SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  23
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Copyright 2011 Digital Enterprise Research Institute. All rights reserved.
Digital Enterprise Research Institute www.deri.ie
Enabling Networked Knowledge
Talking is (virtual) work:
Supporting online argumentation
Jodi Schneider
Weds 18th September 2013
1
Dynamics of Virtual Work Training School
Valletta, Malta
Ph.D. student
o Information Management on
the Web
o Open collaboration systems
o Multidisciplinary,
mixed methods
@jschneider jodischneider.com
Open Collaboration Systems
o Wikipedia
o OpenStreetMap
o Project Gutenberg – Distributed Proofreaders
o Apache projects, Mozilla Firefox, …
In these Open Collaboration Systems
“people form ties with others & create things together”
(Forte and Lampe 2013)
How do we learn the “talk”?
Online “talk” for decisions
Talking is (virtual) work -supporting online argumentation--2013-09-18 Malta virtual work
What’s an Open Collaboration System?
“An online environment that
(1) supports the collective production of an artifact
(2) through a technologically mediated
collaboration platform
(3) that presents a low barrier to entry and exit,
and
(4) supports the emergence of
persistent but malleable social structures.”
(Forte and Lampe 2013)
What’s an Open Collaboration System?
“An online environment that
(1) supports the collective production of an artifact
(2) through a technologically mediated
collaboration platform
(3) that presents a low barrier to entry and exit,
and
(4) supports the emergence of
persistent but malleable social structures.”
(Forte and Lampe 2013)
“Group” collaborating
What’s an Open Collaboration System?
“An online environment that
(1) supports the collective production of an artifact
(2) through a technologically mediated
collaboration platform
(3) that presents a low barrier to entry and exit,
and
(4) supports the emergence of
persistent but malleable social structures.”
(Forte and Lampe 2013)
How things get done
OBSERVATIONS
“Group” collaborating
Make explicit things
get done.
Support Newcomers
by Making Rules Explicit
o Investigate Wikipedia discussions
o Provide semantic support
o Evaluate the impact on the community
Deletion threatens Wikipedia
o 1 in 4 new Wikipedia articles is deleted – within
minutes or hours
o Demotivating!
• 1 in 3 newcomers start by writing a new article
• 7X less likely to stay if their article is deleted!
o Can we support editor retention?
Talking is (virtual) work -supporting online argumentation--2013-09-18 Malta virtual work
Article creators
o Misunderstand policy
• “I do understand that articles on wikipedia need to be
sourced… it is due to have two [sources] once [our
website goes] live”
o Express high levels of emotion
• “To be honest it's been a real turn off adding articles to
WP and I don't think I will add articles again. So smile and
enjoy.”
o Learn from discussions
• “much as it would break my heart … it is perhaps sensible
that the piece is deleted.”
Jodi Schneider, Alexandre Passant, and Stefan Decker. “Deletion Discussions
in Wikipedia: Decision Factors and Outcomes.” In WikiSym2012.
Novices’ arguments
o Structurally different to experts’ arguments
o More problematic arguments from novices
• Personal preference
• Requesting a favor
• Analogy to other cases
• No harm in keeping an article
• Large number of search engine hits
Jodi Schneider, Krystian Samp, Alexandre Passant, Stefan Decker.
“Arguments about Deletion: How Experience Improves the Acceptability of
Arguments in Ad-hoc Online Task Groups”. In CSCW 2013.
Articulate criteria
4 Factors cover
• 91% of
comments
• 70% of
discussions
Factor Example (used to justify
`keep')
Notability Anyone covered by another
encyclopedic reference is
considered notable enough for
inclusion in Wikipedia.
Sources Basic information about this
album at a minimum is certainly
verifiable, it's a major label
release, and a highly notable
band.
Maintenance …this article is savable but at its
current state, needs a lot of
improvement.
Bias It is by no means spam (it does
not promote the products).
Other I'm advocating a blanket
"hangon" for all articles on newly-
drafted players
Jodi Schneider, Alexandre Passant, and Stefan Decker. “Deletion Discussions in
Wikipedia: Decision Factors and Outcomes.” In WikiSym2012.
Add semantic structure
Implementation based on Jodi Schneider and Krystian Samp
“Alternative Interfaces for Deletion Discussions in Wikipedia: Some
Proposals Using Decision Factors. [Demo]” In WikiSym2012.
84% prefer our system
“Information is structured and I can quickly get an
overview of the key arguments.”
“The ability to navigate the comments made it a bit
easier to filter my mind set and to come to a
conclusion.”
“It offers the structure needed to consider each factor
separately, thus making the decision easier. Also, the
number of comments per factor offers a quick
indication of the relevance and the deepness of the
decision.”
Thanks!
o Questions?
o Comments?
o jschneider@pobox.com
o @jschneider
Acknowledgements
o Thanks to collaborators!
• Krystian Samp
• Maciej Dabrowski
o Overall Ph.D. funding, Science Foundation Ireland Grant No.
SFI/08/CE/I1380 (Líon-2), advised by Alexandre Passant,
John Breslin & Stefan Decker
Talking is (virtual) work -supporting online argumentation--2013-09-18 Malta virtual work
image credit: Alexandre Passant
Goals
! "#$%&' ( )*+, (
- #./0", #1234)5%#$ 61%7 $( 8&( 9: %/ %1
- ( .4%1#$)
; , "1"%14)< )
=#$' ( 4
>1?' ".+
Find and Verify
Evidence
High Low Low
! "40%@( .+
Find and Defend a
Suitable Hypothesis
High Low Low
>1A%.: #/%1BC( ( D"1&
Acquire or Give
Information
High Low Low
! ( $"E( .#/%1
Coordinate Goals and
Actions
High Varies High
- ( .4' #4"%1 Persuade Other Party Varies High High
F ( &%/ #/%1
Get What You Most
Want
Low Varies High
9."4/ 0
Verbally Hit Out at
Opponent
Low High High
Walton & Krabbe. D. N. Walton. Commitment in dialogue. State
University of New York Press, Albany, 1995.

Contenu connexe

En vedette

Book review strategy map.
Book review strategy map.Book review strategy map.
Book review strategy map.nasirkhattak111
 
Book review 2
Book review 2Book review 2
Book review 2beverage
 
Book review
Book reviewBook review
Book reviewbeverage
 
Book Presentation on Usage and Abusage and Mind the Gaffe
Book Presentation on Usage and Abusage and Mind the GaffeBook Presentation on Usage and Abusage and Mind the Gaffe
Book Presentation on Usage and Abusage and Mind the GaffeSuyog Ketkar
 
Beirut World Book 2009 Strategy Organizational Plan
Beirut World Book 2009 Strategy Organizational PlanBeirut World Book 2009 Strategy Organizational Plan
Beirut World Book 2009 Strategy Organizational PlanNaja Faysal
 
Book presentation: Excess Returns: a comparative study of the methods of the ...
Book presentation: Excess Returns: a comparative study of the methods of the ...Book presentation: Excess Returns: a comparative study of the methods of the ...
Book presentation: Excess Returns: a comparative study of the methods of the ...Frederik Vanhaverbeke
 
Faride renard book review
Faride renard book reviewFaride renard book review
Faride renard book reviewfariderenard
 
5 Levels of Leadership
5 Levels of Leadership 5 Levels of Leadership
5 Levels of Leadership Des Hague
 

En vedette (11)

the Steve jobs i leadership for new generation book review
the Steve jobs i leadership for new generation   book reviewthe Steve jobs i leadership for new generation   book review
the Steve jobs i leadership for new generation book review
 
Book review strategy map.
Book review strategy map.Book review strategy map.
Book review strategy map.
 
Book review 2
Book review 2Book review 2
Book review 2
 
Book review
Book reviewBook review
Book review
 
Book Presentation on Usage and Abusage and Mind the Gaffe
Book Presentation on Usage and Abusage and Mind the GaffeBook Presentation on Usage and Abusage and Mind the Gaffe
Book Presentation on Usage and Abusage and Mind the Gaffe
 
Beirut World Book 2009 Strategy Organizational Plan
Beirut World Book 2009 Strategy Organizational PlanBeirut World Book 2009 Strategy Organizational Plan
Beirut World Book 2009 Strategy Organizational Plan
 
Book presentation: Excess Returns: a comparative study of the methods of the ...
Book presentation: Excess Returns: a comparative study of the methods of the ...Book presentation: Excess Returns: a comparative study of the methods of the ...
Book presentation: Excess Returns: a comparative study of the methods of the ...
 
Faride renard book review
Faride renard book reviewFaride renard book review
Faride renard book review
 
5 Levels of Leadership
5 Levels of Leadership 5 Levels of Leadership
5 Levels of Leadership
 
The Strategy Book
The Strategy BookThe Strategy Book
The Strategy Book
 
The Top 35 Books on Presentations
The Top 35 Books on PresentationsThe Top 35 Books on Presentations
The Top 35 Books on Presentations
 

Similaire à Talking is (virtual) work -supporting online argumentation--2013-09-18 Malta virtual work

Thesis summary-arguments-about-deleting-wikipedia-content-paris-2013-04-19
Thesis summary-arguments-about-deleting-wikipedia-content-paris-2013-04-19Thesis summary-arguments-about-deleting-wikipedia-content-paris-2013-04-19
Thesis summary-arguments-about-deleting-wikipedia-content-paris-2013-04-19jodischneider
 
How communities curate knowledge & how ontologists can help -Eurecom--2015-01-19
How communities curate knowledge & how ontologists can help -Eurecom--2015-01-19How communities curate knowledge & how ontologists can help -Eurecom--2015-01-19
How communities curate knowledge & how ontologists can help -Eurecom--2015-01-19jodischneider
 
Open Source in Libraries: Freedom and Community
Open Source in Libraries: Freedom and CommunityOpen Source in Libraries: Freedom and Community
Open Source in Libraries: Freedom and CommunityNicole C. Engard
 
Synthesizing knowledge from disagreement -cwi-2015-04-23
Synthesizing knowledge from disagreement -cwi-2015-04-23Synthesizing knowledge from disagreement -cwi-2015-04-23
Synthesizing knowledge from disagreement -cwi-2015-04-23jodischneider
 
Synthesizing knowledge from disagreement -- Manchester -- 2015-05-06
Synthesizing knowledge from disagreement -- Manchester -- 2015-05-06Synthesizing knowledge from disagreement -- Manchester -- 2015-05-06
Synthesizing knowledge from disagreement -- Manchester -- 2015-05-06jodischneider
 
DRIVE 2016 | 26 October: Smart Industry T2T
DRIVE 2016 | 26 October: Smart Industry T2TDRIVE 2016 | 26 October: Smart Industry T2T
DRIVE 2016 | 26 October: Smart Industry T2TCLICKNL
 
The Future of Social Networks on the Internet: The Need for Semantics
The Future of Social Networks on the Internet: The Need for SemanticsThe Future of Social Networks on the Internet: The Need for Semantics
The Future of Social Networks on the Internet: The Need for SemanticsJohn Breslin
 
Understanding Research 2.0 from a Socio-technical Perspective
Understanding Research 2.0 from a Socio-technical PerspectiveUnderstanding Research 2.0 from a Socio-technical Perspective
Understanding Research 2.0 from a Socio-technical PerspectiveYuwei Lin
 
Diversity and inclusion in Open Source Software Communities
Diversity and inclusion in Open Source Software CommunitiesDiversity and inclusion in Open Source Software Communities
Diversity and inclusion in Open Source Software CommunitiesAlexander Serebrenik
 
Enhancing Learning & Participation: Critical Thinking Strategies & Practice
Enhancing Learning & Participation: Critical Thinking Strategies & PracticeEnhancing Learning & Participation: Critical Thinking Strategies & Practice
Enhancing Learning & Participation: Critical Thinking Strategies & PracticeSt. Petersburg College
 
BCcampus a-great-babbling-bazaar
BCcampus a-great-babbling-bazaarBCcampus a-great-babbling-bazaar
BCcampus a-great-babbling-bazaarb p
 
Massively Multiplayer Object Sharing 10328
Massively Multiplayer Object Sharing 10328Massively Multiplayer Object Sharing 10328
Massively Multiplayer Object Sharing 10328Donggi heo
 
Massively multiplayer object sharing (Web 2.0 open 2008)
Massively multiplayer object sharing (Web 2.0 open 2008)Massively multiplayer object sharing (Web 2.0 open 2008)
Massively multiplayer object sharing (Web 2.0 open 2008)Rashmi Sinha
 
Open source-and-you-gr8conf-us-2013
Open source-and-you-gr8conf-us-2013Open source-and-you-gr8conf-us-2013
Open source-and-you-gr8conf-us-2013Peter Ledbrook
 
Looking for Commonsense in the Semantic Web
Looking for Commonsense in the Semantic WebLooking for Commonsense in the Semantic Web
Looking for Commonsense in the Semantic WebValentina Presutti
 
FORCE11: Future of Research Communications and e-Scholarship
FORCE11:  Future of Research Communications and e-ScholarshipFORCE11:  Future of Research Communications and e-Scholarship
FORCE11: Future of Research Communications and e-ScholarshipMaryann Martone
 

Similaire à Talking is (virtual) work -supporting online argumentation--2013-09-18 Malta virtual work (20)

Thesis summary-arguments-about-deleting-wikipedia-content-paris-2013-04-19
Thesis summary-arguments-about-deleting-wikipedia-content-paris-2013-04-19Thesis summary-arguments-about-deleting-wikipedia-content-paris-2013-04-19
Thesis summary-arguments-about-deleting-wikipedia-content-paris-2013-04-19
 
How communities curate knowledge & how ontologists can help -Eurecom--2015-01-19
How communities curate knowledge & how ontologists can help -Eurecom--2015-01-19How communities curate knowledge & how ontologists can help -Eurecom--2015-01-19
How communities curate knowledge & how ontologists can help -Eurecom--2015-01-19
 
Open Source in Libraries: Freedom and Community
Open Source in Libraries: Freedom and CommunityOpen Source in Libraries: Freedom and Community
Open Source in Libraries: Freedom and Community
 
Synthesizing knowledge from disagreement -cwi-2015-04-23
Synthesizing knowledge from disagreement -cwi-2015-04-23Synthesizing knowledge from disagreement -cwi-2015-04-23
Synthesizing knowledge from disagreement -cwi-2015-04-23
 
Synthesizing knowledge from disagreement -- Manchester -- 2015-05-06
Synthesizing knowledge from disagreement -- Manchester -- 2015-05-06Synthesizing knowledge from disagreement -- Manchester -- 2015-05-06
Synthesizing knowledge from disagreement -- Manchester -- 2015-05-06
 
DRIVE 2016 | 26 October: Smart Industry T2T
DRIVE 2016 | 26 October: Smart Industry T2TDRIVE 2016 | 26 October: Smart Industry T2T
DRIVE 2016 | 26 October: Smart Industry T2T
 
The Future of Social Networks on the Internet: The Need for Semantics
The Future of Social Networks on the Internet: The Need for SemanticsThe Future of Social Networks on the Internet: The Need for Semantics
The Future of Social Networks on the Internet: The Need for Semantics
 
Understanding Research 2.0 from a Socio-technical Perspective
Understanding Research 2.0 from a Socio-technical PerspectiveUnderstanding Research 2.0 from a Socio-technical Perspective
Understanding Research 2.0 from a Socio-technical Perspective
 
Diversity and inclusion in Open Source Software Communities
Diversity and inclusion in Open Source Software CommunitiesDiversity and inclusion in Open Source Software Communities
Diversity and inclusion in Open Source Software Communities
 
Oss swot
Oss swotOss swot
Oss swot
 
Enhancing Learning & Participation: Critical Thinking Strategies & Practice
Enhancing Learning & Participation: Critical Thinking Strategies & PracticeEnhancing Learning & Participation: Critical Thinking Strategies & Practice
Enhancing Learning & Participation: Critical Thinking Strategies & Practice
 
BCcampus a-great-babbling-bazaar
BCcampus a-great-babbling-bazaarBCcampus a-great-babbling-bazaar
BCcampus a-great-babbling-bazaar
 
Massively Multiplayer Object Sharing 10328
Massively Multiplayer Object Sharing 10328Massively Multiplayer Object Sharing 10328
Massively Multiplayer Object Sharing 10328
 
Massively multiplayer object sharing (Web 2.0 open 2008)
Massively multiplayer object sharing (Web 2.0 open 2008)Massively multiplayer object sharing (Web 2.0 open 2008)
Massively multiplayer object sharing (Web 2.0 open 2008)
 
Trends
TrendsTrends
Trends
 
Towards An Improvement Community Platform for Service Innovation
Towards An Improvement Community Platform for Service InnovationTowards An Improvement Community Platform for Service Innovation
Towards An Improvement Community Platform for Service Innovation
 
Open source-and-you-gr8conf-us-2013
Open source-and-you-gr8conf-us-2013Open source-and-you-gr8conf-us-2013
Open source-and-you-gr8conf-us-2013
 
Looking for Commonsense in the Semantic Web
Looking for Commonsense in the Semantic WebLooking for Commonsense in the Semantic Web
Looking for Commonsense in the Semantic Web
 
FORCE11: Future of Research Communications and e-Scholarship
FORCE11:  Future of Research Communications and e-ScholarshipFORCE11:  Future of Research Communications and e-Scholarship
FORCE11: Future of Research Communications and e-Scholarship
 
To Wiki or Not to Wiki
To Wiki or Not to WikiTo Wiki or Not to Wiki
To Wiki or Not to Wiki
 

Plus de jodischneider

Continued citation of bad science and what we can do about it--2021-04-20
Continued citation of bad science and what we can do about it--2021-04-20Continued citation of bad science and what we can do about it--2021-04-20
Continued citation of bad science and what we can do about it--2021-04-20jodischneider
 
Continued citation of bad science and what we can do about it--2021-02-19
Continued citation of bad science and what we can do about it--2021-02-19Continued citation of bad science and what we can do about it--2021-02-19
Continued citation of bad science and what we can do about it--2021-02-19jodischneider
 
The problems of post retraction citation - and mitigation strategies that wor...
The problems of post retraction citation - and mitigation strategies that wor...The problems of post retraction citation - and mitigation strategies that wor...
The problems of post retraction citation - and mitigation strategies that wor...jodischneider
 
Towards knowledge maintenance in scientific digital libraries with the keysto...
Towards knowledge maintenance in scientific digital libraries with the keysto...Towards knowledge maintenance in scientific digital libraries with the keysto...
Towards knowledge maintenance in scientific digital libraries with the keysto...jodischneider
 
Methods Pyramids as an Organizing Structure for Evidence-Based Medicine--SIGC...
Methods Pyramids as an Organizing Structure for Evidence-Based Medicine--SIGC...Methods Pyramids as an Organizing Structure for Evidence-Based Medicine--SIGC...
Methods Pyramids as an Organizing Structure for Evidence-Based Medicine--SIGC...jodischneider
 
Annotation examples--Fribourg--2019-09-03
Annotation examples--Fribourg--2019-09-03Annotation examples--Fribourg--2019-09-03
Annotation examples--Fribourg--2019-09-03jodischneider
 
Argumentation mining--an introduction for linguists--Fribourg--2019-09-02
Argumentation mining--an introduction for linguists--Fribourg--2019-09-02Argumentation mining--an introduction for linguists--Fribourg--2019-09-02
Argumentation mining--an introduction for linguists--Fribourg--2019-09-02jodischneider
 
Beyond Randomized Clinical Trials: emerging innovations in reasoning about he...
Beyond Randomized Clinical Trials: emerging innovations in reasoning about he...Beyond Randomized Clinical Trials: emerging innovations in reasoning about he...
Beyond Randomized Clinical Trials: emerging innovations in reasoning about he...jodischneider
 
Problem-citations--CrossrefLive18--2018-11-13
Problem-citations--CrossrefLive18--2018-11-13Problem-citations--CrossrefLive18--2018-11-13
Problem-citations--CrossrefLive18--2018-11-13jodischneider
 
Problematic citations--Workshop-on-Open-Citations--2018-09-03
Problematic citations--Workshop-on-Open-Citations--2018-09-03Problematic citations--Workshop-on-Open-Citations--2018-09-03
Problematic citations--Workshop-on-Open-Citations--2018-09-03jodischneider
 
Modeling Alzheimer’s Disease research claims, evidence, and arguments from a ...
Modeling Alzheimer’s Disease research claims, evidence, and arguments from a ...Modeling Alzheimer’s Disease research claims, evidence, and arguments from a ...
Modeling Alzheimer’s Disease research claims, evidence, and arguments from a ...jodischneider
 
Innovations in reasoning about health: the case of the Randomized Clinical Tr...
Innovations in reasoning about health: the case of the Randomized Clinical Tr...Innovations in reasoning about health: the case of the Randomized Clinical Tr...
Innovations in reasoning about health: the case of the Randomized Clinical Tr...jodischneider
 
Viewing universities as landscapes of scholarship, VIVO keynote, 2017-08-04
Viewing universities as landscapes of scholarship, VIVO keynote, 2017-08-04Viewing universities as landscapes of scholarship, VIVO keynote, 2017-08-04
Viewing universities as landscapes of scholarship, VIVO keynote, 2017-08-04jodischneider
 
Rhetorical moves and audience considerations in the discussion sections of ra...
Rhetorical moves and audience considerations in the discussion sections of ra...Rhetorical moves and audience considerations in the discussion sections of ra...
Rhetorical moves and audience considerations in the discussion sections of ra...jodischneider
 
Citation practices and the construction of scientific fact--ECA-facts-preconf...
Citation practices and the construction of scientific fact--ECA-facts-preconf...Citation practices and the construction of scientific fact--ECA-facts-preconf...
Citation practices and the construction of scientific fact--ECA-facts-preconf...jodischneider
 
What WikiCite can learn from biomedical citation networks--Wikicite2017--2017...
What WikiCite can learn from biomedical citation networks--Wikicite2017--2017...What WikiCite can learn from biomedical citation networks--Wikicite2017--2017...
What WikiCite can learn from biomedical citation networks--Wikicite2017--2017...jodischneider
 
Medication safety as a use case for argumentation mining, Dagstuhl seminar 16...
Medication safety as a use case for argumentation mining, Dagstuhl seminar 16...Medication safety as a use case for argumentation mining, Dagstuhl seminar 16...
Medication safety as a use case for argumentation mining, Dagstuhl seminar 16...jodischneider
 
Acquiring and representing drug-drug interaction knowledge and evidence, Litm...
Acquiring and representing drug-drug interaction knowledge and evidence, Litm...Acquiring and representing drug-drug interaction knowledge and evidence, Litm...
Acquiring and representing drug-drug interaction knowledge and evidence, Litm...jodischneider
 
Acquiring and representing drug-drug interaction knowledge and evidence, TRIA...
Acquiring and representing drug-drug interaction knowledge and evidence, TRIA...Acquiring and representing drug-drug interaction knowledge and evidence, TRIA...
Acquiring and representing drug-drug interaction knowledge and evidence, TRIA...jodischneider
 
Persons, documents, models: organising and structuring information for the We...
Persons, documents, models: organising and structuring information for the We...Persons, documents, models: organising and structuring information for the We...
Persons, documents, models: organising and structuring information for the We...jodischneider
 

Plus de jodischneider (20)

Continued citation of bad science and what we can do about it--2021-04-20
Continued citation of bad science and what we can do about it--2021-04-20Continued citation of bad science and what we can do about it--2021-04-20
Continued citation of bad science and what we can do about it--2021-04-20
 
Continued citation of bad science and what we can do about it--2021-02-19
Continued citation of bad science and what we can do about it--2021-02-19Continued citation of bad science and what we can do about it--2021-02-19
Continued citation of bad science and what we can do about it--2021-02-19
 
The problems of post retraction citation - and mitigation strategies that wor...
The problems of post retraction citation - and mitigation strategies that wor...The problems of post retraction citation - and mitigation strategies that wor...
The problems of post retraction citation - and mitigation strategies that wor...
 
Towards knowledge maintenance in scientific digital libraries with the keysto...
Towards knowledge maintenance in scientific digital libraries with the keysto...Towards knowledge maintenance in scientific digital libraries with the keysto...
Towards knowledge maintenance in scientific digital libraries with the keysto...
 
Methods Pyramids as an Organizing Structure for Evidence-Based Medicine--SIGC...
Methods Pyramids as an Organizing Structure for Evidence-Based Medicine--SIGC...Methods Pyramids as an Organizing Structure for Evidence-Based Medicine--SIGC...
Methods Pyramids as an Organizing Structure for Evidence-Based Medicine--SIGC...
 
Annotation examples--Fribourg--2019-09-03
Annotation examples--Fribourg--2019-09-03Annotation examples--Fribourg--2019-09-03
Annotation examples--Fribourg--2019-09-03
 
Argumentation mining--an introduction for linguists--Fribourg--2019-09-02
Argumentation mining--an introduction for linguists--Fribourg--2019-09-02Argumentation mining--an introduction for linguists--Fribourg--2019-09-02
Argumentation mining--an introduction for linguists--Fribourg--2019-09-02
 
Beyond Randomized Clinical Trials: emerging innovations in reasoning about he...
Beyond Randomized Clinical Trials: emerging innovations in reasoning about he...Beyond Randomized Clinical Trials: emerging innovations in reasoning about he...
Beyond Randomized Clinical Trials: emerging innovations in reasoning about he...
 
Problem-citations--CrossrefLive18--2018-11-13
Problem-citations--CrossrefLive18--2018-11-13Problem-citations--CrossrefLive18--2018-11-13
Problem-citations--CrossrefLive18--2018-11-13
 
Problematic citations--Workshop-on-Open-Citations--2018-09-03
Problematic citations--Workshop-on-Open-Citations--2018-09-03Problematic citations--Workshop-on-Open-Citations--2018-09-03
Problematic citations--Workshop-on-Open-Citations--2018-09-03
 
Modeling Alzheimer’s Disease research claims, evidence, and arguments from a ...
Modeling Alzheimer’s Disease research claims, evidence, and arguments from a ...Modeling Alzheimer’s Disease research claims, evidence, and arguments from a ...
Modeling Alzheimer’s Disease research claims, evidence, and arguments from a ...
 
Innovations in reasoning about health: the case of the Randomized Clinical Tr...
Innovations in reasoning about health: the case of the Randomized Clinical Tr...Innovations in reasoning about health: the case of the Randomized Clinical Tr...
Innovations in reasoning about health: the case of the Randomized Clinical Tr...
 
Viewing universities as landscapes of scholarship, VIVO keynote, 2017-08-04
Viewing universities as landscapes of scholarship, VIVO keynote, 2017-08-04Viewing universities as landscapes of scholarship, VIVO keynote, 2017-08-04
Viewing universities as landscapes of scholarship, VIVO keynote, 2017-08-04
 
Rhetorical moves and audience considerations in the discussion sections of ra...
Rhetorical moves and audience considerations in the discussion sections of ra...Rhetorical moves and audience considerations in the discussion sections of ra...
Rhetorical moves and audience considerations in the discussion sections of ra...
 
Citation practices and the construction of scientific fact--ECA-facts-preconf...
Citation practices and the construction of scientific fact--ECA-facts-preconf...Citation practices and the construction of scientific fact--ECA-facts-preconf...
Citation practices and the construction of scientific fact--ECA-facts-preconf...
 
What WikiCite can learn from biomedical citation networks--Wikicite2017--2017...
What WikiCite can learn from biomedical citation networks--Wikicite2017--2017...What WikiCite can learn from biomedical citation networks--Wikicite2017--2017...
What WikiCite can learn from biomedical citation networks--Wikicite2017--2017...
 
Medication safety as a use case for argumentation mining, Dagstuhl seminar 16...
Medication safety as a use case for argumentation mining, Dagstuhl seminar 16...Medication safety as a use case for argumentation mining, Dagstuhl seminar 16...
Medication safety as a use case for argumentation mining, Dagstuhl seminar 16...
 
Acquiring and representing drug-drug interaction knowledge and evidence, Litm...
Acquiring and representing drug-drug interaction knowledge and evidence, Litm...Acquiring and representing drug-drug interaction knowledge and evidence, Litm...
Acquiring and representing drug-drug interaction knowledge and evidence, Litm...
 
Acquiring and representing drug-drug interaction knowledge and evidence, TRIA...
Acquiring and representing drug-drug interaction knowledge and evidence, TRIA...Acquiring and representing drug-drug interaction knowledge and evidence, TRIA...
Acquiring and representing drug-drug interaction knowledge and evidence, TRIA...
 
Persons, documents, models: organising and structuring information for the We...
Persons, documents, models: organising and structuring information for the We...Persons, documents, models: organising and structuring information for the We...
Persons, documents, models: organising and structuring information for the We...
 

Dernier

UiPath Platform: The Backend Engine Powering Your Automation - Session 1
UiPath Platform: The Backend Engine Powering Your Automation - Session 1UiPath Platform: The Backend Engine Powering Your Automation - Session 1
UiPath Platform: The Backend Engine Powering Your Automation - Session 1DianaGray10
 
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 8
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 8UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 8
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 8DianaGray10
 
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019IES VE
 
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just Minutes
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just MinutesAI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just Minutes
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just MinutesMd Hossain Ali
 
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?IES VE
 
9 Steps For Building Winning Founding Team
9 Steps For Building Winning Founding Team9 Steps For Building Winning Founding Team
9 Steps For Building Winning Founding TeamAdam Moalla
 
UiPath Solutions Management Preview - Northern CA Chapter - March 22.pdf
UiPath Solutions Management Preview - Northern CA Chapter - March 22.pdfUiPath Solutions Management Preview - Northern CA Chapter - March 22.pdf
UiPath Solutions Management Preview - Northern CA Chapter - March 22.pdfDianaGray10
 
COMPUTER 10 Lesson 8 - Building a Website
COMPUTER 10 Lesson 8 - Building a WebsiteCOMPUTER 10 Lesson 8 - Building a Website
COMPUTER 10 Lesson 8 - Building a Websitedgelyza
 
activity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdf
activity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdf
activity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfJamie (Taka) Wang
 
IaC & GitOps in a Nutshell - a FridayInANuthshell Episode.pdf
IaC & GitOps in a Nutshell - a FridayInANuthshell Episode.pdfIaC & GitOps in a Nutshell - a FridayInANuthshell Episode.pdf
IaC & GitOps in a Nutshell - a FridayInANuthshell Episode.pdfDaniel Santiago Silva Capera
 
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 7
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 7UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 7
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 7DianaGray10
 
Anypoint Code Builder , Google Pub sub connector and MuleSoft RPA
Anypoint Code Builder , Google Pub sub connector and MuleSoft RPAAnypoint Code Builder , Google Pub sub connector and MuleSoft RPA
Anypoint Code Builder , Google Pub sub connector and MuleSoft RPAshyamraj55
 
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdf
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdfMachine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdf
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdfAijun Zhang
 
Using IESVE for Loads, Sizing and Heat Pump Modeling to Achieve Decarbonization
Using IESVE for Loads, Sizing and Heat Pump Modeling to Achieve DecarbonizationUsing IESVE for Loads, Sizing and Heat Pump Modeling to Achieve Decarbonization
Using IESVE for Loads, Sizing and Heat Pump Modeling to Achieve DecarbonizationIES VE
 
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBX
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBXVoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBX
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBXTarek Kalaji
 
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability Adventure
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability AdventureOpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability Adventure
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability AdventureEric D. Schabell
 
Computer 10: Lesson 10 - Online Crimes and Hazards
Computer 10: Lesson 10 - Online Crimes and HazardsComputer 10: Lesson 10 - Online Crimes and Hazards
Computer 10: Lesson 10 - Online Crimes and HazardsSeth Reyes
 
Linked Data in Production: Moving Beyond Ontologies
Linked Data in Production: Moving Beyond OntologiesLinked Data in Production: Moving Beyond Ontologies
Linked Data in Production: Moving Beyond OntologiesDavid Newbury
 
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity Webinar
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity WebinarAI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity Webinar
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity WebinarPrecisely
 

Dernier (20)

UiPath Platform: The Backend Engine Powering Your Automation - Session 1
UiPath Platform: The Backend Engine Powering Your Automation - Session 1UiPath Platform: The Backend Engine Powering Your Automation - Session 1
UiPath Platform: The Backend Engine Powering Your Automation - Session 1
 
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 8
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 8UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 8
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 8
 
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
 
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just Minutes
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just MinutesAI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just Minutes
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just Minutes
 
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?
 
9 Steps For Building Winning Founding Team
9 Steps For Building Winning Founding Team9 Steps For Building Winning Founding Team
9 Steps For Building Winning Founding Team
 
UiPath Solutions Management Preview - Northern CA Chapter - March 22.pdf
UiPath Solutions Management Preview - Northern CA Chapter - March 22.pdfUiPath Solutions Management Preview - Northern CA Chapter - March 22.pdf
UiPath Solutions Management Preview - Northern CA Chapter - March 22.pdf
 
COMPUTER 10 Lesson 8 - Building a Website
COMPUTER 10 Lesson 8 - Building a WebsiteCOMPUTER 10 Lesson 8 - Building a Website
COMPUTER 10 Lesson 8 - Building a Website
 
activity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdf
activity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdf
activity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdfactivity_diagram_combine_v4_20190827.pdf
 
IaC & GitOps in a Nutshell - a FridayInANuthshell Episode.pdf
IaC & GitOps in a Nutshell - a FridayInANuthshell Episode.pdfIaC & GitOps in a Nutshell - a FridayInANuthshell Episode.pdf
IaC & GitOps in a Nutshell - a FridayInANuthshell Episode.pdf
 
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 7
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 7UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 7
UiPath Studio Web workshop series - Day 7
 
Anypoint Code Builder , Google Pub sub connector and MuleSoft RPA
Anypoint Code Builder , Google Pub sub connector and MuleSoft RPAAnypoint Code Builder , Google Pub sub connector and MuleSoft RPA
Anypoint Code Builder , Google Pub sub connector and MuleSoft RPA
 
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdf
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdfMachine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdf
Machine Learning Model Validation (Aijun Zhang 2024).pdf
 
Using IESVE for Loads, Sizing and Heat Pump Modeling to Achieve Decarbonization
Using IESVE for Loads, Sizing and Heat Pump Modeling to Achieve DecarbonizationUsing IESVE for Loads, Sizing and Heat Pump Modeling to Achieve Decarbonization
Using IESVE for Loads, Sizing and Heat Pump Modeling to Achieve Decarbonization
 
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBX
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBXVoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBX
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBX
 
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability Adventure
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability AdventureOpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability Adventure
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability Adventure
 
Computer 10: Lesson 10 - Online Crimes and Hazards
Computer 10: Lesson 10 - Online Crimes and HazardsComputer 10: Lesson 10 - Online Crimes and Hazards
Computer 10: Lesson 10 - Online Crimes and Hazards
 
Linked Data in Production: Moving Beyond Ontologies
Linked Data in Production: Moving Beyond OntologiesLinked Data in Production: Moving Beyond Ontologies
Linked Data in Production: Moving Beyond Ontologies
 
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity Webinar
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity WebinarAI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity Webinar
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity Webinar
 
20230104 - machine vision
20230104 - machine vision20230104 - machine vision
20230104 - machine vision
 

Talking is (virtual) work -supporting online argumentation--2013-09-18 Malta virtual work

  • 1. Copyright 2011 Digital Enterprise Research Institute. All rights reserved. Digital Enterprise Research Institute www.deri.ie Enabling Networked Knowledge Talking is (virtual) work: Supporting online argumentation Jodi Schneider Weds 18th September 2013 1 Dynamics of Virtual Work Training School Valletta, Malta
  • 2. Ph.D. student o Information Management on the Web o Open collaboration systems o Multidisciplinary, mixed methods @jschneider jodischneider.com
  • 3. Open Collaboration Systems o Wikipedia o OpenStreetMap o Project Gutenberg – Distributed Proofreaders o Apache projects, Mozilla Firefox, … In these Open Collaboration Systems “people form ties with others & create things together” (Forte and Lampe 2013)
  • 4. How do we learn the “talk”?
  • 7. What’s an Open Collaboration System? “An online environment that (1) supports the collective production of an artifact (2) through a technologically mediated collaboration platform (3) that presents a low barrier to entry and exit, and (4) supports the emergence of persistent but malleable social structures.” (Forte and Lampe 2013)
  • 8. What’s an Open Collaboration System? “An online environment that (1) supports the collective production of an artifact (2) through a technologically mediated collaboration platform (3) that presents a low barrier to entry and exit, and (4) supports the emergence of persistent but malleable social structures.” (Forte and Lampe 2013) “Group” collaborating
  • 9. What’s an Open Collaboration System? “An online environment that (1) supports the collective production of an artifact (2) through a technologically mediated collaboration platform (3) that presents a low barrier to entry and exit, and (4) supports the emergence of persistent but malleable social structures.” (Forte and Lampe 2013) How things get done
  • 11. Support Newcomers by Making Rules Explicit o Investigate Wikipedia discussions o Provide semantic support o Evaluate the impact on the community
  • 12. Deletion threatens Wikipedia o 1 in 4 new Wikipedia articles is deleted – within minutes or hours o Demotivating! • 1 in 3 newcomers start by writing a new article • 7X less likely to stay if their article is deleted! o Can we support editor retention?
  • 14. Article creators o Misunderstand policy • “I do understand that articles on wikipedia need to be sourced… it is due to have two [sources] once [our website goes] live” o Express high levels of emotion • “To be honest it's been a real turn off adding articles to WP and I don't think I will add articles again. So smile and enjoy.” o Learn from discussions • “much as it would break my heart … it is perhaps sensible that the piece is deleted.” Jodi Schneider, Alexandre Passant, and Stefan Decker. “Deletion Discussions in Wikipedia: Decision Factors and Outcomes.” In WikiSym2012.
  • 15. Novices’ arguments o Structurally different to experts’ arguments o More problematic arguments from novices • Personal preference • Requesting a favor • Analogy to other cases • No harm in keeping an article • Large number of search engine hits Jodi Schneider, Krystian Samp, Alexandre Passant, Stefan Decker. “Arguments about Deletion: How Experience Improves the Acceptability of Arguments in Ad-hoc Online Task Groups”. In CSCW 2013.
  • 16. Articulate criteria 4 Factors cover • 91% of comments • 70% of discussions Factor Example (used to justify `keep') Notability Anyone covered by another encyclopedic reference is considered notable enough for inclusion in Wikipedia. Sources Basic information about this album at a minimum is certainly verifiable, it's a major label release, and a highly notable band. Maintenance …this article is savable but at its current state, needs a lot of improvement. Bias It is by no means spam (it does not promote the products). Other I'm advocating a blanket "hangon" for all articles on newly- drafted players Jodi Schneider, Alexandre Passant, and Stefan Decker. “Deletion Discussions in Wikipedia: Decision Factors and Outcomes.” In WikiSym2012.
  • 17. Add semantic structure Implementation based on Jodi Schneider and Krystian Samp “Alternative Interfaces for Deletion Discussions in Wikipedia: Some Proposals Using Decision Factors. [Demo]” In WikiSym2012.
  • 18. 84% prefer our system “Information is structured and I can quickly get an overview of the key arguments.” “The ability to navigate the comments made it a bit easier to filter my mind set and to come to a conclusion.” “It offers the structure needed to consider each factor separately, thus making the decision easier. Also, the number of comments per factor offers a quick indication of the relevance and the deepness of the decision.”
  • 19. Thanks! o Questions? o Comments? o jschneider@pobox.com o @jschneider
  • 20. Acknowledgements o Thanks to collaborators! • Krystian Samp • Maciej Dabrowski o Overall Ph.D. funding, Science Foundation Ireland Grant No. SFI/08/CE/I1380 (Líon-2), advised by Alexandre Passant, John Breslin & Stefan Decker
  • 23. Goals ! "#$%&' ( )*+, ( - #./0", #1234)5%#$ 61%7 $( 8&( 9: %/ %1 - ( .4%1#$) ; , "1"%14)< ) =#$' ( 4 >1?' ".+ Find and Verify Evidence High Low Low ! "40%@( .+ Find and Defend a Suitable Hypothesis High Low Low >1A%.: #/%1BC( ( D"1& Acquire or Give Information High Low Low ! ( $"E( .#/%1 Coordinate Goals and Actions High Varies High - ( .4' #4"%1 Persuade Other Party Varies High High F ( &%/ #/%1 Get What You Most Want Low Varies High 9."4/ 0 Verbally Hit Out at Opponent Low High High Walton & Krabbe. D. N. Walton. Commitment in dialogue. State University of New York Press, Albany, 1995.

Notes de l'éditeur

  1. http://www.contentwire.com/img/zPEAXe6Ec-soFKmr.jpghttp://www.google.com.mt/imgres?safe=off&amp;hl=en&amp;biw=1024&amp;bih=571&amp;tbm=isch&amp;tbnid=xZxsbu4u3puYRM:&amp;imgrefurl=https://plus.google.com/101764199159921388632&amp;docid=Oa38elmbOUqkBM&amp;imgurl=https://lh3.googleusercontent.com/-g_3CKS9d2Y4/T_NocbZKNKI/AAAAAAAAACg/fZ1SoO3L_7g/s0-d/business_meeting.jpg&amp;w=812&amp;h=300&amp;ei=DKA5UubxMorStAa05ICIBw&amp;zoom=1&amp;iact=rc&amp;dur=94&amp;page=6&amp;tbnh=131&amp;tbnw=217&amp;start=85&amp;ndsp=19&amp;ved=1t:429,r:94,s:0,i:368&amp;tx=100&amp;ty=59
  2. written arguments and opinionsanyone can participate
  3. “An online environment that supports the collective production of an artifact through a technologically mediated collaboration platform that presents a low barrier to entry and exit, andsupports the emergence of persistent but malleable social structures.”(Forte and Lampe 2013)
  4. Summarising my research to dateSkills, knowledge and track record I can bring to Understand &amp; improve online discussions Enabling reuse of arguments and opinions from online social disputes
  5. 1“only 0.6 percent of those whose articles are met with deletion stayed editing, compared to 4.4 percent of the users whose articles remained”, http://enwp.org/Wikipedia:Wikipedia_ Signpost/2011-04-04/Editor_retention
  6. Mentoring in discussions is effective: Article creators who receive mentoring seem toMake more edits to the articleContinue editingIncrease understanding of policy
  7. Experts argue from precedentNovices: values, analogy, cause to effectJodi Schneider, KrystianSamp, Alexandre Passant, and Stefan Decker. Arguments about Deletion: How Experience Improves the Acceptability of Arguments in Ad-hoc Online Task Groups. Computer-Supported Cooperative Work and Social Computing (CSCW 2013).
  8. 500 discussions per week about deleting borderline articles
  9. 20 novice participants used both systems“The ability to navigate the comments made it a bit easier to filter my mind set and to come to a conclusion.”“summarise and, at the same time, evaluate which factor should be considered determinant for the final decision”
  10. Different users are persuaded by different kinds of information. Therefore, to solve peoples’ problems, based on knowledge bases, when dealing with inconsistency, understanding the purposes and goals that people have would be useful. Therefore, the goals of a particular dialogue also matter. These have been considered in argumentation theory: Walton &amp; Krabbe have categorized dialogue types based on the initial situation, participant’s goal, and the goal of the dialogue [11]. The types they distinguish are inquiry, discovery, information seeking, deliberation, persuasion, negotiation and eristic. These are abstractions–any single conversation moves through various dialogue types. For example, a deliberation may be paused in order to delve into information seeking, then resumed once the needed information has been obtained. Higher level context would also be useful: different amounts of certainty are needed for different purposes. Some of that is inherent in a task: Reasoning about what kind of medical treatment to seek for a long-term illness, based on PatientsLikeMe, requires more certainty than deciding what to buy based on product reviews. Informal language is very typically found in social media. Generic language processing issues, with misspellings and abbreviations, slang, language mixing emoticons, and unusual use of punctuation, must be resolved in order to enable text mining (and subsequently argumentation mining) on informal language. Indirect forms of speech, such as sarcasm, irony, and innuendo, are also common. A step-by-step approach, focusing first on what can be handled, is necessary. Another aspect of the informality is that much information is left implicit. Therefore, inferring from context is essential. Elliptical statements require us to infer common world knowledge, and connecting to existing knowledge bases will be needed. We apply sentiment techniques to provide candidates for argumentation mining and especially to identify textual markers of subjectivity and objectivity. The arguments that are made about or against purported facts have a different form from the arguments that are made about opinions. Arguments about objective statements provide the reasons for believing a purported fact or how certain it is. Subjective arguments might indicate, for instance, which users would benefit from a service or product (those similar to the poster). Another area where subjective arguments may appear is discussions of the trust and credibility about the people making the arguments.