SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  85
Fraud v Error
Fraud v Error


    Intentional
Fraud v Error
Intentional
Fraud v Error
Intentional




    Misinterpretation
Fraud v Error
Intentional
        Misinterpretation
Fraud v Error
Intentional
             Misinterpretation




   Incorrect Accounting
Fraud v Error
Intentional
             Misinterpretation
   Incorrect Accounting
Fraud v Error
       Intentional
                            Misinterpretation
               Incorrect Accounting



There may be requirements to report suspicions of fraud,
                    but not error
Management v Auditor
Management v Auditor




      Prepare T&F
Management v Auditor
Prepare T&F
Management v Auditor
Prepare T&F




      Prevent & Detect Fraud
Management v Auditor
Prepare T&F
   Prevent & Detect Fraud
Management v Auditor
Prepare T&F
   Prevent & Detect Fraud



          Internal Controls
Management v Auditor
Prepare T&F
   Prevent & Detect Fraud



          Internal Controls

     Good Corporate Governance
Management v Auditor
Management v Auditor




     Report on T&F
Management v Auditor
             Report on T&F
Management v Auditor
                      Report on T&F




Reasonable Assurance Fraud & ERROR
Management v Auditor
                  Report on T&F

 Reasonable Assurance Fraud & ERROR
Management v Auditor
                             Report on T&F

       Reasonable Assurance Fraud & ERROR

Primary F&E responsibility lies with management
Management v Auditor
                              Report on T&F

        Reasonable Assurance Fraud & ERROR

 Primary F&E responsibility lies with management


consider the risk of material misstatement
Management v Auditor
Management v Auditor

   Reduce fraud opportunities
Management v Auditor

    Reduce fraud opportunities

 Establish a culture where no fraud
Management v Auditor

    Reduce fraud opportunities

 Establish a culture where no fraud
 due to the likelihood of detection
Professional Scepticism
Professional Scepticism

Discuss fraud within specific characteristics of
      the audit & potential effect on FS
Professional Scepticism

Discuss fraud within specific characteristics of
      the audit & potential effect on FS
Professional Scepticism

Discuss fraud within specific characteristics of
      the audit & potential effect on FS

Talk to management about controls to detect or
               prevent fraud
Professional Scepticism

Discuss fraud within specific characteristics of
      the audit & potential effect on FS

Talk to management about controls to detect or
               prevent fraud

Obtain evidence that fraud has not occurred or
           detected and corrected
Fraud/Error is Suspected?
Fraud/Error is Suspected?
Fraud/Error is Suspected?   Effect on FS?
Fraud/Error is Suspected?   Effect on FS?
Fraud/Error is Suspected?   Effect on FS?



                                   Document in
                                    Audit files
Fraud/Error is Suspected?   Effect on FS?



                                   Document in
                                    Audit files
Fraud/Error is Suspected?          Effect on FS?




                      Additional          Document in
                       Testing?            Audit files
Fraud/Error is Suspected?                Effect on FS?



                        Extent of misstatement
                      Additional                 Document in
                       Testing?                   Audit files
Fraud/Error is Suspected?                Effect on FS?



                        Extent of misstatement
                      Additional                 Document in
                       Testing?                   Audit files
Fraud/Error is Suspected?                Effect on FS?



                        Extent of misstatement
  Effect on           Additional                 Document in
    Risk?              Testing?                   Audit files
Fraud/Error is Suspected?                Effect on FS?



                        Extent of misstatement
  Effect on           Additional                 Document in
    Risk?              Testing?                   Audit files
Fraud/Error is Suspected?                Effect on FS?



                        Extent of misstatement
  Effect on           Additional                 Document in
    Risk?              Testing?                   Audit files


Discuss with
Management
Fraud/Error is Suspected?                Effect on FS?



                        Extent of misstatement
   Effect on          Additional                 Document in
     Risk?             Testing?                   Audit files


Discuss with
Management
Tell them to get
      legal
advice if fraud is
   suspected
Fraud/Error is Suspected?                Effect on FS?



                        Extent of misstatement
   Effect on          Additional                 Document in
     Risk?             Testing?                   Audit files


Discuss with
Management
Tell them to get
      legal
advice if fraud is
   suspected
Fraud/Error is Suspected?                Effect on FS?



                        Extent of misstatement
   Effect on          Additional                 Document in
     Risk?             Testing?                   Audit files


Discuss with         If Management
Management
Tell them to get        Suspected?
      legal
advice if fraud is
   suspected
Fraud/Error is Suspected?                      Effect on FS?



                           Extent of misstatement
   Effect on             Additional                      Document in
     Risk?                Testing?                        Audit files


Discuss with           If Management
Management
Tell them to get          Suspected?
      legal          Get legal advice or rarely resign
advice if fraud is
   suspected
Fraud/Error is Suspected?                      Effect on FS?



                           Extent of misstatement
   Effect on             Additional                      Document in
     Risk?                Testing?                        Audit files


Discuss with           If Management
Management
Tell them to get          Suspected?
      legal          Get legal advice or rarely resign
advice if fraud is
   suspected
Fraud/Error is Suspected?                      Effect on FS?



                           Extent of misstatement
   Effect on             Additional                      Document in
     Risk?                Testing?                        Audit files

                                                          Consider
Discuss with           If Management                       Report
Management
Tell them to get          Suspected?                       Impact
      legal          Get legal advice or rarely resign
advice if fraud is
   suspected
Fraud/Error is Suspected?                      Effect on FS?



                           Extent of misstatement
   Effect on             Additional                      Document in
     Risk?                Testing?                        Audit files

                                                          Consider
Discuss with           If Management                       Report
Management
Tell them to get          Suspected?                       Impact
      legal          Get legal advice or rarely resign
advice if fraud is
   suspected
Fraud/Error is Suspected?                      Effect on FS?



                           Extent of misstatement
   Effect on             Additional                      Document in
     Risk?                Testing?                        Audit files

                                                          Consider
Discuss with           If Management                       Report
Management
Tell them to get          Suspected?                       Impact
      legal          Get legal advice or rarely resign
advice if fraud is
   suspected
                                                          Report to
                                                         Authorities?
Fraud/Error is Suspected?                      Effect on FS?



                           Extent of misstatement
   Effect on             Additional                      Document in
     Risk?                Testing?                        Audit files

                                                          Consider
Discuss with           If Management                       Report
Management
Tell them to get          Suspected?                       Impact
      legal          Get legal advice or rarely resign
advice if fraud is
   suspected
                                                          Report to
                                                         Authorities?
                                        Consider Confidentiality
The Auditor - Criminal Liability
The Auditor - Criminal Liability

Accepting appointment without being qualified
The Auditor - Criminal Liability

Accepting appointment without being qualified
          Being involved with fraud
The Auditor - Criminal Liability

Accepting appointment without being qualified
          Being involved with fraud
               Insider Dealing
The Auditor - Criminal Liability

Accepting appointment without being qualified
          Being involved with fraud
               Insider Dealing
             Money Laundering
The Auditor - Civil Liability
The Auditor - Civil Liability

 Negligent (careless) auditing
The Auditor - Civil Liability

       Negligent (careless) auditing
Sued by Client company under contract law
The Auditor - Civil Liability

       Negligent (careless) auditing
Sued by Client company under contract law
   Sued by banks etc under negligence
The Auditor - Duty of skill & Care
The Auditor - Duty of skill & Care

    Depends on the circumstance
The Auditor - Duty of skill & Care

         Depends on the circumstance
eg. Accepting the word of management after
            suspicion is aroused
The Auditor - Duty of skill & Care

           Depends on the circumstance
eg. Accepting the word of management after
              suspicion is aroused
    Follow ISAs and show this in working papers
The Auditor - Professional competence
The Auditor - Professional competence

Achieve, and maintain, professional knowledge
The Auditor - Professional competence

  Achieve, and maintain, professional knowledge
eg. Formal & Informal training + experience
The Auditor - Professional competence

  Achieve, and maintain, professional knowledge
eg. Formal & Informal training + experience

   Awareness of general business developments,
       such as dropbox and e-commerce
The Auditor - Due care
The Auditor - Due care

Acting diligently in accordance with technical and
              professional standards
The Auditor - Due care

 Acting diligently in accordance with technical and
               professional standards
means applying knowledge minimising the
               chance of mistakes
                    being made
The Auditor - Due care

 Acting diligently in accordance with technical and
               professional standards
means applying knowledge minimising the
               chance of mistakes
                    being made

   Enough time to complete work with due care
       Staff fully understand the objectives
The Auditor - Negligence - A Civil Wrong
The Auditor - Negligence - A Civil Wrong

              Duty of Care
The Auditor - Negligence - A Civil Wrong

             Duty of Care
             Duty is broken
The Auditor - Negligence - A Civil Wrong

              Duty of Care
             Duty is broken
             Damage results
The Auditor - Negligence - A Civil Wrong

                    Duty of Care
                   Duty is broken
                   Damage results

The auditor does not exist to aid investment decisions,
            unless verbal assurances given
Fraudulent Financial Reporting
Fraudulent Financial Reporting
 Intentional
Misstatement!
Fraudulent Financial Reporting
Fraudulent Financial Reporting

         Manipulation
Fraudulent Financial Reporting

         Manipulation
       Misrepresentation
Fraudulent Financial Reporting

         Manipulation
       Misrepresentation
        Misapplication
Fraudulent Financial Reporting

         Manipulation
       Misrepresentation
        Misapplication

      Earnings Management

Contenu connexe

En vedette

Rise! Triumph Over Courage!
Rise! Triumph Over Courage!Rise! Triumph Over Courage!
Rise! Triumph Over Courage!splendidshire
 
Kuruk set 1
Kuruk set 1Kuruk set 1
Kuruk set 1Qrish
 
VulnerabilidadDelAdolescente Calzada[1]
VulnerabilidadDelAdolescente Calzada[1]VulnerabilidadDelAdolescente Calzada[1]
VulnerabilidadDelAdolescente Calzada[1]media9calzada
 
Evolving Km Practices In Me Iqpc Km Conference Talk (1st Feb 2011)
Evolving Km Practices In Me   Iqpc Km Conference Talk (1st Feb 2011)Evolving Km Practices In Me   Iqpc Km Conference Talk (1st Feb 2011)
Evolving Km Practices In Me Iqpc Km Conference Talk (1st Feb 2011)Abdul Tharayil
 
Winter 2009 Teaser 1
Winter 2009 Teaser 1Winter 2009 Teaser 1
Winter 2009 Teaser 1Oleg Byakhov
 
Cambio en la prisión preventiva en el Ecuador
Cambio en la prisión preventiva en el EcuadorCambio en la prisión preventiva en el Ecuador
Cambio en la prisión preventiva en el EcuadorGina Godoy
 
Monitouch expressvol49
Monitouch expressvol49Monitouch expressvol49
Monitouch expressvol49monitouch
 
Wings power point1
Wings power point1Wings power point1
Wings power point1mah9473
 
UX勉強会(第十三章)
UX勉強会(第十三章) UX勉強会(第十三章)
UX勉強会(第十三章) 大騎 池本
 
Flyer fermentieren
Flyer fermentierenFlyer fermentieren
Flyer fermentierendesignista.
 
Monitouch expressvol61
Monitouch expressvol61Monitouch expressvol61
Monitouch expressvol61monitouch
 
Evolution2014 desert mouse talk
Evolution2014 desert mouse talkEvolution2014 desert mouse talk
Evolution2014 desert mouse talkMatthew MacManes
 

En vedette (15)

Kurulum
KurulumKurulum
Kurulum
 
Rise! Triumph Over Courage!
Rise! Triumph Over Courage!Rise! Triumph Over Courage!
Rise! Triumph Over Courage!
 
Kuruk set 1
Kuruk set 1Kuruk set 1
Kuruk set 1
 
VulnerabilidadDelAdolescente Calzada[1]
VulnerabilidadDelAdolescente Calzada[1]VulnerabilidadDelAdolescente Calzada[1]
VulnerabilidadDelAdolescente Calzada[1]
 
Evolving Km Practices In Me Iqpc Km Conference Talk (1st Feb 2011)
Evolving Km Practices In Me   Iqpc Km Conference Talk (1st Feb 2011)Evolving Km Practices In Me   Iqpc Km Conference Talk (1st Feb 2011)
Evolving Km Practices In Me Iqpc Km Conference Talk (1st Feb 2011)
 
Winter 2009 Teaser 1
Winter 2009 Teaser 1Winter 2009 Teaser 1
Winter 2009 Teaser 1
 
Cambio en la prisión preventiva en el Ecuador
Cambio en la prisión preventiva en el EcuadorCambio en la prisión preventiva en el Ecuador
Cambio en la prisión preventiva en el Ecuador
 
Monitouch expressvol49
Monitouch expressvol49Monitouch expressvol49
Monitouch expressvol49
 
Wings power point1
Wings power point1Wings power point1
Wings power point1
 
UX勉強会(第十三章)
UX勉強会(第十三章) UX勉強会(第十三章)
UX勉強会(第十三章)
 
Green guest
Green guestGreen guest
Green guest
 
Flyer fermentieren
Flyer fermentierenFlyer fermentieren
Flyer fermentieren
 
Monitouch expressvol61
Monitouch expressvol61Monitouch expressvol61
Monitouch expressvol61
 
SYLLABUS INFORMATICA 1
SYLLABUS INFORMATICA 1SYLLABUS INFORMATICA 1
SYLLABUS INFORMATICA 1
 
Evolution2014 desert mouse talk
Evolution2014 desert mouse talkEvolution2014 desert mouse talk
Evolution2014 desert mouse talk
 

Similaire à Fraud & error p7

Fraud Prevention Considerations for Small Businesses
Fraud Prevention Considerations for Small BusinessesFraud Prevention Considerations for Small Businesses
Fraud Prevention Considerations for Small Businessessmshawcfe
 
Fraud Awareness For Managers
Fraud Awareness For ManagersFraud Awareness For Managers
Fraud Awareness For Managersrickycfe
 
Fraud Prevention, Detection and Investigation in the Payday Advance Industry
Fraud Prevention, Detection and Investigation in the Payday Advance IndustryFraud Prevention, Detection and Investigation in the Payday Advance Industry
Fraud Prevention, Detection and Investigation in the Payday Advance IndustryDecosimoCPAs
 
Financial Reporting Fraud Flags
Financial Reporting Fraud FlagsFinancial Reporting Fraud Flags
Financial Reporting Fraud Flagsiauditman
 
The Auditors Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Stat...
The Auditors Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Stat...The Auditors Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Stat...
The Auditors Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Stat...Dr. Soheli Ghose Banerjee
 
Fraud In Our Midst, The Acfe 2010
Fraud In Our Midst, The Acfe 2010Fraud In Our Midst, The Acfe 2010
Fraud In Our Midst, The Acfe 2010annmarieboyd
 
Fraud In Our Midst, The Acfe 2010
Fraud In Our Midst, The Acfe 2010Fraud In Our Midst, The Acfe 2010
Fraud In Our Midst, The Acfe 2010annmarieboyd
 
Smart devine-act now before its too late-0313-v6
Smart devine-act now before its too late-0313-v6Smart devine-act now before its too late-0313-v6
Smart devine-act now before its too late-0313-v6Accounting_Whitepapers
 
Corruption Risks Update 2009
Corruption Risks Update 2009Corruption Risks Update 2009
Corruption Risks Update 2009Stephen_Horne
 
Risk management
Risk managementRisk management
Risk managementcclendenen
 
Griffiith - A Wolf in Sheep's Clothing: Applicant Deception and the Risk to t...
Griffiith - A Wolf in Sheep's Clothing: Applicant Deception and the Risk to t...Griffiith - A Wolf in Sheep's Clothing: Applicant Deception and the Risk to t...
Griffiith - A Wolf in Sheep's Clothing: Applicant Deception and the Risk to t...HR Florida State Council, Inc.
 
The most overlooked human behaviour in investment decisions
The most overlooked human behaviour in investment decisionsThe most overlooked human behaviour in investment decisions
The most overlooked human behaviour in investment decisionsinSTRATEGIA
 

Similaire à Fraud & error p7 (18)

Fraud Prevention Considerations for Small Businesses
Fraud Prevention Considerations for Small BusinessesFraud Prevention Considerations for Small Businesses
Fraud Prevention Considerations for Small Businesses
 
Fraud Awareness For Managers
Fraud Awareness For ManagersFraud Awareness For Managers
Fraud Awareness For Managers
 
Who Commits Fraud
Who Commits Fraud   Who Commits Fraud
Who Commits Fraud
 
Fraud Prevention, Detection and Investigation in the Payday Advance Industry
Fraud Prevention, Detection and Investigation in the Payday Advance IndustryFraud Prevention, Detection and Investigation in the Payday Advance Industry
Fraud Prevention, Detection and Investigation in the Payday Advance Industry
 
Fraud & Error.doc
Fraud & Error.docFraud & Error.doc
Fraud & Error.doc
 
Fraud And Internal Controls Linked In April 2011
Fraud And Internal Controls   Linked In April 2011Fraud And Internal Controls   Linked In April 2011
Fraud And Internal Controls Linked In April 2011
 
Financial Reporting Fraud Flags
Financial Reporting Fraud FlagsFinancial Reporting Fraud Flags
Financial Reporting Fraud Flags
 
The Auditors Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Stat...
The Auditors Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Stat...The Auditors Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Stat...
The Auditors Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Stat...
 
Fraud In Our Midst, The Acfe 2010
Fraud In Our Midst, The Acfe 2010Fraud In Our Midst, The Acfe 2010
Fraud In Our Midst, The Acfe 2010
 
Fraud In Our Midst, The Acfe 2010
Fraud In Our Midst, The Acfe 2010Fraud In Our Midst, The Acfe 2010
Fraud In Our Midst, The Acfe 2010
 
Controlling Fraud in Food & Beverage
Controlling Fraud in Food & BeverageControlling Fraud in Food & Beverage
Controlling Fraud in Food & Beverage
 
Kenya AMC Presentation 2
Kenya AMC Presentation 2Kenya AMC Presentation 2
Kenya AMC Presentation 2
 
Smart devine-act now before its too late-0313-v6
Smart devine-act now before its too late-0313-v6Smart devine-act now before its too late-0313-v6
Smart devine-act now before its too late-0313-v6
 
Corruption Risks Update 2009
Corruption Risks Update 2009Corruption Risks Update 2009
Corruption Risks Update 2009
 
Compliance at an inflection point
Compliance at an inflection pointCompliance at an inflection point
Compliance at an inflection point
 
Risk management
Risk managementRisk management
Risk management
 
Griffiith - A Wolf in Sheep's Clothing: Applicant Deception and the Risk to t...
Griffiith - A Wolf in Sheep's Clothing: Applicant Deception and the Risk to t...Griffiith - A Wolf in Sheep's Clothing: Applicant Deception and the Risk to t...
Griffiith - A Wolf in Sheep's Clothing: Applicant Deception and the Risk to t...
 
The most overlooked human behaviour in investment decisions
The most overlooked human behaviour in investment decisionsThe most overlooked human behaviour in investment decisions
The most overlooked human behaviour in investment decisions
 

Plus de josianne1977

P7 reports to management
P7 reports to managementP7 reports to management
P7 reports to managementjosianne1977
 
Practice management p7
Practice management p7Practice management p7
Practice management p7josianne1977
 
Professional liability p7
Professional liability p7Professional liability p7
Professional liability p7josianne1977
 
Tendering & advertising p7
Tendering & advertising p7Tendering & advertising p7
Tendering & advertising p7josianne1977
 
Materiality & business risks p7
Materiality & business risks p7Materiality & business risks p7
Materiality & business risks p7josianne1977
 
Client acceptance p7
Client acceptance p7Client acceptance p7
Client acceptance p7josianne1977
 
Audit p7 completion
Audit p7 completionAudit p7 completion
Audit p7 completionjosianne1977
 
Audit evidence questions
Audit evidence questionsAudit evidence questions
Audit evidence questionsjosianne1977
 
Appointments & quality p7 questions
Appointments & quality p7 questionsAppointments & quality p7 questions
Appointments & quality p7 questionsjosianne1977
 
Audit of related services p7
Audit of related services p7Audit of related services p7
Audit of related services p7josianne1977
 
Accepting a new appointment p7
Accepting a new appointment p7Accepting a new appointment p7
Accepting a new appointment p7josianne1977
 

Plus de josianne1977 (17)

P7 evidence
P7 evidenceP7 evidence
P7 evidence
 
P7 ethics
P7 ethicsP7 ethics
P7 ethics
 
P7 reports to management
P7 reports to managementP7 reports to management
P7 reports to management
 
Practice management p7
Practice management p7Practice management p7
Practice management p7
 
Professional liability p7
Professional liability p7Professional liability p7
Professional liability p7
 
Tendering & advertising p7
Tendering & advertising p7Tendering & advertising p7
Tendering & advertising p7
 
P7 class 1
P7 class 1P7 class 1
P7 class 1
 
Materiality & business risks p7
Materiality & business risks p7Materiality & business risks p7
Materiality & business risks p7
 
Getting work p7
Getting work p7Getting work p7
Getting work p7
 
Client acceptance p7
Client acceptance p7Client acceptance p7
Client acceptance p7
 
Audit reports
Audit reportsAudit reports
Audit reports
 
Audit planning
Audit planningAudit planning
Audit planning
 
Audit p7 completion
Audit p7 completionAudit p7 completion
Audit p7 completion
 
Audit evidence questions
Audit evidence questionsAudit evidence questions
Audit evidence questions
 
Appointments & quality p7 questions
Appointments & quality p7 questionsAppointments & quality p7 questions
Appointments & quality p7 questions
 
Audit of related services p7
Audit of related services p7Audit of related services p7
Audit of related services p7
 
Accepting a new appointment p7
Accepting a new appointment p7Accepting a new appointment p7
Accepting a new appointment p7
 

Fraud & error p7

Notes de l'éditeur

  1. \n
  2. \n
  3. \n
  4. \n
  5. \n
  6. \n
  7. \n
  8. \n
  9. \n
  10. \n
  11. \n
  12. \n
  13. \n
  14. \n
  15. \n
  16. \n
  17. \n
  18. \n
  19. \n
  20. \n
  21. \n
  22. \n
  23. \n
  24. \n
  25. \n
  26. \n
  27. \n
  28. \n
  29. \n
  30. \n
  31. \n
  32. \n
  33. \n
  34. \n
  35. \n
  36. \n
  37. \n
  38. \n
  39. \n
  40. \n
  41. \n
  42. \n
  43. \n
  44. \n
  45. \n
  46. \n
  47. \n
  48. \n
  49. \n
  50. \n
  51. \n
  52. \n
  53. \n
  54. \n
  55. \n
  56. \n
  57. \n
  58. \n
  59. \n
  60. \n
  61. \n
  62. \n
  63. \n
  64. \n
  65. \n
  66. \n
  67. \n
  68. \n
  69. \n
  70. \n
  71. \n
  72. \n