Laporan Hasil Penelitian Putusan Hakim Tentang Gugatan Sengketa Tata Usaha Negara Atas Ketetapan Surat Ketetapan Pajak Kurang Bayar Penghasilan dan Penghasilan Badan (Sengketa Pajak)

1. 9,
@t]!!tr:tEtz
"da
Ptr'HASILd BdN (SINCXITA PAJAf,l
16

2. Dun hlFri hi e dier4hD n *r
obnk ujE &Lh P@riM, Fitu
^
Ndd Pdh! Pm$n obj* FEliio
B DiDu d nn!*!dh MrjlL,IM
f&ih$EfuP@!si6
5 $n1 tuluei PlnL haq Bly!
tojir Pqtujtrn P6d 5 A!' (! e Prjd Pdsbie ee! m No r
r suuoi Mje'r Fu,adid &i
r xtrDa id@. sE (4*id A4*!)

3. !E !!!ta-E!EBeJ.GM4q!.!1,&b
P@s, rkt nosjnk! Bsh tod

4. AF'(4]fuPqdP{gulh,BDUUN
F!(d6ghnedBlP@ueiry]i/r
dd reFrd y4 bia dijldih!
'bsi
obr*
I^p!'a6enrkn&r:@
FmiFk*u$j?LiaNt'b}*
ehi h@ei. !d3r.b BjsI
!{ Eqsdiq hj* P6r 3 r, ! d,
cdnh Icry$r n{!!&i vr, *hFt obyd Plilt (u4 Bryr P!*
tu ldaihn Fd r ayr. drn Prnk k@q Bry6 P+L P4biLi Bde u!
qri, bei u]e pdtsh, his,
&!ro er&sli rubisdr ibiobrrejak
.-s.iih.i ." " Fq ebh

5. !p!4hsiL!&li!$fuibul9gbG,hd
!at!i, rijqh htE4 slu
FhL. , j6' *ie er@' ,0s dllM
e1rryo$iabscfuEjbdr
sr x6!sr dFr Pljd D cklne
rd,6ryn{&i}qtrP63}6jLaEa&i
rdsFt hdd{hi qitr !u4i dsr tsj
mnuiFhkrc5i6riditurmnhid& lvrjituqtornq&olm
kFba.T6Fct!fub@d.@tsd
h3i4h,6du r0s @Djd dF(sji
&DsD upin $Dg d * tuj poce m F$i r lyr 4 j@ hnr
, n rm dd Eldi F@i @]*

6. kqilrfueb!$Fl@sinq@dknsnufulda
r+& MEj.rn Htb djd
1 bh P!ruhm, P4dmr m4alfih
Lnjd sxPRB,
'iern{*m{
hns,4
I suEl kdllPi Plnr 6aig er{ Pr* h8h.!ih Elr5 qd t1):
b $d klnFo P.nk hE4 hFr hnr tugidh &d4
c ftvrjibk! rEus, nq{[, sff6 P6 hEr ,i a$ 4 ei sprB Ph

7. dkp PlD8sd tu hnr
m0sfusd*leie'nAgn2m
l@Fbi rontsiEi to@d PrnL
Peis!&nd r!$r t AF, i4) dn Ptnk EqidD &du @ No r r!tu
Fh.h ideidih o4Frj*D,n!
iisbd Ftrg ,in6!i ddm bd!i3 @rrh ahn {ajit Prjlr lnu
da@ p4ejika ury &FL dlj!tui b e4db, tullr k@

8. !t*sTqq(hm!*ih$slk+ufu@obFteig}€.thofug
d@nF6fomr0ge*!e
M &roi &@ F6b0 Fa!j*a, Fito
rib c{! prynh tud D ryn 0j &s6 FnnLqryr dn Nd B !,
d,e dbr sp(B PI Be tu
rid be@ p{@er dtuktr sj* etu ,b; uiin, rslw p44ei
UfuIe'p(BU!$eBiBUT

9. dPi y6s nujldi ntnrG bhD &trh
tdstutrkplNliMo6 (dr@(x
1) P6 <*e, x%.e P4hrnru xeu P,nr {Pfr Bi&n)i
&4uldNrNl,'ePh E 16&t4)
rd beB r{s$, mqlns, iaiFdrh,
&tuh turnsr ub4 ajar u6ng MEer rh nd tuF yq didL
esi Fd r syf o), trr eD 1])jo Plsr r0 !y,0) m No 6 ft a*
r. ftrm, + ib .flcss, Gd,sr vijr6
tuisjlru hd4 k! p-sdihi iljlrr du F4ijne bhh! deh wljib
P+rdd!frsr6 ktr !4ueuDd!Gm@ nnnp&r

10. r tsbL Ei3r.b )6anF$ak tuwus drai tmE 66ijibn rqs$i
tuftbprla udin ebls o6Fr kD Fnt w diunsbn dfr kpds
rr susPPhrarar (1):
c4i6n Eo@sr, r&F6dr Flit e& &3iu ebdllFl
eq( LebLje rqssr 0 *i*m
06rr Fi* !b, leLin ehF Pr hq Bryr Puc&ih! pdr ,6 44 (4)
&hsi dFl Fj* &6nnb B&
F$r , lsetu L46 (+!i$i Dr6 Ptj* xo mEqtrrrm tu 4
turinFh w.ltuie D!j!D pqd (+& rs Ej;, di bgroeD Di!6
hnkjo tolr44 o)b*dFjebDu
E4tu kn rGifii r!rcunsn Eer (frj

11. r,hqFtotslo4d$}q]FBaisl
htr k6 Bp r@nt d &Lh hd&p}6 hibr e+ui &bei drr @j{
P66 k! E{mtd kn4Po.hoi* tu$ wqs tojrk
56sg,mld4Ei4ift+hsjoby
6 p6h bliu nn&hn r6i4 i@Enn rlqrsr y4 Eoedprs uplii
!tr@od[biqjidib!fud,tP,miro
hr!I+& Pdsq h4ljik
ylitu turen hr o je rMi
sn ru!€bfti pin!ry o &ris
, Fib je dud! oi r&r tutury.

12. yss d&r E4ryd Fdlh dNi
e tu nb di .6, ld$hi Fis+Fi6t' d6e pei6 Flr, drLi
hc@ rb 6*st ftieph 4rh !d4, oird Fjd Pnr b4a
fiefufu@$luolDenFi
b Esfro r.qhlq dilie4 Pssus,t! c{e oi F3 dpd*n, *
dlh brem uu no$N, Ddnsip t4j!h s'r loulsiln en d hs, d
Fghqunlel@hfiF+iuqkildi
+hiqr n6d+rd dift $Esi
ob]lrEilr FLlitrih hrcD Ed s.
dhtu hd n sFt (1) Esdi FijeLBfr)
Ffubbi tb! !! No l Th
',86
hlag Pedfu mi
I &qr dq*i{ Ei r rtrrbi r!4u@1 Dlmpb udin *&si drr
@id leeidbm@ 4 ear i![n e, dd b! kbij*e kEdr

13. j,d6FiJMuh*$ol{ut+uNimeFkhekld,iohi@u,d
]r!k[Fnekhn$!la!ElEFiNmobrrsq}@nfiEGbFtr
a4r.ubtP.DF.hiklhh&trk
14d*hs!gqdiPogusidjhM]l4
r h.Fbhi kbjei Fnt p liEih iB qrid
a $d krdF Pai'r tu@! Bryr tufi toqtdibq FBrx 4" {1r:
i $a, krdts! hi'( tuEng Bryu tun* tugtdh &enr &n

14. sd k6Fn pljd tuq Bry{rad Poddiq Fd 6 qn (4):
ii snj!, su'lui bputou ruN
otF*@btdpdirylfukM&!efurhfob4ntdih
,e8hM r@en mD&F 6br Dr*!n $bs R! [?M,, G6tu

15. A c! Fi3 hhi !$i rienba &h htu
6Fkn!N&+dohd!&
-LdbudthhFLD!fuFbgo

16. dihlfu debhtui Pcd i@(i)
Nl@6trin'Nfo$&bnpsk
B. tuqeli absrur sqh rl]8k
P€4c@l&$n**F[FFsiMF
na}*hfu!&4udikdulknrU
eld &j!hD G P sde! Pailr kr Pqdih hir r@Fui LluEw{

17. fu4|l!t!edghnlokrlofohgdl$l
DhrEfulgq]PqdhardaUsldN4qaawladc6r@g'raa@
hst rer eiottu hha rENa nLrtrypgdtkrpja
sqtdl ptj4k dd *tckkw)at tut dQkn hdoB?7Nad tutiit
P4gdtht P4e ad hd0 Pruab
P4qa d Ptj,r r.hPayt to{4 t@ r

18. de unm &i rlr c{! ftaljaktr
lesfu|clddieiElkin&lgnmNo16TdDI@
,qydopla4}&elt44hiln|M@Nid
dillfu dlh Pl@sr $hru$F neBl
u d@ rrd c@ P+jEh ELsimu
tojb P!j* hpd h.Eqtbr btudq r y btu Dndb r4t4d
. ed tukl@r Pojor Leil Bqi;
t1)P.@dr Pab nqqawr top dot v*4

19. t1)Pa@dt Pdj* hb,i rd, aE
Ggtdnd4k|pfuNrtedu6@
Pl@dq]PqdrqqnqP4dhlirgl
dPr@kr * yas k841$4r rq! rQrsjer prri@@1izhhr dd
&lu.r&pidiaBob+
nqlqdd rqds Biir ]d!
n jd k!i44isi d{ Pdei PlEk s
r{rd Pii*. aFbi hDFoshr! etua di kd ri4*q Padihi ruN rb!
diEk$ihpdaPaed kirl
oPdqnno{eEhdd
d €dhniF D€nrn6uso rujeLn brh rchas tq,oldrFr Ftun ii nFjri

20. @!e ie rc4bji 06rl &qE! Frb uprift &4e ihlt ts& ihu rhDt
Mljelis bb jqs n@jukPdi url@r]!!lll.ur
Frqa FDrdni d@ tsma t 6ije w eruq $@q dE Fnel r!,
tuinensn nlnk uFyr lmt erujtu
L4dieifudi.!s6GleEenWea
:.'-."'.."

21. l&6€BFk!de6&t
EhnfudePubetrFfu!hj!oMbd:
Ftui pnrrtu mcrld Fj* rq
d uF'iD hlhn eq n@rmh baeliei ehbN tui jre
iendikd eF DllcLh turin

22. rt
r. M4q!6h4!FM@!dlllrortuF*r6!ryi
brki FqdrBiu sdeb Fje k
*Er Mu ldbP,1e @tup@dltE@ lryr.lE
EddFjr!d!66tui4tr.
,, xdi Yddn Ffu ofuhk fu fu Nd'Lqd l,ff.# &q
tlt9llpitujrMje]fututur&r dfu E!&