SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 19
Team Cinergy
Alaina Boyer, Jay Burke, Brendan Cochrane, Pramod Jindal & Beam Ukarapong
Recommendation

Problem
Should Cineplex focus on building its download business or reinvest in its
theatre business?

Recommendation
Cineplex should reinvest in its core competencies within the theatre
experience, while expanding the complementary entertainment services it offers

Major Insights
• Exhibition theatres have problems – we CAN fix them
• Cineplex is REALLY good at its core competencies
• We can PLAY in the Digital sandbox, but…




                  Fixing Problems   Core Competencies   Digital Sandbox
                                                                                 1
Exhibition Theatres have problems – we CAN fix them

 Convenience
 4-hour outing for a 2-hour movie is inconvenient

 Why does this happen?
 Need to get there early for good seats and line-up for food

 Proposal
 CinExpress – a service to reserve your seat, pre-order food & beverage and
 pick-up your order from designated line

 Costs
 • Initial confusion amongst non-reserved seating patrons
 • Dedicated staff for express line
 • Enhance current website/app/interface to incorporate CinExpress

 Benefits
 • Higher revenue from increased ticket price (+$2.00/seat)
 • Pre-ordered food = guaranteed sale
                   Fixing Problems   Core Competencies   Digital Sandbox
                                                                              2
Exhibition Theatres have potential – maximize it

 Loyalty
 Scene Membership card and Loyalty Program: very successful

 How to use Loyalty to our advantage?
 • Incentivize new members - free upgrades
 • Retain members with Milestone Rewards
 • Birthday and anniversary promotions
 • Expand point-redemption partners

 Costs
 • Additional free movies
 • Loss of 10% concession revenue (Scene discount)

 Benefits
 • Increased membership: more theatre footfalls and concession spending
 • Free word-of-mouth advertising


                  Fixing Problems   Core Competencies   Digital Sandbox
                                                                          3
Exhibition Theatres have scope for improvement

 Social Media Penetration
 A Facebook page isn’t enough

 Why should this change?
 Transition from offline to online social experience

 How will we correct this?
 Ability to post updates after ticket sales and reviews post-show

 Costs
 • Programming/development costs

 Benefits
 • Brand recognition (each auto-generated posting has Cineplex brand
   embedded)
 • Free social media advertising will reach broader audience & tech-savvy
   users

                    Fixing Problems   Core Competencies   Digital Sandbox
                                                                            4
Leverage our Core Competency: Theatre Experience

 Broad Experience
 Experience beyond our best movies: complete entertainment experience

 Our Proposal
 Continue to invest in alternative programming, games, liquor-licensed VIP as well as
 non-peak theatre usage

 Actions
 • Theme nights
 • UFC events
 • Customized events

 Costs
 • Licensing, capital expenditures and labour

 Benefits
 • Increased ticket revenue
 • Additional reasons to visit a multiplex
 • Increased share of wallet from customized-event clients
                    Fixing Problems   Core Competencies   Digital Sandbox
                                                                                        5
Leverage our Core Competency: State of the art technology

 Technology
 We have the best technology. Home theatre solutions cannot simulate a real
 theatre experience

 Proposal
 Continue to invest in:
 • UltraAVX
 • Complete digital screen and 3D projection upgrade by 2012 as planned
 • Canadian Digital Cinema Partnership

 Costs
 • No change from current reporting

 Benefits
 • Provide enhanced customer experience
 • Maintain competitive advantage over digital


                  Fixing Problems   Core Competencies   Digital Sandbox
                                                                              6
Leverage our Core Competency: Studio Relationships

 Studio Relationships
 We have the best new movies you can’t find online

 Proposal
 • Leverage leading market share position to acquire best titles
 • Extend relationship to re-release patron favourites

 Costs
 • No change from current reporting

 Benefits
 • Maintain competitive advantage over digital
 • Preferential treatment and flexibility




                   Fixing Problems   Core Competencies   Digital Sandbox
                                                                           7
We can PLAY in the digital sandbox

 But…
 • Non-core business
 • High switching costs for legitimate users
 • Low switching costs for illegitimate users
 • Fierce competition
 • In pipeline “UltraViolet”- new technology, same players

 Cost
 • Advertising costs for brand promotion
 • Increased redemption of Scene points (affecting core margins)

 Benefits
 • Additional revenue stream
 • Allows entry into new market
 • Leveraging Scene loyalty



                   Fixing Problems   Core Competencies   Digital Sandbox
                                                                           8
Risks associated with our Recommendations

 Overall Risks to the Industry
 • Busier life style – not enough free time for movies
 • Recessionary fears – reduced leisure budget

 Convenience, Loyalty and Social Media
 • Customers not receptive to reserved seating  lost revenue
 • Potential breach of privacy in Loyalty program
 • Maintaining higher service delivery levels

 Event Experience
 • Additional improvements not aligned with customer values
 • Changing customer tastes
 • Year without blockbuster movies

 Digital Sandbox
 • Ongoing piracy concerns
 • Competing against new innovations by established digital competitors
 • Digital players enter theatre business
                   Fixing Problems   Core Competencies   Digital Sandbox
                                                                           9
Summary

Recommendation
Cineplex should reinvest in its core competencies within the theatre
experience, while expanding the complementary entertainment services it offers

Major Insights
• Exhibition theatres have problems – we CAN fix them
• Cineplex is REALLY good at its core competencies
• We can PLAY in the Digital sandbox, but…




                 Fixing Problems   Core Competencies   Digital Sandbox
                                                                                 10
Thank you
  Q&A



            11
Reserved Seating Cost/Benefit Structure
                      Reserved Seating                                 Reserved Seating
       Brand new chairs                  $      300.00    Chair covers                    $      35.00
       Total Seats to Change                         60   Total Seats to Change                      60
       TOTAL NEW SEAT COST               $   18,000.00    TOTAL NEW SEAT COST             $   2,100.00
       Replacement Labour Cost           $      100.00    Replacement Labour Cost         $     100.00
       Hours to replace 60 seats                     15   Hours to replace 60 seats                  15
       TOTAL LABOUR COSTS                $    1,500.00    TOTAL LABOUR COSTS              $   1,500.00
       GRAND TOTAL COST                  $   19,500.00    GRAND TOTAL COST                $   3,600.00

                   Increased Revenue                                 Increased Revenue
       Premium for Reserved Seating      $       2.00     Premium for Reserved Seating    $       2.00
       Average Show Rate                             4    Average Show Rate                           4
       50% occupancy                                30    50% occupancy                              30
       75% occupancy                                45    75% occupancy                              45
       80% occupancy                                48    80% occupancy                              48
       85% occupancy                                51    85% occupancy                              51
       TOTAL REVENUE at 50% sales        $     240.00     TOTAL REVENUE at 50% sales      $     240.00
       TOTAL REVENUE at 75% sales        $     360.00     TOTAL REVENUE at 75% sales      $     360.00
       TOTAL REVENUE at 80% sales        $     384.00     TOTAL REVENUE at 80% sales      $     384.00
       TOTAL REVENUE at 85% sales        $     408.00     TOTAL REVENUE at 85% sales      $     408.00

                    Payback Period                                     Payback Period
       Cost/Revenue @ 50%                    81 days      Cost/Revenue @ 50%                  15 days
       Cost/Revenue @ 75%                    54 days      Cost/Revenue @ 75%                  10 days
       Cost/Revenue @ 80%                    51 days      Cost/Revenue @ 80%                  9 days
       Cost/Revenue @ 85%                    48 days      Cost/Revenue @ 85%                  9 days



                                                                                                          12
Scene Membership Growth


                                          Scene Membership
                                             (in millions)



      3.5
               No. of Members                                          3.2

      3.0
                                                              2.6
      2.5
                                                   2.0
      2.0

      1.5
                                 1.2

      1.0

      0.5    0.4


      0.0
            Q3 '07              Q3 '08            Q3 '09     Q3 '10   Q3 '11


                                         Y/Y Growth 23%
                                           (2010-2011)

                                                                               13
Internal Activities and Capabilities
                                                       Plane     Beakers      Boat
                                                      Valuable    Rare     In-imitable
       Movies (Exhibition) - showtimes, convenience      3         2           2
       Movies (Digital)                                  1         1           1
       Loyalty (Scene)                                   3         2           3
       Merchandise (zoning) 30%                          3         1           1
       Alternative                                       3         1           1
       Media (ads)                                       3         2           1
       Media (magazine)                                  2         1           1
       Social media                                      3         1           1
       Premium (seats, sounds, VIP)                      3         1           2
       Interactive (App)                                 3         1           1
       Vendor relationship (food/aeroplan)               3         1           1
       Technology (3D/IMAX)                              3         3           3
       Popcorn                                           3         1           1
       Previews                                          2         1           1
       Partnership (Scotia)                              3         3           3
       CDCP (Empre)                                      3         3           3
       Night-out package                                 2         1           1
       In-house brand (OutTakes)                         2         2           1
       Locations                                         3         3           3
       Studio Relationship (having the best movies)      3         2           3



                                                                                         Source:
                                                                                                   14
Blue Ocean Analysis of Cineplex (Current), Cineplex
(Proposed), Cineplex Anywhere and Digital Download
8

7

6

5
                                                                                              NEW-CPX
4
                                                                                              CineAW
3                                                                                             CPX
                                                                                              Digital
2

1

0
    Watch a     Price   Convenience Great food     Great      Fun   Great social Watch the
     recently                       experience   emotional          experience movie I want
    released                                     experience
      movie




                                                                                                    15
5 forces: Exhibition Entertainment


   Substitute – high, and getting worse
   • More activities

   Buyer – moderate
   • Switching costs low, consumer influence mod

   Supplier – moderate
   • Avatar high, others low

   Barriers – High
   • Huge Capex

   Rivalry – Low
   • Cineplex 66%




                                                   Source:
                                                             16
5 forces: Anyway to Watch a Movie at Home


   Substitute – High
   • Tons of other options

   Buyer – Moderate, and getting worse
   • Can influence the price (Netflix)
   • But there are potential switching costs (Rogers On Demand, buying an Xbox)
   • Getting worse because of increasing piracy

   Supplier – Moderate
   • For legal activities, high
   • For illegal, low

   Barriers – Moderate
   • For legal activities, high
   • For illegal, low

   Rivalry – High
   • Tons of ways to get a movie at home




                                                                                  Source:
                                                                                            17
Industry Analysis


      Exhibition          Out of home                 -   Coffee
   Entertainment in       - Movie                     -   Community
       Canada             - Plays/operas              -   Arcades
                          - Sports events             -   Nightlife
                          - Recreational activities   -   Culture
                          - Dining                    -   Shopping
                          - F&F




                      At home (Electronic)                At home (Non-electronic)
                      - TV                                - Board games
Anyway to get
                      - Movies                            - Card games
movies at home
                      - Computer                          - Reading
                      - Video games                       - Quiet time
                      - Music                             - Exercise
                      - Internet                          - F&F
                      - Social media                      - Cooking




                                                                                     18

More Related Content

What's hot

Priceline business model evaluation
Priceline business model evaluationPriceline business model evaluation
Priceline business model evaluation
Alireza Khosroyar
 
Hubble session 1 case studies
Hubble session 1 case studiesHubble session 1 case studies
Hubble session 1 case studies
Space IDEAS Hub
 

What's hot (20)

Case Study on Oscar Mayer
Case Study on Oscar MayerCase Study on Oscar Mayer
Case Study on Oscar Mayer
 
The Walt Disney: The Entertainment King
The Walt Disney: The Entertainment KingThe Walt Disney: The Entertainment King
The Walt Disney: The Entertainment King
 
GOODYEAR CASE-STUDY
GOODYEAR CASE-STUDYGOODYEAR CASE-STUDY
GOODYEAR CASE-STUDY
 
Reed Supermarkets - A New Wave of Competition
Reed Supermarkets - A New Wave of CompetitionReed Supermarkets - A New Wave of Competition
Reed Supermarkets - A New Wave of Competition
 
Priceline business model evaluation
Priceline business model evaluationPriceline business model evaluation
Priceline business model evaluation
 
Hubble session 1 case studies
Hubble session 1 case studiesHubble session 1 case studies
Hubble session 1 case studies
 
Olympics car rental case study
Olympics car rental case studyOlympics car rental case study
Olympics car rental case study
 
The Springfield Nor'easters:Maximizing revenues in minor league case analysis...
The Springfield Nor'easters:Maximizing revenues in minor league case analysis...The Springfield Nor'easters:Maximizing revenues in minor league case analysis...
The Springfield Nor'easters:Maximizing revenues in minor league case analysis...
 
Disney case study
Disney case studyDisney case study
Disney case study
 
Goodyear : The aquatred launch
Goodyear : The aquatred launchGoodyear : The aquatred launch
Goodyear : The aquatred launch
 
Mountain dew
Mountain dewMountain dew
Mountain dew
 
Red brand canners
Red brand cannersRed brand canners
Red brand canners
 
Beauregard Textile Company Analysis
Beauregard Textile Company AnalysisBeauregard Textile Company Analysis
Beauregard Textile Company Analysis
 
McKinsey & Company: Managing Knowledge and Learning
McKinsey & Company:  Managing Knowledge and LearningMcKinsey & Company:  Managing Knowledge and Learning
McKinsey & Company: Managing Knowledge and Learning
 
Shodh market research for economy housing
Shodh  market research for economy housingShodh  market research for economy housing
Shodh market research for economy housing
 
Educomp-Case Study
Educomp-Case StudyEducomp-Case Study
Educomp-Case Study
 
Metabical
MetabicalMetabical
Metabical
 
SONY AIBO-The value proposition and rationale behind the positioning
SONY AIBO-The value proposition and rationale behind the positioningSONY AIBO-The value proposition and rationale behind the positioning
SONY AIBO-The value proposition and rationale behind the positioning
 
Harrah's Entertainment, Inc. Case Analysis
Harrah's Entertainment, Inc. Case AnalysisHarrah's Entertainment, Inc. Case Analysis
Harrah's Entertainment, Inc. Case Analysis
 
Apex corporation case study
Apex corporation case studyApex corporation case study
Apex corporation case study
 

Viewers also liked

Customer Relationship Management - Cineplex
Customer Relationship Management - CineplexCustomer Relationship Management - Cineplex
Customer Relationship Management - Cineplex
Joshua Favaro
 
Netflix business proposal
Netflix business proposalNetflix business proposal
Netflix business proposal
Brendan Blish
 
Services Marketing
Services MarketingServices Marketing
Services Marketing
Nyssa Razzak
 

Viewers also liked (15)

CINEMA HALL
CINEMA HALLCINEMA HALL
CINEMA HALL
 
SoLoMo Social Summit 2015 - Cineplex Digital Solutions Mad Hatter Technology ...
SoLoMo Social Summit 2015 - Cineplex Digital Solutions Mad Hatter Technology ...SoLoMo Social Summit 2015 - Cineplex Digital Solutions Mad Hatter Technology ...
SoLoMo Social Summit 2015 - Cineplex Digital Solutions Mad Hatter Technology ...
 
Mci scene case study
Mci scene case studyMci scene case study
Mci scene case study
 
Data Intensive Collaboration in Science and Engineering: CSCW workshop themes
Data Intensive Collaboration in Science and Engineering: CSCW workshop themesData Intensive Collaboration in Science and Engineering: CSCW workshop themes
Data Intensive Collaboration in Science and Engineering: CSCW workshop themes
 
Customer Relationship Management - Cineplex
Customer Relationship Management - CineplexCustomer Relationship Management - Cineplex
Customer Relationship Management - Cineplex
 
Netflix business proposal
Netflix business proposalNetflix business proposal
Netflix business proposal
 
Capbudget foreground reading
Capbudget foreground readingCapbudget foreground reading
Capbudget foreground reading
 
219088522 new-heritage-doll-solution
219088522 new-heritage-doll-solution219088522 new-heritage-doll-solution
219088522 new-heritage-doll-solution
 
Story of Wateen Re-branding
Story of Wateen Re-branding Story of Wateen Re-branding
Story of Wateen Re-branding
 
Ten Slides in Ten Minutes - Sex, Lies and Proposal Management
Ten Slides in Ten Minutes - Sex, Lies and Proposal ManagementTen Slides in Ten Minutes - Sex, Lies and Proposal Management
Ten Slides in Ten Minutes - Sex, Lies and Proposal Management
 
New heritage doll company report
New heritage doll company reportNew heritage doll company report
New heritage doll company report
 
Services Marketing
Services MarketingServices Marketing
Services Marketing
 
Partnership Proposal
Partnership ProposalPartnership Proposal
Partnership Proposal
 
Deloitte Undergraduate Case Competition 2015 Final Presentation
Deloitte Undergraduate Case Competition 2015 Final PresentationDeloitte Undergraduate Case Competition 2015 Final Presentation
Deloitte Undergraduate Case Competition 2015 Final Presentation
 
Deloitte Case Competition 2013
Deloitte Case Competition 2013Deloitte Case Competition 2013
Deloitte Case Competition 2013
 

Similar to Rotman Strategy Case Competition

Best Buy Turnaround Strategy
Best Buy Turnaround StrategyBest Buy Turnaround Strategy
Best Buy Turnaround Strategy
Aditya Thakur
 
Innovation Showcase: Shoestring Pitch
Innovation Showcase: Shoestring PitchInnovation Showcase: Shoestring Pitch
Innovation Showcase: Shoestring Pitch
Joshua Simmons
 
GAP inhouse production agency proposal
GAP inhouse production agency proposalGAP inhouse production agency proposal
GAP inhouse production agency proposal
Gautam Ailawadi
 
GAP inhouse production agency proposal
GAP inhouse production agency proposalGAP inhouse production agency proposal
GAP inhouse production agency proposal
Gautam Ailawadi
 
Pitch Deck To Raise Funding From Business Crowdfunding Powerpoint Presentatio...
Pitch Deck To Raise Funding From Business Crowdfunding Powerpoint Presentatio...Pitch Deck To Raise Funding From Business Crowdfunding Powerpoint Presentatio...
Pitch Deck To Raise Funding From Business Crowdfunding Powerpoint Presentatio...
SlideTeam
 
Brockmann_ExecutivesGuidetoHD_030808
Brockmann_ExecutivesGuidetoHD_030808Brockmann_ExecutivesGuidetoHD_030808
Brockmann_ExecutivesGuidetoHD_030808
Videoguy
 
Entrepreneurship Education Experience - Bob Caspe (Aula 3)
Entrepreneurship Education Experience - Bob Caspe (Aula 3)Entrepreneurship Education Experience - Bob Caspe (Aula 3)
Entrepreneurship Education Experience - Bob Caspe (Aula 3)
Cultura e Mercado
 

Similar to Rotman Strategy Case Competition (20)

Trade Promotion For Firms PowerPoint Presentation Slides
Trade Promotion For Firms PowerPoint Presentation SlidesTrade Promotion For Firms PowerPoint Presentation Slides
Trade Promotion For Firms PowerPoint Presentation Slides
 
Best Buy Turnaround Strategy
Best Buy Turnaround StrategyBest Buy Turnaround Strategy
Best Buy Turnaround Strategy
 
Trade Promotion PowerPoint Presentation Slides
Trade Promotion PowerPoint Presentation SlidesTrade Promotion PowerPoint Presentation Slides
Trade Promotion PowerPoint Presentation Slides
 
Cleanie, a hand sanitizer in malaysia
Cleanie, a hand sanitizer in malaysiaCleanie, a hand sanitizer in malaysia
Cleanie, a hand sanitizer in malaysia
 
Innovation Showcase: Shoestring Pitch
Innovation Showcase: Shoestring PitchInnovation Showcase: Shoestring Pitch
Innovation Showcase: Shoestring Pitch
 
Business Growth 051209
Business Growth 051209Business Growth 051209
Business Growth 051209
 
Service Desk Now! Product Outline 2010 07 01
Service Desk Now! Product Outline 2010 07 01Service Desk Now! Product Outline 2010 07 01
Service Desk Now! Product Outline 2010 07 01
 
GAP inhouse production agency proposal
GAP inhouse production agency proposalGAP inhouse production agency proposal
GAP inhouse production agency proposal
 
GAP inhouse production agency proposal
GAP inhouse production agency proposalGAP inhouse production agency proposal
GAP inhouse production agency proposal
 
Video for Sales
Video for SalesVideo for Sales
Video for Sales
 
Pitch Deck To Raise Funding From Business Crowdfunding Powerpoint Presentatio...
Pitch Deck To Raise Funding From Business Crowdfunding Powerpoint Presentatio...Pitch Deck To Raise Funding From Business Crowdfunding Powerpoint Presentatio...
Pitch Deck To Raise Funding From Business Crowdfunding Powerpoint Presentatio...
 
Dolby Laboratories Pitch
Dolby Laboratories PitchDolby Laboratories Pitch
Dolby Laboratories Pitch
 
Brockmann_ExecutivesGuidetoHD_030808
Brockmann_ExecutivesGuidetoHD_030808Brockmann_ExecutivesGuidetoHD_030808
Brockmann_ExecutivesGuidetoHD_030808
 
Entrepreneurship Education Experience - Bob Caspe (Aula 3)
Entrepreneurship Education Experience - Bob Caspe (Aula 3)Entrepreneurship Education Experience - Bob Caspe (Aula 3)
Entrepreneurship Education Experience - Bob Caspe (Aula 3)
 
Expense Management PowerPoint Presentation Slides
Expense Management PowerPoint Presentation SlidesExpense Management PowerPoint Presentation Slides
Expense Management PowerPoint Presentation Slides
 
Good to Great: Achieving Product Excellence in Web 2.0 by Dan Olsen
Good to Great: Achieving Product Excellence in Web 2.0 by Dan OlsenGood to Great: Achieving Product Excellence in Web 2.0 by Dan Olsen
Good to Great: Achieving Product Excellence in Web 2.0 by Dan Olsen
 
Macrocosm Venture Plan: Presentation
Macrocosm Venture Plan: PresentationMacrocosm Venture Plan: Presentation
Macrocosm Venture Plan: Presentation
 
World-Class Web Metrics by Dan Olsen
World-Class Web Metrics by Dan OlsenWorld-Class Web Metrics by Dan Olsen
World-Class Web Metrics by Dan Olsen
 
Mobile Ad Monetization for Games | Christian Calderon
Mobile Ad Monetization for Games | Christian CalderonMobile Ad Monetization for Games | Christian Calderon
Mobile Ad Monetization for Games | Christian Calderon
 
Cloud zow
Cloud zowCloud zow
Cloud zow
 

More from Pramod Jindal

Raising Debt vs. Equity
Raising Debt vs. EquityRaising Debt vs. Equity
Raising Debt vs. Equity
Pramod Jindal
 
Effect of public transit expansion on Real Estate Prices
Effect of public transit expansion on Real Estate PricesEffect of public transit expansion on Real Estate Prices
Effect of public transit expansion on Real Estate Prices
Pramod Jindal
 
Integrative solution for BMO Credit Card
Integrative solution for BMO Credit CardIntegrative solution for BMO Credit Card
Integrative solution for BMO Credit Card
Pramod Jindal
 
Medical Residents Evaluation Delay
Medical Residents Evaluation DelayMedical Residents Evaluation Delay
Medical Residents Evaluation Delay
Pramod Jindal
 
McKinsey Case Compettion
McKinsey Case CompettionMcKinsey Case Compettion
McKinsey Case Compettion
Pramod Jindal
 

More from Pramod Jindal (16)

Initiation coverage Suncor Energy (NYSE:SU)
Initiation coverage Suncor Energy (NYSE:SU) Initiation coverage Suncor Energy (NYSE:SU)
Initiation coverage Suncor Energy (NYSE:SU)
 
Raising Debt vs. Equity
Raising Debt vs. EquityRaising Debt vs. Equity
Raising Debt vs. Equity
 
Barclays and PPI + LIBOR Scandals
Barclays and PPI + LIBOR ScandalsBarclays and PPI + LIBOR Scandals
Barclays and PPI + LIBOR Scandals
 
Effect of public transit expansion on Real Estate Prices
Effect of public transit expansion on Real Estate PricesEffect of public transit expansion on Real Estate Prices
Effect of public transit expansion on Real Estate Prices
 
Long Term Financing Decision
Long Term Financing Decision Long Term Financing Decision
Long Term Financing Decision
 
Manufactured homes inc
Manufactured homes incManufactured homes inc
Manufactured homes inc
 
Rogers business case for extending coverage to the ttc subway system
Rogers  business case for extending coverage to the ttc subway systemRogers  business case for extending coverage to the ttc subway system
Rogers business case for extending coverage to the ttc subway system
 
Integrative solution for BMO Credit Card
Integrative solution for BMO Credit CardIntegrative solution for BMO Credit Card
Integrative solution for BMO Credit Card
 
Medical Residents Evaluation Delay
Medical Residents Evaluation DelayMedical Residents Evaluation Delay
Medical Residents Evaluation Delay
 
BMO Stock Pitch Nov 12 2011
BMO Stock Pitch Nov 12 2011BMO Stock Pitch Nov 12 2011
BMO Stock Pitch Nov 12 2011
 
Research on VOIP
Research on VOIPResearch on VOIP
Research on VOIP
 
McKinsey Case Compettion
McKinsey Case CompettionMcKinsey Case Compettion
McKinsey Case Compettion
 
Bloomberg
BloombergBloomberg
Bloomberg
 
Moneyball
Moneyball Moneyball
Moneyball
 
2011 09-30 pride toronto - infinite possibilities - team 'womacked'
2011 09-30 pride toronto - infinite possibilities - team 'womacked'2011 09-30 pride toronto - infinite possibilities - team 'womacked'
2011 09-30 pride toronto - infinite possibilities - team 'womacked'
 
Out On Bay Street Case Competition
Out On Bay Street Case CompetitionOut On Bay Street Case Competition
Out On Bay Street Case Competition
 

Recently uploaded

CHEAP Call Girls in Malviya Nagar, (-DELHI )🔝 9953056974🔝(=)/CALL GIRLS SERVICE
CHEAP Call Girls in  Malviya Nagar, (-DELHI )🔝 9953056974🔝(=)/CALL GIRLS SERVICECHEAP Call Girls in  Malviya Nagar, (-DELHI )🔝 9953056974🔝(=)/CALL GIRLS SERVICE
CHEAP Call Girls in Malviya Nagar, (-DELHI )🔝 9953056974🔝(=)/CALL GIRLS SERVICE
9953056974 Low Rate Call Girls In Saket, Delhi NCR
 
Navsari Escorts Service ☎️ 6378878445 ( Sakshi Sinha ) High Profile Call Girl...
Navsari Escorts Service ☎️ 6378878445 ( Sakshi Sinha ) High Profile Call Girl...Navsari Escorts Service ☎️ 6378878445 ( Sakshi Sinha ) High Profile Call Girl...
Navsari Escorts Service ☎️ 6378878445 ( Sakshi Sinha ) High Profile Call Girl...
mriyagarg453
 

Recently uploaded (20)

𓀤Call On 6297143586 𓀤 Ultadanga Call Girls In All Kolkata 24/7 Provide Call W...
𓀤Call On 6297143586 𓀤 Ultadanga Call Girls In All Kolkata 24/7 Provide Call W...𓀤Call On 6297143586 𓀤 Ultadanga Call Girls In All Kolkata 24/7 Provide Call W...
𓀤Call On 6297143586 𓀤 Ultadanga Call Girls In All Kolkata 24/7 Provide Call W...
 
Navi Mumbai Call Girls -📞9833754194-Call Girls Number Vashi-Nerul Call Girls ...
Navi Mumbai Call Girls -📞9833754194-Call Girls Number Vashi-Nerul Call Girls ...Navi Mumbai Call Girls -📞9833754194-Call Girls Number Vashi-Nerul Call Girls ...
Navi Mumbai Call Girls -📞9833754194-Call Girls Number Vashi-Nerul Call Girls ...
 
Sonagachi ( Call Girls ) Kolkata ✔ 6297143586 ✔ Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Rea...
Sonagachi ( Call Girls ) Kolkata ✔ 6297143586 ✔ Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Rea...Sonagachi ( Call Girls ) Kolkata ✔ 6297143586 ✔ Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Rea...
Sonagachi ( Call Girls ) Kolkata ✔ 6297143586 ✔ Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi Rea...
 
CHEAP Call Girls in Malviya Nagar, (-DELHI )🔝 9953056974🔝(=)/CALL GIRLS SERVICE
CHEAP Call Girls in  Malviya Nagar, (-DELHI )🔝 9953056974🔝(=)/CALL GIRLS SERVICECHEAP Call Girls in  Malviya Nagar, (-DELHI )🔝 9953056974🔝(=)/CALL GIRLS SERVICE
CHEAP Call Girls in Malviya Nagar, (-DELHI )🔝 9953056974🔝(=)/CALL GIRLS SERVICE
 
𓀤Call On 6297143586 𓀤 Park Street Call Girls In All Kolkata 24/7 Provide Call...
𓀤Call On 6297143586 𓀤 Park Street Call Girls In All Kolkata 24/7 Provide Call...𓀤Call On 6297143586 𓀤 Park Street Call Girls In All Kolkata 24/7 Provide Call...
𓀤Call On 6297143586 𓀤 Park Street Call Girls In All Kolkata 24/7 Provide Call...
 
Navsari Escorts Service ☎️ 6378878445 ( Sakshi Sinha ) High Profile Call Girl...
Navsari Escorts Service ☎️ 6378878445 ( Sakshi Sinha ) High Profile Call Girl...Navsari Escorts Service ☎️ 6378878445 ( Sakshi Sinha ) High Profile Call Girl...
Navsari Escorts Service ☎️ 6378878445 ( Sakshi Sinha ) High Profile Call Girl...
 
Thane West \ Escort Service in Mumbai - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 983332523...
Thane West \ Escort Service in Mumbai - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 983332523...Thane West \ Escort Service in Mumbai - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 983332523...
Thane West \ Escort Service in Mumbai - 450+ Call Girl Cash Payment 983332523...
 
Jodhpur Park ( Call Girls ) Kolkata ✔ 6297143586 ✔ Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi ...
Jodhpur Park ( Call Girls ) Kolkata ✔ 6297143586 ✔ Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi ...Jodhpur Park ( Call Girls ) Kolkata ✔ 6297143586 ✔ Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi ...
Jodhpur Park ( Call Girls ) Kolkata ✔ 6297143586 ✔ Hot Model With Sexy Bhabi ...
 
Verified Trusted Call Girls Egmore Chennai ✔✔7427069034 Independent Chennai ...
Verified Trusted Call Girls Egmore Chennai ✔✔7427069034  Independent Chennai ...Verified Trusted Call Girls Egmore Chennai ✔✔7427069034  Independent Chennai ...
Verified Trusted Call Girls Egmore Chennai ✔✔7427069034 Independent Chennai ...
 
Verified Trusted Call Girls Tambaram Chennai ✔✔7427069034 Independent Chenna...
Verified Trusted Call Girls Tambaram Chennai ✔✔7427069034  Independent Chenna...Verified Trusted Call Girls Tambaram Chennai ✔✔7427069034  Independent Chenna...
Verified Trusted Call Girls Tambaram Chennai ✔✔7427069034 Independent Chenna...
 
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Hire Call Girls Raiganj For a Sensual Sex Experience
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Hire Call Girls Raiganj For a Sensual Sex ExperienceWhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Hire Call Girls Raiganj For a Sensual Sex Experience
WhatsApp Chat: 📞 8617697112 Hire Call Girls Raiganj For a Sensual Sex Experience
 
VIP ( Goa Call Girls ) Margao Beach👉 8617370543 Escort Service Enjoy Your Dre...
VIP ( Goa Call Girls ) Margao Beach👉 8617370543 Escort Service Enjoy Your Dre...VIP ( Goa Call Girls ) Margao Beach👉 8617370543 Escort Service Enjoy Your Dre...
VIP ( Goa Call Girls ) Margao Beach👉 8617370543 Escort Service Enjoy Your Dre...
 
Almora call girls 📞 8617697112 At Low Cost Cash Payment Booking
Almora call girls 📞 8617697112 At Low Cost Cash Payment BookingAlmora call girls 📞 8617697112 At Low Cost Cash Payment Booking
Almora call girls 📞 8617697112 At Low Cost Cash Payment Booking
 
Kolkata Call Girls Service ❤️ at @30% discount Everyday
Kolkata Call Girls Service ❤️ at @30% discount EverydayKolkata Call Girls Service ❤️ at @30% discount Everyday
Kolkata Call Girls Service ❤️ at @30% discount Everyday
 
Call Girls Bhandara Just Call 8617697112 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Bhandara Just Call 8617697112 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Bhandara Just Call 8617697112 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Bhandara Just Call 8617697112 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Manjri Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Manjri Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance BookingCall Girls Manjri Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
Call Girls Manjri Call Me 7737669865 Budget Friendly No Advance Booking
 
𓀤Call On 6297143586 𓀤 Sonagachi Call Girls In All Kolkata 24/7 Provide Call W...
𓀤Call On 6297143586 𓀤 Sonagachi Call Girls In All Kolkata 24/7 Provide Call W...𓀤Call On 6297143586 𓀤 Sonagachi Call Girls In All Kolkata 24/7 Provide Call W...
𓀤Call On 6297143586 𓀤 Sonagachi Call Girls In All Kolkata 24/7 Provide Call W...
 
VIP Model Call Girls Vijayawada ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K ...
VIP Model Call Girls Vijayawada ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K ...VIP Model Call Girls Vijayawada ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K ...
VIP Model Call Girls Vijayawada ( Pune ) Call ON 8005736733 Starting From 5K ...
 
Verified Trusted Call Girls Ambattur Chennai ✔✔7427069034 Independent Chenna...
Verified Trusted Call Girls Ambattur Chennai ✔✔7427069034  Independent Chenna...Verified Trusted Call Girls Ambattur Chennai ✔✔7427069034  Independent Chenna...
Verified Trusted Call Girls Ambattur Chennai ✔✔7427069034 Independent Chenna...
 
Model Call Girls In Velappanchavadi WhatsApp Booking 7427069034 call girl ser...
Model Call Girls In Velappanchavadi WhatsApp Booking 7427069034 call girl ser...Model Call Girls In Velappanchavadi WhatsApp Booking 7427069034 call girl ser...
Model Call Girls In Velappanchavadi WhatsApp Booking 7427069034 call girl ser...
 

Rotman Strategy Case Competition

  • 1. Team Cinergy Alaina Boyer, Jay Burke, Brendan Cochrane, Pramod Jindal & Beam Ukarapong
  • 2. Recommendation Problem Should Cineplex focus on building its download business or reinvest in its theatre business? Recommendation Cineplex should reinvest in its core competencies within the theatre experience, while expanding the complementary entertainment services it offers Major Insights • Exhibition theatres have problems – we CAN fix them • Cineplex is REALLY good at its core competencies • We can PLAY in the Digital sandbox, but… Fixing Problems Core Competencies Digital Sandbox 1
  • 3. Exhibition Theatres have problems – we CAN fix them Convenience 4-hour outing for a 2-hour movie is inconvenient Why does this happen? Need to get there early for good seats and line-up for food Proposal CinExpress – a service to reserve your seat, pre-order food & beverage and pick-up your order from designated line Costs • Initial confusion amongst non-reserved seating patrons • Dedicated staff for express line • Enhance current website/app/interface to incorporate CinExpress Benefits • Higher revenue from increased ticket price (+$2.00/seat) • Pre-ordered food = guaranteed sale Fixing Problems Core Competencies Digital Sandbox 2
  • 4. Exhibition Theatres have potential – maximize it Loyalty Scene Membership card and Loyalty Program: very successful How to use Loyalty to our advantage? • Incentivize new members - free upgrades • Retain members with Milestone Rewards • Birthday and anniversary promotions • Expand point-redemption partners Costs • Additional free movies • Loss of 10% concession revenue (Scene discount) Benefits • Increased membership: more theatre footfalls and concession spending • Free word-of-mouth advertising Fixing Problems Core Competencies Digital Sandbox 3
  • 5. Exhibition Theatres have scope for improvement Social Media Penetration A Facebook page isn’t enough Why should this change? Transition from offline to online social experience How will we correct this? Ability to post updates after ticket sales and reviews post-show Costs • Programming/development costs Benefits • Brand recognition (each auto-generated posting has Cineplex brand embedded) • Free social media advertising will reach broader audience & tech-savvy users Fixing Problems Core Competencies Digital Sandbox 4
  • 6. Leverage our Core Competency: Theatre Experience Broad Experience Experience beyond our best movies: complete entertainment experience Our Proposal Continue to invest in alternative programming, games, liquor-licensed VIP as well as non-peak theatre usage Actions • Theme nights • UFC events • Customized events Costs • Licensing, capital expenditures and labour Benefits • Increased ticket revenue • Additional reasons to visit a multiplex • Increased share of wallet from customized-event clients Fixing Problems Core Competencies Digital Sandbox 5
  • 7. Leverage our Core Competency: State of the art technology Technology We have the best technology. Home theatre solutions cannot simulate a real theatre experience Proposal Continue to invest in: • UltraAVX • Complete digital screen and 3D projection upgrade by 2012 as planned • Canadian Digital Cinema Partnership Costs • No change from current reporting Benefits • Provide enhanced customer experience • Maintain competitive advantage over digital Fixing Problems Core Competencies Digital Sandbox 6
  • 8. Leverage our Core Competency: Studio Relationships Studio Relationships We have the best new movies you can’t find online Proposal • Leverage leading market share position to acquire best titles • Extend relationship to re-release patron favourites Costs • No change from current reporting Benefits • Maintain competitive advantage over digital • Preferential treatment and flexibility Fixing Problems Core Competencies Digital Sandbox 7
  • 9. We can PLAY in the digital sandbox But… • Non-core business • High switching costs for legitimate users • Low switching costs for illegitimate users • Fierce competition • In pipeline “UltraViolet”- new technology, same players Cost • Advertising costs for brand promotion • Increased redemption of Scene points (affecting core margins) Benefits • Additional revenue stream • Allows entry into new market • Leveraging Scene loyalty Fixing Problems Core Competencies Digital Sandbox 8
  • 10. Risks associated with our Recommendations Overall Risks to the Industry • Busier life style – not enough free time for movies • Recessionary fears – reduced leisure budget Convenience, Loyalty and Social Media • Customers not receptive to reserved seating  lost revenue • Potential breach of privacy in Loyalty program • Maintaining higher service delivery levels Event Experience • Additional improvements not aligned with customer values • Changing customer tastes • Year without blockbuster movies Digital Sandbox • Ongoing piracy concerns • Competing against new innovations by established digital competitors • Digital players enter theatre business Fixing Problems Core Competencies Digital Sandbox 9
  • 11. Summary Recommendation Cineplex should reinvest in its core competencies within the theatre experience, while expanding the complementary entertainment services it offers Major Insights • Exhibition theatres have problems – we CAN fix them • Cineplex is REALLY good at its core competencies • We can PLAY in the Digital sandbox, but… Fixing Problems Core Competencies Digital Sandbox 10
  • 12. Thank you Q&A 11
  • 13. Reserved Seating Cost/Benefit Structure Reserved Seating Reserved Seating Brand new chairs $ 300.00 Chair covers $ 35.00 Total Seats to Change 60 Total Seats to Change 60 TOTAL NEW SEAT COST $ 18,000.00 TOTAL NEW SEAT COST $ 2,100.00 Replacement Labour Cost $ 100.00 Replacement Labour Cost $ 100.00 Hours to replace 60 seats 15 Hours to replace 60 seats 15 TOTAL LABOUR COSTS $ 1,500.00 TOTAL LABOUR COSTS $ 1,500.00 GRAND TOTAL COST $ 19,500.00 GRAND TOTAL COST $ 3,600.00 Increased Revenue Increased Revenue Premium for Reserved Seating $ 2.00 Premium for Reserved Seating $ 2.00 Average Show Rate 4 Average Show Rate 4 50% occupancy 30 50% occupancy 30 75% occupancy 45 75% occupancy 45 80% occupancy 48 80% occupancy 48 85% occupancy 51 85% occupancy 51 TOTAL REVENUE at 50% sales $ 240.00 TOTAL REVENUE at 50% sales $ 240.00 TOTAL REVENUE at 75% sales $ 360.00 TOTAL REVENUE at 75% sales $ 360.00 TOTAL REVENUE at 80% sales $ 384.00 TOTAL REVENUE at 80% sales $ 384.00 TOTAL REVENUE at 85% sales $ 408.00 TOTAL REVENUE at 85% sales $ 408.00 Payback Period Payback Period Cost/Revenue @ 50% 81 days Cost/Revenue @ 50% 15 days Cost/Revenue @ 75% 54 days Cost/Revenue @ 75% 10 days Cost/Revenue @ 80% 51 days Cost/Revenue @ 80% 9 days Cost/Revenue @ 85% 48 days Cost/Revenue @ 85% 9 days 12
  • 14. Scene Membership Growth Scene Membership (in millions) 3.5 No. of Members 3.2 3.0 2.6 2.5 2.0 2.0 1.5 1.2 1.0 0.5 0.4 0.0 Q3 '07 Q3 '08 Q3 '09 Q3 '10 Q3 '11 Y/Y Growth 23% (2010-2011) 13
  • 15. Internal Activities and Capabilities Plane Beakers Boat Valuable Rare In-imitable Movies (Exhibition) - showtimes, convenience 3 2 2 Movies (Digital) 1 1 1 Loyalty (Scene) 3 2 3 Merchandise (zoning) 30% 3 1 1 Alternative 3 1 1 Media (ads) 3 2 1 Media (magazine) 2 1 1 Social media 3 1 1 Premium (seats, sounds, VIP) 3 1 2 Interactive (App) 3 1 1 Vendor relationship (food/aeroplan) 3 1 1 Technology (3D/IMAX) 3 3 3 Popcorn 3 1 1 Previews 2 1 1 Partnership (Scotia) 3 3 3 CDCP (Empre) 3 3 3 Night-out package 2 1 1 In-house brand (OutTakes) 2 2 1 Locations 3 3 3 Studio Relationship (having the best movies) 3 2 3 Source: 14
  • 16. Blue Ocean Analysis of Cineplex (Current), Cineplex (Proposed), Cineplex Anywhere and Digital Download 8 7 6 5 NEW-CPX 4 CineAW 3 CPX Digital 2 1 0 Watch a Price Convenience Great food Great Fun Great social Watch the recently experience emotional experience movie I want released experience movie 15
  • 17. 5 forces: Exhibition Entertainment Substitute – high, and getting worse • More activities Buyer – moderate • Switching costs low, consumer influence mod Supplier – moderate • Avatar high, others low Barriers – High • Huge Capex Rivalry – Low • Cineplex 66% Source: 16
  • 18. 5 forces: Anyway to Watch a Movie at Home Substitute – High • Tons of other options Buyer – Moderate, and getting worse • Can influence the price (Netflix) • But there are potential switching costs (Rogers On Demand, buying an Xbox) • Getting worse because of increasing piracy Supplier – Moderate • For legal activities, high • For illegal, low Barriers – Moderate • For legal activities, high • For illegal, low Rivalry – High • Tons of ways to get a movie at home Source: 17
  • 19. Industry Analysis Exhibition Out of home - Coffee Entertainment in - Movie - Community Canada - Plays/operas - Arcades - Sports events - Nightlife - Recreational activities - Culture - Dining - Shopping - F&F At home (Electronic) At home (Non-electronic) - TV - Board games Anyway to get - Movies - Card games movies at home - Computer - Reading - Video games - Quiet time - Music - Exercise - Internet - F&F - Social media - Cooking 18