SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 21
Proposals, Conclusions and Dialogues Piotr Madziar – European Commission 20 November 2009, XI European Banking Supervisors XBRL Workshop - Vienna
Topics European Commission proposal for supervisory reform Critics  Next steps?
XBRL driving forces Simplification - Reduction of Admin Burden De Larosiere Reform EU Council EP MS G20 Corporate governance and transparency E-Gov, Information Society, EU Competitivenss XBRL Simplification Crisis COM De Larosiere Stoiberg
De Larosiere Reform Financial crisis driven Position of national regulators? Global aspect Commission absolute priority.
European Parliament Resolution on Lamfalussy follow-up: future structure of supervision (September 2008) Calls upon the L3 Committees to design common reporting standards Multi-purpose format such as XBRL Throughout the EU Calls upon the Commission to submit adequate legislative proposals
De Larosiere proposal Commission’s proposal of 23 September 2009 ESRB and ESFS = ECB + ESAs + national regulators+… Banking: colaterals, capital, fund transfer reg,… Insurance: insurance and reinsurance, conglomerates, institutions, Solvency II, anti money laundering,… Securities & Markets: transparency, markets in FI, market abuse, prospectuses, hedge funds, CRA, take-over bids, settlements, financial collateral arrangements, ... Technical standards,… XBRL? Links to international standard setters,… XBRL?
More powers for ESAs Technical standards but criteria in Community legislation  Flow of information Supervisory culture and supervisory practices Last resort option in case of disagreement Training programmes Aggregate micro-prudential information from national supervisors Set-up a Central European Database. The information will be available for the relevant authorities in colleges of supervisors and forwarded to the European Systemic Risk Council Technical arrangements with international organisations and administrations of third countries.
Proposed structure for Banking € EBA– EuropeanBankingAuthority European Commission Chairperson ECA - European Court of Auditors Executive Director Mgt Board OLAF – l’Office européen de lutte anti-fraude BankingStakeholderGroup Board of Supervisors
Appeal processes EU Council - QMV Board of Appeal for 3 ESAs EBA QMV Member State Member State NSA NSA NSA EU Court of First Instance EU Court of Justice
Joint Committee of European Supervisory Authorities EIOPA - European Insurance and Occupational Pension Authority EBA - European Banking Authority NSA NSA NSA College of Supervisors NSA NSA NSA – National Supervisory Authority NSA NSA NSA NSA NSA NSA ESFS ESFS - EU System of Financial Supervisors ESMA - European Securities and Markets Authority
Information exchange 3rd Countries & Int’l ECB Information exchange Information exchange ESRB – European Systemic Risk Board ESFS – European System of Financial Supervision ESRB – EU Systemic Risk Board
Practicalities, Agenda Financial assistance 37- 70 M€ in years 2011-2016 40% from the Community budget London, Paris, Frankfurt Status similar to EU Agency 74-90 staff (2016) EU Staff Regulation (independence, impartiality).
Financial Market-driven regulatory data reform Governments All Markets Common Reporting Framework Regulated Financial Markets ?
Critics Tooambitious ,[object Object],Great unease Far from clear Far too fast
Critics R e a l     a r g u m e n t s Sovereignty Global dimension Stop! Exclusion and Dominance Treasury
Critics R e a l     a r g u m e n t s Sovereignty of MS: ,[object Object]
ESAs empowered to overridenational regulators
Changes give EU more powers. Emergencydeclared by the Commission without involvement of the Council. Unclear emergency procedure.
MS should decide first what will ESAs do and how,[object Object]
Need for allignment with G-20 and Basel.
It would be very bad for EU and its financial centres If we forge ahead disregarding what US, Switzerlandand others are doing,[object Object]

More Related Content

Similar to Xi Banking Supervisors Xbrl Workshop 20 November, 2009 Vienna

New Financial Regulations In Europe After Financial Crisis Abhijeet Singhal
New Financial Regulations In Europe After Financial Crisis Abhijeet SinghalNew Financial Regulations In Europe After Financial Crisis Abhijeet Singhal
New Financial Regulations In Europe After Financial Crisis Abhijeet SinghalAbhijeet Singhal
 
La ue estudia la ttf para financiar la supervisión.
La ue estudia la ttf para financiar la supervisión.La ue estudia la ttf para financiar la supervisión.
La ue estudia la ttf para financiar la supervisión.ManfredNolte
 
Euro shorts 15.11.13 including trade repositories, short selling and the FTT
Euro shorts   15.11.13 including trade repositories, short selling and the FTTEuro shorts   15.11.13 including trade repositories, short selling and the FTT
Euro shorts 15.11.13 including trade repositories, short selling and the FTTCummings
 
Building the European Banking Union in Times of Crisis - Ignazio Angeloni - ...
 Building the European Banking Union in Times of Crisis - Ignazio Angeloni - ... Building the European Banking Union in Times of Crisis - Ignazio Angeloni - ...
Building the European Banking Union in Times of Crisis - Ignazio Angeloni - ...SYRTO Project
 
MFA EU Regulation 101
MFA EU Regulation 101MFA EU Regulation 101
MFA EU Regulation 101ManagedFunds
 
Euro shorts 16.12.16 including Brexit: European Parliament briefing and Brexi...
Euro shorts 16.12.16 including Brexit: European Parliament briefing and Brexi...Euro shorts 16.12.16 including Brexit: European Parliament briefing and Brexi...
Euro shorts 16.12.16 including Brexit: European Parliament briefing and Brexi...Cummings
 
Warsaw4 Dec2008
Warsaw4 Dec2008Warsaw4 Dec2008
Warsaw4 Dec2008pmadziar
 
Sbr Poland October 9, 2009 Warsaw
Sbr Poland October 9, 2009 WarsawSbr Poland October 9, 2009 Warsaw
Sbr Poland October 9, 2009 Warsawpmadziar
 
European Union Hedge Fund Regulation 101
European Union Hedge Fund Regulation 101European Union Hedge Fund Regulation 101
European Union Hedge Fund Regulation 101HedgeFundFundamentals
 
Tax avoidance-industry-lobby-low-res
Tax avoidance-industry-lobby-low-resTax avoidance-industry-lobby-low-res
Tax avoidance-industry-lobby-low-resnickcjames
 
XBRL Adoption Europe 2009-10-20
XBRL Adoption Europe 2009-10-20XBRL Adoption Europe 2009-10-20
XBRL Adoption Europe 2009-10-20Conor O'Kelly
 
Euro shorts 24.07.15 including AIFMD EMIR delay on passporting opinion and AI...
Euro shorts 24.07.15 including AIFMD EMIR delay on passporting opinion and AI...Euro shorts 24.07.15 including AIFMD EMIR delay on passporting opinion and AI...
Euro shorts 24.07.15 including AIFMD EMIR delay on passporting opinion and AI...Cummings
 
Debate on europe - How did Europe react to the economic and financial crisis
Debate on europe  - How did Europe react to the economic and financial crisisDebate on europe  - How did Europe react to the economic and financial crisis
Debate on europe - How did Europe react to the economic and financial crisisAndrea Danni
 
Integration without democracy II? | European Banking Union – Democracy, Techn...
Integration without democracy II? | European Banking Union – Democracy, Techn...Integration without democracy II? | European Banking Union – Democracy, Techn...
Integration without democracy II? | European Banking Union – Democracy, Techn...Florence School of Banking & Finance
 
European Union Single Market Capital Flows
European Union   Single Market   Capital FlowsEuropean Union   Single Market   Capital Flows
European Union Single Market Capital Flowseonemo
 
EU exit and financial services report_FINAL (1)
EU exit and financial services report_FINAL (1)EU exit and financial services report_FINAL (1)
EU exit and financial services report_FINAL (1)Matt Bailey
 
European Market Infrastructure Regulation (EMIR) - New EU Rules on Derivative...
European Market Infrastructure Regulation (EMIR) - New EU Rules on Derivative...European Market Infrastructure Regulation (EMIR) - New EU Rules on Derivative...
European Market Infrastructure Regulation (EMIR) - New EU Rules on Derivative...Rüdiger Rücker
 
Euro shorts 29.01.16 including cameron attends last minute talks on uk eu mem...
Euro shorts 29.01.16 including cameron attends last minute talks on uk eu mem...Euro shorts 29.01.16 including cameron attends last minute talks on uk eu mem...
Euro shorts 29.01.16 including cameron attends last minute talks on uk eu mem...Cummings
 

Similar to Xi Banking Supervisors Xbrl Workshop 20 November, 2009 Vienna (20)

New Financial Regulations In Europe After Financial Crisis Abhijeet Singhal
New Financial Regulations In Europe After Financial Crisis Abhijeet SinghalNew Financial Regulations In Europe After Financial Crisis Abhijeet Singhal
New Financial Regulations In Europe After Financial Crisis Abhijeet Singhal
 
La ue estudia la ttf para financiar la supervisión.
La ue estudia la ttf para financiar la supervisión.La ue estudia la ttf para financiar la supervisión.
La ue estudia la ttf para financiar la supervisión.
 
Euro shorts 15.11.13 including trade repositories, short selling and the FTT
Euro shorts   15.11.13 including trade repositories, short selling and the FTTEuro shorts   15.11.13 including trade repositories, short selling and the FTT
Euro shorts 15.11.13 including trade repositories, short selling and the FTT
 
Building the European Banking Union in Times of Crisis - Ignazio Angeloni - ...
 Building the European Banking Union in Times of Crisis - Ignazio Angeloni - ... Building the European Banking Union in Times of Crisis - Ignazio Angeloni - ...
Building the European Banking Union in Times of Crisis - Ignazio Angeloni - ...
 
MFA EU Regulation 101
MFA EU Regulation 101MFA EU Regulation 101
MFA EU Regulation 101
 
Euro shorts 16.12.16 including Brexit: European Parliament briefing and Brexi...
Euro shorts 16.12.16 including Brexit: European Parliament briefing and Brexi...Euro shorts 16.12.16 including Brexit: European Parliament briefing and Brexi...
Euro shorts 16.12.16 including Brexit: European Parliament briefing and Brexi...
 
Warsaw4 Dec2008
Warsaw4 Dec2008Warsaw4 Dec2008
Warsaw4 Dec2008
 
Sbr Poland October 9, 2009 Warsaw
Sbr Poland October 9, 2009 WarsawSbr Poland October 9, 2009 Warsaw
Sbr Poland October 9, 2009 Warsaw
 
European Union Hedge Fund Regulation 101
European Union Hedge Fund Regulation 101European Union Hedge Fund Regulation 101
European Union Hedge Fund Regulation 101
 
Tax avoidance-industry-lobby-low-res
Tax avoidance-industry-lobby-low-resTax avoidance-industry-lobby-low-res
Tax avoidance-industry-lobby-low-res
 
XBRL Adoption Europe 2009-10-20
XBRL Adoption Europe 2009-10-20XBRL Adoption Europe 2009-10-20
XBRL Adoption Europe 2009-10-20
 
Euro shorts 24.07.15 including AIFMD EMIR delay on passporting opinion and AI...
Euro shorts 24.07.15 including AIFMD EMIR delay on passporting opinion and AI...Euro shorts 24.07.15 including AIFMD EMIR delay on passporting opinion and AI...
Euro shorts 24.07.15 including AIFMD EMIR delay on passporting opinion and AI...
 
Debate on europe - How did Europe react to the economic and financial crisis
Debate on europe  - How did Europe react to the economic and financial crisisDebate on europe  - How did Europe react to the economic and financial crisis
Debate on europe - How did Europe react to the economic and financial crisis
 
AFL5010 Workshop 2
AFL5010 Workshop 2AFL5010 Workshop 2
AFL5010 Workshop 2
 
Integration without democracy II? | European Banking Union – Democracy, Techn...
Integration without democracy II? | European Banking Union – Democracy, Techn...Integration without democracy II? | European Banking Union – Democracy, Techn...
Integration without democracy II? | European Banking Union – Democracy, Techn...
 
European Union Single Market Capital Flows
European Union   Single Market   Capital FlowsEuropean Union   Single Market   Capital Flows
European Union Single Market Capital Flows
 
EU exit and financial services report_FINAL (1)
EU exit and financial services report_FINAL (1)EU exit and financial services report_FINAL (1)
EU exit and financial services report_FINAL (1)
 
European Market Infrastructure Regulation (EMIR) - New EU Rules on Derivative...
European Market Infrastructure Regulation (EMIR) - New EU Rules on Derivative...European Market Infrastructure Regulation (EMIR) - New EU Rules on Derivative...
European Market Infrastructure Regulation (EMIR) - New EU Rules on Derivative...
 
Karel Lannoo | COEURE Workshop on Financial Markets
Karel Lannoo | COEURE Workshop on Financial MarketsKarel Lannoo | COEURE Workshop on Financial Markets
Karel Lannoo | COEURE Workshop on Financial Markets
 
Euro shorts 29.01.16 including cameron attends last minute talks on uk eu mem...
Euro shorts 29.01.16 including cameron attends last minute talks on uk eu mem...Euro shorts 29.01.16 including cameron attends last minute talks on uk eu mem...
Euro shorts 29.01.16 including cameron attends last minute talks on uk eu mem...
 

Xi Banking Supervisors Xbrl Workshop 20 November, 2009 Vienna

  • 1. Proposals, Conclusions and Dialogues Piotr Madziar – European Commission 20 November 2009, XI European Banking Supervisors XBRL Workshop - Vienna
  • 2. Topics European Commission proposal for supervisory reform Critics Next steps?
  • 3. XBRL driving forces Simplification - Reduction of Admin Burden De Larosiere Reform EU Council EP MS G20 Corporate governance and transparency E-Gov, Information Society, EU Competitivenss XBRL Simplification Crisis COM De Larosiere Stoiberg
  • 4. De Larosiere Reform Financial crisis driven Position of national regulators? Global aspect Commission absolute priority.
  • 5. European Parliament Resolution on Lamfalussy follow-up: future structure of supervision (September 2008) Calls upon the L3 Committees to design common reporting standards Multi-purpose format such as XBRL Throughout the EU Calls upon the Commission to submit adequate legislative proposals
  • 6. De Larosiere proposal Commission’s proposal of 23 September 2009 ESRB and ESFS = ECB + ESAs + national regulators+… Banking: colaterals, capital, fund transfer reg,… Insurance: insurance and reinsurance, conglomerates, institutions, Solvency II, anti money laundering,… Securities & Markets: transparency, markets in FI, market abuse, prospectuses, hedge funds, CRA, take-over bids, settlements, financial collateral arrangements, ... Technical standards,… XBRL? Links to international standard setters,… XBRL?
  • 7. More powers for ESAs Technical standards but criteria in Community legislation Flow of information Supervisory culture and supervisory practices Last resort option in case of disagreement Training programmes Aggregate micro-prudential information from national supervisors Set-up a Central European Database. The information will be available for the relevant authorities in colleges of supervisors and forwarded to the European Systemic Risk Council Technical arrangements with international organisations and administrations of third countries.
  • 8. Proposed structure for Banking € EBA– EuropeanBankingAuthority European Commission Chairperson ECA - European Court of Auditors Executive Director Mgt Board OLAF – l’Office européen de lutte anti-fraude BankingStakeholderGroup Board of Supervisors
  • 9. Appeal processes EU Council - QMV Board of Appeal for 3 ESAs EBA QMV Member State Member State NSA NSA NSA EU Court of First Instance EU Court of Justice
  • 10. Joint Committee of European Supervisory Authorities EIOPA - European Insurance and Occupational Pension Authority EBA - European Banking Authority NSA NSA NSA College of Supervisors NSA NSA NSA – National Supervisory Authority NSA NSA NSA NSA NSA NSA ESFS ESFS - EU System of Financial Supervisors ESMA - European Securities and Markets Authority
  • 11. Information exchange 3rd Countries & Int’l ECB Information exchange Information exchange ESRB – European Systemic Risk Board ESFS – European System of Financial Supervision ESRB – EU Systemic Risk Board
  • 12. Practicalities, Agenda Financial assistance 37- 70 M€ in years 2011-2016 40% from the Community budget London, Paris, Frankfurt Status similar to EU Agency 74-90 staff (2016) EU Staff Regulation (independence, impartiality).
  • 13. Financial Market-driven regulatory data reform Governments All Markets Common Reporting Framework Regulated Financial Markets ?
  • 14.
  • 15. Critics R e a l a r g u m e n t s Sovereignty Global dimension Stop! Exclusion and Dominance Treasury
  • 16.
  • 17. ESAs empowered to overridenational regulators
  • 18. Changes give EU more powers. Emergencydeclared by the Commission without involvement of the Council. Unclear emergency procedure.
  • 19.
  • 20. Need for allignment with G-20 and Basel.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 24. Bankers dominance in ESRB, disregarding the fact that the choice between security and price is a democratic trade-off decision taken by governments, for the citizens.
  • 25.
  • 26. Contacts DG Internal Market & Services website: http://ec.europa.eu/dgs/internal_market/index_en.htm Piotr Madziar +32-(0)2-2950869 piotr.madziar@ec.europa.eu