6. IBM Institute for Business Value
Retail Industry Perspective
Capitalising on the Smarter Consumer
Understanding and Responding to the Consumers Wants and Needs
7. Who is this „Smarter Consumer‟?
Instrumented Interconnected Intelligent
They have instantaneous They use multiple They have clearly defined
access to information about technologies to interact with expectations of what they
retailers, products and other other consumers and with want from their retailer now
consumers‟ experiences retailers and in the future
through technology
7
8. Executive summary & research methodology
Today‟s consumers are fundamentally changing industries, brands,
interactions, and relationships
“Sales of
4,500,000
iPads in 3Q 2010”*
8 Source: :Fortune October 5, 2010 http://tech.fortune.cnn.com/2010/10/05/how-many-ipads-has-apple-really-sold/
9. Executive summary & research methodology
This year we found the smarter consumer wants to be served, not sold to,
trusts their social network above retailers and is increasingly digital
Technology is a given Shopping process Serve me,
affected by more than don’t sell to me
technology
36 %
Increase in willingness
to use technology in
consumers are optimistic
about income, but are not
Listen to me
New consumer focus
going back to pre-
less than a year group is everybody
recessionary spending
behaviour
58 %
trust family & friends
first, while only
Know me
Personalisation remains
top priority
%
21 Customer reviews
%
18 trust retailers and
manufacturers
Empower me
Consumers leverage
mobility to control the
experience
9 Source: IBM Institute for Business Value Analysis, Retail 2010
10. Agenda
1. Research methodology
2. The future is digital: Smarter Consumers use of technology
3. What you see is not what you get: the Smarter Consumer
changes
Profile
Shopping process
4. Smarter Consumer demand smarter retailers: how smarter
retailers will respond
11. Executive summary & research methodology
IBM’s Institute for Business Value (IBV) studied this new consumer taking
into account 13 countries in both the mature and emerging markets…
Total Surveyed Population = 30,624
Mature Emerging
Australia (2274) Italy (2200) France (2200) Brazil (2200) Argentina (2200)
Canada (2221) Germany (2200) Chile (2200) Colombia (2200)
United States (4121) UK (2200) Mexico (2200)
China (2200)
11
12. Executive summary & research methodology
…and to understand what trends transcend income,
generations and product categories
Income brackets Ages surveyed Product categories
Upper Bracket n= 3,585 Generation (15-19) n=1,544 Adult Apparel n=4,350
Generation (20-29) n= 6,505 Kids Apparel n= 4,287
Upper Middle n= 10,080 Luxury Brands n= 1,344
Generation (30-39) n= 7,865
Shoe/Accessories n= 3,395
Lower Middle n= 7,878 Generation (40-49) n= 6,264 Grocery n= 4.961
Generation (50-59) n= 5,011 Personal Care n= 3,933
Lower Bracket n= 4,736
Generation (60+) n= 3,446 Electronics n= 2,828
Entertainment n= 2,805
Home Merchandise n= 2.721
12 Source: Institute for Business Value Retail 2011 Global = 30624
13. Agenda
1. Research methodology
2. The future is digital: Smarter Consumers use of technology
3. What you see is not what you get: the Smarter Consumer
changes
Profile
Shopping process
4. Smarter Consumer demand smarter retailers: how smarter
retailers will respond
14. Smarter Consumer Profile > Technology
In 2010, ‘Instrumented consumers‟, those willing to use two or more
technologies for purchasing products, is 86%
Number of Australian instrumented consumers
100%
86%
80% INSTRUMENTED =
80%
2 or more technologies
1 technology
60% 36% 49%
No technology
40%
20%
20% 14% 44% 37%
0%
2009: No 2010: No 2009: One or 2010: One or
technology technology more more
technologies technologies
14
15. Smarter Consumer Profile > Technology
Instrumentation has increased year to year and mobility has
increased 92% globally
13% 17%
25% 24%
Mobile technologies has increased 92% and is Willingness to use TVs to make purchases is
still more widely accepted in the growth markets growing as a preferred technology like mobile.
68% 36%
75% 39%
Websites have increased 9 % Kiosks are popular across all counrties
Apr 2010 Oct 2010
15
16. Smarter Consumer Profile > Technology
The number of instrumented consumers has increased the most in 40+ age
group
Percentage of ‘instrumented consumers’ by age group
Generation 60+ 20% 32%
Generation 50 - 59 29% 45%
35% 49%
Generation 40 - 49
Age group
Generation 30 - 39 44% 53%
Generation 20 - 29 48% 55%
Generation 15 - 19 38% 52%
Percent of instrumented consumers
Instrumentation is not correlated to
April 2009 Instrument % higher income brackets, except for
Australia, Canada, China and
Colombia
16 Source: Institute for Business Value Retail 2011 Australia = 2274
17. Smarter Consumer Profile > Technology
Emerging market consumers continue to be the most instrumented
Percentage of ‘instrumented consumers’ by country
Brazil
68%
Chile 62%
China 62%
Mexico 60%
Colombia 59%
Argentina 53%
United Kingdom 48%
Australia 45% Emerging
United States 43%
Italy 40% Mature
Canada 38%
Germany 35%
France 30%
17
18. Smarter Consumer Profile > Summary
The smarter consumer is willing to use two or more technologies in the
shopping process…what are the implications for your business?
Findings Implications
Consumer are instrumented: Allow the Are you leveraging technology to reinforce
consumers to use preferred technology your brand strategy?
Do you know which technologies your
customers prefer to use?
What is your approach to evaluating new
technologies?
What is your organisation‟s ability to rapidly
introduce the new capabilities relevant for
your customer?
18
18
19. Agenda
1. Research methodology
2. The future is digital: Smarter Consumers use of technology
3. What you see is not what you get: the Smarter Consumer
changes
Profile
Shopping process
4. Smarter Consumer demand smarter retailers: how smarter
retailers will respond
20. Agenda
1. Research methodology
2. The future is digital: Smarter Consumers use of technology
3. What you see is not what you get: the Smarter Consumer
changes
Profile
Shopping process
4. Smarter Consumer demand smarter retailers: how smarter
retailers will respond
21. Smarter Consumer Profile > Attitudes
Consumers attitudes are optimistic but they are not going back to pre-
recession spending levels
Attitude Toward Income Attitude Toward Shopping
• 70% of consumers are optimistic about
the future of their income Spending only on needs 20%
• 46% believe their income will stay
Searching out sale items 19%
the same
• 24% believe their income will Waiting longer to
increase by 20% in the next 5 years 16%
purchase
• Optimism was not limited to the higher
Buying more online 12%
income brackets
Purchasing items to
reward yourself 11%
Trading up/down in some
10%
categories
Spending more on 8%
travel/entertainment
Eating out more 5%
21
22. Smarter Consumer Profile > Influencers
Only 18% of consumers are influenced by retailers and manufacturers
Who do you trust to provide honest feedback on
product information and product reviews?
Trust Ranking
Product experts
16% 18%
21% Retail/Manufacturer
Customer Reviews
45%
Family/Friends
22
23. Smarter Consumer Profile > Influencers
While retailers and manufacturers have influence, consumers‟ opinions
are formed predominately by their social network
Grocery 48% 19% 15% 7% 11%
Apparel 47% 22% 13% 7% 11%
Personal Care Products 46% 19% 16% 6% 12%
Home Décor, appliances and
42% 24% 18% 5% 10%
products
Consumer Electronics 38% 25% 19% 7% 11%
Luxury Brands 33% 27% 17% 9% 15%
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Family / Friends Customer Reviews Product Experts Manufacturer Retailer
23 Source: Institute for Business Value Retail 2011 Global = 30624
24. Smarter Consumer Profile > Household Demographics
Purchasing decisions extend beyond the four walls of a
traditional household
• Globally, over 31% are buying in the following
categories for their parents:
– Adult Apparel (23%)
– Grocery (15%)
– Personal Care (13%)
– Consumer Electronics (13%)
– Entertainment (DVD, Games) (12%)
– Home Décor (10%)
– Other Categories (14%)
• 25% of the population are now living in multi-
generational households, which is a change that has
occurred within the last 2 years
• Services desired for 60+ year old individuals:
17% - groceries/prepared meals delivered
18 16% - home cleaning
13% - weekly calls/errands
12% - technical services
24
24 Source: Institute for Business Value Retail 2011 Global (US, UK, Australia, China, Mexico Germany only) = Cater Buying = 8680, household changes=2328, services - 949
25. Smarter Consumer Profile > Summary
Today‟s smarter consumer buys for a virtual household and trusts family,
friends and strangers first…is your organisation able to listen and respond?
Findings Implications
Family and friends rule: Consumers trust Do you have a way to monitor what is being
family/friends and strangers before the retailer said about you?
or manufacturer
Do you have a single view of your customers
The household is “virtual”: Consumers are across channels?
buying for more than their traditional
Can you tell how your customers are
household
influenced and do you know if your
advertising is effective?
Does your organisation have a view of what
constitutes “customer data” and what can be
collected and analysed to make better/timely
decisions?
25
26. Agenda
1. Research methodology
2. The future is digital: Smarter Consumers use of technology
3. What you see is not what you get: the Smarter Consumer
changes
Profile
Shopping process
4. Smarter Consumer demand smarter retailers: how smarter
retailers will respond
27. Shopping experience > Moment
The shopping process has fundamentally changed as consumers use
technology anytime, anywhere
Aware Research Purchase Take Advocate
Possession
Consumers Moment
27
28. Shopping experience > Awareness and Research
From awareness to research, consumers are influenced by
numerous consumer media that they control
Greatest Influences During
Product Awareness and Research
Product Awareness Product Research
TV/Radio/Billboard Friends / Family
Top 5 Influences
Retailer Store TV/Radio/Billboard
Friends / Family Retailer Store
Mobile Apps Search Engine
Emails Retailer Website
Online Streaming Mobile Apps
Social Media Emails
Search Engine Social Media
Magazines Online Streaming
Retailer-Controlled
Retailer Website Magazines
Consumer-Controlled
Shopping Portal Shopping Portal
28 Source: Institute for Business Value Retail 2011 Global = 30624
29. Shopping experience > Purchase
When they are ready to purchase, consumers are influenced
by a variety factors
• The item was in a smaller package size or unique packaging
• It was an item that you currently own and it is very comfortable or easy to use and you wanted
another one
Product • The item was unique and different from competitors‟ products
• You saw a new item and thought it might not be available later
• You wanted to try something different than what you regularly purchase (add some variety in
your life)
• It was a new item or flavor that you wanted to try
Awareness • You saw an item and it gave you an idea (e.g. dinner or how to match it with something you
own)
• Represented your lifestyle (either a clothing style or foods - healthy living; country cooking,
ethnic)
Style / Lifestyle • It was an item that you needed based on an upcoming event or occasion
• It was an item influenced by a celebrity, either designed, worn or advertised as the latest trend
Price / • It was an item that you regularly buy that was on discount
Promotion • Provides a gift with purchase (free installation, batteries, complimentary item)
• You purchased an item because your family/grandchildren/children/friends would like it
• The item made you feel better or happier
Fun • You purchased the item for a special occasion
• Your child/grandchildren/family member influenced you to buy it
Customer • A sales associate assisted or provided you great service in coordinating (e.g. dinner idea,
outfits that would go with the item you chose, showed you how to solve you home problem)
Service
Convenience • The item was located next to one that you considered purchasing
29 Source: Institute for Business Value Retail 2011 Global = 30624
30. Shopping experience > Purchase
Consumers buy when regularly-purchased items are discounted,
a new product is introduced or there is a special event
Category Area Impact Score
Price / Promotion An item that I regular purchase is on discount 119.69
An item needed based on an upcoming
Style / Lifestyle 110.94
event/occasion
Awareness It was a new item/flavor that you wanted to try 109.27
Item currently owned was easy to use/comfortable
Product and wanted another 106.18
Price /
Provide a gift with purchase 105.24
Promotion
Product Try a new product (add variety to life) 104.02
Product Item is unique and different than competitors 103.82
Consumers are least influenced by
celebrities or a sales associate
30 Source: Institute for Business Value Retail 2011 Global = 30624
31. Shopping experience > Abandon
Consumers abandon purchases primarily due to financial reservations
or not enough product information
Top Reasons Globally Why Consumers Abandon Items: Store
• Did not want to spend the money
• Just did not want it
Top Reasons Globally Why Consumers Abandon Items: Online
• Did not want to spend the money
• There was not enough product information and
decided to wait
31 Source: Institute for Business Value Retail 2011 Global = 30624
32. Shopping experience > Take possession
Allowing the customer to specify how to take possession of the
product is important
Which of the following methods would you prefer to obtain the item?
60%
Purchase at store and leave store with item
13%
Purchase online and deliver on the date you specify
Purchase at store and deliver to home the same day 12%
Purchase online/in store and delivery next day 10%
Purchase online and pick up in the store 6%
Emerging markets differ in that delivery
to home the same day is ranked second
32 Source: Institute for Business Value Retail 2011 Global = 30624
33. Shopping experience > Product pick-up
When its time to check out and obtain products, consumers were
specific on how they wanted to use mobile technologies
Mobile Device Check Out Preference
Scan while shopping and checkout at self service 34%
24%
Scan while shopping and checkout with mobile
23%
Scan sample and retrieve at pick up area
19%
Scan sample and deliver to home
33 Source: Institute for Business Value Retail 2011 Global = 30624
34. Shopping experience > Summary
Consumers want an integrated retail experience across multiple
channels…can you deliver?
Findings Implications
The channels are integrated: The customer Can I enable my customer to start a
sees you as one retailer not multiple transaction on one technology and continue
channels. all through the shopping process?
Profit from the information explosion: Can I understand my customers‟ behaviour
Customers are leaving a trail behind as they through the vast amount of data?
interact with you in multiple channels.
Am I segmenting my customers based on
Behavioural analytics: It‟s more than just behaviour?
recency, frequency, and monetary value.
Consumers are behaving differently than they Can I optimise my marketing and media
have in the past. spend, my promotions and my assortment?
Am I delivering relevant interactions to the
customer at the appropriate time in the
shopping process?
34
35. Agenda
1. Research methodology
2. The future is digital: Smarter Consumers use of technology
3. What you see is not what you get: the Smarter Consumer
changes
Profile
Shopping process
4. Smarter Consumer demand smarter retailers: how smarter
retailers will respond
36. Responding > Serve me
A personalised interaction remains the top demand
“Serve me”
Serve me Convenience: (Most Important loyalty drivers)
• Providing the right products and appropriate variety of
brands
• Allows you to determine if the item is in stock prior to
going to the store
Service: (Most important loyalty drivers)
• Make it feel like a pleasure to help me
• Allow me to return products without hassle or questions
asked
• Have knowledgeable employees about
products/services
• Easy way to order items not in stock
36
37. Responding > Listen to me
Executives have it backwards when it comes to consumers reasons for
interacting
Listen to me
Which social networking sites do you have an
account? (select all that apply)
• 45% of consumers have media sharing sites
• 33% of consumers belong to a social network
How often do you frequent social media sites?
• 5% frequent social media daily / weekly to post
comments
• 75% of respondents casually participate monthly by
responding to posts or writing reviews
• 37% of consumers are influenced by external reviews
More than half of “connected” consumers
state social media interactions influence
spend
37
38. Responding > Know me
A personalised interaction remains the top demand
Personalise Promotions (#1 purchase influencer)
Know me • Most likely to increase my spend
• Top consideration when determining where to shop
• The area retailers need to improve most
Personalise Shopping (Most important factors)
• Provide preferred receipt type
• Recognize me in the store or online
• Remember preferred payment method
Personalise Assortments (Most important loyalty
drivers)
• Manufactured or grown in my country
• High quality/low price private label products
• Environmentally friendly or sustainable products
• New and unique products
38
39. Responding > Empower me
Retailers have a vested interested in enabling mobile commerce
“Empower me”
I control the Promotions in the Service In The Store
Store
identification
32% Help me find the
42% Proactively closest customer
communicate service desk/associate
promotions to me based
on what I scan 31% Allow me to order
out-of-stock items
41% Allow me to check
prices from other 29% use mobile to
physical and virtual identify they need help
locations
27% Provide the most
efficient route through
store
27% Allow me to take
a picture/text to get
product information
39
40. Conclusion
Responding as a smarter retailer involves listening to the customer,
making changes to the organisation and improving the shopping experience
Empowering the
1
Listening and Learning 1
Enabling and Executing 1 Consumer
Single View of
Analytics to listen to Consumer self
Consumer across
consumers select interaction
channels
Actionable analytics Consumers choice of
Learn from consumer the interaction
controlled content around merchandising
and marketing channel
Key factors of influence Make the interaction Consumers providing
and motivation personalised across feedback
channels
Change sales to
service associates
40
55. Retail Store Reality
Bottleneck syndrome
Point solutions deployed
individually
Expensive to run and maintain
IHL Group reports that most
retail stores have become mini
data centres.
78% budget on support and maintenance
56. Smarter Retail IT
1. Virtualisation
2. Cloud – Data Centre
3. Unified Platform
4. Managed IT Support
58. Tangible Outcomes
Reduction in Capex Reduction in Opex Reduction in Risk
Before After Before After Before After
Infrastructure Cost per App Sys Admin per App Business Downtime
75. Additional challenges
Stretch the time it
takes to launch new
functionality
Makes it more
difficult to make
strategic decisions..
At a time when it is
critical for retailers
to respond, most
simply cannot
77. Responsiveness
“Since outsourcing our infrastructure to Maclean we no longer have to worry
about the day to day demands IT made on our time, this has allowed us to
improve our service to the franchises.”
Warrick Kemeys, Ops Manager