SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  16
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
NAIMAN CLARKE
IN-HOUSE SURVEY
                         2010




              The best legal opportunities
NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010


    1. INTRODUCTION AND METHODOLOGY


    Unlike many developed economies Australia has been fortunate in sidestepping a technical recession,
    but while a sense of optimism is returning to economic commentary recent events indicate that a return to
    robust growth is still a way off.
    The Global Financial Crisis has tested many businesses and their In-house legal departments like few
    events in recent history. The inaugural Naiman Clarke In-house Legal Practice Survey looks at the effects
    of the downturn on In-house legal practices and sheds some light on how In-house counsel can best
    manage their people and practice through difficult financial times, whilst building a strong foundation for the
    future.



    Research Objectives
    The Naiman Clarke In-house Survey is based on in-depth and national research. To be released annually,
    the report will analyse a range of issues affecting In-house legal practices throughout Australia.
    The research for the 2009/10 report was conducted with the following objectives in mind:
    • To gain an understanding of the challenges faced by In-house legal practitioners
      during the GFC.
    • To explore any changes to the practices mix of In-house legal counsel brought
      about as the result of the Global Financial Crisis.
    • To explore whether the GFC has had any effect on the outsourcing practices of in
      house legal departments, and if so in what way.
    • To investigate the human resource management practices of In-house legal
      departments including hiring intentions, retention strategies and remuneration
      practices.
    • To explore the views of In-house counsel on the economic outlook for Australia in
      general and their industry sector in particular.


    Research Methodology

    The research was carried out by conducting in depth one-on-one interviews with senior In-house lawyers
    across a range of industries. An explorative research technique was chosen because it offered a variety of
    benefits including flexibility (with the researcher being able to ask questions and collect data on a variety of
    topics), and the ability to collect highly detailed data from the subject giving the researcher access to high
    quality information.
    Participants from a range of key industries
    across small (under 100 employees), medium                       Naiman Clarke In-house Legal
    (100-200 employees), and large (200 or more                      Practice Survey...sheds some
    employees) enterprises were surveyed. Due                        light on how In-house counsel can
    to time constraints we were precluded from
    using some of the more time consuming and
                                                                     best manage their people and
    complex probability sampling methods and in                      practice through difficult financial
    these circumstances non-probability sampling                     times, whilst building a strong
    methods such as convenience and snow-ball                        foundation for the future.
    sampling were employed.




2
NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010




For the 2009 survey participants from 17 core industry sectors as detailed below were surveyed.
•       Advertising/Marketing/Media
•       Automotive
•       Construction/Property/Engineering
•       Commodities
•       Education
•       Financial Services/Insurance
•       FMCG
•       Government
•       Information Technology
•       Manufacturing
•       Mining/Resources
•       Professional Services
•       Property
•       Retail
•       Telecommunications
•       Transport/Logistics
•       Wholesale/Distribution
The participants were part of legal departments that ranged in size from 3 to 40 lawyers with an
average team size of six lawyers and two support staff.




                                             Participants from a range of key
                                             industries across small (under
                                             100 employees), medium (100-
                                             200 employees), and large (200
                                             or more employees) enterprises
                                             were surveyed.




                                                                                                           3
NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010


    2. ECONOMIC OUTLOOK


    Economic Prospects
    Respondents were asked their views about the outlook for the Australian economy in general and their industry
    sector in particular. The survey participants were generally optimistic about the Australian economy in 2010 but
    with the exception of a small minority they were not overly bullish.
    The overwhelming feeling was that while there are some green shoots it is unlikely that we will see a quick
    recovery and that it may take until 2012 for the economy to fully recover. Almost universally respondents felt
    that the global economy will continue to do it tough over the next twelve to twenty four months but that the local
    economy would fare better.
    The overall sentiment was caution
    summarised by comments such as “while
    I have a cautiously optimistic outlook there
    is a lot of complexity, we are in uncharted
    waters and not taking anything for granted”
    and “I would express my feeling as
    conservative optimism, I want to believe
    that the worst is over”. There was an
    overwhelming feeling that there is “still some
    pain to come in some sectors”.



                                                             “A lot of the negativity is starting to ease.
                                                             I think it’s going to go up from here and
                                                             come back as quickly as it went away”

    Shape of Recovery
    Most respondents felt that a return to robust growth was unlikely until liquidity returned to global financial
    markets, but while many believed that this was likely in 2010 they were not sure to what extent or how quickly
    the recovery would take place.
    There was a wide divergence of opinion on when the economy would recover as well as the shape of the
    recovery. Opinions were fairly evenly divided between those that expected a “U” shaped recovery and the
    more optimistic respondents who were expecting a “V” shaped recovery. This divergence of opinion is best
    exemplified by the following statements from respondents:


        “I am not a financial expert but it feels like we have hit the bottom but I am not sure about the
       shape of the recovery”
       “We have hit the bottom but the bottom takes a while to play out and in these circumstances
       we are likely to see a parabolic [U shaped] recovery”
       “We are likely to see a moderate recovery, Australia is better placed than other countries but I
       am not sure whether there will be a double dip”
       “I think we are seeing a return to some pretty strong fundamentals but it will probably take a
       good while to get back up to the levels we were operating at previously”
       “I am not sure when it will take off but when it does take off it will take off like crazy”




4
NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010




Shape of Recovery (Continued)
The most common economic concerns were the employment outlook, the likely impact of rising interest rates
on the shape of the economic recovery and continuing unrealistic asset valuations exemplified by the following
comments:

   “While the decline seems to have slowed or stopped I am not convinced that we are going to
   see a significant upturn in the global economy in the short term. I feel we are likely to see a U
   shaped recovery with some pain yet to come. My greatest concern is the hidden jobless in the
   economy, the people who are not showing up in the statistics at this stage but who may struggle
   to find work in the future”
   “We are expecting challenging conditions over the next twelve months ... [due to the] ...
   uncertainty in the manufacturing and commodities sectors, vagaries in exchange rates and the
   global economy, in the macro economy the pain to consumers is still to come as interest rates
   return no long term levels when the economy improves”.
   “I think that the veracity of asset valuations is still questionable and to me this says that
   fundamentally nothing has changed, we have still not learned the lessons of the GFC”
   “While corporate profits which are the primary drivers of share markets have recovered a bit,
   balance sheets still contain a lot of overvalued assets and until this is remedied we can continue
   to expect volatility in the financial markets”.

When it came to discussing prospects for their own industry a majority of respondents felt next year would see
a modest improvement, even participants whose industry had not been adversely affected during the GFC
expressed some caution. The sentiment ranged from a decreasing decline to modest growth as summarised by
comments from respondents such as:

   “Our organisation is budgeting for a decreasing decline in trade volumes in 2010, we are
   cautiously optimistic that we can begin to rebuild our business in 2011”
   “Manufacturing will bounce along the bottom for a while, domestic housing will improve a little
   but interest rates will have an impact”
   “While liquidity is returning to credit markets the improvement is slow and it is still difficult for
   entrepreneurs to get finance. I think it’s going to take a while to return to normal operating levels”
   “The GFC has had a big impact on ... [our] ... industry due to the issues in the finance industry,
   we expect the next 12 months to be steady with modest growth”
   “The prospects for our industry are very much dependent on the preparedness of banks to
   start lending again, at the moment the banks are imposing very strict conditions”
   “I do not believe we are going to see a decline in the domestic market but 30% of our revenue
   comes from international customers and we may see some pressure in that area”

Perhaps unsurprisingly, most confidence was shown by legal counsel in the finical services sector but even here
there was a fair degree of caution.



                                                                                                                  5
NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010


    3. CHANGE TO PRACTICAL MIX


    One might generally expect that during times of serious economic hardship the practice mix of In-house legal
    departments is likely to change. The survey reveals that both the nature and extent of the changes resulting
    from the impact of the Global Financial Crisis have not been in line with expectations. Most notably the survey
    indicates that there has not been a large increase in disputes but finance related transactions appeared to be on
    the up.

       “While we have seen more dispute resolution and insolvency based work it has not been a
       huge change in those areas, but we have seen a substantial increase in finance related work”.
       “Disputes have actually dropped but this is not the result of economic circumstances but the
       manner in which we have handled disputes”

    Many respondents reported only a small decrease in deal related transactions. “Our practice mix has changed
    but not as much or necessarily in the ways I imagined, while we have seen an increase in restructuring work
    there has also been lots of new business as well”.
    As might be expected, bearing in mind the speed at which most businesses moved to reduce headcount, the
    increased focus on productivity as well as recent changes to industrial relations legislations, there has been an
    increase in employment and industrial relations type work. “We have seen more work in the HR space as the
    result of the business ratcheting up performance expectations”.
    Other changes are summarised by the following responses:

       “In past cycles I had noticed a change in the practice mix towards insolvency type
       transactions (debt recovery, liens etc) and disputes generally increasing, but despite the
       current hard times we are still doing a lot of contracts”
       “There hasn’t really been a change in practice mix, we were expecting it but it didn’t really
       happen”
       “We have seen less large transactions such as M&A and large supply agreements ... [but on
       the flip side] ... there has been an increase in restructuring agreements and an increase in
       technology in some parts of the business”

    In the Financial Services and Insurance sectors the GFC has led to an increased focus on compliance work
    and perhaps unsurprisingly, these are the sectors that saw the biggest trend towards an increase in litigation.



                                                              “We have seen more work in
                                                              the HR space as the result
                                                              of the business ratcheting up
                                                              performance expectations.”




6
NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010


4. CHALLENGES


As might be expected In-house lawyers deal with a range of business and professional challenges. The results
of the 2009 survey indicate that in addition to the common challenges normally facing In-house legal practices
(e.g. the requirement to deal with new regulation) there were a number of new challenges arising specifically
from the economic conditions created as the result of the global economic downturn including the increased
focus on corporate governance as well as the challenge of dealing with GFC related resource constraints.




                               “For us the greatest challenge has been the diversity of work.
                               We are expected to be experts on just about everything.”



Doing more with less

When asked about their biggest challenges over the last twelve months the most common response was the
requirement to do more with less as the result of cost constraints exemplified by comments from the following
respondents:

   “We are not splashing the cash anymore, our budgets are under increasing pressure,
   corporate is asking us to do more with less”
   “Our biggest challenge is doing more with the same resources, getting the ship in order
   during an economic downturn requires more legal work but with no extra resources”
   “Providing legal services with insufficient resources is always a challenge”
   “We are dealing with cost pressures but are still responsible for delivering a quality outcome”
   “There has been a huge amount of work created by the market conditions and regulatory
   changes but because of headcount freezes in our company we have been expected to do
   more work with less resources”

Even legal counsel supporting businesses that were not affected by the economic downturn were forced to
deal with a reduction in spending. “Since the financial crisis we have seen some pulling back of discretionary
expenditure, it’s more a case of being cautious rather than the affect of financial circumstances”.
A bi-product of the reduction in resources available to legal departments was that lawyers were sometimes
required to advise in areas where they may not have sufficient expertise. “For us the greatest challenge has
been the diversity of work. We are expected to be experts on just about everything”.



Raising Finance

As might be expected many businesses were dealing with financing pressures arising from the reduction in
liquidity in the credit markets. “While liquidity is starting to return to credit markets the process is slow and it is
still difficult for entrepreneurs to raise finance. Consequently refinancing existing debt and raising new capital
has been difficult in a challenging business environment”. These pressures were also having an impact on
organisations that did not rely on financial markets to raise finance. “The greatest challenge for us is continued
funding, it is becoming harder to get funding from government”.




                                                                                                                          7
NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010




    Regulatory Changes
    The challenge of dealing with new legislation continues to be one of the most common challenges In-house
    lawyers are dealing with:

       “We are preparing for new legislation that is likely to have a significant impact on our industry
       sector. The challenge will be planning for something where we are unsure of the details, so it’s
       a bit like gazing into a crystal ball”
       “Working effectively with regulators is one of the greatest challenges facing our business at
       the moment. It seems that each regulator is very different in style and approach. Being the
       interface between the regulator and the business is an ongoing challenge”
       “We operate in a highly regulated environment dealing with FOI issues, State privacy
       legislation and regulatory oversight from the ombudsman and ICAC and this is a continuing
       challenge for our practice”
       “We are bracing for the legal challenge of dealing with new legislation coming at the end of
       the year”
       “One of the greatest challenges we face is changing regulation, the ability of a change in
       regulation to have a substantial impact on shareholder value”
       “The new government is trying to prove itself by introducing a raft of new legislation to position
       itself as a friend of the consumer. This increases the compliance burden on businesses”.


    Other GFC Related Business Challenges
    When asked to comment on the challenges facing their business the concerns cited included continued margin
    pressure in spite of the general economic recovery, asset values (a number of respondents felt there were still a
    lot of overvalued assets in the market), a slow recovery and the state of the international economy. The following
    comments summarise the most common issues:

       “Our clients are more sophisticated about how they use our services. They have started to
       differentiate among our product offerings in order to save costs. Specifically they are choosing
       less premium products to save money”
       “One of our greatest challenges is declining margins due to a change in product mix caused by
       the GFC”
       “The GFC is unprecedented in terms of the pressure it put on management, advisors and
       boards”
       “Our greatest challenge has been caused by cost cutting & downsizing over the last 12 months.
       The result is a loss of knowledge, momentum & organisational memory of the people who leave”
       “Supporting a business which is under great pressure in the market is always a challenge as is
       dealing with performance and HR issues which are associated with an economic downturn”



8
NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010




Non-GFC related challenges
While GFC related challenges featured highly in this year’s survey there were also a number of issues which
represent continuing challenges for In-house lawyers raised by respondents. These included “understanding the
company and the people and what makes them tick”, managing the expectations of internal clients. “Managing
client expectations is always a challenge. Many internal clients come to the legal department expecting a yes/no
answer and this is often not possible”, and the pressure not to stand in the way of the businesses transactions is
“an ever present challenge for In-house lawyers”.

In the financial services sector the increased focus on compliance was a commonly cited challenge. “Everyone
has raised expectations of the level of risk analysis we are expected to conduct”.




“Everyone has raised expectations of the level of risk analysis we are expected to conduct.”




                                                                                                                     9
NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010


     5. OUTSOURCING


     Few would argue that it would be impossible to effectively run an In-house legal practice without some
     assistance from external legal providers. For this reason, the effective management of outsourcing practices is a
     key area of competency for In-house legal counsel. For the 2009/10 survey respondents were asked their views
     on a range of topics dealing with the issue of outsourcing including the types of matters typically outsourced, the
     impact of the GFC on outsourcing practices as well as their approach to a number of costing models for legal
     services emerging in the marketplace.



     Type of work outsourced
     When asked to comment on the types of matters typically outsourced to external legal providers the majority of
     respondents stated that they were most likely to outsource matters based on their size and strategic importance
     to the business, matters that involved a high risk to the business or had the capacity to have a negative
     reputational impact on the business, and matters in specialized areas of the law. The following responses were
     typical:

        “We outsource non-routine work such as litigation, major M&A and capital raising”
        “We tend to outsource the legally complex matters that we do not have the time or resources
        to handle effectively In-house”
        “It depends on the size of the transaction and how business critical it is”
        “We outsource complicated and high risk matters as well as resource intensive project work”
        “We only outsource work that is significant from a risk or reputational perspective”


     Budgets
     Many legal departments were under pressure to reduce spend on external legal counsel. This was more
     likely to be the case for local affiliates of multi-national corporations:

        “We’re under pressure to reduce external legal costs which we have adapted to in a number of
        ways including keeping more work In-house & negotiating better fees with the firms that we use”
        “The message in our company globally was to reduce costs, to go to the firms and try to reduce
        rates by 10%”
        “Even though there is pressure to reduce costs, I have taken the attitude that it is better to work
        collaboratively with external firms on the issue of fee reduction”
        “There has been some fairly aggressive discounting in the United States and that has resulted
        in some pressure for us to reduce costs in Australia and as a result we have had to make some
        adjustments”
        “The legal department has been under pressure to reduce outsourcing costs as part of a global
        policy of cost cutting. We have looked at both how much work we outsource and who we use
        and have started to use lower tier firms to reduce costs”




10
NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010




Budgets (Continued)
Even lawyers working at organisations which did not have a specific policy of reducing external legal spend were
more likely to look more closely at their outsourcing strategies as part of organisation wide cost cutting initiatives.
The following comments were indicative of the general mood:

   “We have become more vigilant with pricing and more diligent on querying fee estimates”
   “I have become increasingly reluctant to send work externally”
   “We are always looking at reducing costs by driving efficiencies”
   “We have had pressure applied internally to reduce fees to outsourced providers, this has
   come at a time when the amount of work we outsource has dropped significantly because
   there have been less projects on and we are trying to do more In-house”
   “We are reducing our outsourcing spend by increasing the size of our team”.

One of the most common strategies used to reduce external legal spend has been the rationalisation of external
legal panels:

   “Our number one goal globally has been to reduce the number of firms we use around the
   world as part of an initiative to decrease outsourcing of legal work”.
   “One of the KPI’s introduced into our organisation over the last couple of years has been the
   reduction of legal expenditure. We have been able to reduce expenditure by almost twenty
   five per cent by bringing as much legal work as possible In-house and consolidating our
   panel – we took a large informal panel and formalised it as well as introducing restrictions on
   who could brief out to the panel”.

Other commonly employed strategies to reduce external legal spend were “going down a tier” i.e. moving some or
all work from top to medium tier suppliers and looking at non traditional fee arrangements for commoditised work:


   “While we have now tasked our external providers to reduce their hourly rates, we are much
   more sensitive to the resourcing of matters. We are open to and encourage lawyers to come
   up with different approaches to pricing such as fixed fee arrangements and risk sharing
   approaches involving success fees”
    “It often comes down to the relationship with and confidence in the legal service provider
   when it comes to dealing with the bigger matters. In respect of the more commoditised work
   where we believe there is room for improved efficiencies we have made some adjustments by
   encouraging innovation in legal service delivery and cost models”
   “To address the challenge of doing more with less resources we have moved from using the
   top tier firms to mid size firms, we have also moved to retainer based, fixed fee and capped fee
   models”
   “We have stopped using the top tier firms because at medium firms we are allocated a partner
   at the same price as solicitors in top tier firms”



                                                                                                                          11
NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010




     Budgets (Continued)
        “We are going through a RFI at the moment and looking at blending fixed rate fee
        arrangements on some matters and the value add that firms can provide”
         “We have tiered our legal suppliers, as part of this initiative we have defined the
        commoditised work and taken this away from our top tier suppliers”



                                                                                          “We have
                                                                                          reshuffled
                                                                                          our panel
                                                                                          and used
                                                                                          this as an
                                                                                          opportunity
                                                                                          to drive
                                                                                          down rates.”




     While a high proportion of respondents were focusing on reducing external legal spend a statistically significant
     number were not planning on a reduction, or in some cases, due to expected activity in the following year
     actually planned to increase spending:


        “Our company has been more focused on headcount than external legal spending so there
        has been no change in outsourcing planned and our budgets for external legal expenditure
        have remained the same as last year”
        “Our budget for legal services next year is doubling due to deregulation and an increase in
        trade”
        “We are actually planning to increase our legal spend next year due to the number of ... [new
        products] ... expected to come on line next year”.

     Another interesting finding was that more than a third of respondents (37%) did not have a formal budget
     for external legal expenditure. “We do not budget for external legal counsel. While our spending is relatively
     constant on a year to year basis we do not feel it is necessary to set an arbitrary figure for external legal spend”.




12
NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010




Fee Arrangements
There does not appear to have been across the board                       The lawyers we use
pressure on hourly rates of law firms as the result of the GFC
and while there was evidence of fee reduction from some
                                                                          have come to us
external providers there does not appear to have been a                   and been proactive
widespread or systematic focus on fee reduction among law                 in sharpening the
firms providing services to respondents in an effort to win new           pencil and are
business, it appears that any fee reductions that have taken
place were design to retain existing business.                            working harder to
There is also evidence that external providers are trying to              retain our business
use economies of scale and improved internal efficiencies to
provide improved savings to their clients. This appears to be
a response to an increasing trend to avoid the outsourcing of
the more routine work by In-house legal departments.




   “A few firms approached us directly to offer reduced or fixed fee arrangements”
   “We are open to and encourage lawyers to come up with different approaches to pricing such
   as fixed fee arrangements and success fees with risk sharing”
   “We have moved to a fixed fee model for debt recovery”.


While In-house lawyers generally feel that time costing is not the most efficient way to resource matters there is
a general consensus that there are few effective alternatives available in the market at present and that value as
opposed to price is the primary driver in determining choice of provider.


   “The hourly charging model is flawed but in many cases there is no better alternative”
   “We still engage lawyers on an hourly rates basis, if you want fixed pricing there is going to
   be a contingency built unless they are desperate and that is not the type of firm we are likely
   to engage because of the specialist nature of the advice we are seeking”
   “Some law firms have offered us discounted fees but at the end of the day we are looking
   at value for money arising from efficient processes and this does not always come from the
   firms with the lowest hourly rates”
   “The more complex the work, the greater the risk and impact on shareholder value the less
   likely you are to look at price as a determinant and select the service provider based on
   quality”.




                                                                                                                     13
NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010


  6. HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT PRACTICES


  Hiring Intentions
  Most respondents said they planned to keep team size the same with no plans to grow. No respondent
  expressed an intention to reduce their team size. Approximately 15% of respondents were looking at
  growing their team with the majority of these being from the financial services sector or from businesses
  that had not been severely impacted by the GFC.

     “We have head count freezes even though we are expecting work to increase with the
     arrival of new [products]”
     “We are looking at adding to our team but this is dependent on business sign off”
     “There’s scope for growth in the legal team in the next 12-18 months as the business has
     plans for growth”
     “We expect an increase in the size and capabilities of the legal, risk and compliance team”.


  Remuneration Practices
  Unsurprisingly most respondents revealed that their
  organisation was not offering any significant salary
  increases to the legal team. The exceptions were
  at the lower PQE levels where junior lawyers were
  receiving market increases as the result of their
  increasing seniority, these increases were designed
  to avoid a growing gap between private practice and
  In-house remuneration models.
  Bonuses were still being used to reward outstanding            “We haven’t had across the board salary
  performance even with increased pressures on
  costs resulting from the GFC with about one third of
                                                                 freezes but both salary reviews and
  respondents stating that bonuses had been paid to              bonuses were paid out at a lower level”
  the top performers.


     “Companywide there were performance reviews but our organisation instituted an executive
     pay freeze which included the legal team, but fortunately we were able to reward outstanding
     performance with bonuses”
     “Salary reviews for legal were in line with the rest of the company and while the volume and
     complexity of work have not decreased in our department market pressures do get taken into
     account when reviewing salaries”
     “There’s been a companywide freeze on pay and no bonuses paid, the legal team has been
     treated the same”
     “There has been a salary freeze across most areas of the company but this did not apply to
     shared services which includes the legal team”
     “Legal salaries are tightening up globally in line with the rest of the business but we are still
     using bonuses to reward top performers”
NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010




Remuneration Practices (Continued)
  “While officially our organisation has instituted salary freezes the top performers have still been
  looked after with salary reviews”
  “Juniors have been treated differently salary increases are based on market at the lower PQE
  levels”


Career Progression/Retention
Managing the career progression expectations of junior lawyers was one of the greatest human capital
management issues faced by In-house legal departments (especially in the smaller teams). While a range
of tools were employed by far and away the most common strategies were providing opportunities for
lawyers to develop their career by moving into the business and using remuneration policies to retain staff.

  “We have a flat structure in the department and manage career progression by giving our
  lawyers an opportunity to move into the business”
  “One way to keep people is to pay competitively, we try to pay the same as law firms”
  “Because of the size of our team, moving into non-legal roles is the most common way
  lawyers in our department progress”




            “There will be no raises but bonuses will still be paid out to the top performers.”


                                                                                                          15
ABOUT NAIMAN CLARKE                                           ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Naiman Clarke was established in 1999, and since              Johnothan Naiman is a qualified lawyer having
this time has been driven by the desire to be the             practiced as a solicitor, barrister and In-house counsel.
best specialised legal recruiter in Australia. We have        In addition to his legal qualifications, Johnothan has
always believed that the only way to achieve this goal        completed a Masters of Business Administration and is
is to consistently deliver results by providing creative      currently studying towards his Masters of Commerce.
solutions that exceed the expectation of clients and          As the CEO of Naiman Clarke Johnothan regularly
candidates.                                                   provides advice and assistance to some of Australia’s
Naiman Clarke is now one of the largest, most                 leading law firms and In-house practices on a wide
knowledgeable and most experienced niche                      range of employment and HR issues. Johnothan has
consultancies in the country. We strive to provide our        held a number of senior positions prior to his current
clients with an additional resource in all aspects of their   role including the Head of Legal Services, South
human capital management needs. Our integrated                Pacific Region at Avaya Inc, and was a member of
service offering covers all aspects of recruitment,           the Executive Management team of Candle Australia
training and development, performance management              Limited (Australia’s second largest listed recruiter) as
and remuneration planning.                                    General Counsel and Commercial Manager.

Our comprehensive range of services includes:
• Permanent and Temporary Recruitment Services
• Search and Selection
• HR Consulting and other professional services
• Training
• Psychometric testing
Our clients include blue chip multinational corporations,
multi disciplinary practices, government, top and mid
tier capital city firms as well as numerous boutique
firms both in Australia and overseas.
Naiman Clarke has offices in Sydney and Melbourne
where dedicated consultants provide recruitment
services for clients in Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane,
Canberra, Perth, Adelaide and Darwin. Our
international consultants provide Australian candidates
access to some of the leading international and local
firms in the United Kingdom, United States, Europe,
Asia and the Middle East.




   The best legal opportunities

Contenu connexe

Similaire à 2010 naiman clarke in house market report

2016 Australia - State of the Legal Market FINAL.PDF
2016 Australia - State of the Legal Market FINAL.PDF2016 Australia - State of the Legal Market FINAL.PDF
2016 Australia - State of the Legal Market FINAL.PDFBarolsky Advisors Pty Ltd
 
Justifying Physical Security
Justifying Physical SecurityJustifying Physical Security
Justifying Physical SecurityJames McDonald
 
Matthew Gaude – Proactive Advisor Magazine – Volume 6, Issue 10
Matthew Gaude – Proactive Advisor Magazine – Volume 6, Issue 10Matthew Gaude – Proactive Advisor Magazine – Volume 6, Issue 10
Matthew Gaude – Proactive Advisor Magazine – Volume 6, Issue 10Proactive Advisor Magazine
 
Summer training report
Summer training reportSummer training report
Summer training reportNavneet Malhi
 
Microsoft Presentation
Microsoft PresentationMicrosoft Presentation
Microsoft PresentationBilgi MBA 2.0
 
Rules of Thumb for a Volatile Market
Rules of Thumb for a Volatile MarketRules of Thumb for a Volatile Market
Rules of Thumb for a Volatile MarketMarqus J Freeman
 
retirement-matters (Stephen Huppert's take on Australian's attitudes to later...
retirement-matters (Stephen Huppert's take on Australian's attitudes to later...retirement-matters (Stephen Huppert's take on Australian's attitudes to later...
retirement-matters (Stephen Huppert's take on Australian's attitudes to later...Henry Tapper
 
Citi grant teacher training-new normal presentation-o'neill-06-11
Citi grant teacher training-new normal presentation-o'neill-06-11Citi grant teacher training-new normal presentation-o'neill-06-11
Citi grant teacher training-new normal presentation-o'neill-06-11Barbara O'Neill
 
Bo Becker: "Corporate credit and business cycles"
Bo Becker: "Corporate credit and business cycles"Bo Becker: "Corporate credit and business cycles"
Bo Becker: "Corporate credit and business cycles"Global Utmaning
 
New Horizons in SF
New Horizons in SFNew Horizons in SF
New Horizons in SFErik Kolb
 
OFIP Q3 2010 - A Case For Optimism
OFIP Q3 2010 - A Case For OptimismOFIP Q3 2010 - A Case For Optimism
OFIP Q3 2010 - A Case For Optimismbwoyat
 
Grant Thornton IPO Crisis And More
Grant Thornton IPO Crisis And MoreGrant Thornton IPO Crisis And More
Grant Thornton IPO Crisis And Morefnapoli
 
Turn Crisis Into Advantage By Effective Crisis Management
Turn Crisis Into Advantage By Effective Crisis ManagementTurn Crisis Into Advantage By Effective Crisis Management
Turn Crisis Into Advantage By Effective Crisis ManagementRahat Kazmi
 

Similaire à 2010 naiman clarke in house market report (20)

2016 Australia - State of the Legal Market FINAL.PDF
2016 Australia - State of the Legal Market FINAL.PDF2016 Australia - State of the Legal Market FINAL.PDF
2016 Australia - State of the Legal Market FINAL.PDF
 
Justifying Physical Security
Justifying Physical SecurityJustifying Physical Security
Justifying Physical Security
 
Matthew Gaude – Proactive Advisor Magazine – Volume 6, Issue 10
Matthew Gaude – Proactive Advisor Magazine – Volume 6, Issue 10Matthew Gaude – Proactive Advisor Magazine – Volume 6, Issue 10
Matthew Gaude – Proactive Advisor Magazine – Volume 6, Issue 10
 
Summer training report
Summer training reportSummer training report
Summer training report
 
Microsoft Presentation
Microsoft PresentationMicrosoft Presentation
Microsoft Presentation
 
Webinar Slides 16mar Final Changing Financial Landscape
Webinar Slides 16mar Final Changing Financial LandscapeWebinar Slides 16mar Final Changing Financial Landscape
Webinar Slides 16mar Final Changing Financial Landscape
 
Rules of Thumb for a Volatile Market
Rules of Thumb for a Volatile MarketRules of Thumb for a Volatile Market
Rules of Thumb for a Volatile Market
 
retirement-matters (Stephen Huppert's take on Australian's attitudes to later...
retirement-matters (Stephen Huppert's take on Australian's attitudes to later...retirement-matters (Stephen Huppert's take on Australian's attitudes to later...
retirement-matters (Stephen Huppert's take on Australian's attitudes to later...
 
Citi grant teacher training-new normal presentation-o'neill-06-11
Citi grant teacher training-new normal presentation-o'neill-06-11Citi grant teacher training-new normal presentation-o'neill-06-11
Citi grant teacher training-new normal presentation-o'neill-06-11
 
Bo Becker: "Corporate credit and business cycles"
Bo Becker: "Corporate credit and business cycles"Bo Becker: "Corporate credit and business cycles"
Bo Becker: "Corporate credit and business cycles"
 
Laurence simon salary survey 2011/2012
Laurence simon salary survey 2011/2012Laurence simon salary survey 2011/2012
Laurence simon salary survey 2011/2012
 
Q3 2013 Newsletter
Q3 2013 NewsletterQ3 2013 Newsletter
Q3 2013 Newsletter
 
Create2014
Create2014Create2014
Create2014
 
New Horizons in SF
New Horizons in SFNew Horizons in SF
New Horizons in SF
 
@GRIAusConf_Plenary Panel: The Role of Reporting In The Transition To A Susta...
@GRIAusConf_Plenary Panel: The Role of Reporting In The Transition To A Susta...@GRIAusConf_Plenary Panel: The Role of Reporting In The Transition To A Susta...
@GRIAusConf_Plenary Panel: The Role of Reporting In The Transition To A Susta...
 
OFIP Q3 2010 - A Case For Optimism
OFIP Q3 2010 - A Case For OptimismOFIP Q3 2010 - A Case For Optimism
OFIP Q3 2010 - A Case For Optimism
 
Business Cycle Essay
Business Cycle EssayBusiness Cycle Essay
Business Cycle Essay
 
Grant Thornton IPO Crisis And More
Grant Thornton IPO Crisis And MoreGrant Thornton IPO Crisis And More
Grant Thornton IPO Crisis And More
 
March 2020 Investment Commentary
March 2020 Investment CommentaryMarch 2020 Investment Commentary
March 2020 Investment Commentary
 
Turn Crisis Into Advantage By Effective Crisis Management
Turn Crisis Into Advantage By Effective Crisis ManagementTurn Crisis Into Advantage By Effective Crisis Management
Turn Crisis Into Advantage By Effective Crisis Management
 

Dernier

Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation SlidesKeppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation SlidesKeppelCorporation
 
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...lizamodels9
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckHajeJanKamps
 
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptxContemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptxMarkAnthonyAurellano
 
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...lizamodels9
 
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,noida100girls
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...lizamodels9
 
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...ssuserf63bd7
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Shivaji Enclave Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Shivaji Enclave Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Shivaji Enclave Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Shivaji Enclave Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdfInnovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdfrichard876048
 
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detailCase study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detailAriel592675
 
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In.../:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...lizamodels9
 
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City GurgaonCall Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaoncallgirls2057
 
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607dollysharma2066
 
NewBase 19 April 2024 Energy News issue - 1717 by Khaled Al Awadi.pdf
NewBase  19 April  2024  Energy News issue - 1717 by Khaled Al Awadi.pdfNewBase  19 April  2024  Energy News issue - 1717 by Khaled Al Awadi.pdf
NewBase 19 April 2024 Energy News issue - 1717 by Khaled Al Awadi.pdfKhaled Al Awadi
 
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted VersionFuture Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted VersionMintel Group
 
Organizational Structure Running A Successful Business
Organizational Structure Running A Successful BusinessOrganizational Structure Running A Successful Business
Organizational Structure Running A Successful BusinessSeta Wicaksana
 
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...lizamodels9
 

Dernier (20)

Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation SlidesKeppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
 
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...
Call Girls In Radisson Blu Hotel New Delhi Paschim Vihar ❤️8860477959 Escorts...
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Geodesic.Life's $500k Pre-seed deck
 
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptxContemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
 
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...
 
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
Lowrate Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Servi...
 
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Shivaji Enclave Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Shivaji Enclave Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Shivaji Enclave Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Shivaji Enclave Delhi NCR
 
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdfInnovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
 
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detailCase study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
 
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In.../:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...
/:Call Girls In Indirapuram Ghaziabad ➥9990211544 Independent Best Escorts In...
 
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City GurgaonCall Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
Call Us 📲8800102216📞 Call Girls In DLF City Gurgaon
 
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
 
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
 
NewBase 19 April 2024 Energy News issue - 1717 by Khaled Al Awadi.pdf
NewBase  19 April  2024  Energy News issue - 1717 by Khaled Al Awadi.pdfNewBase  19 April  2024  Energy News issue - 1717 by Khaled Al Awadi.pdf
NewBase 19 April 2024 Energy News issue - 1717 by Khaled Al Awadi.pdf
 
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted VersionFuture Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
 
Corporate Profile 47Billion Information Technology
Corporate Profile 47Billion Information TechnologyCorporate Profile 47Billion Information Technology
Corporate Profile 47Billion Information Technology
 
Organizational Structure Running A Successful Business
Organizational Structure Running A Successful BusinessOrganizational Structure Running A Successful Business
Organizational Structure Running A Successful Business
 
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
 

2010 naiman clarke in house market report

  • 1. NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010 The best legal opportunities
  • 2. NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010 1. INTRODUCTION AND METHODOLOGY Unlike many developed economies Australia has been fortunate in sidestepping a technical recession, but while a sense of optimism is returning to economic commentary recent events indicate that a return to robust growth is still a way off. The Global Financial Crisis has tested many businesses and their In-house legal departments like few events in recent history. The inaugural Naiman Clarke In-house Legal Practice Survey looks at the effects of the downturn on In-house legal practices and sheds some light on how In-house counsel can best manage their people and practice through difficult financial times, whilst building a strong foundation for the future. Research Objectives The Naiman Clarke In-house Survey is based on in-depth and national research. To be released annually, the report will analyse a range of issues affecting In-house legal practices throughout Australia. The research for the 2009/10 report was conducted with the following objectives in mind: • To gain an understanding of the challenges faced by In-house legal practitioners during the GFC. • To explore any changes to the practices mix of In-house legal counsel brought about as the result of the Global Financial Crisis. • To explore whether the GFC has had any effect on the outsourcing practices of in house legal departments, and if so in what way. • To investigate the human resource management practices of In-house legal departments including hiring intentions, retention strategies and remuneration practices. • To explore the views of In-house counsel on the economic outlook for Australia in general and their industry sector in particular. Research Methodology The research was carried out by conducting in depth one-on-one interviews with senior In-house lawyers across a range of industries. An explorative research technique was chosen because it offered a variety of benefits including flexibility (with the researcher being able to ask questions and collect data on a variety of topics), and the ability to collect highly detailed data from the subject giving the researcher access to high quality information. Participants from a range of key industries across small (under 100 employees), medium Naiman Clarke In-house Legal (100-200 employees), and large (200 or more Practice Survey...sheds some employees) enterprises were surveyed. Due light on how In-house counsel can to time constraints we were precluded from using some of the more time consuming and best manage their people and complex probability sampling methods and in practice through difficult financial these circumstances non-probability sampling times, whilst building a strong methods such as convenience and snow-ball foundation for the future. sampling were employed. 2
  • 3. NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010 For the 2009 survey participants from 17 core industry sectors as detailed below were surveyed. • Advertising/Marketing/Media • Automotive • Construction/Property/Engineering • Commodities • Education • Financial Services/Insurance • FMCG • Government • Information Technology • Manufacturing • Mining/Resources • Professional Services • Property • Retail • Telecommunications • Transport/Logistics • Wholesale/Distribution The participants were part of legal departments that ranged in size from 3 to 40 lawyers with an average team size of six lawyers and two support staff. Participants from a range of key industries across small (under 100 employees), medium (100- 200 employees), and large (200 or more employees) enterprises were surveyed. 3
  • 4. NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010 2. ECONOMIC OUTLOOK Economic Prospects Respondents were asked their views about the outlook for the Australian economy in general and their industry sector in particular. The survey participants were generally optimistic about the Australian economy in 2010 but with the exception of a small minority they were not overly bullish. The overwhelming feeling was that while there are some green shoots it is unlikely that we will see a quick recovery and that it may take until 2012 for the economy to fully recover. Almost universally respondents felt that the global economy will continue to do it tough over the next twelve to twenty four months but that the local economy would fare better. The overall sentiment was caution summarised by comments such as “while I have a cautiously optimistic outlook there is a lot of complexity, we are in uncharted waters and not taking anything for granted” and “I would express my feeling as conservative optimism, I want to believe that the worst is over”. There was an overwhelming feeling that there is “still some pain to come in some sectors”. “A lot of the negativity is starting to ease. I think it’s going to go up from here and come back as quickly as it went away” Shape of Recovery Most respondents felt that a return to robust growth was unlikely until liquidity returned to global financial markets, but while many believed that this was likely in 2010 they were not sure to what extent or how quickly the recovery would take place. There was a wide divergence of opinion on when the economy would recover as well as the shape of the recovery. Opinions were fairly evenly divided between those that expected a “U” shaped recovery and the more optimistic respondents who were expecting a “V” shaped recovery. This divergence of opinion is best exemplified by the following statements from respondents: “I am not a financial expert but it feels like we have hit the bottom but I am not sure about the shape of the recovery” “We have hit the bottom but the bottom takes a while to play out and in these circumstances we are likely to see a parabolic [U shaped] recovery” “We are likely to see a moderate recovery, Australia is better placed than other countries but I am not sure whether there will be a double dip” “I think we are seeing a return to some pretty strong fundamentals but it will probably take a good while to get back up to the levels we were operating at previously” “I am not sure when it will take off but when it does take off it will take off like crazy” 4
  • 5. NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010 Shape of Recovery (Continued) The most common economic concerns were the employment outlook, the likely impact of rising interest rates on the shape of the economic recovery and continuing unrealistic asset valuations exemplified by the following comments: “While the decline seems to have slowed or stopped I am not convinced that we are going to see a significant upturn in the global economy in the short term. I feel we are likely to see a U shaped recovery with some pain yet to come. My greatest concern is the hidden jobless in the economy, the people who are not showing up in the statistics at this stage but who may struggle to find work in the future” “We are expecting challenging conditions over the next twelve months ... [due to the] ... uncertainty in the manufacturing and commodities sectors, vagaries in exchange rates and the global economy, in the macro economy the pain to consumers is still to come as interest rates return no long term levels when the economy improves”. “I think that the veracity of asset valuations is still questionable and to me this says that fundamentally nothing has changed, we have still not learned the lessons of the GFC” “While corporate profits which are the primary drivers of share markets have recovered a bit, balance sheets still contain a lot of overvalued assets and until this is remedied we can continue to expect volatility in the financial markets”. When it came to discussing prospects for their own industry a majority of respondents felt next year would see a modest improvement, even participants whose industry had not been adversely affected during the GFC expressed some caution. The sentiment ranged from a decreasing decline to modest growth as summarised by comments from respondents such as: “Our organisation is budgeting for a decreasing decline in trade volumes in 2010, we are cautiously optimistic that we can begin to rebuild our business in 2011” “Manufacturing will bounce along the bottom for a while, domestic housing will improve a little but interest rates will have an impact” “While liquidity is returning to credit markets the improvement is slow and it is still difficult for entrepreneurs to get finance. I think it’s going to take a while to return to normal operating levels” “The GFC has had a big impact on ... [our] ... industry due to the issues in the finance industry, we expect the next 12 months to be steady with modest growth” “The prospects for our industry are very much dependent on the preparedness of banks to start lending again, at the moment the banks are imposing very strict conditions” “I do not believe we are going to see a decline in the domestic market but 30% of our revenue comes from international customers and we may see some pressure in that area” Perhaps unsurprisingly, most confidence was shown by legal counsel in the finical services sector but even here there was a fair degree of caution. 5
  • 6. NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010 3. CHANGE TO PRACTICAL MIX One might generally expect that during times of serious economic hardship the practice mix of In-house legal departments is likely to change. The survey reveals that both the nature and extent of the changes resulting from the impact of the Global Financial Crisis have not been in line with expectations. Most notably the survey indicates that there has not been a large increase in disputes but finance related transactions appeared to be on the up. “While we have seen more dispute resolution and insolvency based work it has not been a huge change in those areas, but we have seen a substantial increase in finance related work”. “Disputes have actually dropped but this is not the result of economic circumstances but the manner in which we have handled disputes” Many respondents reported only a small decrease in deal related transactions. “Our practice mix has changed but not as much or necessarily in the ways I imagined, while we have seen an increase in restructuring work there has also been lots of new business as well”. As might be expected, bearing in mind the speed at which most businesses moved to reduce headcount, the increased focus on productivity as well as recent changes to industrial relations legislations, there has been an increase in employment and industrial relations type work. “We have seen more work in the HR space as the result of the business ratcheting up performance expectations”. Other changes are summarised by the following responses: “In past cycles I had noticed a change in the practice mix towards insolvency type transactions (debt recovery, liens etc) and disputes generally increasing, but despite the current hard times we are still doing a lot of contracts” “There hasn’t really been a change in practice mix, we were expecting it but it didn’t really happen” “We have seen less large transactions such as M&A and large supply agreements ... [but on the flip side] ... there has been an increase in restructuring agreements and an increase in technology in some parts of the business” In the Financial Services and Insurance sectors the GFC has led to an increased focus on compliance work and perhaps unsurprisingly, these are the sectors that saw the biggest trend towards an increase in litigation. “We have seen more work in the HR space as the result of the business ratcheting up performance expectations.” 6
  • 7. NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010 4. CHALLENGES As might be expected In-house lawyers deal with a range of business and professional challenges. The results of the 2009 survey indicate that in addition to the common challenges normally facing In-house legal practices (e.g. the requirement to deal with new regulation) there were a number of new challenges arising specifically from the economic conditions created as the result of the global economic downturn including the increased focus on corporate governance as well as the challenge of dealing with GFC related resource constraints. “For us the greatest challenge has been the diversity of work. We are expected to be experts on just about everything.” Doing more with less When asked about their biggest challenges over the last twelve months the most common response was the requirement to do more with less as the result of cost constraints exemplified by comments from the following respondents: “We are not splashing the cash anymore, our budgets are under increasing pressure, corporate is asking us to do more with less” “Our biggest challenge is doing more with the same resources, getting the ship in order during an economic downturn requires more legal work but with no extra resources” “Providing legal services with insufficient resources is always a challenge” “We are dealing with cost pressures but are still responsible for delivering a quality outcome” “There has been a huge amount of work created by the market conditions and regulatory changes but because of headcount freezes in our company we have been expected to do more work with less resources” Even legal counsel supporting businesses that were not affected by the economic downturn were forced to deal with a reduction in spending. “Since the financial crisis we have seen some pulling back of discretionary expenditure, it’s more a case of being cautious rather than the affect of financial circumstances”. A bi-product of the reduction in resources available to legal departments was that lawyers were sometimes required to advise in areas where they may not have sufficient expertise. “For us the greatest challenge has been the diversity of work. We are expected to be experts on just about everything”. Raising Finance As might be expected many businesses were dealing with financing pressures arising from the reduction in liquidity in the credit markets. “While liquidity is starting to return to credit markets the process is slow and it is still difficult for entrepreneurs to raise finance. Consequently refinancing existing debt and raising new capital has been difficult in a challenging business environment”. These pressures were also having an impact on organisations that did not rely on financial markets to raise finance. “The greatest challenge for us is continued funding, it is becoming harder to get funding from government”. 7
  • 8. NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010 Regulatory Changes The challenge of dealing with new legislation continues to be one of the most common challenges In-house lawyers are dealing with: “We are preparing for new legislation that is likely to have a significant impact on our industry sector. The challenge will be planning for something where we are unsure of the details, so it’s a bit like gazing into a crystal ball” “Working effectively with regulators is one of the greatest challenges facing our business at the moment. It seems that each regulator is very different in style and approach. Being the interface between the regulator and the business is an ongoing challenge” “We operate in a highly regulated environment dealing with FOI issues, State privacy legislation and regulatory oversight from the ombudsman and ICAC and this is a continuing challenge for our practice” “We are bracing for the legal challenge of dealing with new legislation coming at the end of the year” “One of the greatest challenges we face is changing regulation, the ability of a change in regulation to have a substantial impact on shareholder value” “The new government is trying to prove itself by introducing a raft of new legislation to position itself as a friend of the consumer. This increases the compliance burden on businesses”. Other GFC Related Business Challenges When asked to comment on the challenges facing their business the concerns cited included continued margin pressure in spite of the general economic recovery, asset values (a number of respondents felt there were still a lot of overvalued assets in the market), a slow recovery and the state of the international economy. The following comments summarise the most common issues: “Our clients are more sophisticated about how they use our services. They have started to differentiate among our product offerings in order to save costs. Specifically they are choosing less premium products to save money” “One of our greatest challenges is declining margins due to a change in product mix caused by the GFC” “The GFC is unprecedented in terms of the pressure it put on management, advisors and boards” “Our greatest challenge has been caused by cost cutting & downsizing over the last 12 months. The result is a loss of knowledge, momentum & organisational memory of the people who leave” “Supporting a business which is under great pressure in the market is always a challenge as is dealing with performance and HR issues which are associated with an economic downturn” 8
  • 9. NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010 Non-GFC related challenges While GFC related challenges featured highly in this year’s survey there were also a number of issues which represent continuing challenges for In-house lawyers raised by respondents. These included “understanding the company and the people and what makes them tick”, managing the expectations of internal clients. “Managing client expectations is always a challenge. Many internal clients come to the legal department expecting a yes/no answer and this is often not possible”, and the pressure not to stand in the way of the businesses transactions is “an ever present challenge for In-house lawyers”. In the financial services sector the increased focus on compliance was a commonly cited challenge. “Everyone has raised expectations of the level of risk analysis we are expected to conduct”. “Everyone has raised expectations of the level of risk analysis we are expected to conduct.” 9
  • 10. NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010 5. OUTSOURCING Few would argue that it would be impossible to effectively run an In-house legal practice without some assistance from external legal providers. For this reason, the effective management of outsourcing practices is a key area of competency for In-house legal counsel. For the 2009/10 survey respondents were asked their views on a range of topics dealing with the issue of outsourcing including the types of matters typically outsourced, the impact of the GFC on outsourcing practices as well as their approach to a number of costing models for legal services emerging in the marketplace. Type of work outsourced When asked to comment on the types of matters typically outsourced to external legal providers the majority of respondents stated that they were most likely to outsource matters based on their size and strategic importance to the business, matters that involved a high risk to the business or had the capacity to have a negative reputational impact on the business, and matters in specialized areas of the law. The following responses were typical: “We outsource non-routine work such as litigation, major M&A and capital raising” “We tend to outsource the legally complex matters that we do not have the time or resources to handle effectively In-house” “It depends on the size of the transaction and how business critical it is” “We outsource complicated and high risk matters as well as resource intensive project work” “We only outsource work that is significant from a risk or reputational perspective” Budgets Many legal departments were under pressure to reduce spend on external legal counsel. This was more likely to be the case for local affiliates of multi-national corporations: “We’re under pressure to reduce external legal costs which we have adapted to in a number of ways including keeping more work In-house & negotiating better fees with the firms that we use” “The message in our company globally was to reduce costs, to go to the firms and try to reduce rates by 10%” “Even though there is pressure to reduce costs, I have taken the attitude that it is better to work collaboratively with external firms on the issue of fee reduction” “There has been some fairly aggressive discounting in the United States and that has resulted in some pressure for us to reduce costs in Australia and as a result we have had to make some adjustments” “The legal department has been under pressure to reduce outsourcing costs as part of a global policy of cost cutting. We have looked at both how much work we outsource and who we use and have started to use lower tier firms to reduce costs” 10
  • 11. NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010 Budgets (Continued) Even lawyers working at organisations which did not have a specific policy of reducing external legal spend were more likely to look more closely at their outsourcing strategies as part of organisation wide cost cutting initiatives. The following comments were indicative of the general mood: “We have become more vigilant with pricing and more diligent on querying fee estimates” “I have become increasingly reluctant to send work externally” “We are always looking at reducing costs by driving efficiencies” “We have had pressure applied internally to reduce fees to outsourced providers, this has come at a time when the amount of work we outsource has dropped significantly because there have been less projects on and we are trying to do more In-house” “We are reducing our outsourcing spend by increasing the size of our team”. One of the most common strategies used to reduce external legal spend has been the rationalisation of external legal panels: “Our number one goal globally has been to reduce the number of firms we use around the world as part of an initiative to decrease outsourcing of legal work”. “One of the KPI’s introduced into our organisation over the last couple of years has been the reduction of legal expenditure. We have been able to reduce expenditure by almost twenty five per cent by bringing as much legal work as possible In-house and consolidating our panel – we took a large informal panel and formalised it as well as introducing restrictions on who could brief out to the panel”. Other commonly employed strategies to reduce external legal spend were “going down a tier” i.e. moving some or all work from top to medium tier suppliers and looking at non traditional fee arrangements for commoditised work: “While we have now tasked our external providers to reduce their hourly rates, we are much more sensitive to the resourcing of matters. We are open to and encourage lawyers to come up with different approaches to pricing such as fixed fee arrangements and risk sharing approaches involving success fees” “It often comes down to the relationship with and confidence in the legal service provider when it comes to dealing with the bigger matters. In respect of the more commoditised work where we believe there is room for improved efficiencies we have made some adjustments by encouraging innovation in legal service delivery and cost models” “To address the challenge of doing more with less resources we have moved from using the top tier firms to mid size firms, we have also moved to retainer based, fixed fee and capped fee models” “We have stopped using the top tier firms because at medium firms we are allocated a partner at the same price as solicitors in top tier firms” 11
  • 12. NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010 Budgets (Continued) “We are going through a RFI at the moment and looking at blending fixed rate fee arrangements on some matters and the value add that firms can provide” “We have tiered our legal suppliers, as part of this initiative we have defined the commoditised work and taken this away from our top tier suppliers” “We have reshuffled our panel and used this as an opportunity to drive down rates.” While a high proportion of respondents were focusing on reducing external legal spend a statistically significant number were not planning on a reduction, or in some cases, due to expected activity in the following year actually planned to increase spending: “Our company has been more focused on headcount than external legal spending so there has been no change in outsourcing planned and our budgets for external legal expenditure have remained the same as last year” “Our budget for legal services next year is doubling due to deregulation and an increase in trade” “We are actually planning to increase our legal spend next year due to the number of ... [new products] ... expected to come on line next year”. Another interesting finding was that more than a third of respondents (37%) did not have a formal budget for external legal expenditure. “We do not budget for external legal counsel. While our spending is relatively constant on a year to year basis we do not feel it is necessary to set an arbitrary figure for external legal spend”. 12
  • 13. NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010 Fee Arrangements There does not appear to have been across the board The lawyers we use pressure on hourly rates of law firms as the result of the GFC and while there was evidence of fee reduction from some have come to us external providers there does not appear to have been a and been proactive widespread or systematic focus on fee reduction among law in sharpening the firms providing services to respondents in an effort to win new pencil and are business, it appears that any fee reductions that have taken place were design to retain existing business. working harder to There is also evidence that external providers are trying to retain our business use economies of scale and improved internal efficiencies to provide improved savings to their clients. This appears to be a response to an increasing trend to avoid the outsourcing of the more routine work by In-house legal departments. “A few firms approached us directly to offer reduced or fixed fee arrangements” “We are open to and encourage lawyers to come up with different approaches to pricing such as fixed fee arrangements and success fees with risk sharing” “We have moved to a fixed fee model for debt recovery”. While In-house lawyers generally feel that time costing is not the most efficient way to resource matters there is a general consensus that there are few effective alternatives available in the market at present and that value as opposed to price is the primary driver in determining choice of provider. “The hourly charging model is flawed but in many cases there is no better alternative” “We still engage lawyers on an hourly rates basis, if you want fixed pricing there is going to be a contingency built unless they are desperate and that is not the type of firm we are likely to engage because of the specialist nature of the advice we are seeking” “Some law firms have offered us discounted fees but at the end of the day we are looking at value for money arising from efficient processes and this does not always come from the firms with the lowest hourly rates” “The more complex the work, the greater the risk and impact on shareholder value the less likely you are to look at price as a determinant and select the service provider based on quality”. 13
  • 14. NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010 6. HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT PRACTICES Hiring Intentions Most respondents said they planned to keep team size the same with no plans to grow. No respondent expressed an intention to reduce their team size. Approximately 15% of respondents were looking at growing their team with the majority of these being from the financial services sector or from businesses that had not been severely impacted by the GFC. “We have head count freezes even though we are expecting work to increase with the arrival of new [products]” “We are looking at adding to our team but this is dependent on business sign off” “There’s scope for growth in the legal team in the next 12-18 months as the business has plans for growth” “We expect an increase in the size and capabilities of the legal, risk and compliance team”. Remuneration Practices Unsurprisingly most respondents revealed that their organisation was not offering any significant salary increases to the legal team. The exceptions were at the lower PQE levels where junior lawyers were receiving market increases as the result of their increasing seniority, these increases were designed to avoid a growing gap between private practice and In-house remuneration models. Bonuses were still being used to reward outstanding “We haven’t had across the board salary performance even with increased pressures on costs resulting from the GFC with about one third of freezes but both salary reviews and respondents stating that bonuses had been paid to bonuses were paid out at a lower level” the top performers. “Companywide there were performance reviews but our organisation instituted an executive pay freeze which included the legal team, but fortunately we were able to reward outstanding performance with bonuses” “Salary reviews for legal were in line with the rest of the company and while the volume and complexity of work have not decreased in our department market pressures do get taken into account when reviewing salaries” “There’s been a companywide freeze on pay and no bonuses paid, the legal team has been treated the same” “There has been a salary freeze across most areas of the company but this did not apply to shared services which includes the legal team” “Legal salaries are tightening up globally in line with the rest of the business but we are still using bonuses to reward top performers”
  • 15. NAIMAN CLARKE IN-HOUSE SURVEY 2010 Remuneration Practices (Continued) “While officially our organisation has instituted salary freezes the top performers have still been looked after with salary reviews” “Juniors have been treated differently salary increases are based on market at the lower PQE levels” Career Progression/Retention Managing the career progression expectations of junior lawyers was one of the greatest human capital management issues faced by In-house legal departments (especially in the smaller teams). While a range of tools were employed by far and away the most common strategies were providing opportunities for lawyers to develop their career by moving into the business and using remuneration policies to retain staff. “We have a flat structure in the department and manage career progression by giving our lawyers an opportunity to move into the business” “One way to keep people is to pay competitively, we try to pay the same as law firms” “Because of the size of our team, moving into non-legal roles is the most common way lawyers in our department progress” “There will be no raises but bonuses will still be paid out to the top performers.” 15
  • 16. ABOUT NAIMAN CLARKE ABOUT THE AUTHOR Naiman Clarke was established in 1999, and since Johnothan Naiman is a qualified lawyer having this time has been driven by the desire to be the practiced as a solicitor, barrister and In-house counsel. best specialised legal recruiter in Australia. We have In addition to his legal qualifications, Johnothan has always believed that the only way to achieve this goal completed a Masters of Business Administration and is is to consistently deliver results by providing creative currently studying towards his Masters of Commerce. solutions that exceed the expectation of clients and As the CEO of Naiman Clarke Johnothan regularly candidates. provides advice and assistance to some of Australia’s Naiman Clarke is now one of the largest, most leading law firms and In-house practices on a wide knowledgeable and most experienced niche range of employment and HR issues. Johnothan has consultancies in the country. We strive to provide our held a number of senior positions prior to his current clients with an additional resource in all aspects of their role including the Head of Legal Services, South human capital management needs. Our integrated Pacific Region at Avaya Inc, and was a member of service offering covers all aspects of recruitment, the Executive Management team of Candle Australia training and development, performance management Limited (Australia’s second largest listed recruiter) as and remuneration planning. General Counsel and Commercial Manager. Our comprehensive range of services includes: • Permanent and Temporary Recruitment Services • Search and Selection • HR Consulting and other professional services • Training • Psychometric testing Our clients include blue chip multinational corporations, multi disciplinary practices, government, top and mid tier capital city firms as well as numerous boutique firms both in Australia and overseas. Naiman Clarke has offices in Sydney and Melbourne where dedicated consultants provide recruitment services for clients in Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, Canberra, Perth, Adelaide and Darwin. Our international consultants provide Australian candidates access to some of the leading international and local firms in the United Kingdom, United States, Europe, Asia and the Middle East. The best legal opportunities