2. 2
Once again the effectiveness study has
provided us with a rich amount of information
that will help us plan our future media
activity. Conducting a second study has
shown us the long-term benefits of
newspaper advertising.
Tony Parkin
Strategic Planning and Development Manager,
Seven Seas
This is the second time we have
worked with the NMA, and once again
we have seen strong results. The
research clearly demonstrates the
benefits of brand advertising in national
newspapers.
Sarah Day
Marketing Manager, Cod Liver Oil
Seven Seas
The client’s view
3. 3
Why newspapers for Seven Seas?
This is the second year Seven Seas have tested their newspaper campaign.
The findings from the previous test proved that newspaper advertising builds
brand equity and delivers sales uplifts.
Seven Seas
Headline results
Newspaper readers increase
purchasing of Seven Seas
The increase in spend on Seven Seas
products by newspaper readers was
almost double that of non-readers.
The increase in penetration was a
third greater among those exposed to
the newspaper campaign.
Newspapers drive web traffic
The number of visits to Seven Seas’
website rose by 30% during the
campaign. Page views to JointAge
Calculator doubled on days when
there was newspaper advertising.
Newspapers built brand equity over
the two campaigns
Competitive advantage increased by
16 percentage points compared to pre
2009 campaign. Awareness, familiarity
and consideration all improved over
the two campaigns.
+16
Percentage points
+30%
JointAge Calculator
page views
x2
x2
Sales uplift
readers vs non readers
5. 5
Seven Seas
The creative work
Strong creative impact leads to high recognition
Recognition – Newspaper ads
% recognising
Seven Seas
29
Millward Brown
print norm
(326 Ads)
20
6. 6
Seven Seas
The creative work
The newspaper ads are extremely
impactful and well-branded
Newspaper ads
% agreeing
Definitely remember ad
was for Seven Seas
Very eye-catching
I’d stop and look rather
than turn the page
73
47
62
95
84
52
Seven Seas
Millward Brown Norm
9. 9
Which of the following statements best describes your
thoughts about the report
% answering
28
32
32
Seven Seas
BMJ findings also impacted perceptions
The report put me off buying
glucosamine products
I use glucosamine for
prevention rather than cure, so
the report was not relevant
I disagree with the research and
believe that glucosamine is effective
11. 11
Seven Seas
Newspapers readers increase in spend is double that of non-readers
Seven Seas value sales
12 w/e 05th Dec 10 vs. pre-period (12 w/e 12th Sep 10)
£000s
Newspaper readers Non-readers
+34%
+18%
Pre-period
During/post
12. 12
Seven Seas
Seven Seas grew market share by 35% more among newspaper readers vs non-readers
Seven Seas value sales
12 w/e 5th Dec 10 vs. pre-period (12 w/e 12th Sep 10)
%
Pre-period
During/post
Newspaper readers Non-readers
+31%
+23%
13. 13
Seven Seas
Penetration increases by 28% among newspaper readers
Seven Seas penetration
12 w/e 5th Dec 10 vs. pre-period (12 w/e 12th Sep 10)
%
Pre-period
Newspaper readers Non-readers
+28%
+21%
During/post
14. 14
Seven Seas
Newspapers readers increase average weekly purchase
Seven Seas average weekly purchase
12 w/e 5th Dec 10 vs. pre-period (12 w/e 12th Sep 10)
£s
Pre-period
Newspaper readers Non-readers
+7%
-1%
During/post
16. 16
Seven Seas
Newspaper insertions double page views
JointAge Calculator web traffic
Page views
During campaign
– days with no ads
+121%
1100
2428
During campaign
– days with ads
17. 17
Seven Seas
Spontaneous awareness increased significantly
Spontaneous awareness
Pre to post % points increase
Top 2 Box %
Total
+23
Users who
recognise NP
Non-users who
recognise NP
+25 +20
Pre-wave
Post-wave
18. 18
Seven Seas
Newspapers enhance consideration
Brand commitment – Likelihood to choose
Pre to post % points increase
Top 2 Box %
Total
+8
Recognise NP Non-recognisers
+22 +1
2009 Pre-wave
2010 Pre-wave
2010 Post-wave
21. 21
Seven Seas
Campaign produces very positive emotional and rational response
Response to newspaper ads
% agreeing
Millward Brown
Norm
50
36
45
71
51
79
Contained new
information
36
Contained different
information
Points made
were relevant
Points made were
believable
Made brand
more appealing
Made me more likely
to buy Seven Seas
71
89
91
84
80
22. 22
Seven Seas
Re-appraisal is strengthened by multiple executions
Advertising measures – Re-appraisal
Surprising and gets me to think differently
Top 2 Box %
1 Newspaper ad
69
73
78
2 Newspaper ads 3 Newspaper adsRecognise:
23. 23
Seven Seas
Strong call to action boosted by multiple executions
Advertising measures – Call to action
Gives me a reason to go out and buy
Top 2 Box %
1 Newspaper ad
69
84 83
2 Newspaper ads 3 Newspaper adsRecognise:
24. 24
Seven Seas
Emotional connection with Seven Seas JointCare is strengthened by multiple executions
Advertising measures – Brand values
Helps me connect and identify more strongly
Top 2 Box %
1 Newspaper ad
73
84
87
2 Newspaper ads 3 Newspaper adsRecognise:
26. 26
Seven Seas
Newspapers closely match brand profile
Analysis by social grade
%
Profile of Vitamin
& Mineral users
18
Heavy NP
readers
Heavy TV viewers
Source TGI 2011 Q1
51
31
23
52
25
35
50
15
AB
C1C2
DE
27. 27
Seven Seas
National newspaper readers are big spenders
Expenditure on vitamin & mineral supplements
£ per household 2010
Source Kantar World Panel 52wk average 26 Dec 10, HH (000s) 7,064 for heaviest TV , 7,729 Freq NP quals 1370, Mids 1907, Pops
3522, Online NP 1,233. Note Online NP data also built in to newspaper groups
Total
Market
Heaviest
1/3 TV
Frequent
Newspaper
readers
Frequent
Quality
NPs
Frequent
Mid-market
NPs
Frequent
Popular
NPs
Frequent
Online
NPs
£1.84
£1.36
£2.24
£2.44
£2.83
£1.62
£2.58
29. 29
Newspapers are the perfect environment for
healthcare ads, as they provide a large, highly
engaged and responsive audience who spend
heavily on healthcare brands
Newspapers create a strong emotional response
among readers, which helps build brands and
influence buying decisions
Relevant editorial heightens audience engagement
and interest
Newspapers’ immediacy drives sales response
Seven Seas
Test hypothesis
30. 30
Seven Seas
Test detail
Media Plan
Sep 10 Oct 10 Nov 10 £m
Media
Target audience:
ABC1C2 Families
National
Newspapers
0.6
Research Dates
Millward Brown
Pre-wave
Post wave
Sample: 711 adults aged 45+ who buy vitamins/supplements nowadays.
ABC1C2 social class plus E social class if in receipt of private pension
Media Source: NMR/BARB/NRS
410 GRPs
Campaign objective
Attract new users to joint care supplements category, and build Seven Seas joint
health expertise credentials. At the same time strengthen loyalty among users.
Editor's Notes
These eye-catching Seven Seas ads achieved good levels of recognition
The ads are extremely impactful and well branded.Placement in the health pages of newspapers allowed Seven Seas to benefit from the engagement of readers in relevant editorial copy. Research carried out for NMA News:Healthcare special* by BMRB in 2009 shows that 88% of regular newspaper readers are interested in health editorial, and 38% are very interested in health articles and sections.
The campaign launched on the same day that research conducted by the BMJ was released. The findings claimed that glucosamine does not cure joint problems.Glucosamine is promoted for prevention rather than cure. However, the findings did have an impact on the glucosamine market.Following publication the glucosamine market saw a 22% drop in sales.
25% of the sample had heard about the findings. And of these nearly a third had been put off buying glucosamine products.
Kantar Worldpanel analysed Seven Seas sales for the 12 week period during and after the newspaper advertising, and compared this to a 12 week pre-period. Despite the negative publicity purchasing among newspaper readers increased by 34%, almost double the increase by non-readers.
During the 12 weeks ending 5th December, Seven Seas’ share of the glucosamine and adult vitamin market increased by 31% among newspaper readers. Over a third more than the value share increase attributed to non-readers.
In the 12 week period during and after the campaign new buyers were attracted to the Seven Seas range. Overall penetration increased by 28% among newspaper readers a third more than those not exposed to the campaign.
Newspaper readers increased their weekly spend by 7% compared to a drop of 1% by non-readers.
Sophus3 carried out analysis of traffic to Seven Seas website. They compared traffic during the campaign to data collected a month before.Traffic increased significantly throughout the campaign and resulted in greater consumer engagement. Number of visits increased by 30% during the campaign period.
Page views of the JointAge Calculator more than doubled on days when advertising appeared in the national newspapers.Research carried out by BMRB in 2009 showed that 78% of respondents often look something up on the internet after reading about it in a newspaper.
The campaign has significantly increased spontaneous awareness both among Seven Seas users and non-users.
The newspaper advertising had a positive impact on future buying intentions. Likelihood to choose rose by 9% points among recognisers. This built on the success of the 2009 campaign with a 22% point increase from the 2009 pre-wave.
Brand Dynamics analysis measures brand equity, describing the customer’s journey to loyalty (bonding). The strength of the relationship correlates with share of category expenditure.The newspaper campaign led to an increase in relevance, performance and advantage in 2010. The 16% points rise at competitive advantage stage corresponds with the share increases measured by Kantar Worldpanel. Looking at the long term effects of newspaper campaigns across 2009-2010, newspapers built brand equity strongly at all levels.
Newspaper ads only have a brief moment to grab the readers attention. If the ad fails to do so the reader will happily turn the page before engaging with the ad.The Seven Seas campaign was highly actively engaging. It was seen as being more than twice as involving compared to Millward Brown print norms, as well as being highly distinctive and interesting.
The newspaper campaign consisted of three executions, two of which focused on JointCare products and communicated well above norms.The third launched a new service called the JointAge Calculator. Over 90% of newspaper ad recognisers agreed with all seven messages statements. Branding was exceptionally strong receiving universal agreement that the service “is from Seven Seas”.
Effectiveness Tests consistently show that multiple executions enhance campaign performance. They also prevent ad wear-out. Newspapers are the home of news, and are the ideal environment to drive re-appraisal of their brand.Re-appraisal is stronger among those consumers recognising all three of the newspaper ads.
Additional executions also improved call to action. Endorsement of call to action rose by 22% when people had seen more than one execution.
The newspaper campaign generated a strong emotional connection and identification with Seven Seas JointCare. Again the endorsement scores rose in line with the number of ads seen. 87% of those that had seen all three executions felt the advertising helped them to connect and identify with Seven Seas JointCare.
More than half the weight of any TV campaign goes to the heaviest third of viewers – who are significantly less upmarket than the brand. Whereas the newspapers’ profile matches well.
Newspaper readers are big spenders in the vitamins and mineral supplements category, and importantly for Seven Seas are more likely to buy branded products rather than private label. This is reflected in the Kantar Worldpanel analysis that shows frequent newspaper readers outspent heavy TV viewers by 64%.
Newspapers are the perfect environment for healthcare brands, as they provide a large, highly engaged and responsive audience who spend heavily on healthcare brandsNewspaper s create a strong emotional response among readers , which helps build brands and influence buying decisionsRelevant editorial heightens audience engagement and interestNewspapers’ immediacy drives sales response
Analysis of the tracking data focuses on a comparison of pre-post shifts among:1) Total sample (Total)2) Those who recognise the newspaper advertising (Recognise NP)3) Those who do not recognise the newspaper ads (Non-recognisers)Kantar Worldpanel data compares spending of those exposed to the newspaper advertising (NP readers) to non-readers of newspapers spending.