SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  13
Three Political Truisms
   All political careers end in failure
Enoch Powell

   It’s the economy, stupid
Bill Clinton aide

   Events, dear boy, events
Harold Macmillan
Prime ministerial powers
- formal
   Head of the Executive
   Chair of the Cabinet
   Quasi Head of State
   Commander-in-chief
   Foreign policy leader
   Parliamentary leader
   Dissolution
Prime ministerial power
- informal
   Chief policy maker

   P olitical patronage , (which is the
    use of state resources to reward
    individuals for their electoral support)

   Government spokesperson
Limitations on power
- formal
   Parliament
   Cabinet
   Party
Limitations on power
- informal
   Popular Image
   Media image
   Personality
   Parliamentary majority
   Party dissent
   Cabinet dissent
   Strength of Opposition
   Stature of predecessor
Jim Callaghan
   Parliamentary majority
   Party dissent (unions)
   Media image
   Wilson’s stature
   Misuse of dissolution power
   Legacy of oil price hike
Margaret Thatcher
   Internal dissent
   Media image
   Length of tenure
   External events
John Major
   Stature of predecessor
   Parliamentary majority
   Party dissent
   Cabinet dissent
   Media image
   Personality
   Economic events
   Strength of Opposition
Tony Blair
   Internal dissent
   One big event
   Parliamentary majority
   Lords and judicial activism
Gordon Brown
   Stature of predecessor
   Personality
   Media image
   Misuse of dissolution
   Events – in spades
   Strength of Opposition
   Parliamentary majority
Lessons from Prime
Ministers’ experience - 1
   10 years and that’s it
   Thatcher, Blair, Brown
   Pareto’s revolving elites (opposing
    parties rotating  in and out of
    government offices and squabbling
    endlessly over policy)
   Patronage
   Media
Lessons from Prime
Ministers’ experience - 2
   External events are increasingly
    influential
   It’s not the events, it’s how you are
    perceived to be handling them
Lessons from Prime
Ministers’ experience - 3
   It’s not just the economy stupid
   Major 1992, Major 1997
   Brown – memories are short
   We’re doomed, Cap’n Mainwaring,
    we’re all doomed.

Contenu connexe

Tendances

07 Governmental Influence on Trade
07 Governmental Influence on Trade07 Governmental Influence on Trade
07 Governmental Influence on TradeBrent Weeks
 
Environmental scanning-ppt
Environmental scanning-pptEnvironmental scanning-ppt
Environmental scanning-ppt16119843
 
Business ethics, social responsibility and environment stability
Business ethics, social responsibility and environment stabilityBusiness ethics, social responsibility and environment stability
Business ethics, social responsibility and environment stabilityChristian James Mingoy
 
Principles Of Governments
Principles Of GovernmentsPrinciples Of Governments
Principles Of Governmentsitutor
 
Presidential Roles
Presidential RolesPresidential Roles
Presidential Rolesvmboda
 

Tendances (6)

07 Governmental Influence on Trade
07 Governmental Influence on Trade07 Governmental Influence on Trade
07 Governmental Influence on Trade
 
Environmental scanning-ppt
Environmental scanning-pptEnvironmental scanning-ppt
Environmental scanning-ppt
 
Decision-making
Decision-makingDecision-making
Decision-making
 
Business ethics, social responsibility and environment stability
Business ethics, social responsibility and environment stabilityBusiness ethics, social responsibility and environment stability
Business ethics, social responsibility and environment stability
 
Principles Of Governments
Principles Of GovernmentsPrinciples Of Governments
Principles Of Governments
 
Presidential Roles
Presidential RolesPresidential Roles
Presidential Roles
 

Similaire à Prime ministerial power - Pros & Cons

Prime ministerial power - With recent examples
Prime ministerial power - With recent examplesPrime ministerial power - With recent examples
Prime ministerial power - With recent examplesmattbentley34
 
The executive branch the presidency
The executive branch   the presidencyThe executive branch   the presidency
The executive branch the presidencyaquinaspolitics
 
Pm and cabinet
Pm and cabinetPm and cabinet
Pm and cabinetmadrob1
 
Election of1912 5 (1)
Election of1912 5 (1)Election of1912 5 (1)
Election of1912 5 (1)anna12435
 
Unit 2 specimen paper
Unit 2 specimen paperUnit 2 specimen paper
Unit 2 specimen papermattbentley34
 
Political arrogance
Political arrogancePolitical arrogance
Political arroganceGed Mirfin
 
Uk politics
Uk politicsUk politics
Uk politicsraegday
 
Sections 4 and 5 of the Executive Branch Unit
Sections 4 and 5 of the Executive Branch UnitSections 4 and 5 of the Executive Branch Unit
Sections 4 and 5 of the Executive Branch Unitadutcher
 
No-Nonsense Guide to the General Election
No-Nonsense Guide to the General ElectionNo-Nonsense Guide to the General Election
No-Nonsense Guide to the General ElectionDavid Price-Williams
 
Possible scenarios for a trump presidency
Possible scenarios for a trump presidencyPossible scenarios for a trump presidency
Possible scenarios for a trump presidencyDavid Silverberg
 
Election of1912 5
Election of1912 5Election of1912 5
Election of1912 5javonnnnnnn
 
Presidential apptmts
Presidential apptmtsPresidential apptmts
Presidential apptmtsshoetzlein
 
Presidential apptmts
Presidential apptmtsPresidential apptmts
Presidential apptmtsshoetzlein
 
Governing a Divided Nation - Insights about the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election
Governing a Divided Nation - Insights about the 2016 U.S. Presidential ElectionGoverning a Divided Nation - Insights about the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election
Governing a Divided Nation - Insights about the 2016 U.S. Presidential ElectionMSL
 
Star-Gazette letters-to-the-editor By Gerald J. Furnkranz 2005-09
Star-Gazette letters-to-the-editor  By Gerald J. Furnkranz 2005-09Star-Gazette letters-to-the-editor  By Gerald J. Furnkranz 2005-09
Star-Gazette letters-to-the-editor By Gerald J. Furnkranz 2005-09Gerald Furnkranz
 
Tabakian Pols 1 Summer 2014 Power 10
Tabakian Pols 1 Summer 2014 Power 10Tabakian Pols 1 Summer 2014 Power 10
Tabakian Pols 1 Summer 2014 Power 10John Paul Tabakian
 
Tabakian Pols 1 summer 2014 power 12
Tabakian Pols 1 summer 2014 power 12Tabakian Pols 1 summer 2014 power 12
Tabakian Pols 1 summer 2014 power 12John Paul Tabakian
 

Similaire à Prime ministerial power - Pros & Cons (20)

Prime ministerial power - With recent examples
Prime ministerial power - With recent examplesPrime ministerial power - With recent examples
Prime ministerial power - With recent examples
 
The Executive Branch | The Presidency
The Executive Branch | The PresidencyThe Executive Branch | The Presidency
The Executive Branch | The Presidency
 
The executive branch the presidency
The executive branch   the presidencyThe executive branch   the presidency
The executive branch the presidency
 
As the executive
As the executiveAs the executive
As the executive
 
Pm and cabinet
Pm and cabinetPm and cabinet
Pm and cabinet
 
Election of1912 5 (1)
Election of1912 5 (1)Election of1912 5 (1)
Election of1912 5 (1)
 
Unit 2 specimen paper
Unit 2 specimen paperUnit 2 specimen paper
Unit 2 specimen paper
 
Political arrogance
Political arrogancePolitical arrogance
Political arrogance
 
Uk politics
Uk politicsUk politics
Uk politics
 
Sections 4 and 5 of the Executive Branch Unit
Sections 4 and 5 of the Executive Branch UnitSections 4 and 5 of the Executive Branch Unit
Sections 4 and 5 of the Executive Branch Unit
 
No-Nonsense Guide to the General Election
No-Nonsense Guide to the General ElectionNo-Nonsense Guide to the General Election
No-Nonsense Guide to the General Election
 
Possible scenarios for a trump presidency
Possible scenarios for a trump presidencyPossible scenarios for a trump presidency
Possible scenarios for a trump presidency
 
Executive
ExecutiveExecutive
Executive
 
Election of1912 5
Election of1912 5Election of1912 5
Election of1912 5
 
Presidential apptmts
Presidential apptmtsPresidential apptmts
Presidential apptmts
 
Presidential apptmts
Presidential apptmtsPresidential apptmts
Presidential apptmts
 
Governing a Divided Nation - Insights about the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election
Governing a Divided Nation - Insights about the 2016 U.S. Presidential ElectionGoverning a Divided Nation - Insights about the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election
Governing a Divided Nation - Insights about the 2016 U.S. Presidential Election
 
Star-Gazette letters-to-the-editor By Gerald J. Furnkranz 2005-09
Star-Gazette letters-to-the-editor  By Gerald J. Furnkranz 2005-09Star-Gazette letters-to-the-editor  By Gerald J. Furnkranz 2005-09
Star-Gazette letters-to-the-editor By Gerald J. Furnkranz 2005-09
 
Tabakian Pols 1 Summer 2014 Power 10
Tabakian Pols 1 Summer 2014 Power 10Tabakian Pols 1 Summer 2014 Power 10
Tabakian Pols 1 Summer 2014 Power 10
 
Tabakian Pols 1 summer 2014 power 12
Tabakian Pols 1 summer 2014 power 12Tabakian Pols 1 summer 2014 power 12
Tabakian Pols 1 summer 2014 power 12
 

Plus de mattbentley34

Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problem
Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problemSlide 1 1mm - the basic economic problem
Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problemmattbentley34
 
Why study economics 2019
Why study economics 2019Why study economics 2019
Why study economics 2019mattbentley34
 
Behavioural economics key terms
Behavioural economics key termsBehavioural economics key terms
Behavioural economics key termsmattbentley34
 
Behavioural economics extra resources
Behavioural economics   extra resourcesBehavioural economics   extra resources
Behavioural economics extra resourcesmattbentley34
 
Behavioural economics
Behavioural economicsBehavioural economics
Behavioural economicsmattbentley34
 
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)mattbentley34
 
The labour market wage determination
The labour market wage determinationThe labour market wage determination
The labour market wage determinationmattbentley34
 
Specimen paper insert
Specimen paper insertSpecimen paper insert
Specimen paper insertmattbentley34
 
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-planner
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-plannerAQA - pecan-pie-ajim-planner
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-plannermattbentley34
 
The Multiplier effect explained
The Multiplier effect explainedThe Multiplier effect explained
The Multiplier effect explainedmattbentley34
 
Model answers nationalism
Model answers nationalismModel answers nationalism
Model answers nationalismmattbentley34
 
Edexcel A level economics exam advice
Edexcel A level economics exam adviceEdexcel A level economics exam advice
Edexcel A level economics exam advicemattbentley34
 
Model answers nationalism & Racialism
Model answers nationalism & RacialismModel answers nationalism & Racialism
Model answers nationalism & Racialismmattbentley34
 
Voting systems in elections
Voting systems in electionsVoting systems in elections
Voting systems in electionsmattbentley34
 
Political representation and democracy
Political representation and democracyPolitical representation and democracy
Political representation and democracymattbentley34
 
Political participation
Political participationPolitical participation
Political participationmattbentley34
 
Political ideologies
Political ideologiesPolitical ideologies
Political ideologiesmattbentley34
 

Plus de mattbentley34 (20)

Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problem
Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problemSlide 1 1mm - the basic economic problem
Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problem
 
Why study economics 2019
Why study economics 2019Why study economics 2019
Why study economics 2019
 
Behavioural economics key terms
Behavioural economics key termsBehavioural economics key terms
Behavioural economics key terms
 
Behavioural economics extra resources
Behavioural economics   extra resourcesBehavioural economics   extra resources
Behavioural economics extra resources
 
Behavioural economics
Behavioural economicsBehavioural economics
Behavioural economics
 
Jan 13
Jan 13Jan 13
Jan 13
 
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)
 
The labour market wage determination
The labour market wage determinationThe labour market wage determination
The labour market wage determination
 
Specimen paper insert
Specimen paper insertSpecimen paper insert
Specimen paper insert
 
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-planner
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-plannerAQA - pecan-pie-ajim-planner
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-planner
 
The Multiplier effect explained
The Multiplier effect explainedThe Multiplier effect explained
The Multiplier effect explained
 
Economic review
Economic reviewEconomic review
Economic review
 
Model answers nationalism
Model answers nationalismModel answers nationalism
Model answers nationalism
 
Edexcel A level economics exam advice
Edexcel A level economics exam adviceEdexcel A level economics exam advice
Edexcel A level economics exam advice
 
Monetary policy
Monetary policyMonetary policy
Monetary policy
 
Model answers nationalism & Racialism
Model answers nationalism & RacialismModel answers nationalism & Racialism
Model answers nationalism & Racialism
 
Voting systems in elections
Voting systems in electionsVoting systems in elections
Voting systems in elections
 
Political representation and democracy
Political representation and democracyPolitical representation and democracy
Political representation and democracy
 
Political participation
Political participationPolitical participation
Political participation
 
Political ideologies
Political ideologiesPolitical ideologies
Political ideologies
 

Prime ministerial power - Pros & Cons

  • 1. Three Political Truisms  All political careers end in failure Enoch Powell  It’s the economy, stupid Bill Clinton aide  Events, dear boy, events Harold Macmillan
  • 2. Prime ministerial powers - formal  Head of the Executive  Chair of the Cabinet  Quasi Head of State  Commander-in-chief  Foreign policy leader  Parliamentary leader  Dissolution
  • 3. Prime ministerial power - informal  Chief policy maker  P olitical patronage , (which is the use of state resources to reward individuals for their electoral support)  Government spokesperson
  • 4. Limitations on power - formal  Parliament  Cabinet  Party
  • 5. Limitations on power - informal  Popular Image  Media image  Personality  Parliamentary majority  Party dissent  Cabinet dissent  Strength of Opposition  Stature of predecessor
  • 6. Jim Callaghan  Parliamentary majority  Party dissent (unions)  Media image  Wilson’s stature  Misuse of dissolution power  Legacy of oil price hike
  • 7. Margaret Thatcher  Internal dissent  Media image  Length of tenure  External events
  • 8. John Major  Stature of predecessor  Parliamentary majority  Party dissent  Cabinet dissent  Media image  Personality  Economic events  Strength of Opposition
  • 9. Tony Blair  Internal dissent  One big event  Parliamentary majority  Lords and judicial activism
  • 10. Gordon Brown  Stature of predecessor  Personality  Media image  Misuse of dissolution  Events – in spades  Strength of Opposition  Parliamentary majority
  • 11. Lessons from Prime Ministers’ experience - 1  10 years and that’s it  Thatcher, Blair, Brown  Pareto’s revolving elites (opposing parties rotating  in and out of government offices and squabbling endlessly over policy)  Patronage  Media
  • 12. Lessons from Prime Ministers’ experience - 2  External events are increasingly influential  It’s not the events, it’s how you are perceived to be handling them
  • 13. Lessons from Prime Ministers’ experience - 3  It’s not just the economy stupid  Major 1992, Major 1997  Brown – memories are short  We’re doomed, Cap’n Mainwaring, we’re all doomed.