The document summarizes a live web optimization clinic session where the presenters optimized various company homepages through experiments and analysis. They shared principles for optimizing homepages, including treating them as directory pages rather than landing pages to move prospects up the inverted funnel. The treatment homepage tested accounted for multiple lead types in columns and saw a 331% increase in conversions over the control.
3. Today’s team
Daniel Burstein Jon Powell
Director of Editorial Senior Manager
Content Research and Strategy
Adam Lapp
Associate Director
Optimization & Research
#webclinic
4. Background and Test Design
Experiment ID: MTCA Microsite Test
Location: MarketingExperiments Research Library
Test Protocol Number: TP1560
Research Notes:
Background: Migraine Treatment Centers of America offers an innovative
long-term migraine treatment solution to people suffering from migraines.
Goal: To increase leads from the website
Primary Research Question: Which value exchange strategy will result in a
higher conversion rate?
Approach: A/b multifactor split
#webclinic
5. Control
Experiment: Control
• The control homepage
casts a broad net and
attempts to capture all
lead types with a single
message and CTA.
#webclinic
6. Experiment: Treatment Treatment
• The treatment accounts
for three major lead
types with three evenly
weighted columns.
6
#webclinic
8. Experiment: Results
331% Increase in lead rate
The Treatment generated 330.6% more conversions than the Control
Verison CR Rel. diff Stat. Conf
Control 1.6% - -
Treatment 7.0% 330.6% 99%
What You Needsequence of the three primarythe value proposition and CTA
to the thought
to Understand: By matching
prospect types, the
treatment generated a 331% higher conversion rate than the control.
#webclinic
9. What we discovered
F Key Principles
1. Too often, marketers confuse the objective of a homepage with the
objective of a landing page.
2. In most cases, the objective of a homepage should be to get various
prospect types on the correct path up the inverted funnel.
#webclinic
10. The goal of the Marketer is to move the Prospect Up, Not down, the Funnel.
10
#webclinic
11. The Inverted Funnel
1. The funnel is often presented as
one potentially useful analogy for
marketing. It is in fact, the
primary analogy. All marketing
should influence a decision.
2. The funnel analogy distorts
g = 9.81 m/s2
reality. People are not falling into
your funnel, they are falling out.
The funnel must be inverted.
3. People don’t travel down the
center of the funnel. People are
climbing up the sides.
#webclinic
12. The Inverted Funnel
(Ma)YES Y
Sales Call (Mi)YES
(Mi)YES
The Message
(Mi)YES
Landing Page
(Mi)YES
(Mi)YES
Business Software Suite
#1 On-Demand. 6459+ World Clients
Award-Winning Solution. Free Trial
www.XXXXXXXXXX.com/Business
PPC Ad
(Mi)YES
12
#webclinic
13. What we discovered
F Key Principles
1. Too often, marketers confuse the objective of a homepage with the
objective of a landing page.
2. In most cases, the objective of a homepage should be to get various
prospect types on the correct path up the inverted funnel.
3. One way to accomplish this objective is by shifting our homepage
approach to a directory page.
#webclinic
14. The Goal of a Homepage
Control: “Landing Page” Approach
Conversion Rate
Prospect Type 1
General Lead
Prospect Type 2 1.6%
Prospect Type 3
14
#webclinic
15. The Goal of a Homepage
Treatment: “Directory Page” Approach
Conversion Rate
Prospect Type 1
Prospect Type 2 Lead Type 2
7.0%
Prospect Type 3
15
#webclinic
16. Today, we are going to learn how to optimize a homepage
through live optimization with our research analysts.
16
#webclinic
This page is now serving as a directory. Some of our most effective pages have been directory pages and have been successful with even more than three options.
Assigned: ADAMSubmitted by: Tina & CherylFIRST HANDSHAKE (CAN’T MAKE ASSUMPTIONS) - WHAT ACTION DO YOU WANT PEOPLE TO TAKE - PROCESS LEVEL VPPrimary Audience: Adult learners (30-55) who are considering going back to school to finish their Bachelors degree in technology or business or to Further their education. Primary Objective: Help prospective students find more information on their program of interest Primary Sources of Traffic for homepage: SEO:50.05% (Google 58%) Referral:21.51% Direct: 27.38% Campaigns: 1.06% Keywords: (SEO) Majority of search volume comes from branded keywords. Non-Branded Keywords: (from highest to lowest) RN to MSN online, online computer science degree, rn to msn, nursing informatics, rn to msn online programs
Assigned: JONSubmitted by: EmirPrimary Audience: Anyone responsible or accountable for improving their organization's innovation processes and practices.Primary Objective: Drive traffic to the SG Navigator product, the seminars line-up, and the various consulting services and publications offerings.Primary Traffic Sources: SEO:stage gate process, stage gate, stage gate model, innovation best practices, innovation benchmark
Assigned: ADAMSubmitted by: AndyVP IS IN HEADER (IF NON-BRANDED KW…) - CONSIDER TOP CATEGORIES - DIRECTORY STYLE - TEST USING HP FOR CUSTOMER FAV CATEGORIESPrimary Audience: Medical Professionals that work in a clinical laboratory environment. (phlebotomists, microbiologists, pathologists)Primary Objective: Sell products and email newsletter signupsPrimary Sources of Traffic: Direct Mail, Catalogs, SEO: clinical lab supplies, lab organization, phlebotomy
Assigned: JONSubmitted by: AlexPrimary Audience: People working in salesPrimary Objective: to get people ineterested in buying the product.Primary Sources of Traffic: online meeting platform and our blog
Assigned: ADAMSubmitted by: KathiHEADLINE - 6 ROTATIONS - GET PEOPLE TO WHERE THEY NEED TO GO (BY CUSTOMER NEED) - SELF SELECT BANNERPrimary Audience: IT, project managers and architectsPrimary Objective: click through to product/solutions pages, ultimately driving salesPrimary Sources of Traffic: branded search and email blasts
Assigned: ADAMSubmitted by: DustinREPITITION (OP EXCEL -> OP EXCEL) - NO IDEA WHAT YOU SHOULD DO - MICRO YES - CLARITY TRUMPS PERSUASION - PRIMARY GOAL SHOULD BE NEAR TOP (EVEN PUT WHITE PAPER ON PAGE)Primary Audience: C-Suite: usually CEO/CFO/COO, Male, 30-50 years old, Very educated, Married with family, Decision maker, User of technology,Primary Objective: Getting visitors to download a whitepaper relevant to one of the 3 funnels (Healthcare/Nonprofit/Business)Primary Sources of Traffic: SEO new site, still working on keywords
Assigned: JONSubmitted by: SarahPrimary Audience: analytics professionals from [electric power] utilities plus solution providers [vendors}Primary Objective: Education on industry events and get them interested enough to click through to other pages and registerPrimary Sources of Traffic: direct, our email ant other promotional pushes, referrals from partners, social media and SEO. keywords: utility analytics
Assigned: ADAMSubmitted by: Mary EllenWHAT DOES FRESH FINDS MEAN - VP SECTION AT TOP 100 PIX - WHAT VALUE DOES THE MAIN HERO PROVIDE (CONSIDER SALES/PROMOS) - APPEAL TO NEW VISITORS (COOKIE)Primary Audience: 30-50 year old womenPrimary Objective: Get visitors to buy the products offeredPrimary Sources of Traffic: Direct, paid search (fresh finds) and email.
Assigned: JONSubmitted by: JoycePrimary Audience: College studentsPrimary Objective: For students to search and buy their course materials and/or register their access code(s)Primary Sources of Traffic: AdWords: (discount/cheap textbooks, etextbooks, ISBNs), course syllabi, professor announcement.
Assigned: ADAMSubmitted by: IgorWHERE IN THE WORLD AM I SUPPOSED TO CLICK (INTUITIVE CTA, DON’T MAKE ME THINK) - YOGA WEBSITE - VP TESTING AND DEVELOPMENT (JACK OF ALL TRADES?) WHAT MAKES YOU DIFFERENT - EMPHASIZE GUARATEE (LOCATION, SHAPE, COLOR, PROOF) - REMOVE ENTIRE TOP SECTION Primary Audience: Small/Medium Business OwnersPrimary Objective: Get people interested in our online marketing servicesPrimary Sources of Traffic: search and social
Assigned: JONSubmitted by: JohnPrimary Audience: Homeowners looking for window replacementsPrimary Objective: Establish credibility of brand and either direct them a form fill or call in inquiry.Primary Sources of Traffic: Blend of direct and SEO, direct response ads, radio, TV
Assigned: ADAMSubmitted by: BernardDISSOLVE YOUR BUSINESS - I HAVE TO FIGURE IT OUT (YOU NEED TO DO THE WORK, NOT ME) - RANDOM CLICKING OF FEATURES - NO CONVERSATION - WHAT’S IN THE VIDEO - FREE TRIAL CTA LM OR SIGNUP DEPENDING ON MAGNITUDE OF MOTIVATION - MORE GENERAL ABOUT THE ENTIRE PRODUCT, THEN HELP THEM DECIDE ON EXACT VERSION - COST IS TOO EARLY BEFORE ENOUGH VALUE HAS BEEN CONVEYEDPrimary Audience: 28-44 year old womenPrimary Objective: To sell softwarePrimary Sources of Traffic: Adwords
Assigned: JONSubmitted by: CraigPrimary Audience: People traveling to PortlandPrimary Objective: Get visitors to book a roomPrimary Sources of Traffic: Organic and paid search
Assigned: ADAMSubmitted by: KathySIMPLIFY TOWARDS THE OBJECTIVE (BANNER, SECONDARY ITEMS) - PROCESS LEVEL VALUE - CREDIBILITY - FLIP PHOTO FOR EYEPATHPrimary Audience: Consumers interested in buying a boat or learning about boatingPrimary Objective: To drive people to a DVD order/download or to request info from boat Manufacturers using the selection toolPrimary Sources of Traffic: Google SEM (boating, find a boat, buy a boat)
Assigned:JONSubmitted by: GregPrimary Audience: Home owners or property managersPrimary Objective: Have users call or fill out price quote formPrimary Sources of Traffic: PPC (lawn care dallas, lawn maintenance companies, etc..)
Assigned: ADAMSubmitted by: ThomasNAVIGATION DIFFICULT TO FIND - LITTLE DIFFERENTIATION BETWEEN THE CTAS (NEW ARRIVALS, TOP STYLES…) - TOO MUCH STUFF (BOXES, CTA’S,) MAKE IT CRYSTAL CLEAR WHAT I SHOULD DO (AND IF I DON’T WANT TO DO THAT…MAKE THE SECONDARY OBJECTIVES SIMPLE AND MINIMAL) - HOW DO PEOPLE SHOP? (FIGURE THAT OUT THEN REPLICATE IT ON THE PAGE)Primary Audience: African-American women ages 30 – 65, upper-middle income, w some college educationPrimary Objective: Help customers find the product they are looking for quicklyPrimary Sources of Traffic: SEO: 79% New Visitors 21% Returning Visitors 57.4% Search Traffic 24% Referral Traffic 14.25% Direct Traffic 4.35%
Assigned: JONSubmitted by: JayPrimary Audience: Electronics ConsumersPrimary Objective: Funnel visitors to products they are interested inPrimary Sources of Traffic: Typed/Bookmarked, SEO (keywords = some iteration of our name)
Assigned: ADAMSubmitted by: ChrisCOMPLEX CTAS (REMEMBER YOUR GOAL) - DO PEOPLE CLICK ON THE BRANDS? - REMOVE EVERYTHING FROM LOGOS TO THE SEDOND SET OF BEST SELLERS - GIVE WAYS TO SHOP (NEED, PRODUCT TYPE, BRAND) Primary Audience: Golfers interested in and willing to spend Money to improve their game through lessons and training devices. (M/F, 35+)Primary Objective: Drive traffic to individual product pages ultimately to have the customer complete a transactionPrimary Sources of Traffic: Email blasts, SEO and AdWords drive traffic directly to individual product pages. Keywords: relate to “golf training aids”
Assigned: JONSubmitted by: DavidPrimary Audience: Small/Medium Business OwnersPrimary Objective: Office professionals (admin assistant, office managers school/church secretaries and purchasing specialists.) Not the business owner.Primary sources of Traffic: AdWords: office signs, nameplates, door signs, room name sign
Assigned: ADAMSubmitted by: CamilleMAIN PRODUCT VP AND DESCRIPTION IS BURIED (LOCATION, FONT SIZE) - THE CATEGORIES ON LEFT - DO YOU NEED A TOP NAV - DO YOU NEED THE FULL CATEGORIES AT THE BOTTOM - VP STATEMENT IS LONG WINDED AND DOESN’T SEEM CUSTOMER CENTRIC (TELL ME HOW EASY TO PUT UP, LOW COST, PERFECT GIFT, FEATURES) - CONSIDER A ROOM DESIGNER TOOL (BUILD, VISUALIZE, PRICE…DO IT WITH YOUR CHILD)Primary Audience: Parents who want to decorate their kids roomsPrimary Objective: To help customers find what they needPrimary sources of Traffic: Organic (Kids Murals, children's murals, etc.)
Assigned: JONSubmitted by: DavidPrimary Audience: Existing customers of the bank (both Business and Retail) Secondary Audience: Potential customersPrimary Objective: Cross sell products and services to exisitng and new customersPrimary sources of Traffic: Exisiting customers, native search, and Adwords: (mortage rates, refinance, refi, HELOC)
Assigned: ADAMSubmitted by: BiancaINTERESTING APPROACH (TESTIMONIALS) - WOULD BE AWESOME TO CLICK THROUGH AND SEE ACTUAL SITE (OPEN NEW TAB) - RADICAL APPROACH (ONE PRODUCT WITH FEATURES…CUSTOMIZE YOUR WEBSITE) - COULD DO MUCH OF THE WORK ON THE HOMEPAGE - CONFLICTING CTAs (GET A QUOTE AND OUR PRICE) - MAIN CTA CART BEFORE THE HORSEPrimary Audience: Small business owners in AustrailiaPrimary Objective: Get people to request a quote for a website.Primary sources of Traffic: SEO. Keyword: Web Design Company
Assigned: JONSubmitted by: JockPrimary Audience: New car buyersPrimary Objective: Get visitors to fill out the quote formPrimary sources of Traffic: SEO