling

Q. The general time frame for recovery from a whiplash injury is said to be 8 to

12 weeks, is this true or a myth depending mostly on the seriousness of the

injury sustained?


             A. This is a myth. Most data now indicates that around 50% will

             still have symptoms at 12 months (see paper from Bone and Joint

             Decade)


Q.Is there an age group of common whiplash sufferers?


             A. Not really. Age is sometimes a predictor of outcome and

             sometimes not.


Q. What are the muscles most affected during whiplash?


             A. Evidence for direct muscle injury/damage is inconclusive (see

             Siegmund paper). However there are certainly changes in muscle

             morphology and recruitment patterns that occur in response to

             either the injury or pain - it’s not clear which, (see Elliott and

             sterling papers).


Q. Is there a minimum force that needs to be applied for a person to suffer neck

muscle damage, or does this depends on the physical condition of the person

involved?


             A. A minimum force for injury has never been demonstrated as far

             as I'm aware. People can be injured in low force/impact collisions.




                                                                                   P a g e | 21
M a y | 2010


Q. I myself suffered a form of whiplash as result of a fall playing sport. How

common is a sports related whiplash injury?


              A. Probably fairly common, but not much research done on this.

              Probably because whiplash from car crashes costs a lot due to

              compensation etc.


Q. I’ve recently used the bio-feedback rehabilitation device, and found it to be

unreliable and sometimes inaccurate, what is your opinion of it?


              A. Reliability and accuracy improves with improved skills of the

              tester. The PBU is a clinical tool only - i.e. feedback for the phsyio

              and the patient. It is not really designed to be a diagnostic tool.


Q. Are there any other devices like the bio-feedback for whiplash treatment

currently available on the market?


              A. Not that I'm aware of.


Q. Do you know of any devices for home treatment of whiplash injuries?


              A. Not sure what you mean here? Do you mean exercise devices?

              If so then no, not that I’m aware of.


Q. When doing physio for rehabilitation of my left hand, I was given exercises

to do outside of session time at home but found them to be doing as much harm

as they were help, do you think this is one of the main reasons injuries are

prolonged?




                                                                               P a g e | 22
M a y | 2010


           A. In the case of whiplash, a group of patients demonstrate

           widespread sensory hypersensitivity and cold allodynia that reflect

           central nervous system hyperexcitability. If any form of exercise

           aggravates these people's pain, then this will potentially further

           wind up the CNS and yes do more harm than good. If the

           exercises a pain free then things should be OK




Pictures




                                     10




                                     11




                                                                           P a g e | 23
M a y | 2010




          12




     13        14




     15        16




17                  18




                          P a g e | 24
M a y | 2010




                                         19




Neck-brace experiment questions:

Q. Is the product easy to get on?


Q. Is the product comfortable to wear?


Q. Is your movement restricted?


Q. Does it offer adequate support?


Each answer was to be given as a rating from 1 – 5 with 1 being weakest and 5

being strongest.




                                                                        P a g e | 25
M a y | 2010


References

   1. http://pericles.ipaustralia.gov.au/ols/auspat/quickSearch.do?queryString=

      657277&resultsPerPage=http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-

      Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PALL&p=1&u=/netahtml/PTO/s

      rchnum.htm&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1=5338276.PN.&OS=PN/5338276&RS=P

      N/5338276


   2. http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-

      Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PALL&p=1&u=/netahtml/PTO/s

      rchnum.htm&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1=5338276.PN.&OS=PN/5338276&RS=P

      N/5338276


   3. http://brevets-patents.ic.gc.ca/opic-

      cipo/cpd/eng/patent/2058233/financial_transactions.html?type=number_

      search


   4. http://healthinfousa.com/chattanooga/biofeedback.jpg


   5. Photos – John Cussen


   6. Photos – John Cussen


   7. Photos – John Cussen


   8. Photos – John Cussen


   9. Photos – John Cussen


   10. Photos – John Cussen


   11. Photos – John Cussen


   12. Photos – John Cussen


                                                                         P a g e | 26
M a y | 2010


13. http://g-ecx.images-

   amazon.com/images/G/01/books/promos/Muscles_Lateral_lg.jpg1


14. http://g-ecx.images-

   amazon.com/images/G/01/books/promos/Muscles_Lateral_lg.jpg2


15. http://g-ecx.images-

   amazon.com/images/G/01/books/promos/Muscles_Lateral_lg.jpg3


16. http://g-ecx.images-

   amazon.com/images/G/01/books/promos/Muscles_Lateral_lg.jpg4


17. http://www.a3bs.com/imagelibrary/VR1132_L/anatomical-charts-poster-

   size/VR1132_L_head-and-neck-chart.jpg1


18. http://www.a3bs.com/imagelibrary/VR1132_L/anatomical-charts-poster-

   size/VR1132_L_head-and-neck-chart.jpg2


19. http://www.physiostuff.com/repository/product/15/img_9781587793752.jp

   g


20. http://www.truckinfo.net/trucking/newwhiplashinformation.htm




                                                                    P a g e | 27
M a y | 2010


Journals

Whiplash Headache and Neck Pain, Jull, G.


The journal of Rehabilitation Medicine, 2005


Do dorsal head contact forces have the potential to identify impairments during

graded crainiocervical flexor muscle contractions, Jull, G. Sterling, M


Smooth pursuit neck torsion test in whiplash associated orders - relationship to

self reports of neck pain & disability, dizziness & anxiety, Jull, G. Sterling, M


Publications


Whiplash (grade II) and cervical radiculopathy share a similar sensory

presentation: an investigation using quantitative sensory testing’ Sterling, M




                                                                                P a g e | 28

Contenu connexe

Tendances

DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICAL MEDICINE & REHABILITATION (PMR) SMS MEDICAL COLLEGE JA...
DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICAL MEDICINE & REHABILITATION (PMR) SMS MEDICAL COLLEGE JA...DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICAL MEDICINE & REHABILITATION (PMR) SMS MEDICAL COLLEGE JA...
DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICAL MEDICINE & REHABILITATION (PMR) SMS MEDICAL COLLEGE JA...drshyamsundersharma
 
Guia practica clinica_en_coxalgia
Guia practica clinica_en_coxalgiaGuia practica clinica_en_coxalgia
Guia practica clinica_en_coxalgiaIsrael Kine Cortes
 
The results of nucleoplasty using the arthrocare coblation technology versus ...
The results of nucleoplasty using the arthrocare coblation technology versus ...The results of nucleoplasty using the arthrocare coblation technology versus ...
The results of nucleoplasty using the arthrocare coblation technology versus ...Dr. Sherry N. Fanous MD, PHD, FIPP, DESA
 
Patellofemoral pain or syndrome
Patellofemoral pain or syndromePatellofemoral pain or syndrome
Patellofemoral pain or syndromeANAOYARZABAL1
 
PMR Buzz Volume 4.2021
PMR Buzz Volume 4.2021PMR Buzz Volume 4.2021
PMR Buzz Volume 4.2021mrinal joshi
 
CLS-461 Literature Review Revision
CLS-461 Literature Review RevisionCLS-461 Literature Review Revision
CLS-461 Literature Review RevisionAndrew Clark
 
Study of functional outcome following arthroscopic anatomical ACL reconstruct...
Study of functional outcome following arthroscopic anatomical ACL reconstruct...Study of functional outcome following arthroscopic anatomical ACL reconstruct...
Study of functional outcome following arthroscopic anatomical ACL reconstruct...Dr.Avinash Rao Gundavarapu
 
Benefits of Osteopathic Manual Treatment on Aerobic Group Exercise Instructors
Benefits of Osteopathic Manual Treatment on Aerobic Group Exercise InstructorsBenefits of Osteopathic Manual Treatment on Aerobic Group Exercise Instructors
Benefits of Osteopathic Manual Treatment on Aerobic Group Exercise InstructorsLondon College of Osteopathy
 
Scapular positioning and motor control in children and adults a laboratory st...
Scapular positioning and motor control in children and adults a laboratory st...Scapular positioning and motor control in children and adults a laboratory st...
Scapular positioning and motor control in children and adults a laboratory st...lichugojavier
 
Taddio Nicola Knee Remplacement Rehabilitation The Battle 2018 Cattolica (ITA)
Taddio Nicola Knee Remplacement Rehabilitation The Battle 2018 Cattolica (ITA)Taddio Nicola Knee Remplacement Rehabilitation The Battle 2018 Cattolica (ITA)
Taddio Nicola Knee Remplacement Rehabilitation The Battle 2018 Cattolica (ITA)Nicola Taddio
 
Dry-Needling Harm Minimisation Osteopathy Australia
Dry-Needling Harm Minimisation Osteopathy AustraliaDry-Needling Harm Minimisation Osteopathy Australia
Dry-Needling Harm Minimisation Osteopathy AustraliaStiofán Mac Suibhne
 
Nezgoda CAD Lit Review
Nezgoda CAD Lit ReviewNezgoda CAD Lit Review
Nezgoda CAD Lit Reviewuneekcowgirl
 
Arthroplasty: Present practices by DR. D. P. SWAMI
Arthroplasty:  Present practices by DR. D. P. SWAMI Arthroplasty:  Present practices by DR. D. P. SWAMI
Arthroplasty: Present practices by DR. D. P. SWAMI DR. D. P. SWAMI
 

Tendances (16)

DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICAL MEDICINE & REHABILITATION (PMR) SMS MEDICAL COLLEGE JA...
DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICAL MEDICINE & REHABILITATION (PMR) SMS MEDICAL COLLEGE JA...DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICAL MEDICINE & REHABILITATION (PMR) SMS MEDICAL COLLEGE JA...
DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICAL MEDICINE & REHABILITATION (PMR) SMS MEDICAL COLLEGE JA...
 
Guia practica clinica_en_coxalgia
Guia practica clinica_en_coxalgiaGuia practica clinica_en_coxalgia
Guia practica clinica_en_coxalgia
 
The results of nucleoplasty using the arthrocare coblation technology versus ...
The results of nucleoplasty using the arthrocare coblation technology versus ...The results of nucleoplasty using the arthrocare coblation technology versus ...
The results of nucleoplasty using the arthrocare coblation technology versus ...
 
PASTA Repair
PASTA RepairPASTA Repair
PASTA Repair
 
Patellofemoral pain or syndrome
Patellofemoral pain or syndromePatellofemoral pain or syndrome
Patellofemoral pain or syndrome
 
PMR Buzz Volume 4.2021
PMR Buzz Volume 4.2021PMR Buzz Volume 4.2021
PMR Buzz Volume 4.2021
 
Osteoarthritis Management R Gunadi
Osteoarthritis Management R GunadiOsteoarthritis Management R Gunadi
Osteoarthritis Management R Gunadi
 
CLS-461 Literature Review Revision
CLS-461 Literature Review RevisionCLS-461 Literature Review Revision
CLS-461 Literature Review Revision
 
Study of functional outcome following arthroscopic anatomical ACL reconstruct...
Study of functional outcome following arthroscopic anatomical ACL reconstruct...Study of functional outcome following arthroscopic anatomical ACL reconstruct...
Study of functional outcome following arthroscopic anatomical ACL reconstruct...
 
PHYSICAL ACTIVITY AND POLIO
PHYSICAL ACTIVITY AND POLIOPHYSICAL ACTIVITY AND POLIO
PHYSICAL ACTIVITY AND POLIO
 
Benefits of Osteopathic Manual Treatment on Aerobic Group Exercise Instructors
Benefits of Osteopathic Manual Treatment on Aerobic Group Exercise InstructorsBenefits of Osteopathic Manual Treatment on Aerobic Group Exercise Instructors
Benefits of Osteopathic Manual Treatment on Aerobic Group Exercise Instructors
 
Scapular positioning and motor control in children and adults a laboratory st...
Scapular positioning and motor control in children and adults a laboratory st...Scapular positioning and motor control in children and adults a laboratory st...
Scapular positioning and motor control in children and adults a laboratory st...
 
Taddio Nicola Knee Remplacement Rehabilitation The Battle 2018 Cattolica (ITA)
Taddio Nicola Knee Remplacement Rehabilitation The Battle 2018 Cattolica (ITA)Taddio Nicola Knee Remplacement Rehabilitation The Battle 2018 Cattolica (ITA)
Taddio Nicola Knee Remplacement Rehabilitation The Battle 2018 Cattolica (ITA)
 
Dry-Needling Harm Minimisation Osteopathy Australia
Dry-Needling Harm Minimisation Osteopathy AustraliaDry-Needling Harm Minimisation Osteopathy Australia
Dry-Needling Harm Minimisation Osteopathy Australia
 
Nezgoda CAD Lit Review
Nezgoda CAD Lit ReviewNezgoda CAD Lit Review
Nezgoda CAD Lit Review
 
Arthroplasty: Present practices by DR. D. P. SWAMI
Arthroplasty:  Present practices by DR. D. P. SWAMI Arthroplasty:  Present practices by DR. D. P. SWAMI
Arthroplasty: Present practices by DR. D. P. SWAMI
 

En vedette

MAGLEV TRAIN BY GIRISH HARMUKH
MAGLEV TRAIN BY GIRISH HARMUKHMAGLEV TRAIN BY GIRISH HARMUKH
MAGLEV TRAIN BY GIRISH HARMUKHGIRISH HARMUKH
 
Gari report
Gari reportGari report
Gari reportbetu8137
 
Maglev
MaglevMaglev
Maglevmokhim
 
MAGLEV TRAIN
MAGLEV TRAINMAGLEV TRAIN
MAGLEV TRAINRafee Dar
 
Magnetic Levitation Train Research Paper
Magnetic Levitation Train Research PaperMagnetic Levitation Train Research Paper
Magnetic Levitation Train Research PaperKatie Dillon
 
Maglev Train Paper Presentation, Magnetic Leviation Train, High Speed Magneti...
Maglev Train Paper Presentation, Magnetic Leviation Train, High Speed Magneti...Maglev Train Paper Presentation, Magnetic Leviation Train, High Speed Magneti...
Maglev Train Paper Presentation, Magnetic Leviation Train, High Speed Magneti...SHRIKANT KHATING
 
Maglev Train Ppt 1
Maglev Train Ppt 1Maglev Train Ppt 1
Maglev Train Ppt 1shelly yadav
 
Basic Maglev Train and its Working
Basic Maglev Train and its WorkingBasic Maglev Train and its Working
Basic Maglev Train and its WorkingVASAV SHETHNA
 
A seminar report on maglev train
A seminar report on maglev trainA seminar report on maglev train
A seminar report on maglev train007skpk
 

En vedette (10)

MAGLEV TRAIN BY GIRISH HARMUKH
MAGLEV TRAIN BY GIRISH HARMUKHMAGLEV TRAIN BY GIRISH HARMUKH
MAGLEV TRAIN BY GIRISH HARMUKH
 
Gari report
Gari reportGari report
Gari report
 
maglev train
maglev trainmaglev train
maglev train
 
Maglev
MaglevMaglev
Maglev
 
MAGLEV TRAIN
MAGLEV TRAINMAGLEV TRAIN
MAGLEV TRAIN
 
Magnetic Levitation Train Research Paper
Magnetic Levitation Train Research PaperMagnetic Levitation Train Research Paper
Magnetic Levitation Train Research Paper
 
Maglev Train Paper Presentation, Magnetic Leviation Train, High Speed Magneti...
Maglev Train Paper Presentation, Magnetic Leviation Train, High Speed Magneti...Maglev Train Paper Presentation, Magnetic Leviation Train, High Speed Magneti...
Maglev Train Paper Presentation, Magnetic Leviation Train, High Speed Magneti...
 
Maglev Train Ppt 1
Maglev Train Ppt 1Maglev Train Ppt 1
Maglev Train Ppt 1
 
Basic Maglev Train and its Working
Basic Maglev Train and its WorkingBasic Maglev Train and its Working
Basic Maglev Train and its Working
 
A seminar report on maglev train
A seminar report on maglev trainA seminar report on maglev train
A seminar report on maglev train
 

Similaire à Research report

Avoiding tech neck: adverting biomechanical dysfunction from the use of techn...
Avoiding tech neck: adverting biomechanical dysfunction from the use of techn...Avoiding tech neck: adverting biomechanical dysfunction from the use of techn...
Avoiding tech neck: adverting biomechanical dysfunction from the use of techn...Chiropractic Economics
 
Zenkers presentation IRAPS
Zenkers presentation IRAPSZenkers presentation IRAPS
Zenkers presentation IRAPSWilliam Boro
 
Why put collars on concious trauma patients
Why put collars on concious trauma patientsWhy put collars on concious trauma patients
Why put collars on concious trauma patientsJaqueline Paschoal
 
The ICU Ultrasound Pocket Book - guia rápido
The ICU Ultrasound Pocket Book - guia rápidoThe ICU Ultrasound Pocket Book - guia rápido
The ICU Ultrasound Pocket Book - guia rápidoYasminBittar
 
19250 MCU UMag April 2015_web
19250 MCU UMag April 2015_web19250 MCU UMag April 2015_web
19250 MCU UMag April 2015_webAlbert Ong
 
Running head LITERATURE REVIEW13LITERATURE REVIEW8.docx
Running head LITERATURE REVIEW13LITERATURE REVIEW8.docxRunning head LITERATURE REVIEW13LITERATURE REVIEW8.docx
Running head LITERATURE REVIEW13LITERATURE REVIEW8.docxcharisellington63520
 
Anaesthesia at a Glance.pdf
Anaesthesia at a Glance.pdfAnaesthesia at a Glance.pdf
Anaesthesia at a Glance.pdfLaurie Smith
 
Head transplantation
Head transplantationHead transplantation
Head transplantationAmankumar1485
 
Jc on the effect of tooth loss on body balance control/certified fixed orthod...
Jc on the effect of tooth loss on body balance control/certified fixed orthod...Jc on the effect of tooth loss on body balance control/certified fixed orthod...
Jc on the effect of tooth loss on body balance control/certified fixed orthod...Indian dental academy
 
A Brief History of Scoliosis Treatment
A Brief History of Scoliosis TreatmentA Brief History of Scoliosis Treatment
A Brief History of Scoliosis TreatmentDr. Clayton Stitzel
 
Intervertebral Disc Replacement
Intervertebral Disc ReplacementIntervertebral Disc Replacement
Intervertebral Disc ReplacementDr Madhusudhan NC
 

Similaire à Research report (14)

FULL111711
FULL111711FULL111711
FULL111711
 
Avoiding tech neck: adverting biomechanical dysfunction from the use of techn...
Avoiding tech neck: adverting biomechanical dysfunction from the use of techn...Avoiding tech neck: adverting biomechanical dysfunction from the use of techn...
Avoiding tech neck: adverting biomechanical dysfunction from the use of techn...
 
Zenkers presentation IRAPS
Zenkers presentation IRAPSZenkers presentation IRAPS
Zenkers presentation IRAPS
 
Why put collars on concious trauma patients
Why put collars on concious trauma patientsWhy put collars on concious trauma patients
Why put collars on concious trauma patients
 
Cellular Therapies (Including Stem Cell treatment) for Human SCI
Cellular Therapies (Including Stem Cell  treatment) for  Human SCICellular Therapies (Including Stem Cell  treatment) for  Human SCI
Cellular Therapies (Including Stem Cell treatment) for Human SCI
 
The ICU Ultrasound Pocket Book - guia rápido
The ICU Ultrasound Pocket Book - guia rápidoThe ICU Ultrasound Pocket Book - guia rápido
The ICU Ultrasound Pocket Book - guia rápido
 
19250 MCU UMag April 2015_web
19250 MCU UMag April 2015_web19250 MCU UMag April 2015_web
19250 MCU UMag April 2015_web
 
Running head LITERATURE REVIEW13LITERATURE REVIEW8.docx
Running head LITERATURE REVIEW13LITERATURE REVIEW8.docxRunning head LITERATURE REVIEW13LITERATURE REVIEW8.docx
Running head LITERATURE REVIEW13LITERATURE REVIEW8.docx
 
Anaesthesia at a Glance.pdf
Anaesthesia at a Glance.pdfAnaesthesia at a Glance.pdf
Anaesthesia at a Glance.pdf
 
Head transplantation
Head transplantationHead transplantation
Head transplantation
 
Jc on the effect of tooth loss on body balance control/certified fixed orthod...
Jc on the effect of tooth loss on body balance control/certified fixed orthod...Jc on the effect of tooth loss on body balance control/certified fixed orthod...
Jc on the effect of tooth loss on body balance control/certified fixed orthod...
 
Activator
ActivatorActivator
Activator
 
A Brief History of Scoliosis Treatment
A Brief History of Scoliosis TreatmentA Brief History of Scoliosis Treatment
A Brief History of Scoliosis Treatment
 
Intervertebral Disc Replacement
Intervertebral Disc ReplacementIntervertebral Disc Replacement
Intervertebral Disc Replacement
 

Plus de John

Old device storyboard
Old device storyboardOld device storyboard
Old device storyboardJohn
 
Storyboard old
Storyboard   oldStoryboard   old
Storyboard oldJohn
 
Storyboard new
Storyboard   newStoryboard   new
Storyboard newJohn
 
Storyboard old
Storyboard   oldStoryboard   old
Storyboard oldJohn
 
Final Concept
Final ConceptFinal Concept
Final ConceptJohn
 
Catering For All
Catering For AllCatering For All
Catering For AllJohn
 
Models
ModelsModels
ModelsJohn
 
Weeks 3&4
Weeks 3&4Weeks 3&4
Weeks 3&4John
 
Week 2, Weekend Concepts
Week 2, Weekend ConceptsWeek 2, Weekend Concepts
Week 2, Weekend ConceptsJohn
 
Week 2 Concepts+Models
Week 2 Concepts+ModelsWeek 2 Concepts+Models
Week 2 Concepts+ModelsJohn
 
John Cussen 0655457
John Cussen 0655457John Cussen 0655457
John Cussen 0655457John
 
Whiplash Rehabilitation Device
Whiplash Rehabilitation DeviceWhiplash Rehabilitation Device
Whiplash Rehabilitation DeviceJohn
 
Sketch Model
Sketch ModelSketch Model
Sketch ModelJohn
 
Final Concept + Possible Alterations
Final Concept + Possible AlterationsFinal Concept + Possible Alterations
Final Concept + Possible AlterationsJohn
 
Final Concept + Possible Alterations
Final Concept + Possible AlterationsFinal Concept + Possible Alterations
Final Concept + Possible AlterationsJohn
 
Npdp Presentation
Npdp PresentationNpdp Presentation
Npdp PresentationJohn
 
Npdp Presentation
Npdp PresentationNpdp Presentation
Npdp PresentationJohn
 
Npdp Presentation
Npdp PresentationNpdp Presentation
Npdp PresentationJohn
 
Phase 2 concepts
Phase 2 conceptsPhase 2 concepts
Phase 2 conceptsJohn
 
Concepts - phase 2
Concepts - phase 2Concepts - phase 2
Concepts - phase 2John
 

Plus de John (20)

Old device storyboard
Old device storyboardOld device storyboard
Old device storyboard
 
Storyboard old
Storyboard   oldStoryboard   old
Storyboard old
 
Storyboard new
Storyboard   newStoryboard   new
Storyboard new
 
Storyboard old
Storyboard   oldStoryboard   old
Storyboard old
 
Final Concept
Final ConceptFinal Concept
Final Concept
 
Catering For All
Catering For AllCatering For All
Catering For All
 
Models
ModelsModels
Models
 
Weeks 3&4
Weeks 3&4Weeks 3&4
Weeks 3&4
 
Week 2, Weekend Concepts
Week 2, Weekend ConceptsWeek 2, Weekend Concepts
Week 2, Weekend Concepts
 
Week 2 Concepts+Models
Week 2 Concepts+ModelsWeek 2 Concepts+Models
Week 2 Concepts+Models
 
John Cussen 0655457
John Cussen 0655457John Cussen 0655457
John Cussen 0655457
 
Whiplash Rehabilitation Device
Whiplash Rehabilitation DeviceWhiplash Rehabilitation Device
Whiplash Rehabilitation Device
 
Sketch Model
Sketch ModelSketch Model
Sketch Model
 
Final Concept + Possible Alterations
Final Concept + Possible AlterationsFinal Concept + Possible Alterations
Final Concept + Possible Alterations
 
Final Concept + Possible Alterations
Final Concept + Possible AlterationsFinal Concept + Possible Alterations
Final Concept + Possible Alterations
 
Npdp Presentation
Npdp PresentationNpdp Presentation
Npdp Presentation
 
Npdp Presentation
Npdp PresentationNpdp Presentation
Npdp Presentation
 
Npdp Presentation
Npdp PresentationNpdp Presentation
Npdp Presentation
 
Phase 2 concepts
Phase 2 conceptsPhase 2 concepts
Phase 2 concepts
 
Concepts - phase 2
Concepts - phase 2Concepts - phase 2
Concepts - phase 2
 

Research report

  • 1. John ǀ Cussen 0655457 0655457 Whiplash ǀ Rehabilitation ǀ Device Research ǀ Report
  • 2. M a y | 2010 Contents Introduction ......................................................................................................... 2 Secondary ǀ research .......................................................................................... 3 Literary ǀ research ............................................................................................ 3 Patents ............................................................................................................ 4 Australian Patent .......................................................................................... 5 United States Patent .................................................................................... 6 Canadian Patent ........................................................................................... 8 Primary ǀ research ............................................................................................... 9 Focus ǀ groups ................................................................................................. 9 Observations ................................................................................................. 10 Behaviour ǀ mapping ...................................................................................... 11 Interviews ǀ questionnaires ............................................................................ 12 User trials ǀ Product–in-use ........................................................................... 15 Market ǀ analysis ............................................................................................ 17 Personality ǀ profiling ..................................................................................... 18 Style ǀ analysis ............................................................................................... 19 Appendices ....................................................................................................... 20 Interview with Professor Michele Sterling ...................................................... 21 Pictures.......................................................................................................... 23 Neck-brace experiment questions: ................................................................ 25 References........................................................................................................ 26 Journals ......................................................................................................... 28 Page |1
  • 3. M a y | 2010 Introduction The author has chosen physiotherapy as his field of study. The aim is to create a device for rehabilitation at home for patients suffering from whiplash. Whiplash is an injury caused by or related to a sudden distortion of the neck. The injury is commonly associated with motor vehicle accidents, usually when the vehicle has been hit from the rear. The injury can relate from aches and pains in the neck to serious back problems. Symptoms include:  Neck pain  Headache  Shoulder pain  Low back pain  Difficulty swallowing  Blurred vision  Ringing in the ears  Nausea  Fatigue or weakness  Irritability  Dizziness  Vertigo A 2004 survey by Daniel G. Baldyga showed that almost 10% of all whiplash victims became totally disabled for long periods after the initial injury. This survey also found that 60% of whiplash victims needed long-term treatment for recurrence of the injury. The survey also suggested that almost a quarter of whiplash patients feel the effects of the injury for up to 6 months after the initial Page |2
  • 4. M a y | 2010 injury. Whiplash patients are usually scheduled for a single session of physiotherapy each week. During this session the ‘Stabilizer Bio-Feedback’ is used as treatment. Once this session ends there is an array of exercises that the patient is given to do at home. However if not done properly these exercises can cause as much as they can help. It is for this reason that the authors believes a device needs to be created that instils confidence in both physio and patient that the rehabilitation can be correctly continued outside of the designated physio sessions. Secondary ǀ research Literary ǀ research Literary research has mostly consisted of books and publications regarding neck stress and whiplash. The author acquired a booklist containing over 75 books with information on the above from a physiotherapist specialising on neuro and physio treatment. One of the stand out books was ‘Whiplash Headache and Neck Pain’ by Gwen Jull. The book deals with the initial evaluation and diagnosis of the injury and the different ways in which the injury should be dealt with, how much rest to get, exercises to do etc. Using Jull as a reference the author looked into different publications specialising in whiplash related injuries. The journal of Rehabilitation Medicine, 2005 included two very interesting publications, ‘Do dorsal head contact forces have the potential to Page |3
  • 5. M a y | 2010 identify impairments during graded crainiocervical flexor muscle contractions’ and ’Smooth pursuit neck torsion test in whiplash associated orders – relationship to self reports of neck pain and disability, dizziness and anxiety’. Another important specialist the author found helpful was Professor Michele Sterling PhD MPhty Bphty from the University of Queensland, Australia. She was involved in the both ‘Do dorsal head contact forces have the potential to identify impairments during graded crainiocervical flexor muscle contractions’ and ’Smooth pursuit neck torsion test in whiplash associated orders – relationship to self reports of neck pain and disability, dizziness and anxiety’. One of her own publications ‘Whiplash (grade II) and cervical radiculopathy share a similar sensory presentation: an investigation using quantitative sensory testing’ featured in Clinical Journal of Pain, offered an insight into the effects of a whiplash injury on the different systems in the body, most notably the nervous system. Having read her publications and researched her patents the author subsequently contacted Professor Sterling and she was more than happy to answer the questions posed to her, answers from which were very helpful. Patents The author has also carried out patent searches related to the area of research; the following are patents from Australia and the USA for similar Bio-Feedback products. Page |4
  • 6. M a y | 2010 Australian Patent no. 657277 1 Application details Australian application no.: 85932/91 Patent application Type: standard Serial no.: 657277 Application status: SEALED Paid to date: 18-10-2009 First IPC mark: A61 5/22 (2006.01) Currently under opposition: No proceeding type(s) Invention title: Exercise monitoring device Inventor(s): Jull, Gwendolen Anne; Richardson, Carolyn Anne Agent name: Fisher & Kelly Address for legal service: 349 Coronation Drive Milton QLD 4064 Filing date: 1991-10-18 Australian OPI date: 1993- 02-25 OPI published in journal Effective date of patent: 1991-10-18 Expiry date: 2011-10-18 Page |5
  • 7. M a y | 2010 United States Patent no. 5338276 2 Application Details: Application number: 783299 Filing date: October 1991 Summary of The Invention The invention provides in one aspect an exercise monitoring device including a pressure pad, an air pump, feedback means and an air line associated with the pressure pad, air pump and feedback means to permit inflation of the pressure pad for monitoring purposes. The pressure pad may be of any suitable form and thus comprise a flexible bladder or bag preferably formed of non-resilient or non-stretchable material inclusive of plastics material such as vinyl, leather or fabrics like cotton or wool. Although the pressure pad may comprise a single air chamber it is preferred that there are provided a plurality of air chambers separated by boundaries only permitting restricted air access between adjacent air chambers. It is preferred to utilise a plurality of air chambers having restricted air access between the chambers as this allows appropriate monitoring of variable changes (eg rotation) of the patient's body position unlike a single air chamber. Page |6
  • 8. M a y | 2010 In another embodiment, the pressure pad may be formed of a plurality of completely separate air chambers whereby each chamber has its own air line to provide a plurality of air lines all communicating with a common manifold. In a preferred embodiment therefore the pressure pad may comprise an air bag which is suitably plate like in shape having a pair of opposed walls wherein adjacent parts of each wall may be fused or welded together so as to form the abovementioned boundaries with openings or air passages between each boundary to provide access of air between adjacent air chambers. The air pump may be of any suitable kind and suitably comprises an air bulb or pressure bulb which may be actuated or pressurised manually. However this does not preclude the use of other air pumps such as piston pumps or diaphragm pumps for example. The feedback means may be of any suitable type that permits monitoring or metering of the pressure biofeedback which is transmitted by the pressure pad. This may include an analogue meter for example such as an aneroid dial or electronic or electrically operated meter such as a digital read out or a suitably visual display unit or VDU. In one form the feedback means may also include a pressure transducer such as a strain gauge or pressure transducer based on a piezo electric effect or variable resistance effect. In the latter arrangement this may operate with one side or face of a membrane incorporating a circuit having the variable resistance being subject to the pressure change which will result in a change in the electrical resistance of the circuit which is related to or proportional to the change. The pressure transducer may be connected to the pressure pad in any suitable Page |7
  • 9. M a y | 2010 fashion such as by an air hose. The pressure transducer in turn may then be connected to a digital read out or analogue meter or interfaced with a computer which incorporates the VDU which if desired may be coupled to a printer. The computer may use appropriate software so as to provide a thorough analysis of the output of a patient undergoing an exercise routine which may be contained in a suitable print out from the printer. Preferably for ease and convenience the air bulb is directly coupled to an aneroid dial so that the result on the aneroid dial may be read by the patient undergoing the exercise so as to provide a form of self assessment. There also may be provided valve means so as to adjust the pressure in the pressure pad if required. In one form this may comprise a screw actuated valve associated with an air passage between the aneroid dial and the air bulb. When the valve is in an open position air may not reach the pressure pad but is pumped directly to atmosphere. When the valve is closed or partially closed air may be pumped to the pressure pad so as to inflate the pressure pad. Further opening of the valve may decrease the pressure in the pressure pad as recorded on the aneroid dial when required. Canadian Patent no. 2058233-2 3 Page |8
  • 10. M a y | 2010 In the patents there is no mention of the products being designed for home use. Only the hand pump device is mentioned as a form of pressure gauge, this is an aspect of the product I hope to develop as the current method can be unreliable. Primary ǀ research Focus ǀ groups Since the beginning of the project in September 2009 the author has been to the West Limerick Neuro and Physio Rehabilitation Clinic in Newcastle West, co. Limerick. On two of these occasions the author has met with two of the physio’s for focus groups where ideas were put on the table, pro’s and con’s discussed and decisions made. Along with the focus group aspect of the meetings the physio’s involved the author in demonstrations of the different exercises and routines the patient is put through during the session, in preparation for continuation of the exercise at home. Seeing the preparation that goes into selecting the exercises for the patient to be doing at home was a very important aspect of these meetings. All that was given to the patient was a set of exercises based around what was done during the session on the ‘Stabilizer Bio-Feedback’ device. The Bio-Feedback device is the only recognised piece of equipment currently available for the treatment of whiplash. Both physios and patients of whiplash expressed mixed emotions when it came to the Bio-Feedback device. The patient confessed to a lack of motivation when Page |9
  • 11. M a y | 2010 trying to recite exercises learned during physio sessions. The physio was concerned in relation to mis-use of the exercise instructions given which may lead to further aggravation of the injury. 4 Stabilizer Bio Feedback Observations The observations carried out by the author have been to do with two different forms of whiplash treatment the first was the use of lasers on pre-designed charts. This method is used when there is an imbalance or a misalignment of the cranium. The activity involves the attaching of a laser to the patients head with the use of an elastic band and a hair band. Both parties found this particularly difficult as the physio had to securely attach the laser pen to the hair band with the elastic band, this was awkward and time consuming. The patient’s issues were to do with the insecurity of the bond between the pen and the hair, making it difficult to carry out the appropriate exercises. P a g e | 10
  • 12. M a y | 2010 5 Laser pen used for correcting cranium alignment 6 Charts also used in treatment The second observation made by the author was the use of the bio-feedback device. This method involved the patient lying on his/her back with the blue piece of the apparatus behind their head. They then have to hold the pressure gauge aloft in order to read the pressure as they completed the exercise. The exercise involved retracting the chin towards the neck, against the pressure built up in the blue apparatus. This device appeared both problematic and awkward for physiotherapist and patient. The patient described it as ‘uncomfortable’ and ‘difficult to figure out’. The physio described it as ‘awkward’ and ‘more time consuming than necessary’. This view was due to the fact the physio had to stay with the patient for most of the exercise, to ensure it was being done properly but also because the patients arm was becoming fatigued as result of holding the pressure gauge aloft. Behaviour ǀ mapping The patient can have many different characteristics so it is hard to map behaviour. Whiplash is mostly suffered by those involved in car accidents but can also be as result of a fall on a hard surface, a sports injury or just aggravation of muscles with a sharp movement of the neck. On the other side of P a g e | 11
  • 13. M a y | 2010 the treatment is the physiotherapist. He/she would generally work a regular office day, often dealing with whiplash patients for one hour blocks at a time. The use of the product is often determined by the seriousness of the injury sustained, or the stage of the recovery the patient is at. Interviews ǀ questionnaires At the beginning of research, once the decision had been made to focus on the neck, a questionnaire/social experiment was carried out with a neck brace. The questionnaire involved candidates wearing the brace for a certain frame of time, before rating the product on different qualities. The aim of the experiment was to evaluate the effectiveness of the most basic neck support products. The questionnaire had four questions, each answer was to be given as a rating from 1 – 5 with 1 being weakest and 5 being strongest. There were 12 candidates, 8 male, 4 female, 7 candidates fell in the 17-29 age bracket, 1 in the 30-44, 3 in the 45-59 and 1 in the 60+. For the age group 17-29 the average responses were Q1 moderate-okay, Q2 uncomfortable-noticeable, Q3 couldn’t move-restricted, Q4 supported-sufficient support. For the age group 30-44 Q1 okay, Q2 easy, Q3 slight movement, Q4 sturdy support. For the age group 45-59 Q1 okay, Q2 noticeable, Q3 no difference, Q4 supported-sufficient support. For the age group 60+Q1 difficult, Q2 uncomfortable, Q3 restricted, Q4 limited support. P a g e | 12
  • 14. M a y | 2010 The social side of the experiment was carried out by the author and involved him wearing a neck brace, while undertaking different activities during the course of a regular day. These activities included reading a book, using a laptop, eating a meal and watching TV. After approximately 5 minutes of wearing the brace it because extremely uncomfortable and come the end of the experiment found his neck muscles to be increasingly strained. During the process of research and information gathering many different therapists were interviewed by the author. The interviews were carried out at different stages of the research; these offered both great insights into the range of rehabilitation equipment already on the market and ideas as to what direction that could be taken to improve this market range. The first official was in the sports arena in UL, he agreed that there was little in the way of equipment for those rehabilitating muscles other than thera-bands, which are prone to misuse. The aspect of the idea that most appealed to him was the thought of a product that would have the ability to be used for both sports injuries and general physiotherapy. He recommended a meeting with more specialised physiotherapists to get a more focused opinion on physical therapy. Next to be interviewed were two physiotherapists based in Newcastle West, co. Limerick. This was at a stage when the project was making a move towards focusing on the neck. They have their own clinic, West Limerick Physiotherapy & Neuro Rehabilitation Clinic in Newcastle West and were able to offer several areas in the physiotherapy where products needed development. Products that ranged from roller tubes for back pain to treatment tables. The biggest problem they stated was cost, there was equipment out there but because of increasing costs smaller practices like theirs were unable to afford P a g e | 13
  • 15. M a y | 2010 them. On the second visit to the West Limerick Physiotherapy & Neuro Rehabilitation Clinic the author was given demonstrations for several products and could immediately see the areas either where new products or improvements were needed. They gave a full list of books and publications to read up on, and in particular mentioned Professor Michelle Sterling, an author of several publications who is based in Queensland, Australia. At this point the author successfully contacted Professor Sterling and she has agreed to a Skype interview when she is free, but in the meantime offered to answer any immediate questions. The next interview carried out by the author was with a chartered physiotherapist based in Castletroy, Limerick who has masters in sports physiotherapy, he practices in the United Physiotherapy Clinic at Whitehorns, Castletroy. The author asked him, what he felt were the major flaws in whiplash treatment. He replied ‘after a trauma muscles become sensitised and the pain felt by the affected neck muscles can spread through the nervous system, making it difficult to treat, also with whiplash injuries, an x-ray of a perfectly healthy neck and an x-ray of a neck post whiplash will look the exact same so it can be hard to differentiate between tissue and muscle damage’. ‘Loads on damaged muscles can leave them fatigued, hampering treatment and during certain treatments the front neck muscles (deep neck flexors) become inhibited’. The author then asked him his opinion on his own thoughts that home treatment can be harmful as much as helpful! He agreed, stating that ‘there is a big problem with home exercises as there is no guarantee the exercises are being done properly and the exercises are being done at all’. He suggested maybe some form of a video diary or clicker to indicate number of replications done. He P a g e | 14
  • 16. M a y | 2010 also talked about Ultrasound treatment, this form of treatment allows the physiotherapist to view the muscles contracting. The author also contacted and visited physiotherapists in St. Camillus, Shelbourne road, Limerick. The physio echoed a lot of the points of view already gathered by the author, but was unable to offer more as they did not deal with whiplash first hand in the clinic. On the visit to St. Camillus the author was referred to their specialist physio clinic, located within a kilometre of the main clinic. The author was familiar with this clinic as he had completed rehabilitation there previously. The physio met there was very helpful and offered her opinions on several of the devices currently in use for whiplash rehabilitation. She felt the laser head-band/chart idea was effective but could be made more user-friendly. She did not have any major trouble with the bio-feedback either but again felt it could be more user- friendly. She did confess though that her patients had more negative feelings towards the bio-feedback than her. User trials ǀ Product–in-use Testing carried out by the author has included trials on different neck braces and on the ‘Stabilizer Bio-Feedback’. This testing helped distinguish the exact issues and flaws with the different treatment devices used for whiplash. Problems with neck braces included height around the neck that caused discomfort, other than this flaw the issues were to do with comfort and restriction of movement; these however were unavoidable with compromising the purpose of the brace. P a g e | 15
  • 17. M a y | 2010 7 neck-brace front 8 neck-brace back 9 neck-brace side Problems with the ‘Stabilizer Bio-Feedback’ were numerous. There were complaints about the position it had to be used in, the struggle to get the exact required pressure, having to keep the pressure gauge aloft for the duration of the exercise and also the fact the patient couldn’t take the device home to continue recovery. P a g e | 16
  • 18. M a y | 2010 Videos involving these user trials for both the neck brace and the bio-feedback device are available for viewing on www.johncussen.vox.com Market ǀ analysis At the moment Stabilizer are the only manufacturers of the bio feedback device. As there are no other manufacturers, there are no other variations of the product, meaning the current flaws remain constant. These flaws include a lack of clarity over how exactly to use the product. The pressure is hard to correctly gauge as there is constantly air moving between the tube connecting the pressure pump and gauge to the head rest. The current version also requires two people in order to use the device correctly for the duration of the exercise. The rest which sits under the neck offers no support for the head, which leads to doubt about how to position the device correctly this can also cause further muscle issues. These flaws are mainly due to the fact the device was originally invented for use by patients with back issues. The author feels the following features need to be introduced to the device to aid the physio and the patient.  Ability to use the device anytime, anywhere and in any position.  Easier to use.  Better neck support.  Incorporation of some sort of motivational device.  More cost effective. Currently, there are no other variations of this device on the market, or plans to introduce a new variation into the market. This gives the author reassurance P a g e | 17
  • 19. M a y | 2010 that there is a hole in the market that can be filled with a well designed and manufactured product that already has a concrete target market. Personality ǀ profiling The primary user will be the patient, with the secondary being the physiotherapist. Mike, 23, is a young male who is currently doing his masters degree in Biology, in University of Limerick. He is an independent individual who lives away from home and pays his own way in life by virtue of his part-time job. Mike is an active member of his local GAA club and enjoys kick-a-bouts with his friends during free evenings. He also has an active social life. One evening driving home from work Mike is rear ended by another vehicle but doesn’t suffer immediate health issues. A few weeks later however he complains of muscle pains, is referred to a physiotherapist, Linda, and is diagnosed with whiplash. With restricted movement and having to attend physiotherapy sessions once a week, Mike’s life is completely disrupted. He is unable to attend college, work or play any sports. He feels his treatment could be progressing faster, especially if he could continue his rehabilitation after physio sessions at home... Linda, 52, has been working as a physiotherapist for almost 30 years. She owns her own clinic and is used to dealing with whiplash victims, none more so than patients involved in road accidents. She has recently had to let a physiotherapist go because of spiralling expenses so as a result has a heavier workload. As her clinic is based in the city centre she has many whiplash P a g e | 18
  • 20. M a y | 2010 patients but little time to fit them all in for minimum one session a week. She finds recovery times slow as well and wishes there was only some way she could monitor her patients progress outside of sessions... Style ǀ analysis The styles a device for a neck muscle rehabilitation device would have to follow the typical medical device features. These include the device being a clean soft colour, having little or no ‘fancy tech add-ons’ and being designed to meet all medical requirements especially the strict guidelines of what is and isn’t classed as medical waste. The device should also look comfortable and to wear. The patient will be wearing the device for no longer than 10-15 minutes at any one time but it is still important for the device to carry an appealing aesthetic. P a g e | 19
  • 21. M a y | 2010 Appendices The following is a list of individuals who have been interviewed, offered advice or contributed to the project during research in any way. Claire Noonan, Physiotherapist, West Limerick Physiotherapy and Neuro Rehabilitation Clinic, Newcastle West Fiona Taylor, Physiotherapist West Limerick Physiotherapy and Neuro Rehabilitation Clinic, Newcastle West Dr Johnson McEvoy, United Physiotherapy Clinic at Whitehorns, Castletroy Dr Cian O’Neill, Course Director, health fitness, University of Limerick Assoc Prof Michele Sterling, Associate Professor, University of Queensland, Australia Niall Deloughry, Lecturer, M&OE Department, UL Dermot McInerney, Lecturer, M&OE Department, UL Muireann McMahon, Lecturer, M&OE Department, UL Sara Cox, Lecturer, M&OE Department, UL Marion McCarthy, Physiotherapist, St.Camillus, Shelbourne Road Sarah Breen, Post-graduate student, Department of physical education and sport sciences, UL Joseph Costello, Post-graduate student, Department of physical education and sport sciences, UL Dr Christy Gillick, Lecturer, M&OE department, UL Dr Colin Fitzpatrick, Lecturer, Electronic Engineering, UL Dr Pepijn Van de Ven, Lecturer, Electronic Engineering, UL P a g e | 20
  • 22. M a y | 2010 Interview with Professor Michele Sterling Q. The general time frame for recovery from a whiplash injury is said to be 8 to 12 weeks, is this true or a myth depending mostly on the seriousness of the injury sustained? A. This is a myth. Most data now indicates that around 50% will still have symptoms at 12 months (see paper from Bone and Joint Decade) Q.Is there an age group of common whiplash sufferers? A. Not really. Age is sometimes a predictor of outcome and sometimes not. Q. What are the muscles most affected during whiplash? A. Evidence for direct muscle injury/damage is inconclusive (see Siegmund paper). However there are certainly changes in muscle morphology and recruitment patterns that occur in response to either the injury or pain - it’s not clear which, (see Elliott and sterling papers). Q. Is there a minimum force that needs to be applied for a person to suffer neck muscle damage, or does this depends on the physical condition of the person involved? A. A minimum force for injury has never been demonstrated as far as I'm aware. People can be injured in low force/impact collisions. P a g e | 21
  • 23. M a y | 2010 Q. I myself suffered a form of whiplash as result of a fall playing sport. How common is a sports related whiplash injury? A. Probably fairly common, but not much research done on this. Probably because whiplash from car crashes costs a lot due to compensation etc. Q. I’ve recently used the bio-feedback rehabilitation device, and found it to be unreliable and sometimes inaccurate, what is your opinion of it? A. Reliability and accuracy improves with improved skills of the tester. The PBU is a clinical tool only - i.e. feedback for the phsyio and the patient. It is not really designed to be a diagnostic tool. Q. Are there any other devices like the bio-feedback for whiplash treatment currently available on the market? A. Not that I'm aware of. Q. Do you know of any devices for home treatment of whiplash injuries? A. Not sure what you mean here? Do you mean exercise devices? If so then no, not that I’m aware of. Q. When doing physio for rehabilitation of my left hand, I was given exercises to do outside of session time at home but found them to be doing as much harm as they were help, do you think this is one of the main reasons injuries are prolonged? P a g e | 22
  • 24. M a y | 2010 A. In the case of whiplash, a group of patients demonstrate widespread sensory hypersensitivity and cold allodynia that reflect central nervous system hyperexcitability. If any form of exercise aggravates these people's pain, then this will potentially further wind up the CNS and yes do more harm than good. If the exercises a pain free then things should be OK Pictures 10 11 P a g e | 23
  • 25. M a y | 2010 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 P a g e | 24
  • 26. M a y | 2010 19 Neck-brace experiment questions: Q. Is the product easy to get on? Q. Is the product comfortable to wear? Q. Is your movement restricted? Q. Does it offer adequate support? Each answer was to be given as a rating from 1 – 5 with 1 being weakest and 5 being strongest. P a g e | 25
  • 27. M a y | 2010 References 1. http://pericles.ipaustralia.gov.au/ols/auspat/quickSearch.do?queryString= 657277&resultsPerPage=http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph- Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PALL&p=1&u=/netahtml/PTO/s rchnum.htm&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1=5338276.PN.&OS=PN/5338276&RS=P N/5338276 2. http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph- Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PALL&p=1&u=/netahtml/PTO/s rchnum.htm&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1=5338276.PN.&OS=PN/5338276&RS=P N/5338276 3. http://brevets-patents.ic.gc.ca/opic- cipo/cpd/eng/patent/2058233/financial_transactions.html?type=number_ search 4. http://healthinfousa.com/chattanooga/biofeedback.jpg 5. Photos – John Cussen 6. Photos – John Cussen 7. Photos – John Cussen 8. Photos – John Cussen 9. Photos – John Cussen 10. Photos – John Cussen 11. Photos – John Cussen 12. Photos – John Cussen P a g e | 26
  • 28. M a y | 2010 13. http://g-ecx.images- amazon.com/images/G/01/books/promos/Muscles_Lateral_lg.jpg1 14. http://g-ecx.images- amazon.com/images/G/01/books/promos/Muscles_Lateral_lg.jpg2 15. http://g-ecx.images- amazon.com/images/G/01/books/promos/Muscles_Lateral_lg.jpg3 16. http://g-ecx.images- amazon.com/images/G/01/books/promos/Muscles_Lateral_lg.jpg4 17. http://www.a3bs.com/imagelibrary/VR1132_L/anatomical-charts-poster- size/VR1132_L_head-and-neck-chart.jpg1 18. http://www.a3bs.com/imagelibrary/VR1132_L/anatomical-charts-poster- size/VR1132_L_head-and-neck-chart.jpg2 19. http://www.physiostuff.com/repository/product/15/img_9781587793752.jp g 20. http://www.truckinfo.net/trucking/newwhiplashinformation.htm P a g e | 27
  • 29. M a y | 2010 Journals Whiplash Headache and Neck Pain, Jull, G. The journal of Rehabilitation Medicine, 2005 Do dorsal head contact forces have the potential to identify impairments during graded crainiocervical flexor muscle contractions, Jull, G. Sterling, M Smooth pursuit neck torsion test in whiplash associated orders - relationship to self reports of neck pain & disability, dizziness & anxiety, Jull, G. Sterling, M Publications Whiplash (grade II) and cervical radiculopathy share a similar sensory presentation: an investigation using quantitative sensory testing’ Sterling, M P a g e | 28