SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  13
How to Evaluate New Medical Treatments Mark Perloe, M.D. www.ivf.com
Mass-Media Influence ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Internet Medicine ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Rationale for Evidence-based Medicine ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Evidence-based Medicine ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Clinical Study Types ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Statistics ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Evaluating Medical Studies ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Evaluating Medical Studies ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
What’s a Meta-analysis? ,[object Object],[object Object]
Meta-Analysis ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Limitations of EBM ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Clinical Decision-making ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Contenu connexe

Tendances

How to comment on a Cochrane review
How to comment on a Cochrane reviewHow to comment on a Cochrane review
How to comment on a Cochrane review
Tamara Rader
 
The AHRQ Training Modules for the Systematic Reviews Methods Guide: An Introd...
The AHRQ Training Modules for the Systematic Reviews Methods Guide: An Introd...The AHRQ Training Modules for the Systematic Reviews Methods Guide: An Introd...
The AHRQ Training Modules for the Systematic Reviews Methods Guide: An Introd...
Effective Health Care Program
 
Biomedical Literature
Biomedical Literature Biomedical Literature
Biomedical Literature
Arete-Zoe, LLC
 

Tendances (20)

How to comment on a Cochrane review
How to comment on a Cochrane reviewHow to comment on a Cochrane review
How to comment on a Cochrane review
 
Clinical Trial Recruitment
Clinical Trial RecruitmentClinical Trial Recruitment
Clinical Trial Recruitment
 
The AHRQ Training Modules for the Systematic Reviews Methods Guide: An Introd...
The AHRQ Training Modules for the Systematic Reviews Methods Guide: An Introd...The AHRQ Training Modules for the Systematic Reviews Methods Guide: An Introd...
The AHRQ Training Modules for the Systematic Reviews Methods Guide: An Introd...
 
Structure of medical data
Structure of medical dataStructure of medical data
Structure of medical data
 
Outcomes Research
Outcomes ResearchOutcomes Research
Outcomes Research
 
Clinical Trial Recruitment & Retention
Clinical Trial Recruitment & RetentionClinical Trial Recruitment & Retention
Clinical Trial Recruitment & Retention
 
Value of Personalized Health Care
Value of Personalized Health CareValue of Personalized Health Care
Value of Personalized Health Care
 
Expanded PICO V1
Expanded PICO V1Expanded PICO V1
Expanded PICO V1
 
P04.17. Adverse effects of homeopathy, what do we know? A systematic review
P04.17. Adverse effects of homeopathy, what do we know? A systematic reviewP04.17. Adverse effects of homeopathy, what do we know? A systematic review
P04.17. Adverse effects of homeopathy, what do we know? A systematic review
 
Evidence Based-Medicine
Evidence Based-MedicineEvidence Based-Medicine
Evidence Based-Medicine
 
What are the essential design features of personal health records to improve ...
What are the essential design features of personal health records to improve ...What are the essential design features of personal health records to improve ...
What are the essential design features of personal health records to improve ...
 
Health research
Health researchHealth research
Health research
 
Biomedical Literature
Biomedical Literature Biomedical Literature
Biomedical Literature
 
EBM Systematic Review Appraisal Template V1
EBM Systematic Review Appraisal Template V1EBM Systematic Review Appraisal Template V1
EBM Systematic Review Appraisal Template V1
 
EBM Therapy Appraisal Template F1
EBM Therapy Appraisal Template F1EBM Therapy Appraisal Template F1
EBM Therapy Appraisal Template F1
 
Assessing Applicability Quiz
Assessing Applicability QuizAssessing Applicability Quiz
Assessing Applicability Quiz
 
EBM ppt by ANN
EBM ppt by ANNEBM ppt by ANN
EBM ppt by ANN
 
Quantitative Synthesis II
Quantitative Synthesis IIQuantitative Synthesis II
Quantitative Synthesis II
 
Dawn Stacey, Theory and Knowledge of Patient Decision Aids: the Evidence
Dawn Stacey, Theory and Knowledge of Patient Decision Aids: the EvidenceDawn Stacey, Theory and Knowledge of Patient Decision Aids: the Evidence
Dawn Stacey, Theory and Knowledge of Patient Decision Aids: the Evidence
 
Evidence Based Medicine
Evidence Based MedicineEvidence Based Medicine
Evidence Based Medicine
 

En vedette

Kansainvälisyyspäivän vesivisa (2)
Kansainvälisyyspäivän vesivisa (2)Kansainvälisyyspäivän vesivisa (2)
Kansainvälisyyspäivän vesivisa (2)
Pasi Siltakorpi
 
Unit 2. extra practice
Unit 2. extra practiceUnit 2. extra practice
Unit 2. extra practice
Sonia
 
【労働者健康福祉機構】平成17年度環境報告書
【労働者健康福祉機構】平成17年度環境報告書【労働者健康福祉機構】平成17年度環境報告書
【労働者健康福祉機構】平成17年度環境報告書
env25
 
Ogc in arc_gis_g_tstyle
Ogc in arc_gis_g_tstyleOgc in arc_gis_g_tstyle
Ogc in arc_gis_g_tstyle
Gert-Jan
 
Wellspiration 6 - Fighting Heart Disease Naturally
Wellspiration 6  - Fighting Heart Disease NaturallyWellspiration 6  - Fighting Heart Disease Naturally
Wellspiration 6 - Fighting Heart Disease Naturally
Yafa Sakkejha
 
Rusu 2012 clubs affil pack
Rusu 2012 clubs affil packRusu 2012 clubs affil pack
Rusu 2012 clubs affil pack
Mohammad Hassan
 

En vedette (20)

CinestudiO Cine Prêmio 2010 - Parte 1/4
CinestudiO Cine Prêmio 2010 - Parte 1/4CinestudiO Cine Prêmio 2010 - Parte 1/4
CinestudiO Cine Prêmio 2010 - Parte 1/4
 
Rotary geotourism angus_m_robinson
Rotary geotourism angus_m_robinsonRotary geotourism angus_m_robinson
Rotary geotourism angus_m_robinson
 
Mitä mun puhelin osaa010316
Mitä mun puhelin osaa010316Mitä mun puhelin osaa010316
Mitä mun puhelin osaa010316
 
Hydrogen Station Design from CaFCP
Hydrogen Station Design from CaFCPHydrogen Station Design from CaFCP
Hydrogen Station Design from CaFCP
 
Bolyst - når gamlekjæresten prøver seg igjen
Bolyst - når gamlekjæresten prøver seg igjenBolyst - når gamlekjæresten prøver seg igjen
Bolyst - når gamlekjæresten prøver seg igjen
 
Kansainvälisyyspäivän vesivisa (2)
Kansainvälisyyspäivän vesivisa (2)Kansainvälisyyspäivän vesivisa (2)
Kansainvälisyyspäivän vesivisa (2)
 
Unit 2. extra practice
Unit 2. extra practiceUnit 2. extra practice
Unit 2. extra practice
 
Health Care HR
Health Care HRHealth Care HR
Health Care HR
 
Competitive intelligence - Pubcon 2013
Competitive intelligence - Pubcon 2013Competitive intelligence - Pubcon 2013
Competitive intelligence - Pubcon 2013
 
【労働者健康福祉機構】平成17年度環境報告書
【労働者健康福祉機構】平成17年度環境報告書【労働者健康福祉機構】平成17年度環境報告書
【労働者健康福祉機構】平成17年度環境報告書
 
Bella susona legend amaya isabella_anna_cristina
Bella susona legend amaya isabella_anna_cristinaBella susona legend amaya isabella_anna_cristina
Bella susona legend amaya isabella_anna_cristina
 
How to Optimize Your Blog for Faster Loading in Three Easy Steps
How to Optimize Your Blog for Faster Loading in Three Easy StepsHow to Optimize Your Blog for Faster Loading in Three Easy Steps
How to Optimize Your Blog for Faster Loading in Three Easy Steps
 
Adobe Indesign CS 5.5 (Corso Base)
Adobe Indesign CS 5.5 (Corso Base)Adobe Indesign CS 5.5 (Corso Base)
Adobe Indesign CS 5.5 (Corso Base)
 
In-House Tips and Tricks: Pubcon 2015
In-House Tips and Tricks: Pubcon 2015In-House Tips and Tricks: Pubcon 2015
In-House Tips and Tricks: Pubcon 2015
 
Wordpress Starter Kit
Wordpress Starter KitWordpress Starter Kit
Wordpress Starter Kit
 
Ogc in arc_gis_g_tstyle
Ogc in arc_gis_g_tstyleOgc in arc_gis_g_tstyle
Ogc in arc_gis_g_tstyle
 
Twijfelen tussen Doen en Denken
Twijfelen tussen Doen en DenkenTwijfelen tussen Doen en Denken
Twijfelen tussen Doen en Denken
 
Wellspiration 6 - Fighting Heart Disease Naturally
Wellspiration 6  - Fighting Heart Disease NaturallyWellspiration 6  - Fighting Heart Disease Naturally
Wellspiration 6 - Fighting Heart Disease Naturally
 
Rusu 2012 clubs affil pack
Rusu 2012 clubs affil packRusu 2012 clubs affil pack
Rusu 2012 clubs affil pack
 
Viestintäroolit ja -keinot vuorovaikutteisessa viestinnässä (Sitran Maamerkit...
Viestintäroolit ja -keinot vuorovaikutteisessa viestinnässä (Sitran Maamerkit...Viestintäroolit ja -keinot vuorovaikutteisessa viestinnässä (Sitran Maamerkit...
Viestintäroolit ja -keinot vuorovaikutteisessa viestinnässä (Sitran Maamerkit...
 

Similaire à Medical Studies What Can You Believe

Matching the Research Design to the Study Question
Matching the Research Design to the Study QuestionMatching the Research Design to the Study Question
Matching the Research Design to the Study Question
AcademyHealth
 
Knowledge Transfer & Exchange
Knowledge Transfer & ExchangeKnowledge Transfer & Exchange
Knowledge Transfer & Exchange
CFHI-FCASS
 
Evidence of influence
Evidence of influenceEvidence of influence
Evidence of influence
Hesham Gaber
 
Eblm pres final
Eblm pres finalEblm pres final
Eblm pres final
prasath172
 
Personalized Medicine: Current and Future Perspectives Personalized Medicin...
Personalized Medicine: Current and Future Perspectives 	 Personalized Medicin...Personalized Medicine: Current and Future Perspectives 	 Personalized Medicin...
Personalized Medicine: Current and Future Perspectives Personalized Medicin...
MedicineAndHealth
 
Pcori final writeup
Pcori final writeupPcori final writeup
Pcori final writeup
hbocian14
 
Considering adverse effects in prioritising reviews
Considering adverse effects in prioritising reviewsConsidering adverse effects in prioritising reviews
Considering adverse effects in prioritising reviews
Cochrane.Collaboration
 
Critical Appraisal Of Research Essay Example Paper.docx
Critical Appraisal Of Research Essay Example Paper.docxCritical Appraisal Of Research Essay Example Paper.docx
Critical Appraisal Of Research Essay Example Paper.docx
studywriters
 
Critical Appraisal Of Research Essay Example Paper.docx
Critical Appraisal Of Research Essay Example Paper.docxCritical Appraisal Of Research Essay Example Paper.docx
Critical Appraisal Of Research Essay Example Paper.docx
studywriters
 
Level of Evidence- Dina Hudiya Nadana Lubis.pptx
Level of Evidence- Dina Hudiya Nadana Lubis.pptxLevel of Evidence- Dina Hudiya Nadana Lubis.pptx
Level of Evidence- Dina Hudiya Nadana Lubis.pptx
dina410715
 

Similaire à Medical Studies What Can You Believe (20)

introductoin to Biostatistics ( 1st and 2nd lec ).ppt
introductoin to Biostatistics ( 1st and 2nd lec ).pptintroductoin to Biostatistics ( 1st and 2nd lec ).ppt
introductoin to Biostatistics ( 1st and 2nd lec ).ppt
 
Knowledge transfer, and evidence informed health policy-minster's meeting
Knowledge transfer, and evidence informed health policy-minster's meetingKnowledge transfer, and evidence informed health policy-minster's meeting
Knowledge transfer, and evidence informed health policy-minster's meeting
 
The role of patients and healthcare providers in translational medicine
The role of patients and healthcare providers in translational medicineThe role of patients and healthcare providers in translational medicine
The role of patients and healthcare providers in translational medicine
 
Introduction to Evidence Based Medicine (EBM)
Introduction to Evidence Based Medicine (EBM)Introduction to Evidence Based Medicine (EBM)
Introduction to Evidence Based Medicine (EBM)
 
Matching the Research Design to the Study Question
Matching the Research Design to the Study QuestionMatching the Research Design to the Study Question
Matching the Research Design to the Study Question
 
Knowledge Transfer & Exchange
Knowledge Transfer & ExchangeKnowledge Transfer & Exchange
Knowledge Transfer & Exchange
 
Evidence of influence
Evidence of influenceEvidence of influence
Evidence of influence
 
Outcomes research
Outcomes researchOutcomes research
Outcomes research
 
Eblm pres final
Eblm pres finalEblm pres final
Eblm pres final
 
The drug effectiveness review project: governments collaborating to use syste...
The drug effectiveness review project: governments collaborating to use syste...The drug effectiveness review project: governments collaborating to use syste...
The drug effectiveness review project: governments collaborating to use syste...
 
Personalized Medicine: Current and Future Perspectives Personalized Medicin...
Personalized Medicine: Current and Future Perspectives 	 Personalized Medicin...Personalized Medicine: Current and Future Perspectives 	 Personalized Medicin...
Personalized Medicine: Current and Future Perspectives Personalized Medicin...
 
Pcori final writeup
Pcori final writeupPcori final writeup
Pcori final writeup
 
Decisions in Healthcare.docx
Decisions in Healthcare.docxDecisions in Healthcare.docx
Decisions in Healthcare.docx
 
Evidence-based medicine in clinical pharmacy
Evidence-based medicine in clinical pharmacyEvidence-based medicine in clinical pharmacy
Evidence-based medicine in clinical pharmacy
 
Considering adverse effects in prioritising reviews
Considering adverse effects in prioritising reviewsConsidering adverse effects in prioritising reviews
Considering adverse effects in prioritising reviews
 
Critical Appraisal Of Research Essay Example Paper.docx
Critical Appraisal Of Research Essay Example Paper.docxCritical Appraisal Of Research Essay Example Paper.docx
Critical Appraisal Of Research Essay Example Paper.docx
 
Critical Appraisal Of Research Essay Example Paper.docx
Critical Appraisal Of Research Essay Example Paper.docxCritical Appraisal Of Research Essay Example Paper.docx
Critical Appraisal Of Research Essay Example Paper.docx
 
Evidence based periodontology
Evidence based periodontology Evidence based periodontology
Evidence based periodontology
 
Level of Evidence- Dina Hudiya Nadana Lubis.pptx
Level of Evidence- Dina Hudiya Nadana Lubis.pptxLevel of Evidence- Dina Hudiya Nadana Lubis.pptx
Level of Evidence- Dina Hudiya Nadana Lubis.pptx
 
Comparative Effectiveness Research
Comparative Effectiveness ResearchComparative Effectiveness Research
Comparative Effectiveness Research
 

Medical Studies What Can You Believe

  • 1. How to Evaluate New Medical Treatments Mark Perloe, M.D. www.ivf.com
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.

Notes de l'éditeur

  1. The costs of medical care are rising sharply, yet we know that not all common or expensive procedures are necessary, and some may be harmful. Wide variations in the outcomes of medical care have been observed between different centres and different individual clinicians. Patients and their advocates are becoming more informed, more aware that they have (or should have) choices, and more vocal in seeking to make informed choices. Clinicians, health care managers, and, increasingly, lawyers, acknowledge that decision making in health care should involve the patient and be based on best evidence of effectiveness and harm. Comprehensive lists of published research papers, indexed electronically and accessible via standard search techniques, have become available at little or no cost over the internet. Statistical tools, especially those of meta-analysis, are better understood and more widely used. Hence, precise and cumulative estimates of effectiveness and harm tend now to be published soon after the relevant trials are complete. The discipline of critical appraisal (evaluating research papers for their validity and relevance) has evolved and become both more rigorous and more accessible to the non-expert through the publication of basic guides and structured checklists.
  2. Assignment of individuals is randomized RCT: Individuals similar at the beginning RCOT: Prospective analytical, susceptible to bias if carry over effects occur Observational: allocation or assignement is not under investigator control; weaker potential evidence; potential for large confounding variables Cohort: prospective, follow-up period to determine effect of exposure and outcome, stronger than case-control but more expensive Case-Control: retrospective, secondary data from chart review, useful for rare conditions, inexpensive, many forms of bias Cross-Sectional: descriptive study of relationship between factors at one point in time Case-Series: series of cases, lack of comparability, source of hypothesis, most common study type Case-Report: anecdotal evidence,
  3. Scientific enquiry has never been, and never will be, independent of prevailing political, ideological, economic and technological forces