1. Lawyers, Guns & Money: IRS
Administration of Social Welfare Policy
Roger Royse
Royse Law Firm, PC
Palo Alto, San Francisco, Los Angeles
rroyse@rroyselaw.com
www.rogerroyse.com
www.rroyselaw.com
Skype: roger.royse
Twitter @rroyse00
IRS Circular 230 Disclosure: To ensure compliance with the requirements imposed by the IRS, we inform you that any tax advice contained in this communication,
including any attachment to this communication, is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, by any taxpayer for the purpose of (1) avoiding penalties
under the Internal Revenue Code or (2) promoting, marketing or recommending to any other person any transaction or matter addressed herein.

2. Tax Expenditures
Overview
• The U.S. tax code contains over $1 trillion of expenditures
designed to encourage certain behavior among
taxpayers, e.g., to encourage spending, saving, and
working
• With most tax expenditures, taxpayers declare their own
eligibility as opposed to direct spending programs which
require agency approval
• Tax expenditures take many different forms
–
–
–
–
Exemptions and “above-the-line” deductions (54%)
Itemized deductions (30%)
Refundable tax credits (15%)
Non-refundable tax credits (1%)

3. Forms of Tax Expenditure
•
Exemptions
–
–
•
Deductions
–
–
–
•
Foreign source income (policy = promote competitiveness of US companies overseas)
Preferential rates
–
•
Interest on home loans (policy = home ownership)
Charitable contributions (policy = charitable giving)
Bonus depreciation (policy = capital expenditure)
Deferral
–
•
Employer health insurance (policy = provision of health insurance through the workplace)
401(k) contributions (policy = retirement saving)
Lower capital gains tax rates (policy = mitigate double tax, provide for inflation)
Credits
–
–
Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) and Child Tax Credit (CTC) are by far the largest credit (policy = to
encourage working and lift people out of poverty)
Also:
• Investment tax credits for expenditure on certain energy-efficient assets – most expired at
the end of 2013 but may be renewed
• Adoption tax credit – nonrefundable credit of up to $12,970
• American Opportunity Tax Credit – credit of up to $2,500 per qualifying student ($1,000 of
which is refundable)

4. Use of Refundable Tax Credits to
Implement Social Welfare Policies
Earned Income Tax Credit
• Implemented to encourage and reward work
• Provides an additional incentive to leave welfare if unemployed or for low-wage
workers to increase their hours
• Credited with significantly raising employment among single mothers in 1990s
• Maximum available credit is between $487 and $6,044 depending on income
level and number of children
Tax Credits Under the Affordable Care Act (ACA)
• Implemented to lower the number of Americans without health insurance
(estimated at 48 million people)
• Provides a system of refundable tax credits and tax credits paid directly to
health insurance providers
Additional Child Tax Credit
• Provides a refundable credit where the full CTC is in excess of the income tax
liability
• Capped at lower of (i) 15% of income over $3,000 or (ii) the unclaimed CTC

5. Earned Income Tax Credit
• The EITC has been successful at lifting people out of poverty, but
the system suffers from high levels of fraud
• An estimated $13 billion in wasted payments were made in 2012
(and $133 billion over the last ten years)
• The rate of fraud in the system is between 21%-25% of payments
– 75% of the fraud relates to problems authenticating the number of
“qualifying children,” which requires a complicated facts and
circumstances analysis
– 25% of the fraud relates to problems verifying the levels of income
• The IRS is subject to an Executive Order to reduce fraud in the
EITC system and must undergo annual Government Accountability
Office (GAO) audits on EITC fraud levels

7. Affordable Care Act Tax Credits
•
The ACA has two different tax credits:
– (1) Advanced Premium Tax Credit (APTC) - payable directly to the health insurance provider
– (2) Premium Tax Credit (PTC) - refundable tax credit that must be claimed on the tax return
•
The IRS has three key roles in the implementation of the ACA:
– (1) determine eligibility for tax credits;
– (2) calculate the APTC; and
– (3) reconcile the PTC and APTC with the taxable income on the taxpayer’s return
•
The GAO audited the IRS system and determined that the software was working
well to determine eligibility and the amount of credit available
– However, the audit found fraud detection mechanisms were lacking and there was no
overall fraud mitigation strategy in place
•
Many politicians and commentators are concerned that the EITC experience
could be repeated with the ACA tax credits
– May be even harder to detect fraud because ACA looks to “Household Income,” which can
be estimated when claiming the APTC and may be different from what is reported on the
final tax return
– Likely to be a big issue in 2015 when the 2014 tax returns are filed

9. Conclusion
Solutions to Fraud Problems
• Limit credits to verifiable information?
– Probably unworkable
– Could use third parties to verify information but this would reduce
participation
• Split the credits between the amount dependent on financial
information and non-financial information
– Could help to better target fraud prevention efforts
– E.g., EITC fraud is mainly based on number of children so this part of the
credit could be split out to help target investigations
• Request additional data on the tax return
– The GAO audited the IRS National Research Program and stated that the IRS
is not fully utilizing the information it already collects
– The GAO concluded that in certain areas, e.g., expense data on individual
tax returns, additional IRS spending to improve data analysis would bring in
enough extra revenue to justify the expense

10. Additional Thoughts
• EITC Compared to Food Stamps
–
–
–
–
1/5 of Food Stamp budget is admin costs
Low error rate
Food Stamp application takes 5 hours
47% participation of eligible low income workers (vs. 80% to 90%
EITC participation)
(Source: Urban Institute)
• IRS Focus on Enforcement vs Delivering Social Benefits
– Low cost of delivery but high cost of non-compliance
– High Penalties

11. RoyseUniversity.com
Royse University: Providing business, tax, and personal
finance ideas to founders and executives.
RoyseLink.com
RoyseLink: Connecting founders with investors and service
partners.

12. Contact Us
Palo Alto Office: 650-813-9700
PALO ALTO
1717 Embarcadero Road
Palo Alto, CA 94303
SAN FRANCISCO
135 Main Street
12th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94105
LOS ANGELES
11150 Santa Monica Blvd.
Suite 1200
Los Angeles, CA 90025
www.rroyselaw.com
@RoyseLaw