~~Slides from May 17, 2012 presentation at the North East HR Association conference~~
How often have you realized, only after an employee has left the company, how critical he or she actually was to the business? Have you ever found your company in dire straits because key positions have been empty for too long? Or have you hired a promising new executive only to see that person fail after just a short time on the job?
If so, you’re not alone. Sixty-four percent of new executives hired from the outside fail at their jobs, according to HR Review. And companies regularly fail to recognize the value of individuals or roles until they’re gone.
Succession planning helps improve the situation. But the data most companies use to make decisions about development and succession is incomplete.
The missing piece is the organization’s networks. Networks show the hidden relationships within organizations and identify deeply trusted employees, subject matter experts, innovation leaders, effective implementers, and problem solvers. They show who is deeply trusted, who people go to for leadership, and who might shine on their performance reviews but can’t work well with others.
Knowledge of the information embedded in networks can help leaders identify high potentials more effectively, make better decisions about succession, and craft more accurate and effective development plans.
More: http://partneringresources.com/organizational-networks-and-talent/
business environment micro environment macro environment.pptx
Using Hidden Networks to Identify and Develop High Potentials
1. Stacking the Deck:
Using Hidden Networks to Identify
and Develop High Potentials
Presented By:
Maya Townsend & Keli Trejo
Partnering Resources
2. The Point
HR leaders can achieve
more trustworthy,
complete, and
nuanced information
about high potentials
by using the
organization’s hidden
networks.
2
3. Learning Objectives
• Why and how employees develop networks of relationships to
help get work done
• The types of networks that typically form in organizations and
the 3 critical roles in networks
• How the 3 critical roles can help HR professionals identify and
develop more effective and accurate succession and
development programs
• Case studies of how companies have used network analysis to
develop the workforce
• Plans for applying network knowledge to current and upcoming
human capital development and succession planning efforts
3
4. About Us
We help organizations address complex collaboration and change challenges
Maya Townsend, Founder & Lead Consultant
• Specializes in using network knowledge to help organizations with
large scale change
• Rich experience in organization change, collaboration, and talent
assessment
• Author: Chief Learning Officer, Talent Management, CIO.Com, Mass
High Tech, et al.
• Presenter: NEHRA, PMI, Gartner, et al.
• Chocolate fanatic
Keli Trejo, Lead Consultant
• 20+ years HR experience, including OD, Executive
Coaching, Business Partner, HR Leadership roles
• Significant change management roles through multi-year HR
transformations
• Deep experience with leadership development and succession
management
• Strong, collaborative client and HR partner relationships
• Artist
4
6. What is a Network?
Networks are the webs of trusted
relationships that people forge in
order to perform work:
Routine Work Socializing Sharing
Expertise Innovating Improving
Making Ad Hoc Decisions Mentoring
7
Image: NetForm International. Used with permission.
7. Networks versus Social Networks
Social network tools help us
develop and maintain networks But the goal is the network
8
14. The R&D Organization
Jerry, CEO of the R&D
Jerry organization, is ready to retire.
Here’s the top three levels of
his organization (lower levels
hidden for simplicity).
15
Case: Netform, Inc. Used with permission.
16. The R&D Social Network
This map shows how people
connect socially.
Jerry
Joe and the CEO have a
strong social relationship
Diane has only four
connections, none of
which are with the CEO
Joe Diane
17
Case: Netform, Inc. Used with permission.
17. Your Turn
Howdy, neighbor!
Who should Jerry appoint as his successor? Why?
Who do you think Jerry did appoint as his
successor? Why?
18
18. The Recommendation
Joe would not be a good candidate for
succession since he is not well integrated into
the work network and is overly dependent on the
CEO.
Based on his strong personal trust for Joe, the
CEO chose Joe as his successor.
19
19. The Promotion
Joe became the new CEO
Joe
Diane, frustrated at
being passed over,
left the company.
Diane
20
Case: Netform, Inc. Used with permission.
20. The Defection
Without Diane, the
organization fractured and
Joe became deeply disconnected
After 6 disastrous months, Joe
was fired.
21
Case: Netform, Inc. Used with permission.
21. The Aftermath
Stan stepped in as
the new CEO
22
Case: Netform, Inc. Used with permission.
23. Quick Case: Who’s the High Performer?
Here’s who the Here are the actual
executives top 30 influencers
thought were as shown by the
the top 30 network analysis.
influencers in a Only 5 people show
Fortune 500 up on both lists.
global
information
company.
Why the gap? The
initial top 30 list
represents only the
executives’ direct
contacts and the
next level down.
They had no insight
into the rest of the
organization.
24
24. Quick Case: Critical Connector Lost
• Technology organization
• $75M operating budget
• Annual trade show was a
major revenue generation
vehicle
• The company let go of a low-
level administrator citing the
need to reduce overhead.
• They realized afterwards
that she was single-
handedly responsible for
securing millions of dollars
each year for the trade
show.
25
25. Quick Case: Critical Connectors Saved
• Situation: Merger of two
container plants required
decisions about staff retention
and outsourcing
• Results: Leaders identified and
retained people previously on
the layoff list:
► Two employees who provided a
steady source of innovation that
were previously slated for
retirement
► The group of employees that
were responsible for helping a
star achieve
26
From Stephenson (2008): “Building a Culture of Trust” and Stephenson (2005): “Trafficking in Trust.”
27. What HR Gets from a Network Analysis
A Nuanced “Go To” List for Talent
HR can use these lists for…
Creating mentoring pairs Seeding mission-critical teams Finding succession
candidates Accelerating change initiatives
28
29. Development & Networks
• Critical connectors have
specific attributes that help
them develop others more
successfully
► We can use critical connectors to
help accelerate on-
boarding, leader
integration, team
development, and so on
• High performers use networks
in specific ways that help
them be successful
► The top 20% of employees are
more likely to build and maintain
personal networks
Adapted from Cross, Thomas, & Light, How Top Talent Uses Networks and Where Rising Stars Get Trapped and The Organizational Network
30
Fieldbook, by Cross, Singer, Colella, Thomas, & Silverstone.
30. Network Practices of High Performers
Leveraging the Developing Awareness of
Periphery Expertise
• Learning how to access
• Integrating newcomers rapidly information, expertise, resources, an
• Ensuring access d decision approval
• Ensuring others know how to access
information, etc.
Managing the Center
• Preventing overload
• Freeing up SMEs and high
potentials to help others
Minimizing Insularity
• Building relationships outside Bridging Silos
my expertise, position, function • Brokering connections
• Collaborating • Ensuring collaboration
31
3131
Adapted from “Improving Leadership Effectiveness Through Personal Network Analysis and Development,” by Cross in The Organizational Network Fieldbook.
31. Your Turn: Mini Network Assessment
• Which practices do
leaders use most
effectively in your
organization? Please
share success stories!
• Which practices do
leaders need to improve?
Why?
32
32. Network Knowledge & High Performance
41%
• 36 - 42% more
34%
likely to exceed
30%
expectations
24%
• 43 – 72% more
likely to be 15%
promoted 11% 12% 11%
5%
• 42 – 74% more
likely to stay with "Far Exceeds" Promoted to Higher Left Company
Expectations Rank
the company
BLP Graduates Control Group Others in Top 5 Job Ranks
33
From Burt & Ronchi, “Teaching Executives to See Social Capital: Results from a Field Experiment.”
34. What You Can Do
1. Map your networks
2. Analyze the data
3. Engage, grow, and leverage critical connectors
4. Evolve the networks
35
35. Stacking the Deck
Using Hidden Networks to Identify and Develop High
Performers
Maya Townsend & Keli Trejo
Web: partneringresources.com
Blog: partneringresources.com/blog
Twitter: mayapare
Email: maya@partneringresources.com / keli@partneringresources.com
Phone: 617.395.8396 / 508.212.2268
Notes de l'éditeur
MESSAGE:
MESSAGE: Networks are the trusted webs of relationships that people form in every organization in order to get things done.
MESSAGE: Networks are the goal. Social networks are tools used to build and connect with networks.
MESSAGE: Organization charts are important, but don’t tell the whole story.
MESSAGE: Networks can show you the people who keep the company running.
MESSAGE: Networks aren’t just about the grapevine.
MESSAGE: Networks are an important consideration in succession planning
The social network looks very different. Overwhelmed by work, Diane has little opportunity to socialize.Joe has a strong relationship with the CEO.
MESSAGE: Networks can help generate more accurate assessments of human capital
MESSAGE: We don’t always know who our high performers are despite our best efforts.One company’s leadership team identified the 30 individuals they thought would be highly connected. Then, after a network analysis, they matched their list to the results. Only five people from the initial list were actual critical connectors. It turned out that the other 25 on the initial list were only one or two steps away from the leaders: direct contacts or contacts of direct contacts. But, since the leaders' personal networks were limited (as everyone’s are), they couldn’t see the connectors outside their personal networks. It was a wake-up call. The leadership team rethought their talent development strategies and created special plans to leverage the actual key connectors.
MESSAGE: Not knowing people in the network can cost millions.In one such example, a software company let go of a low-level administrator citing the need to reduce overhead in the organization. Little did they know that this woman was single-handedly responsible for securing millions of dollars each year by nagging companies until they finally sent in sponsorship checks for the annual trade conference. Once she left, the leaders realized their error, but the damage was already done. Her expertise about the sponsors, and how best to influence them, left with her.
MESSAGE: The key to managing networks is understanding critical connectors
MESSAGE: Networks can help with human capital development.
MESSAGE: High performers do specific things with their networks. Build high-quality relationshipsManage the Center: Minimize bottlenecks and acknowledge / develop high performers. Position selves at key network points and leverage people around them.Leverage the Periphery: Rapidly integrate newcomers and reengage under-connected high performersSelectively Bridge Silos: Reach across important differences such as geography, function, etc.Develop Awareness of Expertise: Invest in relationships to extend expertise, balance biases, and prevent career traps.Minimize Insularity: Cultivate select ties with internal & external experts and stakeholders.
MESSAGE: It pays to help people develop high performer networks.Burt & Ronchi “Teaching Executives to See Social Capital” in Social Science ResearchExecutives active in a network learning course were over 2 times more likely to far exceed expectations on performance reviews than the control group Active executives were 3 times more likely to be promoted to a higher rank than the control group Active executives were less likely to leave the company
MESSAGE: Analysis helps you find the riches in your network.This is where many organizations thrive. We’ve covered some of the things to look for in the network: single points of failure, weak links, hubs, gatekeepers, pulsetakers, structural over-dependency, missing links, unaligned links, too many links, and orphans. Analysis helps Leaders identify and correct these risks. This is also the time to build redundancy into the system, mitigate potential risks, and act on opportunities.In this case study…